NIETZSCHE — THE FOUR GREAT
ERRORS
Nietzsche argues that human beings have misunderstood the world for centuries because we
constantly repeat four major thinking mistakes.
These mistakes became the foundation of religion, morality, psychology, and everyday
beliefs.
He calls them “great errors” because they distort reality and weaken human life.
1. Error: Confusing Cause and Effect
People think A causes B, but actually B causes A.
✔ Nietzsche’s Example: Cornaro’s diet
Cornaro believed he lived long because he ate a small, strict diet.
Nietzsche says:
Cornaro didn’t choose that diet freely.
He had a slow metabolism (cause).
Because of that, he needed to eat lightly (effect).
So he mixed it up:
He thought the effect (diet) produced the cause (long life).
✔ Nietzsche’s general point
Morality says:
“If you behave virtuously, you will be happy.”
Nietzsche flips it:
“Happy, healthy people naturally behave in certain ways.
Their virtue is an effect of their strength, not a cause of it.”
✔ Why this matters
When societies decline, people think “luxury and vice destroyed them.”
Nietzsche says it’s the opposite:
Decline comes first → vice appears as a symptom.
2. Error: False Causality
People believe they know what “causes” their actions because they look inside themselves
and see “will,” “motives,” and an “I.”
Nietzsche says this is an illusion.
✔ Traditional belief
“I choose by my free will.”
“My motives cause my actions.”
“My mind produces my thoughts.”
✔ Nietzsche’s view
Modern psychology shows:
The will does not cause actions — it appears after the action starts.
“Motives” are surface explanations invented by consciousness.
The “I” itself is not a real cause — it is a story we tell ourselves.
✔ Big consequence
Human beings imagined the world to be like themselves:
everything has a “doer,”
everything has a “purpose,”
everything behaves like a “mind.”
From this, we invented:
souls
free will
God
atoms as “little souls”
the “thing-in-itself”
All based on a false idea of causality inside us.
3. Error: Imaginary Causes
When something happens and we don’t understand it, the mind invents a cause to feel safe.
✔ Example: dreams
When we feel something during a dream (pressure, noise, fear), the mind automatically
creates a story to explain it — even though the real cause is physical.
✔ Human pattern
We hate not knowing “why something happened,” so we invent explanations:
gods
spirits
signs
fate
moral punishments
“karma”
“bad luck”
These explanations comfort us but are not real causes.
4. Error: Belief in Free Will
Nietzsche says the idea of free will was created for moral judgment.
Priests and moralists needed a reason to say:
o “You are guilty.”
o “You deserve punishment.”
o “You chose wrongly.”
So they invented “free will” to make humans responsible for actions that are really caused by:
instincts
upbringing
physiology
strength or weakness of the organism
✔ Nietzsche’s conclusion
“Free will” was a tool for power, not truth.
� Overall Message: Revaluation of Values
These four errors show that:
Our moral beliefs come from misunderstandings.
We attribute causes where there are none.
We misunderstand ourselves most of all.
Real human flourishing requires dropping old explanations and seeing the world
clearly.
Nietzsche wants a new, life-affirming way of thinking — free from these four illusions.