AUTOMATIC LINE CALCULATION PROGRAM THEORY FOR PASSENGER ROPEWAYS TESTING Introduction The calculation routines for the configuration of the ropes in the spans according to the different load conditions are mainly based on the theoretical principles described in the publication "Elementi di Progetto per Impianti a Fune ediz.1981" and in the report "Calcolo di una linea funiviaria bifune a più campate, con l'ausilio del calcolatore elettronico", by Prof. Pietro D'Armini. Calculation theory As we know, the balance configuration for a rope only subject to its own weight and to the tensions at the ends, is represented by a curve, called catenary curve, which may be shown on the Cartesian plane by the equation below: x eh e y h 2 x h x h cosh h h being defined as a catenary "parameter" . The fundamental properties of the catenary curve make it possible to obtain the relation expressing the tension value at any point along the rope, only as a function of the ordinate "y" and the unit weight "q" of the rope: T = q·y Particularly, at the vertex V in the catenary curve (cf. Figure 1) : H = q·h Wherein h is the ordinate for V, vertex of the catenary curve. Figure 1. Graphical representation of a rope length only subject to its own weight. Unladen rope between two ends (catenary). The calculation of the configuration of an unladen rope laid between two ends A and B, is obtained by taking into consideration the diagram in Figure 1. 1 Solution for the unladen span, considering: a) Known values : -L horizontal length of the span between the ends A and B - span difference in height between the ends A and B -q unit weight of the rope - Ta tension at the downstream end (=counterweight/2 for the 1° span) b) Unknown values : -S rope development between the ends A and B -f deflection at any point in the span - Tb tension of the rope at the upstream end - a rope mouth angle downstream from the span - b rope mouth angle upstream from the span c) Symbols: - Cos hyperbolic cosine - arctg arc cotangent - cos trigonometric cosine - tg trigonometric tangent The formulae used for the calculus of the unladen spans are the following: 1) we calculate yA = TA / q Δ L L 2 y A A arctg 2) we calculate h y A cos A L arcsen tg A h B arctg sen yB 3) we check h cos B yB - yA - < 0.001 (convergence) 4) if convergence has not been checked out, we must correct angle a, then, we can continue the iterative calculus from stage NR.2. 5) if convergence has been checked out, we find S = h · ( tg(B) - tg(A) ) TB = yB · q 6) in the end, we find the deflection of the generic abscissa "x" x y x h cos arcsen tg A y A h fx x yA L The application software makes use of the Excel functions for the solution of the above formulae and for the automatic seek of the calculus routine convergence (specific function “expression.GoalSeek(Goal, ChangingCell)”). 2 FLOW-CHART OF THE PROGRAM FOR THE AUTOMATIC CALCULATION OF THE SPAN WITH UNLADEN ROPE, WITH THE EXACT CATENARY CURVE FORMULAE Known Values Input - L Span horizontal length - span difference in height - q rope unit weight - Ta tension at the downstream end Ordinate calculus and angle of 1 tangency downstream from the rope yA = TA/q A = arctg(/L - L/(2·yA)) We calculate: 2 - h = yA·cos(A) - B = arctgsen(L/h+arcsen(tg A)) - yB = h/cos(B) 3 NO YB - yA - < 0.001 YES We calculate: - S = h· (tg(B)-tg(A)) - TB = yB·q 5 and the deflection of the generic abscissa x as to the downstream end A - yx = h·cos(x/h+arcsentg A)- yA - fx = x·/L- yA END 3 4 We correct angle a then we repeat the cycle Formulae used for the subsequent unladen spans Regarding the subsequent spans, the calculation method remains unchanged, provided that it is given the new value for the initial tension downstream from the new span to be tested (Ta). It is the result of the sum of the value Tb' of the previous span plus the rope-tower friction value. But, as the rope-tower friction value depends on pressure, and pressure depends on the rope tension and angle of deviation values, it is necessary to go on through subsequent iterations, according to the subsequent sequence: 1) as a first put and take technique, we put friction null Ta = Tb' of the previous span Ts = Ta ( Atp = 0 ) 2) we find, through the previous procedure, the downstream mouth angle a 3) we find the pressure value on the tower (b' and a being the rope mouth angles downstream and upstream from the tower) Ps = 2 * Ts * sen ( b' - a ) / 2 4) we find the rope-tower friction value At = * Ps being the friction coefficient 5) we compare the friction value At with the previous one Atp, then, we check that At - Atp < 0.01 6) it the put and take technique has not been checked out, we put Atp = At Ts = Tb' + At / (tension at tower middle) Ta = Ts + At / 2 And we repeat the sequence starting from item NR.2. 7) if the put and take technique has been checked out, we go on calculating the subsequent span. NB: The rope-tower friction coefficient is positive or negative depending on the direction of the rope, thus, for the carrying ropes the result is that: ) it is positive for the towers downstream from the carrier truck 2) it is negative for the towers upstream from the carrier truck 3) it is null in the case of end spans less than 20 m in length (relating to which it is assumed that the rope is not subject to such remarkable spring shifts to induce friction pressures). 4 FLOW-CHART OF THE PROGRAM FOR THE AUTOMATIC CALCULATION OF SPANS, WITH UNLADEN ROPE, SUBSEQUENT TO THE FIRST ONE Known values input - i span number - L span horizontal length - span difference in height - q rope unit weight - Ta tension at downstream end - Ts tension on the tower - rope-shoe friction coeff. 1 As a first approximation, we put the downstream tension equal to the tension Tb of the previous span: At = 0 TA = TB’(i-1) Ts = TA We find: with the PCS procedure 2 the concerned span, then, we find the downstream mouth angle a We find the pressure on the tower downstream from the span: 3 Ps = 2∙Ts∙sen((fB’-fA)/2) We find the friction value on the tower: At = ∙Ps 5 At-Atp < 0.01 4 NO YES Now, we can go on calculating 7 the subsequent spans by following the same criterium END 5 The friction value is stored, then, the tension values are 6 updated for the tower and downstream from the concerned span: - Atp = At - Ts = TB’+ At/2 - TA = Ts + At/2 Calculation of the laden span Referring to the typical ropeway span with load kept by the carrying rope and the counter rope, we take into consideration the balance condition for the forces at the load application point C, which is the point of convergence for load weight, tensions towards downstream and upstream from the carrying rope, tension of the carrying rope and tension of the counter rope. The test diagram is the following: cf. Figure 2 and Figure 3): Figure 2 Balance of forces in the single span with load P Where: P is the load weight; T1 is the carrying rope tension at the downstream tower; T2 is the downstream tension of the carrying rope; T3 is the upstream tension of the carrying rope; T4 is the tension of the carrying rope at the upstream tower; t1 is the tension of the hauling rope at the downstream tower; t2 is the tension of the counter rope at position C; t3 is the tension of the hauling rope at position C; t4 is the tension of the hauling rope at the downstream tower; 1 is the angle between the horizontal and tension t1 of the hauling rope; 2 is the angle between the horizontal and tension t2 of the counter rope; 3 is the angle between the horizontal and tension t3 of the hauling rope; 4 is the angle between the horizontal and tension t4 of the hauling rope. Here below, the graphical representation of the forces at the load application position is shown. 6 Figure 3 Polygon of the forces applied to position C Ignoring the slide friction of the load on the carrying rope, the balance equation is the following: T2cos 2 t2cosψ2 T3cos 3 t3cosψ3 T2 sen 2 P t2 senψ2 T3 sen 3 t3 senψ3 From which we can obtain the components of the tensile force on the carrier truck : t3cosψ3 T2 (cos 2 cos 3 ) t2 cosψ2 t3 senψ3 P T2 (sen 2 sen 3 ) t2 senψ2 dividing the second expression by the first one and summing up the squares make it possible to find the angle of tensile force of the hauling rope on the carrier truck and the value of the tension module in coincidence with the point where the carrying rope is fixed to the carrier truck: tgψ3 P T2 (sen 2 sen 3 ) t2 senψ2 N T2 (cos 2 cos 3 ) t2cosψ2 M t3 N 2 M 2 Also for the loaded span we must work by subsequent iterations according to the sequence below: 1) we find (by first put and take technique) q P L L f c p 1 2 l T1 2 Δ1 L1 2) we find 2 Δ fc L = 1 7 3) we find the two unladen half-spans near the load: - carrying rope half-span 1,L1,T1 - carrying rope half-span 2,L2,T3=T2 - counter rope span D1,L1,t1 we store T2,1 2,S1p we store T4,3,4,S2p we store t2,1,2,Sz 4) we find and store, with the balance equation: - ' 3 = N / M - t3 N2 M2 5) we find the half-span of the carrying rope upstream from the load: - carrying rope span D2,L2,t3 storing t4,3,4,St 6) we check that y3 - y'3= | 3 | < 0.001 7) in case of no check, we correct the value 1, then we restart from stage NR.2 8) if the check has been carried out, we find fc = L1 * / L - 1 (final) deflection on the load t = ( 2 + 3 ) / 2 course angle of the load Pt = P * sen(t) carrying rope component 8 FLOW-CHART OF THE PROGRAM FOR THE AUTOMATIC CALCULATION OF THE LADEN SPAN WITH THE EXACT FORMULAE OF THE CATENARY CURVE -L - - L1 - qp - qz - qt - T1 - t1 -P - Known values input span horizontal length span difference in height load distance from downstream unit weight of the carrying rope counter rope weight haul rope weight carrying rope tension downsrt. counter rope tension downstr. load weight on the carrying rope truck-rope friction coeff. Initially we find: L2 = L - L1 fc = (qp/2+P/L) ·L1·L2/T1 1 =L1·/L - fc 1 We find 21 2 Through the automatic calculation procedure, we find: 3 1) carrying rope half-span downstream from load 1,L1,T1 => T2,1,2,S1p 2) carrying rope half-span upstream from load D2,L2,T3=T2 => T4,3,4,S2p 3) counter rope half-span with 1,L1,t1 ==> t2,1,2,Sz We apply the balance equation of forces and we find: ψ3 arctg * P (1 μ sen( P μ cos 2 3 2 2 3 2 ) T2 (sen 2 sen 3 ) t2 senψ 2 T2 (cos 2 cos 3 ) t2 cosψ 2 t3 N 2 M 2 N M 4 Through the procedure PCS we find the carrying rope span with 2,L2,t3 And we get => t4,3,4,St 5 6 We check that NO 3-3*30.001 We correct the difference in height D1 then we repeat the cycle from item NR. 2 7 YES 9 Now we can find the deflection value in coincidence with load, load course angle and the component of tensile force of the hauling rope in coincidence with the point where the rope is fixed to the carrier truck. - fc = L1 . /L-1(final) - t = (2+3) / 2 - Pt = P . sent 8 END Line global test mode The line test is carried out by applying the above calculation principles to each single span. Calculation always starts from downstream and goes on towards upstream, considering the load at a certain position on the ascent branch, thus determining the corresponding position of the load on the descent branch. Carrying ropes: It is provided the case of carrying ropes anchored upstream and with counter weight downstream, or anchored at the two ends. 1) Ropes with counter weight downstream. In this case, we know the initial tension at the downstream end, therefore, all the unknown values may be found univocally. 2) Ropes anchored at the ends. In this case, the rope tension at the downstream end is not known, but we know the laying tension of the unladen ropes at a certain datum temperature. The problem may be solved by put and take technique, as follows: a) we assume that the initial tension in the rope at the downstream end is equal to the laying tension. b) we carry out the line calculation with the initial tension pre-set by defining the total development of the carrying rope regarding each one of the two branches. c) considering the mean tensions of the single spans obtained by line calculation and the temperature difference from the laying temperature, we find the new length of the carrying rope per each single branch, also considering that the temperature difference induces an elongation ’S=Sot and that the tension difference induces and elongation ' ' S S o T being: EA - So rope length at the laying tension and temperature - rope linear expansion coefficient - t thermal head - T tension difference - E the rope modulus of elasticity, A rope metallic section Thus, the new rope length will be Sm = So + ’S - ’’S to be compared with the result of the calculation obtained with pre-set downstream tension. d) If the difference between the two lengths is higher than the desired value (usually 0.001 m) we must suitably change the value for the initial downstream tension, then we repeat the cycle from B). Hauling ropes and counter ropes: The ropes are provided with counter weight, therefore, we can know the initial downstream tension value. In the case of counter weight upstream and power unit downstream, we go on by subsequent iterations so as to make converge the tension values to the counterweight known value. In the case of counterweight downstream and power unit upstream, the values for the initial tensions are immediately known. 10