Paper

advertisement

The Future of Bancassurance

Rebuilding Confidence

International Insurance Society Annual Seminar

June 07, 2010

Oscar Zimmerman

SVP & Managing Director, Corporate Insurance

The Bank of Nova Scotia

2

Agenda

• Bancassurance

• Customer Needs

• Opportunities

• Challenges

• Scotiabank Strategy

• Key Success Factors

• Operational Results

• Closing

Definition

BANCASSURANCE

Distribution of any insurance product through Bank channels

Products - Bank Owned Insurer Products – Other Insurers

Branch Officers Insurance Agents External Sales Forces

Telemarketing Internet Mailing

3

Types of Products

BANCASSURANCE

• Risk Protection

• Life and health insurance

• Automobile and home insurance

Creditor Insurance

Optional Insurance

4

• Wealth Accumulation

• Savings with an insurance component

• Accumulation and payout annuities

• Pensions

Universal Life

Annuities

5

Retail Banking Products

CUSTOMER NEEDS

• Choice

• Simple, easy to understand and purchase

• Convenience

• Service

• Trust the “promise to pay”

• Price competitive

Bancassurers are uniquely positioned to offer an integrated value proposition to meet customer needs at various life stages.

6

Life Stages

CUSTOMER NEEDS

Typical Changes in Life Stage

Couple

• Buy Home

• Start Saving

• Acquire Goods

New

Family

• Buy Home

• Acquire Goods

• Protect Income

Single

• Buy Car

• First Job

• Start Saving

Established

Family

• Save for

Education

• Reduce Debt

Independent

• Plan to retire

• Buy home

• Plan estate

Pre-

Retirement

• Plan to Retire

• Accumulate

• Plan Estate

Retired

• Disburse

Savings

• Plan Estate

It is easier to cross sell insurance to existing relationships

7

How Does Bancassurance Help Retail Banks?

RETAIL BANK OPPORTUNITY

• Protects credit insurance

• Improves loyalty and cost utilization

• Additional fee income boosts shareholder ROE

• Insurance risk taking is less correlated to the credit cycle

• Approved borrowers tend to be better insurance risks

8

Cultural Differences Between Financial Sectors

BANCASSURANCE CHALLENGES

BANKING INSURANCE

Consumer Brand

Transactions

Distributor Brand

Sales &

Relationship-based

Fixed cost Variable cost

Liquidity, credit

& financial risk management

Mortality, morbidity, property & financial risk management

Short Term

Focus

Long Term

Focus

Deconsolidated capital ratio test

Chief Risk Officer

(CRO)

Deconsolidated capital ratio test

Appointed Actuary

(AA)

Closing the Cultural Gaps

 Protect Bank Reputation

 Focus on Retail

 Understand and manage insurance risk volatility

 Enhance ROE with stable recurring income

9

Regulatory Framework

BANCASSURANCE CHALLENGES

• Bank and Insurance sectors separately regulated

• Outdated regulations

• Limits of regulatory restrictions

• International insurance regulation vary

10

Strength of Canada & Canadian Financial System

SCOTIABANK STRATEGY

• Strong Canadian Financial System

• Sound Canadian Banking System

• World Economic Forum

Relative bank share price performance

30

25

20

15

10

5

0

-5

-10

-15

-20

-25

Canada

* As of April 30, 2010.

Source: Bloomberg; Scotia Capital.

Australia U.S.

5-Year CAGR

10-Year CAGR

Switzerland

Data to May 3, 2010

U.K.* Japan*

Scotiabank Around The World

SCOTIABANK STRATEGY

• 14.6 million customer in some 50 countries

• 68,000 employees worldwide (32,000 in Canada)

• Personal, Commercial, Corporate and Investment Banking

• 2700 + Branches and Offices, 5800 ABMs

• Diversified Business Lines: Canadian Banking, International

Banking, Scotia Capital

• Market Cap. Circa $50 billion, USD (Top 25)

• Tier 1 capital ratio 11.2%, S & P AA-

• Net Income 2009 Full Year $C3.5 billion ROE 16.7%

2010 Half Year $C2.1 billion ROE 18.7%

11

12

Top Tier ROE Versus Global Peer Group

SCOTIABANK STRATEGY

2009 Return on Equity (Reported)

Scotia

Canada

16.7%

Royal 11.9

U.S.

Wells Fargo 9.9%

US Bancorp 8.2

International

Credit Suisse 18.3%

BBVA 16.0

BMO

CIBC

TD

9.9

9.4

8.4

JPMorgan 6.0

Commonwealth

Bank of Australia

15.8

Bank of

America

Citibank n/m n/m

Deutsche

HSBC

14.6

5.1

13

Global Priorities

SCOTIABANK STRATEGY

• Sustainable revenue growth

• Capital management

• Leadership

• Prudent risk management and appetite

• Efficiency and expense management

14

Scotiabank Mission

SCOTIABANK STRATEGY

To be the best at helping customers become financially better off by finding relevant solutions to meet their unique needs.

Four Cornerstone Strategy

15

Bancassurance Strategy

SCOTIABANK STRATEGY

• Focus on helping customers protect their assets

• Leverage Bank distribution and servicing capabilities, financial strength and brand awareness

• Assume retail insurance risks

• Assume 3 rd party reinsurance risks that are less correlated with traditional bank risk

16

Insurance Footprint

SCOTIABANK STRATEGY

Direct Writing Subsidiaries

Canada (L & H)

Dominican Republic (L & H)

El Salvador (L & H / P & C)

Jamaica (L & H)

Trinidad (L & H)

Reinsurance Subsidiary

Barbados (L & H / P & C)

Joint Venture

El Salvador (Auto)

Insurance Brokerages

Canada

Chile

Costa Rica

Dominican Republic

Puerto Rico

Insurance Fee Income

Caribbean

Central America

Mexico

Peru

Key Success Factors in Bancassurance

KEY SUCCESS FACTORS

• Identify profit zone in retail value chain

• Integrated sales processes

• Sales Management

• Optimize corporate structure and risk taking business model

• Manage adverse earnings volatility

Teamwork is critical to strategy execution

17

Identify Profit Zone in the Retail Value Chain

KEY SUCCESS FACTORS

Retail Banking

Products

Retail Consumers

Protection Needs

18

Retail Banking Sales &

Service Platforms

Value Proposition Differs By Customer Segment

19

Integrated Sales Processes

KEY SUCCESS FACTORS

Simple product portfolio

Low product complexity

Attractive packaging

Streamlined sales process

Comprehensive sales support

Bundled sales

Systematic sales management

Leverage

Information

Technology

Systems and

Customer Data

Integrated Sales

Management

Simplified underwriting

Systematic sales guidance

Rigorous Market conduct compliance

Sales Management

KEY SUCCESS FACTORS

• Measurable bank channel sales targets

• Appropriate incentives impacting bonus compensation

• Fully automated and simple sales process

• Provide continuous product and sales training

20

21

Optimize Business Model

KEY SUCCESS FACTORS

Decision Criteria:

• Local Market Structure

• Insurer Financial Strength

• Regulatory Environment

• Retained Risk Appetite

• Management Capacity

• Speed to Market

Choices:

Underwriting Subsidiary

• Pure Distribution

• Distribution/Reinsurance

• Joint Venture

22

Manage Adverse Earnings Volatility

KEY SUCCESS FACTORS

• Insurance Oversight Committee

• External Appointed Actuaries for Subsidiaries

• Follow Canadian Insurance Prudential Standards

• Pre-Approval of limits for catastrophic events

23

Operational Results

• Protect Bank Reputation

• Focus on Retail

• Understand and manage insurance risk

• Enhanced ROE, Stable Recurring Income

Closing Observations

• Insurance profits held firm during financial crisis

• Bank colleagues were very appreciative

24

25

Thank You

Download