Hot White Dwarfs
M. A. Barstow1 and K. Werner2
1
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Leicester, University Road, Leicester, LE1 7RH, UK
Kepler Center for Astro and Particle Physics, University of Tübingen, Sand 1, 72076 Tübingen, Germany
2
INTRODUCTION
Theoretical and observational study of stellar behaviour has provided white dwarfs with their evolutionary
context as one end point of the life-cycle of stars. In general terms, all stars with masses below about eight
times that of the Sun will pass through one or more red giant phases before losing most of their original
mass to form a planetary nebula. These earlier phases of evolution, dealing with the white dwarf progenitors
have been discussed extensively by Herwig1. This paper discusses the phases of evolution immediately
following, when the white dwarf first emerges from these as a hot, but more or less dead object. Quite when
all nuclear burning ceases is still the subject of some debate, but it is certainly extinguished early in the
lifetime of a white dwarf, unless the star is able to accrete material from a companion in sufficient quantities
to restart the fusion process. Here we mostly only consider isolated objects, as binary systems containing
white dwarf components are dealt with in detail by other articles in this volume.
In the absence of any internal source of energy, the temperature of a white dwarf, after its birth, is
determined by how rapidly stored heat is radiated into space. Over time, white dwarfs will cool to
invisibility, a process taking billions of years. Hence, white dwarfs are among the oldest objects in the
galaxy. Since, the galaxy is younger than the cooling timescales; the lowest temperature (oldest) white
dwarfs yield a lower limit to its age (Garcia-Berro & Oswalt2). Although modified by processes other than
thermal radiation, such as neutrino cooling and phase changes in the internal structure, white dwarf cooling
curves follow a quasi-exponential function. Hence, the temperature changes most rapidly when the star is
young and hot. Consequently, we would also expect to see the most rapid evolution during this time. As a
consequence, study of hot white dwarfs is of great importance in revealing the underlying physical
processes.
So, just what is a “hot white dwarf”? In this chapter we will deal with white dwarfs from their formation
at temperatures ~200,000K down to ~10,000K, encompassing the first ~1 billion years of evolution
(depending on the stellar mass). In this temperature range the main observational signature of a white dwarf
is largely determined by the principle photospheric component, either H or He (usually). At lower
temperatures, below ~10,000K, even if present, the signatures of H and He become difficult and eventually
impossible to detect. The physics of the atmospheres of these cooler objects is quite different, and
understanding their compositions and physical structure is even more complex than for their hotter
counterparts3.
The small radius and consequent low luminosity of white dwarfs has made them difficult to observe in
detail. Hence, this original framework of their properties and astrophysical importance owed much more to
theory than observation. Important physical characteristics such as temperature and surface gravity could, at
first, only be based on broadband visual colours. During the past 25 years, there has been a revolution in
astronomical observation techniques. The advent of electronic detectors and improvements in sensitivity of
ground-based telescopes has been matched by the opening of ultraviolet, extreme ultraviolet and X-ray
wave bands by satellite-borne observatories, which are of particular importance for study of hot white
dwarfs.
A direct result of this has been a remarkable transformation in our observational knowledge concerning
white dwarfs and major advances in our understanding of their physical characteristics and evolution. This
review concentrates on some of the most important recent work contributing to studies of the white dwarf
mass-radius relation and white dwarf composition from ultraviolet observations. Particular reference will be
paid to measurements of temperature, surface gravity and composition, using spectroscopic data from a
variety of wavelength ranges. The importance of Teff and log g, determined for an individual white dwarf, in
1
estimating of mass and radius will be described, and the dependence of such determinations on theoretical
calculations of the mass-radius relation discussed.
1 CLASSIFICATION OF HOT WHITE DWARFS
The basis for understanding the nature of most stars is analysis of their optical spectra and classification
according to the characteristics revealed. A number of physical processes can alter the atmospheric
composition of a white dwarf as it cools. As noted by Schatzman4, the strong gravitational field (log g ~ 8 at
the surface) causes rapid downward diffusion of elements heavier than the principal H or He component.
Hence, Schatzman predicted that white dwarf atmospheres should be extremely pure. Consequently, the
spectra should be devoid of most elements, showing signatures of only hydrogen and, possibly, helium.
White dwarfs are thus divided into two main groups according to whether or not their spectra are dominated
by one or other of these elements. The hydrogen-rich stars are given the classification DA, while the
helium-rich white dwarfs are designated DO if He II features are present (hotter than about 45000K) and
DB if only He I lines are visible. Small numbers of hybrid stars exist, with both hydrogen and helium
present. In these cases, two classification letters are used, with the first indicating the dominant species. For
example, DAO white dwarfs are mostly hydrogen but exhibit weak He II features. There is also the
important group of the PG1159 type [WC] central stars, exhibiting strong C IV and He II lines in the optical
and which are believed to the progenitors of the DO white dwarfs.
The above classification scheme applies only to white dwarfs with temperatures above ~10000K, the hot
white dwarfs with we are concerned in this chapter, when the H and He energy levels are sufficiently
populated above the ground state to produce detectable features. However, at lower temperatures, although
H and/or He may be present these elements are no longer directly detectable. Figure 1 summarises the
current thoughts regarding the relationships between the hot white dwarf groups along with the principal
mechanisms that provide evolutionary routes between them.
However, the gravitational force can be countered by that of radiation pressure which acts outward to
support heavy elements in the atmosphere, a process termed “radiative levitation”. Another mechanism that
can mix elements that have settled out in the stellar atmosphere is convection. If the convective zone
reaches down to the base of the atmosphere then heavy elements can be dredged back up into the outer
atmosphere. A further complication is that material can also be accreted from the interstellar medium
(ISM).
The emergence from the Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) of two main white dwarfs channels, whose
compositions are dominated by H or He, is beginning to be understood in relation to mass-loss processes
and the number of times a star ascends the giant branch. However a demonstrable temperature gap in the
He-rich cooling sequence, between the DO and DB groups, is problematic. Until recently, the temperature
range from ~45,000K down to 30,000K was completely devoid of He-rich objects. However, a large
increase, from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, in the overall numbers of white dwarfs known has provided a
few such stars in this temperature range. Nevertheless, the reason for the dearth of objects remains to be
understood.
2 SPECTROSCOPIC MEASUREMENTS OF EFFECTIVE TEMPERATURE AND SURFACE
GRAVITY
2.1 Balmer lines of DA white dwarfs
To solve the problems of white dwarf evolution it is necessary to measure a number of basic parameters
for a significant fraction of the white dwarf population. To set a star in its evolutionary context we need to
know its effective temperature and surface gravity. In early studies, these were estimated from broadband
photometric observations, coupled with simple assumptions about the relation between temperature and
spectral shape (e.g. the assumption of a blackbody). In modern astronomy we now have access to high
signal-to-noise spectra and sophisticated stellar atmosphere models and associated synthetic spectra for
comparison with the data.
2
Figure 1.
Schematic description of the production of H-rich and He-rich branches of white dwarf evolution
For the largest group of white dwarfs, the DA stars, there is a very powerful analysis technique based on
the hydrogen Balmer absorption lines. The strength and shape of an individual line depends on the
temperature and density structure of the atmosphere in which it is formed, which in turn are determined by
the temperature and gravity of the star. Specifically, line strengths depend on the populations of atoms at the
energy levels involved in a particular transition, which are temperature sensitive. An “indefiniteness” in the
energy levels for individual atoms leads to line broadening. This arises from two sources. First, a
perturbation of the radiative wave train through collisions with other particles in the gas causes pressure
broadening, which depends mainly on gravity. Secondly, temperature dependent gas motions lead to
Doppler broadening of the lines. Figure 2 shows a selection of optical spectra of hot DA white dwarfs
ordered by decreasing temperature. By comparing the observed line profiles with predicted ones
simultaneously for at least four lines it is possible to obtain a unique solution for Teff and log g for any DA
white dwarf. This procedure, illustrated in Figure 3 for the hot DA white dwarf PG1342+444, allowed the
first systematic spectroscopic study of a large sample of stars5. An important feature of this analysis
technique is that it is completely objective. Rather than making a purely visual comparison and selection of
the best-fit synthetic spectrum, the best match is determined by a goodness of fit statistic such as the χ2 test.
In addition, this allows formal determination of the statistical errors by examining the variation of χ 2 with
Teff and log g.
3
Figure 2.
Sample of Balmer line spectra for a selection of hot DAs in order of decreasing temperature from the top.
The study of Bergeron et al.5 was based on the use of pure H model atmospheres computed under the
assumption of Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (LTE), that the ion and level populations are entirely
specified by the Saha and Boltzmann equations. Further work has involved the use of better non-LTE
models, where the ion and level populations are determined by statistical equilibrium calculations, which
take into account the radiation field besides the collisional interactions between particles. In addition, the
assumed composition has an influence on the calculated Balmer line profiles. Barstow et al.6 assessed how
this affects the temperature and gravity determinations, noting that the inclusion of significant quantities of
metals lowers the inferred temperature, particularly for the hottest objects.
2.2 Lyman line studies of DA white dwarfs
In the samples studied using the Balmer line technique, the majority of the stars are isolated objects. If
any are in binaries, they are either wide, resolved systems or the companions are late-type dwarfs, where the
4
white dwarf can be spectroscopically isolated. However, when a white dwarf binary companion is spatially
unresolved and of type K or earlier, the white dwarf visible signature is hidden in the glare of the more
luminous object (e.g. Figure 4) and, therefore, the Balmer lines cannot be used for determination of Teff or
log g. If the companion is not earlier than type A, the white dwarf spectrum dominates in the far-UV (see
Figure 4) and the Lyman lines are accessible, allowing them to be used for determination of Teff and log g.
A well-known illustration of this is the DA+K star binary V471 Tauri, which has been extensively studied
and where the Lyman series spectrum obtained by the ORFEUS mission was used to obtain the first
accurate measurements of Teff and log g7,8.
Figure 3.
Example of the technique of comparing the Balmer lines from the spectrum (error bars) of the hot DA white dwarf
PG1342+444, with the synthetic line profiles from stellar atmosphere calculations (solid curve).
While the Lyman α line is encompassed by the spectral coverage of IUE and HST data, a single line
cannot provide an unambiguous measurement of Teff and log g. Access to the full Lyman series lines has
been provided by the short duration missions of the Hopkins Ultraviolet Telescope (HUT) and Orbiting and
Retrievable Far and Extreme Ultraviolet Spectrometers (ORFEUS). They provided observations of a
number of white dwarfs at wavelengths down to the Lyman limit, yielding a first opportunity to compare
Balmer and Lyman line measurements systematically. Barstow et al.9 carried out an evaluation of all the
available archival data for these missions, including some early spectra from the Far Ultraviolet
Spectroscopic Explorer (FUSE). Comparing the results with those from the standard Balmer line analysis,
they found general overall good agreement between the two methods. However, significant differences
were noted for a number of stars. These differences were not always consistent in that sometimes the
Balmer temperature exceeded that derived from the Lyman lines and in other instances was lower, which
would not be expected if the problems arose from the limitations of the stellar atmosphere calculations and
the treatment of the Lyman and Balmer line broadening. The most likely conclusion was that systematic
effects arising from the observations, the data reduction and the analysis were responsible for the
discrepancies.
5
More recently it has been possible to re-examine the issue of the Lyman line analysis with a greatly
expanded far-UV data set available from the FUSE mission. These spectra cover the complete Lyman line
series from β to the series limit, excluding Lyman α, and cover a larger number of stars, particularly at
values of Teff above 50,000K (a range that was sparsely sampled by Barstow et al.10). In addition, FUSE has
observed some of the targets many times, for purposes of monitoring the instrument calibration, which
provides a powerful tool for examining systematic effects in the instrument and analysis procedure. Figure
5 shows a sample of typical FUSE spectra, ordered by decreasing temperature from Teff~70,000K down to
Teff~20,000K, and Figure 6 the results of the Lyman line analysis for GD659.
Figure 4.
UV and optical spectrum of the DA white dwarf plus A8-F2 main sequence star binary system BD+2701888 (error
bars). A synthetic DA white dwarf model spectrum is shown for comparison (smooth curve).
With the availability of the FUSE data archive and observations from Guest Observer programmes,
Barstow et al.11 examined the use of the Lyman series to determine the values of Teff and log g for a sample
of 16 hot white dwarfs. Having a source of data produced by a single instrument and processed with a
uniform pipeline, made it possible to eliminate some of the possible systematic differences between
observations of the same or different stars associated with different instruments. However, it is clear from
this study that systematic error in the overall observation, data reduction and analysis procedures dominate
the measurement uncertainties. Using the scatter in values derived from multiple observations of some stars
it was possible to determine more realistic errors in the measurements than obtained just from the statistical
error values. The new results partially reproduce the earlier study of a more limited stellar sample, showing
that Balmer and Lyman line determined temperatures are in good agreement up to ~50,000K. However,
above this value there is an increasing systematic difference between the Lyman and Balmer line result, the
former yielding the higher temperature (Figure 7). Furthermore, there are several outliers that do not follow
the general trend. At the moment, there is no clear explanation of this effect but it is most likely associated
with deficiencies in the detailed physics incorporated into the stellar model atmosphere calculations. Even
so, the data do demonstrate that, for temperatures below 50,000K, the Lyman lines give reliable results.
Furthermore, for the hotter stars, a useful empirical calibration of the relationship between the Lyman and
Balmer measurements has been obtained, that can be applied to other FUSE observations.
6
Figure 5.
Sample FUSE spectra for all the DA white dwarfs in order of decreasing Teff (as measured with the Balmer lines)
from the top of the figure.
7
Figure 6.
Lyman β-ε lines from a FUSE spectrum of the hot DA white dwarf GD659 (grey error bars), showing the
comparison with the best-fit synthetic model spectrum (black curve). Data gaps arise from removal of the Lyman geocoronal
emission and interstellar absorption. Other strong interstellar lines have also been removed for the analysis.
Figure 7.
Scatter plot of the simple mean values of Teff measured using the ground-based Balmer and FUSE Lyman lines. The
error bars are calculated from the variance of the values in multiple observations or are the statistical 1σ error for single
observations. The solid line corresponds to equal Balmer and Lyman line temperatures.
8
2.3 Temperature and gravity determination of hot hydrogen deficient white dwarfs
Reliable measurements of the high effective temperature and the surface gravity of DO white dwarfs and
PG1159 stars are based on elaborated non-LTE model atmospheres. By definition, cool DO stars (Teff from
~40,000 K to ~80,000 K) display He I lines which together with He II lines can be used to fix the effective
temperature. Detailed line profile fitting at the same time gives the surface gravity. Hot DO stars as well as
PG1159 do not display He I lines, making the parameter determination significantly more difficult, because
temperature and gravity derived from He II lines alone are uncertain to a large extent. This uncertainty can
only be reduced when lines from another element, preferably from two ionization stages, are detectable. In
particular the PG1159 stars display C IV and sometimes O V and O VI as well as Ne VII and Ne VIII lines
in their optical spectra. Ultraviolet spectroscopy reveals many more species and greatly helps to confine the
photospheric parameters.
2.3.1 DO white dwarfs
The first systematic non-LTE analysis of a large sample of DO stars was presented by Dreizler & Werner12.
The Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) has discovered a number of new DOs so that at present the total
number of these stars with effective temperature and surface gravity measured amounts to 4013.
Temperatures cover a wide range, spanning from Teff=40,000 K to 200,000 K, and gravities range between
log g=7 and 8.4. Figure 8 displays optical spectra of several DOs, demonstrating the relative strengths of the
He I and He II lines as a function of Teff.
Figure 8.
Normalised optical spectra (grey lines) of DO white dwarfs along with model atmosphere fits (black lines). The top
two objects exhibit ultrahigh-ionisation features. Teff and log g of the models are given as labels on the right hand portion of the
spectra. The spectra of the hottest stars are dominated by He II lines while increasing He I line strengths are observed with
decreasing temperature. (From Hügelmeyer et al.13).
9
Hydrogen is difficult to detect in DOs because the Balmer lines become rather weak with increasing
effective temperature and because of the dominant He II line blends. In only two objects trace hydrogen
was definitely detected and its abundance determined (PG0038+199, H/He=0.2215; and HD149499B,
H/He=0.212), although a closer inspection with higher spectral resolution and S/N might reveal that many
more DOs are in fact DOA white dwarfs. Upper H abundance limits measured for most objects are of the
order H/He=0.1 (number ratios). Some DOs display C IV lines in the optical spectrum, reminiscent of the
same features seen in PG1159 stars, however, with much reduced strength. Consequently, the carbon
abundance is much lower than in the PG1159 stars, namely of the order 0.1-1%. Carbon and other species
present in even lower abundance can be seen in UV spectra (see below). A typical representative of a hot
DO with 1% carbon is RE0503-289, which has remarkable UV and EUV spectral properties that will be
discussed below.
KPD0005+5106, the hottest DO white dwarf, is a particularly interesting object. A Teff=120,000 K was
derived from the He II lines15. A recent discovery, however, revealed that the temperature was severely
underestimated, emphasizing the potential uncertainty of the Teff determination for hot DOs from He II lines
alone. The identification of Ne VIII lines in the FUSE spectrum and in optical spectra (Figure 9) means that
the temperature of KPD0005+5106 must be of the order 200,000 K16. It remains to be investigated whether
this can explain the mysterious observed hard X-ray emission as of photospheric origin17. The optical Ne
VIII lines appear in emission and were previously thought to stem from superionized (i.e., non-thermally
excited) O VIII. This puts an end to speculations about how superionized lines could be produced in
KPD0005+5106 (and some PG1159 stars, which show the same emission lines; see RX J2117+3412 in
Figure 8).
Figure 9.
Identification of Ne VIII lines in the hottest known DO white dwarf, KPD0005+5106. Overplotted are computed
profiles from models with Teff and log g as depicted. Left panel: Several absorption lines of the n=5→6 transition are detected in the
FUSE spectrum. Middle and right panels: Optical spectral regions with emissions lines from the Ne VIII n=5→8 and n=9→10
transitions.
This brings us to a still mysterious phenomenon that is observed in a large number of hot DOs, namely
the occurrence of extremely high (super-) ionized absorption lines in the optical spectra (C V-VI, N VI-VII,
O VII-VIII, and Ne IX-X18,19; see Figure 10). From the blue-shifted asymmetric line profiles it was
concluded that they stem from an optically thick, extremely fast (~10,000 km/s) stellar wind. On the other
hand, the He II lines are symmetric and, strangely enough, they are extraordinarily strong and cannot be
fitted by any model atmosphere. This obviates a temperature and gravity determination. The lack of He I
lines gives only a lower limit to Teff. Neither HST8, nor ORFEUS20, nor FUSE spectroscopy21 gave any
conclusive hint as to the origin of these observed characteristics. It must be emphasized that almost every
other hot DO exhibits this unexplained phenomenon and not just a few “rare freaks”. Interestingly, it has
also been discovered in a hot DA and a PG1159 star, too22,13.
10
Figure 10.
Normalised optical spectrum of the prototype DO star displaying ultrahigh ionization lines of CNO. Overplotted is a
DO model with Teff=70,000 K and log g=7.5. The observed He II lines are unusually strong and cannot be fitted by any model.
(From Werner et al.19).
2.3.2 PG1159 stars
The optical spectra of PG1159 stars are characterized by weak and broad absorption lines of He II and C
IV, sometimes with central emission reversals. The hottest objects also display O VI and Ne VII/NeVIII
lines. Three spectral subclasses have been introduced that allow a coarse characterization of each star.
According to the appearance of particular line features, the subtypes “A” (absorption lines, e.g.,
PG1424+535 in Figure 11), “E” (emission lines, e.g., PG1159-035), and “lgE” (low gravity with emission
lines, e.g., RX J2117+3412) were defined by Werner23.
Quantitative spectral analyses became feasible with the first construction of line-blanketed non-LTE
model atmospheres that accounted for peculiar chemical compositions24. At that time, only a handful of
PG1159 stars had been identified. Today, 40 such stars are known. Most of them were found by systematic
spectroscopic observations of the central stars of old, evolved planetary nebulae25, as well as follow-up
spectroscopy of faint blue stars from various optical sky surveys (the Palomar-Green survey, MontrealCambridge-Tololo Survey, Hamburg-Schmidt and Hamburg/ESO Surveys, and SDSS) and soft X-ray
sources detected in the ROSAT All-Sky Survey.
11
Figure 11.
Normalised blue spectra of representative PG1159 stars compared to a hot hydrogen-rich central star (top,
NGC7293, Teff=120,000 K, log g=6.3). This sample illustrates the variety of possible spectral appearance. RX J2117+3412 is an
extremely hot low-gravity object (Teff=170,000 K, log g=6) displaying Ne VIII lines. The prototype PG1159-035 (Teff=140,000 K,
log g=7) represents a hot, high gravity PG1159 star with central emission reversals in the He II and C IV lines in the 4600-4700Å
absorption trough region. PG1424+535 (Teff=110,000 K, log g=7) represents a cool high-gravity PG1159 star with a pure
absorption-line spectrum. PG1144+005 exhibits N V emission lines. HS2324+3944 is a hybrid-PG1159 star, representing the
subgroup of rare PG1159 stars with residual hydrogen detectable. H1504+65 is a unique PG1159 star (Teff=200,000 K, log g=8),
being H and He-deficient; the He II 4686Å emission is lacking.
In Figure 12 we show the location of all analysed PG1159 stars in the Teff-log g diagram. They span a
wide range in temperature and gravity, and they represent stars in their hottest phase of post-AGB
evolution. Some of them (those with logg<~6.5) are still helium-shell burners (located before the “knee” in
their evolutionary track), while the majority have already entered the WD cooling sequence.
From optical spectra the He/C ratio can be derived. In addition, the hottest objects (Teff>~120,000 K)
exhibit oxygen lines (O VI and, sometimes, very weak O V), so the O abundance in cooler stars cannot be
determined unless UV spectra are available. Similarly, only the hottest objects display optical neon lines,
and only UV spectra allow access to the neon abundance in the case of cooler objects. The He, C, and O
abundances show strong variations from star to star; however, a word of caution is also appropriate here.
The quality of the abundance determination is also very different from star to star. For some objects, only
relatively poor optical spectra were analyzed, while others were scrutinized with great care using high
signal-to-noise ratio, high-resolution optical and UV/far-UV (FUV) data. Nevertheless, we think that the
abundance scatter is real. The prototype PG1159-035 displays what could be called a mean abundance
pattern: He/C/O = 0.33/0.50/0.17 (all abundances in this paper discussed in the context of PG1159 stars are
given in mass fractions). For instance, an extreme case with low C and O abundances is HS 1517+7403,
which has He/C/O = 0.85/0.13/0.02. Taking all analyses into account, the range of mass fractions for these
elements is approximately He = 0.30–0.85, C = 0.13–0.60, and O = 0.02–0.20 (excluding the peculiar object
H1504+65; see below). There is a strong preference for a helium abundance in the range 0.3–0.5,
12
independent of the stellar mass. Only a minority of stars has a higher He abundance, namely in the range
0.6–0.8. There is a tendency for high O abundances only to be found in objects with high C abundances.
Figure 12.
Hot H-deficient post-AGB stars in the g-Teff plane. We identify PG1159 stars, early and late-type [WC] central stars,
as well as two transition-type objects. Evolutionary tracks are labeled with masses in M. (From Werner & Herwig30).
As in the case of DO stars, the hydrogen detection and abundance determination poses a special problem,
because all Balmer lines are blended with He II lines. In medium-resolution (~1Å) optical spectra, hydrogen
is only detectable if its abundance is higher than about 0.1. With high-resolution spectra, which are difficult
to obtain because of the faintness of most objects, this limit can be pushed down to about 0.02. For PG1159
stars within a PN, the situation is even more difficult, because of the presence of nebular Balmer emission
lines. Four objects clearly show photospheric Balmer lines, and they are called hybrid PG1159 stars. The
deduced H abundance is quite high, H=0.1726. It is worthwhile to note for the discussion of their evolution
that nitrogen is seen in the optical spectra of some of these stars, but quantitative analyses are still lacking.
The hybrid star NGC 7094 shows Ne and F enhancements, as do many PG1159 stars (see below).
Therefore, one can conclude that aside from the presence of H, the elemental abundance pattern of the
hybrid PG1159 stars seems to resemble that of many other PG1159 stars. However, not all the hybrids have
been analyzed appropriately yet, although good UV and optical spectra are available.
Some remarks on the possible analysis errors are necessary. As pointed out, the observational data are of
rather diverse quality, but in general the following estimates hold. The temperature determination is
accurate to 10–15%. The surface gravity is uncertain at the 0.5 dex level. Elemental abundances should be
accurate within a factor of two. The main problem arises from uncertainties in line-broadening theory,
which directly affects the gravity determination and the abundance analysis of He, C, and O.
Since the first quantitative abundance analyses it was speculated that the PG1159 stars exhibit intershell
matter on their surface, however, the C and O abundances were much higher than predicted from stellar
evolution models. It was further speculated that the H-deficiency is caused by a late He-shell flash, suffered
by the star during post-AGB evolution, laying bare the intershell layers. The re-ignition of He-shell burning
brings the star back onto the AGB, giving rise to the designation “born-again” AGB star27. If this scenario is
true, then the intershell abundances in the models have to be brought into agreement with observations. By
introducing a more effective overshoot prescription for the He-shell flash convection during thermal pulses
13
on the AGB, dredge-up of carbon and oxygen into the intershell can achieve this agreement28. Another
strong support for the born-again scenario was the detection of neon lines in optical spectra of some
PG1159 stars29. The abundance analysis revealed Ne=0.02, which is in good agreement with the Ne
intershell abundance in the improved stellar models.
If we do accept the hypothesis that PG1159 stars display former intershell matter on their surface, then we
can in turn use these stars as a tool to investigate intershell abundances of other elements. Therefore these
stars offer the unique possibility to directly see the outcome of nuclear reactions and mixing processes in
the intershell of AGB stars. Usually the intershell is kept hidden below a thick H-rich stellar mantle and the
only chance to obtain information about intershell processes is the occurrence of the third dredge-up. This
indirect view onto intershell abundances makes an interpretation of the nuclear and mixing processes very
difficult, because the abundances of the dredged-up elements may have been changed by additional burning
and mixing processes in the H-envelope (e.g., hot-bottom burning). In addition, stars with an initial mass
below 1.5 M do not experience a third dredge-up at all.
The course of events after the final He-shell flash is qualitatively different depending on the moment when
the flash starts. We speak about a very late thermal pulse (VLTP) when it occurs in a WD, i.e., the star had
turned around the ``knee´´ in the HR diagram and H-shell burning has already stopped. The star expands
and develops a H-envelope convection zone that eventually reaches deep enough that H-burning sets in (a
so-called hydrogen-ingestion flash). Hence H is destroyed and whatever H abundance remains, it will
probably be shed off from the star during the “born-again” AGB phase. A late thermal pulse (LTP) denotes
the occurrence of the final flash in a post-AGB star that is still burning hydrogen, i.e., it is on the horizontal
part of the post-AGB track, before the “knee”. In contrast to the VLTP case, the bottom of the developing
H-envelope convection zone does not reach deep enough layers to burn H. The H-envelope (having a mass
of about 10-4 M) is mixed with a few times 10-3 M intershell material, leading to a dilution of H down to
about H=0.02, which is below the spectroscopic detection limit. If the final flash occurs immediately before
the star departs from the AGB, then we talk about an AFTP (AGB final thermal pulse). In contrast to an
ordinary AGB thermal pulse the H-envelope mass is particularly small. Like in the LTP case, H is just
diluted with intershell material and not burned. The remaining H abundance is relatively high, well above
the detection limit (H>~0.1).
The central stars of planetary nebulae of spectral type [WC] are believed to be immediate progenitors of
PG1159 stars, representing the evolutionary phase between the early post-AGB and PG1159 stages. This is
based on spectral analyses of [WC] stars which yield very similar abundance results; see Werner &
Herwig30 for a detailed comparison.
3 WHITE DWARF MASSES AND RADII
Two of the most important physical parameters that can be measured for any star are the mass and radius.
They determine the surface gravity by the relation g=GM/R2. Hence, if log g is measured the mass can be
calculated provided the stellar radius is known. One outcome of Chandrasekhar’s original work on the
structure of white dwarfs was the relationship between mass and radius, arising from the physical properties
of degenerate matter. Further theoretical work yielded the Hamada-Salpeter zero-temperature mass-radius
relation31. However, white dwarfs do not have zero temperature, indeed many are very hot, as illustrated in
section 2. Hence, the Hamada-Salpeter relation is only a limiting case and the effects of finite temperature
need to be taken into account. Evolutionary calculations showing that the radius of a white dwarf of given
mass decreases as the star cools have been carried out by Wood32,33, Blöcker34 Blöcker et al.35 and others.
The most recent Blöcker models are full evolutionary calculations from the AGB, while those of Wood
have a semi-arbitrary starting point for the hottest models.
3.1 DA white dwarfs
Even the earliest measurements of surface gravity gave a strong hint that the distribution of log g values
and, therefore, of mass was very narrow. This supposition was subsequently confirmed by the work of
Bergeron et al.5 and other authors. Until recently, the largest sample, based mainly on EUV-selected objects
comprised ~ 100 objects36. However, the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) has yielded samples of several
thousand white dwarfs, dramatically improving the statistics and allowing the white dwarf mass distribution
14
to be studied in considerably more detail than in the past. There have been several papers based on the
SDSS as the sample has built up over time. One of the most recent yields a peak mass of 0.578 M and an
estimated FWHM of ~0.016 M for the distribution37. However, with the enhanced sample size and
improved statistics, it is now possible to see some of the complexity of the mass distribution, with a
secondary low mass peak at 0.381 M and a significant tail towards high masses. It is interesting that the
EUV-selected sample yielded a larger fraction of high-mass white dwarfs than the earlier studies based
entirely on optical surveys. This preferential detection of high mass objects in the hot DA sample probably
arises from a drop in neutrino cooling which leads to a slow down of the evolution of the highest mass
white dwarfs.
The narrowness of the observed mass distribution is a direct consequence of the evolution of single stars,
with masses from 1M up to ~8M. While the details of the relationship between the initial mass of the
progenitor star and the final white dwarf mass are not particularly well understood, it is clear that the small
dispersion in the white dwarf masses is related to a similarly small range of stellar core masses and the fact
that most of the outer stellar envelope is expelled through several phases of mass loss along the AGB.
Importantly, any white dwarf with masses outside the approximate range 0.4-1.0M cannot arise from
single star evolution and must have an origin in a binary, where mass exchange has taken place.
While, the basic model of the white dwarf mass-radius relation, which is used to derive masses from the
spectroscopic data, is not in serious doubt, it is interesting to note that opportunities for direct observational
tests of the work are rare. This is particularly true of the higher-level refinements that take into account the
finite stellar temperature and details of the core/envelope structure, discussed above. Varying the assumed
input parameters in these models can lead to quite subtle, but important differences in the model
predictions. To test these requires independent measurements of white dwarf mass, which can be compared
with the spectroscopic results. Such information can be obtained dynamically, if the white dwarf is part of a
binary system, or from the gravitational redshift (Vgr [km s-1] = 0.636M/R), for which an accurate systemic
radial velocity is required (often only possible in a binary). An additional important constraint is knowledge
of the stellar distance. We have such data for only a very few white dwarfs. The four best examples (i.e.
where we have the most complete and accurate information) are 40 Eri B, Procyon B, V471 Tauri B and
Sirius B, where we can combine the assembled data with the Hipparcos parallax to test the mass radius
relation (Figure 13). While there is good agreement between the observation and theory, there nevertheless
remains a high degree of uncertainty in the mass determinations. As a result, for example, it is not possible
to distinguish between different models, such as those with “thin” or “thick” H envelopes.
Clearly it would be very desirable to extend the sample of white dwarfs for which we have dynamical
masses, gravitational redshifts and accurate parallaxes to more objects and, possibly, explore a wider range
of masses and temperatures. A major result of the EUV sky surveys conducted by ROSAT and EUVE was
the discovery of many unresolved binary systems containing white dwarfs and companion spectral types
ranging from A to K38,38,40. Therefore, a large pool of potential sources exists, for which the required
information may be forthcoming in the future. In most of these cases Lyman series observations will be
essential to determine Teff and log g. Importantly, although most isolated white dwarfs were too faint for
Hipparcos parallax measurements, the presence of the bright binary companion means that Hipparcos data
is often available. Although these systems are not resolved in ground-base observations, the HST Wide
Field Planetary Camera 2 has observed most of them in the UV, to measure their separations, or at least
provide improved constraints. Images of 18 binary systems resolve 9 objects 9. Figure 14 shows one of the
most interesting examples, 56 Per, a known binary in which each component has been resolved into a pair,
making it a quadruple star system. The white dwarf is a companion to 56 Per A and is labeled 56 Per Ab in
the image. At a distance of 42pc, the measured 0.39 arcsec separation indicates a binary period of ~50 years
for the Aa/Ab system. Therefore, the orbital motion of the two stars should be readily apparent with
repeated exposures on timescales ~1-2 years, from which a dynamical white dwarf mass can ultimately be
obtained. This is clearly demonstrated in Figure 9 which shows a zoomed view of the Aa/Ab pair from the
main image and, on a similar, scale a second image obtained ~18 months after the first.
15
Figure 13.
Comparison of mass estimates for 40 Eri B, Procyon B, V471 Tau B and Sirius B with the evolutionary models of
Wood33, displayed at various temperatures and with “thin” and “thick” H envelopes. The solid limiting curve represents the
Hamada-Salpeter zero temperature relation for a carbon core (figure produced by Jay Holberg).
Figure 14.
Wide Field Planetary Camera image of the binary 56 Per, where each component (A & B) is itself resolved into a
pair (right). Successive images of the Aa/Ab pair taken ~18 months apart clearly show the orbital motion of the system.
3.2 The special case of Sirius B
As the nearest and brightest hot white dwarf, Sirius B is one of the best studied. Through its companionship
with Sirius A it provides an important opportunity for astrometric mass determination. Indeed, this effort
has been continuous since its discovery by Bessel in 1844. However, a disadvantage is that the close
proximity of the A star has made detailed observation of the white dwarf difficult in the UV and visible
wavebands. The advent of space-based observations has allowed short wavelength observations in the EUV
and soft X-ray, where the emission from Sirius A is negligible, but the obtaining a spectroscopic mass
estimate from the Balmer line series remains problematic. The first attempt was carried out by Greenstein et
al.41 using photographic plate data. Unfortunately, this spectrum, and a similar one published by Kodaira42,
both suffer from a high level of scattered light contamination from Sirius A, amounting to ~1/4 to 1/3 of the
total flux.
16
Figure 15.
HST Wide Field Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2) image of the Sirius system showing the overexposed image of Sirius
A, with its four diffraction spikes. The vertical bar is the “bleed” of Sirius A into adjacent pixels along the readout columns of the
CCD, due to the overexposure. Sirius B lies just to the right of the bottom left diffraction spike. The grey box represents the
dimensions of the 52x0.2" slit, which cuts across Sirius B and two of the diffraction spikes.
From space it is possible to take advantage of the superb spatial resolution of the Hubble Space
Telescope to resolve the A and B components. Since the closest approach in 1993, the separation between
the two stars has become increasingly favourable and Barstow et al.43 were able to obtain a spectrum of the
complete Balmer line series for Sirius B using HST’s Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS).
Figure 15 shows a HST Wide Field Planetary Camera image of the Sirius system, with the location of Sirius
B and the orientation of the slit used for the spectroscopic observation. The quality of the STIS spectra (see
Figure 16) greatly exceed that of previous ground-based spectra, and were used to provide an important
determination of the stellar temperature (Teff = 25,193K) and gravity (log g = 8.556). In addition a new,
more accurate, gravitational red-shift of 80.42 ± 4.83 km s-1 was obtained for Sirius B. Combining these
results with the photometric data and the Hipparcos parallax a new determination of the stellar mass was
obtained for comparison with the theoretical mass-radius relation. However, there are some disparities
between the results obtained independently from log g and the gravitational redshift which may arise from
flux losses in the narrow 50x0.2″ slit. Combining the measurements of Teff and log g with the Wood33
evolutionary mass-radius relation a best estimate of 0.978 M was obtained for the white dwarf mass.
Within the overall uncertainties, this is in agreement with a mass of 1.02 M obtained by matching the new
gravitational red-shift to the theoretical M/R relation.
3.3 DO white dwarfs and PG1159 stars
One principal result of the earlier analyses of DO white dwarfs12 was that their mean mass (0.59±0.08
M), derived from temperature and gravity determination in comparison with theoretical evolutionary
tracks, is virtually identical to the mean mass of DA white dwarfs. The newly discovered DOs from the
SDSS have a mean mass that seemed to be significantly higher (0.68 M13). Taken altogether, the mean
mass of all analyzed DOs (0.65 M, 40 objects) would then be ~10% higher than the mean DA mass. This
difference, however, is perhaps insignificant, because a reanalysis of the SDSS DOs yields different
temperature and gravity values and, consequently, a lower mean mass (0.65 M instead of 0.68 M,
Hügelmeyer priv. comm.). The reason is that the previous analysis was based on the spectra of SDSS
Fourth Data Release (DR4), whereas the reanalysis is based on DR6 spectra with improved calibration.
Dynamical mass determinations of DOs are not available. Interestingly, the mean mass of DB stars (0.67
M 45), the putative DO progeny, appears to be slightly larger than that of DA stars (0.638 M 46) and it is
similar to the DO mean mass. DO white dwarfs are non-pulsating stars, so that asteroseismology methods
cannot be applied for mass determination. Note that because of non-existing DO pulsators the so-called
DOV variable stars are just an unfortunate designation for pulsating PG1159 stars.
The mean spectroscopic mass of PG1159 stars is 0.57 M. This result was derived from the spectroscopic
temperature and gravity determinations of 37 PG1159 stars, accumulated over the last almost two decades,
17
and comparison with modern evolutionary tracks for H-deficient post-AGB stars4. This value represents a
significant shift towards a lower mean mass compared to a previously determined value (0.62 M ) that was
derived from H-rich surface tracks17. Obviously, there is no strongly significant difference between the
mean masses of DA, DO, DB, and PG1159 stars.
Figure 16.
Flux calibrated and background subtracted spectra of Sirius B obtained, as described in the text, with the
G430L (3000-5700Å) and G750M (6300-6900Å) gratings of the STIS instrument on HST.
At present no dynamical mass determination of any PG1159 star is possible. However, this might change
in the near future, because recently the first discovery of a PG1159 star in a close binary system was
announced48. Some PG1159 stars are multi-periodic non-radial pulsators, defining the group of GW Vir
stars (also called misleadingly, as just mentioned, DOV stars). Stellar masses from asteroseismic modeling
were derived for five objects and, considering possible error margins in both methods, the results are in
good agreement with spectroscopic masses (see, e.g., Werner et al.49). The precise mass determination of a
PG1159 star is particularly important, because the nucleosynthesis and mixing processes in the AGB
progenitor star are strongly mass dependent. The interpretation of the element abundance pattern of a
certain PG1159 star allows us to conclude on details of these processes, and this is particularly useful if the
stellar mass is known.
4 ELEMENT ABUNDANCES FROM EUV AND UV SPECTROSCOPY
4.1 The Historical Picture
Determination of the photospheric He and heavy element content in DA white dwarfs provides
important information on the prior evolutionary history of a white dwarf and the physical effects of
mechanisms that may compete to alter the observed composition of the atmosphere. While H and He are
readily detected in the visible region of the spectrum, it is much harder to detect other elements, unless the
abundances are very high. For example, absorption lines from C IV can be seen in many He-rich white
dwarf spectra, with an abundance (C/He) of ~10-2. However, in the DA stars, the C/H ratio is usually much
lower and the carbon undetectable in the visible band. Indeed, He is also hard to detect in the DAs,
requiring abundances in excess of a few times 10-3 in the visible band. Therefore, the most important and
useful transitions (in particular for many resonance lines of elements heavier than H and He) lie in the farultraviolet (far-UV, 1000-2000Å), extreme ultraviolet (EUV, 100-1000Å) and soft X-ray (about 10-100Å)
18
regions of the spectrum. Hence, access to these wavebands has been crucial for understanding the detailed
atmospheric composition of white dwarfs. Unfortunately, absorption of the incident radiation by the Earth’s
atmosphere prevents ground-based observations and the development of space observatories has largely
determined what could be achieved.
The first far-UV and X-ray observatories, flown in the early 1970s, were largely insensitive to white
dwarfs. Nevertheless, a handful of stars were detected stimulating future work. Subsequently, key
contributions have been made by a succession of missions beginning with the International Ultraviolet
Explorer (IUE), and continuing with Roentgen Satellit (ROSAT), the Extreme Ultraviolet Explorer (EUVE)
and Hubble Space Telescope (HST).
Since the hottest white dwarfs radiate the majority of their energy in the soft X-ray and EUV regions of
the spectrum, they are likely to provide a significant fraction of the ionising photons in the local interstellar
medium (LISM). Hence, one original motivation for observing white dwarfs in the far-UV was to study
their circumstellar environments and the LISM, by observing absorption lines projected onto their otherwise
smooth hot blue continua. Such features were detected and usually associated with low ionisation stages of
elements, usually of C I, C II, N I, N II, O I, O II, Si I, Si II and Si III, although sulphur has also been seen.
Since these interstellar lines are weak and narrow, they are only visible at high resolution (R>20000). An
example is a small section of the high-resolution spectrum of the DA white dwarf REJ0558-373, recorded
with the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS) onboard HST (Figure 17), which shows the
interstellar 1260.4Å line of Si II together with photospheric N V.
Interstellar absorption features typically arise from low ionisation species. However, high ionisation
transitions were detected in some of the first IUE echelle spectra of DA white dwarfs50. Initially, it was
suggested that these features were associated with circumstellar material, excited by the strong UV and
EUV flux of the white dwarf. However, determination of the photospheric velocities of several stars,
coupled with the EXOSAT EUV spectrum of Feige 2451, established that the observed features were
photospheric in origin. Nevertheless, it was far from clear whether stars like Feige 24 or the similar G191B2B were typical of the DA population or if stars with pure H atmospheres were more representative.
Ultimately, the larger statistical sample of the ROSAT WFC EUV sky survey provided the solution to that
question. The emergent EUV continuum radiation from a white dwarf is very sensitive to the presence of
absorbing heavy elements, which suppress the flux compared to the level that would be expected from a
pure H atmosphere. In a sample of ~100 stars studied by ROSAT, it is clear that the EUV and soft X-ray
luminosities of objects hotter than about 50,000K are much lower than expected, while white dwarfs below
this temperature typically have luminosities consistent with pure H envelopes52,53. In most of the hottest
white dwarfs, broadband soft X-ray and EUV photometry was able to rule out helium as the sole source of
opacity, indicating that heavier elements play a significant role. This result is consistent with the view that
radiation pressure can counteract the downward diffusion of heavy elements induced by gravity in the
hottest white dwarfs54.
4.2 UV Spectroscopy
Broadband fluxes do not provide sufficient information to determine either the specific absorbing
species or to estimate their abundances. Hence, the survey data must be complemented by more detailed
spectroscopic observations in the EUV and far-UV, but, because of limits on the available observing time,
for a smaller number of objects. Prior to the shutdown of the IUE satellite, high-resolution (R~20,000)
echelle spectra were routinely obtained. These were very important for the initial exploitation of interesting
white dwarfs newly discovered by the ROSAT survey (e.g. Holberg et al.55,56). However, the IUE spectra
had a typical limiting signal-to-noise of ~3:1 and a limiting magnitude ~V=15 for practical exposure times.
Subsequently, an effective technique was developed for coadding multiple exposures to improve signal to
noise. This has been further enhanced, by reprocessing the original data, yielding a valuable archive of high
dispersion white dwarf spectra (see Holberg et al.57). The overall quality of the archive is quite variable
depending on the number of exposures taken of each star. Typically, those stars suspected of containing
heavy elements have been observed more often, achieving a higher ultimate signal to noise than single
observations of apparently pure H white dwarfs. An example of the result of combining several exposures is
seen in Figure 18, which shows a region of the coadded IUE spectrum of G191-B2B (14 exposures). This is
19
compared with a single optimally exposed spectrum of PG1234+482, showing a clear difference in signalto-noise.
Figure 17.
1230Å to 1280Å region of the STIS spectrum of REJ0558-373, showing photospheric absorption lines of N V
(1238.821/1242.804Å) and large numbers of Ni lines. The best-fit synthetic spectrum is shown offset for clarity. The strong line
near 1260Å, present in the observation but not in the model, is interstellar Si II.
In parallel with the latter years of the operation of IUE, the Hubble Space Telescope has given further
access to the far-UV waveband. However, with a considerably larger aperture than IUE, it is possible to
observe fainter targets and achieve greater signal to noise. Initially, high dispersion (R~40,000-100,000)
spectra were obtained by the Goddard High Resolution Spectrograph (GHRS) but, unlike the IUE echelle
data could only cover a narrow (30-40Å) waveband in a single exposure. Hence, complete wavelength
coverage similar to that obtained by IUE would have required a large number of individual exposures,
yielding prohibitively long observations. The replacement of the GHRS by the Space Telescope Imaging
Spectrograph (STIS) in 1997 provided an instrument with improved throughput and IUE-like wavelength
coverage while retaining the high-resolution spectroscopic capabilities. In the E140M (medium echelle)
mode, the resolving power is R~40,000 and far-UV coverage from ~1150-1750Å. The highest resolution
E140H grating only gives a span of ~200Å at a time but can be tilted to build up full wavelength coverage
in successive exposures. The capabilities of STIS are illustrated in the E140H exposure of G191-B2B in the
region of the C IV resonance doublet, the equivalent IUE observation is also shown for comparison (Figure
19). It is interesting to see how the apparent single components seen by IUE have a clear asymmetric
appearance indicating that each is a pair of blended lines, in this case circumstellar and photospheric
contributions.
20
Figure 18.
Comparison of the signal-to-noise achieved from a co-added IUE spectrum (top, of G191-B2B) with a single
exposure (bottom, of PG1234+482). The lower spectrum has been scaled to the flux of the upper one and then offset for clarity.
Between IUE and HST, good quality high-resolution spectra have been obtained for about 25 hot DA
white dwarfs, spanning a temperature range from 110,000K down to 20,000K. Using the latest heavy
element blanketed non-LTE stellar atmosphere calculations, Barstow et al.58 have addressed the heavy
element abundance patterns. Completely objective measurements of abundance values and upper limits
have been made using a χ2 fitting technique to determine the uncertainties in the abundance measurements,
which can be related to the formal upper limits in those stars where particular elements are not detected.
This work shows that the presence or absence of heavy elements in the hot DA white dwarfs largely reflects
what would be expected if radiative levitation is the supporting mechanism, although the measured
abundances do not match the predicted values very well, as reported by other authors in the past. Almost all
stars hotter than ~50,000K contain heavy elements.
A few other strong temperature/evolutionary effects are seen in the UV abundance measurements. There
is a decreasing Si abundance with temperature and a sharp decline in Fe and Ni abundance to zero, below
~50,000K. When detected, the Fe and Ni abundances maintain an approximately constant ratio, close to the
cosmic value ~20. For the hottest white dwarfs observed by STIS, the strongest determinant of abundance
appears to be gravity. Qualitatively, these results are in keeping with physical models of diffusion and
radiative levitation, but the detailed abundance measurements do not match predicted values.
4.3 UV spectroscopy of DO white dwarfs
Heavy element abundances in DO white dwarfs are less well explored than in DAs and in PG1159 stars.
Dreizler & Werner12 and Dreizler59 have summarized the state and presented new analyses. Lines of only a
few species (CNO, Si, Fe) were discovered in selected DOs for which IUE and HST spectra were taken.
Generally, the comparison of observed abundances with predictions from diffusion calculations was
disappointing because of the significant deviations. A thorough investigation of this problem by Dreizler57
arrived at the surprising results that, in contrast to DA stars, the metal lines in DOs are better reproduced by
chemically homogeneous model atmospheres than by self-consistently computed stratified models
accounting for diffusion and radiative levitation. Since these studies a number of new spectroscopic
observations of DOs were performed with FUSE.
21
Figure 19.
Comparison of the coadded IUE spectrum of G191-B2B with that obtained at higher spectral resolution by the STIS
instrument on HST, in the region of the C IV 1548/1550Å doublet. The asymmetry of the line profiles in the STIS data reveals the
presence of two absorbing components, not visible at the lower spectral resolution of IUE, where they are blended into a single
gaussian.
A remarkable achievement was the discovery of trans-iron elements (Ge, As, Se, Zn, Te, I; Figure 20) in
the cool DO white dwarfs HD149499B and (some of these species) in HZ2160. Later on, most of these
elements as well as Ga, Mo, and the noble gases Kr and Xe were detected in the hot DO RE0503-289 61
(Figure 21; see below for more details about his star). The observed number abundances are small, of the
order log(X/He) = -6 to -8. The measured mass fractions, however, reveal overabundances ranging up to a
factor of 1000 relative to the Sun. This could be the result of slow neutron capture nucleosynthesis, which
would have occurred during the AGB phase of the stars´ evolution, although this interpretation is
problematic. Diffusion and radiative levitation certainly influence the element abundances. This is
underlined by the fact that a more than 100 times oversolar abundance was measured for argon in the hot
DO PG1034+00162, although nucleosynthesis processes are not expected to affect argon. The solar argon
abundance found in a PG1159 star, where we expect to see nuclear processed material, confirms this
expectation.
RE0503-289 is a remarkable DO star. It is relatively hot and shows C IV lines in the optical spectrum
(Teff=70,000 K, logg=7.5, C/He=0.005 by number). It has an extremely low ISM hydrogen column density
along the line-of-sight so that EUV spectroscopy, with surprising results, was possible (see below). What is
particularly interesting in our context is its UV spectrum observed with HST and FUSE. Barstow et al.63
have identified nickel lines (log Ni/He=-5) in the HST/GHRS spectrum, however, at the same time iron is
not detectable at all (log Fe/He<-6). Hence, the Ni/Fe ratio is at least 10 times larger than observed in hot
DA stars. This difference is not understood in terms of radiative levitation/diffusion processes alone. The
FUV spectrum taken with FUSE shows numerous spectral lines which initially could not be identified64. A
large fraction of them were later, also already mentioned above, identified as lines from trans-iron
elements61.
We already described the remarkable optical spectrum of hottest DO white dwarf KPD0005+5106 (Sect.
2.3.1, Teff=200,000 K). Lines from highly ionized metals which were never seen before in a stellar
photosphere are exhibited in the FUSE spectrum of the star, for example Ca X and Fe X 65,66 (Figures 22
and 23). The metal abundance pattern suggests that KPD0005+5106 might be a descendant of an RCrB star,
hence, it could be the result of a binary white dwarf merger and therefore represent a different post-AGB
evolutionary sequence towards the white dwarf stage66.
22
4.4 UV spectroscopy of PG1159 stars
Abundance analyses of PG1159 stars are performed by detailed fits to spectral line profiles. Because of
the high Teff all species are highly ionized and, hence, most metals are only accessible by UV spectroscopy.
As mentioned above, optical spectra always exhibit lines from He II and C IV. Only the hottest PG1159
stars display additional lines of N, O, and Ne. For all other species we have utilized high-resolution UV
spectra that were taken with HST and FUSE. FUSE allowed observations in the Lyman-UV range (~9001200 Å) that is not accessible with HST. This turned out to be essential for most results reported here. For a
more detailed discussion and references to these results see Werner & Herwig30.
A number of chemical elements could be identified for the very first time (F, P, S, Ar). In addition, very
high ionisation stages of several elements, which were never seen before in stellar photospheric spectra,
could be identified in the UV spectra for the very first time (e.g., Si V, Si VI, Ne VIII). To illustrate this, we
display in Figures 24-31 details of FUSE and HST spectra of PG1159 stars. We discuss the spectroscopic
results comparing with the PG1159 progenitors stars (the [WC] central stars) and stellar evolution model
predictions.
Figure 20.
Photospheric lines of trans-iron elements observed in FUSE, HST, and IUE spectra of HD149499B overplotted with
computed line profiles. (From Chayer et al.60).
23
Figure 21.
Photospheric lines of krypton and xenon in the FUSE spectrum of the hot DO RE0503-289 overplotted with
computed line profiles. (From Werner et al.61).
Figure 22.
Two photospheric Ca X lines discovered in the hot DO KPD0005+5106 overplotted with computed line profiles.
(From Werner et al.65).
Figure 23.
Two photospheric Fe X lines discovered in the hot DO KPD0005+5106 overplotted with computed line profiles.
(From Wassermann et al.66).
24
Figure 24.
Detail from FUSE spectra of two relatively cool PG1159 stars (see labels). Note the following features. The F VI
1139.5 Å line which is the first detection of fluorine at all in a hot post-AGB star; the P V resonance doublet at 1118.0 and 1128.0
Å, the first discovery of phosphorus in PG1159 stars; the N IV multiplet at 1132 Å. Also detected are lines from Si IV and S VI.
The broader features stem from C IV and O VI. (From Reiff et al.67).
Hydrogen - Four PG1159 stars show residual H with an abundance of up to 0.35 (the so-called hybridPG1159 stars). These objects are the outcome of an AFTP. All other PG1159 stars have H<~ 0.1 and,
hence, should be LTP or VLTP objects. H was also found in [WCL] stars (H=0.01-0.1).
Helium, carbon, oxygen - These are the main constituents of PG1159 stellar atmospheres. A large variety of
relative He/C/O abundances is observed which might be explained by different numbers of thermal pulses
during the AGB phase, except for the most He-rich stars. They might belong to a different post-AGB
sequence involving the so-called O(He) stars (see Rauch et al.68). The He/C/O abundances in PG1159 stars
are consistent with results found for [WC] stars.
Nitrogen - N is a key element that allows to decide whether the star is the product of a VLTP or a LTP.
Models predict that N is diluted during an LTP so that in the end N=0.1%. This low N abundance is
undetectable in the optical and only detectable in extremely good UV spectra. In contrast, a VLTP produces
N (because of H-ingestion and burning) to an amount of 1% to maybe a few percent. N abundances of the
order 1% are found in some PG1159 stars (e.g., PG1144+005 in Figure 11), while in others it is definitely
much lower. This picture is similar to the [WC] stars.
25
Figure 25.
The high spectral resolution capability of STIS aboard HST allows to distinguish the photospheric NV resonance
doublet from the weak blueshifted ISM components. This enabled the first reliable nitrogen abundance determination in the PG1159
prototype. (From Jahn et al.69).
Neon - Ne is made from 14N that was produced by CNO burning. In the He-burning region, α-captures
transform 14N to 22Ne. Evolution models predict Ne=0.02 in the intershell. A small spread is expected as a
consequence of different initial stellar masses. Ne=0.02 was first found from optical analyses of a few stars
and, later, in a larger sample observed with FUSE (Werner et al.70,16; Figures 26 and 27). The neon
abundance in [WC] stars is very similar (0.02-0.04).
Figure 26.
First identification of the NeVII 973.3 Å line, shown here in the FUSE spectrum of the PG1159 star PG1520+525.
This strong absorption feature is seen in the spectra of many hot post-AGB stars, but remained unidentified for some years.
Figure 27.
Discovery of NeVIII lines in the FUSE spectrum of the PG1159-type central star of K1-16. This is the first detection
of NeVIII in any photospheric spectrum. Lines from this ion are only exhibited by the very hottest post-AGB stars (Teff>~140,000
K).
Fluorine - F was discovered for the first time by Werner et al. (2005) in hot post-AGB stars; in PG1159
stars as well as hydrogen-normal central stars. A strong absorption line in FUSE spectra located at 1139.5 Å
remained unidentified until we found that it stems from F VI (see Figure 24). The abundances derived for
PG1159 stars show a large spread, ranging from solar to up to 250 times solar. This was surprising at the
outset because 19F, the only stable F isotope, is very fragile and easily destroyed by H and He. A
comparison with AGB star models of Lugaro et al.71, however, shows that such high F abundances in the
intershell can indeed be accumulated by the reaction 14N(α,γ)18F(β+)18O(p,α)15N(α,γ)19F, the amount
depends on the stellar mass. We find a good agreement between observation and theory. The results also
suggest, however, that the F overabundances found in AGB stars can only be understood if the dredge-up in
AGB stars is much more efficient than hitherto thought72.
26
Silicon - Si is expected to remain almost unchanged, in agreement with PG1159 stars for which the Si
abundance could be determined (Figure 22). The same holds for some [WC] stars, but in other cases
overabundances were found (8-45 times solar).
Phosphorus - Systematic predictions from evolutionary model grids are not available; however, the few
computed models show P overabundances in the range 4-25 times solar. This is at odds with spectroscopic
measurements for two PG1159 stars (Figure 22) that reveal a solar P abundance.
Sulphur - Again, model predictions are uncertain at the moment. Current models show a slight (0.6 solar)
underabundance. In strong contrast, a large spread of S abundances is found in PG1159 stars, ranging from
solar down to 0.01 solar (Figure 28).
Argon - Ar was identified recently for the first time in hot post-AGB stars and white dwarfs67. Among them
is one PG1159 star for which a solar abundance has been determined (Figure 29). This is in agreement with
AGB star models which predict that the Ar abundance remains almost unchanged.
Iron - From the non-detection of Fe VII lines it was previously concluded that PG1159 stars are possibly
Fe-deficient75. Recently, however, lines from Fe VII, Fe VIII, or Fe X were discovered in a number of
PG1159 stars (Figure 30). In all cases, a solar iron abundance was derived77,79.
Figure 28.
FUSE enabled the first abundance determination of sulpur in PG1159 stars. Shown here is the S VI resonance
doublet in the prototype of the PG1159 spectral class. (From Jahn et al69.).
Figure 29.
Discovery of the Ar VII 1063.55 Å line in the FUSE spectrum of the PG1159 star PG1425+535. This is the first
detection of Ar VII in a photospheric spectrum and the only detectable argon line in any wavelength region of hot post-AGB stars.
PG1159 stars do not exhibit wind features in their optical spectra. However, UV spectroscopy reveals that
many of the low-gravity central stars display strong P Cygni profiles; e.g., the resonance lines from C IV
27
and OVI, and subordinate lines from He II (1640 Å), O V (1371 Å), F VI (1139 Å, see Figure 31) and Ne
VII (973 Å). Mass-loss rates in the range log (M-dot /[M]) = -8.3 to -6.9 were derived76,77,78, and it appears
that they are in accordance with predictions from radiation driven–wind theory.
Figure 30.
Fe VIII lines detected in the prototype PG1159-035 compared to model profiles. (From Werner et al.74).
Figure 31.
Observed and computed P Cygni profiles of the F VI 1139.5 Å line in the FUSE spectra of the [WC]-PG1159
transition type object Abell 78 (top panel) and the hybrid PG1159 star NGC 7094 (bottom). Compare with the symmetric line
shapes in higher-gravity PG1159 stars (Figure 26). (From Reiff et al.75).
In the year 1992 the extremely hot central star of Longmore 4 (Teff=170,000 K) showed a remarkable
event during which its spectral type turned from PG1159 to [WCE] and back again to PG1159, most
probably due to a transient but significant increase in the mass-loss rate79. Bond80,81 has been monitoring the
spectrum of Longmore 4 since 2003 and he discovered that the phenomenon recurred twice in the year 2006
(Figure 32), and once again in 2008. The reason for these spectacular events is unknown. It might be
connected to the fact that the star is a pulsator. This phenomenon has not been witnessed in any other
PG1159 star.
4.5 EUV Spectroscopy
4.5.1 DA white dwarfs
A great deal of detailed information has been obtained from analysis of UV spectra of DA white dwarfs
and this observing technique will continue to be of tremendous importance. However, as some UV results
already indicate, where the detailed line profiles suggest that photospheric material is not homogeneously
mixed, they do not necessarily tell the whole story concerning the structure and composition of the
28
photosphere. The emergent EUV flux from a hot white dwarf star is highly sensitive to both the effective
temperature and composition of the envelope. Hence, EUV observations were recognized to have important
diagnostic potential even before any EUV astronomy missions were actually flown. Barstow and Holberg82
have recently and extensively reviewed the development of EUV astronomy and some of the detailed
results concerning white dwarfs. Therefore, this section discusses a subset of results that are particularly
concerned with this review theme on the measurement of fundamental parameters of white dwarfs.
Figure 32.
The mean of 29 normal spectra of Longmore 4 is shown at top. On 2006 Jan 16 (middle) and Nov 30 (bottom) the
star was in its transient [WCE] stage, with strong C IV and He II emission. Spectra taken 53-56 days earlier, and 15-17 days later,
showed the normal PG1159 spectrum. Tick marks on the y axis are spaced at 0.5 of the continuum level. (From Bond80).
Unlike the UV band, where high-resolution spectroscopy has been available for more than 20 years, the
field of EUV astronomy has emerged more slowly, due to the greater difficulty of instrument development
and practical observation in a region where the opacity of interstellar gas is at its greatest. Consequently, the
spectrometers on board the Extreme Ultraviolet Explorer (EUVE) mission had relatively low effective area
and modest spectral resolution (R~300) compared to UV instrumentation. Nevertheless, since hot white
dwarf fluxes peak in the EUV, detailed observations could be made of a significant sample of white dwarfs.
Those white dwarfs with pure H envelopes are the most luminous at the shorter EUV wavelengths, as
illustrated in Figure 33, which shows an EUVE spectrum of the white dwarf HZ43. HZ43 was the first
reported detection of an EUV source and has been studied frequently and, because of it pure H photosphere,
often been used for calibration purposes. The flux corrected spectrum peaks near 200Å. The short
wavelength decrease is determined entirely by the properties of the atmosphere but at long wavelengths,
while some of the opacity is from the photosphere, the dominant effect is absorption by interstellar
hydrogen and helium. Although interstellar opacity is not the topic of this review, a discussion of its
characteristics in the EUV band is essential for understanding the photospheric results since photospheric
He features could also be present at these same wavelengths in some stars. The interstellar features may
interfere with or even completely mask any stellar component at the resolution of EUVE. The sharp step at
504Å is the He I ISM absorption edge. The important He II Lyman series lines also lie between the He II
edge at 228Å and the He II Lyman α line at 304Å but the He II column density is too low for a significant
detection of these interstellar lines in HZ43. However, when the total interstellar H I column density is
higher (a few x 1018cm-2 compared to ~1018cm-2 for HZ43), and the He I & He II columns larger as a result,
the He II edge can be readily detected, along with the He I autoionization edge at 206Å (Figure 34).
29
Figure 33.
EUV spectrum of the pure H atmosphere white dwarf HZ43, recorded with the EUVE spectrometers and described in
the text.
Figure 34.
EUVE count spectrum of the DA white dwarf GD659 (error bars), showing the He I interstellar autoionization
feature at 206Å and the interstellar He II Lyman edge at 228Å. The solid histogram that matches the data is the best fit model
spectrum for a pure H atmosphere, while the histogram that does not match the observed flux is a model including N V at the
abundance reported by Barstow et al.58 assuming that the mixture is homogeneous.
If the white dwarf atmosphere contains significant quantities of elements heavier than H or He, the EUV
spectrum is cut off very sharply at short wavelengths. Figure 35 shows the spectrum of the white dwarf
G191-B2B, which is the proto-type “heavy element-rich” object. In this object the peak flux is at a
wavelength ~260Å, with hardly any flux detectable below 200Å, in contrast to those stars with pure H
30
envelopes. Initially, an understanding of the EUVE spectrum of G191-B2B and similar stars was quite
elusive. First attempts to match the observation with synthetic spectra failed to reproduce either the flux
level or even the general shape of the continuum (see Barstow et al.83 and Figure 35). This problem was
perceived to be due to the inclusion of an insufficient number of Fe and Ni lines. Adding some 9 million
predicted lines to the few thousand with measured wavelengths did provide a self-consistent model able to
reproduce the EUV, UV and optical spectra (Lanz et al. 1996). However, good agreement between the
observed EUVE spectrum and the model prediction could only be achieved by inclusion of a significant
quantity of helium, either in the stellar photosphere or as an ionised interstellar/circumstellar component.
Unfortunately, due to the limited resolution of EUVE (~0.5Å) in the region of the He II Lyman series, this
inferred He contribution could not be directly detected.
Figure 35.
EUVE spectrum of G191-B2B (thick solid line) compared with two non-LTE line-blanketed models for
Teff=58000K, log g=7.5. The dashed model includes blanketing from 6,000 lines of Fe and Ni, while the thin solid line includes
300,000 lines.
The nature of the He opacity, if really present, is problematic. If all of it is interstellar, the implied He
ionization fraction is much larger (by a factor ~2) than the 30-40% typical of the nearby ISM. Furthermore,
the level of agreement between model and data at short wavelengths, below ~200Å, is poor, the predicted
flux exceeding that observed by a factor ~10 (Figure 36). Empirically, Barstow et al.85 showed that the
overall flux distribution could be matched by assuming a different Fe abundance for models separately
applied to the short (<190Å) and long (>190Å) ranges. Examination of the formation depths of the Fe lines
at different wavelength hints at an explanation of the problem (Figure 37), showing that the formation depth
has a strong wavelength dependence and indicating that abundance measurements made in the UV and
EUV, and even in different parts of the EUV, are sampling quite different regions of the atmosphere.
Therefore, the results imply that the Fe is not distributed homogeneously in the atmosphere, but has
different abundances at different depths. A fairly simple model, dividing the atmosphere into two “slabs”
with a lower Fe abundance in the outer region (Fe/H=10-6 cf. 4x10-5) provides a good, but not completely
unique, match to the data (Figure 38). Subsequently, important progress has been made in incorporating
radiative levitation and diffusion self-consistently into the atmosphere calculations to give predictions of the
depth dependent abundance profiles a firm physical basis86,88,88. Interestingly, the Fe profile determined
from these calculations is similar to the simple slab model of Barstow et al.85, but with a smoother transition
region between the two main regions.
The need for a He opacity component, required to provide a good match to the homogeneous models, is
reduced in the stratified models but not eliminated. Although, in principle EUV observations are more
sensitive to the presence of He than any other waveband, there have been few real detections of the element
in EUVE spectra. One example is the massive DA star GD50, where the He II Lyman line series is clearly
31
visible (Figure 39). However, because of the high mass (1.2M), it is likely that the star is a product of
binary evolution and other stars where He has been detected are in known binary systems. Therefore, the
issue of whether or not photospheric He is present in the hottest DA white dwarfs is still needs to be
resolved.
Figure 36.
Comparison of the complete EUVE spectrum of G191-B2B (error bars) with a single model that give the optimum
match to the >180Å wavelength range. Discontinuities near 170 and 320Å are regions where the EUVE spectrometer channels
overlap, and arise from differing spectrometer effective area. The predicted short wavelength flux is a factor 5-10 greater than that
observed.
Figure 37.
Mass depth (total mass above the point of interest) of the line (upper, dashed curve) and continuum (lower curve)
formation at monochromatic optical depth τυ=2/3 as a function of wavelength in the EUV and far UV.
Direct detection of He in those stars with significant heavy element opacity requires higher spectral
resolution than was achieved with EUVE, to separate the He II Lyman lines from the much larger number
from other elements. Recent developments in normal incidence optics have allowed the construction of a
new generation of spectrographs combining high throughput with high spectral resolution. Thus far, the
technique has only been applied on short duration sounding rocket flights, with exposure times far shorter
than available with satellite missions. The spectrum of G191-B2B, obtained with the J-PEX mission, shows
32
the promise of future instrumentation and partially solves the problem of the He inferred from the EUVE
analyses (Figure 40, Barstow et al.89). He is certainly directly detected and the best-fit model requires both
interstellar and photospheric components. However, only the interstellar complex in the 228-230Å range is
detected directly. The predicted strength of the photospheric He II line at 243Å is at a level similar to the
signal-to-noise in that part of the spectrum and so a significant detection of photospheric He cannot be
claimed at this stage. Further analysis of the spectrum, indicates that the interstellar He II has two
components, one associated with the local ISM and a second that may be related to the circumstellar
material detected in the far-UV90.
Figure 38.
Comparison of the complete EUVE count spectrum of G191-B2B with the “slab” model of Fe depth dependent
abundance described in the text.
Figure 39.
EUVE spectrum of the massive DA white dwarf GD50, showing the presence of photospheric He II.
33
Figure 40.
High-resolution EUV spectrum of G191-B2B, obtained with the J-PEX spectrometer, spanning the wavelength
range 226-245 Å (error bars). The blue histogram is the best-fit theoretical model of the star and ISM.
More recently, a second high resolution EUV spectrum, of the white dwarf component in the precataclysmic binary Feige 24, has been obtained in a re-flight of the J-PEX payload. If a WD has evolved as
part of such a short period (4.23d) binary, then the mass-loss may have also been affected by a common
envelope (CE) phase. Some evolutionary calculations predict that DA dwarfs are formed with
comparatively massive H layers (~10-4M, e.g. Iben and Tutukov91), where He, having sunk out of the
atmosphere, should be undetectable even in the EUV. One possible consequence of binary evolution is the
expulsion of the CE, reducing the system angular momentum and leaving only a thin H-rich shell above the
core compared to that expected in a single star92. However, the efficiency of CE ejection is poorly
understood. Detection of He in the EUV might indicate that a large part of the H envelope has been
expelled by some mechanism or that there is unexpected mixing. Comparative abundance measurements in
EUV, FUV and optical bands can determine the H/He structure (stratified H upon He or homogeneous
H+He) and distinguish between these situations.
Feige 24 is an important contrast to G191-B2B representing a close binary rather than an isolated object.
The surprising result of the J-PEX observation is that there is no evidence for the existence of a thin H-layer
or any photospheric HeR93. This is illustrated in Fig. 41a, which shows a section of the best fit model and
observational data, where the H-layer mass has converged to the upper limit of the grid (10-12.92M), a level
at which no He is detectable. The sensitivity to the H-layer mass is illustrated in Figs. 41b and 41c, which
show the effect of decreasing the H-layer mass in the model to 10-13.5 and 10-14 M. The strong constraints
on the amount of He present are provided by the absence of detectable He II lines, particularly at 237.3 Å
and 243 Å, and the predicted suppression of the continuum flux below ~233 Å for thinner H-layers.
Formally, the lower limit to the H-layer mass is 1.2x10-13 M, equivalent to a He abundance upper limit
(90%) of 2.5x10-6. Hence, it is evident that the common envelope phase of evolution of the Feige 24 system
has not led to erosion or expulsion of the WD’s H envelope and that, despite this more complex
evolutionary path, the WD appears no different from G191-B2B.
Observations of isolated white dwarfs with Chandra and XMM-Newton are scarce. The Chandra LETG
(Low Energy Transmission Grating) spectrum of HZ43 (50-170Å) together with EUV and UV spectra is
perfectly matched by a pure hydrogen atmosphere, confirming previous results. The same holds for Sirius
B94 and LB191995. More challenging is the LETG spectrum of GD246, a hot DA with significant trace
metal abundances as derived from detailed studies with EUVE and (F)UV telescopes. Thanks to the
superior spectral resolution of Chandra over EUVE, individual spectral lines from Fe could be identified in
the soft X-ray spectrum of a DA star for the first time95,96. Figure 42 shows the Chandra spectrum which is
34
dominated by a forest of Fe lines. XMM-Newton has observed two DAs, G191-B2B and GD153, for
calibration purposes97 but no detailed results are available, yet. G191-B2B, as discussed above, contains
trace metals and therefore is a less suitable calibration object than the pure-hydrogen WD GD153.
a)
b)
c)
Figure 41.
J-PEX high resolution spectrum (black error bars) compared to a composite photospheric and interstellar model
spectrum (blue histogram). a) Best fit model with H-layer mass of 10-12.92M; b) H-layer mass = 10-13.5M; c) H-layer mass = 1014M .

35
Figure 42.
Chandra LETG spectrum of the hot DA white dwarf GD246 (thin line) with fits by a chemically homogeneous
model (top panel) and a stratified model (bottom). (From Adamczak et al.95).
4.5.2 DO white dwarfs and PG1159 stars
There are only two DO stars with low enough ISM column densities that are accessible for EUV
observations, HD149499B99 and RE0503-289. The latter´s EUVE spectrum (Figure 43) represents a
particular challenge. Model atmospheres including metal abundances as derived from UV spectroscopy
predict an EUV flux that is significantly higher than observed. This problem is still unsolved. Decreasing
the effective temperature of the model would help to explain the EUV flux level. This possibility, however,
is excluded because such cooler models exhibit optical He I lines which are not observed. Another
possibility is additional EUV opacity sources. In the FUSE spectrum, lines from many trans-iron elements
were discovered recently64 (see above). The respective opacities were not yet included in the EUV analysis.
36
Figure 43.
EUVE spectrum of the hot DO white dwarf RE0503-289 compared to models with Teff=70,000 K. To facilitate line
identification, carbon or oxygen was added to the helium model (top and bottom panels, respectively). Labels and arrows indicate
firm identifications of CIII/IV and OIII/IV lines. Most prominent are the lines of the He II resonance series, beginning with Lyα at
304Å. The models are normalized to the V magnitude. Values for HI and He I interstellar column densities were treated as free
parameters and adjusted to fit the continuum in the 500-600Å region and the He I edge at 512Å, respectively. (From Werner et al.23)
PG1159 stars have high C and O abundances in addition to helium in their photospheres so that they are
EUV emitters only if their effective temperature is very high (Teff>140,000 K). PG1520+525 is the only
PG1159 star (except for H1504+65, see below) for which a reasonable EUVE spectrum could be obtained.
Flux is detected in a very narrow region, 100-130Å, and it was used to estimate Teff=150,000 K. The star is
a non-pulsator so that this result in combination with the temperature of the pulsating prototype PG1159035 (Teff=140,000 K) constrains the location of the blue edge of the GW Vir instability strip in the
Hertzsprung-Russell diagram100. This result was confirmed later by a Chandra LETG observation95,98
(Figure 44).
37
Figure 44.
Chandra LETG spectrum of PG1520+525 (thin line) and simulated observations from two models with different
effective temperature. The 140,000 K model overestimates the flux at λ>110Å. (From Werner et al.98)
The most bizarre PG1159 star is H1504+65. It was discovered as one of the brightest soft X-ray sources in
the sky in the HEAO-1 survey101. Optical follow-up spectroscopy revealed a hot white dwarf closely related
to the PG1159 class. It is (together with the DO KPD0005+5106) the hottest white dwarf known
(Teff=200,000 K) and it has a unique photospheric composition. It is H- and He-free and mainly composed
by C and O by equal parts. The EUVE spectrum shows flux in the 75-150Å range and it is dominated by
strong and broad O VI and Ne VII absorption line102. Chandra has taken a spectacular LETG spectrum,
arguably the richest X-ray absorption line spectrum recorded so far (Figure 45). Many lines from several
ionisation stages of Ne and Mg can be seen and high abundances were derived: Ne=Mg=2% by mass. It is
speculated that H1504+65 is a naked C-O white dwarf or even a WD with a O-Ne-Mg core resulting from
carbon burning70. The recently discovered new class of “Hot DQ” white dwarfs, having carbon dominated
atmospheres with Teff ~20,000 K103, could represent the progeny of H1504+65 and might hold the key for
understanding the origin of H-He-deficient white dwarfs.
5 CONCLUSION
This paper has reviewed the range of techniques applied to measuring the parameters of the hot, hydrogenand helium-rich white dwarf stars. The principle direct measurements are of effective temperature, surface
gravity and photospheric composition. From these it is possible to infer more fundamental information such
as the stellar mass and radius, which are essential for the calculation of cooling rates and the use of the
white dwarf population to study the history and evolution of the galaxy. Spectroscopic data from a variety
of wavelength ranges are required for this work and the important contributions from optical, ultraviolet and
extreme ultraviolet studies have been outlined. While some important results have been obtained, a number
of important questions remain to be answered. Continued access to high-resolution spectroscopy in the farUV and a new, similar capability in the EUV will be essential to provide final solutions for the outstanding
problems.
38
Figure 45.
Detail from the Chandra spectrum of H1504+65 (thin line). Overplotted is a model with parameters as given in the
panel. (From Werner104)
Apart from a very few white dwarfs, where dynamically determined masses are available, we rely on the
theoretical white dwarf mass-radius relation to determine these parameters from the values of Teff and log g.
The issue of the accuracy of the theoretical mass-radius calculations is an important one and the discovery
of a sample of white dwarfs in binary systems, from which we might ultimately extend the number of
objects for which we have dynamical masses, indicates that we might finally be able to make a definitive
test of this Nobel Prize-winning theory.
References
[1] Herwig, F., this volume
[2] Garcia-Berro, E & Oswalt, T., this volume
[3] Bergeron, P. this volume
[4] Schatzman, E.L., 1958, White Dwarfs, North Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam
[5] Bergeron P., Saffer R., Liebert J., 1992, ApJ, 394, 228
[6] Barstow, M.A., Hubeny, I. and Holberg, J.B., 1998, MNRAS, 299, 520.
[7] Barstow M.A., Holberg J.B., Cruise A.M., Penny A.J., 1997, MNRAS, 286, 58
[8] Werner, K., Rauch, T., 1997, A&A, 324, L25
[9] Barstow M.A., Bond H.E., Burleigh M.R., Holberg J.B., 2001a, MNRAS, 322, 891
[10] Barstow M.A., Holberg J.B., Hubeny I., Good S.A., Levan A.J., Meru F., 2001, MNRAS, 325, 211
[11] Barstow M.A., Good S.A., Burleigh M.R., Hubeny I., Holberg J.B., Levan A.J., 2003, MNRAS, 344,
562.
[12] Dreizler, S., Werner, K. 1996, A&A, 314, 217
[13] Hügelmeyer, S., Dreizler, S., Homeier, D., et al., 2006, A&A, 454, 617
[14] Dreizler, S., Werner, K., Heber, U., Reid, N., Hagen, H. 1997, in The Third Conference on Faint Blue
Stars, eds. A.G. Davis Philip, J.W. Liebert, R.A. Saffer, L. Davis Press, p. 303
[15] Werner, K., Heber, U., Fleming, T. 1994, A&A, 284, 907
[16] Werner, K., Rauch, T., Kruk, J.W. 2007, A&A, 474, 591
[17] O’Dwyer, I.J., Chu, Y.-H., Gruendl, R.A., Guerrero, M.A., Webbink, R.F. 2003, AJ, 125, 2239
[18] Werner, K., Dreizler, S., Heber, U., Rauch, T., Wisotzki, L., Hagen, H.-J. 1995a, A&A, 293, L75
[19] Werner, K., Rauch, T., Dreizler, S., Heber, U. 1995b, in Koester D., Werner K., eds, Lecture Notes in
Physics, White Dwarfs. Springer, Berlin, p. 171
[20] Werner, K., Dreizler, S., Rauch, T., et al. 1999, in 11th European Workshop on White Dwarfs, eds. J.E. Solheim, E. Meistas, ASP Conference Series, 169, 511
39
[21] Werner, K., Dreizler, S., Kruk, J.W., Sitko, M.L. 2003, in White Dwarfs, eds. D. de Martino, R.
Silvotti, J.-E. Solheim, R. Kalytis, NATO Science Series II, 105, 171
[22] Dreizler, S., Heber, U., Napiwotzki, R., Hagen, H.J. 1995, A&A, 303, L53
[23] Werner, K. 1992, in The Atmospheres of Early-Type Stars, eds. U. Heber, C.S. Jeffery, Lecture Notes
in Physics, 401, 273
[24] Werner, K., Heber, U., Hunger, K. 1991, A&A, 244, 437
[25] Napiwotzki, R., Schönberner, D. 1995, A&A, 301, 545
[26] Dreizler, S. 1998, Baltic Astronomy, 7, 71
[27] Iben, I., Jr., Kaler, J.B., Truran, J.W., Renzini, A. 1983, ApJ, 264, 604
[28] Herwig, F., Blöcker, T., Langer, N., Driebe, T. 1999, A&A, 349, L5
[29] Werner, K., Rauch, T., 1994, A&A, 284, L5
[30 17] Werner, K., Herwig, F., 2006, PASP, 118, 183
[31] Hamada T., Salpeter E.E., 1961, ApJ, 134, 683
[32] Wood M.A., 1992, ApJ, 386, 539
[33] Wood M.A., 1995, in Koester D., Werner K., eds, Lecture Notes in Physics, White Dwarfs. Springer,
Berlin, p. 41
[34] Blöcker T., 1995, A&A, 297, 727
[35] Blöcker T., Herwig F., Driebe T., Bramkamp H., Schönberner D., 1997, in Isern J., Hernanz M.,
Garcia-Berro E., eds, White Dwarfs. Kluwer, Dordrecht, p. 57
[36] Napiwotzki R., Green P.J., Saffer R.A., 1999, ApJ, 517, 399
[37] Kepler, S.O, et al., 2007, MNRAS, 375, 1315
[38] Barstow, M.A., Holberg J.B., Fleming T.A., Marsh M.C., Koester D., Wonnacott D., 1994, MNRAS,
270, 499
[39] Burleigh M.R., Barstow M.A., Fleming T.A., 1997, MNRAS, 287, 381
[40] Vennes S., Christian D., Thorstensen J.R., 1998, ApJ, 502, 763
[41] Greenstein, J.L., Oke, J.B. and Shipman, H.L., 1971, ApJ, 169, 563
[42] Kodaira, K., 1967, PASJ, 19, 172
[43] Barstow, M.A., Bond, H.E., Holberg, J.B., Burleigh, M.R., Hubeny, I., and Koester, D., 2005,
MNRAS, 362, 1134
[44] Voss, B., Koester, D., Napiwotzki, R., Christlieb, N., Reimers, D. 2007, A&A, 470, 1079
[45] Bergeron, P., Wesemael, F., Dufour, Pierre, Beauchamp, A., Hunter, C., Saffer, R. A., Gianninas, A.,
Ruiz, M. T., Limoges, M.-M., Dufour, Patrick, Fontaine, G., Liebert, J. 2011, ApJ, 737, 28
[46] Gianninas, A., Bergeron, P., Ruiz, M. T. 2011, ApJ, 743, 138
[47] Miller Bertolami, M.M., Althaus, L.G. 2006, A&A, 454, 845
[48] Nagel, T., Schuh, S., Kusterer, D.-J., et al. 2006, A&A, 448, L25
[49] Werner, K., Rauch, T., Reiff, E., Kruk, J.W. 2008, in Hydrogen-Deficient Stars, eds. K. Werner, T.
Rauch, ASP Conference Proceedings, 391, 239
[50] Bruhweiler F.C., Kondo Y., 1983, ApJ, 269, 657
[51] Vennes S., Pelletier C., Fontaine G., Wesemael F., 1988, ApJ, 331, 867
[52] Barstow M.A., et al., 1993, MNRAS, 264, 16
[53] Marsh M.C. et al., 1997, MNRAS, 286, 369
[54] Chayer P., Fontaine G., Wesemael F., 1995, ApJS, 99, 189
[55] Holberg J.B., et al., 1993, ApJ, 416, 806
[56] Holberg J.B., Hubeny I., Barstow M.A., Lanz T., Sion E.M., Tweedy R.W., 1994, ApJ, 425, L205
[57] Holberg J.B., Barstow M.A. Sion E.M., 1998, ApJ Suppl., 119, 207
[58] Barstow M.A., Good S.A., Holberg J.B., Hubeny I., Bannister N.P., Bruhweiler F.C., Burleigh M.R.,
Napiwotzki R., 2003b, MNRAS, 341, 870.
[59] Dreizler, S. 1999, A&A, 352, 632
[60] Chayer, P., Vennes, S.; Dupuis, J.; Kruk, J. W.2005, ApJ, 630, L169
[61] Werner, K., Rauch, T., Ringat, E., Kruk, J. W. 2012, ApJ, submitted
[62] Werner, K., Rauch, T., Kruk, J.W. 2007, A&A, 466, 317
[63] Barstow, M.A., et al. 2000, MNRAS, 314, 109
[64] Barstow, M.A., Dobbie, P.D., Forbes, A.E., Boyce, D.D. 2007, 15th European Workshop on White
Dwarfs, eds. R. Napiwotzki, M.R. Burleigh, ASP Conference Series, 372, 243
40
[65] Werner, K., Rauch, T., Kruk, J. W. 2008, A&A, 492, L43
[66] Wassermann, D., Werner, K., Rauch, T., Kruk, J. W. 2010, A&A, 524, A9
[67] Reiff, E., Rauch, T., Werner, K., Kruk, J.W., Herwig, F. 2007, in 15th European Workshop on White
Dwarfs, eds. R. Napiwotzki, M.R. Burleigh, ASP Conference Series, 372, 237
[68] Rauch, T., Reiff, E., Werner, K., Kruk, J.W. 2008, in Hydrogen-Deficient Stars, eds. K. Werner, T.
Rauch, ASP Conference Proceedings, 391, 135
[69] Jahn, D., Rauch, T., Reiff, E., et al. 2007, A&A, 462, 281
[70] Werner, K., Rauch, T., Barstow, M.A., Kruk, J.W. 2004, A&A, 421, 1169
[71] Lugaro, M., Ugalde, C., Karakas, A.I., et al. 2004, ApJ, 615, 934
[72] Jorissen, A., Smith, V.V., & Lambert, D.L. 1992, A&A, 261, 164
[73] Werner, K., Rauch, T., Kruk, J. W. 2010, ApJ, 719, L32
[74] Werner, K., Rauch, T., Kruk, J. W., Kurucz, R. L. 2011, A&A, 531, A146
[75] Reiff, E., Rauch, T., Werner, K., Kruk, J.W., Koesterke, L. 2008, in Hydrogen-Deficient Stars, eds. K.
Werner, T. Rauch, ASP Conference Series, 391, 121
[76] Koesterke, L., Werner, K. 1998, ApJ, 500, L55
[77] Koesterke, L., Dreizler, S., Rauch, T. 1998, A&A, 330, 1041
[78] Herald, J.E., Bianchi, L., Hillier, D.J. 2005, ApJ, 627, 424
[79] Werner, K., Hamann, W.-R., Heber, U., et al. 1992, A&A, 269, L69
[80] Bond, H.E. 2008, in Hydrogen-Deficient Stars, eds. K. Werner, T. Rauch, ASP Conference
Proceedings, 391, 129
[81] Bond, H. E. 2008, The Astronomer's Telegram, #1858
[82] Barstow M.A., Holberg J.B., 2003, Extreme Ultraviolet Astronomy, Cambridge University Press
[83] Barstow M.A., Hubeny I., Lanz T., Holberg J.B., Sion E.M., 1996, in Astrophysics in the Extreme
Ultraviolet, eds. S. Bowyer, R.F. Malina, Kluwer, Dordrecht, p 203.
[84] Lanz T., Barstow M.A., Hubeny I. and Holberg J.B., 1996, ApJ, 473, 1089
[85] Barstow, M.A., Hubeny, I. and Holberg, J.B., 1999, MNRAS, 307, 884.
[86] Dreizler, S. and Wolff, B., 1999, A&A, 348, 89.
[87] Schuh, S., Dreizler, S. and Wolff, B., 2001, in the Proceedings of the 12th European White Dwarf
Workshop, Eds. J.L. Provencal, H.L. Shipman, J. MacDonald and S. Goodchild, ASP Conference Series,
226, 79
[88] Schuh S., Dreizler S., Wolff B., 2002, A&A, 382, 164
[89] Barstow M.A. et al., 2005, MNRAS, 362, 1273
[90] Barstow M.A., et al., 2003, Proc SPIE, 4854, 654.
[91] Iben, I., Tutokov. A.V. 1984, ApJ, 284, 719
[92] Iben, I., Livio M. 1993, PASP, 105, 1373
[93] Kowalski, M., et al., 2011, ApJ, 730, 115
[94] Beuermann, K., Burwitz, V., Rauch, T. 2006, A&A, 458, 541
[95] Adamczak, J., Werner, K., Rauch, T., Schuh, S., Drake, J. J., Kruk, J. W. 2012, A&A, in prep.
[96] Vennes, S., Dupuis, J. 2002, in The High Energy Universe in Sharp Focus: Chandra Science, eds. E.M
Schlegel, S.D. Vrtilek, ASP Conference Series, 262, 57
[97] Chen, B., Schartel, N., Kirsch, M.G.F., Smith, M.J.S., Altieri, B., Pollock, A.M.T. 2004, MmSAI, 75,
561
[98] Werner, K., Drake, J.J., Rauch, T., Schuh, S., Gautschy, A. 2007, in 15th European Workshop on
White Dwarfs, eds. R. Napiwotzki, M.R. Burleigh, ASP Conference Series, 372, 225
[99] Jordan, S., Napiwotzki, R., Koester, D., Rauch, T. 1997, A&A, 318, 461
[100] Werner, K., Dreizler, S., Heber, U., Rauch, T. 1996, in Astrophysics in the Extreme Ultraviolet, eds.
S. Bowyer, R.F. Malina, Kluwer Dordrecht, p. 229
[101] Nugent, J.J., Jensen, K.A., Nousek, J. A., et al. 1983, ApJS, 51, 1
[102] Werner, K., Wolff, B. 1999, A&A, 347, L9
[103] Dufour, P., Liebert, J., Fontaine, G., Behara, N. 2007, Nature, 450, 7169
[104] Werner, K. 2008, in The Universe in X-Rays, eds. J.E. Trümper, G. Hasinger, Springer, p. 133
41
42