Coalition for Urban River Evaluation 1697 Cole Blvd., Ste 200, Golden, Colorado 80401 ● Ph: (303) 239-5411 ● Fax: (303) 239-5454 SP CURE Board Meeting Tuesday, December 20, 2011 – 9:00 a.m. Meeting Location: Brown and Caldwell 1697 Cole Blvd. Ste 200, Golden CO 80401 Host: Sarah Reeves (303) 239-5411 December Meeting Summary 1. Discussion and Approval of November Meeting Summary Dennis Stowe moved approval of the November meeting summary. The motion was seconded by Blair Corning, which passed unanimously. 2. Urban Waters Federal Partnership The Urban Waters Federal Partnership’s Mission: Multiple federal agencies working together to reconnect urban communities by improving coordination among federal agencies and collaborating with community-led revitalization efforts to improve our Nation’s water systems and promote their economic, environmental, and social benefits. Proposed South Platte River because had been working with Greenway Program and the City of Denver, Denver Environmental Health and were familiar with the issues and needs of this area. The South Platte pilot is a little different because USFS put in for the headwaters of the South Platte and EPA put in for the Urban South Platte, so there are sort of 2 separate projects. The website is www.UrbanWaters.gov. There are 7 pilots in total. There is $180,000 available in Region VII so will likely be able to fund 3 projects. Okay for our region because we are not that urban – will only be competing against those in our EPA Region. The hope is that there will be more money to fund additional projects next year. The South Platte Urban Waters Project covers a rather large area that encompasses the urban and suburban area around the Denver Metro Area as well as the headwaters watershed (basically 2 different watershed areas). It does not include the Cherry Creek basin, and Stacey Erikson will bring that back to the Urban Waters group to see if they should be included. Talking about the need to have a full-time person to coordinate the efforts in the South Platte. Also looking at mapping who is doing what in the South Platte area and how they overlap. A good example of this mapping effort is the Anacostia River in Washington, D.C. Looking for money for this effort. Projects: Groundwork Denver watershed plan for Bear Creek. 1 of 5 Greenway Foundation expansion to River Rangers program (green jobs pilot) with water quality monitoring (EPA lab to analyze data), watershed trips. Partnership with Denver Water to protect water supplies – looking at Hayman fire area. Trust for Public Land green infrastructure mapping to map parks, open spaces, conservation areas and where there are environmental justice areas and looking to make sure people have access to these lands. Also working on a Westerley Creek stream restoration. U.S. Corps of Engineers has had some issues because they have been given a “no new starts” order by Congress, but are trying to work through this. Looking at personal care products and other contaminants of emerging concern (CECs) in the watershed. Want to know how present these products are and where they are being found. Their hope is that they won’t find these personal care products in national parks and other headwaters areas. This is being coordinated with the USGS, but is basically a research project. The data are expected to be put up on the Data Sharing Network (DSN). EPA wants to see that proposals address community priorities and Environmental Justice areas. Jill Piatt Kemper asked if deference would be given to projects that are part of a larger effort and commitment by a watershed group. That is possibly one area that will be considered. The time frame for this effort is unknown at this point. It is supported under the current administration and will likely continue if this administration continues. Seeing a lot more collaboration between agencies through this project and agencies are making it a priority. Agencies are identifying barriers to working together and have a list of issues that need to be revised to allow better coordination. This effort has also allowed agencies to understand each others’ funding mechanisms. If you would like to be on the mailing list for the South Platte River Urban Waters Project, email Stacey Eriksen at Eriksen.stacy@epa.gov. SP CURE discussed the possibility of developing a proposal for submission for funding by the Urban Waters Program. The timeframe is tight – January 23, 2011 – maybe we could wait until next year. Stacey suggested that the Piton Foundation has environmental justice information that we could use regarding population below poverty line, etc. Laurie Rink suggested that we certainly have a lot of stakeholders and we have ways to show that we address environmental justice areas because of the funding issues associated with nutrient treatment. Laurie Rink volunteered to help, as needed. The Board decided that it would be great to have Laurie put together a grant application using her ideas if she has time and wants to do it. 3. Segment 14 MMI Results The Board reviewed the MMI results and recognized the inherent variability in the MMI measurements. We also noted that the MMI does not apply to Segment 14 and that the MMI thresholds are not applicable. The Board had asked Aquatics Associates to perform the MMI calculations for information only. 2 of 5 Brown and Caldwell will provide Phil Russell with MMI data to add in with the nutrients data he is already summarizing. For January Board Meeting, Phil will present his nutrient data summary and a comparison of nutrient data with MMI scores. 4. Nutrient Monitoring Framework Sarah Reeves went to the Chatfield Bill Lewis requested to comment on the appropriateness of SPARROW model to look at these data. Xcel lab suggests that MDL is not appropriate here. PQL is likely more appropriate – or just a reporting limit. This is definitely an item that SP CURE should comment on. If you have any comments, please send Sarah an email. Members will coordinate with other entities within S. Platte Basin for nutrient monitoring and data collection. 5. Arsenic Hearing Update There was an emergency arsenic hearing on December 13, 2011 where the Water Quality Control Division (Division) 6. UDFCD Update No report. 6. Budget Update We are on budget. We will work in January on the budget for 2012/13. Project Updates a. BMW – No report b. DSN – All data uploaded into AWQMS except L/E; sampling method not recognized by current database. Gold Systems waiting on EPA to approve sampling method, they will included into AWQMS. c. Monitoring Committee – Committee working on finalizing SP CURE SAP with projected completion date of February 14, 2012. 3 of 5 7. New Business Emergency Arsenic Hearing – CDOT has construction dewatering remediation permit for water they are collecting along Segment 14. They have limits of 0.02 ug/L because it is a water plus fish standard. The water is about 2 ug/L and they cannot treat for the arsenic to these levels. They are currently trucking the water down to Segment 15 and discharging it. CDOT has a number of other projects that are coming up in the same area and would like to address the standard so they don’t have to truck the water to Segment 15. December 13th Emergency Hearing is set. The Division will be developing the proposal. Dennis Stowe pointed out that a change in the footnote would likely fix this issue. Chatfield Watershed Authority Meeting – Want to discuss monitoring framework. Sarah Reeves or Phil Russell to come to talk to the group. Tim Grotheer to let Sarah know who he wants to present and the date and time of the meeting. Thornton Involvement – Vic Lucero is retiring in December/January and there may be a lapse in attendance/involvement for a while. Mark Koleber will be their new contact. 8. Next Meeting Dates January 17, 2012 – City of Aurora February 14, 2012 – SACWSD March 20, 2012 – Metro Wastewater Reclamation District Meeting summary was prepared by Sarah Reeves. Approved by: ___________________________________ Christine Johnston, Secretary ____________________ Date Approved 4 of 5 SPCURE Board Meeting – November 15, 2011 Attendance Record Present Name Organization Linda Boyle Mary Dawson Randy Giffin Jill Piatt Kemper Ed Burke Al Baker Aurora Aurora Aurora Aurora Brighton Centennial W&S District X Tim Grotheer Nick Tino Alan Polonsky Jon Novick Kevin Lewis Dave Kaunisto Centennial W&S District Centennial W&S District City and County of Denver City and County of Denver Denver Wastewater East Cherry Creek Valley W&S X (phone) Laurie Rink Anne Beierle Mary Gardner Phil Russell Dennis Stowe Barbara Biggs FRICO Golden Littleton/Englewood WWTP Littleton/Englewood WWTP Littleton/Englewood WWTP Metro District Amy Woodis Jim Dorsch Michelle Ryerson Fred Linton Blair Corning Stephen Ellis Metro District Metro District Metro District Miller/Coors South Adams County W&S South Adams County W&S JM Grebnec Tony Congram Vic Lucero Shay Shih Steve Materkowski Christine Johnston South Adams County W&S Suncor Energy (U.S.A.) Thornton Thornton UDFCD Xcel Energy X X X X X X X X Sarah Reeves X Brenda Stansbury Visiting Attendees X Amy Conklin X Coordinator - Brown and Caldwell Brown and Caldwell BMW Association EPA Urban Watershed Revitalization Coordinator (eriksen.stacey@epa.gov) Stacey Eriksen 5 of 5