Subject: Agricultural and Horticultural Science Level: Year 11 Title: Soil’s not dirt Authors: Kerry Hunt & Trudy Gee Email addresses: james.allen@clear.net.nz (for Kerry Hunt) trudy.gee@outer.net.nz All Curriculum Support Days resources reflect the work of subject specialists during a two-day forum. You should view them as ‘work-in- progress’, not as finished units to download and use. They demonstrate a range of ways of thinking about how you might build the ‘front end’ of the NZ Curriculum (the Vision, Principles, Values, Key Competencies, Effective Pedagogies and Learning Area Statements) into your existing units of work, by re-focusing how you teach rather than changing what you teach. The questions and comments recorded in the body of each resource are at least as important as the unit itself. If for some reason your software does not display such questions and comments, it is likely that you need to make some technical adjustment to how you are viewing the resource. References in senior units to achievement or unit standards are to current standards, and generally do not take into account possible revisions of these standards to take effect from 2011. 1. Why this unit is worth reworking The unit comprises both Agricultural and Horticultural Science concepts. Important foundation for beginning Agricultural and Horticultural Science as a subject. Students enjoy the practical element. Practical work and project management in this topic offer opportunities to develop relevant skills, work collaboratively, and become confident, independent learners. As a topic learners are able to develop an understanding of: o the interconnections between people, soils, plants, and animals in agricultural and horticultural production, o the ways in which agricultural and horticultural practices impact on the environment and can be used to sustain or enhance it. 2. Re-Thinking the unit As the unit is currently written, it is content driven towards students gaining knowledge for a NCEA external exam. It needs to include values and Key Competencies within the context of the unit. More student-directed learning needs to take place in this unit. We want our unit to provide effective pedagogy to promote student learning. Throughout the revised unit, students are gathering and processing information from the activities. It is suggested that at the end of each activity some information is summarised and recorded. This could be done in a number of ways that may include both teacher-directed and student-directed. THIS IS THE OLD UNIT AHS 1.3 Describe the properties and management of Soils. Achievement Objectives 1 Importance of growing medium Describe why plants need a growing medium Nature of soil as a variable mixture subject to change, & providing nutrients, minerals, air, & water. 2 1Soil composition. Describe soil composition & components. 3 3Soil profile Lesson Structure Discussion Define growing medium & soil composition using scheme & Grow It pg 27-28. Learning Strategies Pg 22-25 Make notes from scheme & OHTs Answer qs pg 24-25 Grow It w/s pg 29-31 Lesson 1 sheet (TFS) Define soil composition using scheme & Grow It pg 27-28. What is soil? (OHTs) Soil horizons (OHTs) Grow It activities pg 8191 OHTs Dig soil profile Resources Scheme & OHTs Appendices 2 &3 Text Grow It TFS Grow it OHTs Spade Explain how these variations affect plant growth 4 oHow is soil made? 4 5 5Physical characteristics of Soil Describe the physical characteristics of soil Soil structure Simple knowledge of structure Dig soil profile writing description (see case study 7). Note variation with depth Consider how these variations affect plant growth, relate to the Hort unit gardens. Compare local profile with different areas – why are they different? (see Activity 4) Brainstorm the physical characteristics of soil Look at soil structure (see scheme) in terms of particle size & pore structure Soil types (OHT) 6 6Soil texture Simple knowledge of texture Soil texture using OHTs, triangle & w/s Expt: App 6 Do movement through soils – permeability Relate to fertilisers Copy OHTs Comprehension exercise (TFS) Compare profiles using Hort unit & Volcanic Soils of the central North Island with Sandy Soils of the Coasts. Summarise differences (TFS). Topsoil w/s TFS lesson 2 sheet W/s Growing it Notes OHTs Graphing soil particles sizes exercise Show soil egs Write up different soil types Soil structure exercise sheet Notes (OHTs) & scheme W/s on soil texture Practical – Determine 1) different soils & 2) drainage App 6 Grow It activity pg 9294 Soil, isn’t dirt chap w/s Volcanic Soils of the central North Island & Sandy Soils of the Coasts Topsoil w/s Case study 7 Activity 4 OHTs TFS W/s Growing it OHT Graphing soil particles sizes exercise Soil structure exercise sheet W/s OHTs Appendix 6 Practical gear Grow It activity pg 9294 scheme 7 7Chemical characteristics of soil Describe the chemical characteristics of soil Soil types Soil pH Soil pH Notes (App 10-11) 8 8Soil as a reservoir & a source of nutrients 9 9Biological characteristics of soil Describe the biological characteristics of soil 10 11) Organic matter 0 Organic matter & its decomposition to humus Value of organic matter & humus 11 12) Soil organisms 1 The role of soil organisms Symbiotic associations, soil pathogens, & soil pests. The role of soil disinfection 12 1Modification of natural soils 2 Describe the methods used to modify soil so that it becomes Notes (see scheme, OHT & App 13 &14) Read pg 28-30 Do questions, exercise pg 30-31 Grow It activity pg 95100 Soil pH practical problem w/s Dictate notes from scheme. Practical – Measuring pH of plots Notes from scheme & OHT Text pH meter Appendix 11 scheme OHT Grow It activity pg 95 – 100 Soil pH practical problem w/s Scheme & OHT App 13 & 14 Text OHTs Go over using OHTs Copy OHTs Read pg 31-33 Do qs & exercise Discuss using OHTs Make notes using OHTs OHTs Go over using OHTs Make notes using OHTs Pg 46-47, read & answer qs Text OHTs Pg 36 & 39 Do exercise & qs Copy OHT or pg 39 Text OHT Scheme 1) By physical means cultivation (scheme) drainage – movement of water a medium suitable for growing plants by physical means. Importance of water/air balance through soil (OHT) irrigation (scheme) 13 1 3 Describe the methods used to modify soil so that it becomes a medium suitable for growing plants by adding organic material & lime. 14 1Alternative Growing Media 7 Identify alternative growing media Growing mixes for various purposes 2) By adding organic material (see AS 1.5) By adding organic matter (scheme) Mulching (scheme) and briefly discuss composting (see AS 1.5) By adding lime (scheme & OHTs) Go over using scheme & OHTs Copy notes from scheme Ground water movement SEEN activity (see sheet) Physical modification to soils w/s Assessing soil drainage w/s Make notes using OHTs Read article ‘Making the most of mulches’ & answer qs; or Mulches in the Home Garden. Read pgs 44-45 Answer qs pg 45 & 46 Mulch wordfind Make notes using OHTs Word search Practical analysis of an alternative growing media sheet Creating an alternative growing medium to soil sheet SEEN activity Physical modification to soils w/s Assessing soil drainage w/s Scheme & OHTs W/s Mulch wordfind Scheme OHTs Wordsearch Practical analysis of an alternative growing media sheet Creating an alternative growing medium to soil sheet 15 1Materials used in Media 8 The characteristics of their components Describe the composition 1) 2) 3) 4) Organic – brainstorm in groups Minerals – OHT Plastics Nutrient supply – OHTs 16 2Hydroponics. Investigate &explain different types of commercial & home hydroponics systems. Alternative growing media & characteristics of their components. History (see Hort TIS) Types of hydroponics systems, description & explanation of. (see sheet) Examples from school. Methods (see Biotissue stuff) Video Hydroponics Explained Advantages – of hydroponics, - to the grower, - to the retailer. (see sheet) 17 3Nutrients. Identify the nutrients that are Nutrients: Ca, Fe, Mg (see Biotissue stuff) Write the advantages & disadvantages of each Read pg 51-52 & answer qs on pg 52 & 53 Practical App 24 Crossword &/or Wordgame Show examples. Guess the media from the box, determine which are organic or inorganic. Classroom discussion & a visual comparison of the 2 systems. W/s on different systems, eg Read ‘Hydroponics & the Home Gardener’ & answer qs; &/or ‘Hydroponic Easy’ & answer qs; &/or ‘NZ Hydroponics’ & answer qs Read pg 55 & do qs pg 56 Watch Hydroponics video. Discussion & notes. Text Crossword App 24 OHTs Wordgame Video player & video School h/ps system Text Biotissue stuff Hort TIS H/ps & the Home Gardener w/s H/p Easy w/s NZ H/ps w/s Video & player School hydroponics used in hydroponics & the components & relationships within a hydroponics system. Alternative growing media & characteristics of their components. Light – use of Panda film Oxygen – air pump Warmth Submersible pumps Use of nutrients. pH Conductivity factor (CF) system 18 1Revision 9 19 2Test. To assess the above topic 0 Soil crossword Homework question sheet. Match up words Sit Crossword Question sheet. Match up Test 3. The Revised Unit Agricultural and Horticultural Science: Soil’s not Dirt Essence statement: Duration: 5-6 weeks Using Agricultural and Horticultural Science knowledge and skills to make informed decisions that enhance and sustain soils for Agricultural and Horticultural production. Big Picture: Soils are the basis of the Agricultural and Horticultural industry. They provide a foundation for plant growth and support stock production. Growers need to manage soil as a sustainable resource for present and future plant and stock production. The following are important ideas within the Big Picture: Soil is not dirt – it is a natural growing medium containing mineral and organic matter. Apply soil knowledge and concepts to the learner’s local area. Learning Objective 3: Understand how the management of soil properties affects plant growth. Curriculum Level 6 Strand: The Environment Learning Objective 4: Understand how management and/or design practices impact on the environment. Key Competency: Values: Principles: Thinking: make sense of information, develop understanding, make decisions, and reflect on learning. Using Language, symbols, and text: to access and communicate information and to communicate this information with others. Ecological sustainability, which includes care for the environment. Community and participation for the common good. Coherence: creating links between knowledge gained within the Soil unit and also wider Agricultural and Horticultural Science units. Future Focus: sustainability and soil conservation management decisions that allow producers to enhance and sustain soils for Agricultural and Horticultural production. Context: Soil science: soil components, physical properties, chemical properties and biological properties. Management practices: fertiliser and lime application, cultivation, adding composted material, drainage, irrigation, crop rotation, effluent application. Specific learning outcomes/ Depth of coverage. What’s the Big Picture? Describe why plants need a growing medium? Soil is a variable mixture subject to change, & provides nutrients, Learning Activities. Resources. Possible brainstorming ideas may include. What would Earth be like with no soil? Consider naturally occurring versus managed ecosystems and production systems in a world with no soil. Global and local impacts of a world with no soil. Small groups of students take a shovel full of soil from the garden, place it on a sheet of newspaper. They then classify the contents into groups they have developed. From the discussion that follows a definition of Poster paper. Pens. Shovel. Newspaper. Plants growing in different soils Assessment. minerals, air, & water. The concept that Soil is not Dirt. Introduce local soil context, soil composition. Describe soil composition & components. Soil Profile. Explain how variations in the soil profile affect plant growth. How is soil made? Physical characteristics of soil. Understand the physical characteristics of soil. Soil structure. Simple knowledge of structure. Soil texture. Simple knowledge of texture. growing medium & soil composition can be made. Make links between plant growth and soils. may be useful. Students to obtain a variety of soil samples from a range of environments. Do a round robin; look at the trays of soil for visual and textural differences and similarities. Define soil composition and components. What is soil? Dig soil profiles. Note variation with depth Consider how these variations affect plant growth; relate to own immediate surroundings. Compare local profile with different areas – why are they different? Summarise differences. Soil samples. Trays. Think/pair/share the physical characteristics of soil, soil structure (particle size and pore structure) and soil types. Other activities could include; e.g. graphing soil particles sizes exercise, separating the particle sizes using different sized sieves. Soil texture by feel analysis. Water movement through soils – permeability experiment. Put the question to the students: If water moves through soil at different rates depending on the soil texture, what does this mean for the producer? (Could relate to fertiliser if students’ learning allows for it.) Spades. Compare profiles from a local profile with an area different to your own. Soil examples. Soil Texture by Feel Analysis Sheet. Experiment – determine different soils through soil texture analysis. Experiment – water permeability. Students could peer assess how effectively they were able to teach their peers. Chemical characteristics of soil. Understand the chemical characteristics of soil. Soil pH. Simple knowledge of soil pH. Soil as a reservoir for minerals. Simple knowledge of soil as a source of nutrients for plant growth. Biological characteristics of soil. Understand the biological characteristics of soil. Organic matter. Organic matter & its decomposition to humus. Value of organic matter & humus. Soil organisms. The role of soil organisms. Symbiotic associations, soil pathogens, & soil pests. The role of soil disinfection. Practical – Measuring pH of plots or gardens and soils from the local area. Students to gather information on plant nutrients: what they are and why the plant needs them. This could be done by using a “jigsaw” activity or other information-gathering techniques. Nutrient movement through soils activity. Put the question to the students: Why is soil pH and nutrient status important for the producer? (could relate to fertiliser if students learning allows for it) Remind students of their classification at the beginning of the unit: Ask them, what were the dead and living things they found? Carry out Berlese Funnel activity. Use this information to understand the role that soil organisms play in the soil. Relate this to your local area. What is organic matter and how does it become useful to plants? The role of soil organisms in producing humus. Class discussion around beneficial and harmful soil organisms. A power point showing images and asking questions could be used to stimulate this discussion. Soil pH practical. Berlese Funnel equipment. Images of soil organisms. Management practices Understand soil management practices and explain how they impact on plant growth. Possible learning experiences Divide the eight management practices between the class. Groups of students become responsible for being the teacher for their management practice. Time is given for them to research and prepare an activity for them to use with their peers. Learning stations: Where teacher-prepared material is set out and students work their way around stations gathering relevant information to answer questions. The following examples provide some alternative ideas for teachers to use. Students need to be aware of different techniques within each management practice. Discuss with students how the techniques will effect plant growth. Cultivation Teacher guided images of different cultivation practices that are carried out. Discuss each picture and answer the question, why the practice is used and how does it impact on plant growth? Drainage Role play activity involving students becoming sand, silt, clay particles and water molecules to show the movement of water through soil. Using this role play relate concepts to the impact on plant growth. Discuss with students what techniques are used to modify soil drainage, e.g. mole drains, subsoiler, tile drains, adding perlite. Irrigation Irrigation efficiency practical utilising different Assessing soil drainage practical. If using one of the possible learning experiences, students could self-assess how effectively they were able to teach their peers or gather relevant information. Revision The Big Picture incorporating the three big ideas is brought together as a group. techniques to apply water, e.g. visiting a local producer and comparing K-line, centre-pivot and sprinkler irrigation. Using this demonstration, students can discuss the implications on plant growth. By adding organic matter through composting or mulching Carry out a practical were students need to build a composting unit and investigate the rates of decomposition of different materials, e.g. grass, straw and peastraw. Effluent application Look at different production systems and how they deal with effluent, e.g. dairying. Fertiliser application Get in an expert speaker such as a Ravensdown representative and get them to explain the techniques for fertiliser application and impacts on plant growth through a question and answer session. Students should have prepared questions to ask. Lime application Carry out the flocculation experiment. Using this experiment, students can discuss the implications on plant growth. Crop rotation Design a crop rotation plan. Understand why crop management is carried out and make links to the design plan. In groups using a large concept map, students draw their understanding of the links and ideas throughout the topic. This is supported by the Agricultural and Horticultural concepts learnt throughout the unit. Design plan could be formatively assessed and feedback provided to students. Paper. Pens. Or a large white board. 4. Reflecting on the process We have taken a unit that was content -driven and involved a number of teacher-directed learning experiences, and changed it to put the responsibility back on the students. The process of implementing the New Zealand Curriculum has been time consuming, however it can be made easier by taking an existing unit and adapting it. The new revised unit is a student-focused unit that uses a variety of teaching strategies, enabling students to be confident, independent learners. Important things to think about: The big ideas you want students to get out of the unit. What type of resources you have available. There is no point planning activities you will have trouble facilitating e.g. a field trip to a centre-pivot. Finding the links with the New Zealand Curriculum, such as Vision and Principles; and also links with the forthcoming Agricultural and Horticultural Science Teaching and Learning Guidelines, e.g. rationale and learning objectives.