CHCPR509A: Document, interpret and use information about children Monitor children’s developmental progress and develop understanding of individual children Contents Use observations and information to assess and monitor child’s play preferences, social interactions, communication and language, thinking styles, physical abilities and emotional status Use observations to assess and monitor 3 Sociocultural approaches to documentation 4 Interpret information and observations to identify individual emerging skills, capabilities, potential, interests, preferences of child to guide program strategies to foster development Interpretations 7 7 Decoding 11 Monitor and interpret behaviour that is out of character for an individual child and respond appropriately Monitor and interpret behaviour Demonstrate understanding and application of inclusive principles in interpreting observations Inclusive principles and understanding 2 3 14 14 15 15 Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 Use observations and information to assess and monitor child’s play preferences, social interactions, communication and language, thinking styles, physical abilities and emotional status Use observations to assess and monitor Observations can be used to assess and monitor the child's play preferences, social interactions, communication and language, thinking styles, physical abilities and emotional status. Observing children at play A great time to observe children is when they are engaged in play. From babies through to primary-aged children, observing children at play gives us a wealth of information about the child’s development, strengths, emerging skills and interests. When observing play we can see: • • • • what children do and say the toys and equipment they use the skills they are developing what is influencing or triggering aspects of the play Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 3 • • • • problem solving as the play develops imitation, collaboration and negotiation during play social relationships and friendships and much, much more. Of course, children play in different ways at different stages of their development. These differences in play reflect changes in the child’s overall development— particularly their thinking and social skills. For example, the dramatic play of preschoolers and primary-aged children is often very involved and tells us a lot about the children’s understanding of the world in general as well as peer relations, social roles and appropriate behaviour. When observing babies, special note should be made of their developing fine and gross motor skills, their evolving attachment relationships and growing interest in other babies and children. When observing school-aged children, focusing on the child’s leisure and recreational choices and pursuits often reveals important information. Sociocultural approaches to documentation So far we have looked at observation methods that focus on an individual child and their development. There are other methods that reflect a sociocultural approach and aim to paint a picture of children in the context of their influences and relationships. Sociocultural methods attempt to avoid studying the child in isolation and instead aim to capture interpersonal relationships, learning influences and cultural and institutional contexts. They aim to look at our interdependence as humans rather than independence (Fleer and Richardson, 2004). The following excerpts from a preschool profile are rating scales that refect a sociocultural approach by applying Vygotsky’s theory of the 'zone of proximal development' (ZPD) to a preschooler’s level of literacy and numeracy (Fleer and Richardson, 2004). The three columns in the rating scale indicate where the child is in the ZPD by looking at how much assistance from others is needed. 4 Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 Profile of print literacy awareness and understanding (excerpt) Shows awareness of the print literacy they see in their home In child’s first language Shows awareness that printed texts are read from left to right and from top to bottom In child’s first language Can recognise own printed name In child’s first language WITH ADULT/PEER JOINTLY CHILD TAKES SUPPORT AND UNDERTAKEN BY LEADERSHIP AND/OR MINIMAL CHILD CHILD AND WORKS INPUT ADULT/PEER INDEPENDENTLY (MODELLED) (SHARED) (INDEPENDENT) WITH ADULT/PEER JOINTLY CHILD TAKES SUPPORT AND UNDERTAKEN BY LEADERSHIP AND/OR MINIMAL CHILD CHILD AND WORKS INPUT (MODELLED) ADULT/PEER INDEPENDENTLY (SHARED) (INDEPENDENT) In English In English In English Can write some letters In child’s first language In English Profile of numeracy awareness and understanding (excerpt) Demonstrates an understanding of time In child’s first language In English Demonstrates an understanding of number In child’s first language In English Recognises and In child’s Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 5 uses symbols appropriately first language In English Can group things together In child’s first language In English (Adapted from Fleer and Richardson, 2004, pp 21–22) Rating scales such as these do not look at the child’s acquisition of skills in isolation. They acknowledge the influence of social interactions on learning and development and the interdependence of humans. 6 Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 Interpret information and observations to identify individual emerging skills, capabilities, potential, interests, preferences of child to guide program strategies to foster development Interpretations It is important to remember that the main purpose of observing and interpreting is to get to know each unique child in depth and to learn more about the relationships, play and interactions in groups of children. We need to be alert to what the observations tell us about the children's interests, perspectives, capabilities and individual characteristics. Observations and interpretations do not have to be lengthy to be worthwhile. By this stage in your training you should be aiming to record shorter observations and interpretations that focus on significant behaviour and child characteristics. Look at the following observation. In the left-hand column is recorded what I saw Lyle do in a short period of time. As much as possible, I have tried to be objective and to record actual behaviours rather than impressions. The sentences in bold type are the ones I have interpreted. In the right-hand column and in the evaluation below I have tried to draw out meaningful information from this observation. This information can be used later to help with planning and evaluating the program in a service. Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 7 Running record Name: Lyle Setting: Toddler room, Indoor Play Age: 17 months Date: 24.2.05 Observation Lyle has both of his hands on the back of a small chair pushing it from behind, along the Playroom floor for 2 metres. The chair reaches the strip separating the lino from the carpet. L pushes the chair but it will not go over. He brings back the chair and tries to push it again. He tries a third time. L goes to the front of the chair. He bends over and picks up the whole chair, turns around 180 degrees so that the back of the chair is now next to the bump. He places the chair back on the ground, reaches for the top of the chair with his left hand and drags the chair across the bump for several metres. Interpretation Is able to manipulate large objects in efficient manner – push objects Repeats behaviour 3 times. Lyle is persistent in reaching his goal. Using trial and error – solves problem in a different way from first attempt – experimentation. Demonstrating aspects of Piaget's theory – substage 5 of Sensorimotor stage Lifts large objects without overbalancing Can also pull large objects across floor In the left-hand column I have observed the child's behaviours. This column should be based on what I saw when I observed the child. It should be nonjudgmental, clear and accurate. In the right-hand column I have interpreted the observation based on what I saw. I have tried to apply my understanding of child development and have also looked out for individual capabilities and qualities in Lyle. Even in such a short, everyday incident the individuality of each child shows through. Above are three of the four parts that make up a complete Running record: 1 2 3 the information about the child the actual observation my interpretation of the events. Now summarise or evaluate this information. To do this, put all the comments in the interpretation column into a more readable format. You can then form the evaluation. Evaluation Lyle is able to push and pull objects along the floor. He can also lift large objects and manoeuvre them without overbalancing. On previous 8 Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 occasions when Lyle reached the 'bump' he would start to yell until a caregiver came over to help him. In this observation he has shown signs of being in Piaget's substage 5 of the Sensorimotor period, by using trial and error to solve a problem (Nixon and Gould, 1999). He is showing indications of developing persistence in achieving his goals as he learns to problem-solve. Lyle is also showing an interest in exploring his environment in novel ways by using the chair as a part of his explorations. Let’s see how the same event would look if it were recorded and interpreted later from memory in an Anecdotal record. Anecdotal record Name: Lyle Setting: Toddler room, Indoor Play Age: 17 months Date: 24.2.05 Observation Interpretation/Evaluation Lyle was pushing a child-sized chair along the Playroom floor. When he came to the 'bump' between the lino and the carpet, he continued to push the chair. It wouldn't go over the bump. He tried a couple of times. He then lifted the chair up, turned it around and dragged it across the bump onto the carpet for several metres. Lyle is able to push and pull objects along the floor. He can also lift large objects and manoeuvre them without overbalancing. On previous occasions when Lyle reached the 'bump' he would start to yell until a caregiver came over to help him. In this observation he has shown signs of being in Piaget's substage 5 of the Sensorimotor period, by using trial and error to solve a problem (Nixon and Gould, 1999). He is showing indications of developing persistence in achieving his goals as he learns to problem-solve. Lyle is also showing an interest in exploring his environment in novel ways, by using the chair as a part of his explorations. You can see that it is very similar except the observation has been written after the event in much briefer terms. It has, however, been decoded it and arrived at similar conclusions. In the above interpretation/evaluation I have also linked the new information from this observation to other information about this child ('On previous occasions when Lyle reached the 'bump' he would start to yell until a caregiver came over to help him'). I am not just looking at this child through this short narrative recording—this would be too limiting. Instead I am trying to make meaningful connections between information gathered at different times in order to better understand him. Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 9 Let’s recap what we should be looking for when interpreting our observations of children. We are looking for evidence or indications of: • • • • • • • • a child’s individuality a child’s interests a child’s emerging skills a child’s thinking or perspectives a child’s particular expertise or strengths a milestone reached unusual or unexpected behaviour for this child a need for practice, experience or assistance. If you would like to read more about interpretation, go to Martin (2004) Take a Look, pages 17–20 (see Additional resources) and read her ‘Plan to Assist the Analysis of an Observation’. Martin uses the term analysing rather than interpreting. She offers some useful guiding questions for interpreting or analysing the information in observations in this section of the book. Activity 1 Activity 2 Interpretations based on photographs Written records are not the only kind of information about children we can interpret. You can gather information from a range of sources, not just from written records. Try practicing writing interpretations based on photographs and work samples. Look at the following series of photos and write your evaluation of this toddler. What do you know about her from the photos? What is she interested in? 10 Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 Screen dumps of Elizabeth Activity 3 Activity 4 A good way to record your interpretation or analysis is to structure the information into each of the developmental domains. Most people find it useful to include a section for 'interests' too. Decoding One process used in analysis is called decoding. In decoding we attempt to identify developmental information about the child. You may choose to decode each observation immediately after you complete it or you may want to decode when you have a collection of observation material and you are ready to summarise the child’s development to that point. Generally this type of detailed Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 11 analysis is used with narrative observations such as anecdotes and running records. Here are some suggestions of what to look for when decoding: • • • • • physical development, for example physical description of the child, health and fitness, general characteristics of activities, large and small muscular coordination, eating, dressing, toileting, rest social development, for example attitude towards other children, main attachments to others, ability to lead and follow, special friends, social techniques used with other children (sharing, cooperation, etc) and attitude towards adults, regular carers, student teachers, visitors) cognitive and language development, for example attention span and persistence, reasoning and problem solving, comprehension, abstract concepts, memory, imagination, receptive and expressive language and vocabulary, ability to express needs and ideas emotional development, for example adjustment to change and new situations, ability to control emotions, expression of anger, fear, affection, joy and pleasure, spontaneity, reactions to guidance – testing, resistance, temper outbursts, etc interests, for example activities preferred, favourite toys, ideas expressed in play, interest in stories and books, use of art materials, interest in music, experiences in science and other areas. Here is an example of decoding a running record. Child’s name: Rajinder Age: 1.4 Date: 23/08/05 Setting: In the kitchen with his grandmother, father, mother, Sukhadeep (sister 4) Mena (cousin 5) and observer present. Time: 8.00 – 8.05 pm Observation 8.00 Rajinder is near the birdcage when he hears the dog barking in the kitchen (1). He crawls in on his hands and knees. He stands up and moves to a chair (2). His father calls him, ‘Come here, Rajinder’. Rajinder ignores his father (3) and toddles (4) off to a kitchen cupboard, (5) where there are utensils hanging on the wall. He tentatively touches one (6) and it moves. He jabbers to it (7) and pushes it. He pulls the utensil, seemingly to try to get it off its hook (8). He finally leaves it (9) and toddles over to the table. Grandmother gives him a biscuit, which he takes in his left hand saying, ‘Ta’ without being prompted (10). Dropping his biscuit, he bends down to pick it up with his left hand (11). Rajinder 12 Decoding 1 Auditory perception—location of sound 2 Motor skills—crawls, stands from prone position, needs no support 3 Father not the focus at present, environment too interesting 4 Locomotion balance still uncertain 5 Exploring skills 6 Reaching, hand-eye coordination 7 Language still babbling but has purpose in communication 8 Piaget’s tertiary circular reactions trial and error process problem solving 9 Attention span short (15 sec) Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 then begins to blow bubbles, laughing and chortling. His laugh is high-pitched (12). Sukhadeep calls him, ‘Rajinder’. He turns his body towards her and gabbles away (13). Seeing something on the floor, he drops to a prone position and crawls after it (14). It is a piece of cellophane, which he picks up with thumb and index finger of left hand (15). He crumples the paper, laughing at the sound (16). His mother takes it from him. He is not concerned by this loss and does not look for the lost plaything (17). Picking up an empty ice-cream container with two hands, he drops it to the floor several times (18). Then, putting it on his head, he toddles across to his father, laughing (19). His stance when walking is inclined forward, feet slightly splayed and arms hanging loosely. He tends to run, as if he is afraid he will fall (20). 10 Primitive knowledge of social role 11 Hand-eye coordination; fine motor control, gross motor—can stoop from standing; using left hand 12 Non-verbal communication 13 Recognises his name and answers nonverbally 14 Curiosity—crawls to desired object 15 Fine motor—using pincer grasp and left hand 16 Pleasure in sounds 17 Accepts removal of the toy—can use alternatives 18 Repetitive behaviour for its own sake 19 Pretending it is a hat?—beginnings of pretend play 20 Not yet walking confidently Sometimes an observer will classify the decoding as it is recorded, deciding which developmental domain each specific decoding relates to. One way to do this is to use a colour code for each developmental area or perhaps a number code that identifies the relevant developmental domain. It is a lengthy process but it can yield a great deal of detail-rich information about all areas of the child’s development and interests and makes it easier to group all the information quickly. Activity 5 In this example you can see that the observation has mainly illustrated knowledge about Melanie’s social and emotional development. If Voula put this knowledge into context with the other observations in Melanie’s portfolio she would be able to plan strategies and opportunities to enhance Melanie’s social and emotional development. Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 13 Monitor and interpret behaviour that is out of character for an individual child and respond appropriately Monitor and interpret behaviour Annelise is a well-settled child who normally engages enthusiastically in the centre program and routines and plays happily with a stable group of children her age. Lately, however, our observations reflect significant changes in her behaviour. She is sometimes reluctant to let her mother leave in the morning and spends a lot of time staying close to caregivers, ‘helping’ them with routine tasks and only briefly engaging in play experiences with other children. Annelise’s behaviour has changed markedly and no-one at the centre knows why. There are many different reasons why her behaviour may have changed. Activity 6 It is important in these circumstances that changes in behaviour are noted so that caregivers can devise strategies to find out the reasons for these changes and can plan appropriately for the child. Activity 7 14 Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 Demonstrate understanding and application of inclusive principles in interpreting observations Inclusive principles and understanding 'Tom is such an academic child, he loves to sit and read books and complete puzzles and never wants to run and play outside with the other boys. But as he is Filipino this is to be expected, as Asian children are never interested in gross motor play.' 'Alison is very aware of her appearance and only engages in activities that will not spoil her beautiful clothes. She needs a program that allows her to continue playing with dolls and strollers while maintaining her immaculate standards of dress.' 'Bernie is a rather shy, uncertain child. This is because he has same-sex parents and his mothers are lesbians.' Activity 8 These stereotypical views are likely to lead to poor understanding of these children and inadequate programming for them. There are many other reasons why they may display the preferences and behaviours summarised in these statements and there are many other strategies that could be explored with them. Stereotypical views of children limit our vision for planning. We do need to understand the family and cultural context of each child but we need a full, informed understanding, not a narrow, stereotypical view based on preconceptions about family, culture and gender. Children don't come to you without a past or a context. The family they belong to, the family’s cultural background and the community and society they live in influences them. For young children the most significant influence is their family. Parents are also a wonderful source of information about their children, as we discussed earlier, and they are usually happy to be asked about their children! Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 15 Situational analysis A situational analysis (sometimes known as an environmental analysis) is a method of gathering information about the total environment that surrounds and influences the children, caregivers and families in a service. It provides a way for you to become quickly familiar with the service and the people that use and influence the service, in order to plan effectively for the children that attend. Developing a situational analysis for a service is another way of gathering information about the children in your service. It focuses on the wider perspective of the context they live in and are developing in. It discourages us from looking at the child in isolation. It highlights the interconnected layers of family, neighbourhood, services, culture and beliefs that surround a child and play a part in their development. These layers impact on the child, and the child too has an influence on them. In this sense it is a type of observation or information gathering, and it is one that both informs you about the children in your care and informs your planning for them. The list below contains headings and guiding questions needed to develop a situational analysis. When we do a situational analysis we need to find out about the community in which the service is situated. The community: we need to find out the: • • • • • • language and cultural groups in the community available resources in the community values and beliefs in the community types of workplaces and jobs available in the community interests and leisure pursuits of the community members socioeconomic groups in the community. The service: we need to find out situational factors in the service itself, factors such as: • • • • • the management model used (ie privately owned and run, council run, community based, etc) staff qualifications, hours, special roles equipment and resources available, building type philosophy, goals and policy of the service regulations, funding, accreditation requirements. The children: we also need to find out about the children themselves—details such as: • • • 16 their home language and cultural backgrounds their interests and experiences their developmental stages, and their developmental emerging skills and strengths Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 • • how the children are grouped (eg peer grouping, mixed-age grouping, small developmental groups, etc) in the service friendship groups and kinship groups among the children. The above guiding questions are adapted from Arthur et al (1996) Programming and Planning in Early Childhood Settings (2nd edn), Harcourt and Brace, Australia. You can read more about conducting a situational analysis in this textbook. Activity 9 Diploma of Children’s Services: CHCPR509A: Reader LO 9392 © NSW DET 2010 17