SC9XA
WGA4-2
16 November 2010
M Petkova
CLC/TS50238-2:2010
Railway applications - Compatibility between
rolling stock and train detection systems Part 2:
Compatibility with track circuits (pr15360)
•100% positive vote received
•Individual results yes/no - 21/0
•Publication prepared July 2010
•All editorial comments addressed
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
CLC/TS50238-3:2010
Railway applications - Compatibility between
rolling stock and train detection systems Part 2:
Compatibility with axle counters (pr21550)
•96% weighted positive vote received
•Individual results yes/no - 20/1
•Publication prepared July 2010
•All editorial comments addressed
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Definition of susceptibility limits of
axle counters
Axle counter detector
Transmission to
evaluator unit
Channel 1
Sensors
on rail
Pulse or count
transmission
circuits
Detection
circuits
Channel 2
Control circuits
Linear analogue or
digital filters
Transmission circuits
(Modulation or coding)
Pulse detection circuits
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Standard co-ordinates
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
FM – x direction
In-band
Out-band
150
Magnetic field emission limits (eff), X-direction [dBuA/m]
Band 1
Band 2
Band 3
140
130
120
110
100
90
80
70
60
10
100
1,000
10,000
Frequency f [kHz]
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
FM – y direction
In-band
Out-band
150
Band 2
Magnetic field emission limits (eff), Y-direction [dBuA/m ]
Band 1
Band 3
140
130
120
110
100
90
80
70
60
10
100
1,000
10,000
Frequency f [kHz]
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
FM – z direction
In-band
Out-band
150
Band 1
Band 2
Band 3
140
Magnetic field emission limits (eff), Z-Axis
[dBuA/m ]
130
120
110
100
90
80
70
60
10
100
1,000
10,000
Frequency f [kHz]
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Frequency Management for Axle Counters –
Band 1
Axle Counter Model
Designation
Operating frequency
range [kHz]
True -3dB
Bandwidth Bo
[Hz]
TS 50238-3
Emission field
limits (RMS)
X / Y / Z relative to
Bo [Hz]
Correction
Factor
10log B/ Bo
[B: bandwidth
defined for FM]
TS 50238-3
Emission field limits
(RMS)
X / Y / Z relative to B
[Hz]
In-band emission field limits (RMS)
for FM in X / Y / Z direction
[dBμA/m]
other evaluation parameters
Zp 30 H
Zp 30 C-NT
D 39
WDD39
27 – 32
240
114 / 94 / 101
39 ± 0.39
200
93 / 126 / 126
39 ± 0.15
1000
109.5 / 121.5 / 121,5
43 ± 1
320
100 / 83 / 98
ZP D 43
43 ± 1.7
40
100 / 85 / 98
D 50
50 ± 0.5
200
93 / 126 / 126
WDD50
50 ± 0.15
1000
109 / 121 / 121
ZP43 E **
1dB
(B = 300Hz
Band 1)
2dB
(B = 300Hz
Band 1)
-5dB
(B = 300Hz
Band 1)
0dB
(B = 300Hz
Band 1)
+9dB
(B = 300Hz
Band 1)
+2dB
(B = 300Hz
Band 1)
-5dB
(B = 300Hz
Band 1)
115 / 95 / 102
BAND 1
95 / 128 / 128
27 – 52 kHz
104 / 116 / 116
Limits X / Y / Z =
93/ 93[300Hz BW]&85[40Hz BW]/ 86
100 / 83** / 98
-3dB BW = 300Hz (4 Order)
109 / 94 / 107
Additional
nd
-3dB BW = 40Hz (2 Order) for the Y
Axis
95 / 128 / 128
Integration Time = 1ms
th
104 / 116 / 116
** Axle Counter does not fulfil the technical performance criteria of the proposed FM
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Frequency Management for Axle Counters –
Band 2
Axle Counter Model
Designation
RSR 180
AS / AZSB 300
Operating frequency
range [kHz]
250 ± 1
325 ± 25
True -3dB
Bandwidth Bo
[Hz]
10000
4000
TS 50238-3
Emission field
limits (RMS)
X / Y / Z relative to
Bo [Hz]
121 / 113.8 / 101
109 / 99 /87@ 4kHz
Correction
Factor
10log B/ Bo
[B: bandwidth
defined for FM]
TS 50238-3
Emission field limits
(RMS)
X / Y / Z relative to B
[Hz]
-1dB
(B = 10kHz
Band 2)
120 / 112.8 / 100
4dB
(B = 7.5kHz
Band 2)
113 / 103 / 91
In-band emission field limits (RMS)
for FM in X / Y / Z direction
[dBμA/m]
other evaluation parameters
BAND 2
Limits X / Y / Z =
120 / 99 / 100
th
-3dB BW = 7.5kHz (4 Order) between
234 – 287kHz 3dB BW = 7.5kHz
and
109 / 99 / 91 (7.5kHz BW)
and 87 (4kHz BW)
rd
-3dB BW = 7.5kHz (3 Order) and
rd
additional 4kHz (3 Order) for Z-Axis
between 287 – 363kHz Axis
Integration Time = 1.5ms
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Frequency Management for Axle Counters –
Band 3
Axle Counter Model
Designation
Operating frequency
range [kHz]
True -3dB
Bandwidth Bo
[Hz]
TS 50238-3
Emission field
limits (RMS)
X / Y / Z relative to
Bo [Hz]
Correction
Factor
10log B/ Bo
[B: bandwidth
defined for FM]
TS 50238-3
Emission field limits
(RMS)
X / Y / Z relative to B
[Hz]
In-band emission field limits (RMS)
for FM in X / Y / Z direction
[dBμA/m]
other evaluation parameters
BAND 3
WSD SYS 1
830 ± 26
8000
WSD SYS 1
960 ± 26
8000
RSR 123
SYS 1
1000 ± 1
6000
106 / 85 / 101
RSR 123
SYS 2
1228.8 ± 1
6000
120.5 / 114.5 / 114.5
119.5 / 113.6 / 113.6
+1dB
(B = 10kHz
Band 3)
+2dB
(B = 10kHz
Band 3)
+2dB
(B= 10kHz
Band 3)
107 / 86 / 102
Limits X / Y / Z =
106 / 85 / 101
nd
3dB BW = 10kHz (2 Order) between
740 – 1026kHz
122.5 / 116.5 / 116.5
And
121.5 / 115.6 / 115.6
119 / 113 / 113
th
3dB BW = 10kHz (4 Order) between
1026 – 1250kHz
Integration Time = 1.5ms
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Pr16623 Basic parameters for train detection systems
to allow safe detection of RST
Resolution 34/1
Noting BT decision D136/033 to set back project 16623
to PWI stage, SC9XA resolves to initiate a survey group
within WGA4-2 with the remit of identifying the
characteristics of train detection that need to be defined,
with the objective of initiating a New Work Item
Proposal.
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Report from the survey group/WGA4-2
• Progress to date
• 28 September – 1st meeting of WGA4-2
Decision taken to continue work in two subgroups
focused on track circuits and axle counters,
correspondingly
• 10 November – 1st meeting of TC survey group
• 11 November – 1st meeting of AxC survey group
• 2 parameters list developed accordingly and responsibility
for managing assigned
• Additional responsibility identified for IM for maintaining
parameters in the framework of interoperability
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Way forward
•SC9XA issues the report of the survey group to
all National Committees for 2 month enquiry to
finalise the new mandate for WGA4-2.
•WGA4-2 starts work immediately, to avoid
further delay to the introduction of
Interoperability
•WGA4-2 remains a joint WG. New members
are welcome.
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Frequency management
(rules for definition)
CCS TSI – interface Doc
RST
AxC (or TC, or other)
Design guideline
Design target
TSI
Basic
parameters for
target system
Implementation timeframe
•X years
•X years
•TS50238 (Appendix C)
•TS50238 - matured
•Compatibility
+
+
with other/old
+
vehicles
{
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
16.7 Hz traction – next step for
FM
All Track Circuits currently listed as preferred can be
taken into account for the FM.
- Austria – S50108914 106,7 Hz; S1722-8 100 Hz
- Germany – FTGS 46, FTGS 917
- Netherlands – FTGS 46, FTGS 917, HVI
- Norway – FTGS 46, FTGS 917, 95 Hz, 105 Hz
- Sweden – JRK10470
-Switzerland – UGSK 95, UGSK 3, FTGS 46, FTGS 917
-Note: TI21 listed as preferred in TS50238-2 but since
dropped from the list by the Norwegian National Rail
Administration
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
DC Traction
Proposed steps to achieve f-management
• 750 V DC special case
• 1 500 V DC and 3 000 V – f
management to be merged if possible,
as in the Energy TSI, across the f-range
• Audio F track circuits –1.6 – 7kHz
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
50Hz traction – proposed steps to
achieve f-management
50 Hz traction
• LF area
Single f + 75/275 Hz – special case
Coded track circuits
• Audio F track circuits –1.6 – 7kHz
• Higher F management – 50-70kHz
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
List of preferred track circuits for
50 Hz traction (TS50238-2)
- Belgium – Jade 2, HVI TC
- Czech Republic – EVKO 275 Hz, KOA 75 Hz, KOA 275 Hz, ASE,
ASAR
- Denmark – DC TC, 77 Hz, FTGS 46, FTGS 917
- France – UM71 C*, UM71 CB*, UM71 CTVM*, HVI, SJB*
- Italy – ATIS (CBDAC), Digicode DTC24-2
- Poland – SOT-1, SOT-2, EON-1, EON-3, EON-6
- Netherlands – Jade 1-28, Jade 1-31, Jade 1-49, Jade 1-67, Jade
2, HVI
- UK – EBI Track 200 (TI21), DC AC immune various, UM71 C TVM
SEI
- Spain – FS3000
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova
Q&A
Thank you for your attention
Convenor of WGA4-2
M Petkova