Presentation 3 Company Background System Requirements Synopsis Alternative Matrix Pre-Packaged Software Outsourcing Cloud Computing Custom Development Implementation Plan Lesson’s Learned National Tint and Trim is a small, locally owned audio and tint store in Ruston, Louisiana. It has a minimum amount of employees and has been conducting the majority of it’s business the conventional way: hard copy. As the company’s customer base continues to grow, it would like to make it’s business processes more efficient. National Tint and Trim requires an information system that will integrate website functionality with inventory automation, appointment scheduling, online quoting, tracking consumer buyer statistics, and improving customer service. This will allow customers an ease of access to the information while improving the company’s image. This will be accomplished by integrating the business and suppliers through a central database. Alternative Matrix National Tint and Trim Alternative 1: Packaged Software NPV $21,626.30 -$15,062.28 $2,855.75 -60,335.83 Return On Investment 176.06% -11.19% 4.00% -54.94% Tangible Benefits Intangible Benefits Reduced inventory costs by 5% of yearly inventory costs Increase efficiency by 5% of yearly sales Reduce labor by $2,600 per year Alternative 2: Outsourcing Score 4 4 Better Supplier Relations Increase Company Reputation Increase Quality of Service Score Increase efficiency (5% of sales) Reduce Risk Reduced Labor Costs 5 Better Supplier Relations Increase Company Reputation Increase Quality of Service More time to complete projects Alternative 3: Cloud Computing Alternative 4: Custom Development Economic 3 Reduced Maintenance Costs Lower Infrastructure Cost Reduced Installation Cost and Testing Reduced Information Technology Yearly System Assessment Access System From Any Browser Increased Scalability Easy Implementation Frees Up Internal Resources Document Compatibility Increased Data Reliability Device Independence Score 3 Weighted Score 2 20 3 15 Space Freed Reduce Inventory Costs 5 Score Better supplier relations Increase positive company reputation Increase quality of service Technology Familiarity with Business Process Alternative 1: Packaged Software Team: Basic knowledge regarding National Tint and Trim business processes Novice knowledge base of the Quickbooks Point of Sale and Appointment-Plus software packages Client: Mr. Merritt has a general knowledge of the way Quickbooks software packages work. Mr. Merritt has no knowledge of the way AppointmentPlus software works. Score Alternative 2: Outsourcing 3 Luxoft: Luxoft is a global company that has built a proven reputation for tailoring system projects and applications to meet the business needs for all of its clients. Client: National Tint & Trim has been serving the community of Ruston for nearly 10 years. Tim Merritt is the sole creator and owner of National Tint & Trim and has developed the business processes in use today. Score 4 Alternative 3: Cloud Computing Visual Online Data and Donnie Bell Design: No knowledge regarding National Tint and Trim business processes Unfamiliar with as-is system used to keep records of customers and related to inventory Client: Expert knowledge base Familiar with the as-is system as manager of National Tint and Trim Score 4 Alternative 4: Custom Development Team: Novice knowledge base regarding National Tint & Trim’s business processes. Unfamiliar with the as-is system used to keep records of customers and related to inventory. Client: Expert knowledge base regarding National Tint & Trims business processes. Familiar with the as-is system. Weight 3 15 Familiarity with Technology Team: One team member of Technical Innovations has onthe-job experience with Quickbooks software. All members of Technical Innovations have evaluated the demo version of Appointment-Plus software. All members of Technical Innovations have a general background in an IT related fields. Client: National Tint and Trim management have a working knowledge of Quickbooks software editions. Management has a general knowledge of the necessary hardware components of the system. 4 Luxoft: Each team member is chosen through an intense recruitment process and selected among the best of individuals. Luxoft specializes in providing services that go above and beyond the industry standards. Client National Tint & Trim management is familiar with the Microsoft Windows based operating systems. Management has experience with the Microsoft Office™ Suite as well as Quickbooks™ software package. Management contains the basic knowledge of web and internet functions. 5 Visual Online Data Software engineering firm that specializes in inventory control online since 1988 Donnie Bell Design Graphic design firm that specializes in web designing as well as graphic design Client: Management has no knowledge of visual online software or web design Moderate knowledge base regarding Windows OS and Microsoft Office Team: Broad range of experience pertaining to hardware and software. Client: Working knowledge of QuickBooks, Windows OS, and Microsoft Office software. 5 3 25 Alternative 1: Packaged Software Organizational Support of Management Support of Users Weighted Total Timothy McCalman and Rodriguez Merritt plan to use the proposed system at their current location and future expansion to West Monroe. Involvement from the Owner and Project Sponsor is critical. At the moment, the organization has under ten employees. All employees will have access to the system with certain rights depending on user log in. The owners will be in charge of what their employees can do within the system. The customers will have access to the quoting and appointmentscheduling features. Alternative 2: Outsourcing Score 5 5 440 Timothy McCalman and Rodriguez Merritt plan to use the proposed system at their current location and future expansion to West Monroe. Involvement from the Owner and Project Sponsor is critical. All employees will have access to the system with certain rights depending on user log in. Customers will be able to access the interactive website to enable efficiency within the company. Alternative 3: Cloud Computing Score 5 5 435 Timothy McCalman and Rodriguez Merritt plans to use the proposed system at their current location and future expansion site in West Monroe Employees will have access to the system with certain rights depending on user log in. Employees will get the most use out of the online scheduling process because of their pay by job basis. Score Weight 4 4 430 Timothy McCalman and Rodriguez Merritt plans to use the proposed system at their current location and future expansion site in West Monroe All employees will have access to the system with certain rights depending on user log in. The owners will be in charge of what their employees can do within the system. 4 15 3 10 295 Familiarity with Application Technical Innovations Novice knowledge base with Quickbooks Point of Sale and Appointment Plus Basic knowledge of the business processes of National Tint and Trim National Tint and Trim Mr. Merritt uses Quickbooks for the accounting of National Tint and Trim Very little knowledge of the Appointment Plus software A tutorial will be provided for this software Familiarity with Technology Technical Innovations One team member with on-the-job experience with Quickbooks All members have evaluated Demo version of Appointment Plus All technical innovations members have general background in an IT related field National Tint and Trim Working knowledge of the Quickbooks software Moderate knowledge base of Windows OS General knowledge of the hardware components of this system Project Size The to-be system will combine four major functions including inventory management, appointment scheduling, price quoting, and tracking consumer buyer statistics. Compatibility The current information system consists of a software program along with online and paper based ordering from no more than four vendors. The new system will contain an automated inventory system, online quoting process for auto tinting, as well as an online appointment scheduler. Economic Feasibility Economical Feasibility (Should we build it?) : 1. Development Costs QuickBooks Point of Sale Pro Bundle (Point of Sale Software, Bar Code Scanner, Credit Card Reader, and Receipt Printer) Installation Costs and Testing Software Training 2. Reoccurring Costs Appointment-Plus Gold edition software package Suddenlink 10mb Internet IT Yearly System Assessment 3. Total 4. Annual Tangible Benefits Increased Efficiency Reduced Inventory Costs Reduce Labor Costs Total Annual Benefits 5. Net Present Value 6. Return on Investment 7. Intangible Benefit Better supplier relations Increase positive company reputation Increase quality of service HIGH $1899.95 $370.40 $750.00 $3,020.35 $920.00/yr. $420.00 /yr. $1000.00 per yr. $2,040.00 $5,060.35 $3,250.00/yr. $2,277.50/yr. $2,600.00/yr. $8,127.50 $21,626.30 176.06% Year 0 Benefits Increase Efficiency Reduced Inventory costs Excess Inventory will be eliminated. Reduce Labor costs Total Benefits in today's dollars $0.00 $0.00 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 $3,250.00 $3,250.00 $3,250.00 $3,250.00 $3,250.00 $2,277.50 $2,600.00 $8,127.50 $7,696.50 $2,277.50 $2,600.00 $8,127.50 $7,288.35 $2,277.50 $2,600.00 $8,127.50 $6,901.85 $2,277.50 $2,600.00 $8,127.50 $6,535.84 $2,277.50 $2,600.00 $8,127.50 $40,637.50 $6,189.24 $34,611.77 $920.00 $420.00 $1,000.00 $2,340.00 $2,215.91 $920.00 $420.00 $1,000.00 $2,340.00 $2,098.40 $920.00 $420.00 $1,000.00 $2,340.00 $1,987.12 $920.00 $420.00 $1,000.00 $2,340.00 $1,881.74 $920.00 $420.00 $1,000.00 $2,340.00 $14,720.35 $1,781.95 $5,787.50 $5,480.59 $5,787.50 $5,189.95 $5,787.50 $4,914.73 $5,787.50 $4,654.10 $5,787.50 $4,407.29 Costs One-time costs QuickBooks Point of Sale Pro Bundle (Point of Sale Software, Bar Code Scanner, Credit Card Reader, and Receipt Printer) Installation Costs and Testing Software Training Total One-time costs Recurring costs Appointment-Plus Silver edition software package Suddenlink 10mb Internet IT Yearly System Assessment Total Costs in today's dollars Net in today's dollars NPV Assumed interest rate ROI $1,899.95 $370.40 $750.00 $3,020.35 $3,020.35 $3,020.35 $(3,020.35) $(3,020.35) $21,626.30 5.60% 176.06% Project Champion Rodriguez Merritt Senior Management Timothy McCalman Plans to use the proposed system in future expansion of the business Involvement from the owner and project sponsor is critical Users Employees Access rights Customers Stakeholders Along with Rodriguez Merritt, customers will benefit from the implementation of this new system. •Who is Luxoft? Luxoft is a global corporation known for providing services to meet the needs of both business and technology requirements. Luxoft is recognized as an industry leader with numerous awards and quality certifications. To name a few, Luxoft provides: Application Software Development Software Architecture Services IT Infrastructure Management IT Strategy Consulting and more… Outsourcing Technical Feasibility • Familiarity with Business Processes(Moderate) Team – Moderate Client – High • Familiarity with Technology (Moderate) Team – High Hardware Software Client – Moderate Project Size – High Economical Feasibility (Low ) Should we build it? : Development Costs (one time costs) Development Labor (Technical Innovations) Development Labor (Luxoft) Total Development Costs $8,000.00 $50,000.00 $58,000.00 Recurring Costs Web Hosting Travel Expenses Total Recurring Labor $1,200.00 $500.00 $1,700.00 Tangible Benefits (Present Value) Increase Efficiency Reduce Risk Reduce Labor Costs Increase Productivity Total Benefits $12,775.80 $5,962.04 $29,810.20 $2,129.30 $50,677.34 Net Present Value (NPV) Return on Investment (ROI) Intangible Benefits Better supplier relations Increase positive company reputation Increase quality of service Improved Capabilities $-$15,062.28 -11.19% Outsourcing Organizational Feasibility • If We Build It, Will They Come? – High • Project Champion Rodriquez Merrit, National Tint & Trim Coowner • Senior Management Timothy McCalman is the primary co-owner and plans to use the proposed system in future expansion to West Monroe. Outsourcing Organizational Feasibility • Users At the moment, the organization has fewer than en employees. All employees will have access to the system with certain rights depending on user log in. The owners will be in charge of what their employees can do within the system. In addition, customers will be able to access the interactive website to enable efficiency within the company. • Stakeholders Along with Rodriquez Merrit, customers will benefit from the implementation of this new system. In today’s digital society, most consumers shop and research online before purchasing a product or service. This new system will enable consumers to access National Tint & Trim’s inventory and provide more information on scheduling. Familiarity with Application: (Low) Visual Online Data has no knowledge base regarding National Tint & Trim's business processes and is unfamiliar with the as-is system used to keep records of customers and related to inventory. Donnie Bell Design has no knowledge base regarding National Tint & Trim’s business processes and is unfamiliar with the as-is system used to keep records of customers and related to inventory. Mr. Merritt has a expert knowledge base regarding National Tint & Trim's business processes and is familiar with the as-is system as the manager of National Tint & Trim. Familiarity with Technology: (High) Visual Online Data is a software engineering firm that has specialized in inventory control software since 1988. Since 2004 they have focused their applications towards web application development. Donnie Bell Design is a graphic design firm that specializes in web designing as well as other graphic design features. Donnie Bell Design is a new business starting just a year ago in 2009. National Tint & Trim management has no knowledge of the visual online software or web site design. Management has a moderate knowledge base regarding Windows OS™ and Microsoft Office™ software. Project Size: (Moderate) The to-be system will combine four major functions including inventory management, appointment scheduling, price quoting, and tracking consumer buyer statistics. Compatibility: (Moderate) The current information system consists of a software program along with online and paper based ordering from no more than four vendors. Year 0 Benefits Reduced Maintenace Costs Lower Infrastructure Cost Installation Costs and Testing IT Yearly System Assessment Total Benefits in today's dollars Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 $438.90 $438.90 $438.90 $438.90 $438.90 $1,000.00 $1,438.90 $1,362.59 $1,000.00 $1,438.90 $1,290.34 $1,000.00 $1,438.90 $1,221.91 $1,000.00 $1,438.90 $1,157.11 $1,000.00 $1,438.90 $1,095.75 $1,200.00 $420.00 $1,620.00 $1,534.09 $1,200.00 $420.00 $1,620.00 $1,452.74 $1,200.00 $420.00 $1,620.00 $1,375.70 $1,200.00 $420.00 $1,620.00 $1,302.74 $1,200.00 $420.00 $1,620.00 $1,233.66 -$181.10 -$171.50 -$181.10 -$162.40 -$181.10 -$153.79 -$181.10 -$145.63 -$181.10 -$137.91 $2,122.00 $2,222.40 $4,344.40 $4,344.40 Costs One-time costs Visual Inventory Professional Version Donnie Bell Design - Scheduling - Quoting Total One-time costs $1,995.00 $500.00 $500.00 $2,995.00 Recurring costs Web Hosting Suddenlink 10mb Internet Total Costs in today's dollars Net in today's dollars NPV Assumed interest rate ROI Year 1 $2,995.00 $2,995.00 $ $ 1,349.40 1,349.40 $578.17 5.60% 4.00% Economic Feasibility (High): Should We Build It? One Time Costs Visual Inventory Professional Version Donnie Bell Design (Quoting and Scheduling) Total One Time Costs $1,995.00 $1,000.00 $2,995.00 Recurring Costs Web Hosting Suddenlink 10mb Internet Total Recurring Costs $1200.00 $420.00 $1,620.00 Tangible Benefits (Present Value) Reduced Maintenance Costs Lower Infrastructure Cost Installation Cost and Testing IT Yearly System Assessment Total Benefits $1671.15 $2,122.00 $2,222.40 $3,807.59 $10,472.10 Net Present Value (NPV) $578.17 Return On Investment (ROI) 4.00% Intangible Benefits Access the System from any web browser Increased Scalability Easy Implementation Frees Up Internal Resources Document Compatibility Increased Data Reliability Device Independence Project Champion Rodriguez Merritt, National Tint and Trim CoOwner Senior Management Timothy McCalman is the primary co-owner and plans to use the proposed system in future expansion to West Monroe. Involvement from the Owner and Project Sponsor is critical. Users At the moment, the organization has under ten employees. All employees will have access to the system with certain rights depending on user log in. The owner and management will be in charge of what their employees can do within the system. In addition, customers will be able to access the interactive website to enable efficiency within the company. Stakeholders Along with Rodriguez Merritt, customers will benefit from the implementation of this new system. In today's digital society, most consumers shop and research online before purchasing a product or service. This new system will enable consumers to access National Tint and Trim's inventory and provide more information on scheduling. Technical Feasibility (Can We Build It?) : (MODERATE) Familiarity with Application: (Moderate) Team: (Low) Technical Innovations has a novice knowledge base regarding National Tint & Trim's business processes. Technical Innovations is unfamiliar with the as-is system used to keep records of customers and related to inventory. Mr. Merritt has a expert knowledge base regarding National Tint & Trim's business processes. Client: (High) Mr. Merritt is familiar with the as-is system as the manager of National Tint & Trim Familiarity with Technology: (Moderate) Team: (High) Technical Innovations has a broad range of experience pertaining to hardware and software required to plan, analyze, design, and implement the new system All of Technical Innovations members have been employed in a IT related field. Client: (Moderate) National Tint & Trim management has working knowledge of Quick Books™ software. Management has a moderate knowledge base regarding Windows OS™ and Microsoft Office™ software. Project Size: (Moderate) The to-be system will combine four major functions including inventory management, appointment scheduling, price quoting, and tracking consumer buyer statistics. Compatibility: (Moderate) The current information system consists of a software program along with online and paper based ordering from no more than four vendors. The new system will contain an automated inventory system, online quoting process for auto tinting, as well as an online appointment scheduler. Economical Feasibility (Should we build it?) : 1. Development Costs Dell 2135cn Multi Function Laser Printer Software Licenses (3) Dell Precision T3500 Networking Infrastructure Online Inventory System Dell PowerEdge T710 Server Development Labor Total One-time costs 2. Reoccurring Costs Hardware Software Online Backup Web Hosting Maintenance Total Recurring Labor Total Annual Reoccurring Costs 3. Total Costs HIGH $549.00 $719.80 $3,300.00 $500.00 $4,495.00 $2,222.00 $80,000.00 $91,785.80 $550.00 $350.00 $54.95 $160.00 $500.00 $1,614.95 $8,074.75 $99,860.55 4. Annual Tangible Benefits Space Freed(Annually) Reduce Inventory Costs (Annually) Total Annual Benefits 5. Net Present Value 6. Return on Investment 7. Intangible Benefits Better supplier relations Increase positive company reputation Increase quality of service $4,500.00 $4,500.00 $45,000.00 - $60,335.83 -54.94% Organizational Feasibility (If We Build It, Will They Come) HIGH Project Champion Rodriguez Merritt, National Tint and Trim Co-Owner Senior Management Timothy McCalman is the primary co-owner and plans to use the proposed system in future expansion to West Monroe. Involvement from the Owner and Project Sponsor is critical. Users At the moment, the organization has under ten employees. All employees will have access to the system with certain rights depending on user log in. The owners will be in charge of what their employees can do within the system. In addition, customers will be able to access the interactive website to enable efficiency within the company. Stakeholders Along with Rodriguez Merritt, customers will benefit from the implementation of this new system. In today's digital society, most consumers shop and research online before purchasing a product or service. This new system will enable consumers to access National Tint and Trim's inventory and provide more information on scheduling. Introduction ◦ National Tint and Trim requires an information system that will integrate website functionality with inventory automation, appointment scheduling, online quoting, tracking consumer buyer statistics, and improving customer service. This will allow customers an ease of access to the information while improving the company’s image. This will be accomplished by integrating the business and suppliers through a central database. System Implementation Plan ◦ Technical Innovations chose to purchase a prepackaged system. ◦ Our prepackaged system satisfies all of system requirements including: quoting, purchasing, and scheduling. In addition, this package offers the highest net present value and the easiest means of implementation for a company that does not have a well-trained information system’s department. Conversion Strategy ◦ Since the company only has one location, Technical Innovations has chosen to implement a direct conversion for the system. ◦ Direct conversion involves the instant replacement of the old system with the new system. Since the system wasn’t developed from the ground up by National Tint and Trim, they can trust that there will not be in major bugs in the software. Change Management ◦ Change management is the process of helping the organization adjust and accept the new system. ◦ Luckily, there is plenty of support from upper management. Business Continuity Plan ◦ Currently, National Tint and Trim does not have a system in place. Everything is done by hand and filed away for retrieval. Thus, all employees were trained to run the business in a conventional fashion. Moreover, it will not be hard for the company to revert back to its original structure if the prepackage does not perform as expected. Choose group members wisely Constant Communication Study for the first quiz Delegate the workload It’s not advisable to copy previous projects Never wait until the last minute Be prepared to meet on weekends Late nights are inevitable Time management Beware of the kid playing WoW past midnight in the COB bathroom Google groups is a lifesaver Don’t expect meetings to be short Hope for the best, but plan for the worst Chat Roulette passes time during group meetings Listen to EVERYTHING Mrs. Blackman tells you to do! Take CIS 450 without a full load Pick group members before CIS 450 starts Be able to explain EVERYTHING during your presentations Freddie listens to country music. Make sure to turn items to Mrs. Richardson before 12:00…… not 12:05! Victor’s laptop is made by Fisher Price.