Supplementary Table 1 Existing literature of radiological findings associated with Balό’s concentric sclerosis. Reference Spiegel M et al. (1989)1 Clinical characteristics and treatment Presentation: 39-year-old man with mental deficits, mild spastic tetraparesis, dysarthria, left central facial palsy and gait disturbances Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone Hanemann CO et al. (1993)2 Outcome: improved gait, facial palsy and mental deficit Presentation: 32-year-old woman with left hemiparesis, urinary retention, fatigue and mental slowing Conventional neuroimaging (T1weighted and T2-weighted) Initial imaging: multiple concentric white matter lesions consistent with BCS Diffusionweighted imaging (DWI) Not performed Magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) Not performed Not performed Not performed 6 months later: additional reduction in all lesions; no enhancement Initial imaging: multiple high Not performed signal foci with alternating low and high signal areas; one lesion enhanced Not performed 10 weeks later: reduction in the size and number of the lesions Initial imaging: hypointense concentric lesions in right frontal, left occipital and left centroparietal lobes Diagnosis: biopsy-proven BCS Treatment: intravenous dexamethasone followed by mitoxantrone Outcome: improvement in disability Revel MP et al. (1993)3 Presentation: 22-year-old woman with progressive left hemiparesis and right lateral gaze palsy Treatment: intravenous 6 weeks later: reduction in size of all lesions methylprednisolone followed by oral taper Revel MP et al. (1993)3 Outcome: mild left hemiparesis 6 months later Presentation: 27-year-old man with right hemiparesis and dysarthria Treatment: none Tersegno MM and Reich DR (1993)4 Outcome: spontaneous recovery within 10 days; right facial paresis 3 months later Presentation: 32-year-old woman with sudden left paresthesias Diagnosis: autopsy-proven BCS Treatment: steroids Gharagozloo et al. (1994)5 Outcome: clinical progression followed by death 1 year later Presentation: 32-year-old woman with progressive left hemiparesis hemiplegia, and left homonymous heminanopsia over 2 weeks Diagnosis: autopsy-confirmed BCS Treatment: intravenous steroids Initial imaging: periventricular white matter hyperintensities with concentric foci Not performed Not performed Initial imaging: large right parietal mass with concentric rings and peripheral enhancement Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed 8 months later: bilateral frontal lesions with concentric rings; atrophy in region of initial lesion Initial imaging: large right parietal lesion with mass effect and marginal enhancement Approximately 9 months later: multiple large lesions with concentric ring appearance Louboutin JP and Elie B (1995)6 Outcome: initial improvement followed by increasing weakness and apathy with relentless progression until death 1 year after symptom onset Presentation: 16-year-old boy with acute bilateral visual impairment, headache, ataxia, right hemisensory loss, alteration of consciousness, and vertigo Diagnosis: biopsy-proven BCS Treatment: intravenous prednisone (initially), followed by intravenous cyclophosphamide and ACTH (after worsening), followed by azathioprine (maintenance) Chen CJ et al. (1996)7 Outcome: mild improvement after steroids followed by worsening to include left hemiparesis; further improvement after cyclophosphamide and ACTH and sustained improvement after starting azathioprine Presentation: 27-year-old woman with rapidly progressive right hemiparesis Initial imaging: multiple white matter lesions of varying size with concentricity in a 3cm right frontal lesion Not performed Not performed Not performed 4 months later: all lesions smaller; concentric pattern still evident in right frontal lesion 16 months after presentation: loss of concentric pattern 2 years after presentation: one new lesion near right occipital horn Initial imaging: multiple concentric white matter lesions Diagnosis: biopsy-proven BCS Treatment: none Not performed 10 days later: bifrontal alternating isointense and hypointense or hyperintense Outcome: nearly complete recovery rings with partial after 3 months with no weakness after 1 enhancement year 20 days later: concentric lesion with partial enhancement in frontal lobe Chen CJ et al. (1996)8 Presentation: 54-year-old man with unsteady gait, progressing to hiccups, slurred speech and choking within 2 weeks 3 months later: marked resolution of all lesions Initial imaging: multiple round lesions in a concentric or mosaic pattern with mild rim enhancement Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Treatment: corticosteroids for 2 weeks Morioka C et al. (1996)9 Outcome: full recovery after 2 weeks of therapy; stable at 8 month follow-up Presentation: 22-year-old man with Initial imaging: concentric nausea and vomiting, bowel and patterns of low signal lesions bladder incontinence, quadriparesis, with enhancement and altered level of consciousness 3 weeks later: enlarged Treatment: glycerin (initially) followed lesions with presumed by prednisone (after second MRI) necrosis on T1-weighted MRI Outcome: normalization of function except for residual euphoria and severe 9 weeks later: regression of cognitive abnormalities at 3 weeks; hyperintensities with after treatment with steroids had mild concentric lesions cognitive dysfunction 16 weeks later: lesions were "remarkably" improved Sekijima Y et al. (1997)10 Presentation: 28-year-old woman with confusion and impaired level of consciousness, progressive gait disturbance, aphasia, right leg weakness, and right homonymous hemianopsia Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone then oral taper followed by plasmapheresis Outcome: marked improvement in symptoms; no further demyelinating events 3 years after onset of symptoms Kim MO et al. Presentation: 52-year-old woman with (1997)11 right hemiparesis 12 days after onset: multiple lesions with ‘fried egg’ appearance; no enhancement Outcome: gradual resolution of hemiparesis over 5 months; no further events after 17 months Not performed Not performed Initial: decrease in NAA:Cr ratio, increased Cho:Cr ratio, elevated lipid peak 21 days after onset: slight enlargement of existing lesions; some with enhancing concentric rings 53 days after onset: regression of lesions with no enhancement Initial imaging: multiple white matter lesions with marginal enhancement Diagnosis: biopsy-proven BCS Treatment: intravenous dexamethasone Not performed 14 days later: increased size of initial lesion 9 months later: Decreased lipid peak, increased myoinositol peak, no significant changes in NAA:Cr or Cho:Cr ratios Murakami Y et al. (1998)12 Presentation: 4-year-old boy with headaches, drowsiness, and right hemiparesis Initial imaging: concentric Not performed enhancing lesions in centrum semiovale and occipital lobes Treatment: intravenous dexamethasone 3 weeks later: non-enhancing hyperintensities in occipital lobe Outcome: complete resolution of symptoms in two weeks Singh S et al. (1999)13 Presentation: 45-year-old woman with cognitive decline, seizures and abnormal limb movements Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone and intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) followed by high-dose intravenous methylprednisolone and azathioprine Singh S et al. (1999)13 Outcome: slight improvement after 1 month, followed by slowly progressive worsening Presentation: 38-year-old man with alexia, aphasia and right hemiparesis Treatment: dexamethasone and plasmapheresis followed by oral steroids and azathioprine 6 months later: nonenhancing hyperintensities in occipital lobe Initial imaging: multiple concentric lamellar rings in left frontal, temporal and parietal lobes, with additional lesions in corpus callosum Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed 9 months later: reduction in lesion size and absence of concentric layers Initial imaging: left frontal lesion consisting of alternating concentric rings and surrounding edema with peripheral enhancement 6 weeks later: reduction in Ng SH et al. (1999)14 Outcome: mild cognitive recovery after treatment; no long-term follow-up reported Presentation: 56-year-old woman with right-sided weakness, dysarthria and gait abnormalities Treatment: oral prednisolone followed by slow taper Outcome: resolution of hemiparesis after 1 month; subsequent recurrence of right hand clumsiness Chen CJ et al. (1999)15 Presentation: 27-year-old woman with right hemiparesis and memory impairments Diagnosis: biopsy-proven BCS lesion size with persistent rings and widening of lamellae Initial imaging: left frontoparietal lesions with edema and concentric ring enhancement; right frontal subcortical lesion with concentric rings and enhancing lamellae Not performed 12 months later: persistence of concentric ring pattern in left frontoparietal cortex Initial imaging: Not performed frontoparietal lesions with concentric rings; outer two to three layers had incomplete enhancement Not performed Not performed Treatment: not reported Chen CJ et al. (1999)15 Outcome: no clinical relapse after 1 year Presentation: 56-year-old woman with right hemiparesis and dysphagia Diagnosis: biopsy-proven BCS Treatment: not reported Initial imaging: frontoparietal lesions with multiple lamellae that enhanced Not performed Not performed Chen CJ et al. (1999)15 Outcome: no clinical relapse after 1 year Presentation: 22-year-old man with tetraparesis and confusion Initial imaging: multiple concentric lesions with enhancement Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Treatment: not reported Outcome: no clinical relapse after 1 year Chen CJ et al. (1999)15 Presentation: 42-year-old man with left hemiparesis 2 weeks later: outward expansion of lesions with loss of internal enhancement but new peripheral enhancement Initial imaging: frontoparietal and temporal rings without enhancement Treatment: not reported Chen CJ et al. (1999)15 Outcome: no clinical relapse after 2 years Presentation: 33-year-old woman with left hemiplegia Treatment: not reported Outcome: no clinical relapse after 1 year Manelfe C et al. (1999)16 Presentation: 44-year-old man with rapid onset of cerebellar and ‘hemispheric’ symptoms and signs Treatment: mitoxantrone Initial imaging: frontoparietal lesions with enhancement of all layers except at the margins. 1 month later: new hypointensity in frontal lobe within one lesion Initial imaging: multifocal superficial and deep white matter lesions, some of which enhanced in a ringlike manner; rare gray matter Iannucci G et al. (2000)17 Outcome: improvement in the subsequent months without complete resolution (some remaining ataxia, arm incoordination, and memory and attention deficits) Presentation: 31-year-old with weakness Treatment: not reported Caracciolo JT et al. (2001)18 involvement (insula, caudate, putamen) Initial imaging: two lesions with alternating concentric rings with an intermediate ring that enhanced Outcome: not reported 4 months later: coalescence of lesion Presentation: 34-year-old woman with seizures and expressive aphasia Initial imaging: concentric demyelinating lesion in left frontal lobe with enhancing concentric rings Diagnosis: biopsy-proven BCS Initial imaging: Not performed diffusivity values (x 10-3 mm2/s): center, 1.234; inner ring, 1.295; intermediate ring, 1.099; outer ring, 1.146 Not performed Not performed Treatment: not reported Karaarslan E et al. (2001)19 Outcome: not reported Presentation: 52-year-old man with ataxia, left hemiparesis and confusion Diagnosis: biopsy-proven BCS Treatment: not reported Outcome: residual left hemiparesis and no further events after 3 years Initial imaging: concentric rings in right centrum semiovale with focal peripheral enhancement 13 months later: residual concentric lesion Not performed Not performed Karaarslan E et al. (2001)19 Presentation: 20-year-old woman with left hemiparesis Treatment: corticosteroids Karaarslan E et al. (2001)19 Outcome: no further relapses after 6 months Presentation: 48-year-old man with aphasia Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone Initial imaging: concentric rings adjacent to right lateral ventricle with prominent peripheral enhancement Not performed Not performed Initial imaging: multiple white matter lesions with an enhancing left concentric temporoparietal lesion Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Initial: increased Cho:Cr ratio, decreased NAA:Cr ratio; possibly increased lipid and lactate 1 month later: no new lesions Outcome: mild clinical improvement after 1 month Karaarslan E et al. (2001)19 Presentation: 38-year-old man with dysarthria, dysphagia and fatigue Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone Karaarslan E et al. (2001)19 Outcome: normal neurological examination after 4 years without further clinical events Presentation: 15-year-old woman with left hemiparesis Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone 4 years later: no new lesions; gliosis within old lesions Initial imaging: multiple white matter lesions with concentric enhancing pattern 3 weeks later: multiple concentric lesions with no enhancement Initial imaging: concentric lesion in right centrum semiovale Chen CJ et al. (2001)20 Outcome: improvement with no further events after 6 months Presentation: 37-year-old woman with right face and hand numbness and weakness peaks Initial imaging: frontoparietal lesions with marginal enhancement Not performed Initial: decreased NAA:Cr ratio, increased Cho:Cr ratio Treatment: not reported Not performed 7 months later: incomplete improvement Initial: decreased NAA:Cr ratio and increased Cho:Cr peak Not performed 14 months later: persistent abnormalities Initial: decreased NAA:Cr ratio, increased choline:Cr ratio Outcome: no further events at 8 months Chen CJ et al. (2001)20 Presentation: 56-year-old woman with progressive right hemiparesis and dysphagia Initial imaging: frontoparietal lesions with concentric ring enhancement Treatment: not reported Outcome: no further events at 1 year Chen CJ et al. (2001)20 Presentation: 42-year-old man with progressive left hemiparesis and concentration problems Initial imaging: frontoparietal and temporal lesions with no enhancement Treatment: not reported Outcome: no further events at 2 years Chen CJ et al. (2001)20 Presentation: 33-year-old woman with left hemiplegia Treatment: not reported Initial imaging: frontoparietal lesions with concentric rings and marginal enhancement Not performed 8 months later: incomplete improvement Decreased NAA/Cr ratio, increased choline/Cr peak Two months later: Kastrup O et al. (2002)21 Outcome: no further events at 1 year Presentation: 43-year-old man with inattention, memory deficits, and rightsided clumsiness Treatment: intravenous prednisolone Outcome: gradual improvement of symptoms Gu J et al. (2003)22 Presentation: 35-year-old man with left hemiparesis Treatment: repeated courses of intravenous dexamethasone Outcome: mild clinical improvement after first steroid course and nearly complete restoration of strength after second course of steroids Gu J et al. (2003)22 Presentation: 38-year-old woman with bifacial paresis, quadriplegia, apathy and seizures Initial imaging: right parietal lesion with concentric rings and mild surrounding edema; marked contrast enhancement of lamellae 4 weeks later: confluence of lesions with patchy enhancement Initial imaging: multiple concentric rings in right frontal, parietal and temporal lobes with no enhancement Not performed limited improvement Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed Not performed 1 month after symptoms: concentric rings remaining 3 years after presentation: small, non-specific, plaquelike lesion remained Initial imaging: concentric rings with no enhancement Treatment: corticosteroids Gu J et al. (2003)22 Outcome; death resulting from pulmonary embolism Presentation: 40-year-old man with subacute headaches and left Initial imaging: left frontoparietal concentric hemiparesis lesions with no enhancement Treatment: intravenous dexamethasone Pohl D et al. (2005)23 Outcome: significant improvement after therapy with no relapses after 2 years Presentation: 5-year-old girl with acute anomia and right hemianopsia after a viral illness; subsequent clinical decline over one month; evidence of human herpesvirus 6 acute seroconversion Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone and foscarnet; then high-dose steroids and foscarnet, followed by monthly intravenous IVIg (after further clinical deterioration 7 months later) Nagi S et al. (2005)24 Outcome: persistent hemianopsia after treatment but stable for 6 months, followed by further deterioration that improved markedly after IVIg Presentation: 22-year-old man with tetraparesis and horizontal diplopia Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone Outcome: no further relapses after 18 Initial imaging: multiple Not performed white matter lesions with one having ring-like enhancement Not performed 1 month later: striking enlargement of lesions with garland-like enhancement 7 months later: new right frontal lesion without enhancement 8 months later: enlargement of all lesions with garlandlike enhancement Initial imaging: bilateral concentric centrum semiovale lesions with lamellar enhancement Not performed Not performed Bruneteau G et al. (2005)25 months Presentation: 28-year-old man with right hemiparesis and hypoesthesia Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone followed by oral steroid taper Outcome: improvement of symptoms: at 6 months only hyperreflexia and mild spasticity remained Airas L et al. (2005)26 Presentation: 23-year-old pregnant woman with blurry vision, alexia and visuospatial disturbance, followed 1 month later by right homonymous hemianopsia, memory disturbance and right leg paresthesias Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone followed by plasma exchange (five exchanges) Outcome: partial resolution of symptoms, followed by relapse consisting of gait ataxia, leg paresthesias, weakness, and right asteroagnosia and homonymous hemianopsia. 4 months after initial onset: improvement in all deficits after Initial imaging: left frontoparietal lesion with concentric enhancement 1 month later: reduction in size of lesion with no enhancement 6 months later: unchanged from 1 month Initial imaging: bilateral confluent parieto-occipital white matter and splenium lesions with laminar pattern and partially-laminar enhancement; multiple small multiple sclerosis-like lesions 1 month later: lesions reduced in size 4 months later: new lesions in the superior parietal white matter with ring-like enhancement Not performed Initial: decreased NAA:Cr ratio, increased Cho:Cr ratio, elevated lactate and lipid peaks 6 months later: decreased Cho:Cr peak, absent lactate peak, elevated myoinositol, NAA peak still low 1 month after onset: 4 months after onset: no diffusion “active biochemical restriction changes associated with active 4 months after demyelination” onset: facilitated diffusion in enhancing regions Wiendl H et al. (2005)27 plasma exchange Presentation: 28-year-old woman with right hemiparesis and hypoesthesia Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone Outcome: improvement, but mild residual right hemiparesis, spasticity and hyperreflexia at 6 months Kavanagh EC et al. (2006)28 Presentation: 45-year-old woman with dysarthria and right upper extremity weakness Initial imaging: nonenhancing left centrum semiovale lesions 14 days later: enhancing left centrum semiovale lesions 10 weeks later: hyperintensity remained; no enhancement Initial imaging: left posterior corona radiata lesion with concentric enhancing rings Initial imaging: severe restriction of diffusion in left centrum semiovale Not performed 14 days later: enlargement of restricted diffusion lesion 10 weeks later: no restricted diffusion Initial imaging: restricted diffusion in outer ring Not performed Treatment: oral steroids Anschel DL (2006)29 Outcome: improvement of symptoms after steroids Presentation: 32-year-old man with left-sided tingling followed by gait disturbance and left upper extremity weakness Initial imaging: multiple T2 hyperintensities in brain and spine; two brain lesions with lamellar appearance and a ring of enhancement Initial imaging: no restricted diffusion Not performed Initial imaging: right periventricular Initial imaging: restricted diffusion 2 weeks after presentation: normal Treatment: not reported Mowry EM et al. (2007)30 Outcome: not reported Presentation: 37-year-old woman who presented with acute left-sided weakness and numbness in a ring around a nidus of facilitated diffusion Cho peak, decreased NAA peak, elevated lactate peak 2 weeks later: concentric Outcome: nearly complete resolution of rings of hyperintensity with symptoms without new clinical events patchy enhancement after 3 years 3 months after presentation: disorganization of concentric ring with new edema surrounding the lesion; less enhancement than before 2 weeks later: band of restricted diffusion surrounding nidus of facilitated diffusion; decreased perfusion around the lesion (contrast perfusion study) 5 months after presentation: further decrease in NAA peak, less prominent lactate doublet peak, mild increase in Cho peak 5 months after presentation: reduced lesion size with less enhancement 3 months after presentation: facilitated diffusion in region that previously had restricted diffusion; thin rim of diffusion restriction remaining at the periphery Treatment: intravenous methylprednisolone hyperintensity with rings and faint hyperintensities before and after contrast 7 months after presentation: continued reduction in lesion size Additional imaging (up to 3 years after presentation): no new lesions 7 months after presentation: continued decrease in NAA peak with slight increase in Cho peak and only a small lactate peak 5 months after presentation: no restricted diffusion Abbreviations: BCS, Balo’s concentric sclerosis; ACTH, adrenocorticotropic hormone; NAA, N-acetylaspartate; Cr, creatine; Cho, choline; IVIg, intravenous immunoglobulin. References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. Spiegel M et al. (1989) MRI study of Balό's concentric sclerosis before and after immunosuppressive therapy. J Neurol 236: 487–488 Hanemann CO et al. (1993) Balό's concentric sclerosis followed by MRI and positron emission tomography. Neuroradiology 35: 578–580 Revel MP et al. (1993) Concentric MR patterns in multiple sclerosis. Report of two cases. J Neuroradiol 20: 252–257 Tersegno MM and Reich DR. (1993) Balό’s concentric sclerosis: a rare form of multiple sclerosis manifested as a dominant cerebral mass without other white matter lesions on MR. AJR Am J Roentgenol 160: 901 Gharagozloo AM et al. (1994) Antemortem diagnosis of Balό concentric sclerosis: correlative MR imaging and pathologic features. Radiology 191: 817–819 Louboutin JP and Elie B (1995) Treatment of Balό’s concentric sclerosis with immunosuppressive drugs followed by multimodality evoked potentials and MRI. Muscle Nerve 18: 1478–1480 Chen CJ et al. (1996) Serial MRI studies in pathologically verified Balό's concentric sclerosis. J Comput Assist Tomogr 20: 732–735 Chen CJ et al. (1996) Balό's concentric sclerosis: MRI. Neuroradiology 38: 322–324 Morioka C et al. (1996) Higher cerebral dysfunction in a case with atypical multiple sclerosis with concentric lesions. Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 50: 41–44 Sekijima Y et al. (1997) Serial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) study of a patient with Balό's concentric sclerosis treated with immunoadsorption plasmapheresis. Mult Scler 2: 291–294 Kim MO et al. (1997) Balό's concentric sclerosis: a clinical case study of brain MRI, biopsy, and proton magnetic resonance spectroscopic findings. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 62: 655–658 Murakami Y et al. (1998) Balό's concentric sclerosis in a 4-year-old Japanese infant. Brain Dev 20: 250–252 Singh S et al. (1999) Balό's concentric sclerosis: value of magnetic resonance imaging in diagnosis. Australas Radiol 43: 400– 404 Ng SH et al. (1999) MRI features of Balό's concentric sclerosis. Br J Radiol 72: 400–403 Chen CJ et al. (1999) Serial magnetic resonance imaging in patients with Balό's concentric sclerosis: natural history of lesion development. Ann Neurol 46: 651–656 Manelfe C et al. (1999). Case no. 1. Diagnosis: Balό concentric sclerosis. Journees Francaises de Radiologie 80: 1700–1702 Iannucci G et al. (2000) Vanishing Balό-like lesions in multiple sclerosis. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 69: 399–400 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. Caracciolo JT et al. (2001) Pathognomonic MR imaging findings in Balό concentric sclerosis. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 22: 292–293 Karaarslan E et al. (2001) Balό's concentric sclerosis: clinical and radiologic features of five cases. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 22: 1362–1367 Chen CJ (2001) Serial proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy in lesions of Balό concentric sclerosis. J Comput Assist Tomogr 25: 713–718 Kastrup O et al. (2002) Balό's concentric sclerosis. Evolution of active demyelination demonstrated by serial contrastenhanced MRI. J Neurol 249: 811–814 Gu J et al. (2003) Concentric sclerosis: imaging diagnosis and clinical analysis of 3 cases. Neurol India 51: 528–530 Pohl D et al. (2005) Balό's concentric sclerosis associated with primary human herpesvirus 6 infection. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 76: 1723–1725 Nagi S et al. (2005) Balό's concentric sclerosis in a North-African patient [French]. Rev Neurol (Paris) 161: 78–80 Bruneteau G et al. (2005) Contribution of proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy to the diagnosis of Balό's concentric sclerosis [French]. Rev Neurol (Paris) 161: 455–458 Airas L et al. (2005) Successful pregnancy of a patient with Balό’s concentric sclerosis. Mult Scler 11: 346–348 Wiendl H et al. (2005) Diffusion abnormality in Balό's concentric sclerosis: clues for the pathogenesis. Eur Neurol 53: 42–44 Kavanagh EC et al. (2006) Diffusion-weighted imaging findings in Balό concentric sclerosis. Br J Radiol 79: e28–e31 Anschel DJ (2006) Reply to the paper by Wiendl et al.: diffusion abnormality in Balό's concentric sclerosis: clues for the pathogenesis. Eur Neurol 55: 111–112 Mowry EM et al.: Balό's concentric sclerosis that presented as a stroke-like syndrome. Nat Clin Pract Neurol, in press