English Language Arts: Informational Text — Reading Unit 2: Dimensions of Text Complexity Facilitator’s Guide Slide 1-2: Welcome and Objectives Welcome to Unit 2: Dimensions of Text Complexity. In Unit 2 of the module, you will Understand and be able to use the three dimensions of text complexity when selecting texts for students to read Understand and be able to use Lexile measurements to determine the quantitative level of a book and one measure of a student’s reading level Slide 3: Understanding the Dimensions of Text Complexity Although students need opportunities to improve their reading abilities through challenging grade level texts, the CCSS for ELA/Literacy also encourage the use of text that is at the developmental level of the student. Both of these experiences are important for students reading skills that will prepare them for college and career. Slide 4: The CCSS for ELA/Literacy Model of Text Complexity The CCSS for ELA/Literacy define a three-part model for determining how easy or difficult a particular text is to read as well as grade-by-grade specifications for increasing text (Reading Standard 10). Resource: Common Core State Standards for English Language Arts & Literacy in History/Social Studies, Science, and Technical Subjects - Appendix A A variety of factors influence text complexity. The CCSS for ELA/Literacy emphasize three components of text complexity: 1. Qualitative dimensions of text complexity 2. Quantitative dimensions of text complexity 3. Reader and task considerations Within the next few slides, we will take a deeper look at text complexity. Source: Common Core State Standards Initiative Web site at http://www.corestandards.org/assets/Appendix_A.pdf Slide 5: Understanding the Dimensions of Text Complexity In your participant packet, let’s look at Appendix A of the CCSS for ELA/Literacy which shows the model for measuring text complexity. Let’s watch the video, “Introduction to Text Complexity”. Now that we have watched the video, let’s read through the information in Appendix A, the section on its page four that begins with the heading “The Standards’ Approach to Text Complexity,” and highlight components of text complexity that you currently use in your classroom and underline components you plan to start doing when planning reading instruction. Slide 6: Table Discussion Turn to a table partner and discuss why it will be important to examine the three dimensions of text complexity concerning a particular text before teaching it in the classroom. Slide 7: Experts Discuss Text Complexity Let’s watch the first three minutes of the video, “Staircase of Complexity”. Video: http://www.engageny.org/resource/common-core-in-ela-literacy-shift-3-staircase-of-complexity Slide 8: Experts Discuss Text Complexity Continued Let’s watch this video of Timothy Shanahan. Video: http://www.schooltube.com/video/c06b25c976d22dadf36e/ Slide 9: Table Discussion Select one of the topics Dr. Shanahan talks about to discuss with a table partner: CCSS for ELA/Literacy are intended to raise the complexity level of texts students read at every grade level in all content areas Teaching more complex text stretches a student’s abilities Teachers need to use scaffolds that support students in comprehending complex text Slide 10: Assessing Students’ Reading Level The Lexile Framework provides guidance about how to select books based on a student’s reading ability and not by the student’s grade level. Slide 11: Assessing a Student’s Reading Level Let’s view the following short video about the Lexile Framework for Reading. Video link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=AiFm2Jr8FzY Slide 12: Aligning Lexile© Ranges to College and Career Readiness Lexile measurement has been adjusted by MetaMetrics to match the CCSS for ELA/Literacy text complexity bands and to address the gap between texts read near the end of high school and university texts. This chart shows Lexile ranges by grade level. Slide 13: Increased Text Complexity Expectations Let’s review the description of Increased Text Complexity from Appendix A. Slide 14: Progression of Reading Standard 10 In your participant packet, let’s turn to the text complexity expectations of the CCSS for ELA/Literacy. This chart presents the progression of Reading Standard 10, which defines grade-by-grade growth in students’ ability to read complex text. The development of this ability in individual students is unlikely to occur at an unbroken pace. As students’ ability to read complex text does not always develop in a linear fashion, students reading well above and well below grade-band level need additional support. Consider what procedures can you in your classroom to ensure students are reading texts at their individual comprehension level. Slide 15: Three Dimensions of Text Complexity Let’s read the text complexity annotation for The Grapes of Wrath in your participant packet. Although this is a literature text, it is a good example of the need to look at all three dimensions of text complexity when planning scaffolding strategies for student reading. Slide 16: Three Dimensions of Text Complexity Let’s view the first five minutes of the video of Susan Pimentel explaining text complexity to teachers in Hawaii. You may refer to Appendix A’s entire section regarding text complexity on pages 2-16. There are many examples given in this section to help teachers understand how to look at all three dimensions of text complexity. Video link: http://mediasite.k12.hi.us/HIDOE/Viewer/?peid=1d2454866ec44a769623b25c287efe691d Slide 17: An Educator’s Role in Supporting All Readers As we previously have discussed, all readers must be able to access complex text in order to develop the skills needed for college and career. Slide 18: Text Complexity and English Learners To increase instruction and the achievement for English learners to the level of linguistic complexity called for in the CCSS for ELA/Literacy requires a focus on English language development and scaffolding strategies across the curriculum. The new California English Language Development Standards, adopted in the fall of 2012 are aligned to the CCSS for ELA/Literacy. All students can benefit from scaffolding within the classroom that is designed to help students access challenging material. Scaffolding “supports students on how to do something with support today that they will be able to do independently in the future.” Teachers should adjust the degree of scaffolding, light, moderate, or substantial, depending on the needs of each task and each student. Appendix C of the ELD Standards in your participant packet identifies two types of scaffolding: planned scaffolding and just-in-time scaffolding. Teachers prepare planned scaffolding before the lesson “in order to support students’ access to the academic content and linguistic development” of the text. “This planned scaffolding in turn allows teachers to provide just-in-time scaffolding during instruction, which flexibly attends to students’ needs as they interact with content and language.” Slide 19: Text Complexity and English Learners Continued Let’s watch this video with Lily Wong Fillmore discussing text complexity, the CCSS for ELA/Literacy, and English learners. Let’s look at the “Scaffolding for English Learners” from Appendix C of the ELD Standards in your participant packet for the suggestions of both planned and just-in-time scaffolding. Select an example of planned scaffolding that you could use in an upcoming lesson. Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=STFTX7UiBz0 Slide 20: Supporting Students with Disabilities and Underperforming Students Scaffolding strategies are appropriate for supporting all students as they engage in the process of learning to read complex texts. Let’s look at this list of scaffolding strategies that may support students with disabilities and underperforming students. Slide 21-22: Additional Information and Resources for Supporting Struggling Students In the resource section of your participant packet, you will find information regarding teaching students who are struggling with reading complex text. Slide 23: Unit 2 Conclusion In this module we examined the following objectives: Understand and be able to use the three dimensions of text complexity when selecting texts for students to read Understand and be able to use Lexile measurements to determine the quantitative level of a book and one measure of a student’s reading level