Board of Directors’ Meeting Thursday, June 5, 2014 Community Transit Board Room 3:00 p.m. Board Members Present Councilmember Kim Daughtry Councilmember Tom Hamilton Mayor Leonard Kelley Mayor Jon Nehring Lance Norton Councilmember Sid Roberts Councilmember Terry Ryan Mayor Jerry Smith Councilmember Mike Todd Councilmember Stephanie Wright City of Lake Stevens City of Snohomish City of Stanwood City of Marysville Labor Representative, non-voting City of Lynnwood, Board Alternate Snohomish County City of Mountlake Terrace City of Mill Creek Snohomish County Board Members Absent Mayor Dave Earling City of Edmonds Others Present Melinda April Ken Bailey Colleen Baumann Roland Behee Art Braeul Sam Brodland Darren Brugmann Melissa Cauley Tim Chrobuck Donna Clausen Kathleen Custer Larry Daubenmire June DeVoll Barbara Earl Joyce Eleanor Rita Fox Don Hart Emmett Heath Al Hendricks Brenna Holland Stacy Hupp Rick Jurkovic Roger Kee Wade Mahala Pete Majkut Laurel McJannet Gail McNutt Self CT-Vehicle Maintenance Manager CT-Manager of Transportation Operations CT-Strategic Planning Unit Manager CT-Customer Services Manager CT-Supervisor of Service Planning and Development Senior Services of Snohomish County CT-Grant Program Manager Chief Technology Officer Administrative Assistant II, Strategic Communications ATU CT-Capital Project Manager CT-Manager Strategic Planning & Grants BETS Consulting CT-Chief Executive Officer CT-Administrative Assistant II (Transportation) Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office CT-Director of Administration CT-Legal Counsel Daily Herald CT-Procurement Specialist ATU CT-Procurement Specialist CT-Manager of Contracted Transportation ATU CT-Online Content Specialist CT-Executive Secretary Board of Directors’ Meeting June 5, 2014 Page 2 Martin Munguia Joy Munkers Darren Noblick Nick Plantilla Dave Richards Scott Ritterbush Ken Rutz John Sainz Jan Schuette Juanita Shuler Lynn Starcher Carol Thompson Doug Thorndike Bob Throckmorton Kate Tourtellot David True Emily Vanderwielen Gerhild Turner Fred Worthen CT-Public Information Officer CT-Director of Planning & Development Self CT-Coach Operator CT-Director of Maintenance CT-Senior Transportation Planner First Transit ATU City of Arlington, Board Alternate CT-Records Management/Administrative Assistant CT-Human Resources and Labor Relations Manager CT-Service Development Manager Self CT-Director of Customer Relations CT-Senior Transportation Manager CT-Capital Development Program Manager City of Mukilteo, Board Alternate CT-Procurement and Contracts Manager CT-Director of Transportation Call to Order Chair Mike Todd called to order the June 5, 2014, Board of Directors Meeting at 3:00 p.m. at the Community Transit Board Room, Everett, Washington. Roll Call of Members The Executive Secretary called roll. Attendance was as noted above. A quorum was present. Public Comment Kathleen Custer, Amalgamated Transit Union (ATU) President, reviewed a recent Public Employment Relations Commission (PERC) decision regarding an unfair labor practice. John Sainz, ATU Treasurer, questioned the amount of money Community Transit spent in fighting the recent unfair labor practice, along with the lawsuit regarding labor representation on the Board. Darren Noblick asked Joyce Eleanor to resign her position as Chief Executive Officer of Community Transit. He requested that the Board terminate the Chief Executive Officer’s employment if she chose not to resign. Presentations There were no presentations. Committee Reports Executive Committee Chair Mike Todd reported the following items: Federal House and Senate bills continued to work their way through the approval process. A long-term fix to the problems with the highway fund still needed to be resolved so that transit agencies could make funding plans for their major projects. The Bus Coalition continued to grow membership, develop their charter and legislative papers. Puget Sound Regional Council (PSRC) Transportation 2040 Plan assumed adequate funding would be found to implement Transportation 2040. The Federal Transit Administration (FTA) Board of Directors’ Meeting June 5, 2014 Page 3 wrote a letter to PSRC outlining their concerns regarding the ambitious investments necessary to implement the plan. FTA recommended that PSRC significantly shift projects into the unfunded category until a commitment of resources to pay for the transportation solution could be demonstrated. The committee continued to work with the CEO to develop annual performance goals that were specific and measurable. Other reports were also discussed that were currently being provided to the Board. Staff would review them to make sure they included information that was timely and useful to the board members. Finance & Administration Committee Mayor Jon Nehring reviewed the following topics: Sales tax revenues received year-to-date through May exceeded the amended budget by $688,000. Diesel fuel was within budget and prices were forecast to be stable in the months ahead. Emmett Heath briefed the Committee on the Employee Occupational Health Center project. A vendor contract was scheduled to be finalized and presented to the Committee at their June meeting and to the full Board in July. Marketing, Operations, and Maintenance Committee Councilmember Kim Daughtry reviewed the following: ITB No. 18-14, Parts for Bus Passenger Seat Modifications, was discussed at length. Community Transit had received notification from New Flyer of a recommendation to disable front row, forward-facing flip up seats behind the wheelchair securement areas for improved passenger safety. Staff recommended removal of the first row of forward-facing seats installing a barrier panel and two side-facing seats in place of the existing seats. Approximately 116 coaches would be impacted. Parts were not interchangeable with new coaches that would be purchased in the future. The Committee recommended approval to award ITB No. 18-14, parts for Bus Passenger Seat Modifications, to Gillig not to exceed $603,954.41. Planning and Capital Projects Committee Councilmember Kim Daughtry reviewed the following: The 2013 Fare Policy Report was reviewed by staff. Farebox recovery was 24 percent of operating costs. Total fare revenue rose to $19.3 million. ORCA fare payments accounted for 81 percent of fare revenue collected on bus service in December 2013. Award of ITB No. 21-14, MCOB Entrance Drive Slab Replacement and Seismic Retrofit Project, was reviewed. Bids were received from three contractors; the lowest responsive and responsible bidder was Road Construction Northwest. The Committee recommended the item be awarded to Road Construction Northwest as part of today’s consent agenda. The September 2014 Service Changes were reviewed. Public comments received were discussed. The Committee recommended approval of the September 2014 Service Change. Consent Calendar Labor representative Lance Norton requested that item D, Award of ITB No. 18-14, Parts for Bus Passenger Seat Modifications, be removed from the consent calendar for further discussion. Councilmember Stephanie Wright moved to approve items A. through C and items E through L: A. Approval of the minutes of the May 1, 2014, Board of Directors’ Meeting. B. Approval of the minutes of the April 24 – 25, 2014, Board of Directors Retreat. Board of Directors’ Meeting June 5, 2014 Page 4 C. Award of ITB No. 21-14, MCOB Entrance Drive Slab Replacement and Seismic Retrofit Project to Road Construction Northwest in an amount not to exceed $207, 874. E. Approval of vouchers dated April 2, 2014, in the amount of $443,248.47. F. Approval of vouchers dated April 4, 2014, in the amount of $716,468.72. G. Approval of vouchers dated April 10, 2014, in the amount of $778,859.09. H. Approval of vouchers dated April 16, 2014, in the amount of $1,064,755.78. I. Approval of vouchers dated April 18, 2014, in the amount of $281,430.92. J. Approval of vouchers dated April 24, 2014, in the amount of $313,889.70. K. Approval of vouchers dated April 29, 2014, in the amount of $458,051.07. L. Approval of vouchers dated April 30, 2014, in the amount of $268,161.96. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Kim Daughtry and passed unanimously. Mayor Jerry Smith moved to approve item D on the consent agenda. The motion was seconded by Mayor Jon Nehring: D. Award of ITB No. 18-14, Parts for Bus Passenger Seat Modifications, to Gillig in an amount not to exceed $603,954.41. Labor representative Lance Norton noted that 116 buses required the suggested retrofitting. The change would not be covered by a warranty. After a lengthy discussion, board members suggested a response to New Flyer’s letter be written advising them that Community Transit was disappointed that New Flyer had not taken responsibility and offered to compensate Community Transit for the retrofit costs. Dave Richards, Director of Maintenance, advised that a similar letter had been received from Gillig, but Community Transit did not have any Gillig buses that required retrofitting. The vote was taken and the item passed unanimously. Action Items Approval of September 2014 Service Changes Carol Thompson, Service Development Manager, reviewed the upcoming service changes. The September service change would add about 13,800 revenue hours and would be another large step toward reestablishing a solid foundation for growth. Core service and local feeder service would see service additions. Suburban/rural service and commuter service would see improved connections. The service change would take effect beginning Monday, September 29. Councilmember Stephanie Wright moved to approve the September 2014 service change. The motion was seconded by Mayor Leonard Kelley and passed unanimously. Chair’s Report Chair Mike Todd noted that funding amounts in PSRC’s list of projects in the 2040 Plan differed from the Washington State Department of Transportation list and the projects being considered in the legislator’s transportation package. It was important that each city stay informed regarding funding for their transit and road projects. Chief Executive Officer’s Report Lynn Starcher read Public Employment Relations Commission (PERC) Decision No. 10647-A-PECB into the record. Joyce Eleanor announced that beginning June 9, Community Transit service to Darrington would return to Highway 530. A new route, Route 232, would serve two roundtrips between Darrington and Smokey Point each weekday. This new route would eliminate the need to transfer buses to get from Darrington Board of Directors’ Meeting June 5, 2014 Page 5 to Smokey Point. Community Transit would continue to offer vanpool options to residents of Darrington and Oso. Board Communication Lance Norton said he was glad that partial Sunday service was supported at the recent retreat. He requested that staff work with Senior Services of Snohomish County to communicate more information regarding DART service to the local senior centers and assisted living and retirement homes. Joy Munkers, Director of Planning and Development, advised that Community Transit’s Travel Training Program already provided this information and also worked with local human services programs to get the message out to seniors. Executive Session An executive session was called at 4:17 p.m. for 15 minutes to discuss labor negotiations and the performance of a public employee. The executive session was extended for an additional five minutes. The executive session ended at 4:37 p.m. and the regular meeting was immediately adjourned. The next regular Board meeting will be held July 3, 2014, at 3 p.m. at Community Transit’s Board Room, 7100 Hardeson Road, Everett, WA. Gail McNutt Executive Secretary