Dogon classification

advertisement

Dogon classification

Jeffrey Heath (Univ. of Michigan),

Steve Moran (Univ. of Munich),

Kirill Prokhorov (Humboldt Univ. of Berlin and MAE RAS)

Structure of the talk

• Dogon languages, basic information and data

• Lexicostatistical data and the resulting tentative classification

• Evidence from nominal morphology

• Revised classification and further issues

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

2

Dogon languages: Trivia

21 language identified

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

3

Dogon languages: Trivia

21 language identified (+Bangiime, isolate)

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

4

Dogon languages: Trivia

21 language identified (+Bangiime, isolate)

Up to 1 million speakers

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

5

Dogon languages: Trivia

21 language identified (+Bangiime, isolate)

Up to 1 million speakers

Spoken in eastern Mali and (partially) northern Burkina Faso

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

6

Data

 Several grammars and dictionaries done by non-professional linguists

(Léger 1971, Prost & Kervran 1986)

 Two published reference grammars done by professional linguists

(Plungian 1995) and (Heath 2008)

 Dogon project materials

(www.dogonlanguages.org)

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

7

Dogon Project

 Started in 2004

 Supported by NSF (grant BCS-

0537435)

 Website: www.dogonlanguages.org

 Data on more than 20 Dogon idioms, incl. comparative lexical spreadsheet with more than 7 thousand entries

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

8

100 Swadesh word list: cognacy rates

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

9

Family depth: the lowest rate

Bunoge – Tomo Kan ~ 32%

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

10

Family depth: the highest rate

Ben Tey – Nanga ~ 88%

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

11

Family Tree: Lexicostatistics

?

2

4

1

?

2

3

?

1 2

Calculated using Starling (starling.rinet.ru)

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

12

Problems 1:Tiranige

?

1 Even from the lexicostatistical perspective

Tiranige may equally be attributed to the

Western group (Mombo, Penange, Ampari,

Bunoge)

Cf. Tiranige – Mombo (West) ~ 65%

Tiranige – Najamba-Kindige (North-East) ~

66%

Cf. also morphological evidence below

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

13

Problems 2: Bigger groups

?

2 question whether the 4 branches identified form bigger groups remains problematic:

- lexicostatistical data are not definitive cf. rather short period between the supposed major split and following splits into the four branches on the tree)

- some morphological isoglosses go across these groupings

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

14

Nominal Morphology 1: East

 Eastern-type class-number system

Jamsay :

HumSg

-n

HumPl

-m

Toro Tegu : -rⁿu ~ -n(u) -m(u)

Tommo so: –n ɛ -m

Proto-East: *-nu ‘person’ *-n-bu

Nonh

*-

Found in: East

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

15

Nominal Morphology 2: North-East

 Najamba-Kindige class system suffixes final-vowel animate Sg -Ø animate Pl -mbo

E

O inanimate Sg -ŋgo/-go (O/E class) O (O/E class)

-ŋge/-ge (E/E class) E (E/E class) inanimate Pl -Ø E

Other languages of North-East group have simpler systems, cognate to that of Najamba-Kindige.

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

16

Nominal morphology 3

 Western-type system of plural making:

Mombo

Penange Ø

Sg PL

Ø -ŋge/-ge

-ge

Ampari Ø

Bunoge Ø ge ge

Also found in Tiranige (see below)

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

17

Nominal morphology 4: North-West

Nanga

Ben Tey

Bankan Tey

AnSg

-Ø (-ŋ)

-m

-m

AnPl

Ø

Ø

Ø

Inan

Ø

Ø

Ø

In Nanga only nasal suffix ya -ŋ ‘woman’ (pl. ya : ‘women’) has singular

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

18

Plural marking in Tiranige

?

1 Tiranige shows clear affinities with Western group

(Mombo, Penange, Ampari, Bunoge) in nominal morphology

(1) Plural formation: Tiranige na : ‘cow’ na : ge ta ŋgi le 'side‘ ta ŋgi le ge ‘sides’

‘cows’

(2) Plural formation: Ampari (WEST) ga na :

:wa ‘bone’

‘cow’ ga na

:wa

:-ge

-ge

‘cows’

‘bones’

Cf. Class system in Najamba kindige

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

19

Tiranige: What happened?

1.

Tiranige is originally North-Eastern (NED) language that borrowed nominal morphology

(and some lexicon) from Western Dogon (WD)

2.

Tiranige is originally WD that borrowed lexicon from NED

3.

Tiranige is a separate branch, that is equally close to both WD and NED

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

20

Frozen class suffixes in WD and

Tiranige

‘peanut’

Najamba ɛ́

Mombo ɔ́

Tiranige ɛ̀ l l ɛ ɔ́

(PL), ŋge

:l ɛ̀ ŋge ɛ́ l ɛ́ -ŋgo (SG)

NB: disharmonic combinations ɔ /e and ɛ /e in Mombo and Tiranige

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

21

Frozen class suffixes …

‘blood’

Najamba

Mombo

Tiranige ge n (Pl) ge ŋ-ge (Sg) ge :ŋge je :ŋge

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

22

Conclusion 1

 4 groups can be securely identified based on lexicostatistical and morphological data

East: Toro Tegu, Tomo Kan, Togo Kan, Perge, Jamsay,

Donno So, Tommo So, Yorno So

North-East (NED): Najamba-Kindige, Yanda, Tebul,

Dogulu

North-West (NWD): Ben Tey, Bankan Tey, Nanga

West (WD): Mombo, Penange, Ampari, Bunoge

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

23

Conclusion 2

 Tiranige shows some lexical grammatical proximity to both WD and NED, but none of them is decisive for defining it’s (inner) affiliation

 Tiranige (for now) is better considered as separate branch

 Common WD-NED-Tiranige features (cf. frozen class suffixes) may indicate that these languages form a bigger group within the family or an intensive mutual contact influence that these language were subject to in the past.

Niger-Congo Congress

September 18-21,

2012, Paris, INALCO

24

Download