Case Study: Beschta et al. 2018 - Trophic cascades in Yellowstone
These questions concern the second half of the paper. You should start reading from the
Results section.
Groupmates: Georgina Alvarenga Escobar Janet Nguyen
1) Large spatial scale: Review Figure 2.
a. As simply as possible explain what this figure is communicating about the
relationship between the density of Elk and the average heights of aspen trees.
Figure two, Image (A) explains the density over time between the East and the West.
The density of the population has been declining over the years. Image (B) focuses
more on the browsing rate. Browsing rate also shows a decrease over time. Image (C)
explains the relationship between the height sampled in young Aspen in the same two
sectors.
b. Are there any noticeable differences between what the researchers observed in the
West and East sector of the park?
There is little to no difference between what the researchers observed in the West and
East sector of the park. The elk density and aspen height in the West and East sector of the park
shows no major difference. They are pretty similar besides the difference of year for aspen
height. However, the browsing rate (graph B of figure 2) shows a different shape on the line of
the graph. The East sector line shows a steep change while the west sector line there is more of a
curve.
2) Medium spatial scale: How has the presence of humans at the Mammoth townsite thought
to have impacted the aspen there? Is this an example of direct or indirect interactions?
Explain the step-by-step effect.
The presence of humans at the Mammoth townsite has impacted the aspen there because it
reduced the predation risk for elk. This led to elks browsing behavior to drastically increase
because of human shielding. Human presence and development most likely played a role in
keeping wolves away from the townsite. Since, there are no predators around for elks to worry
about, it greatly affected the aspens height. This is an example of indirect interaction.
3) Small spatial scale: What factors seem to affect how much browsing Elk do in a given
location? Support your claim with data, for example by citing figures and parts of figures.
Hint: Figure 3 might be useful.
The factors that affect Elk’s browsing behavior in a given location are presence of
predators(wolves) and the geography of the location. The browsing rate decreases when there is
an increase of the aspen height because the elks can not flee freely when predators are around.
For example, in figure 3 (graph A), it shows the bar graph for “No” to be significantly greater
than the bar graph for “Yes’. However, there is not much difference between conifer edge or
downed logs relationship with the elk’s browsing behavior. As the bar graphs from both graph A
and B in figure 3 show little to no significant difference. Routes that were mostly frequented by
wolves show to have low browsing rates since elks began to avoid those areas.
4) Why was it important to conduct a study like this at multiple spatial scales, rather than a
single spatial scale, for a study area such as Yellowstone?
It is important to conduct multiple scales rather than one to show reliability and validity. A
large place such as Yellowstone should have as much information as possible to reduce bias,
and provide detailed information about the place.
5) Can you think of any ways in which this study or the paper could be improved or expanded?
There are multiple ways in which this paper could be improved. However, if my classmates and I
were to take initiative to do “better research” we would improve the scales, expand the perimeter
of the research studied to obtain better results.