Foreign Remittances u/s 195 of
Income tax Act
May 10, 2014
CA. PANKAJ SHAH
|F.C.A.|C.S.|LLB(Hons.)|B.B.A.|
FEMA - Foreign Remittance

Current Account remittances like Trading remittances,
Rent, Dividend, Interest, etc are freely remittable unless
prohibited

Capital Account transactions like Investment in Shares,
Property, Sale proceeds of Assets are generally restricted
unless specifically allowed

NRI/PIO are allowed to remit upto USD One Million
p.a. out of funds in NRO Account
2
G.J. Shah & Company.
Remittance Procedure as per RBI

RBI has in A.P. (DIR Series) Circular No. 56, dated
November 26, 2002 has instructed the Authorised
Dealers (Banks) to make Remittance abroad after
obtaining following:

Declaration from the Remitter in Form A2 (FEMA)
specifiying nature and purpose of remittance

Income tax Clearance
3
G.J. Shah & Company.
Income tax Clearance

Under Income tax following facilities are
available for Income tax Clearance

Sec. 195(2) - Application by payer to A.O. for lower deduction

Sec. 195(3 & 4) - Application by payee to A.O. for lower
deduction of Tax

Sec. 195(5) - Powers to CBDT to make Rules (Rule 37BB)
Eg. Travel for Pilgrimage, Student Education, Equity Investment

Section 195(6) – C.A. Certificate in Form 15CB
4
G.J. Shah & Company.
Tax Determination

Under Income tax if Remittance amount is

Taxable in hands of NR – Clearance after tax is paid



5
Taxable If income is Received in India
Taxable if income is accrued in India
Not taxable – Clearance on determination that no
tax payable
G.J. Shah & Company.
Section 195 (1)
“Any Person responsible for paying to a non-resident, not being a
company, or to a foreign company, any interest or any other sum
chargeable under the provisions of this Act (not being income
chargeable under the head “Salaries”) shall, at the time of credit of
such income to the account of the payee or at the time of payment
thereof in cash or by the issue of a cheque or draft or by any other
mode, whichever is earlier, deduct income tax thereon at the rates
in force…………….”
“Provided further that no such deduction shall be made in respect
of any dividends referred to in section 115-O”
6
G.J. Shah & Company.
Objective of S. 195

Circular No. 152 dt. 27-11-74

Tax is collected at the earliest point of time

No difficulty in collection of tax at the time of
assessment

To avoid loss of revenue as the non resident may
not have assets in India for subsequent recovery
7
G.J. Shah & Company.
Scope of S. 195

Person responsible to deduct tax
- Person as defined in section 2(31)
- Includes non-residents and foreign companies
• Satellite Television Asia Region Ltd (99 ITD 92)(Mum)
• Vodafone B.V. (SC)
• E-trade Mauritius Ltd (Mum HC)

On Payments made to non residents
- Includes all non residents having presence in India or not
- It does not include RNOR
8
G.J. Shah & Company.
Scope of S. 195

What are the payments covered?
-
-
Any sum chargeable under the Act
Except Salary and dividends referred to in section 115-O

When to deduct tax?
- At the time of payment or credit whichever is earlier

What rate to apply?
-
9
Lower of the two rates:
• Relevant rates in force; or
• Rates under the Tax Treaty – sec 2(37A)(iii) – Circular No. 728 dt. 3010-1995
G.J. Shah & Company.
Section 4 and 195

Section 4(2) – “chargeable”

Section 195 not a charging but a machinery provision to give
effect to Section 4(2). Eli Lily’s case (312 ITR 225)(SC)

Withholding tax is an offshoot of chargeability - not independent
of it.

Whether payer is under obligation to withhold tax , even if the
receipt is not taxable in the hands of the payee?
 G.
E. India Technologies v. CIT (327 ITR 456)(SC)
 Cooper Engineering v CIT (68 ITR 457) (Bom)
 Transmission Corporation’s case (239 ITR 587) (SC).
 Vijay Ship Breaking Corporation v. CIT (314 ITR 309)
 Maharashtra State Electricity Board v. DCIT (90 ITD 793)
10
G.J. Shah & Company.
Section 5 and Section 9

Section 5(2)(b) defines ‘Total Income’ of ‘non-resident’ to
include income which ‘accrues’ or ‘arises’ or is ‘deemed to
accrue or arise’ in India.

Section 9 explains the meaning of the words “deemed to accrue
or arise in India’ used in section 5(2)(b)

Right to tax – some reasonable nexus with India
 Residence; or
 Source
[Wadia v. CIT (17 ITR 63)(PC)]
11
G.J. Shah & Company.
Impact of DTAA

Section 90(2) provides that where a DTAA exists
beneficial of


Income tax Act or
DTAA
shall apply

However for availing benefit of DTAA it is compulsary to
obtain TRC of the Payee Non Resident
12
G.J. Shah & Company.
Accrue or Arise – Business Income

Sale of Goods or Service in India.

Through a Fixed place of Business / PE in India

Profits attributable to Indian operations taxable in India

Eg. HSBC Bank (Branch of HSBC Bank Singapore)
13
G.J. Shah & Company.
Accrue or Arise – Capital Gains

Subject Property located in India

Transferred and Gains accrue to NR

Taxable in India as Income generates in India

However, Treaty with Tax Havens like Mauritius, Singapore
provide that gains are taxable in Country of Residence.

14
Azadi Bachao Andolan versus Union of India (SC)
G.J. Shah & Company.
Deemed to accrue or arise in India –
meaning
Section
Sources Of
Income
9(1)(i)
Business
Income
Income from a business connection in India or through or from
any property or capital asset or source of income or transfer
of capital asset situated in India.
9(1)(ii)
Salaries
Salaries for services rendered in India.
9(1)(iii)
Salaries
Salaries by Govt. for services outside India.
9(1)(iv)
Dividend
Dividend paid by an Indian Company outside India. (now
Exempt)
9(1)(v)
Interest
Interest by Govt. or by a resident (unless for a business or source
outside India)
9(1)(vi)
Royalty
‘Royalty’ by Govt. or a resident (unless for a business or a source
outside India).
9(1)(vii)
FTS
‘Fees for Technical Services (FTS)’ by Govt. or a resident
(unless for a business or a source outside India).
15
Description
G.J. Shah & Company.
BUSINESS CONNECTION

Taxability of a Business Income of Non-Resident Sec. 9(1)(i)

Taxability if “Business Connection“ exists or if asset or source in India.
(Vodafone)
R.D. Agarwal (56 ITR 20(SC)); Cir. 23 of 1969 & Cir. 786)

Taxable only to the extent “reasonably attributable” to
India.

Morgan Stanley-292 ITR 416 (SC);
16
G.J. Shah & Company.
operations in
Import Payments

Remittance for Import Purchases to overseas supplier

Proceeds are Business Income of the Supplier NR

If the Supplier does not have a Permanent Establishment in
India then No tax

However 15CB required for remittance of Import Proceeds
A.P. (DIR SERIES) (2007-08) CIRCULAR NO. 3, DATED 19-7-2007
17
G.J. Shah & Company.
Overseas Commission to NR Agent

NR Agent provides services to locate buyers for Export

The same is business income of NR

In absence of PE/ Business connection in India – Not taxable

DCIT v Eon Technology ( P) Ltd ( 2011) 46 SOT 323,
Dy. CIT v Devi’ s Laboratories Ltd ( 2011) [140 TTJ 746]

18
G.J. Shah & Company.
TAXABILITY OF REIMBURSEMENT OF
EXPENSES
Reimbursement of Expenses:
 CIT Vs. TELCO (245 ITR 823 (Bombay))
 CIT Vs. Industrial Projects (202 ITR 1014-Delhi)
 Clifford Chance 82 ITD 106-Mumbai)
 Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. (10 SOT 896 (Mum)
Against:
 Cochin Refineries (222 ITR 354 (Ker)
 Hindalco (278 ITR 125 (AT)
19
G.J. Shah & Company.
Explanation to S.9(1)(v), (vi) &(vii)
Interest, Royalty, FTS
Taxable whether or not, —
(i) the non-resident has a residence or place of business
or business connection in India; or
(ii) the non-resident has rendered services in India.”

Nullified

Jindal Thermal Power Company Ltd. vs. DCIT (TDS) (182 Taxmann 252)

Bombay High Court in Clifford Chance vs. DCIT (176 Taxmann 458)
20
G.J. Shah & Company.
Case Studies
Interest

Loan taken from a Foreign Bank abroad for


Indian Project
Overseas Project

Interest is being paid to Lender Bank abroad

Taxable or Not?

Interest paid to Bank resident in Mauritius ?
22
G.J. Shah & Company.
Royalty

Payment for “right to use” an Asset

Whether or not



used in India or
located in India
Imported Software?
23
G.J. Shah & Company.
Fees for Technical Services

Includes payment in consideration for the services of
 managerial,
 technical
or
 consultancy nature


Whether or not PE or received in India
DTAA – “make available”


USA, Netherlands, U.K.
Rate of Tax – 25%
24
G.J. Shah & Company.
Fees for Technical Services

Fees for Due Diligence carried out in South Africa?

Fees to Foreign Recruitment Agency in


Resident of South Africa
Ressident of USA

Fees for Repair of Imported Machinery to USA Co.

Fees for technical service paid to UAE Company
which does not have clause of ‘FTS’?
25
G.J. Shah & Company.
Golden Rules (as per ACT)


Income Received in India – Taxable
Income Accrued in India - Taxable
26
Nature of Remittance
TAXABILITY
BUSINESS INCOME
PE MUST
INTEREST
PE IRRELEVENT
ROYALTY
PE IRRELEVENT
FEES FOR TECHNICAL
SERVICES
PE IRRELEVENT
CAPITAL GAINS
ASSET OR BUSINESS IN
INDIA
G.J. Shah & Company.
C. A. Certificate

Reasoning for nil/lower deduction.

Determination of residence for deduction

Precautions
– No PE
 Copies of Back-up papers.
 Certificate of Fiscal Residence must for Treaty Benefit
 Representation
27
G.J. Shah & Company.
“Rates in Force” & S. 206AA

Section 2(37A)

Effect of DTAA

CBDT Circular No. 728 dated 30.10.95

Whether surcharge leviable if DTAA rates adopted.

Effect of 206AA
28
G.J. Shah & Company.
Consequences of non-deduction

Deductor deemed “assessee in default” – S. 201(1)

Interest @ 15% p.a. Section 201(1A).

Penalty u/s. 221

Penalty u/s. 271C.

Prosecution u/s. 276B.

Section 40(a)(i)

Section 163
29
G.J. Shah & Company.
**Certificate No.2
Date: April 18, 2014
Signature:____________________
Form 15CA
Part A: To be filled up if
the remittance is chargeable to tax and
does not exceed fifty thousand rupees and
the aggregate of such remittances made during the financial year does
not exceed two lakh fifty thousand rupees
Part B: To be filled up if
the remittance is chargeable to tax and
exceeds fifty thousand rupees and
The aggregate of such remittances made during the financial year
exceeds two lakh fifty thousand rupees
THANK YOU
Pankaj G. Shah
|F.C.A.|C.S.|LLB(Hons.)|BBA|
G.J. Shah & Company
Chartered Accountants
Mob-969 189 3040
pankajgshah@gmail.com