Pharmaceutical Inspection Co-operation Scheme (PIC/S) Good Manufacturing Practice - GMPs Trends in Pharmaceutical Inspections Cooperation Scheme (PIC/S) Brasilia – August 2014 Mrs. Helena Paula Baião PIC/S Former Chairperson helena.baiao@infarmed.pt http://www.infarmed.pt/ © PIC/S 2014 All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 Bom dia Good Morning Mrs. Helena Paula Baião PIC/S Chairperson helena.baiao@infarmed.pt http://www.infarmed.pt/ All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 Overview I. About PIC/S & Mission & Goals & Quality Systems & Guides & Recommendations & Seminars & Expert Circles & JVP & JRP & training activities &Liaison with other organisations II. Trends and Observations related to GMP inspections III. PIC/S Future & Philosophy IV. Final Remarks V. Acknowledgement All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. PIC/S is ... an international organisation a non-profitable organisation a non-political organisation made up of regulators (inspectors) The convention was signed in Geneva on 8 October 1970 All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. PIC/S Mission “To lead the international development, implementation and maintenance harmonised GMP quality systems of of standards and inspectorates in the field of medicinal products”. “成立的宗旨 領導,擴展,實施, 藥品GMP法規標準協和、藥品稽查管理體系(稽查品質)一致化, 國際化 和全球化. “ While adapting to its growth and needs as well as to a constantly changing GMP environment, PIC/S remains focused on what has made its success to this day. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Original Goals Harmonised GMP requirements (*) Mutual recognition of inspections Uniform inspection systems Training of Inspectors Mutual confidence (Trust) (*) The difference is not so much in different GMP standards being used around the world but in the interpretation of standards All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Achievement of PIC/S Goals Developing and promoting harmonised GMP standards and guidance documents Assessing (and reassessing) GMP Inspectorates Training competent authorities, in particular GMP inspectors Facilitating the co-operation and networking for competent authorities and international organisations All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Quality System requirements for Pharmaceuticals Inspectorates Reference document : PI 002-3 Purpose : adopt a common standard for quality system requirements in order to achieve consistency in inspection standards between National Pharmaceutical Inspectorates and thus to facilitate the equivalence of Inspectorates All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Obligations as a PIC/S Member (1) Payment of annual membership fee (2) To attend PIC/S Committee Meetings – twice a year – one in Geneva and the other one in a member country (together with the annual seminar) (3) To host or participate in the annual PIC/S Seminar (4) To host or participate in PIC/S Expert Circles & JVP & JRP (5) To participate in PIC/S Sub-Committees (SC). Active participation and contribution is the only way forward All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Information sharing inside PIC/S Reports of GMP inspections List of planned foreign inspections List of inspectors List of competencies within each inspectorate Training events arranged by inspectorates Rapid alerts and drug recalls Surveillance activities All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 46 PIC/S Members (as of 1 July 2014) 10 PIC/S Applicants & Pre-Applicants All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 PIC/S Members (Europe) AUSTRIA BELGIUM CZECH REP. (Human & Vet) CYPRUS DENMARK ESTONIA FINLAND FRANCE (Human & Vet) GERMANY GREECE HUNGARY ICELAND IRELAND ITALY LATVIA LIECHTENSTEIN LITHUANIA MALTA NETHERLANDS NORWAY POLAND PORTUGAL ROMANIA SLOVAK REPUBLIC SLOVENIA SPAIN SWEDEN SWITZERLAND UKRAINE UNITED KINGDOM (Human & Vet) All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Accession & Pre-accession procedure Useful Documents Pharmaceutical Inspection Cooperation Scheme (PIC/S 1/95) Guidelines for Accession to PIC/S (PS/W 14/2011) Questionnaire for Competent Authorities (PS/W 1/2011) Audit Checklist (PS/W 1/2005) Recommendations on quality system requirements for pharmaceutical inspectorates (PI 002) All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Accession &+ Pre-accession Applicants being assessed for membership Brazil / ANVISA Hong-Kong SAR / PPBHK Iran / MoH Philippines / PFDA Turkey / TMMDA Applicants for Pre-Accession Armenia / SCDMTE Belarus / MoH Chile / ISP Kazakhstan / CCMPA Mexico / COFEPRIS interest in joining PIC/S China / CFDA Croatia / HALMED Nigeria / NAFDAC Russia / Roszdravnadzor Saudi Arabia / SFDA All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. PIC/S Training for GMP Inspectors Annual Training Seminars Training Courses for New Inspectors Expert Circles Joint Visits Programme (JVP) and Coached Inspections Programme (CIP) PIC/S - Industry Workshops All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Upcoming PIC/S Training Activities PIC/S – IMB New Inspector Training Course which will be hosted and run by Ireland / IMB from 16-19 June 2014 in Dublin (Ireland), followed by a Train the Trainer course on 20 June 2014 (http://www.picscheme.org/various.php); PIC/S – PDA (Parenteral Drug Association) Q7 Training Course, part of the PIC/S International API Training Programme set up by the PIC/S Expert Circle on API, which regularly delivers general API training in several locations around the world. The next training courses, open to inspectors and industry, will be held in Brussels (Belgium), on 18-19 September 2014 and in Brasilia (Brazil), in October 2014, in co-operation with Brazil / ANVISA (http://www.picscheme.org/various.php) PIC/S Advanced QRM Training Course for GMP inspectors, which will be hosted by Japan / PMDA in Tokyo (Japan), on 8-10 December All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 2014, organised by the PIC/S Expert Circle on Quality Risk I. PIC/S Seminars Qualification and Validation Ukraine, 2012 Global Supply Chains and Canada, 2013 GMP Compliance “Dedicated facilities or not ?” France 2014 “Biopharmaceutical and biosimilars, how to inspect?” Indonesia, 2015 All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Development of GMP Guidance Documents Usually initiated at end of PIC/S Seminars PIC/S Working Group formed Author prepares draft Comments from Working Group Comments from PIC/S Inspectorates Comments from Industry Endorsed by PIC/S Committee for general distribution Simultaneous distribution by EMA (& vice versa) All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. Relationship with EMA 歐洲藥物管理局 (European Medicine Agency, EMA) Associated Partnership negotiated in 2007 (renewed in 2010) EMA attends PIC/S Committee as a Associated Partner organisation A Harmonised Consultation Procedure Since 8 May 2012 EMA and PIC/S signed an agreement to “Harmonize the Consultation Procedure “ for all GMP documents. PIC/S-EU liaison officer attends Inspectors meetings at EMA as an observer All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. PIC/S Guides & Recommendations PIC/S GMP Guide Virtually identical to EC GMP Guide (main difference = “Qualified Person” vs. “authorised person”) Basic GMP Guide (Part I) The PIC/S GMP Guide – PE 009-11 , into force on 1 March 2014. Geneva, 31 January 2014: the PIC/S Committee has adopted by written procedure the revision of the PIC/S GMP Guide (PE 009-11). l l l l l The following parts have been amended: - Part II of GMP Guide (Q7A): Introduction of risk management principles - Annexes: * Revised Annex 2 (biological medicinal products for human use) * Revised Annex 14 (products derived from human blood or human plasma) All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. PIC/S Guides & Recommendations PIC/S GMP Guide (similar to EU GMP Guide) PIC/S GMP Guide for Blood Establishments PIC/S Guide to Good Practices for the Preparation of Medicinal Products in Healthcare Establishments Validation (master plan, IQ/OQ, process, cleaning) Validation of Aseptic Processes Inspection of Isolator Technology Quality Systems for Inspectorates Validation of Computerised Systems PIC/S Aide –Memoire ON ASSESSMENT OF QRM IMPLEMENTATION PI 038-1 PIC/S RECOMMENDATION ON RISK-BASED INSPECTION PLANNINGPI-037-1 All rights reserved PIC/S 2013 I. PIC/S Liaison with other organisations The European Department for the Quality of Medicines (EDQM 歐洲 药品质量部) : Associated Partnership negotiated in 2007 (renewed in 2010) United Nations International Children‘s Emergency Fund (or known as United Nations Children’s Fund, UNICEF, 聯合國儿童基金会(舊 称聯合國國際兒童緊急救援基金會 : Associated Partnership negotiated in 2008 World Health Organisation, WHO 世界衛生組 織 : Co-operation Arrangement negotiated in May 2009 International Conference on Harmonization,ICH (國際協调會) European Commission (DG Health & Consumers) 歐盟執委會 Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN); All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. PIC/S liaises with major Professional Organisations PIC/S liaises with major professional organisations such as ISPE and PDA, active in the field of interpretation & guidance documents as well as training; The support of industry associations and professional organisations to the goals of PIC/S is crucial. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 I. PIC/S Liaison with other organisations In the PIC/S Blueprint, Co-operation between PIC/S and other organisations should be based on the principle of complementarity. Where PIC/S Participating Authorities are already actively co-operating, PIC/S as an organisation should not duplicate Members’ efforts. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. PIC/S's perspectives Trends and Observations related to inspections US/FDA makes their inspection results available to the public due to the Freedom of Information Act (FOI). However, very rarely, inspection results of European supervisory authorities are accessible in any public domain except analysis of regulatory / GMP inspection findings that are periodically published by UK/MHRA and European Medicines Agency (EMA). All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. PIC/S's perspectives Trends and Observations related to inspections At PIC/S level, a similar exercise has never been done before in spite of the fact that PIC/S is an international organization with membership spread across all the 6 continents globally but as part of the PIC/S Seminar 2011 on “Good Pharmaceutical Inspection Practices”, developed a worshop “Similarities and differences for top 10 deficiencies cited by PIC/S Members; Hans Smallenbroek (Netherlands/IGZ) and Boon Meow Hoe (Singapore/HSA) All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. PIC/S's perspectives Trends and Observations related to inspections Methodology Questionnaire invite all PIC/S Participating Authorities and applicants to offer data. 1. Top ten & most frequently cited categories of GMP deficiencies 2. Top five &f most severe GMP deficiencies (critical and/or major) The scope of the survey was defined for GMP inspection findings of finished product dosage form manufacturers only, including medicines for veterinary use and investigational medicinal products, if applicable. Inspections of Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (API) were out of the scope of this survey. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. PIC/S's perspectives Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S did not have a formal model “Categories of GMP Deficiencies”, the model of “Categories of GMP Deficiencies” used by UK/MHRA was used as a standard template. However, flexibilities were given to PIC/S Participating Authorities and applicants which might wish to use their own model of “Categories of GMP Deficiencies”. Inspection findings were classified into the categories “critical:”, “major” and “others or minor” All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections Analysis and summary of raw data Summary of top 10 most frequently cited categories of GMP deficiencies (1) Documentation - manufacturing 24 (2) Design and maintenance of premises 22 (3) Documentation - quality systems elements / procedures 20 (4) Personnel issues - training 19 (5) Design and maintenance of equipment 18 (6) Cleaning validation 14 (6) Process validation 14 (6) Product Quality Review 14 (7) Supplier and contractor audit 13 (8) Calibration of measuring + test equipment 12 (9) Equipment validation 11 All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 TOTAL NUMBER OF DEFICIENCIES PER GROUP OF TOP TEN MOST FREQUENTLY CITED DEFICIENCIES All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 Total number of deficiencies per group of top ten most frequently cited deficiencies All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections Analysis and summary of raw data Total number of deficiencies per group of top five most severe deficiencies (1) Production 44 (27%) (2) Quality system 32 (20%) (3) Premises and equipment 28 (17%) (4) Validation 22 (14%) (5) Quality control 14 ( 9%) (6) Regulatory issues 9 ( 6%) (7) Materials management 8 ( 5%) All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 (8) Personnel issues 5 ( 3%) Summary of top 5 most severe GMP deficiencies Documentation-manufacturing Regulatory issues - non compliance qwith marketing authorisation Documentation - QS elements / procedure Investigation of anomalies Cleaning Validation Process Validation Batch release procedures Sterility assurance Design and maintenance of equipment Contamination, potential for (chemical, physical, microbial) Design and maintenance of premises 15 10 5 0 15 12 11 9 9 9 8 7 7 5 5 All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 Summary of top 5 most severe GMP deficiencies TOTAL NUMBER OF DEFICIENCIES PER GROUP OF TOP FIVE MOST SEVERE DEFICIENCIES All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections Review similarities and differences for the top 10 deficiencies Comparison between summary of groups Most severe deficiencies Most frequently cited deficiencies Production 24% Quality system 20% Quality control 14% Premises + equipment 14% Validation 12% Personnel issues 8% Materials management 7% Regulatory issues 1% Production 27% Quality system 20% Premises + equipment 17% Validation 14% Quality control 9% Regulatory issues 6% Materials management 5% Personnel issues 3% All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections GENERAL OBSERVATIONS Differences PIC/S Participating Authorities use different GMP deficiencies classification model: Some used the model developed by UK/MHRA; Some use the PIC/S GMP Part I model i.e. in according to the 9 Chapters and Annex 1. Some have their own classification methodology. Some members did not have formal analysis trending on such GMP deficiencies. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections Review similarities and differences for the top 10 deficiencies GENERAL OBSERVATIONS Some of the most frequently cited GMP deficiencies may due to easy detection as part of the inspection process. (E.g. Documentation – manufacturing -- #1 most frequently cited deficiency). The design and maintenance of premises ranked as #2 most frequently cited deficiency may relate to aged buildings or saving on maintenance budget. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections Review similarities and differences for the top 10 deficiencies GENERAL OBSERVATIONS The 10 most frequently cited GMP deficiency classes meant that the industry is weak in these areas and inspectors should communicate more effectively and efficiently to the industry on such weaknesses. Different level of details of the deficiency classes model observed. A model that could be accepted by most PIC/S PAs may be required All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections Common model recommendation Adopt this exercise at PIC/S level in an annual basis. Output may be used as a Training Need Analysis to identify common specific GMP areas to be focused on training and to pull all resources together within PIC/S. PIC/S may wish to consider to develop a PIC/S common GMP deficiencies classification model May 2013, established Working Group coordinated by TGA (...) All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections Data trending recommendation All PIC/S Participating Authority (PA) should consider to implement and put in place such exercise for analysis and trending within a defined period (e.g. annually) and subsequently, for trending across different years. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections Conclusion There is a correlation between the most frequent GMP Deficiencies Classes and the most severe GMP Deficiencies Classes. There is no significant differences among regions This implies that there is harmonisation across all PIC/S Participating Authorities. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities PIC/S facilitates international technical training on relevant topics of interest. One of the most active bodies within PIC/S is the API Expert Circle. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities, harmonizes GMP standards, and provides training for inspectors worldwide. Carmelo Rosa chair of the PIC/S API Expert Circle, others All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities Efforts and strategic plan are focused in 4 key areas: identifying regions and countries where the inspectorate and industry have greater needs of GMP training in APIs; providing the inspectorate with up-to-date information on advanced or complex APIs manufacturing processes; through partnership with technical organizations and established procedures, ensuring that the inspectorate is exposed to new technology All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities Five API Expert Circles have been held, in September 2012, in Washington DC, where approximately 130 inspectors were trained on sterile APIs and biotechnology manufacturing. The 6th Expert Circle on APIs will be held in Rome on May 19-21, 2014 on the topic of API process validation and contemporary issues. (…) All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities Since the implementation of Q7, manufacturers appear to have understanding of GMP principles. most API a better Many firms have good quality systems, process understanding, seek opportunities for optimization, have robust change-controls systems, and have good laboratory controls and procedures to facilitate knowledge management. On the other hand, inspections also reveal that some API manufacturers continue to struggle with achieving sustainable compliance with GMP requirements. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities Inspections of API facilities, conducted by PIC/S members, have recently been reporting critical deficiencies related to laboratory controls, records/investigations, quality systems, equipment cleaning/maintenance, and process validation. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities Data integrity issues PIC/S members and partners have also noted an increase in findings of data-integrity practices during inspections of API sites. These deficiencies include: recording data in logbooks, falsification of batch records and test results, pretesting samples and ignoring or not investigating out-ofspecification results, blending or mixing API batches that failed to meet the established released specifications with batches that met the required final specifications, lacking the necessary controls in handling and managing critical data, and entering manufacturing activities on records before they had occurred. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities Outsourced operations and the changing face of API manufacturing With the increase in the outsourcing of APIs by sponsors/drug applicants/finished drug product owners/contract givers (party that purchases APIs), there is more concern about how the roles and responsibilities of each party are established and managed. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities . During PIC/S’ API Expert Circles, inspectors are trained on new technology, quality trends, and critical deficiencies and how to detect problems that may affect the quality of the APIs produced and that may impact the finished drug products, and subsequently affect the patients who consume these medicines. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 II. Trends and Observations related to inspections PIC/S reviews deficiencies found during inspections of API manufacturing facilities Conclusion A regulator’s role is to determine whether firms are operating in sustainable compliance with GMP for APIs, pursuant to ICH Q7. Bearing in mind that inspections are limited by time and other resource constraints, regulators rely heavily on manufacturers to implement and maintain appropriate quality systems and processes to ensure that all APIs produced meets the required quality standards. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 III. Future of PIC/S & New Projects Expansion to cover Good Distribution Practices - GDP PIC/S adopted a Guide on Good Distribution Practice (GDP), into force since 1 June 2014; Good Clinical Practices - GCP and Good Pharmacovigilance Practices - GVP (new Working Group); PIC/S Inspectorates Academy; Other needs of Agencies (e.g. biosafety, medical devices, etc.). All rights reserved PIC/S 2013 III. PIC/S Future Recent Developments Accession of Japan’s MHLW, PMDA & Prefectures and of South Korea’s MFDS (July 2014) New PIC/S GDP Guide, based on EU GDP Guide (June 2014) Revision of PIC/S GMP Guide (Part II of GMP Guide (Q7A), Annex 2 and 14) (March 2014) Revision of PIC/S Guide to Good Practices for the Preparation of Medicinal Products in Healthcare Establishments (new Annex 3 on radiopharmaceuticals) (March 2014) New PIC/S Organisational Sub-Committee Structure (Jan 2014) Accession of United Kingdom’s Veterinary Agency VMD (Jan 2014) Accession of Chinese Taipei’s TFDA and New Zealand’s Medsafe (Jan 2013) All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 III. PIC/S Future New PIC/S Organisational Sub-Committee Structure To reply to PIC/S’s growing membership, a new SubCommittee structure has been developed and come in force 1st January 2014, in order to: • Favour the participation of all PIC/S Participating Authorities • Establish a more participative and efficient organisation of PIC/S, where each Sub-Committee will be responsible for its respective core areas and will take the lead in developing policies. • Among the Sub-Committee Members, 57% are from non-EU PIC/S Participating Authorities, reflecting the fact that PIC/S has become less of an Eurocentric and an ever more global international organisation. All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 III. PIC/S Future PIC/S new structure as of 1 January 2014 All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 PIC/S Executive Bureau - - Joey Gouws (South Africa / MCC), PIC/S Chairperson; Paul Hargreaves (UK / MHRA), PIC/S Deputy Chairman and Chair of the Sub-Committee on Budget, Risk and Audit (SCB); Helena Baião (Portugal / INFARMED IP), immediate former Chairperson; Boon Meow Hoe (Singapore / HSA), Chair of the Sub-Committee on Training (SCT); Alexander Hoenel (Austria / AGES), Chair of the Sub-Committee on Expert Circles (SCEC); Jacques Morénas (France / ANSM), Chair of the Sub-Committee on Strategic Development (SCSD); Anne Hayes (Ireland / IMB), Chair of the Sub-Committee on Compliance (SCC); Paul Gustafson (Canada / HPFBI), Chair of the Sub-Committee on GM(D)P Harmonisation (SCH); Tor Gråberg (Sweden / MPA), Chair of the Sub-Committee on All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 Communication (SC COM). IV. Final Remarks Trends and Needs There is a need Of Training for regulators and industry for adequate expertise at National and Global level (at a time of limited resources) There is a need to share knowledge with the network of Assessors and Inspectors (Training & Guidance) incl. discussions before, during & after assessment For appropriate continuous dialogue between regulators and industry All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 IV. Final Remarks Trends and Needs There is a need better use of international cooperation opportunities in order to achieve a better use of resources through better communication and collaboration in areas of common interest Entails the use of : Science-based Policies and Standards Risk-based orientation To ensure Public Health Protection All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 IV. Final Remarks Conclusions “PIC/S is continuously exploring ways to facilitate the harmonization of GM(D)P and to adapt to a beautiful but constantly changing world” Trust & Co-operation & Communication Reason for PIC/S’ success: mandate & mission still valid today Increasingly becoming and acting as a “global player” All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 V. Acknowledgement Mr. Boon Meow Hoe (HSA, Singapore) (Chinese version) Chair of the Sub-Committee on Training (SCT) Mr. Hans Smallenbroek (Netherlands/IGZ) PIC/S Former Chair Speakers, workshop facilitators, participants, “Global Supply Chains and GMP Compliance”, Canada Seminar 2013 Mr. Daniel Brunner; Mr. Jeffrey Hodgson PIC/S Secretariat all those who directly or indirectly contribute to PIC/S Goals and make them possible All rights reserved PIC/S 2013 PIC/S Secretariat 14 rue du Roveray CH - 1207 GENEVA Tel: +41.22 738 92 16 Fax:+41.22 738 92 17 Email:info@picscheme.org Web site: www.picscheme.org All rights reserved PIC/S 2014 The protection of public health and of the patient is our common goal Thanks for the attention