FACTSHEET Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) AMS-III.S. - Introduction of low-emission vehicles/technologies to commercial vehicle fleets Developer Developed by Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) under the category of “Indicative simplified baseline and monitoring methodologies for selected small-scale CDM project activity” Location http://cdm.unfccc.int/methodologies/DB/TBTZSAWMBPHAPHSVXAK0NGHLEGPN79/vie w.html Methodology This methodology is for project activities introducing low-emission vehicles for commercial passenger (including public transportation), material and freight transport, operating on a number of routes with comparable conditions. Types of low-emission vehicles include compressed natural gas (CNG) vehicles, electric vehicles, liquid petroleum gas (LPG) vehicles and hybrid vehicles with electrical and internal combustion motive systems. Retrofitting of existing vehicles is also included in the methodology. This methodology is applicable under these conditions: The overall level of service provided on comparable routes before project implementation shall remain the same and a modal shift in transport is not eligible; There is no significant change in tariff discernible from their natural trend, which could lead to change in patterns of vehicle use; The frequency of operation of the vehicles is not decreased; The characteristics of the travel route – distance, start and end points and the route itself and/or the capacity introduced by the project is sufficient to service the level of passenger/freight transportation previously provided. The project boundary includes the following: Fleet to which low emission vehicles are introduced; The geographical area covering the physical routes along which these vehicles operate; Auxiliary facilities such as fuelling stations, workshops and service stations that are visited by the vehicles in the feet. The additionality1 should be demonstrated that the project activity would not have occurred anyway due to at least one of these barriers: investment barrier, technological barrier, barrier due to prevailing practice or other barriers2. Baseline Emissions The baseline emissions can be calculated based on baseline emission factor and annual average distance of transportation per passenger or tonne of goods by project vehicles and total annual passengers or tons of goods transported by project vehicles. Project Emissions Project emissions are determined by monitoring the consumption of fuel or energy consumed by the vehicles introduced. It can be calculated based on CO2 emission factor of fuel used by project vehicles and quantity of consumed fuel by these vehicles. For electric vehicles, the emissions from the production of electricity used will constitute the project emissions. This will be determined as per the ”Tool to calculate baseline, project and/or leakage emissions from electricity consumption”3. For hybrid vehicles that can run on fossil fuels and electricity, the emissions resulting from the fossil fuel use should also be included in the direct emissions, in addition to the emissions from the electricity used. The emissions from fossil fuel consumption shall be as per the “Tool to calculate project or leakage CO2 emissions from fossil fuel combustion”4. Leakage No leakage calculation is required. However, if the project activity involves fossil fuel switching measures, leakage resulting from fuel extraction, processing, liquefaction, transportation, re-gasification and distribution of fossil fuels outside of the project boundary shall be considered. The guidance provided in the leakage section of “ACM0009Consolidated baseline and monitoring methodology for fuel switching from coal or petroleum fuel to natural gas”5 shall be followed in this regard. Inputs Baseline emission factor per passenger or ton of goods per kilometer for the baseline vehicles (BEF) The concept of “additionality” under the CDM refers to the project has to prove that the emission reductions are additional to any that would occur in the absence of the certified project activity (CDM Rule book: http://cdmrulebook.org/84) 2 More information about additionality (attachment A to Appendix B) is available at: http://cdm.unfccc.int/Reference/Guidclarif/ssc/methSSC_guid05.pdf 3 More information is available at: http://cdm.unfccc.int/methodologies/PAmethodologies/tools/am-tool-03-v2.pdf 4 More information is available at: http://cdm.unfccc.int/methodologies/PAmethodologies/tools/am-tool-05-v1.pdf 5 More information is available at: http://cdm.unfccc.int/methodologies/DB/2CRBYLJO5JWC9YHBSWJQWYIH2LLGMJ/view.html 1 Total annual passengers or tons of goods transported by baseline vehicles (P) The annual average distance of transportation per person or tonne of freight by baseline vehicles (dp) Total annual distance travelled by baseline vehicles (D) Efficiency of baseline vehicles (BLV) Net calorific value of fuel (NCV) CO2 emission factor of fuel used by baseline vehicles (EFCO2) Parameters Monitored The parameters below are required for monitoring the project activity progress. Total distance travelled by vehicles (DTPJ) Consumption of fuel (or electricity) by vehicles (FC, EC) CO2 emission factor of fuel used by project vehicles (EFCO2) CO2 emission factor of grid electricity used by project vehicle (EFelec) Total annual passengers or goods transported by project vehicles (P) Annual average distance of transportation per person or tonne of freight by project vehicles (dp) Distance of routes (D) Service level in terms of total passengers or volume of goods on routes (SL) Service level in terms of total passengers or volume of goods carried on routes before the beginning of project (SLBL) Pollutants/Gases Analyzed CO2 Evaluation No independent evaluation has been undertaken of this methodology. However as a CDM based methodology the following strengths and weaknesses apply. Strengths Weaknesses This methodology allows estimating accurately the emission reduction of biodiesel production and use for transport applications. It does an ex-ante appraisal, which has to be validated in the future with ex-post estimation in order to This methodology is considerably data-intensive due to the requirement for verification of progress during the lifetime of the project and the need to undertake exante and ex-post analyses. These data may also not be readily available in get the Certified Emissions Reductions (CER) (Emissions reduction estimations may result in the acquisition of CER). developing countries. Costly data collection which frequently exceeds what CDM credits pay. (Punte, 2011) Strict guidelines for data collection, estimation of leakages and a clear procedure make this methodology accurate.6 Guidelines are available online. References CDM – Executive Board, Introduction of low-emission vehicles to commercial vehicle fleets, AMS-III.S./ Version 03, Sectoral Scope: 07, EB 66. Punte, S., Replogle, M., Mejia, A., 2011. Transport Emissions Evaluation Models for Projects (TEEMP). Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Actions as Catalysts for Environmentally Sustainable Transport. Seoul, South Korea. http://www.transport2012.org/bridging/ressources/documents/2/1362,4.-TEEMPOverview-Seoul-12Apr2011-f.pdf 6 Each CDM project has to be verified during the lifetime of the project comparing the real emissions with the corresponding forecasted emissions.