Spanish Civil War
Causes and a Cause
Introduction
Spanish Civil War
Broke out in 1936
More than a century of
social, economic and
political
Half a million died
Long-Term Causes
Weakness of Government
Political instability
19th century, Spain struggled between
periods of conservatism and liberalism
Several factors that caused tension and
division
Weakness of government
1871, Spain became a constitutional
monarchy
King Amadeo became head of state and he
appointed a Prime Minister who should
have commanded the majority of parliament
(Cortes)
Real power held by wealthy
oligarchs, control shifted between
cliques
Two main parties, Conservatives
and Liberals, no real difference
Elections rigged
Role of Spanish Army
Army had a powerful position in Spain due to its imperial
past
Believed that was the protector of the nation
Right and duty to intervene, did so in 1829, 1871,
1923
Did not act to save King Alfonso in 1931, led to his
exile
Did intervene during Second Republic and in 1936
Unpopular with the people
Reputation for brutality, expensive
Had lost Empire in 19th century, to American in 1898,
struggled to keep Morocco 1906-26
In need of reform
Too big, too many officers
Upper and middle classes make up the officer corps
Generally conservative
‘Africanistas’ had experienced war in
Morocco, the hard-liners
Role of Church
Catholic Church rich and
powerful in Spain
Disputes between them and
state in 1800s
State guaranteed role in
education and economy,
church used its wealth for
influence
Supported conservative
policies
Aristocracy tied closely to
the church
Defended rights of upper
classes, led to resentment
Economic Causes
Plight of agricultural workers
was a key factor, focus of the
economy, source of
employment
Did not provide sufficient
food and work was seasonal
Need for workers to migrate
Most in poverty, wide gap
Central and South, land
owned in huge estates, by
‘Grandees’ who dominated
the political system
North, peasants owned
small plots of land, too poor
Economic Causes
Rioting in the countryside
Civil Guard deployed to repress
No support from the church,
some looked to anarchists who
sought redistribution of land
Catholics resistant to socialist
ideas
Catholic Agrarian Federation
formed to support farmers and
reject socialism
Would later support Franco
Economic Causes
Industrially a need for reform
Had been little growth in the 19th century
Expansion limited by poverty
Workers poor conditions
Growth of trade unionism
Competed with one another though, failed to
achieve anything substantial
Employers could always find alternative labor
Workers’ parties had no power, no legal means
Spain’s neutrality in WWI had caused a boom
Increase in exports meant inflation and shortages
Militancy increased
Early 1920s major economic problems, led to
violent conflict in industrial cities in Catalonia
Role of Regions
Catalonia and Basque
provinces seeking
independence
Had own cultures and
economies
Primo de Rivera, Prime
Minister in 1923, ruled Spain
as a dictator until 1930
Took back Catalonia’s selfgoverning rights
Separatists supported
Republican movement that
overthrew Alfonso in 1931
Political Opposition
Number of groups opposed to status quo
Liberal groups achieved nothing, remained
a political force
Spanish Socialist Party had grown, UGT
more visible
Small Communist Party after Russian
Revolution
All divided over which reforms should take
place
Moderate Socialists Indalecio Prieto
Radicals Largo Caballero
Anarchists also a major force
Popular with the peasants
Boycotted democracy, active with CNT
Responsible for some bombings
Fall of the Monarchy and
Establishment of the Second Republic
King Alfonso was not a modernizer
Pressure on him after defeats and ineffective
government
Did not resist coup of General Primo de Rivera
in 1923
Primo de Rivera
Tried to establish right-wing regime similar to
Italy
Infrastructure and Industry advances
Ran up massive debts, worse when Depression
hit
Alienated landowners and army
Resigned in 1930, did not bring about stability
Elections in 1930 then showed support for
republicans, liberals, socialists and Catholics
King went into voluntary exile
Neither Church or army stepped in
Second Republic established 1931
Short-Term Causes
Political Polarization
Between 1931 and 1936,
major gap in ideology
Did not anticipate war in
1931
By 1936, it will be desireable
The Left Republic
Following departure, center-left
wanted to modernize
Government declared a new
constitution, stating Spain was a
democratic republic of workers
Manuel Azana became President
Key issues continued
Addressed church’s power
Anticlerical, tried to separate
church and state
No longer in control of
education, state payment of
clergy stopped, power of the
army attacked
Made it only more
nationalist really
The Left Republic
Desperate economic problems existed in
Spain exacerbated by the Depression
Agricultural prices tumbling, exports fell,
unemployment rising
Industrial output fell
Largo Caballero, Minister of Labour intiated
an extensive land redistribution program
with compensation
1932, land law, right saw as a major threat
Civil unrest and violence continued
Dealt with brutally, introduced Assault
Guard
Risings by both sides
General Jose Sanjurjo from right
Casas Viejos anarchist uprising from left
Army remained mostly loyal
The Left Republic
Catalonia given its own parliament,
some powers over law and education
Right-wing groups angered by this move
towards independence and break-up of
Spain
New right-wing party, Confederacion
Espanola de Derechas Autonamas,
formed to defend the church and
landlords
CEDA led by Jose Maria Gil-Robles
modelled on German Nazi Party
Political divisions definitely increased
Azana also attacked anarchists, lost him
some working class support, resigned in
1933
The Right Republic
Elections of 1933, Republic swung
right
Disunity on the left
CEDA largest party, Gil-Robles
made War Minister
New government ruled for two
years
Known as black years,
systematically reversed Left
Republic’s reforms
Church and land restored
Catalonia suppressed by
troops
Threat of general strike
The right lost support of the
Basques
The Right Republic
Political response to Right
Republic divided
CEDA labeled Spanish Nazi
party, some thought they
should seek Soviet-style
solution
Right demanded a shift to
more authoritarian approach
Led to more cooperation
on the Left
The Popular Front
Right wing disintegrated as economic and political
situation deteriorated
Election of 1936, Popular Front, anti-fascist pact of
left-wing groups including socialists and
communists, victorious
Some associated it with democracy, some with
Stalin
Manifesto promoted by Azana who now returned,
liberal, not radical
Wanted to restore reforms of 31-33
Still no political census
Anarchists encouraged peasants to seize land,
recruited militias
Conflict with fascists, government faced
increasing disorder
General strike in May
Right wing thought they were in left revolution
Immediate Causes
1936
Victory of the left in 1936 elections threw CEDA into
turmoil
Used funds to support military plans for a coup
Began planning immediately
Nationalist junior officers joined with senior Africanista
officers, including Franco
Coup began after murder of popular CEDA leader on
July 13
Azana attempted to prevent coup by moving key military
figures to remote posts
Conspirators made contact with two groups, Falange
(authoritarian radicals) and Carlists (monarchists)
Fascists versus communists
Coup began on July 17 from Morocco, took northern
Spain
Half of the army remained Republican, coup actually
unsuccessful without foreign intervention