Federal Transportation Administration National Transit Database Rural Reporting CalACT Spring Conference & Expo May 22, 2014 NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration NTD Contact Information Federal Transit Administration National Transit Database 943 Glenwood Station Lane, Suite 102 Charlottesville, VA 22901 (888) 252-0936 NTDHelp@dot.gov Monday – Friday 8:00am – 7:00pm Eastern NTD National Transit Database 2 Federal Transportation Administration NTD Program @ FTA Headquarters Keith Gates Gary DeLorme NTD Program Manager NTD Senior Advisor 202-366-1794 202-366-1652 keith.gates@dot.gov gary.delorme@dot.gov NTD National Transit Database 3 Federal Transportation Administration Presenters Andy Lofton Joe Eldredge Validation Project Manager Validation Analyst 434-260-1175 434-993-8690 andy.lofton.ctr@dot.gov joseph.eldredge.ctr@dot.gov NTD National Transit Database 4 Federal Transportation Administration Agenda • Background – What is the National Transit Database? – Who Reports? • Data Submission – How Does Data Get to NTD? • Collection & Validation • State 5311 program • NTD Legacy (Current), NTD NextGen (In Development) • Data Product – What does FTA do with the data? – What data resources are produced? NTD National Transit Database 5 Federal Transportation Administration BACKGROUND NTD National Transit Database 6 Federal Transportation Administration What is the NTD? • Online reporting system for transit providers • Title 49 U.S.C. 5335(a) establishes the National Transit Database: “The Secretary shall. . . maintain a reporting system, using uniform categories to accumulate public transportation financial, operating, and asset condition information . . . using a uniform system of accounts” NTD National Transit Database 7 Federal Transportation Administration Why does the NTD exist? • Serves as a tool for public transportation service planning • Collects information for any level of government to make public sector investment decisions • Is a resource for peer agency comparisons, statewide statistics • Supports FTA apportionment formulas – 5307, 5311, 5329, 5337 NTD National Transit Database 8 Federal Transportation Administration Who Reports? • Beneficiaries of federal funds – State reports data for all 5311 subrecipients – Data must be reported according to FTA’s Uniform System of Accounts and the NTD reporting manual. • Voluntary reporters – FTA encourages all public transportation providers to report, provided they can adhere to reporting requirements • Urban providers (5307 beneficiaries) report directly to the NTD Urban Module, not through the State NTD National Transit Database 9 Federal Transportation Administration Who Benefits from §5311? §5311(a) – Definitions (1) Recipient – a State or Indian tribe that receives a transit program grant directly from the Federal Transit Administration (2) Subrecipient – a State or local governmental authority, a nonprofit organization, or an operator of public transportation or intercity bus service that receives Federal transit program grants funds indirectly through a recipient. (Chapter 53 of title 49, as amended by MAP-21) NTD National Transit Database 10 Federal Transportation Administration Funding Structure FTA Provider F Provider E Provider D Provider C Provider B Subrecipients: Caltrans Provider A Recipient: NTD National Transit Database 11 Federal Transportation Administration NTD and CTSAs • NTD collects service data for transit provided by Coordinated Transportation Service Agencies (CTSAs) • To report, service must meet NTD requirements • Challenges: – Definition of public transportation – Identifying sources of funds NTD National Transit Database 12 Federal Transportation Administration DATA REPORTING PROCESS NTD National Transit Database 13 Federal Transportation Administration Data Reporting Process Closeout NTD Analyst DOT Transit Agency Raw Data NTD National Transit Database NTD Senior Staff/Program Managers Data Product Federal Transportation Administration Finances, Assets, and Service DATA COLLECTION NTD National Transit Database 15 Federal Transportation Administration Data Collection Caltrans sends out form known as RU-20 each year to subrecipients of 5311. Templates available here. NTD National Transit Database 16 Federal Transportation Administration Types of Data Collected • §5311(b)(4) – Data Collection “each recipient shall submit an annual report . . . on capital investment, operations, and service provided with funds received under this section, including – ” • Total operating costs • Vehicle revenue miles • Fleet size • Sources of revenue • Ridership • Fleet type • Total annual capital costs • Related facilities (Chapter 53 of title 49, as amended by MAP-21) NTD National Transit Database 17 Federal Transportation Administration www.ntdprogram.gov NTD National Transit Database 18 Federal Transportation Administration Public Transit Service • Agencies must report revenue miles, revenue hours, and unlinked passenger trips for each mode of public transportation operated by the agency. • Public transportation – – – – regular and continuing general or special service open to public Includes complimentary ADA & non-emergency medical NTD National Transit Database 19 Federal Transportation Administration Public Transit Service - Modes • The most common modes for transportation in rural areas include: – – – – Bus (Fixed, Deviated-Fixed, Both) Demand Response Demand Taxi Vanpool • Each mode presents unique challenges in terms of data collection NTD National Transit Database 20 Federal Transportation Administration Revenue Service • The time when a vehicle is available to the general public and there is an expectation of carrying passengers • These passengers may: – Directly pay fares – Be subsidized by public policy – Provide payment through some contractual arrangement • Vehicles operated in fare free service are considered to be in revenue service NTD National Transit Database 21 Federal Transportation Administration Revenue Service • Layover and recovery time are included – The hours scheduled at the end of the route before the departure time of the next trip • This time is scheduled for two reasons: – To provide time for the vehicle operator to take a break (layover) – To provide time to get back on schedule before the next trip departs if the trip arrives late at the end of the route (recovery) NTD National Transit Database 22 Federal Transportation Administration Revenue Service • The following examples are excluded from revenue service: – – – – Deadhead Vehicle maintenance testing School bus service Charter service NTD National Transit Database 23 Federal Transportation Administration Deadhead • The miles and hours that a vehicle travels when out of revenue service • Deadhead includes: – Leaving or returning to the garage or yard facility – Changing routes – When there is no expectation of carrying revenue passengers NTD National Transit Database 24 Federal Transportation Administration Unlinked Passenger Trips • These are the number of passengers who board public transportation vehicles • Passengers are counted each time they board vehicles no matter how many vehicles they use to travel from their origin to their destination NTD National Transit Database 25 Federal Transportation Administration Sponsored Trips • Sponsored service is paid, in whole or in part, directly to the transit provider by a third party. • May be offered by providers as part of the Coordinated Human Services Transportation Plan • Common sponsors include: – – – – – – the Veterans Administration Medicaid sheltered workshops The Arc Assisted Living Centers Head Start programs NTD National Transit Database 26 Federal Transportation Administration Rural CA - Total Trips by Type 10,000,000 8,000,000 6,000,000 4,000,000 2,000,000 0 2010 2011 Sum of REGULAR TRIPS 2012 Sum of COORDINATED TRIPS NTD National Transit Database 27 Federal Transportation Administration Revenue Miles & Hours • Vehicle Revenue Miles (VRM) – include the miles that vehicles are scheduled to, or actually travel while in revenue service • Vehicle Revenue Hours (VRH) – include the hours that vehicles are scheduled to or actually travel while in revenue service NTD National Transit Database 28 Federal Transportation Administration Rural CA - Revenue Miles by Mode 25,000,000 20,000,000 VP 15,000,000 DT DR 10,000,000 CB MB 5,000,000 0 2010 2011 2012 NTD National Transit Database 29 Federal Transportation Administration Examples - Revenue Service • Through a broker, Nursing Home schedules a Medicaid-sponsored trip – Bob’s Dial-a-Ride cutaway departs from garage @ 10:45 – Arrives @ 11:00, 5 passengers board vehicle @ 11:02 – Drops off passengers at destination 3 miles away @ 11:15 • Resulting Data – 3 vehicle revenue miles – 0.25 vehicle revenue hours – 5 sponsored unlinked passenger trips NTD National Transit Database 30 Federal Transportation Administration Volunteers • Many coordinated systems use volunteer drivers • The reporting agency may include volunteer trips IF: – – – – It has control over volunteer resources It ensures there is an attempt to share rides It tracks service data: revenue miles, revenue hours, trips It records cost of operating, includes fuel reimbursement • The following examples are not reportable to NTD: – Passengers call the volunteer driver directly for transport, bypassing transit provider – Passengers are transported by a family member or friend – Passengers self-transport to the final destination NTD National Transit Database 31 Federal Transportation Administration How to Record Financial Data § 5335 (b) – Reporting and Uniform Systems Accrual Accounting Expenses are recorded when incurred, regardless of whether or not receipt of the revenue takes place in the same reporting period Ex. A passenger buying $10 worth of fare, but only expending $5. (Chapter 53 of title 49, as amended by MAP-21) NTD National Transit Database 32 Federal Transportation Administration How to Record Financial Data § 5335 (b) – Reporting and Uniform Systems Accrual Accounting Expenditures are recorded as soon as they result in liabilities for benefits received, regardless of whether or not payment of the expenditure is made in the same reporting period. Ex. An employee receives a paycheck 10 days after it was issued. The receipt date is in a new fiscal year. (Chapter 53 of title 49, as amended by MAP-21) NTD National Transit Database 33 Federal Transportation Administration Financial Information • Report the total amount of expenses incurred by your agency annually • This information is separated into two functions on rural NTD forms: – Operating Expenses • Includes administrative/vehicle maintenance – Capital Expenses • Expenses are broken out by source of funding used to cover the expense. NTD National Transit Database 34 Federal Transportation Administration Operating Expenses • Agencies report – The day-to-day expenses of operating and maintaining vehicles; maintaining other equipment, buildings, and grounds – General administration costs including marketing and customer support; finance and procurement; planning and service development; legal costs NTD National Transit Database 35 Federal Transportation Administration Operating Expenses Examples: California: • • • • Year 2012 2011 2010 Salaries, wages, benefits Utilities – Electric, water Materials and Supplies Equipment lease and rental • Cleaning services • Insurance • Taxes Average $71,930,292 $75,322,667 $80,381,597 NTD National Transit Database 36 Federal Transportation Administration Capital Expenses • Agencies report: – The expenses related to the purchase of equipment where equipment means an article of non-expendable personal property having a useful life of more than one year – An acquisition cost which equals the lesser of • The capitalization level established by the government unit for financial statement purposes • $5,000 (Office of Management and Budget, Circular A87) NTD National Transit Database 37 Federal Transportation Administration Capital Expenses Examples: • Vehicles • Buildings California: Year 2012 2011 2010 Average $23,029,069 $12,403,860 $17,215,114 NTD National Transit Database 38 Federal Transportation Administration Recording Expenses • Subrecipients receive funding from different grants and have access to multiple sources of revenue • When reporting to the State, subrecipients must: – Report the original source of funds – Report the total amount used for reimbursement NOT the total grant or award. NTD National Transit Database 39 Federal Transportation Administration Sources of Revenue • Four major categories • Subrecipients must report revenues as: – – – – Federal State Local Other (Directly Generated) NTD National Transit Database 40 Federal Transportation Administration Local • Financial assistance from local entities that support the operation of the transit system, including: – Tax levies: A specified amount from local levies that is dedicated to supporting public transit operation costs – General funds: Transfers from the general fund of local governments to cover the Local Share portion of the transit system budget – Specified contributions: Contributions from city, county or other municipal government towards the Local Share portion of the transit system budget NTD National Transit Database 41 Federal Transportation Administration State Funds • State programs that support public transportation vary • Caltrans Grant Programs: – – – – – Partnership Planning for Sustainable Transportation Transit Planning for Sustainable Communities Transit Planning for Rural Communities Environmental Justice Transportation Planning Grants Community-Based Transportation Planning Grants NTD National Transit Database 42 Federal Transportation Administration Federal Funds • Caltrans is the designated recipient of 5311 – Administers FTA grants for rural and small urban • Other Common FTA Grants supporting CTSA providers – 5310 (Elderly Individuals and Individuals with Disabilities) – Previous: 5316 (Job Access and Reverse Commute) – Previous: 5317 (New Freedom) • Coordinated/Consolidated Human Service Plans NTD National Transit Database 43 Federal Transportation Administration Other; Directly Generated • Sources in this category include: – – – – – Fares Contracts Bus Advertisements Vending Machines Donations NTD National Transit Database 44 Federal Transportation Administration Rural CA - Operating Assistance Expended by Source 100,000,000 Other Funds 80,000,000 FTA Parks Program (§5320) FTA New Freedom Program funds (§5317) 60,000,000 FTA Job Access and Reverse Commute Formula (§5316) FTA Rural Areas (§5311 & ARRA §5311) 40,000,000 FTA Elderly and Disabled (§5310) State funds Local Funds 20,000,000 Contract Revenues Fare Revenues 0 2011 2012 NTD National Transit Database 45 Federal Transportation Administration DATA VALIDATION NTD National Transit Database 46 Federal Transportation Administration Caltrans Validation • After transit provider or reporting entity sends to State, 5311 office validates before submitting to NTD – Several data integrity checks NTD National Transit Database 47 Federal Transportation Administration NTD Validation Integrity – Revenue miles per revenue hour Consistency – 2012 vs. 2013 Timeliness – Caltrans submits on 11/30/13 Completeness – Service data for volunteers Accuracy – Revenue miles vs. actual miles Validity – Positive numbers only for RU-20 NTD National Transit Database 48 Federal Transportation Administration Rural CA - Average Revenue MPH by Mode 35 30 25 20 MB CB 15 DR 10 5 0 2010 2011 2012 NTD National Transit Database 49 Federal Transportation Administration Revenue Hours per Mile NTD National Transit Database 50 Federal Transportation Administration NTD ONLINE REPORTING NTD National Transit Database 51 Federal Transportation Administration www.ntdprogram.gov Resources Login NTD National Transit Database 52 Federal Transportation Administration NTD NextGen • New online reporting system – Currently in development; currently in pilot testing – Content very similar to NTD Legacy – Interface mimics popular online tax software • Subrecipients file an annual Identification Form (B-10) that determines structure of report. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration NTD NextGen (cont.) • Structure for general rural public transit providers: – Reduced Reporting Form (RR-20) • Layout varies based on reporter type selected • Comparable to Financial, Service, Safety sections of RU-20 – Revenue Vehicle Inventory (A-30) • Comparable to Vehicles subsection of RU-20 – Maintenance Facilities Form (A-10) • Comparable to Facilities subsection of RU-20 NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration New Requirements • Beginning with Report Year 2014, subrecipients will provide more information on revenue vehicle inventory. • • • • • • • • • • • RVI ID Number of Vehicles in Total Fleet Vehicle Type Ownership Type Funding Source Number of Active Vehicles in Fleet Number of ADA Accessible Vehicles Fuel Type Vehicle Length Seating Capacity Used for another mode NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration New Requirements • Beginning with Report Year 2014, subrecipients will allocate operating expenses by Mode and Type of Service (Directly Operated or Purchased) NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Cost Allocation Methods • Determine which expenses are direct expenses and can be easily traced to a particular mode/TOS. • Determine which expenses are joint expenses. These costs are incurred for the benefit of more than one mode/TOS and cannot be easily traced to a specific mode/TOS. • Allocate joint expenses or shared costs to each mode/TOS. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Cost Allocation Methods (cont.) • Recognizing that some agencies may not already allocate joint costs by mode/TOS, NTD suggests common allocation variables: – – – – Revenue Hours Revenue Miles Number of Employees Ridership NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Example—Allocating by VRM • Subrecipient operates a Dial-a-Ride or Demand Response (DR) service and a fixed-route bus (MB) service – Collects Annual Vehicle Revenue Miles (VRM) for each mode separately. • DR: 200,000 VRM • MB: 300,000 VRM – Does not allocate joint Operating Costs by mode. • Total Annual Operating Expenses: $1,000,000 NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Example—Allocating by VRM NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration DATA PRODUCT NTD National Transit Database 61 Federal Transportation Administration Data Product Uses • Public transportation service planning • Facilitate public sector investment decisions • Peer grouping and agency comparisons, statewide statistics • FTA apportionment formulas – 5307, 5311, 5329, 5337 NTD National Transit Database 62 Federal Transportation Administration Transportation Planning • Serves as a base for public transportation service planning – Example: Toolkit for Rural Community Coordinated Transportation Services • Published by FTA in 2004; used Rural NTD data to study efficient coordinated systems NTD National Transit Database 63 Federal Transportation Administration Comparisons and Performance Measurement • Resource for peer agency comparisons, statewide statistics – Performance measures development, as explained by CalACT NTD National Transit Database 64 Federal Transportation Administration Cost per Mile by Region $7.00 $6.00 Cost per Mile – FY 2012 $5.00 $4.00 Average Cost per Mile-Rural $3.00 Average Cost per Mile-Urban $2.00 $1.00 $0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 FTA Region NTD National Transit Database 65 Federal Transportation Administration Rural CA – Number of Vehicles by Type and Manufacture Year 30 Total FTA-funded State/Localfunded Total 20 Automobiles Bus Cutaway Minivan Over-the-road bus School Bus 10 Van 0 1992 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 NTD National Transit Database 66 Federal Transportation Administration Rural CA – Number of Vehicles by Type and Manufacture Year 30 Total State/Localfunded FTA-funded FTA 20 Bus Cutaway Minivan Van 10 0 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 NTD National Transit Database 67 Federal Transportation Administration Rural CA – Number of Vehicles by Type and Manufacture Year Total FTA-funded State/Localfunded State/Local NTD National Transit Database 68 Federal Transportation Administration RESOURCES NTD National Transit Database 69 Federal Transportation Administration www.ntdprogram.gov Manual Templates NTD National Transit Database 70 Federal Transportation Administration Reporting Manual The manual provides: - An overview of NTD - An in-depth explanation of each form - Line-by-line form instructions - Examples NTD National Transit Database 71 Federal Transportation Administration Webinars & Screen Sharing • Analysts are available to deliver Webinars when requested to help review the reporting process. • Remote access and screen sharing can help agencies navigate the online reporting system. NTD National Transit Database 72 Federal Transportation Administration Thank You Jacklyn Montgomery, CalACT Katherine Pongratz, CalTrans California Public Transit Operators NTD National Transit Database 73 Federal Transportation Administration Questions? • Contact – Joe Eldredge Joseph.Eldredge.CTR@dot.gov – Loucas Lamkin Loucas.Lamkin.CTR@dot.gov – NTD Help Desk (888) 252-0936 NTDHelp@dot.gov NTD National Transit Database 74 Federal Transportation Administration Line 01 For consistency, NTD asks that the full legal name is provided. This helps those who are unfamiliar with your agency correctly identify you. Acronyms can be provided on a different line. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 01 If your agency changes its legal name, please report the name the agency is operated under on the last day of the reporting period. Please be sure to notify the analyst of the change. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 01 NTD offers two places to report mailing addresses. The line “mailing address line 1” must be filled out even though there is a separate line for Post Office Boxes. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 01 Please report the last day of your report year to ensure data is being reported for the correct report period and so analysts can reconcile your data with another agency, if necessary. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 01 You do not have to restate the P.O. Box if it is given in Mailing Address 1 line. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 01 List up to five counties. If there are more, list only the county where the agency is headquartered followed by the number of additional counties. If multiple states, include the state in parenthesis. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 01 If you do not have a website, please enter N/A in the URL box. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 02 Please keep the contact information updated from year to year. Notify DOT if the phone number or contact person changes within the report year. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 03 “Other” is usually only selected for subrecipients who are in the planning stage (not operating modes). If you select, please be sure to describe the service area in the box that appears next to the window. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 04 All modes must be reported separately. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 04 NTD validation analysts can help you determine whether your mode should be “other” NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 04 A process should be in place to try to ride share. If not, this service is not considered public transportation. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 06 - Revenue Sources Report revenues expended NOT earned The grant award amount can be larger than the amount actually used. Revenues expended should be reported according the revenue’s original source. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 06 If you do not track fares, but instead accept donations, report this on the “Other Funds” line. If the program is fare-free and supported by a third party, please report that contribution on the appropriate line. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 07 Contract Revenues do not include: - advertising - purchase of transit passes or other fare media - funds received pursuant to a service agreement with a State of local social service agency or a private social service organization NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Lines 08 - 09 Local sources used for operating assistance. Do not report funding passed through the state from a federal grant on Line 09. The line is intended for statelevel programs only. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 10a – 10b If 5309 funds were expended on operating activities, report those funds in Column a. Ensure the funds are not from 5339. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 10a – 10b A match for the 5310 program should be reported. This may have been provided by another party, such as the state and would be reported as state funds. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 10c – 10f If a tribe contributes funds towards an existing service with Tribal Transit Program dollars, those funds should show on line 10d. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 10g – 10j Enter 0s if no funds were expended from these programs. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 10k – 10l Report all other FTA program funds on line 10k. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 10k – 10l Report federal Medicaid and other federal programs not listed, on line 10l State Medicaid on Line 09 for state funds. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 11 Line 11 is a summation of all sources of funding, line 06-10l. Must equal total federal funds expended during current report year. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 11a Report any donations and contributions from sources other than federal, state or local governments. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 12 Line 12 is a summation of all funding sources, lines 0611a. NTD RU-20 National Transit Database Federal Transit Administration National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Validation Tip Line 05 and Line 12 should match. Line 12 is a sum of all funding sources used to cover the expense listed on Line 05. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 13 To add new vehicles, click add fleet group. If the vehicles acquired are the same type and manufacture year, they must be reported on the same line. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 13 Choose the vehicle type that best matches the vehicle. NTDYear of manufacture is not model year. National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 13 The largest source of funding for the vehicle should be reported. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 13 To delete a fleet, click the delete button and then save the form. That entire fleet group will be removed. If only one vehicle was removed from a fleet, edit the number in column g. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 14 – Validation Tip The summation of column “a” should always be larger than the summation of column “g” or the values should match NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 15 Enter 0 if the vehicles are serviced at a local station. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 16 and Line 17 Report the number of volunteer drivers available to the agency and the number of vehicles routinely used. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 18 Service data by mode NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 18 Report all miles traveled in revenue service. Please exclude deadhead, training, testing, and school bus and charter services. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 18 Report all hours traveled in revenue service. Please exclude deadhead, training, testing, and school bus and charter services. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 18 – Example NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 18 One bus makes 40 trips a day, is that what you are asking here? NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 18 Passenger trips are individual boardings, i.e., each time a person gets “on-board” a vehicle. The total trips will be the total passenger count for the year. NTD National Transit Database Federal Transportation Administration Line 20, 21, 22 - Immediate transport to a hospital - A death within 30 days - Property damage >$25,000 NTD National Transit Database