Conscious and unconscious
personality at work: an application
of the Enneagram typology
Dr Anna Sutton
PhD at Leeds University Business School
What is it?
“dynamic system of nine personality types
that empowers you to better understand
yourself and others”
Helen Palmer and David Daniels, MD
Enneagram teachers
“something to do with naked encounter groups in
California”
Prof Chris Allinson
My supervisor!
A quick intro to the Enneagram
Personality typology
9 types based on unconscious “worldview”
Diagram summarises theory:
Circle: “wings”
Arrows: Changes in stress and security
Also has 3 subtypes for each type
But is it real?
Wagner (1981)
reliability of type decisions
Significant differences between types on MBTI and MillonIllinois scales
Questionnaire studies show distinctive type profiles
on:
16PF (Warling 1995)
Adjective Checklist (Dameyer 2001)
NEO PI-R (Newgent 2001)
OPQ-32 (Brown and Bartram 2005)
Study 1
Investigating Conscious and
Unconscious Personality using the
Enneagram
Personality in the workplace
Personality is:
Conscious or Explicit personality
A “character description”
Unconscious or Implicit personality
Unique pattern of thoughts, feelings and
behaviours
“Hidden” motives or reasons for behaviour
Drawback of self-report
Need to include conscious + unconscious
Background
Personality psychology fragmented
Enneagram types combine descriptions of cs
and ucs aspects
Is the Enneagram Typology valid?
Benefit Enneagram community: solid evidence for
the types
Benefit Personality psychologists: bring together
fragmented field
Method
Rich descriptions of type Specific
hypotheses
Questionnaire survey
Big Five traits (self-report)
Personal Values (self-report)
Implicit motives (semi-projective)
Job outcomes
Sample
N = 416
Min 30 of each
Enneagram Type
not in
employment
23%
self-employed
40%
employed
37%
75% female
46% UK & 37% USA
Good range of ages:
Mean age = 53.5, S.D. =
10.7
Master's degree
36%
Doctoral
14%
Other
16%
Bachelor’s degree
31%
GCSE or A-level
6%
Vocational
10%
Other
3%
Results
Individual hypotheses about each type:
69 made, 53 confirmed
Of non-significant relationships, all but one in right
direction
Good evidence for the validity of the types
Validation of Enneagram types – Big Five
traits
Extraversion - Confident, sociable and outgoing, with a
positive attitude and a focus on the outside world
Extraversion
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1
-1.2
Type 1
Type 2
Type 3
Type 4
Type 5
Type 6
Type 7
Type 8
Type 9
Validation of Enneagram types – Values
Achievement - Being successful by demonstrating one’s
ability in ways other people will recognise and acknowledge
Achievement
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
Type 1
Type 2
Type 3
Type 4
Type 5
Type 6
Type 7
Type 8
Type 9
Validation of Enneagram types – Implicit
Motives
nPow – implicit motivation to have impact, control or
influence over another person, group or the world
Need for Power
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
-0.05
-0.1
Type 1
Type 2
Type 3
Type 4
Hope of Power
Type 5
Type 6
Fear of Power
Type 7
Type 8
Power Motive
Type 9
Predictive ability of Enneagram – Job
Attitudes
Job-related Self-Efficacy – extent to which employees
consider they can do everything their job requires of them
Job Esteem
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
Type 1
Type 2
Type 3
Type 4
Type 5
Type 6
Type 7
Type 8
Type 9
Predictive ability of Enneagram – Job
Choices
Percentage
Occupational distribution by type (percentages)
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Type 1
Type 2
Type 3
Type 4
Type 5
Type 6
Type 7
Professional (teaching, health, legal, science)
Manager / Senior Official
Associate Professional and Technical
Other
Type 8
Type 9
Study 1 Conclusions
Enneagram valid model of personality
Unique relationships of E-Types to
established personality models
Impact of E-Type on job outcomes
Both short term (attitudes) and long term (choice
of occupation)
Combines both explicit and implicit
personality
Study 2
Self-awareness in the workplace:
An application of the Enneagram
Personality instruments in the workplace
Assumptions:
Self-awareness can be improved
Self-awareness is beneficial
The “Sadder but Wiser” paradox: Reflection
and Rumination
Background
Can self-awareness be improved?
What outcomes are associated with selfawareness in the workplace?
2 workshops designed to improve selfawareness:
Generic training
Enneagram-specific training
Method
80 participants in 3 workshops
“switching replications” design
Time
-5 weeks
Group 1
Group 2
Group 3
Q1
-2 weeks
Training
+1 week
+4 weeks
Q3
Q1
Enneagram
Q2
Q2
Enneagram
Q3
Q1
Self-awareness Q2
Q3
Control
Short-term effects
Long-term effects
Quantitative analysis – change in SA,
relationship with job-related affect and coping
strategies
Quantitative results
Control: no effect of questionnaire
Self-awareness:
Job-related affect:
General workshop: ST drop in Reflection
Enneagram workshop: LT drop in Rumination
Reflection associated with +ve affect
(Contentment and Enthusiasm)
Rumination associated with –ve affect
(Dissatisfaction and Depression)
Coping Strategies
Relationships strengthened in long term
Qualitative Analysis
Open-ended question in final questionnaire
63 responses
Used grounded theory to examine emergent
themes and develop categories
Then content analysis
Qualitative results
Category
Theme
Group 1
(E)
Group 2
(E)
Group 3
(SA)
Total
Overall effect
No noticeable effect
7
9
3
19
Short term negative effects
1
2
0
3
Generally beneficial
3
6
0
9
Continuing reflection
5
2
3
10
Understanding / acceptance of
self, reassurance
11
20
4
35
Understanding / acceptance of
others, diversity
7
15
4
26
Confidence
0
2
1
3
Made active changes
3
5
3
11
Improved relationships /
communication with others
3
0
2
5
Thoughts about career options /
current job
1
3
1
5
Self-development
2
7
0
9
Internal /
reflective
changes
Specific effects
Future
No noticeable effect
I think that the
workshop has
had very little
effect, if any, on
my work life
But majority went on to
describe the effects!
Why this discrepancy?
Changes not perceived
as dramatic enough?
Understanding / Acceptance of self
This helps me avoid
taking the reactions of
others personally and
will help me deal with
others better in the
future
Feel better knowing
that I am not the only
person who behaves
and thinks the way I
do
Most commonly
reported effect
New insights into self
Facing weaknesses
Interaction with others
Made active changes
I have also realised
that others in the team
have vulnerabilities
which has helped me to
respond in a more
effective / empathic
way
It has made me
more assertive in
making space for
me
Unusual as most
effects were “internal”
Self-development
I still have to take the
time out and really
develop further as
there are some parts
(as with any [type]) of
myself that do really
need looking at in
order for me to
become a better
person
Limited to Enneagram
workshop
Comments often
related to specific
Enneagram type
Study 2 conclusions
Self-awareness can be improved and is
associated with positive job outcomes
Effects of workshops mainly internal but did
include specific, active changes
Workshops had differential effects
Enneagram useful beyond workplace
Tools vs Framework
Future development
Overall Conclusions
Study 1
Enneagram useful for integrating models of
conscious and unconscious personality
Study 2
Self-awareness can be improved
Enneagram training has beneficial effects in
workplace