Stratospheric Ozone Lesson Plans Summer Scarlatelli Grade Level 8th grade Physical Science, 9th Grade Earth Science or 11th grade Environmental Science Objectives Students will be able to describe where in the atmosphere the ozone layer is located. Students will be able to differentiate between O2 oxygen and 03 ozone. Students will be able to identify a chlorofluorocarbon and describe how they cause ozone depletion. Students will be able to describe how volcanoes affect the ozone layer Students will be able to identify how the depletion of the ozone layer is letting in harmful radiation and how this is affecting humans and other organisms. Students will be able to use the UV index and describe how to better protect themselves from harmful UV radiation. Through research and discussion the students will be able to give an accurate and detailed description of how the lithosphere and the biosphere affect stratospheric ozone and how the depletion of stratospheric ozone layer is affecting the biosphere and hydrosphere. Key Words Ozone or O3, Oxygen or O2, Chlorofluorocarbons, UV-A radiation, UV-B radiation, UV-C radiation, atmosphere, stratosphere, ozone layer, skin cancer, UV Index, catalyst, triatomic molecule, diatomic molecule Teaching Time Five 45-minute class periods (to allow time for research and rehearsals) and one 30 minute class period for class play. Curriculum and Instructional Strategy 1. Have students take a “Pre-test” survey and grade themselves on how much they think they know about change and the terminology that encompasses it. They will rate themselves 4 – 1, four feeling they know a lot through one meaning they feel that they know very little. The questions will look like the following. a. How well can you explain ozone depletion? b. Can you identify what the molecule O2 is? c. Can you identify what the molecule O3 is? d. e. f. g. h. Can you locate the ozone layer in the atmosphere? Can you identify human made products that are harming the ozone layer? Can you identify natural causes that are affecting the ozone layer? Can you describe UV radiation and can you identify the three major types of it? Can identify how UV radiation reaches Earth and can you identify how they affect organisms. Can you describe the UV Index? Can you list five ways to protect yourself from UV radiation? i. j. 2. Hook a. When students come into the class they will be shown the picture below and asked to comment on it. They will also hear the following statistics from www.skincancer.org: i. “As much as 80 percent of UVR can pass through thin clouds that appear to block the sun, so that you can sunburn even on an apparently cloudy day.” ii. “Typically, it takes about 15 minutes for a fair-skinned person to develop perceptible sunburn in mid-summer”. b. Next the students will be split into groups of five and they will write what they know about the ozone layer and what they know about the hole in the ozone layer. i. As a class the students will combine the information they have compiled and separate them into facts and fiction. 1. This will hopefully dispel any misconceptions. ii. Next the class will be given the following facts 1. The ozone layer is found in the stratosphere a. It protects Earth and its inhabitants from harmful UV radiation. b. It is found most often between six and thirty miles above Earth’s surface. c. The ozone absorbs UV radiation and helps trap in heat. i. Without the filtering of the ozone layer, more harmful UV-B radiation would reach Earth’s surface. ii. In humans overexposure to UV radiation can cause cataracts, skin cancer, premature aging and the weakening of the immune system. 2. The ozone layer is getting thinner primarily because of human made chemicals called CFCs. a. Winds carry CFCs into the stratosphere where they are broken apart by UV radiation and release chlorine i. Every atom of chlorine can attack and destroy as many as 100,000 ozone molecules b. CFC’s can be found in aerosols, Styrofoam products, fire extinguishers, and refrigerants just to name a few. c. As the ozone layer is depleted more harmful radiation can penetrate through the layer and reach the Earth. d. In 1985 the Montreal Protocol decided to end all production of halocarbons by 1994 and chlorofluorocarbons in developed countries by 1996. If CFC’s had not been banned, “by 2060, the levels of stratospheric chlorine would have been 16 times above 1980 levels and average global ozone levels would have decreased by two thirds.” (www.skincancer.org) 3. Ozone is made up of three oxygen molecules 4. Even though volcanoes produce small amounts of aerosols, major volcanic eruptions can speed up ozone depletion. iii. Now the class will split back into groups and create posters on what they were surprised to learn. 3. In class, students will take the Ozone Hole Tour at http://www.atm.ch.cam.ac.uk/tour/index.html in order to better understand the ozone layer and the progression of the hole in the ozone layer. 4. Gumdrop Science a. The teacher will demonstrate the effects that the depletion of the ozone layer can have on humans. i. This lab was modified from the Environmental Protection Agency’s Sun Wise Program ii. Supplies 1. One bag of multicolored gumdrops, toothpicks, flashlight, blue transparency (if you do not have one you can color a blank transparency with a sharpie), purple transparency, clear transparency, white piece of paper. iii. Procedure 1. Part 1 a. Connect three or four pairs of white gum drops with a tooth pick to simulate a diatomic oxygen molecule, which are present in the air we breathe. b. Have a student shine the flashlight on one of these molecules while holding the blue colored transparency between the two. i. The blue transparency is demonstrating how short UV wavelength radiation from the sun can break up diatomic oxygen, leaving the oxygen molecules to form triatomic oxygen or ozone. c. In the stratosphere ozone meets up with CFCs like CFC 11 so have students make a model of CFC 11 using one black gumdrop for fluorine and thee green gumdrops for chlorine. d. Stick three toothpicks into the carbon to form a three legged stool. Put a green chlorine atom on each of the free ends of the toothpicks. e. With the stool standing on the desk, put another toothpick in the carbon and attach the fluorine to it. f. Lay the CFC molecule and the and the ozone molecule side by side on a white piece of paper i. The white paper represents the stratosphere g. Bombard them with simulated UV radiation from your flashlight. i. The flashlight should be covered with a s purple colored plastic sheet to represent a longer wavelength of UV light ii. In the end, this lab describe how CFC continue to break apart ozone molecules, leaving the chlorine molecules to attack and break up ozone molecules for many years. 2. Part 2 a. Students will investigate a UV Index i. The UV index provides a daily forecast of the expected risk of overexposure to the sun. The scale is numbered 1 to 11, 1 meaning the lowest risk of exposure to 11 identifying that there is a high risk of exposure. The UV index takes into account clouds and other local conditions that affect the amount of UV radiation that reaches the Earth all over the country. ii. Students will go to http://www.epa.gov/sunwise/uvindex.html type in their zipcode and look at the UV index for the present date and time. iii. Students will then interpret the results b. The teacher will discuss several ways UV radiation can harm humans i. Overexposure to UV radiation can increase the likelihood of cataracts forming in the eye of many organisms. Cataracts cause the lens in the eye to look milky and they give the sense of a continuously cloudy vision. If cataracts are not treated they could potentially lead to blindness. ii. One in every five Americans will develop some type of skin cancer in their life time, and that one American dies every hour. Melanoma is perhaps the scariest form of skin cancer and because it may take ten to twenty years to develop, many doctors feel that it usually occurs from sunburns obtained in the patient’s youth. Two other forms of skin cancer are Basal cell carcinoma and Squamous cell carcinoma. Basal cell carcinomas are slow spreading small and fleshy tumors that grow around the head and neck of an individual. Squamous cell carcinomas are red, patchy and scaly tumors that can grow into large groups and spread to other parts of the body. iii. Overexposure to UV radiation can also cause our skin to prematurely age, making it look thick, wrinkly and leathery. iv. Too much UV radiation can also suppress the proper functioning of the body’s immune system. c. Students will identify ways to protect themselves from harmful UV radiation and make posters to post around school. i. The list will look like the following: 1. Limit you exposure to the sun, especially between 10am and 3pm where they sun’s rays are at their peak. 2. While out it in the sun you should always wear: polarized sunglasses, hats (widebrimmed if possible), light weight longsleeved shirts and plants. 3. Wear sunscreen with an SPF or Sun Protection Factor of 15 or higher. The sunscreen should be applied before exposure to the sun and reapplied continuously throughout the day, especially after swimming or any physical activity. 4. Avoid tanning beds iv. Assigned Questions 1. Why is ozone good for the atmosphere? 2. How is the breakup of ozone in the stratosphere similar to its formation? 3. How do increases in CFC’s affect the stratosphere and more specifically stratospheric ozone? 4. What is the UV index and why is it important? 5. Student Research and School Play i. Now that the students have a basic understanding of the ozone layer, the causes of ozone depletion and the effects of ozone depletion has on living organisms the students will compose research papers and then compose scenes for a play to present to the lower school. ii. The teacher will divide the class into five groups. 1. Each group will represent a different way that either the ozone layer is affected by a sphere or how the depletion of the ozone layer affects a sphere. Each group will be labeled one of the following: a. Atmosphere and the ozone layer – Students will describe and investigate where the ozone layer is located, what it is composed of and why it is important. b. The lithosphere and its effect of the ozone layer – Students will investigate how volcanic eruptions affect the ozone layer. c. The biosphere and its effects on the ozone layer – Students will investigate how human made chlorofluorocarbons are affecting the ozone layer. d. The depletion of the ozone layer and its affects on the hydrosphere – Students will investigate how the depletion of the ozone layer is affecting the hydrosphere in particularly water circulation and water temperature. Students will also go more in depth and describe how the depletion of the ozone layer is affecting the organisms within the hydrosphere. e. The depletion of the ozone layer and its affect on the biosphere – Students will investigate how the depletion of the ozone layer is affecting organisms like humans and plants. 2. Students will then split into groups of five, each having an expert in one of the five fields. a. They will then create a five to ten minute skit based on their cumulative knowledge on the importance of the ozone layer and how it affects and how it affected by other spheres. b. Before preparing the skits they will be told by the teacher which grade level their skit needs to be modified for (PreK/K, 1st/2nd, 3rd/4th or 5th/6th) c. Students must emphasize sun safety in their skits. d. Students must make their skits appropriate for the age level they are presenting their skits to e. After the play, students will then ask the class if they have any questions. 6. Extra Credit a. For extra credit students can create a school policy or a “Sunwise Policy” to protect themselves and their fellow students at school. The policy should include how to make students more aware of sun safety and how the students can ensure that there is enough shade around school to protect faculty and students from the sun. 7. Have each student retake “Pre-Test” survey and compare their results. a. Include the following questions i. Can you identify five ways to protect yourself from harmful UV radiation? ii. Can you name two things you can do on your own to help stop ozone depletion? iii. Can you define a catalyst and can you identify one that aids in ozone depletion? iv. Can you define and differentiate between a triatomic molecule and a diatomic molecule? v. Can you describe how describe how photochermical reactions are involved in the creation and destruction of stratospheric ozone? Teacher Rubric 1. The teacher will evaluate the student’s depth of understanding of global climate and class participation through the following rubric. Each category will be graded on a four to one scale, four meaning the student became an expert in the area while a one means that student did not actively participate in the activities or did not pay attention. a. Knowledge of Stratospheric ozone and in-class participation i. Students will be able to differentiate between O2 oxygen and O3 ozone. ii. The student can explain the layers of the atmosphere and identify where the ozone layer is located. iii. The student actively participated in creating a poster on stratospheric ozone iv. The student actively watched the Ozone Hole Tour and was able to comment on it. v. The students helped write what they know about the ozone layer and what they know about the hole in the ozone layer. vi. The student is able to identify a chlorofluorocarbon and describe how they cause ozone depletion. vii. The student describe how volcanoes affect the ozone layer viii. The student can describe how the depletion of the ozone layer is letting in harmful radiation and how this is affecting humans and other organisms. ix. The student is able to use the UV index and can describe to someone else how to protect themselves from harmful UV radiation. x. The student actively listed and participated in the discussion on the Ozone Layer demonstration. xi. The student completed the activity on Gumdrop Science and correctly answered the assigned questions. b. Participation in Research i. The student actively and accurately researched how stratospheric ozone was either affected by a sphere of how a sphere affected it. ii. The student was able to actively put their research into kid friendly terminology for the play for the lower school students. iii. The student used reputable resources for their research. c. Participation in Play i. The student actively participated in creating the play, giving ideas on dialogue to include and how to act the scenes out. ii. The student was able to excite the younger students and help them learn about the ozone layer and how to protect themselves from sun damage Individual Reflection This sphere report and lesson plan in particular has most definitely been the hardest one of the semester for me. I spent more time putting this sphere report than others and I ran into a lot more mental road blacks with the Lesson Plans than any of the others. The sphere report has helped me develop a better understanding of the ozone layer and it will allow me to better incorporate the ozone layer into my lesson plans on the atmosphere, especially because I knew virtually nothing about the topic. I knew from past ESSEA analysis that volcanoes can harm the ozone layer but I was happy to learn that volcanic aerosols only remain in the stratosphere for 2-5 years and the affects of volcanic eruptions on stratospheric ozone does not help explain why the ozone layer is depleting so quickly. I also did not initially realize that ozone was found in two layers of the atmosphere, the stratosphere and the troposphere and that stratospheric ozone is “good” ozone and the tropospheric ozone is the “bad” ozone. Creating this lesson plan has allowed me to incorporate skin cancer and sun safety into the small section I teach in Earth Science on the ozone and the ozone layer. After working at Seacamp for a year and a half and growing up on the beach, I have most definitely learned the importance of sunscreen and sun safety. Over the last few years I have noticed the way kids disregard the sun and I think this my job as a teacher to dispel their myths and teach them the real facts. I think it is especially important in south Florida in particular with my African American student who many think that because their skin is dark they don’t have to take any precaution to protect themselves. Humans with darker pigments or more melanin in their skin can deal with more exposure to UV-B than humans with lighter skin because the melanin helps block it out, yet the melanin doest protect them again skin cancer. Through my research on this topic, I have learned that there are three main types UV radiation and that rain, air pollution, altitude, cloud cover, time of day, season and the percentage of light that is reflected off of different land masses all have an effect of the amount of UV-B radiation that reaches Earth. While I was doing research for my Lesson Plan, the most impressive fact that I learned was that if it wasn’t for the Montreal Protocol in 1985 limiting CFC’s into the atmosphere that the “by the year 2060 the levels of stratospheric chlorine would have been 16 times above 1980 levels”. I think it pretty awesome that humans are finally doing something to protect the environment and that countries have banned together with a common goal. Lastly because I love marine science a lot I was impressed to learn that the depletion of the ozone layer could cause the amount of phytoplankton to decrease which could then in turn increase global warming, it seems to be a viscous cycle. In retrospect as much as I had a lot of mental blocks writing my lesson plan and sphere report, I think I gained a lot more knowledge on the stratospheric ozone than I initially realized. Peer Reflection 1 Hi Summer,sorry for the late response-my Internet at home is not working... so here I am at school trying to add to the discussion. It hasn't been working since Thursday! Anyhow, here's what I have to say about your lesson: 1. I like the range of grade levels that the lesson may be used in. 2. Wow, love the class play idea-it makes the learning fun! 3. I like your hook-it's a cute idea to use cartoon to get their attention.-Besides commenting on the picture, what else would they do with the hook? 4. I like how you addressed students' prior knowledge and how you have a plan for dealing with their misconceptions. 5. What are students going to do with the facts given in Part B section II, create a poster? What about having them do their own research. 6. I like the gumdrop activity-my students liked labs that have anything to do with food! 7. My understanding of the lesson is that the 1st part builds background knowledge and the 2nd discusses in details the expert groupsrubric looks great too!! Overall, great job! Hope this helps-Lascelia Peer Reflection 2 Hi Summer, Thanks for reviewing my lesson plan! I thought yours was very well done- extremely detailed! I had very few edits, I just turned the 2s and 3s in O2and O3 into subscripts, because I have memories of losing points for that in high school chemistry and now I'm weird about it.... Also relating high school chemistry, I liked your activity with modeling the different molecules with toothpicks and gumdrops- I definitely remember doing that to learn molecular structures. Should the students be breaking gumdrops off the toothpicks and rearranging once the UV radiation hits or chlorine is introduced? That was a little unclear. I also liked how the students would be performing a skit to teach younger students about ozone and sun safety- good creative way to use jigsaw. - Sarah