James Madison University – College of Education Social Studies Lesson Plan Format Name: ______Stephanie Suess__________ Date: _____7/20________ Subject/Class: _IB History of the Americas__ Grade Level: ___11____ Topic: __Ideas that Shaped the Declaration of Independence__________ NCSS Theme # 6: Power, Authority and Governance Subthemes: Knowledge: The need for respect for the rule of law, as well as a recognition of times when civil disobedience has been justified; fundamental values of constitutional democracy (e.g. the common good, liberty, justice, equality, and individual dignity). Processes: Examine persistent issues involving the rights, responsibilities, roles, and status of individuals and groups in relation to the general welfare; analyze and evaluate conditions, actions, and motivation that contribute to conflict and cooperation among groups and nations. NCSS Theme # 10: Civic Ideals and Practices Subthemes: Knowledge: Concepts and ideals such as human dignity, social justice, social liberty, equality, inalienable rights, responsibilities, civil dissent, citizenship, majority and minority rights, the common good, and the rule of law; key practices involving the rights and responsibilities of citizenship and the exercise of citizenship (e.g. respecting the rule of law and due process, voting, serving on jury, researching issues, making informed judgments, expressing views on issues, and collaborating with others to take civic action.) Processes: Research primary and secondary sources to make decisions and propose solutions to selected civic issues in the past and present; identify, seek, describe, and evaluate multiple points of view about selected issues, noting the strength and weaknesses, and consequences associated with holding each position. Essential Questions/Big Ideas: How did colonists view their rights as royal subjects under the Crown? How did the ideas of John Locke influence Thomas Jefferson and the signing of the Declaration of Independence? What is the Origin, Purpose, Value, and Limitations of the Declaration of Independence? How John Locke, Thomas Paine, and Thomas Jefferson are conceptually related to the Declaration of Independence. SOLs/Standards addressed: STANDARD VUS.4a The student will demonstrate knowledge of events and issues of the Revolutionary Period by a) analyzing how the political ideas of John Locke and those expressed in Common Sense helped shape the Declaration of Independence; Dept. of Middle, Secondary, and Math Education modified by Dr. Cude & Dr. Stern 8/10 IB Standard Section 1: United States Declaration of Independence; processes leading to the declaration; influence of ideas; nature of the declaration; military campaigns and their impact on the outcome (suitable examples could be Saratoga and Yorktown) Learning Outcomes/Objectives: Students Will Be Able To: 1. V: Evaluate their viewpoints on various questions about human nature and government. 2. U: Explain the fundamental views colonists had about their rights in colonial political structures. 3. D: Interpret the ideas of John Locke as they relate to limited government, unalienable rights, equal rights, and authority from the consent of the governed. 4. D: Apply their interpretations Locke’s ideas to a photograph from the 1989 revolt in Tiananmen Square. 5. D: Interpret quotes from Locke in order to create new understandings of his theories. 6. D: Appraise the Origin, Purpose, Values, and Limitations of the Declaration of Independence. 7. D: Create a Class Concept Chart that demonstrates the contributions of John Locke and Thomas Paine, and Thomas Jefferson to the Declaration of Independence. Assessment alignment chart: How will you know they know the objectives listed above? Objective V1: SWBAT Evaluate their viewpoints on various questions about human nature and government. Assessment (formative and summative) Formative: The students will think critically about the questions regarding human nature and government, which will be reflected in quality responses during the discussion. U2: SWBAT Explain the fundamental views colonists had about their rights in colonial political structures. Summative: Students will use these conclusions to support essay responses regarding content on the unit test. Formative: The students will contribute accurate and grounded responses during the discussion of Chapter 5 of the We The People textbook. D3: SWBAT Interpret the ideas of John Locke as they relate to limited government, unalienable rights, equal rights, and Summative: Students will use these conclusions to support essay responses regarding content on the unit test. Formative: The students will contribute accurate and grounded responses during the discussion of John Locke’s ideas and contributions to the American political Dept. of Middle, Secondary, and Math Education modified by Dr. Cude & Dr. Stern 8/10 authority from the consent of the foundation. governed. Summative: Students will use these conclusions to support essay responses regarding content on the unit test. D4: SWBAT Apply their Formative: The students will contribute interpretations Locke’s ideas to accurate and grounded responses during a photograph from the 1989 the discussion of the photograph of the revolt in Tiananmen Square. 1989 revolt in Tiananmen Square. D5: SWBAT Interpret quotes from Locke in order to create new understandings of his theories. Summative: Students will use these conclusions to support essay responses regarding content on the unit test. Formative: The students develop logical alternative interpretations of quotes by John Locke. Summative: Students will use these conclusions to support essay responses regarding content on the unit test. D6: SWBAT Appraise the Formative: The students will accurately Origin, Purpose, Values, and assess OPVL for the Declaration of Limitations of the Declaration of Independence. Independence. Summative: Students will use this practice to complete the OPVL portion of the unit test. D7: SWBAT Create a Class Formative: The students will accurately Concept Chart that demonstrates complete the Class Concept Chart on the the contributions of John Locke Declaration of Independence and Thomas Paine, and Thomas Jefferson to the Declaration of Summative: Students will complete Independence. questions that contain similar concept charts on benchmark assessments accurately for SOL style preparation. Background Content Outline: (Taken Directly From the Curriculum Framework) New political ideas about the relationship between people and their government helped to justify the Declaration of Independence. The revolutionary generation formulated the political philosophy and laid the institutional foundations for the system of government under which we live. The American Revolution was inspired by ideas concerning natural rights and political authority, and its successful completion affected people and governments throughout the world for many generations. The ideas of John Locke Dept. of Middle, Secondary, and Math Education modified by Dr. Cude & Dr. Stern 8/10 The period known as the “Enlighten-ment” in Europe during the 17th and 18th centuries saw the development of new ideas about the rights of people and their relationship to their rulers. John Locke was an Enlightenment philosopher whose ideas, more than any other’s, influenced the American belief in self-government. Locke wrote that: • All people are free, equal, and have “natural rights” of life, liberty, and property that rulers cannot take away. • All original power resides in the people, and they consent to enter into a “social contract” among themselves to form a government to protect their rights. In return, the people promise to obey the laws and rules established by their government, establishing a system of “ordered liberty.” Government’s powers are limited to those the people have consented to give to it. Whenever government becomes a threat to the people’s natural rights, it breaks the social contract and the people have the right to alter or overthrow it. • Locke’s ideas about the sovereignty and rights of the people were radical and challenged the centuries-old practice throughout the world of dictatorial rule by kings, emperors, and tribal chieftains. Thomas Paine and Common Sense Thomas Paine was an English immigrant to America who produced a pamphlet known as Common Sense that challenged the rule of the American colonies by the King of England. Common Sense was read and acclaimed by many American colonists during the mid 1700s and contributed to a growing sentiment for independence from England. The Declaration of Independence The eventual draft of the Declaration of Independence, authored by Thomas Jefferson of Virginia, reflected the ideas of Locke and Paine: • “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” • “That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed….” • “That whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute new government….” • Jefferson then went on to detail many of the grievances against the king that Paine had earlier described in Common Sense. DEAN CHART Concept word Natural Rights D=define any right that exists by virtue of natural law E=examples Right to life, liberty, and property (Locke) pursuit of happiness (Jefferson) Consent to permit, approve, or agree; comply or yield The Enlightenment An intellectual movement of the seventeenth and eighteenth Agree to share power, agree to share a resource, giving someone joint ownership Meetings in salons of Paris to discuss human progress, Dept. of Middle, Secondary, and Math Education modified by Dr. Cude & Dr. Stern 8/10 A=attributes Rights believed facilitate the human experience, fundamental belief that all people have, not given to women and minorities until later on. To give, to turn over freely, to agree N=non-examples Speech, Freedom of Religion, and other extended versions of natural rights Locke, Montesquieu, Voltaire, Rousseau, ideas Absolute power, divine right, despotism Total power, absolute control, uncompromising centuries marked by a celebration of the powers of human reason, a keen interest in science, the promotion of religious toleration, and a desire to construct governments free of tyranny. writings of Enlightenment philosophers being read in other countries and areas of the world incorporated in the Declaration of Independence, The Constitution, The Bill of Rights Instructional Plan: Discussion 10 minutes We The People Textbook: Colonial Politics 20 minutes What the Teacher Will Do The teacher will begin class by asking the students the following questions: What is human nature? That is, what traits of personality and character, if any do all people have in common? Are people selfish? Do they have the capacity to care for the good of others? What should be the purpose of government? Where should people in positions of power get their authority to govern? How should a government (power) be organized? What kinds of governments should be respected and supported? What kinds of governments should be resisted and fought? The teacher will assign students to read the Chapter: What Basic Ideas About Rights and Constitutional Government Did Colonial Americans Hold? The teacher will instruct the student to take notes as they read. They will also be given the discussion questions to reflect on while they are reading. Once most students have finished, the teacher will review the questions: What do you think is the best way to explain the American colonists’ view of government? In what ways were 18th century Dept. of Middle, Secondary, and Math Education modified by Dr. Cude & Dr. Stern 8/10 What the Students Will Do Students will respond to the discussion questions thoughtfully. The students will take notes on Chapter 5 and develop responses to the two discussion questions. YLI John Locke Lesson (modified) 30 minutes American and British societies similar and different in terms of the rights of individual liberty, equality of opportunity, suffrage, and property? The teacher will distribute copies of the biography provided on John Locke and ask students to read it and answer the questions included: What are three of John Locke’s beliefs about government? What U.S. document(s) are based on the ideas of Locke? How can Locke’s influence be seen in this document? The teacher will then put up the photograph from the 1989 revolt in Tiananmen Square and ask the following questions: What is happening in this photograph? Which principles of democracy are possibly being violated? i. (equality, natural rights, liberty, unalienable rights) How does this photograph relate to limited government? OPVL Instruction: Decl. of Ind and Two Treatises on Government 20 minutes Concept Chart: The teacher will then have student go back to the study guide page with excerpts of Locke’s ideas and direct students to complete these individually or in groups. Discuss their interpretations of Locke’s writings. The teacher will have the students turn back to the We The People Textbook and have them review pages 46-48 about the Declaration of Independence. She will then instruct the class to turn to the Appendix where there is a full version of the Declaration of Independence. The teacher will then explain how to analyze documents using the components of Origin, Purpose, Values, and Limitations (OPVL). She will instruct the student to take notes on these three components and then look for examples in the Declaration. If advanced students finish, they can practice OPVL on Locke’s Second Treatise on Government included in the Locke Packet. The teacher will create a large concept chart on Dept. of Middle, Secondary, and Math Education modified by Dr. Cude & Dr. Stern 8/10 The students will read the biography and answer the three questions as they are reading. I usually instruct students that they can highlight or underline the text and then write the question number in the margin. The students will analyze the photograph and discuss the correlation to Locke’s ideas about unlimited and limited government. The student will work in pairs and re-interpret the quotes by Locke to find new understanding of his ideas. Students will review page 4648 with the teacher, they will then take notes on OPVL. Next, 4 students will read the 4 parts of the Declaration of Independence. They will then suggest elements from the document that meet the requirements of Origin, Purpose, Values and Limitations. The student will write down the examples that the class comes up with on their notes page from earlier. The students will copy the Ideas Contributing to the Declaration of Independence 10 minutes the board for students to copy on their notes page. The teacher will place John Locke, Thomas Paine, and Thomas Jefferson in a triangle formation. She will then ask the class for two pieces of important information for each individual (reviewing content about Thomas Paine’s contributions from a prior lesson) Then, she will ask the students what goes in the middle of the triangle. Wrap Up: As a light and humorous way to end the class, Video: Too Late to the teacher will play the video ‘Too Late to Apologize Apologize: A Declaration’ 5 minutes http://youtu.be/uZfRaWAtBVg concept chart, contribute appropriate responses, and correctly name that the central concept is the Declaration of Independence. The students will view the video and reflect on the significance of the colonists actions and relationship with King George. Materials Needed for the Lesson: We The People Textbook (Our school has a set) Chapter 5 and Declaration of Independence Packet containing the Biography on John Locke, Study Guide with quotations, and selected excerpts from his Second Treatise on Government. Overhead with copy of photograph from Tiananmen Square. Highlighters for students. Projector Bibliography/Resources Used (using APA): Commonwealth of Virginia, Department of Education. (2008). Curriculum framework virginia and united states history Richmond, VA: Retrieved from http://www.doe.virginia.gov/testing/sol/frameworks/history_socialscience_framewks/2008/200 8_strikethrough/framewks_va-us_history.pdf Leeson, SM., Branson, MS., Casper, SE., & Quigley, CN. (2009). We the people: the citizen & the constitution. Calabasas, CA: Center for Civic Education. Youth Leadership Initiative. (n.d.). Lesson plan: the key to john locke. Retrieved from http://www.youthleadership.net/central/lesson_plans/421?_yli_session=c9e7462b5268e064b4b 472460f12b876 Soomopublishing. (Producer). (2010). Too late to apologize: a declaration. [Web]. Retrieved from http://youtu.be/uZfRaWAtBVg LLC, . (n.d.). Dictionary.com. Retrieved from http://dictionary.reference.com/?o=100074 Adaption/Differentiation: ELL/struggling Contact YLI and ask how I can access the Spanish version of the John Dept. of Middle, Secondary, and Math Education modified by Dr. Cude & Dr. Stern 8/10 readers ADHD Gifted Locke lesson plan. Give struggling readers outlines of Chapter 5 and more detailed notes on OPVL. Perhaps a Guided Reading page in place or in addition to. Also, give them a pre-made concept chart if necessary. All concepts will be covered orally with reinforcement. If there is an inclusion teacher in the room, I will ask her to help monitor all students’ progress on the components of the lesson. I will also send their completed work to Support for individual study and study with their case manager. This lesson is chunked into many different segments, portions spent on analysis are not lengthy and in most cases done with a class or in pairs. The teacher will check on these student individually for clarification of instructions and redirection when needed. Individual students may be instructed to check with a specific neighbor for clarification or verifying responses. One of these students could also be asked to draw the concept chart on the board with the teacher’s direction. Advanced students will be directed to read excerpts included from John Locke’s Second Treatise on Government and complete OPVL. Gifted students will also have opportunities to answer the discussion questions using higher-level thinking skills. Gifted students will have the opportunity to analyze different eras of history and how they are related. These students will also be asked to look for deeper Values and Limitations of the Decl. of Independence, as well as other Purposes of its composition. Explanation of Instructional Strategies Used: I really struggled with this lesson and was trying to find the best way to tackle this SOL. I decided to go to the We the People Textbook and see if there were portions that I could use. Fortunately, I was able to pick through the first few chapters and find some really great concepts. After speaking with my department head, I was informed that we have a set of these books at our school. Unfortunately, I was still not satisfied with my resources for John Locke so I decided to look at the YLI website after finding a listing of a Locke lesson on the ‘List of Lesson Plans’ page in our YLI folders. After creating a free account, I found the lesson and decided to use it. By saving the lesson into Word format and resaving it as a modified version, I was able to cut it down to what I needed for class. Finally, OPVL is a skill that is assessed with the IB test during the second year so I have to teach it to students early in the year and we apply throughout on unit tests with various primary sources. It is always hard to find a good document to use as practice which will help the students understand what each component is, and isn’t. After some review I realized the Declaration of Independence is a perfect document to use. The Concept Chart idea came from the recognition of the need to use these types of graphic organizers to illustrate relationships between topics. These formats will be found on the new SOL tests so I have to start incorporating them on a large scale. (See sample that I will use on the following page). Finally, the last element is the YouTube video. I remember Brian Heintz showing us an SNL skit on the Gadsden Purchase and recommending that we incorporate Dept. of Middle, Secondary, and Math Education modified by Dr. Cude & Dr. Stern 8/10 humorous media into our methods wherever possible to keep the student’s interest and attention. Unfortunately, search results for “SNL History Skits” turned up nothing, but somehow I did find the Too Late To Apologize Video when searching under ‘Declaration of Independence’. I hope that students will have the song stuck in their heads for the rest of the day and think about the ‘personal relationship’ with Great Britain that it is playing off of. Sample Concept Chart: Thomas Paine: John Locke: How they are related Thomas Jefferson: Dept. of Middle, Secondary, and Math Education modified by Dr. Cude & Dr. Stern 8/10