Prof. Dr. Ursula Walther Summer 2026
Managing Financial Resources
Examples of Examination Questions 2026 with Answers:
1. Basics of company organization:
• What is a company’s objective according to most finance textbooks
and how does this contrast to real life?
A company’s main objective in most finance textbooks is to maximize
shareholder value, meaning the company should make decisions that
increase the value of the owners’ investment. In theory, managers
should choose projects that increase firm value, generate positive cash
flows, and improve profitability.
In real life, however, companies do not only focus on shareholders. They
also consider employees, customers, suppliers, banks, government
regulations, sustainability, reputation, and long-term survival. For
example, a company may reject a highly profitable project if it damages
its public image or violates ESG expectations.
• Explain the “financial balance” (see overhead no. 14)
Financial balance means that a company must keep a healthy
relationship between its financing and investment structure. Long-term
assets should usually be financed with long-term capital, such as equity
or long-term debt. Short-term assets can be financed with short-term
liabilities. If a company finances long-term projects with short-term
loans, it may face liquidity problems.
• Why does a company’s legal form matter for its financing possibilities?
A company’s legal form matters because it affects how the company
can raise capital. For example, a sole proprietorship may have limited
access to financing because it depends mainly on the owner’s money
and bank loans. A corporation can raise equity from shareholders, issue
bonds, and has limited liability, making it more attractive to investors.
2. Discounted Cash Flow Valuation
As a preparation for the following questions, please also see the exercises Part
1.
• Explain the time value of money:
o Why is money today worth more than at a later time?
The time value of money means that money today is worth more than money
in the future. This is because money today can be invested and earn interest.
1
Also, future money is uncertain because inflation, risk, and opportunity costs
reduce its value.
For example, €100 today is better than €100 next year because you can invest
it and earn interest. If the interest rate is 7%, €100 today becomes €107 after
one year.
o Which capital market assumptions are necessary for this methodology?
The main capital market assumptions are:
•
Investors can lend and borrow at the same market interest rate.
•
Capital markets are efficient.
•
There are no transaction costs or taxes in the simplified model.
•
Investors prefer more money to less money.
•
Future cash flows can be discounted using an appropriate rate.
o Explain the role of compound interest and its power both for compounding
and discounting.
In Managerial Finance, understanding compound interest is one of the most
important concepts because it forms the foundation of time value of money
(TVM). The principle states that money available today is worth more than the
same amount received in the future because today's money can earn returns
over time.
The concept of compound interest has two major applications:
1. Compounding – determining the future value of money.
2. Discounting – determining the present value of future cash flows.
The relationship between these two concepts is fundamental in almost
every financial decision made by businesses and investors.
(A) COMPOUNDING:
Compound interest means earning interest not only on the original amount invested
(principal) but also on the accumulated interest from previous periods.
Unlike simple interest, where interest is earned only on the principal, compound
interest creates exponential growth.
This is often called:
"Interest earning interest."
2
The longer money remains invested, the faster it grows.
Compound Interest Formula
FV = PV(1+r)^n
Where:
•
FV = Future Value
•
PV = Present Value (initial investment)
•
r = interest rate
•
n = number of periods
Example: FV=PV(1+r)n=1000(1+0.05)20=$2,653.30
Example 1: Power of Compounding
Suppose Michelle invests:
•
€10,000
•
Interest = 8%
•
Investment = 10 years
Future Value
= €10,000 × (1.08)¹⁰
= €21,589
Notice:
Original investment:
€10,000
Interest earned:
€11,589
Why is this called the "Power" of Compounding?
The interest earned becomes greater than the original investment simply
because interest keeps generating additional interest.
3
Because growth is exponential, not linear.
Example:
Year Amount (€)
0
10,000
1
10,800
2
11,664
3
12,597
5
14,693
10
21,589
20
46,610
30
100,627
Notice how growth becomes much faster during the later years.
This demonstrates why starting investments early is extremely
valuable.
Factors Affecting Compound Growth
The future value increases when:
1. Higher Interest Rate
Higher returns generate faster growth.
Example
5%: €10,000 becomes €16,289 after 10 years
8%: €21,589
10%: €25,937
•
A small increase in the interest rate creates a large difference over time
2. Longer Investment Period
Time has the greatest impact.
Investment: €10,000 at 8%
o 10 years: €21,589
o 20 years: €46,610
o 30 years: €100,627
•
•
Notice that the final ten years generate more wealth than the
first twenty years combined.
This demonstrates the true power of compounding.
4
3. More Frequent Compounding
Interest may be compounded:
o
o
o
o
o
Annually
Semi-annually
Quarterly
Monthly
Daily
• The more frequently interest is compounded, the greater the future
value.
Managerial Finance Application of Compounding
Companies use compounding to estimate:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Future investment values
Retirement funds
Sinking funds
Growth of cash reserves
Project returns
Shareholder wealth creation
Investment portfolios
Example:
A company invests excess cash today and wants to know its value after 15
years. Compounding provides that answer.
(B) Discounting:
Discounting is simply the reverse process of compounding.
Instead of asking:
"How much will today's money become in the future?"
we ask
"What is a future amount worth today?"
Businesses need this because money received years from now is worth less
than money received immediately.
Present Value Formula:
PV=FV(1+r)nPV=\frac{FV}{(1+r)^n}PV=(1+r)nFV
Example of Discounting:
A company expects to receive €100,000 after five years.
Required return: 10%
Present Value = €100,000 ÷ (1.10)⁵= €62,092
5
This means: Receiving €100,000 five years from now is financially equivalent to
receiving only about €62,092 today if the required return is 10%.
Why is Discounting Important?
Money loses value over time because of:
1. Inflation
Prices increase over time.
€100 today buys more goods than €100 ten years from now.
2. Opportunity Cost
Money invested today can generate returns.
Receiving money later means losing investment opportunities.
3. Risk
Future cash flows may never be received.
Examples:
•
•
•
•
Customer default
Economic recession
Bankruptcy
Market uncertainty
Higher risk requires higher discount rates.
Managerial Finance Applications of Discounting:
•
Discounting is used extensively in capital budgeting.
Examples include:
1. Net Present Value (NPV)
Managers evaluate projects by discounting future cash flows.
Positive NPV → Accept project
Negative NPV → Reject project
2. Business Valuation
Companies are valued based on the present value of expected future cash
flows.
3. Bond Pricing
Bond prices equal the present value of:
•
•
Future coupon payments
Principal repayment
6
4. Stock Valuation
Investors estimate stock prices by discounting expected dividends or
future free cash flows.
5. Loan Decisions
Banks discount future loan repayments when evaluating lending decisions.
Relationship Between Compounding and Discounting:
Compounding
Moves money forward in time
Calculates Future Value
Measures investment growth
Used for savings and investments
Formula: FV = PV(1+r)^n
Discounting
Moves money backward in time
Calculates Present Value
Measures today's worth of future
money
Used for project evaluation and
valuation
Formula: PV = FV/(1+r)^n
Why This is Important in Managerial Finance
Every major financial decision relies on these concepts.
Managers use compounding and discounting to answer questions such as:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Should we invest in this project?
Should we purchase new equipment?
Is borrowing worthwhile?
What is the value of this business?
How much should we save today to meet future obligations?
Which investment generates the highest shareholder value?
Without understanding compound interest, managers cannot accurately evaluate
investment opportunities or make sound financial decisions.
Summary on Compounding and Discounting:
Compound interest is the process of earning interest on both the original principal
and previously earned interest, resulting in exponential growth over time. In
managerial finance, its power is demonstrated through two key applications:
compounding and discounting.
•
Compounding calculates the future value of money using the formula
FV=PV(1+r)nFV = PV(1+r)^nFV=PV(1+r)n,
7
helping businesses forecast investment growth, retirement funds, and longterm savings.
•
Discounting is the reverse process, calculating the present value of future
cash flows using
PV=FV(1+r)nPV = \frac{FV}{(1+r)^n}PV=(1+r)nFV.
•
It is essential in capital budgeting, Net Present Value (NPV), business
valuation, bond pricing, and investment appraisal.
•
Together, compounding and discounting embody the time value of money
principle, enabling managers to compare cash flows occurring at different
points in time and make financially sound decisions that maximize
shareholder wealth.
Given is the following investment project, the interest rate (discount rate) is
7%:
0
1
2
3
4
-400
50
100
120
150
o Explain how to find the NPV and the NFV
o Explain how NPV and NFV can help assessing the project’s profitability
o Explain the possible meanings of the interest rate (discount rate)
§
NPV and the NFV:
The NPV formula is:
§
NPV = (50 / 1.07) + (100 / 1.07²) + (120 / 1.07³) + (150 /
1.07⁴) - 400
Year
1
2
3
4
§
Cash Flow
50
100
120
150
Present Value
46.73
87.34
97.95
114.43
Total PV of inflows = 346.45
§ NPV=346.45−400=−53.55
§ So the NPV is negative. This means the project
should be rejected because it destroys value at a 7%
required return.
8
The NFV, or Net Future Value, takes all cash flows to the end of the
project:
§
§
NFV=NPV×(1.07)4
NFV=−53.55×1.3108=−70.20
The negative NFV also shows the project is not profitable.
The discount rate can mean:
• Required rate of return
• Opportunity cost of capital
• Cost of capital
• Minimum return expected by investors
• Risk-adjusted return.
The discount rate in an NPV calculation can be interpreted as “cost of capital”.
What does this mean? Is there a cost of capital for all types of capital (for both
debt and equity)?
The discount rate in an NPV calculation can be interpreted as the "Cost of Capital."
The cost of capital is the minimum rate of return that investors require for providing
funds to the company. In other words, it is the opportunity cost of investing money
in a particular project instead of investing it elsewhere with similar risk.
When a company evaluates an investment project using Net Present Value (NPV),
the discount rate represents this required return. Future cash flows are discounted
because investors expect to earn at least the cost of capital.
For example:
• If investors require a 7% return, every future cash flow is discounted at 7%.
• The project should only be accepted if it generates returns greater than or
equal to this required return.
• If the project earns less than the cost of capital, it destroys shareholder
value.
This is why the NPV decision rule is:
• NPV > 0: Accept the project because it earns more than the cost of capital.
• NPV = 0: The project exactly earns the required return.
• NPV < 0: Reject the project because it earns less than the cost of capital.
Is there a cost of capital for all types of capital?
Yes. Every source of financing has a cost, including both debt and equity.
1. Cost of Debt
The cost of debt is the interest rate that the company pays on loans
or bonds.
9
Examples include:
• Bank loans
• Corporate bonds
• Credit facilities
If a company borrows €1 million at 5% interest, the cost of debt is 5%.
However, because interest is tax-deductible, the after-tax cost of debt is lower.
Formula:
After-tax Cost of Debt=rD(1−T)
where:
• rDr_DrD = interest rate
• TTT = corporate tax rate
2. Cost of Equity
Many people mistakenly believe equity has no cost because companies do not
pay fixed interest to shareholders. This is incorrect.
Equity also has a cost because shareholders expect compensation for investing
their money and taking greater risk.
Shareholders expect returns through:
• Dividends
• Capital gains (share price appreciation)
•
If investors expect a 10% annual return, then the company's cost
of equity is 10%.
•
Unlike debt, equity has no contractual payment, but it is usually
more expensive because shareholders bear more risk.
Why is Equity More Expensive than Debt?
Debt holders:
• Receive fixed interest.
• Have priority if the company goes bankrupt.
• Face lower risk.
Shareholders:
• Receive dividends only if profits exist.
• Are paid last during liquidation.
• Bear greater business risk.
Because they assume more risk, shareholders demand a higher required
return.
Typically:
• Cost of Debt = 4–6%
• Cost of Equity = 8–15%
10
How are both costs combined?
• Companies are financed by both debt and equity.
• Therefore, when calculating NPV, companies usually use the Weighted
Average Cost of Capital (WACC) as the discount rate.
The formula is:
WACC = (E / (D + E)) × rE + (D / (D + E)) × rD × (1 − T)
Where:
E = Market Value of Equity
D = Market Value of Debt
rE = Cost of Equity
rD = Cost of Debt
T = Corporate Tax Rate
WACC represents the company's overall cost of financing and is commonly used
as the discount rate in DCF and NPV analysis.
Example
A company finances a project using:
• 60% Equity
• 40% Debt
Cost of Equity = 10%
Cost of Debt = 5%
Tax Rate = 30%
WACC=(0.60×10%)+(0.40×5%×(1−0.30))
=6%+1.4%=7.4%= 6\% + 1.4\% = 7.4\%=6%+1.4%=7.4%
The company should therefore discount future cash flows at 7.4% when evaluating
projects with similar risk.
Key Takeaways (Exam Summary)
• Cost of capital is the minimum return required by investors for providing
funds.
• In an NPV calculation, the discount rate usually represents the cost of
capital.
• Debt has a cost because companies pay interest.
• Equity also has a cost because shareholders expect dividends and capital
gains.
• Equity is generally more expensive than debt because shareholders take
more risk.
• Companies often use the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) as the
discount rate because it combines the costs of both debt and equity.
• A project should be accepted only if it earns more than its cost of capital
(positive NPV).
11
What is an annuity (or perpetuity)? What does it mean that an annuity (or perpetuity)
grows? What are areas of applications for annuities (or perpetuities)?
1. What is an Annuity?
An annuity is a series of equal cash payments made at regular intervals
for a fixed period of time.
Examples include:
• Monthly mortgage payments
• Car loan repayments
• Pension payments for 20 years
• Annual insurance premiums
• Lease payments
An annuity has:
• Equal payment amount
• Equal time intervals
• A fixed ending date
Formula for the Present Value of an Annuity:
•
•
PV = PMT(1-(1+r)^{-n}/r
PV=PMTr1−(1+r)−n=10000.051−(1+0.05)−20=$12,462.21
Where:
• PV = Present Value
• PMT = Annual payment
• r = Discount rate (interest rate)
• n = Number of payments
2. What is a Perpetuity?
A perpetuity is a series of equal cash payments that continue forever.
Unlike an annuity, a perpetuity has no maturity date.
Examples include:
• Some preferred shares that pay fixed dividends forever
• Endowment funds
• Certain government or historical bonds (consols)
• The Gordon Growth Model used for valuing companies
Formula for a Perpetuity
PV=CrPV=\frac{C}{r}PV=rC
Where:
•
•
•
PV = Present Value
C = Constant annual payment
r = Discount rate
Although payments continue forever, the present value remains finite
because future cash flows are continuously discounted.
12
3. What does it mean that an annuity (or perpetuity) grows?
A growing annuity or growing perpetuity means that the cash payments
increase by a constant growth rate every year instead of remaining
constant.
For example:
Year
1
2
3
4
Payment
€1,000
€1,030
€1,060.90
€1,092.73
If the growth rate is 3%, each payment is 3% higher than the previous one.
This growth often reflects:
• Inflation
• Salary increases
• Business expansion
• Increasing rental income
• Growing dividends
Growing Perpetuity Formula
•
PV=r−gC1
Where:
• C₁ = First payment next period
• r = Discount rate
• g = Constant growth rate
Important condition:
r>gr>gr>g
The discount rate must be greater than the growth rate.
Otherwise, the formula does not work because the present value would
become infinite.
Growing Annuity
A growing annuity also has increasing payments, but only for a limited number of
years.
Example:
• A salary that increases 5% every year for 30 years.
• Rental income increasing annually during a 10-year lease.
13
4. Applications of Annuities
Annuities are widely used in finance because many financial contracts involve
fixed periodic payments.
Examples include:
Loans and Mortgages
Most home loans require equal monthly payments.
Example:
A €250,000 mortgage paid monthly over 30 years.
Car Loans
Monthly repayments remain constant until the loan is fully repaid.
Pension Payments
Many retirement plans pay a fixed amount each month for a certain number
of years.
Insurance
Insurance companies calculate premiums and future benefit payments using
annuity models.
Lease Contracts
Businesses often pay equal lease payments every month or year.
Student Loans
Loan repayments are usually structured as annuities.
5. Applications of Perpetuities
Perpetuities are mainly used in company valuation and investment analysis.
Examples include:
Dividend Valuation
The Dividend Discount Model (DDM) assumes dividends continue
forever.
Stock Valuation
Many mature companies are valued using a growing perpetuity assumption
after an explicit forecast period.
Business Valuation
In DCF valuation, the Terminal Value is commonly calculated using the
growing perpetuity formula.
Endowment Funds
Universities often invest endowment funds to generate perpetual income.
Preferred Shares
Some preferred stocks promise fixed dividends forever.
14
Difference Between Annuity and Perpetuity:
Feature
Number of Payments
End Date
Payment Amount
Growth Possible
Common Uses
Annuity
Perpetuity
Fixed
Yes
Usually Equal
Yes
Loans, pensions,
leases
Infinite
No
Usually Equal
Yes
Company valuation, preferred stock,
terminal value
Example;
• Suppose you receive €1,000 every year for 5 years.
This is an annuity because the payments are fixed and end after five years.
•
Now suppose you receive €1,000 every year forever.
This is a perpetuity because there is no ending date.
•
If those payments increase by 2% every year, they become a growing
annuity (for a fixed number of years) or a growing perpetuity (forever).
KEY TAKE-AWAY:
• An annuity is a series of equal cash payments made at regular intervals for a
fixed period of time, such as mortgage payments, pensions, lease payments,
or insurance premiums.
•
In contrast, a perpetuity is a series of equal cash payments that continue
forever, with no maturity date.
•
A growing annuity or growing perpetuity means that the payments increase at
a constant growth rate each period, often due to inflation, salary increases,
rental growth, or rising dividends.
•
Annuities are commonly used in loans, mortgages, pensions, and lease
contracts, while perpetuities are mainly used in business valuation, the
Dividend Discount Model, preferred shares, endowment funds, and terminal
value calculations in Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis.
•
The key difference is that an annuity has a fixed ending date, whereas a
perpetuity continues indefinitely.
15
How is it possible that an infinite cash flow (e.g., a perpetuity) has a finite
present value?
A perpetuity is a series of equal cash payments that continue forever.
Although the payments are infinite, their present value is finite because of
the time value of money. Money received in the future is worth less than
money received today since it could have been invested to earn interest, and
future cash flows are subject to risk and inflation.
Each future payment is discounted back to its present value using the
discount rate. As the payments occur further into the future, their present
values become progressively smaller and approach zero. Therefore, even
though there are infinitely many payments, the sum of all discounted cash
flows converges to a finite amount.
The present value of a perpetuity is calculated using the formula:
[
PV=\frac{C}{r}
]
Where:
•
•
•
PV = Present Value
C = Constant annual cash flow
r = Discount rate
For a growing perpetuity, the formula is:
[
PV=\frac{C_1}{r-g}
]
Where:
•
•
•
C₁ = First payment next period
r = Discount rate
g = Constant growth rate
The condition r > g must always be satisfied. If the growth rate were equal
to or greater than the discount rate, the present value would become
infinite.
Example: If an investment pays €100 every year forever and the discount
rate is 5%, the present value is:
[
PV=\frac{100}{0.05}=€2,000
]
16
Although the payments continue forever, the investment is worth only
€2,000 today because future payments are discounted.
Conclusion: A perpetuity has a finite present value because discounting
reduces the value of future cash flows, causing the infinite series of
payments to converge to a finite amount.
How does an annuity loan work?
An annuity loan is a loan in which the borrower pays the same total amount
(annuity) at regular intervals, usually monthly or annually, until the loan is fully
repaid.
Each payment consists of two components:
1. Interest payment – the cost of borrowing money.
2. Principal repayment – the portion that reduces the outstanding loan balance.
At the beginning of the loan, the outstanding balance is high, so the interest
portion is also high while the principal repayment is relatively small.
As the loan balance decreases over time:
•
•
•
The interest portion decreases because interest is calculated on the
remaining balance.
The principal repayment increases.
The total payment remains constant throughout the loan.
For example, a borrower takes out a €100,000 mortgage at an annual interest
rate of 5%. Every year, the borrower pays the same amount. In the first year, most
of the payment goes toward interest. In later years, a larger portion goes toward
repaying the principal until the loan is completely paid off.
Annuity loans are commonly used for:
•
•
•
•
Home mortgages
Car loans
Student loans
Business loans
Advantages:
•
•
Fixed and predictable payments make budgeting easier.
The loan is fully repaid at the end of the repayment period.
Disadvantages:
•
Interest payments are highest during the early years.
17
•
Total interest paid over the loan term may be significant.
An annuity loan is one of the most common repayment methods because it
provides borrowers with stable and predictable instalments.
Which are the three basic redemption types for loans? Is the total sum of
interest payments (ignoring discounting) a good measure for the effective cost
of the loan?
There are three basic redemption (repayment) types for loans:
1. Bullet Loan (Lump-Sum Loan)
In a bullet loan, the borrower pays only the interest during the life of the loan.
The entire principal is repaid at the maturity date.
Characteristics:
•
•
•
Low periodic payments.
Large final repayment.
Common in corporate finance and bond financing.
2. Constant Principal (Amortizing) Loan
In a constant principal loan, the borrower repays the same amount of principal in
every period. Since the outstanding balance decreases over time, the interest
payments also decrease.
Characteristics:
•
•
•
Principal repayment remains constant.
Interest payments decrease.
Total payment decreases over time.
3. Annuity Loan
In an annuity loan, the borrower makes equal total payments every period. Each
payment includes both interest and principal repayment.
Characteristics:
•
•
•
•
Equal total instalments.
Interest portion decreases over time.
Principal repayment increases over time.
Most common repayment method for mortgages.
18
Is the total sum of interest payments (ignoring discounting) a good measure of
the effective cost of the loan?
No.
Simply adding all interest payments does not accurately measure the true cost
of a loan because it ignores the time value of money.
Money paid today is more expensive than money paid in the future since money
has an opportunity cost and can earn interest if invested.
The effective cost of a loan should therefore be evaluated using discounted
cash flow methods, such as:
•
•
•
•
Present Value (PV)
Net Present Value (NPV)
Effective Interest Rate (EIR)
Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
These methods discount future payments back to their present value, providing
a more accurate measure of the loan's real economic cost.
Conclusion: The total interest paid alone is not a reliable measure of
borrowing cost. The timing of payments must also be considered through
discounting, which reflects the time value of money.
SECTION 3 – INVESTMENT DECISIONS
3.1 Which investment decision rules do you know? Pick one and explain it in more
detail.
Investment decision rules are methods used by managers and investors to
determine whether an investment project should be accepted or rejected. Their
objective is to identify projects that create value and maximize shareholders'
wealth. Different decision rules evaluate projects from different perspectives,
such as profitability, liquidity, efficiency, or rate of return.
The most common investment decision rules are:
•
•
•
•
•
Payback Period
Net Present Value (NPV)
Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
Profitability Index (PI)
Net Future Value (NFV)
19
Among these methods, the Net Present Value (NPV) is generally regarded as the
best investment decision rule because it directly measures the value created for
investors.
The NPV method calculates the difference between the present value of all
expected future cash inflows and the initial investment. All future cash flows are
discounted using the project's required rate of return or cost of capital to account
for the time value of money.
The NPV decision rule is straightforward:
•
•
•
If NPV > 0, the project should be accepted because it creates value.
If NPV = 0, the investor is financially indifferent.
If NPV < 0, the project should be rejected because it destroys value.
For mutually exclusive projects, the project with the highest positive NPV should
be selected because it generates the greatest increase in shareholder wealth. This
decision rule is emphasized in the lecture as the primary criterion for evaluating
investment projects.
3.2 Explain the Payback Period and its advantages and disadvantages.
The Payback Period is one of the simplest investment appraisal methods. It
measures the amount of time required for an investment to recover its initial cost
from its cash inflows. In other words, it answers the question:
"How long does it take to get back the initial investment?"
According to the lecture, the payback period is the number of years until the
cumulative cash inflows equal or exceed the original investment.
For example, if a project requires an initial investment of €100,000 and generates
€25,000 per year, the payback period is four years.
Companies often establish a maximum acceptable payback period. Projects that
recover the investment before this limit are accepted, while those exceeding the
limit are rejected.
Advantages
The payback period offers several benefits:
•
•
•
•
It is easy to understand and calculate.
It focuses on liquidity by showing how quickly invested money is recovered.
It helps evaluate project risk because projects with shorter payback periods
generally expose investors to less uncertainty.
It is useful for businesses facing cash constraints or operating in highly
uncertain environments.
20
Disadvantages
Despite its simplicity, the payback period has important limitations:
•
•
•
•
It ignores the time value of money, meaning it does not discount future
cash flows.
It ignores all cash flows occurring after the payback period.
It may accept projects with a negative Net Present Value.
It tends to favor short-term investments while discriminating against
profitable long-term projects.
Therefore, the payback period should not be used as the sole investment criterion
but rather as a supplementary measure alongside NPV or IRR. These advantages
and disadvantages are highlighted in the lecture slides.
3.3 Explain the Net Present Value (NPV) Rule.
The Net Present Value (NPV) rule is considered the most reliable investment
decision criterion because it directly measures how much value an investment adds
to the company.
The NPV is calculated by discounting all expected future cash inflows to their
present value and subtracting the initial investment.
Mathematically,
NPV = Present Value of Future Cash Flows − Initial Investment
The decision rule is:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Accept the project if NPV > 0.
Reject the project if NPV < 0.
If several mutually exclusive projects are available, choose the one with the
highest positive NPV.
The lecture explains that the Net Present Value represents the increase in
the investor's wealth at the beginning of the investment. It is also
interpreted as the maximum amount an investor could pay for an
investment opportunity without becoming financially worse off.
For example, if an investment has an NPV of €50,000, accepting the project
increases shareholder wealth by €50,000.
Because it considers all project cash flows, the time value of money, and
the required return, NPV is generally preferred over other investment
decision methods.
21
3.4 What is the reinvestment assumption in the NPV Rule?
The reinvestment assumption of the Net Present Value rule states that all
intermediate cash flows generated by the project can be reinvested at the
discount rate, which is usually the firm's cost of capital.
For example, if the project's discount rate is 10%, every cash inflow received
before the end of the project is assumed to earn 10% until the project's
completion.
The lecture illustrates this assumption using a bank account example. The project
is assumed to be financed through an overdraft account that both pays and charges
interest at the same discount rate. This allows all intermediate cash flows to be
reinvested consistently at the required rate of return.
This assumption is generally considered realistic because companies are usually
able to reinvest funds at approximately their cost of capital rather than at
unusually high rates.
For this reason, financial theory considers the NPV reinvestment assumption more
realistic than the IRR assumption.
3.5 How can we adjust the NPV Rule to reflect the riskiness of cash flows?
Projects with more uncertain future cash flows are riskier and therefore should
have lower present values than projects with stable and predictable cash flows.
The lecture explains two methods for incorporating risk into the Net Present Value
calculation.
Method 1 – Reduce the Expected Cash Flows
The expected future cash inflows can be adjusted downward to reflect uncertainty
before discounting them using the risk-free rate.
For example, expected cash inflows of €320, €610, €450 and €400 may be reduced
to lower values to account for the probability that actual cash flows will be
smaller.
Method 2 – Increase the Discount Rate
Instead of reducing the cash flows, the company can use a higher discount rate,
known as a risk-adjusted discount rate.
A higher discount rate reduces the present value of future cash flows because
investors require higher compensation for taking greater risk.
22
According to the lecture, both methods are theoretically equivalent and aim to
reflect the project's uncertainty. As project risk increases, either expected cash
flows decrease or the required rate of return increases, resulting in a lower Net
Present Value.
For example, if the risk-free discount rate is 10%, a risky project may instead be
evaluated using a discount rate of 14%. This higher rate produces a lower NPV,
reflecting the additional risk faced by investors.
Oral Exam Summary
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Investment decision rules help managers decide whether an investment
should be accepted or rejected.
The main methods are the Payback Period, Net Present Value, Internal Rate
of Return, Profitability Index, and Net Future Value.
Among these, the Net Present Value is considered the best because it
measures how much value the project adds to shareholder wealth.
A project should be accepted if its NPV is positive and rejected if it is
negative.
The Payback Period measures how quickly the initial investment is
recovered and is useful for assessing liquidity but ignores the time value of
money and cash flows after payback.
The NPV rule assumes that intermediate cash flows can be reinvested at the
discount rate, which is generally the firm's cost of capital.
To account for project risk, managers can either reduce expected cash flows
or apply a higher risk-adjusted discount rate, both of which lower the
project's NPV.
3.6 What is an investment project's Internal Rate of Return (IRR)? Explain the
IRR Rule.
The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is the discount rate that makes the Net Present
Value (NPV) of an investment equal to zero. In other words, it is the project's
expected annual rate of return based on its estimated cash flows.
Mathematically,
NPV=0
Or
0 = -I + (CF1 / (1 + IRR)) + (CF2 / (1 + IRR)²) + ... + (CFn / (1 + IRR)ⁿ)
Where:
I = Initial Investment
CF1 = Cash Flow in Year 1
CF2 = Cash Flow in Year 2
23
CFn = Cash Flow in Year n
IRR = Internal Rate of Return
The IRR represents the highest discount rate at which a project still breaks even. If
the discount rate increases above the IRR, the NPV becomes negative.
The IRR Rule states:
•
•
•
Accept the project if IRR > Required Rate of Return (Cost of Capital).
Reject the project if IRR < Required Rate of Return.
If IRR = Cost of Capital, the investor is indifferent because the project
neither creates nor destroys value.
For example, if a company's cost of capital is 8% and a project's IRR is 12%, the
project should be accepted because it generates a return greater than the
minimum required by investors.
The IRR is widely used because it expresses profitability as a percentage, making it
easy for managers and investors to compare projects of different sizes.
3.7 Explain Slide 10 – Interpretation of the IRR. What does it tell us?
The lecture explains that the Internal Rate of Return is the discount rate at
which the project's Net Present Value becomes exactly zero. At this point, the
present value of all future cash inflows is exactly equal to the initial investment.
Graphically, the NPV curve slopes downward as the discount rate increases.
The interpretation is:
•
•
•
When the discount rate is below the IRR, the project has a positive NPV
and should be accepted.
When the discount rate equals the IRR, the project's NPV is zero.
When the discount rate is above the IRR, the project has a negative NPV
and should be rejected.
This relationship illustrates that higher required returns reduce the present value
of future cash flows. Therefore, the IRR identifies the maximum required return
that still makes the investment worthwhile.
The lecture emphasizes that the IRR is not simply another percentage; rather, it
represents the project's break-even discount rate. If investors require a return
higher than the IRR, the investment is no longer economically attractive.
24
3.8 What are the potential difficulties when applying the IRR Rule?
Although the Internal Rate of Return is a useful investment criterion, it has several
important limitations.
1. Multiple IRRs
Projects with non-conventional cash flows, where the signs of the cash flows
change more than once, may produce more than one Internal Rate of Return.
This creates ambiguity because it is unclear which IRR should be used for
decision-making.
2. No IRR
Some investment projects do not produce any valid IRR because the NPV
curve never crosses zero.
3. Incorrect Reinvestment Assumption
The IRR method assumes that intermediate cash flows are reinvested at the
project's own IRR.
For example, if a project has an IRR of 25%, the IRR method assumes every
intermediate cash flow can also earn 25%, which is often unrealistic.
The NPV method instead assumes reinvestment at the company's cost of
capital, making it more realistic.
4. Mutually Exclusive Projects
When comparing two competing projects, the project with the highest IRR
does not always produce the highest shareholder value.
A project may have a very high percentage return but generate only a small
amount of total profit.
The NPV method correctly identifies which project creates more value.
5. Different Project Sizes
IRR ignores the scale of investment.
25
A small project earning 40% may create much less value than a large project
earning only 15%.
Therefore, managers should rely primarily on NPV when choosing between
projects.
3.9 When may the NPV Rule and the IRR Rule disagree?
The Net Present Value rule and the Internal Rate of Return rule generally produce
the same accept-or-reject decision for independent investment projects.
However, they may disagree when evaluating mutually exclusive projects.
The main situations where disagreement occurs are:
Different Timing of Cash Flows
One project generates cash flows earlier, while another generates larger
cash flows later.
The IRR tends to favour projects with earlier returns because it assumes
reinvestment at the IRR.
The NPV method discounts all cash flows using the cost of capital and
measures total value creation.
Different Investment Sizes
One project requires a small investment while another requires a much
larger investment.
The smaller project may have a higher IRR but produce a lower NPV.
The larger project may generate more shareholder wealth despite
having a lower percentage return.
Different Project Lifetimes
Projects lasting different numbers of years may also produce conflicting
rankings under IRR.
Because of these problems, financial theory recommends using NPV
whenever NPV and IRR disagree, since NPV directly measures the
increase in shareholder wealth.
26
3.10 What is the Timing Problem of the IRR Rule?
The Timing Problem occurs when two mutually exclusive projects generate cash
flows at different times.
One project produces large cash inflows during the early years, while another
generates larger cash flows later.
Because the IRR places greater emphasis on early cash flows, it may rank the first
project higher even though the second project creates greater overall value.
The NPV method discounts all cash flows at the company's cost of capital and
therefore correctly measures the project's total contribution to shareholder
wealth.
For example:
Project A:
•
•
•
High early cash inflows
IRR = 18%
NPV = €90,000
Project B:
•
•
•
Larger later cash inflows
IRR = 15%
NPV = €130,000
According to the IRR rule, Project A would be chosen.
According to the NPV rule, Project B should be selected because it generates
€40,000 more value.
This illustrates why the timing of cash flows can cause conflicts between IRR and
NPV.
3.11 Explain the Concept of a Profitability Index (PI)
The Profitability Index (PI) measures the value created for every euro invested.
It compares the present value of future cash inflows with the initial investment.
27
The formula is:
PI=Present Value of Future Cash Flows/Initial Investment
Decision Rule:
•
•
•
PI > 1 → Accept the project.
PI = 1 → Investor is indifferent.
PI < 1 → Reject the project.
For example:
Initial Investment = €100,000
Present Value of Future Cash Flows = €125,000
PI=125,000100,000=1.25PI=\frac{125,000}{100,000}=1.25PI=100,000125,00
0=1.25
This means that every €1 invested generates €1.25 in present value,
creating €0.25 of additional value.
The Profitability Index is especially useful when a company has limited
investment capital. It helps rank projects according to the value created
per euro invested, allowing managers to allocate scarce resources
efficiently.
However, like the IRR, the Profitability Index should be used alongside
NPV because it may not always select the project that creates the highest
total shareholder value.
Oral Exam Summary
•
•
•
•
•
•
The Internal Rate of Return, or IRR, is the discount rate that makes the Net
Present Value equal to zero.
A project should be accepted if its IRR is greater than the company's
required rate of return or cost of capital.
Graphically, the IRR is the point where the NPV curve crosses the horizontal
axis.
Although IRR is easy to interpret as a percentage return, it has several
weaknesses. It assumes reinvestment at the IRR, may produce multiple IRRs
for non-conventional cash flows, and can give incorrect rankings for
mutually exclusive projects.
The NPV and IRR rules may disagree when projects differ in timing, size, or
duration of cash flows.
In these situations, finance theory recommends following the NPV rule
because it directly measures shareholder value.
28
•
The Profitability Index measures the present value created for each euro
invested and is useful when investment funds are limited, although it should
also be used together with NPV rather than as a standalone decision
criterion.
CASE STUDY: PROFITABILITY ANALYSIS OF A MULTI-FAMILY HOUSE
3.12 Explain the concept of the DCF analysis, i.e., setting up the project's cash
flow and finding a discount rate.
The Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis is one of the most widely used valuation
methods in finance. It determines whether an investment creates value by
estimating all future cash inflows and outflows, discounting them to their present
value using an appropriate discount rate, and comparing the result with the initial
investment.
The main principle of DCF analysis is the time value of money, which states that
money received today is worth more than the same amount received in the future
because today's money can be invested to earn a return.
In the Multi-Family House case study, the DCF analysis begins by identifying all
expected project cash flows from the equity investor's perspective. These include:
Initial Investment (Year 0)
The initial investment consists of:
•
•
•
•
Purchase price of the building (€15,000)
Acquisition costs (approximately €2,000)
Renovation costs (€243,000)
Any additional costs financed by equity after deducting bank loans
These represent the project's initial cash outflow.
Operating Cash Inflows
After renovation, the building generates annual rental income from seven
apartments with a total living area of 420 square meters. According to the case
study, only 75% occupancy is assumed, with rent of €5 per square meter per
month, excluding utilities.
Operating Cash Outflows
Annual operating expenses include:
29
•
•
•
•
•
Administration costs
Repair and maintenance expenses (€6,000 annually)
Loan interest payments
Income taxes
Other operating expenses
Interest payments are tax deductible, while loan principal repayments are not.
Additionally, the investor may claim annual depreciation equal to 2.5% of the
production costs as a tax deduction.
Financing
The project is financed through:
•
•
•
A KfW loan with an interest rate of 1%
A regular bank loan with an interest rate of 3.5%
Equity provided by the investor
Both loans are annuity loans with equal periodic payments.
Choosing the Discount Rate
Once annual free cash flows are determined, they are discounted using an
appropriate discount rate.
The discount rate should reflect:
•
•
•
The opportunity cost of capital
The required return of investors
The project's level of risk
In the case study, the project is evaluated using a 5% discount rate when
calculating NPV.
The final DCF calculation discounts every annual cash flow to Year 0. The
difference between the present value of all future cash flows and the initial
investment is the project's Net Present Value.
A positive NPV indicates that the investment creates value and should be
accepted.
3.13 Explain the role of the Terminal Value.
The Terminal Value (TV) represents the value of all future cash flows that occur
after the explicit forecasting period.
30
In the Multi-Family House case study, cash flows are forecast for the first 20
years. However, the building is expected to continue generating rental income
beyond Year 20.
Rather than forecasting every future year's rental income individually, finance uses
the concept of a terminal value, which assumes that the project continues
indefinitely.
The case study specifically instructs students to assume that rental income
continues forever and to calculate the terminal value using the perpetuity
formula. After determining the terminal value, any remaining debt must be
deducted to obtain the investor's equity value.
The formula is:
TV=FCF21rTV=\frac{FCF_{21}}{r}TV=rFCF21
If the cash flows are expected to grow at a constant rate, the growing perpetuity
formula is used:
TV=FCF21r−gTV=\frac{FCF_{21}}{r-g}TV=r−gFCF21
Where:
•
•
•
•
TV = Terminal Value
FCF21 = Free Cash Flow in Year 21
r = Discount Rate
g = Long-term Growth Rate
The terminal value is then discounted back to the present value and added to the
discounted cash flows from the first twenty years.
In long-term investments such as real estate, the terminal value often represents
the largest portion of the project's total value because buildings continue
generating rental income for many decades.
3.14 Explain the meaning of the investment figures NPV, IRR and Payback Rule.
Three important indicators are used to evaluate the profitability of an investment
project: Net Present Value (NPV), Internal Rate of Return (IRR), and the
Payback Period.
Net Present Value (NPV)
The Net Present Value measures how much value a project adds to the investor
after considering the time value of money.
Decision rule:
31
•
•
NPV > 0 → Accept the project.
NPV < 0 → Reject the project.
Among all investment criteria, NPV is considered the best because it directly
measures shareholder wealth creation.
Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
The Internal Rate of Return is the discount rate that makes the project's NPV
equal to zero.
It represents the project's expected annual percentage return.
Decision rule:
•
•
IRR > Required Return → Accept the project.
IRR < Required Return → Reject the project.
Payback Period
The Payback Period measures how long it takes for cumulative cash inflows to
recover the initial investment.
Projects with shorter payback periods recover invested capital more quickly
and are generally considered less risky.
However, the Payback Rule ignores:
•
•
The time value of money.
Cash flows occurring after the payback period.
Therefore, it should be used only as a supplementary decision criterion.
Together, these three indicators provide a comprehensive assessment of
profitability, return, and liquidity.
3.15 How can we reflect project risk in this type of analysis?
Project risk refers to the uncertainty surrounding future cash flows. A project with
highly uncertain future income is riskier than one with stable and predictable cash
flows.
32
According to the lecture, there are two principal methods for incorporating risk
into a Discounted Cash Flow analysis.
Method 1 – Reduce Expected Cash Flows
The first approach is to reduce expected future cash inflows before discounting
them.
For example, if rental income is uncertain because occupancy rates may be
lower than expected, the projected rental income can be reduced accordingly.
This approach uses conservative estimates of future cash flows while
maintaining the risk-free discount rate.
Method 2 – Increase the Discount Rate
The second approach is to keep the expected cash flows unchanged but
increase the discount rate.
A higher discount rate reflects greater investment risk because investors
require higher compensation for bearing uncertainty.
For example:
•
•
Low-risk project → Discount Rate = 5%
High-risk project → Discount Rate = 8%
A higher discount rate reduces the present value of future cash flows and
therefore lowers the project's NPV.
The lecture states that both approaches are theoretically equivalent and
produce similar valuation results.
Additional risk analysis techniques include:
•
•
•
•
Sensitivity Analysis
Scenario Analysis
Break-even Analysis
Monte Carlo Simulation (advanced financial modelling)
These methods help investors understand how changes in occupancy, rental
income, construction costs, interest rates, inflation, or maintenance
expenses affect the project's profitability.
33
COMPLETE ORAL EXAM ANSWER
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
The Multi-Family House case is evaluated using Discounted Cash Flow
analysis. First, we identify all project cash inflows and outflows from the
equity investor's perspective.
Initial cash outflows include the purchase price, acquisition costs,
renovation costs, and the equity contribution after considering bank
financing.
Annual cash inflows consist mainly of rental income, while annual outflows
include maintenance costs, administration expenses, taxes, and loan
payments. These annual free cash flows are discounted to the present using
an appropriate discount rate, which reflects the investor's required rate of
return and the project's risk.
The Net Present Value measures how much value the investment creates,
while the Internal Rate of Return represents the project's expected annual
return.
The Payback Period measures how quickly the initial investment is
recovered but ignores the time value of money. Because the property is
expected to generate rental income beyond the explicit 20-year forecast, a
Terminal Value is calculated using the perpetuity formula and discounted
back to present value.
Finally, project risk can be incorporated by either reducing expected future
cash flows or increasing the discount rate.
Together, these methods allow investors to determine whether the
investment creates value and whether it should be accepted.
SECTION 4 – FINANCING INSTRUMENTS AND THE LEVERAGE EFFECT
4.1 Name several criteria that distinguish debt and equity.
Debt and equity are the two primary sources of financing used by companies.
Although both provide capital to finance business operations and investments, they
differ significantly in terms of ownership rights, repayment obligations, risk,
return, and control.
The main characteristics that distinguish debt and equity are:
Criteria
Ownership
Debt
No ownership rights
Voting Rights
Repayment
None
Must be repaid
Return
Fixed interest
payments
Equity
Represents ownership in the
company
Usually includes voting rights
No obligation to repay while the
company exists
Dividends and capital gains
34
Priority in
Liquidation
Risk
Expected Return
Tax Treatment
Maturity
Paid before
shareholders
Lower risk
Lower
Interest is tax
deductible
Usually fixed
Paid only after creditors
Higher risk
Higher
Dividends are not tax deductible
No maturity date
Debt holders are creditors of the company. They provide funds in exchange for
contractual interest payments and repayment of principal at maturity. Because
their return is fixed and they have priority during liquidation, debt investments are
generally less risky.
Equity holders are the owners of the company. They participate in both the profits
and risks of the business. Their returns depend on dividends and increases in the
company's market value. Because shareholders receive payment only after all
creditors have been paid, equity is considered the riskiest form of financing but
also offers the highest potential return.
The lecture emphasizes that debt represents a contractual obligation, whereas
equity represents ownership and residual claims on the firm's assets and earnings.
ownership and residual claims on the firm's assets and earnings.
4.2 Imagine a company needs additional financing for a new project. What
could be arguments in favor of or against using equity?
A company may choose to finance a new investment project through equity by
issuing new shares or retaining earnings.
Advantages of Equity Financing
Equity financing does not require mandatory repayment. Unlike debt,
there is no obligation to repay investors at a specific maturity date. This
improves the company's financial flexibility and reduces the risk of
financial distress.
Another advantage is that dividend payments are not legally required. If
business conditions deteriorate, management may reduce or suspend
dividends without defaulting on any contractual obligation.
Equity financing also improves the company's creditworthiness because
higher equity strengthens the balance sheet and reduces leverage. Banks
often view companies with higher equity ratios as financially more stable.
Finally, equity financing reduces bankruptcy risk because there are fewer
fixed financial obligations.
35
Disadvantages of Equity Financing
Issuing new shares dilutes the ownership percentage of existing
shareholders.
New shareholders may also gain voting rights, reducing the control of
current owners.
Equity financing is generally more expensive than debt because
shareholders require higher expected returns to compensate for higher
risk.
Furthermore, dividends are not tax deductible, making equity financing
less tax-efficient than debt financing.
Overall, equity financing is most appropriate for companies seeking longterm financial stability or those with high business risk.
4.3 Imagine a company needs additional financing. What could be arguments in
favor of or against using debt?
Debt financing involves borrowing money from banks or issuing bonds.
Advantages of Debt Financing
One major advantage is the tax shield. Interest payments on debt are
tax deductible, reducing taxable income and lowering the company's
effective financing cost.
Debt financing does not dilute ownership because lenders do not receive
voting rights.
It is often cheaper than equity because lenders face lower risk and
therefore require lower returns.
Debt can also increase shareholders' returns through the leverage
effect, provided the company earns a return on assets greater than the
cost of borrowing.
Disadvantages of Debt Financing
Debt creates mandatory interest and principal payments.
Failure to meet these obligations may result in financial distress or
bankruptcy.
Higher debt increases financial risk and reduces financial flexibility.
36
Highly leveraged companies may also find it more difficult to obtain
additional financing in the future.
Debt financing is therefore most suitable for companies with stable and
predictable cash flows that can comfortably service interest payments.
4.4 Given a Balance Sheet (Lufthansa Group)
How much money was paid in by shareholders? How much did the company
earn and retain?
The shareholders' equity section of the balance sheet distinguishes between capital
contributed by shareholders and profits generated by the company over time.
For Lufthansa's 2025 financial statements:
•
•
Issued Capital: €3,070 million
Capital Reserve: €395 million
These represent money contributed directly by shareholders through the purchase
of shares.
The company has also accumulated profits over many years, shown as:
•
Retained Earnings: €7,515 million
Retained earnings represent profits that were not distributed as dividends but
were reinvested in the business to finance future growth.
Thus,
Capital contributed by shareholders
= Issued Capital + Capital Reserve
= €3,465 million
Accumulated retained profits
= €7,515 million
This distinction helps investors understand how much of the company's equity
comes from external financing versus internally generated profits.
37
4.5 Can the book value of equity differ from its market value? What does a
difference indicate?
Yes.
The book value of equity is the accounting value reported on the balance sheet. It
is calculated as:
Book Value of Equity = Total Assets − Total Liabilities
The market value of equity, also called market capitalization, equals:
Market Value of Equity = Share Price × Number of Outstanding Shares
The market value may be higher or lower than the book value.
If the market value exceeds the book value, investors expect the company to
generate strong future profits, possess valuable intangible assets, or have
attractive growth opportunities.
If the market value is below the book value, investors may expect weak future
performance, declining profitability, or increased business risk.
Because market value reflects investor expectations while book value reflects
historical accounting costs, the two figures frequently differ.
4.6 What is Working Capital and Net Working Capital?
Working Capital represents the resources available to finance a company's day-today operations.
Current assets typically include:
•
•
•
•
•
Cash
Trade receivables
Inventories
Marketable securities
Other short-term assets
Current liabilities include:
•
•
•
•
Trade payables
Short-term loans
Taxes payable
Other current obligations
38
The most commonly used measure is Net Working Capital (NWC).
Formula:
Net Working Capital = Current Assets − Current Liabilities
Net Working Capital measures the company's short-term liquidity.
If Net Working Capital is positive, the company has sufficient short-term assets to
cover its short-term liabilities.
If it is negative, the company may face liquidity problems.
The net position matters because it indicates whether normal business operations
can be financed without financial stress.
For companies like Lufthansa, effective working capital management is particularly
important because airlines require substantial cash resources to finance fuel
purchases, maintenance, employee salaries, airport fees, and daily flight
operations.
Oral Exam Summary
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Debt and equity are the two primary financing sources for companies.
Debt represents borrowed money that must be repaid with interest, while
equity represents ownership in the company.
Debt holders receive fixed interest payments and have priority during
liquidation, whereas shareholders receive dividends and capital gains but
bear higher risk.
Equity financing improves financial stability because it does not require
mandatory repayments, although it dilutes ownership and is generally more
expensive.
Debt financing benefits from tax-deductible interest and can increase
shareholder returns through leverage, but it also increases financial risk.
In Lufthansa's balance sheet, issued capital and capital reserves represent
funds contributed by shareholders, while retained earnings represent
accumulated profits reinvested in the business.
The book value of equity reflects accounting values, whereas market value
reflects investor expectations.
Finally, Net Working Capital measures a company's short-term liquidity by
comparing current assets with current liabilities, indicating its ability to
meet short-term obligations.
39
4.7 Given an Income Statement (Lufthansa Group): Which positions denote
profit for shareholders, and which denote profit for all capital providers?
The income statement presents a company's financial performance over a specific
accounting period. Different profit measures are relevant to different stakeholders
because some belong to all providers of capital, while others belong only to
shareholders.
Profit for All Capital Providers
The profit available to all capital providers (both debt holders and
shareholders) is EBIT (Earnings Before Interest and Taxes).
Formula:
EBIT = Revenue − Operating Expenses
EBIT measures the profitability generated purely from business
operations before considering financing decisions and taxation.
Since interest has not yet been deducted, EBIT represents the
earnings available to both lenders and shareholders.
For Lufthansa in 2025:
•
EBIT = €2.03 billion
Profit for Shareholders
The profit belonging exclusively to shareholders is Net Income (Net
Profit).
Formula:
Net Income = Revenue − Operating Expenses − Interest − Taxes
After paying:
•
•
•
Operating expenses
Interest to lenders
Taxes to the government
the remaining profit belongs to shareholders.
For Lufthansa in 2025:
40
•
Net Profit = €1.339 billion
This amount may either be:
•
•
distributed as dividends, or
retained within the company as retained earnings.
Therefore:
Profit Measure Belongs To
EBIT
Debt holders + Shareholders
Net Income
Shareholders only
4.8 Where can we see the tax advantage of debt (deductibility of interest
payments)?
One of the major advantages of debt financing is the tax shield created by interest
payments.
Interest paid on loans and bonds is considered a business expense. Therefore, it is
deducted before calculating taxable income.
The sequence in the income statement is:
Revenue
↓
Operating Expenses
↓
EBIT
↓
Interest Expense
↓
Profit Before Tax (EBT)
↓
Income Tax
↓
Net Income
Because interest reduces Profit Before Tax, the company pays less corporate
income tax.
For example:
Without debt:
EBIT = €100 million
Taxes (30%) = €30 million
Net Income = €70 million
41
With debt:
EBIT = €100 million
Interest = €20 million
Profit Before Tax = €80 million
Taxes (30%) = €24 million
Net Income = €56 million
Although shareholders receive lower accounting profit due to interest payments,
the company saves €6 million in taxes.
This tax saving is called the Interest Tax Shield and is one of the main reasons
companies choose debt financing.
4.9 What is a company's leverage? Explain why leverage has attractive but also
problematic effects.
Leverage refers to the extent to which a company finances its assets with debt
rather than equity.
It measures the proportion of borrowed money used to finance business activities.
The leverage ratio can be expressed as:
Leverage = Debt / Equity
or
Debt Ratio = Debt / Total Assets
Using debt can increase shareholders' returns because debt is usually cheaper than
equity.
If the company's operating return exceeds the interest rate on debt, shareholders
benefit from the positive leverage effect.
For example:
Return on Assets = 12%
Interest Rate = 3%
Because the company earns 12% while paying only 3% for borrowed funds, the
remaining profit increases shareholders' return.
42
However, leverage also increases financial risk.
Interest payments must be made regardless of whether the company earns profits.
If operating income falls below the interest cost, shareholders experience
amplified losses.
Therefore, leverage has two opposite effects:
Advantages
•
•
•
•
Increases Return on Equity (ROE)
Creates tax savings
Allows companies to finance larger investments
Improves shareholder returns when business performs well
Disadvantages
•
•
•
•
Increases bankruptcy risk
Requires fixed interest payments
Makes profits more volatile
Reduces financial flexibility
A moderate level of leverage is generally beneficial, while excessive leverage can
threaten the company's financial stability.
4.10 A company shows the following figures:
Total Assets = €100 million
Equity = 60%
Debt = 40%
EBIT = €12 million
Interest Rate = 3%
Interest Payments = €1.2 million
What is the Return on Assets (ROA)?
Return on Assets measures how efficiently the company uses its total
assets to generate operating profit.
Formula:
ROA = EBIT / Total Assets
Calculation:
ROA = €12 million / €100 million
ROA = 12%
This means the company earns 12 cents of operating profit for
every €1 invested in assets.
43
4.11 What is the Return on Equity (ROE)?
Return on Equity measures the profitability earned by shareholders on their
invested capital.
Formula:
ROE = Net Income / Equity
•
Step 1
Calculate Interest Expense:
Interest = 3% × €40 million
= €1.2 million
•
Step 2
Profit before taxes (ignoring taxes for simplicity):
€12 million − €1.2 million
= €10.8 million
•
Step 3
ROE
ROE = €10.8 million / €60 million
ROE = 18%
Although the company earns only 12% on its assets, shareholders earn 18% because
debt financing amplifies their return.
4.12 How do these figures depend on leverage and EBIT?
The relationship between leverage, EBIT, ROA and ROE is one of the central
concepts in corporate finance.
If EBIT increases
Higher operating profit increases both ROA and ROE.
Because debt interest remains fixed, additional profits mainly benefit
shareholders.
Therefore, leverage amplifies gains.
44
If EBIT decreases
Lower operating profit reduces ROA.
ROE falls even faster because interest payments must still be made.
If EBIT becomes lower than interest payments, shareholders may
experience losses.
If leverage increases
More debt means:
•
•
•
Lower equity investment
Same operating assets
Greater amplification of shareholder returns
If operating returns exceed borrowing costs, ROE increases.
If operating returns fall below borrowing costs, ROE decreases
sharply.
If leverage decreases
Lower debt reduces financial risk.
ROE becomes more stable.
However, shareholders may earn lower returns during profitable
periods because less borrowed money is used.
4.13 Explain the Leverage Effect based on these figures.
The leverage effect occurs when a company earns a return on its assets that
exceeds the cost of debt.
In this example:
Return on Assets = 12%
Interest Rate = 3%
45
Because the company earns much more on its investments than it pays in
borrowing costs, shareholders benefit from borrowing.
Without debt: ROE would equal ROA: 12%
With debt: ROE increases to: 18%
The additional return arises because lenders receive only their fixed
interest of 3%, while shareholders receive all remaining profits.
Therefore, leverage increases shareholder returns whenever:
Return on Assets > Cost of Debt
However, leverage also magnifies losses.
If the Return on Assets falls below the interest rate, shareholders
bear the full reduction in profits while interest payments remain
fixed.
Thus, leverage increases both expected return and financial risk.
ORAL EXAM SUMMARY
•
•
•
•
•
The income statement contains different profit measures for
different stakeholders.
EBIT represents operating profit available to both debt holders and
shareholders because interest has not yet been deducted.
Net Income belongs only to shareholders after interest and taxes have
been paid.
One major advantage of debt financing is the tax shield because
interest payments reduce taxable income.
Leverage refers to the use of debt financing to increase shareholder
returns.
In the numerical example:
• Total Assets are €100 million
• EBIT is €12 million
• Equity is €60 million
• Debt is €40 million.
• Return on Assets equals 12%
• Return on Equity equals 18%
•
•
Demonstrating the positive leverage effect.
This occurs because the company earns 12% on its assets while paying
only 3% interest on debt.
46
•
•
However, leverage also increases financial risk because interest
payments remain fixed even when profits decline.
Therefore, leverage can increase both shareholder returns and
shareholder losses.
4.14 Which are the central features of a standard bond?
A bond is a debt instrument through which an investor lends money to a company
or government in exchange for periodic interest payments and repayment of the
principal at maturity. When a company issues a bond, it becomes the borrower,
while investors become creditors rather than owners.
The central features of a standard bond are:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Nominal (Face) Value – The amount repaid to the investor at maturity.
Coupon Rate – The fixed annual interest rate paid on the nominal value.
Coupon Payment – The periodic interest payment received by the
bondholder.
Maturity Date – The date on which the bond issuer repays the nominal
value.
Market Price – The price at which the bond is bought or sold in the financial
market.
Yield to Maturity (YTM) – The effective return earned if the bond is held
until maturity.
Unlike shareholders, bondholders do not own part of the company and generally do
not have voting rights. Instead, they receive fixed contractual payments regardless
of the company's profitability.
Because bondholders have priority over shareholders during liquidation, bonds are
generally considered less risky than equity investments.
4.15 A 5-year bond has a nominal value of €10,000 and a coupon of 4%.
Describe the bond's cash flow.
The bond has:
•
•
•
Nominal Value = €10,000
Coupon Rate = 4%
Maturity = 5 years
47
The annual coupon payment is:
Coupon = Nominal Value × Coupon Rate
Coupon = €10,000 × 4% = €400
Therefore, the investor receives:
Year
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Cash Flow
€400
€400
€400
€400
€10,400
During the first four years, the investor receives only the annual coupon payment.
In the fifth year, the investor receives:
•
•
Final Coupon = €400
Principal Repayment = €10,000
Total cash flow in Year 5: €10,400
4.16 How would you determine the bond's value?
(Assume market yield = 2%)
The value of a bond is equal to the present value of all future coupon payments
and the repayment of the nominal value, discounted using the current market
yield.
The valuation formula is:
Bond Value=(1+r)1C+(1+r)2C+...+(1+r)nC+F
Where:
•
•
•
•
C = Coupon Payment
F = Face Value
r = Market Yield
n = Number of Years
48
Substituting the values:
•
•
•
Coupon = €400
Face Value = €10,000
Market Yield = 2%
Bond Value=1.02400+1.022400+1.023400+1.024400+1.02510,400
Because the coupon rate (4%) is higher than the market yield (2%), investors
receive coupons that are more attractive than newly issued bonds.
Therefore: The bond's market value will be greater than €10,000 (it sells at a
premium).
4.17 What happens if market yield rises or falls?
There is an inverse relationship between bond prices and market interest rates.
If market yield increases:
•
•
•
Discount rate increases.
Present value of future cash flows decreases.
Bond price falls.
Investors demand higher returns, making older bonds with lower coupons less
attractive.
If market yield decreases:
•
•
•
Discount rate decreases.
Present value increases.
Bond price rises.
Older bonds paying higher coupons become more valuable than newly issued
bonds.
Therefore:
Interest Rates ↑ → Bond Prices ↓
Interest Rates ↓ → Bond Prices ↑
This inverse relationship is one of the most fundamental principles of bond
valuation.
49
4.18 Which main factors determine the value of a corporate bond?
Several factors influence the value of a corporate bond.
1. Market Interest Rate
Higher market interest rates reduce bond prices.
Lower market interest rates increase bond prices.
2. Coupon Rate
Higher coupons make bonds more attractive.
Higher coupon bonds therefore have higher market values.
3. Time to Maturity
Long-term bonds are more sensitive to changes in interest rates than shortterm bonds.
4. Credit Risk
If investors believe the company may default, bond prices decrease.
Companies with higher credit ratings can borrow at lower interest rates.
5. Inflation Expectations
Higher inflation reduces the purchasing power of future coupon payments,
lowering bond values.
6. Liquidity
Bonds that are actively traded are generally worth more because investors
can sell them easily.
50
4.19 Describe a Convertible Bond (Lufthansa Example)
A convertible bond is a hybrid financial instrument that combines characteristics
of both debt and equity.
Initially, it functions as an ordinary bond:
•
•
Investors receive regular coupon payments.
The company must repay the principal at maturity.
However, the bondholder also has the right to convert the bond into a
predetermined number of ordinary shares.
Lufthansa issued €600 million of convertible bonds, giving investors the option to
convert their debt into Lufthansa shares under specified conditions. This allowed
Lufthansa to strengthen its financial position while reducing financing costs.
Why Companies Issue Convertible Bonds
Companies use convertible bonds because:
•
•
•
•
Lower coupon interest rates
Easier access to financing
Delayed equity dilution
Improved financial flexibility
Why Investors Like Convertible Bonds
Investors benefit because they receive:
•
•
•
Fixed coupon payments like ordinary bonds
Downside protection through debt
Potential upside if the company's share price increases
Convertible bonds therefore combine the safety of debt with the growth potential
of equity.
4.20 What is Mezzanine (Hybrid) Financing?
Mezzanine financing refers to financing instruments that combine characteristics
of both debt and equity.
These instruments rank:
•
•
Below senior debt
Above ordinary shareholders during liquidation.
51
Examples include:
•
•
•
•
•
Convertible Bonds
Hybrid Bonds
Profit Participation Certificates
Subordinated Loans
Preferred Shares
Because mezzanine financing is riskier than ordinary debt, investors require higher
expected returns.
However, it is still cheaper than issuing new equity.
Mezzanine financing is commonly used when companies need additional capital
while avoiding immediate shareholder dilution.
4.21 Hybrid Bonds (Lufthansa Example)
Lufthansa issued a hybrid bond to strengthen its capital structure and improve its
credit profile. Hybrid bonds combine features of debt and equity. They generally
have very long maturities or no fixed maturity date, and issuers often have the
option to defer coupon payments under certain conditions. Because of these
equity-like characteristics, rating agencies may treat part of the hybrid bond as
equity, helping improve leverage ratios while still providing financing.
For Lufthansa, issuing a hybrid bond offered several advantages:
•
•
•
•
Strengthened the capital base.
Improved financial flexibility.
Reduced pressure to issue new shares immediately.
Helped maintain investment-grade credit metrics.
Investors are attracted to hybrid bonds because they typically offer higher coupon
rates than ordinary corporate bonds to compensate for the additional risk and
subordinated position.
ORAL EXAM SUMMARY
•
•
•
A standard bond is a debt instrument with a face value, coupon rate,
maturity date, and periodic interest payments.
In the example of a five-year bond with a face value of €10,000 and a 4%
coupon, the investor receives €400 annually and €10,400 in the final year,
including repayment of the principal.
A bond's value equals the present value of all future coupon payments and
the redemption value discounted at the current market yield.
52
•
•
•
•
•
Bond prices move inversely to interest rates: when market yields rise, bond
prices fall, and vice versa.
The value of a corporate bond depends mainly on the market interest rate,
coupon rate, time to maturity, credit risk, inflation expectations, and
liquidity.
Convertible bonds combine debt and equity because investors receive
regular coupons but also have the option to convert into shares.
Lufthansa used convertible bonds to obtain financing at lower interest rates
while giving investors future upside potential.
Hybrid or mezzanine financing combines characteristics of debt and equity
and strengthens the company's capital structure without immediately
diluting existing shareholders.
4.22 Explain the Two-Phase Model for Valuing a Stock or a Firm (Slides 5 & 6)
The Two-Phase Model is a valuation method used to estimate the value of a stock
or an entire company when it is expected to experience different growth rates
over time.
The model divides the company's life into two distinct phases:
Phase 1 – High Growth Period
During the first phase, the company experiences above-average growth due
to factors such as:
•
•
•
•
Expansion into new markets
New products or technologies
High investment opportunities
Competitive advantages
During this period, dividends or free cash flows are forecast individually for
each year because growth is not yet stable.
Example:
Year 1 Dividend = €2.00
Year 2 Dividend = €2.40
Year 3 Dividend = €2.85
Each dividend is discounted separately to its present value.
53
Phase 2 – Stable Growth Period
After several years, the company reaches maturity.
Growth becomes stable and sustainable.
Instead of forecasting every future dividend individually, finance assumes
that dividends grow forever at a constant long-term growth rate.
This second phase is valued using the Gordon Growth (Growing Perpetuity)
Model.
The terminal value at the beginning of the stable phase is:
TV=Dn+1r−g
Where:
•
•
•
•
TV = Terminal Value
Dₙ₊₁ = Dividend expected in the first year of stable growth
r = Required Rate of Return
g = Constant Growth Rate
The terminal value is then discounted back to the present value.
The total value of the company equals:
Value = Present Value of Phase 1 Cash Flows + Present Value of
Terminal Value
This approach is more realistic than assuming one constant growth rate
because young companies often grow rapidly before eventually reaching a
mature stage.
4.23 What is the role of growth and growth opportunities in the Dividend
Growth Model?
The Dividend Growth Model (Gordon Growth Model) values a company's shares
based on the assumption that dividends will continue to grow at a constant rate
forever.
54
The formula is:
P0=D1r−g
Where:
•
•
•
•
P₀ = Current Share Price
D₁ = Dividend expected next year
r = Required Rate of Return
g = Constant Dividend Growth Rate
Growth is one of the most important drivers of company value.
If a company can continuously increase its dividends, investors expect higher
future cash flows, increasing the current share price.
Growth opportunities arise when a company can invest retained earnings into
projects that generate returns greater than its cost of capital.
Examples include:
•
•
•
•
•
Opening new markets
Product innovation
Digital transformation
Acquisitions
Research and Development
If these investments generate returns above the required rate of return,
shareholders benefit because future dividends increase.
Therefore, profitable growth opportunities create additional shareholder value.
The Dividend Growth Model demonstrates that company value depends not only on
current dividends but also on investors' expectations regarding future dividend
growth.
4.24 May growth lead to a lower company value? Why?
Yes. Growth does not always increase company value.
Growth creates value only when the return earned on new investments exceeds
the company's cost of capital.
55
If a company invests heavily in projects that generate returns lower than the
required return demanded by investors, growth actually destroys shareholder
value.
For example:
Suppose a company's cost of capital is 10%.
If management invests retained earnings into projects earning only 6%,
shareholders would have been better off receiving the money as dividends and
investing elsewhere.
Although revenues and company size increase, shareholder wealth decreases.
Therefore, companies should not pursue growth simply for the sake of
becoming larger.
Instead, growth should occur only when investments generate positive Net
Present Value (NPV).
Finance therefore distinguishes between:
Value-Creating Growth
•
•
•
Return on Investment > Cost of Capital
Positive NPV
Company value increases
Value-Destroying Growth
•
•
•
Return on Investment < Cost of Capital
Negative NPV
Company value decreases
This concept explains why some rapidly growing companies still experience
falling share prices.
Investors focus on profitable growth rather than growth alone.
4.25 Explain the Example on Slide 12 (Growth Creates Value)
The example on Slide 12 illustrates how growth opportunities increase company
value when new investments earn returns greater than the required return.
Suppose a company currently pays dividends of €5 per share.
56
Without future growth:
P=50.10=€50
If the company discovers profitable investment opportunities and future dividends
grow by 4% per year, the valuation becomes:
P=50.10−0.04
P=50.06=€83.33
Although today's dividend remains €5, investors pay significantly more because
they expect future dividends to increase.
The increase in value comes from future profitable investment opportunities rather
than current profits.
This demonstrates that expectations about future growth are an important
determinant of stock prices.
4.26 Explain the Example on Slide 13 (Growth Can Destroy Value)
Slide 13 demonstrates that growth can reduce company value when management
invests in projects with returns below the cost of capital.
Assume:
Required Return = 10%
Investment Return = 6%
Management retains profits instead of paying dividends and invests them in
projects earning only 6%.
Although accounting earnings may increase, shareholders receive a lower return
than they require.
The retained earnings therefore reduce shareholder wealth.
Investors would have preferred receiving dividends and investing elsewhere at the
required return.
Consequently:
•
•
•
Sales may increase.
Company size may increase.
Earnings may increase.
57
Yet:
•
•
Share price decreases.
Company value falls.
This example emphasizes an important principle in finance:
Growth only creates value when investment returns exceed the company's cost
of capital.
Otherwise, retaining earnings destroys shareholder wealth.
Key Difference Between Slides 12 and 13
Slide 12
Profitable Growth
ROI > Cost of Capital
Positive NPV Projects
Company Value Increases
Growth Creates Shareholder Wealth
Slide 13
Unprofitable Growth
ROI < Cost of Capital
Negative NPV Projects
Company Value Decreases
Growth Destroys Shareholder Wealth
ORAL EXAM SUMMARY
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
The Two-Phase Model values a company by dividing its future into two
periods. During the first phase, the company experiences high growth, so
dividends or free cash flows are forecast individually each year.
During the second phase, the company reaches maturity and grows at a
constant rate forever.
The second phase is valued using the Gordon Growth Model, where the
terminal value equals the next dividend divided by the difference between
the required return and the growth rate.
Growth plays a central role in company valuation because investors pay for
future dividend increases, not only current dividends.
However, growth creates value only if new investments earn returns greater
than the company's cost of capital. If the return on investment is lower than
the required return, growth destroys shareholder value.
This is illustrated in the lecture examples: Slide 12 shows that profitable
growth increases firm value, while Slide 13 demonstrates that unprofitable
growth can reduce company value even if revenues and earnings continue to
grow.
This principle highlights that companies should pursue value-creating
growth rather than growth for its own sake.
58
PROJECT VALUATION USING DCF AND RISK ANALYSIS
1. Given an earnings and Free Cash Flow calculation for a project (like
HomeNet or RFX), explain the calculation.
The purpose of the calculation is to determine whether a project creates value for
the company.
The process consists of three main steps:
Step 1 – Forecast Incremental Earnings
Only revenues and costs that occur because of the project are included.
For the HomeNet project:
Revenue
100,000 units × $260 = $26 million
Less:
•
•
•
•
Production costs
Marketing expenses
R&D expenses
Depreciation
This gives:
EBIT (Earnings Before Interest and Taxes)
Taxes are calculated using EBIT because financing decisions are ignored during
project valuation.
After taxes:
Unlevered Net Income
The project is evaluated as if it were financed entirely with equity.
59
Step 2 – Convert Earnings into Free Cash Flow (FCF)
Accounting earnings are not actual cash flows.
Therefore adjustments are made:
Add back depreciation
because depreciation reduces accounting profit but is not a cash payment.
Subtract:
•
•
Capital expenditures (CAPEX)
Investments in Net Working Capital
The formula is:
Free Cash Flow = Unlevered Net Income + Depreciation − CAPEX −
Increase in Net Working Capital
This represents the cash actually generated by the project that is available to
investors.
Step 3 – Discount Free Cash Flows
Future cash flows are discounted using the project's required return (WACC).
The discounted cash flows are added together.
If NPV > 0
the project creates value.
If NPV < 0
the project destroys value.
The IRR is also calculated and compared with the required return.
60
Calculation:
Revenue: 100,000 × $260 = $26 million
Production costs: 100,000 × $110 = $11 million
Gross profit: $15 million
Marketing: $2.8 million
Depreciation: $1.5 million
EBIT: $10.7 million
Taxes (40%): $4.28 million
Unlevered Net Income: $6.42 million per year.
Questions from Slide 4 (HomeNet): Why are feasibility study costs not included?
The $300,000 feasibility study has already been spent.
It is a sunk cost.
Sunk costs cannot be recovered and therefore do not affect the investment
decision.
Why isn't the $7.5 million equipment investment included in the earnings
calculation?
Because earnings follow accounting rules.
The equipment is a capital expenditure (CAPEX).
Instead of expensing the full amount immediately, it is recognized gradually
through depreciation.
However, the full $7.5 million cash outflow appears in the Free Cash Flow
calculation.
Why are there five years although the project lasts four years?
The product is sold for only four years.
However:
•
•
•
depreciation continues into Year 5,
taxes related to depreciation still occur,
final working capital recovery or asset disposal may also occur in Year 5.
Therefore Year 5 is included.
61
Why is there a positive tax effect in Years 0 and 5?
In Year 0:
The company reports a loss due to R&D expenses.
That loss reduces taxable income elsewhere.
This creates a tax shield.
In Year 5:
Depreciation still reduces taxable income, creating another tax benefit.
Aren't additional fixed overhead costs missing?
Only incremental costs are included.
Existing fixed overhead that will occur regardless of the project should not be
included.
Only additional overhead caused by the project is relevant.
What other effects should be included?
Examples include:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Opportunity costs
Cannibalization
Salvage value
Working capital changes
Inflation
Price changes
Cost changes
Market demand uncertainty
These affect project cash flows and therefore project value.
62
2. What are opportunity costs (or cannibalization) and why do we care in Free
Cash Flow?
Opportunity Cost
Opportunity cost is the value lost by using a resource for the project instead of
its best alternative use.
Example from HomeNet:
The laboratory occupies warehouse space that could otherwise be
rented for $200,000 per year.
Although no cash payment occurs, the company sacrifices rental income.
Therefore this forgone rent is treated as a project cost.
Opportunity costs reduce Free Cash Flow because they represent real
economic costs.
Cannibalization
Cannibalization occurs when a new product reduces sales of an existing
product.
Example:
25% of HomeNet customers would otherwise have bought Cisco's existing
wireless router.
The new product therefore reduces profits from the existing router.
The lost profit must be deducted from project cash flows because it
represents a real loss to the company.
Ignoring cannibalization would overestimate the project's value.
63
3. Explain the role of Working Capital in a Free Cash Flow calculation. How are
financing expenses accounted for?
Role of Working Capital
Working Capital represents the short-term funds required to operate the business.
Examples:
•
•
•
•
Inventory
Accounts Receivable
Cash
Accounts Payable
Formula:
Net Working Capital = Current Assets − Current Liabilities
If working capital increases: the company ties up more cash.
Therefore: Increase in NWC is deducted from Free Cash Flow.
When working capital is recovered at the end of the project: cash returns to the
company, so it is added back.
Thus:
•
•
Increase in NWC → decreases FCF.
Recovery of NWC → increases FCF.
How are financing expenses treated?
Interest expenses are not included in Free Cash Flow.
Why?
Because project valuation evaluates the project independently of how it is
financed.
Instead:
•
•
operating cash flows are calculated first,
financing costs are reflected later through the discount rate (WACC).
Including interest expenses in the cash flow would double count financing costs
because WACC already incorporates the cost of debt and equity.
64
4. What is a Break-even Analysis (Sensitivity Analysis / Scenario Analysis) and
how does it support an investment decision?
Break-even Analysis
Break-even analysis determines the value of a project variable at which:
NPV = 0
At this point: the project neither creates nor destroys value.
Examples:
•
•
•
•
Minimum sales volume
Minimum selling price
Maximum production cost
Maximum cost of capital
For capital costs, the break-even value is the IRR.
Sensitivity Analysis
Sensitivity analysis changes one variable at a time while keeping all others
constant.
Examples:
•
•
•
•
Sales volume
Selling price
Production costs
WACC
Purpose:
Identify which variable has the greatest effect on NPV.
For HomeNet, the exercise varies units sold and other single parameters to observe
changes in project NPV.
Scenario Analysis
Scenario analysis changes several variables simultaneously.
65
Example:
Best Case:
•
•
•
Higher sales
Higher prices
Lower costs
Worst Case:
•
•
•
Lower sales
Lower prices
Higher costs
Unlike sensitivity analysis, scenario analysis evaluates the combined effect of
multiple assumptions, providing a more realistic picture of project risk and
possible outcomes.
Why are these analyses useful?
They help managers:
•
•
•
•
identify key project risks,
understand which assumptions most affect project value,
test whether the investment remains profitable under different conditions,
support better investment decisions by reducing uncertainty before
committing capital.
Oral Exam Summary
•
•
•
Project valuation using Discounted Cash Flow begins by forecasting the
project's incremental earnings, including only revenues and costs caused by
the investment. For the HomeNet project, sales, production costs,
marketing, R&D, depreciation, and taxes are used to calculate EBIT and
unlevered net income.
This accounting profit is then converted into Free Cash Flow by adding back
non-cash depreciation and subtracting capital expenditures and increases in
net working capital. Interest expenses are excluded because financing costs
are already reflected in the discount rate, typically the WACC.
The discounted free cash flows are used to calculate Net Present Value and
the Internal Rate of Return. In addition, opportunity costs, such as forgone
rental income, and cannibalization, where a new product reduces sales of
an existing one, must be included because they affect the project's true
economic cash flows.
66
•
Finally, break-even, sensitivity, and scenario analyses help managers
understand how changes in assumptions affect project value, making
investment decisions more informed and robust under uncertainty.
5. Risk and Return, Portfolio Theory and the CAPM
1. Explain the terms dividend yield, capital gains yield and total return for a stock.
A stock generates returns from two sources:
•
Dividend Yield
The dividend yield is the dividend received during the year divided by the
initial stock price.
Dividend Yield=Dividend/Beginning Price
It measures the cash income earned from owning the stock.
•
Capital Gains Yield
Capital gains yield measures the increase (or decrease) in the stock price.
Capital Gains Yield=P1−P0/P0
where:
•
•
•
P0 = beginning stock price
P1 = ending stock price
Total Return
Total return combines both sources of return.
Total Return=Dividend Yield+Capital Gains
Example from the lecture
Beginning Price = €25
Ending Price = €35
Dividend = €2
67
Dividend Yield: 2/25=8
Capital Gain: 35−25/25=40%
Total Return: 8%+40%=48
Many stock indices such as the DAX report total return, meaning dividends
are included
2. Would you use an arithmetic or geometric average to derive a return
forecast? Why?
The answer depends on the investment horizon.
Arithmetic Average
The arithmetic average is appropriate for forecasting one-period returns.
It simply averages historical returns.
It answers:
"What is the expected return next year?"
Geometric Average
The geometric average measures the average compound growth rate over
several periods.
It reflects the actual wealth growth of long-term investors.
Because volatility reduces compound growth, the geometric average is
always lower than the arithmetic average.
Therefore:
•
•
One-year forecast → Arithmetic average
Long-term investment performance → Geometric average
According to the lecture:
Arithmetic average reflects one-period investments.
Geometric average reflects long-term investments.
Volatility reduces long-term returns.
68
3. Explain the Risk–Return Trade-off. Why do we observe it?
The Risk–Return Trade-off means that investors require higher expected returns to
compensate for taking higher risk.
This relationship exists because:
• risky investments have greater uncertainty,
• investors are generally risk-averse,
• therefore they demand compensation for accepting uncertainty.
Historical data supports this relationship.
For example:
Asset
Treasury Bills
Corporate Bonds
S&P 500
Small Stocks
Average Return
Low
Moderate
Higher
Highest
Risk
Low
Moderate
Higher
Highest
Therefore:
Higher Risk → Higher Expected Return
Lower Risk → Lower Expected Return
This is one of the fundamental principles of finance.
4. Explain the concept of a Risk Premium
A Risk Premium is the additional return investors expect for investing in a risky
asset instead of a risk-free asset.
Formula:
Risk Premium=Expected Return−Risk Free Rate
Example from the lecture:
Treasury Bills:
3.3%
S&P500: 12.2%
Risk Premium:
12.2% − 3.3% = 8.9%
The risk premium rewards investors for accepting uncertainty.
Without extra return, rational investors would simply buy risk-free assets.
69
5. How do we measure chances and risk in Portfolio Theory?
Portfolio Theory measures:
Chance
Expected Return
Average return expected from the portfolio.
Risk
Standard Deviation Measures how much returns fluctuate around the
expected return.
Higher standard deviation = higher uncertainty = higher risk.
Professor Walther assumes investors are risk-averse.
Therefore:
If two portfolios have equal return
↓
choose lower risk.
If two portfolios have equal risk
↓
choose higher return.
6. Explain the diversification effect. What is the role of correlation?
Diversification means combining several assets so that poor performance of one
asset is offset by better performance of another.
The result is: Lower portfolio risk without necessarily reducing expected return.
The key factor is correlation.
Correlation measures how assets move together.
Correlation = +1
Move perfectly together. Almost no diversification benefit.
Correlation = 0
Move independently.
Some diversification benefit.
Correlation = –1
Move perfectly opposite.
Maximum diversification.
Portfolio risk can theoretically be eliminated.
Therefore: The lower the correlation, the greater the diversification
benefit.
70
This is why portfolio managers combine assets from different industries and asset
classes.
7. Explain the diversification effect based on Slide 23.
Slide 23 shows that portfolio risk falls as more assets are added.Initially, adding
assets reduces risk significantly. Eventually, the reduction slows.
This happens because:
Diversification removes firm-specific (unsystematic) risk, but it cannot eliminate
market-wide (systematic) risk.
Therefore: Total Risk = Systematic Risk
Unsystematic Risk Diversification only removes unsystematic risk.
8. Explain the concept of Efficient Portfolios (Efficient Set).
An efficient portfolio offers:
• the highest expected return for a given level of risk, or
• the lowest possible risk for a given expected return.
Portfolios below the efficient frontier are inefficient because another portfolio
provides:
• higher return for the same risk, or
• lower risk for the same return.
Therefore rational investors choose portfolios located on the efficient frontier.
The worksheet explains that the efficient frontier is obtained by minimizing
portfolio variance while achieving specified expected returns using historical
returns, standard deviations, and covariances.
9. Explain Slide 29 and Slide 32. What is the difference?
Slide 29
No risk-free asset.
Only risky assets.
The efficient frontier is curved.
Investors select different portfolios along the frontier depending on their risk
tolerance.
Slide 32
Risk-free asset is introduced.
A straight Capital Market Line (CML) touches the efficient frontier at the
market portfolio.
Every efficient portfolio is now a combination of:
• Risk-Free Asset
• Market Portfolio
71
Difference:
Slide 29 → only risky portfolios.
Slide 32 → risky + risk-free asset, giving investors better risk-return combinations.
10. What is the composition of efficient portfolios when a risk-free asset exists?
(Separation Principle)
According to the Separation Principle:
All investors hold the same optimal risky portfolio, called the Market Portfolio.
The only difference is how much they invest in:
• the Risk-Free Asset, and
• the Market Portfolio.
Risk-averse investors: More risk-free asset.
Risk-seeking investors: Borrow at the risk-free rate and invest more than 100% in
the market portfolio.
Thus: Portfolio Choice = Risk-Free Asset
o Market Portfolio
11. Explain Market Risk and Beta.
Market Risk
Market Risk is the risk affecting the entire market.
Examples:
• inflation,
• recessions,
• interest rate changes,
• financial crises.
Market Risk cannot be diversified away.
Beta
Beta measures how sensitive a stock is to market movements.
Formula:
β=Cov(Ri,RM)/Var(RM)
Interpretation:
β = 1 Moves exactly like the market.
β > 1 More volatile than the market.
β < 1 Less volatile than the market.
β = 0 No relationship with market.
Negative β Moves opposite the market.
Beta measures systematic risk only.
72
12. Additional assumptions of CAPM
CAPM assumes:
• investors are rational and risk-averse
• everyone has the same information,
• investors have identical expectations,
• no taxes,
• no transaction costs,
• assets are infinitely divisible,
• investors can borrow and lend at the risk-free rate,
• markets are perfectly competitive,
• all risky assets are traded publicly.
These assumptions simplify the model and lead to the CAPM relationship.
13. Explain the Capital Market Line (CML).
The Capital Market Line shows the relationship between:
•
•
•
•
•
Expected Return and Total Risk (standard deviation) for efficient portfolios.
It starts at the risk-free rate and passes through the Market Portfolio.
All efficient portfolios lie on this line.
The CML represents the best possible combinations of risk and return
available to investors.
Only efficient portfolios are located on the CML.
14. Explain the Security Market Line (SML). What are its applications?
The Security Market Line is the graphical representation of CAPM.
Formula: E(Ri)=Rf+βi(E(RM)−Rf)
Where:
• RfR_fRf = Risk-Free Rate
• E(RM)E(R_M)E(RM) = Expected Market Return
• β\betaβ = Beta
The SML relates: Expected Return to Market Risk (Beta) Applications:
• estimating cost of equity,
• determining discount rates,
• evaluating whether a stock is overvalued or undervalued,
• project valuation,
• capital budgeting,
• calculating WACC.
73
Unlike the CML, the SML applies to individual securities as well as portfolios
because it uses beta rather than total risk.
15. Be able to solve Exercise 4
Although your professor may change the numbers, the procedure remains the
same.
Typical steps:
1. Calculate the expected return of the portfolio:
2. Calculate the portfolio variance:
3. Convert variance into standard deviation:
4. Compare portfolios based on risk and return.
5. Identify which portfolios lie on the efficient frontier.
The worksheet explains that Excel Solver is used to minimize portfolio variance
subject to asset weights summing to one and target expected returns, thereby
generating the efficient frontier.
Difference between the CML and the SML:
Capital Market Line (CML)
Uses total risk (standard
deviation)
Applies only to efficient
portfolios
Based on Modern Portfolio
Theory
Shows the best risk-return
combinations
Security Market Line (SML)
Uses systematic risk (Beta)
Applies to all individual securities and
portfolios
Based on the CAPM
Shows the required return for a given level of
market risk
6. Valuation based on the WACC Method
1. What is the WACC Method to value a project or a company?
The Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) Method is one of the most widely
used Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) valuation methods. It values a company or
investment project by discounting its future Free Cash Flows to the Firm (FCFF)
using the firm's weighted average cost of capital.
The lecture explains that the company is treated as an investment project, and its
value equals the present value of all future free cash flows. Because the discount
rate (WACC) already incorporates the tax benefit of debt, the resulting value
represents the total enterprise value (debt + equity).
74
WACC Formula:
WACC=E/D+ErE+D/D+ErD(1−T)
Where:
• E = Market value of equity
• D = Market value of debt
• rEr_ErE = Cost of equity
• rDr_DrD = Cost of debt
• T = Corporate tax rate
The project or firm value is then:
Value=∑FCFFt/(1+WACC)t
Why is WACC used?
The WACC reflects:
• the required return of shareholders,
• the required return of lenders,
• the tax shield created by interest payments.
Therefore, it measures the firm's overall opportunity cost of capital and is the
appropriate discount rate for projects with similar risk and capital structure as the
firm.
2. Explain the calculations on overheads (Slides 8–10)
Slides 8–10 demonstrate how to move from accounting earnings to Free Cash Flow
(FCFF) and then value the project.
Slide 8 – Expected Free Cash Flow
The project generates annual sales of $60 million.
Step 1: Calculate EBIT
Sales = 60
Less Cost of Goods Sold = 25
Gross Profit = 35
Less Operating Expenses = 9
Less Depreciation = 6
EBIT = 20 million
Step 2: Taxes
Corporate tax rate = 40%
Tax = 20 × 40% = 8
Step 3: Unlevered Net Income
EBIT – Tax = 20 – 8 = 12 million
75
Step 4: Convert Accounting Profit into Free Cash Flow
Add back depreciation because it is a non-cash expense.
Subtract capital expenditures.
Subtract increases in net working capital.
Therefore:
Item
Unlevered Net Income
+ Depreciation
– Capital Expenditure
– Increase in NWC
FCFF
Amount ($m)
12
6
0 (after Year 0)
0
18
At Year 0: Initial Investment = −28 million
Therefore the free cash flows become:
Year FCFF
0
−28
1
18
2
18
3
18
4
18
Slide 9 – Calculate WACC
The firm's capital structure is:
Debt =300 million
Equity = 300 million
Debt weight=50%
Equity weight=50%
Cost of equity=10%
Cost of debt=6%
Tax rate=40%
Formula:
WACC=0.5(10%)+0.5(6%)(1−0.40)
Debt after tax:
6%(0.60)=3.6%
Therefore:
WACC=5%+1.8%=6.8%
So the project should be discounted at 6.8%.
76
Slide 10 – Calculate Project Value
Discount each annual FCFF:
PV=181.068+181.0682+181.0683+181.0684
Result:
PV=61.25 million
Subtract initial investment:
NPV=61.25−28=33.25 million
Since:
NPV > 0 the investment should be accepted because it increases shareholder
value.
3. Exercise 5 – Explain how to solve it (or a similar problem)
Your professor may change the numbers, but the method is always the same.
Step 1
Calculate annual Free Cash Flow (FCFF).
Use:
• EBIT
• Taxes
• Depreciation
• Capital Expenditure
• Net Working Capital
Formula:
FCFF=EBIT(1−T)+Depreciation−CAPEX−ΔNWC
Step 2
Calculate Cost of Equity using CAPM.
rE=Rf+β(RM−Rf)
Step 3
Calculate Cost of Debt after tax.
rD(1−T)
Step 4
Calculate WACC.
WACC=ED+ErE+DD+ErD(1−T)
Step 5
Discount every FCFF.
PV=∑FCFFt(1+WACC)t
77
Step 6
Compute NPV.
NPV=PV−Initial Investment
Decision Rule:
• NPV > 0 → Accept project
• NPV < 0 → Reject project
•
This is exactly the procedure followed in the Avco RFX example in the lecture and
textbook.
4. Explain the Two-Phase Model for valuing a stock or a firm (Exercise 7)
The Two-Phase Model is used when a company is expected to experience:
1. a period of high growth, followed by
2. a period of stable long-term growth.
This is more realistic than assuming constant growth from the beginning.
Phase 1 – High Growth
Forecast the free cash flows (or dividends) individually during the extraordinary
growth period.
Example:
Year FCFF
1
20
2
25
3
30
4
35
Discount each cash flow separately:
PV=FCF1(1+r)+FCF2(1+r)2+
Phase 2 – Stable Growth
Once the company reaches stable growth, calculate the Terminal Value using the
Gordon Growth Model:
TV=FCFn+1WACC−g
where:
• g = perpetual growth rate
• WACC = discount rate
Step 3
Discount the Terminal Value back to today:
PV(TV)=TV(1+WACC)n
78
Step 4
Firm Value = Present Value of Phase 1
Present Value of Terminal Value:
Firm Value=PV(High Growth)+PV(Terminal Value)
This approach recognizes that firms often grow rapidly in the early years before
settling into a stable long-term growth rate. It is commonly used in DCF valuation
for companies with changing growth prospects.
How do you value a company using the WACC method?
1. Estimate the company's Free Cash Flow to the Firm (FCFF).
2. Calculate the cost of equity using the CAPM.
3. Calculate the after-tax cost of debt.
4. Compute the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) using the marketvalue weights of debt and equity.
5. Discount all future FCFF using the WACC to obtain the enterprise value.
6. Subtract debt (or otherwise adjust for financing as appropriate) to arrive at
the equity value if required.
79
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )