Material Requirements Planning and Enterprise Resource Planning Dr. Ron Lembke Historical Perspective ERP- Enterprise Resource Planning MRP II – Manufacturing Resource Planning mrp – material requirements planning MRP Crusade (1975) Material Requirements Planning Make sure you have enough parts when you need them Take future demands, factor in lead times (time phase), compare to on hand, order Determine order size and timing Control and plan purchasing vs. OSWO inventory management Closed-Loop MRP Capacity Consideration: Part routings Calculate loads on each work station See if scheduled load exceeds capacity Lead-time long enough to allow some shuffling to make plan feasible MRP II -- Manufacturing Resource Planning “A method for the effective planning of all resources of a manufacturing company” (APICS def.) Financial accounting incorporated Sales Operations Planning Simulate capacity requirements of different possible Master Production Schedules 1989, $1.2B MRPII sales in U.S., one third of total software sales Success? MRP Crusade Begins ERP differences Material planning Capacity planning Product design Information warehousing All functions in the entire company operate off of one common set of data Instantaneous updating, visibility ERP Sales Y2K: Worldwide sales of top 10 vendors 1995 $2.8 B 1996 $4.2 B 1997 $5.8 B $3.2 B SAP Fortune survey: 44% reported spending at least 4 times as much on implementation as on software ERP Challenges Modules assume “best practices:” Change software to reflect company ($) Change company to follow software (?) Accuracy of data Drives entire system Ownership of / responsibility for Ability to follow structure ERP Novel? “Goal-like” novel Hero learns more about ERP, deciding if it is right for his company Company rushes through installation General introduction to ERP systems, what they do, how different from MRP SAP R/3 screen shots The Heart of the Matter - mrp System for organizing WIP releases Work in Process – work that has been started, but not yet finished Consider Lead Time (LT)for each item Look at BOM to see what parts needed Bill of Materials – what goes into what Release so they will arrive just as needed Bike Production Frame OCLV Carbon Drivetrain Wheels Seat, Bars 1 Mar 7 14 21 28 4 Apr Assemble Parts Due Arrive 11 18 Snow Shovels Example – Snow Shovel Order quantity is 50 units LT is one week Simple Bill of Materials - BOM MRP Table 1 Gross Requirements 3 10 Scheduled receipts (begin) Projected Available Balance (ending) 2 4 5 40 10 50 4 54 44 44 4 Net Requirements 6 Planned Order Receipts Planned Order Releases 6 units short MRP Table 1 Gross Requirements 10 Scheduled receipts (begin) Projected Available Balance (ending) 2 3 4 5 40 10 50 4 54 44 44 4 Net Requirements 6 Planned Order Receipts Planned Order Releases Order 50 units week earlier 50 50 Ending Inventory 1 Gross Requirements 10 Scheduled receipts (begin) Projected Available Balance (ending) 2 3 4 5 40 10 50 4 54 44 44 4 44 Net Requirements 6 Planned Order Receipts Planned Order Releases Ending inventory 50 50 Terminology Projected Available balance Not on-hand (that may be greater) Tells how many will be available Available to Promise – the units aren’t spoken for yet, we can assign them to a customer Planned order releases ≠ scheduled receipts Only when material has been committed to their production Move to scheduled receipts as late as possible Preserves flexibility 1605 Snow Shovel 1605 Snow Shovel 314 scoop assembly 118 Shaft (wood) 14127 Rivet (4) 048 Scoop-shaft connector 062 Nail (4) 13122 Top Handle Assy 314 scoop assembly 314 scoop assembly 019 Blade (steel) 2142 Scoop (aluminum) 14127 Rivet (6) 13122 Top Handle Assembly 13122 Top Handle Assembly 11495 Welded Top handle bracket Assembly 457 Top handle (wood) 1118 Top handle Coupling (steel) 129 Top Handle Bracket (steel) 082 Nail (2) BOM Explosion Process of translating net requirements into components part requirements Take into account existing inventories Consider also scheduled receipts BOM Explosion Example Need to make 100 shovels We are responsible for handle assemblies. 13122 Top Handle Assembly 13122 Top Handle Assembly 11495 Welded Top handle bracket Assembly 457 Top handle (wood) 1118 Top handle Coupling (steel) 129 Top Handle Bracket (steel) 082 Nail (2) Net Requirements Part Description Top handle assy Top handle Nail (2 required) Bracket Assy Top bracket Top coupling Inv 25 22 4 27 15 39 Sch Gross Rec Req -100 25 50 --15 Net Req 75 Net Requirements Part Description Top handle assy Top handle Nail (2 required) Bracket Assy Top bracket Top coupling Inv 25 22 4 27 15 39 Sch Rec -25 50 --15 Gross Req 100 75 150 75 Net Req 75 28 96 48 13122 Top Handle Assembly 13122 Top Handle Assembly 11495 Welded Top handle bracket Assembly 457 Top handle (wood) 1118 Top handle Coupling (steel) 129 Top Handle Bracket (steel) 082 Nail (2) Net Requirements Part Description Top handle assy Top handle Nail (2 required) Bracket Assy Top bracket Top coupling Sch Inv 25 22 4 27 15 39 Gross Rec Req -100 25 75 50 150 -75 -48 15 48 Net Req 75 28 96 48 33 -- Timing of Production This tells us how many of each we need Doesn’t tell when to start Start as soon as possible? Dependent events (oh no, not that!) 13122 Top Handle Assy Order policy: Lot-for-lot 13122 Top handle LT = 2 Gross Req 1 2 20 3 25 25 5 5 4 10 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req 5 Planned Order Receipt Planned Order Release 5 5 5 6 7 20 5 8 9 10 35 10 13122 Top Handle Assy-2 Order policy: Lot-for-lot 13122 Top handle LT = 2 Gross Req 1 2 20 3 4 10 5 6 7 20 5 8 9 10 35 10 25 25 5 5 0 5 0 0 0 20 5 0 0 0 35 10 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 5 5 20 20 5 5 35 10 35 10 457 Top Handle 13122 Top handle LT = 2 Gross Req 1 2 20 3 4 10 5 6 7 20 5 8 9 10 35 10 25 25 5 5 0 5 0 0 0 20 5 0 0 0 35 10 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec 5 Pl Order Rel One handle for Each assembly LT = 2 Gross Req 5 1 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 2 5 3 25 22 22 20 5 20 5 4 20 5 5 35 10 35 10 6 7 8 35 10 9 10 457 Top Handle Order policy: Lot-for-lot LT = 2 Gross Req 1 2 5 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 3 25 22 22 17 4 20 5 5 6 7 8 35 10 9 10 457 Top Handle Order policy: Lot-for-lot LT = 2 Gross Req Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req 1 2 5 3 7 8 35 10 9 10 22 17 17 0 0 18 10 0 0 4 20 5 5 6 25 22 22 17 42 18 10 Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 18 10 082 Nail (2 required) 13122 Top handle LT = 2 Gross Req 1 2 20 3 4 10 5 6 7 20 5 8 9 10 35 10 25 25 5 5 0 5 0 0 0 20 5 0 0 0 35 10 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec 5 Pl Order Rel Two nails for Each assembly 5 LT = 1 Lot Size = 50 Gross Req 1 Sch receipts 50 Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 4 54 2 10 20 3 20 5 5 4 5 40 10 35 10 35 10 6 7 8 70 20 9 10 082 Nail (2 required) LT = 1 Lot Size = 50 Gross Req 1 Sch receipts 50 Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req 2 10 3 4 54 44 44 4 5 40 10 4 Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 6 44 44 24 6 26 50 50 7 8 70 20 50 50 4 9 10 4 4 11495 Bracket Assembly 13122 Top handle LT = 2 Gross Req 1 2 20 3 4 10 5 6 7 20 5 8 9 10 35 10 25 25 5 5 0 5 0 0 0 20 5 0 0 0 35 10 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec 5 Pl Order Rel One bracket for Each assembly 5 LT = 2 Gross Req 1 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 27 2 5 3 20 5 20 5 4 20 5 5 35 10 35 10 6 7 8 35 10 9 10 11495 Bracket Assembly Order policy: Lot-for-lot LT = 2 Gross Req 1 2 5 3 4 20 5 5 6 7 8 35 10 9 10 27 27 22 22 2 0 3 0 0 0 35 10 0 0 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 3 3 35 10 35 10 129 Top Bracket LT = 2 Gross Req 1 2 5 3 4 20 5 5 6 7 8 35 10 9 10 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req 27 22 22 2 Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 3 LT = 1 Gross Req 1 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 15 2 3 3 3 35 10 3 35 10 35 10 4 5 6 7 35 10 8 9 10 129 Top handle bracket Order policy: Lot-for-lot LT = 1 Gross Req 1 2 3 3 4 5 6 7 35 10 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 15 15 15 12 12 23 10 23 10 23 10 8 9 10 1118 Top handle coupling LT = 2 Gross Req 1 2 5 3 4 20 5 5 6 7 8 35 10 9 10 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req 27 22 22 2 Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 3 LT = 3 Safety Stock = 20 Gross Req 1 Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 39 2 3 35 10 3 35 10 35 10 3 3 4 5 6 35 10 7 8 9 10 1118 Top handle coupling Order policy: Lot-for-lot LT = 3 Safety Stock = 20 1 2 Gross Req Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req 4 5 6 7 35 10 15 39 39 54 51 51 16 4 Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 3 3 4 4 8 9 10 1118 Top handle coupling LT = 3 Safety Stock = 20 Gross Req Sch receipts Proj. Avail Bal (ending) Net Req 1 2 3 3 5 6 7 35 10 8 9 10 15 39 39 54 51 51 20 20 20 20 20 20 4 10 Pl Order Rec Pl Order Rel 4 4 4 10 10 Other considerations Safety stock if uncertainty in demand or supply quantity Safety LT if uncertainty in arrival time Don’t let available go down to 0 Place order earlier than necessary Order quantities EOQ – Economic Order Quantity, Fixed Size If that’s not enough, order what you need, OR order two or more of the Fixed Size Lot-For-Lot, Periodic Order quantity, others Summary Demand for final products Compute needs for it and Dependent Demand for components Look at all parts of the Bill of Materials Complete the Table for each Bottom row (Pl Order Releases) becomes top row (Gross Requirements) of input components (also called children) Multiplied by # needed for each parent