Media representations of ethnicity Britain is a multicultural society. 7.9% of the UK population are from ethnic minority groups. Ethnic minority groups are at the forefront in their use of the new media. So, what should we expect in terms of ethnic minority representations within the media? Key ways in which ethnic minorities are represented within the media Underrepresented These are the findings of Represented in a Van Dijk, who has examined media representations of ethnic minorities. He made these findings via content analysis of thousands of news items over several decades. So, what can we say about Van Dijk’s findings in relation to representativeness? stereotypical way Represented negatively As criminals As a threat As culturally abnormal As unimportant As dependent As invisible Ethnic minorities are criminals!! 1. 2. 3. 4. • • 1. 2. 3. Black crime & violence is the underlying theme in media news coverage. Van Dijk has found the following to be common ways in which Black people are portrayed via the tabloid newspapers: Criminal Organised gangs Push drugs Violently defend urban territories Akinti has made similar findings in the television. He believes tv reflects an inaccurate view of Black life, with over-emphasis on gun crime. Agbetu has found the following common portrayals of Black people: Involved in criminality (perpetrators) Involved in sport Involved in entertainment Moral panics…. The findings of the previous thinkers (Van Dijk, Akinti, Agbetu) indicate that Black people are newsworthy because they are bad news! Rarely are Black people portrayed as normal functioning individuals within everyday society. Watson notes that moral panics often result from such stereotyping of Black people within the media, particularly the panic that they are potentially criminal. Think headlines!! Such headlines back up Hall’s study of a 1970s moral panic around the ‘Black mugger’. More recently, moral panics have remained around the idea of Black crime – particularly gang crime In 2003, David Blunkett (Home Secretary) said he was ‘appalled’ by lyrics in rap & hip-hop music. Kim Howells (Culture Secretary) claimed a particular Black band was glorifying gun culture. In 2005, ASA criticised 50 Cent’s film poster for glamorising gun crime. In 2006, David Cameron (leader of Conservative party) criticised BBC Radio 1 for playing gangsta rap as such music ‘encourages people to carry guns & knives. "The Good Die Young" Yo, you know what I want? I want the beat to drop right..now niggas be thinkin' I'm crazy right? you are crazy.. I ain't crazy... you are crazy.... at least I don't think I'm crazy I think my shit is hot, I think I'm hot you hot but you crazy.. why they wanna?..man..I don't know... [Verse 1:] It's the money that - makes shit get ugly It's the money that - makes these hoes love me It's the money that - makes niggas wanna slug me man..I thought the money would make it all lovely Yo, I actually write what I do or see the felonies from day to day make me say what I say when I die my art will be worth more than Picasso's, don't cry for me, smile for me and if you see them niggas that wet me, wile' for me remember the good times, the chips we stacked the clips we packed and all the bricks we cooked from coke to crack let my tombstone read "I Tried" and from the start everything I wrote was from my heart so it'll always be number one on my chart I get sensitive with my shit, don't fuck with my art sometimes it sounds like I'm playin' but I'm sayin' this shit is real, it ain't a game. Analyse how the previous claims by people in positions of authority contribute to a moral panic about Black people. Ethnic minorities are a threat!! Through his content analysis Van Dijk has said a common stereotype is that ethnic minorities are posing a threat to the majority. This is seen through news content, again contributing to moral panics. Main ethnic minorities that are portrayed as posing a threat are: 1. Immigrants 2. Refugees & asylum seekers 3. Muslims Immigrants This group is seen as a threat in terms of their numbers. Common media coverage focuses on how their presence is affecting housing, jobs etc. In 1995, a government trade minister resigned because he was unhappy with the lack of European border controls – leading to illegal immigration into the country. Philo & Beattie explain this resignation set off media hysteria about immigration & the consequences of it. Immigration portrayed in an alarmist way & reported as threatening the British way of life. Sensationalists language, such as ‘flood’ & ‘tidal wave’ also used. Philo & Beattie basically believe that such media coverage created a moral panic about immigration, particularly as no positive stories about the contribution of ethnic minorities were presented. Refugees & asylum seekers are a threat!! Similar treatment by the media to immigrants. Often portrayed as coming to Britain to abuse the welfare state & claim benefits. The media rarely covered responsible stories that many of this people had to flee their countries in order to avoid persecution, torture or extreme poverty. News was quite xenophobic in tone, which reinforced exclusion – rather than embracing diversity. Muslims are a threat!! The media coverage of the 9/11 attacks in the US & the 7/7 attacks in Britain have greatly contributed to the idea that we should be afraid of Muslims; although it is fair to say that even before these events Islam was often demonised by the media as being a threat to Western way of life. The above events were undoubtedly terrible, but the headlines of many of the tabloid newspapers (Sponging Bomber) have not helped & have only served to further create the idea that we should be afraid of Muslims & the religion of Islam that they follow. Poole carried out content analysis of broadsheet British newspapers (The Guardian) between 1993-1996 & found that representations of British Muslims suggested they were a threat to British security & dominant values. Headlines which claim Muslims are a threat to British way of life…. What are the consequences of such racist headlines in the tabloids? 1. 2. 3. 4. * Richardson has made the following findings from his study of the broadsheet press in relation to representations of British Muslims: Wholly absent from the news When they do appear, tends to be a negative context Rarely called upon as providers of informed commentary on news events Their everyday issues & concerns are not being addressed Thinkers like Nahdi believe that Islam is presented by the media in a distorted way. Are there any positive representations of Muslims? More balanced & positive stories about Muslims & Islam do now exist. Both BBC & Channel 4 have websites that explain Islam in a balanced fashion. The Guardian, Observer & Independent have sympathetically focused on Muslim Britain. Even The Sun ran a 2 page editorial in 2005 declaring ‘Islam is not an evil religion!’ Content of BBC website Islam began in Arabia and was revealed to humanity by the Prophet Muhammad. Those who follow Islam are called Muslims. Muslims believe that there is only one God. The Arabic word for God is Allah. Image © Marc C. Johnson/iStockphoto Features Abortion This article examines Islamic teachings on abortion and various ethical viewpoints. The Qur'an This article covers some basic information about The Qur'an and provides some sections spoken aloud in Arabic. More religions and beliefs » Messageboards Have your say on the Religion & Ethics Message Boards » Related links Also in Religion & Ethics Muslim prayer times calculator Muslim calendar However……. Overall findings indicate the majority of media representations about Muslims & Islam are negative & unsympathetic. The British mass media has contributed to Islamophobia in Britain. Ethnic minorities are abnormal!! False cultural stereotypes are regularly transmitted regarding other cultural groups & their norms & values. Certain cultural practices, such as arranged marriages among certain Asian groups, was not reported accurately. For example, there is a distinction between arranged vs forced marriages – yet this was reflected. Common media stereotypes is that Asian people are forced into loveless marriages. Ameli notes that media discussion around the wearing of the hijab & veil is also problematic & implies it is an inferior type of dress that creates divisiveness between Muslims & British people. Minister calls for veil-wearing teaching assistant to be sacked By Andrew Grice, Political Editor What is the implications of such headlines? Ethnic minorities are unimportant!! Van Dijk says that some aspects of the media imply that the lives of white people are more important than the lives of nonwhites. For example, disasters in other countries are only given a few lines; priority is given to the white holiday maker who may have been caught up in it. Black victims of crime are not given the same attention as victims who are white. Sir Ian Blair (Met Police Commissioner) claimed institutional racism is present in the British media. Evidence for this is in the way they reported murders that happened on the same day. Priority given to murder of white solicitor (87%) in comparison to murder of Asian taxidriver (13%). Note, the Independent & Mirror didn’t cover the latter murder at all!! What message is this sending out? Are ethnic minorities always considered unimportant? The murder of Black teenager, Stephen Lawrence in 1993, by white racists was covered very well by many aspects of the media. Many newspapers not only covered this racist murder, but also highlighted the racists actions of the police in their investigation of the murder. The interesting thing about this headline is that it is the Daily Mail, which would be quite racist in may of its articles Ethnic minorities are dependent. They rely on the west to rescue them!! African countries are particularly portrayed by the media (tv & newspapers) as having problems they have caused themselves (having too many babies!) & that Western countries are needed to help them out. A common theme is the ‘coup-war-famine-starvation’ syndrome. Live Aid & Comic Relief are regularly portrayed by the media as the only way these countries can escape their disasters. Pambazuka, for example, has pointed out that media reporting about Africa is too dominated by Western campaigns such as Live 8 & Make Poverty History. Bob Geldof’s agenda is more highlighted than the real situation in Africa. Overall, there is too much emphasis on bad news like war, famine disaster. Little devoted to why countries were underdeveloped & poor. British news reporting is ethnocentric. In other words, it is shaped by view that British White culture is superior in its norms & values in comparison to other cultures which are considered inferior. Ethnic minorities invisible within the media Generally we can say there has been an improvement in the way race id dealt with within tv programmes & there appears to have been an increase in the number of Black & Asian newscasters, tv presenters, journalists etc. However still not fully represented. Read page 198 & summarise the following complaints in relation to the invisibility of ethnic minorities Limited roles Cultural irrelevance Media personnel Invisibility Ghettoisation Realism Advertising industry Tokenism Some media institutions have been developed by ethnic minorities working within the media to try & address ethnic minority issues. Bollywood channels The Indian Times www.brasian.co.uk The Kumars at Number 42 Concluding point by Castells… When evaluating media representations of how they portray ethnic minorities, we must take into consideration the different social positions (class, gender, religion) that actually divide a particular ethnic group. In other words, there is diversity within them that the media should acknowledge. Essay question Critically examine media representations of ethnic minority groups.