ULNAR NERVE ENTRAPMENT CUBITAL TUNNEL SYNDROME Epidemiology Elbow most common site for ulnar nerve entrapment 2nd most common compressive neuropathy after carpal tunnel Bilateral in 12% F>M 3-8:1 medial aspect of the elbow has 2-19 times more fat content in women than in men Aetiology 1. Constricting fascial bands 2. Subluxation of ulnar nerve over epicondyle friction generated with repeated subluxation may cause inflammation within the nerve, and in the subluxed position, the nerve may be more susceptible to inadvertent trauma. Present in 16% of normal population 3. Cubitus valgus 4. Bony spurs 5. heterotrophic ossification – secondary to burns, head injury 6. Aberrant muscle - anconeus epitrochlears( 9-30% of patients undergoing surgery for cubital tunnel; bilateral in 12%). This muscle arises from the medial humeral condyle and inserts on the olecranon, crossing superficially to the ulnar nerve, where it may cause compression. 7. Synovitis 8. Tumors 9. Ganglions 10. Direct compression Repetitive work related activities have been shown to aggravate condition but no evidence to support a causal role. Proximal compression of a nerve trunk, such as occurs with cervical radiculopathy or thoracic outlet syndrome, may lead to increased vulnerability to compression of the nerve in a distal segment. This double crush syndrome can affect the ulnar nerve and results from disruption in normal axonal transport. Pathophysiology 1. Compression As the elbow moves from extension to flexion, the distance between the medial epicondyle and the olecranon increases 5 mm for every 45 degrees of elbow flexion. Shape of the cubital tunnel changes from a round to an oval tunnel with a 2.5-mm loss of height Loss in height with flexion results in a 55% volume decrease in the canal, which further results in the mean ulnar intraneural pressure increasing from 7 mm Hg to 14 mm Hg. A combination of shoulder abduction, elbow flexion, and wrist extension results in the greatest increase in cubital tunnel pressures, with an increase in intraneural pressure 6 times normal. 2. Traction ulnar nerve elongates 5-8 mm with elbow flexion. If it doesn’t elongate because of inflammation, cause increase in intraneural pressure 3. Excursion With full range of motion (ROM) of the elbow, the ulnar nerve undergoes 10mmm of longitudinal excursion proximal to the medial epicondyle and 5mm of excursion distal to the epicondyle. Anatomy Course of Ulnar nerve at arm Medial cord (C7-T1) Starts posterior to the vessels, piercing medial intermuscular septum No branches in arm First branch is to FCU Sites of entrapment at elbow (Posner 1998) 1. Arcade of Struthers a. musculofascial band about 8 cm proximal to the medial epicondyle b. formed by attachments of i. internal brachial ligament (between insertion of coracobrachialis and intermuscular septum) ii. fascia and superficial fibers of medial head of triceps laterally iii. intermuscular septum anteriorly c. present in 70% of specimens d. beware posterior branch of medial cutaneous nerve of forearm – crosses over nerve between 6cm proximal to 4cm distal to epicondyle (90% at or proximal to epicondyle) 2. medial epicondyle and epicondylar groove a. from previous fractures (tardy ulnar palsy), arthritic spurs b. A congenitally shallow groove or a torn fibrous roof can allow the nerve to chronically subluxate or dislocate, causing neuritis and palsy. 3. Cubital tunnel a. Fibrous band, 4mm wide – extends from medial epicondyle to tip of olecranon (remnant of the anconeus epitrochlear muscle.) b. Tight in elbow flexion c. Roof = arcuate ligament of Osborne, floor = elbow capsule and medial collateral ligament (posterior and transverse component) 4. Flexor-pronator mass a. As the nerve exits the flexor carpi ulnaris, it perforates a fascial layer between the flexor digitorum superficialis and the flexor digitorum profundus 3cm distal to the cubital tunnel and 5cm distal to the medial epicondyle Blood supply of ulnar nerve Extrinsic blood supply segmental and involves 3 vessels. 1. superior ulnar collateral artery – branch from brachial 16cm above elbow 2. posterior ulnar recurrent artery – branch from ulnar artery 7cm below elbow 3. the inferior ulnar collateral artery, (minor) Typically, the inferior ulnar collateral artery, and often the posterior ulnar recurrent artery, is sacrificed with anterior transposition. At the level of the medial epicondyle, the inferior ulnar collateral artery is the sole blood supply to the ulnar nerve. In an anatomic study, no identifiable anastomosis was found between the superior ulnar collateral artery and the posterior ulnar recurrent arteries in 20 of 22 arms. Instead, communication between the 2 arteries occurred through proximal and distal extensions of the inferior ulnar collateral artery. Intrinsic An interconnecting network of vessels that run along the fascicular branches and along each fascicle of the ulnar nerve. Shown to be significant, allowing safe proximal and distal dissection over a long distance Clinical History Onset of symptoms insidious, average duration of symptoms 6 months to 1 year Sensory numbness ulnar one and a half fingers numb dorsoulnar aspect Motor weakness of grip, pinch strength and fine dexterity activities when torque applied to tool Symptoms worse with elbow flexion or resting elbow on table Examination Start at neck Spurling’s test for cervical root compression Axial compression of the head with slight extension to the right or left Suspect thoracic outlet syndrome if Dysaesthesia of ulnar nerve + medial cutaneous nerve of arm + medial cutaneous nerve of forearm Look for elbow deformities Palpate ulnar nerve in flexion and extension for subluxation Check elbow ROM Examine hand Tinels test – positive in 24% of asymptomatic patients Elbow flexion test Maximally flex elbow in forearm supination and wrist extension Positive test if symptoms in <1 minute Sensation – Semmes Weinstein (innervation density test) Intrinsic muscle sparing may occur with Martin-Gruber anastamosis (7.5%) FDP/FCU usually spared – innervation may branch off proximal to cubital tunnel or axons are in deeper fascicles in the tunnel Investigations Xray elbow (arthritis, history of trauma) - approximately 20% to 29% of patients with cubital tunnel syndrome had abnormalities, compared with 6% of controls CXR (pancoast tumor, cervical rib) and cervical spine xray as indicated Electrophysiology Nerve conduction focal slowing of ulnar nerve segment across elbow considered positive for cubital tunnel syndrome when the motor conduction velocity across the elbow is less than 50 m/s or the difference between the motor conduction velocity across the elbow and that below the elbow is greater than 10 m/s. During the test, it is important to stimulate the nerve over 2-cm intervals to precisely localize the area of entrapment. 80% of patients with mild symptoms and 47% with severe symptoms will have normal conduction velocities Postoperative velocities often fail to correlate with clinical outcomes EMG 1st dorsal interossei most commonly affected test APB to exclude C8-T1 root lesion MRI sensitive and specific in the diagnosis of ulnar nerve entrapment at the elbow. may be useful if the patient has previously undergone an anterior transposition of the ulnar nerve. increased signal intensity in the nerve is more sensitive than enlargement for entrapment of the nerve. Disadvantage: expense Classification Nonoperative Treatment 1. Splinting at 45 flexion a. studies have shown that the intraneural and extraneural pressures within the cubital tunnel are lowest at 45 degrees of flexion. 2. Protective elbow pads 3. Recommend decreasing activities of repetition that may exacerbate the patient's symptoms Nonperative measures should be tried for 3-6 months in those with mild symptoms (velocities >40ms) Urbaniak believes patients with the following traits should undergo a trial of conservative treatment: 1. early symptoms, intermittent episodes 2. mild paresthesias without significant pain 3. minimal physical findings (slight numbness), with normal motor examination Operative Treatment 1. In situ decompression May relieve traction problems by improving excursion of ulnar nerve Advantages 1. simple and easy to perform 2. low morbidity. 3. In contrast to other methods, avoids damage to the vascular supply of the nerve. 4. requires minimal or no postoperative immobilization. 5. documented results are equally successful to those of other decompression procedures Disadvantage Inability to relieve dynamic stresses on the nerve Indications 1. Mild ulnar nerve compression (McGowan 1) 2. Non subluxing nerve 3. Absence of pain around medial epicondyle 4. Normal osseous anatomy 5. Findings at surgery consistent with compression under fibrous arcade Technique 10cm incision centred between medial epicondyle and olecranon beware medial brachial and forearm nerves ulnar nerve is not disturbed in its bed if nerve subluxates – transpose or epicondylectomy 2. Medial epicondylectomy best indication - nonunion of an epicondyle fracture with ulnar nerve symptoms. Other indications are a poor bed for the ulnar nerve in the retrocondylar groove or ulnar nerve subluxation. Compared to a simple decompression, the possibility of elbow stiffness or an elbow flexion contracture developing is greater A poor choice for athletes who throw because of the significant stresses placed on the medial aspect of the elbow joint Advantages Less dissection than anterior transposition Disadvantages Elbow joint instability Bone tenderness Flexor forearm weakness Ectopic bone formation Technique 15cm incision over nerve CTR released but nerve left in bed medial epicondyle exposed subperiosteally flexor-pronator origin detached and reflected distally osteotome thru epicondyle, preserving UCL Muscle mass reinserted in elbow extension 3. Anterior transposition Indications 1. unsuitable bed for the nerve secondary to the presence of osteophytes, a tumor, a ganglion, an accessory anconeus epitrochlears muscle, heterotopic bone, significant bursal tissue or other mass. 2. significant tension on the ulnar nerve as implicated with a positive elbow flexion test result 3. subluxation of the ulnar nerve with elbow flexion 4. deformity at the elbow secondary to a valgus elbow or a tardy ulnar palsy Advantages 1. moves the ulnar nerve from an unsuitable bed to one that is less scarred. 2. nerve is effectively lengthened a few centimeters with transposition. Disadvantages 1. Technically more demanding 2. Higher complications 3. Risk of devascularising the ulnar nerve Variations 1. Subcutaneous transposition Procedure of choice for throwing athletes, during operative reduction of an acute fracture, elbow arthroplasty, and neurorrhaphy. Disadvantage is the superficial location of nerve and blood supply concerns Technique: creation of a dermofascial sling or myofascial sling to hold nerve in position 2. Intramuscular transposition yields the fewest excellent results and the most recurrences with severe ulnar nerve compression Advantage - it buries the nerve deeply, yet provides a tunnel for the nerve to pass through. It also allows the nerve to be entirely surrounded by vascularized muscle tissue. Disadvantages: it is a complicated procedure. It involves significant soft tissue dissection. Risk of perineural scar is increased, and the procedure may expose the nerve to repeated muscular contractions. Technique: create 5mm deep channel in pronator, and repair flexorpronator aponeurosis over the nerve 3. Submuscular transposition offers the best results with the fewest recurrences with severe ulnar nerve compression best salvage procedure when previous surgery has failed because it places the nerve in an unscarred bed. Also works well for patients who are very thin, in whom a subcutaneous transposition may result in an area of hypersensitivity over the transposed nerve. Many consider it the procedure of choice for symptomatic athletes who throw. Contraindications : significant scarring or distortion of the elbow joint capsule, such as in a malunited fracture or in a patient who has undergone excisional arthroplasty. Disadvantages: 1. Technically demanding procedure. 2. Higher morbidity 3. Increased pain 4. Prolonged splintage 5. risk of elbow flexion contracture is 5-10%. 6. extensive scar formation from the procedure 7. difficult procedure to revise if the patient has a recurrence. 4. Transmuscular transposition Mackinnon describes a variation of submuscular transposition step-lengthening incision in the flexor-pronator mass is used to develop fascial flaps, and a transmuscular tunnel is created through the muscle Literature Review Treatment from Dellon’s review of 50 reports 1989 1. McGowan Grade 1 – 50% success with nonoperative measures, >90% success with any surgical options 2. McGowan Grade 2 – submuscular transposition gave the best results with fewest recurrences 3. McGowan Grade 3 – Submuscular transposition gave the best results and intramuscular the worst Biggs Neurosurg 2006 Randomised study: In-situ release vs submuscular transposition Both procedures equally effective but transposition had higher complications (wound infection) Bartels Neurosurg 2005 Randomised study: In-situ release vs subcutaneous transposition Both procedures equally effective but transposition had higher complications Post Operative Ensure early mobility exercises at elbow to prevent tethering of the nerve Dellon recommends 8 days of immobilization Mackinnon recommends that all patients begin range-of-motion exercises for the hand, wrist, elbow, and shoulder within 2 to 3 days after surgical treatment Complications Recurrence Often due to incomplete release of the medial intermuscular septum (secondary compression point) or at the flexor-pronator mass (Mackinnon) Lack of recovery of intrinsics or sensation is not an indication to reoperate – it may be that recovery will never be complete in these severe cases. Should document electrophysiologic deterioration compared to preoperative levels. Medial cutaneous nerve of forearm injury (20%) Hyperalgesia of this nerve may give a false positive Tinels sign and may lead to reoperation Test by superficially blocking the nerve Treated by excising neuroma and burying it proximally in muscle FCU weakness with injury to its branches Perineural fibrosis with devascularisation recurrent ulnar nerve subluxation elbow flexion contracture most common after submuscular transposition (5-10%) Medial epicondylitis can occur from detachment of the flexor pronator mass or as a result of a medial epicondylectomy. Medial elbow instability According to O'Driscoll et al, excision of more than 20% (1-4 mm) of the width of the medial epicondyle in the coronal plane violates the important anterior band of the MCL ULNAR TUNNEL SYNDROME Compressive neuropathies in the canal of Guyon are less common, but they can also result in significant disabilities. Aetiology 1. Space occupying lesions (32-48%) Ganglia, ulnar artery aneurysms,synovitis 2. Muscle anomalies (16%) Most arise from antebrachial fascia of the forearm. Thought to be an accessory abductor digiti minim 3. Trauma – hamate fractures, distal radius fractures with marked dorsal displacement of distal fragments Anatomy Guyons canal - interaponeurotic space about 4 cm in length with discrete anatomical limits and boundaries. It extends from the proximal edge of the palmar carpal ligament, which is the distal extent of the antebrachial fascia, to the fibrous edge of the hypothenar muscles Ulnar artery lies radial and volar to the nerve Boundaries o Radial: hook of hamate, junction of the roof, including the palmaris brevis muscle, to the flexor retinaculum o Ulnar: Flexor carpi ulnaris, the pisiform, and the abductor digiti minimi constitute the ulnar wall o Roof: proximally is composed of the palmar carpal ligament which blends with the tendinous insertion of the flexor carpi ulnaris into the pisiform bone. Distally, the palmaris brevis muscle, hypothenar fat and fibrous tissue form the roof o Floor: floor is made up of the pisohamate ligament centrally, fibres of the transverse carpal ligament and the opponens digiti minimi radially, and fibres of the pisometacarpal ligament distally and ulnarly Compression can occur in 1 of 3 zones. (Gross and Gelberman) 1. Zone 1 is in the most proximal portion of the canal, where the nerve is a single structure consisting of motor and sensory fascicles o Boundaries 1. Dorsal – FDP and TCL 2. Volar/radial – palmar carpal ligament 3. Medial – pisiform and FCU o Compression by ganglions, hook fracture and anomalous muscles 2. Zones 2 - motor branch o Boundaries 1. Dorsal –pisometacarpal and pisohamate ligaments. Triquetrohamate joint, opponens digiti minimi 2. Volar – palmaris brevis, fibrous arch insertion of flexor digiti minimi over hook of hamate Radial - TCL, flexor digiti minimi, hook of hamate 3. Ulnar – abductor digiti minimi, Sensory branch o Path – leaves the tunnel between abductor and flexor digiti minimi, pierces opponens digiti minimi and then curves radially and dorsally around the hook of hamate under fibrous arch (pisohamate tunnel) o Compression caused by hook fractures and ganglions 3. Zone 3 - superficial branch o Boundaries 1. Dorsal – hypothenar fascia 2. Volar – Palmaris brevis and ulnar artery 3. Radial – motor branch 4. Ulnar – abductor digiti minimi o Compression by ulnar artery lesion (thrombosis, aneurysm), anomalous abductor digiti minimi, synovitis Clinical Pain is less a feature Often worse with sustained hyperextension and hyperflexion of wrist Weakness in hand Examine for masses Percussion test Allen’s test – for confirmation of ulnar collateral circulation; thrombosis or aneurysm of the ulnar artery can be a cause of ulnar neuropathy, which may be predicted if Allen’s test shows slowed circulation from the ulnar artery Management Surgery indicated for fractures and space occupying lesions, and failure of conservative management Landmark – nerve lies ulnar side of 4th ray Some surgeons release carpal tunnel at the same time Incision for Guyon canal release Start 3cm proximal to crease at radial border of FCU Cross wrist at 60 and continue in between pisiform and hook of hamate Angle radially parallel to proximal transverse palmar crease If compression was located in zone 2, after releasing Guyon's canal the fibrous arcade of the pisohamate tunnel is cut and the deep branch of the ulnar nerve was released distally