A Boy
ENGL
University
10/14/2024
The Causes and Effects of Childhood Neglect
Growing up, I felt like just any other kid. Living in a household, I had my older siblings
and my younger siblings, as well as pets that came and went. Real run-of-the-mill. And
sure, only seeing my dad once a week was a real bummer, but who was I gonna argue
with at the time, my mom? No. There was no arguing with my mom. But that was simply
because she was always in charge and thus commanded respect, right? Of course, I
was too young to recognize the neglective nature of my primary parent, because most
kids are. One of our greatest skills at our youngest is seeking out the limits to their own
actions. Finding how the world works, and where the sidewalk ends. However, it matters
less about any opportunities we might find, defined by the extent of the world around
them, and more about if someone has our back along the way. The extent at which
one’s parents go to support their kid effectively sets the expectation for love and
affection in the world. No longer living with my mom, I look back on my time under her
with distaste. She was manipulative, judgemental, hypocritical, and self-righteous. I
know that because of this parental behavior, or the lack thereof, my siblings and I have
all faced unnecessary struggles and responsibilities after leaving her direct care. But
none of these negative impacts are very clean-cut, so I often felt confused as to how
specifically her parenting style was affecting my life. In wanting to understand more
about this impact, I found an article covering a survey-based experiment on the lasting
effects of childhood neglect. A National Comorbidity Survey Replication, which compiles
data on just that, was analyzed by a group of sociologists find real trends between
parental neglect and suicidal behavior in over 5,500 participants. With this single
resource, I want to survey the existing research done on child neglect, and how
maltreatment from parents can significantly impact its victims in their futures
Probably what first comes to mind when someone hears the term, childhood neglect, is,
what in the article’s investigation has categorized as, supervisory neglect. Simply put, it
is the lack of a physical and ethically guiding parental presence for the children. When
children are subjected to supervisory neglect, they are commonly led to question their
personal value. The effect of this can stem into extended periods of depression, loss of
confidence, and even suicidal ideals. For the purposes of the experiment in the article,
supervisory neglect is defined as, “respondents reported the frequency they were ‘left
alone or unsupervised when (they) were too young to be alone’. In addition,
respondents reported on 'how often (they) were made to do chores that were too difficult
or dangerous for someone (their) age’”(Stickley et al.). The practicality of these
answers, and the relevance of these certain aspects of neglect in the study, is that
children rely heavily on guidance and attention in order to gain perspective on what is
right or wrong. The amount of time a young child spends under the direct supervision of
a parent or guardian is crucial to their early development, and taking away that quality
time of practical education is a direct cause for the victims to later doubt their worth as
adults.
Conceptually similar to supervisory neglect is care neglect, focusing on a middle ground
between emotional and material needs of children. The article clarifies care neglect by
specifying, “‘Care’ neglect was assessed with two items. Respondents first rated the
frequency they went hungry as a child by answering the question, ‘how often did your
parents or your caregivers make you go hungry or not prepare regular meals?’
Respondents then rated the frequency with which they went ‘without things (they)
needed like clothes, shoes, or school supplies because (their) parents or caregivers
spent money on themselves’”(Stickley et al.). This sort of neglect is most likely to fall on
the financial situation of the parents, typically limiting their abilities to support their kids.
Failing to deliver on the care that a child needs can easily distort that kid’s perception of
love, forcing them to re-learn such expressions of love much later on. It is more of a
tragic result of some other exterior cause. Unfortunately, however, limitations to the
parents’ abilities to provide isn’t necessary for care-oriented child neglect to occur.
Situations such as the caregiver prioritizing themself over the child are a sad reality that
continue to contribute to the number of aged adults reporting childhood neglect, and
deteriorate the familial values of our society.
Another subtype of childhood neglect, and the third causal focus in the NCS-R
investigation being referenced, is medical neglect, neglecting to provide the child with
medical protection. In the article, participants of the research reporting medical neglect
meant, “asking respondents how often their parents ignored or failed ‘to get (them)
treatment when (they) were sick or hurt’”(Stickley et al.). This subtype of child neglect,
while still commonly caused by the financial situation of the parents, can have specific
drastic effects on the victimized children, such as depleted self-worth and engagement
in dangerous activities; put those two outcomes together and a suicidal pattern will
inevitably show. Medical neglect in particular can have lasting effects on the psychology
of the victimized children where they will not know what is socially acceptable or normal
in regards to medical attention, physical or mental.
In Regards to the effects of maltreatment, no part of a small child is more offended by
parental neglect than the mind. Everyone derives the majority of their understanding of
the world from how they perceived their parents at a young age, and tainting that
impression for them can result in decades of recovery. In the NCS-R investigation, it
was found that, “a number of studies have linked childhood neglect to cognitive deficits
in adulthood including poorer executive functioning and problem solving/non-verbal
reasoning, worse memory, and lower IQ, all of which may be important for suicidal
behavior”(qtd. in Stickley et al.). Tainting that parental impression for young adults,
through any of the aforementioned types of neglect, can result in decades of recovery.
Children victimized by neglect grow up in their own category of handicap, relying on
therapy to put their childhoods into perspective. Particularly from care neglect, another
sub-effect of the deterioration of mental health is that victimized individuals who seek to
raise children of their own can often reflect their own experiences of how they were
raised onto their successors, leading to an unhealthy cycle of generational neglect.
One of the very visible impacts of child maltreatment can be seen in a victimized child’s
academic performance. As both distractions and mental health deficiencies can easily
cripple a young adult’s education, an unhealthy and insufficient relationship with a
parental force can condemn a child to maintaining a poor performance in school, which
can have a dramatic snowball effect on their life down the road. Particularly caused by
supervisory or care neglect, younger kids can develop mentalities of false
independence, leading them to try and take control over factors of their life that, in their
best interest, should stay as superior forces. Such factors might be school attendance,
schoolwork prioritization, or the freedom of having dangerous behavior.
The third primary effect of childhood neglect is the distorted incentive towards
dangerous behavior, especially addictive activities like graffiti or drugs. The article’s
experiment acknowledged the fact that, “childhood neglect has also been associated
with greater impulsivity, which is often considered a risk factor for suicide”(qtd. in
Stickley et al.). Experiencing neglect from a supervisory character like a parent can
easily lead to a sense of self-righteousness that devolves to a form of carelessness in
which many young adults find themselves in harm's way, running in with law
enforcement, or identifying with the wrong crowd. In the experiment report, the article
also focused on the commonality of self harm and suicidal trends, noting that, “In
models that were adjusted for demographic, socioeconomic, mental health and
childhood physical abuse variables, all of the individual neglect items except the care
neglect variables (went hungry, went without things) in the suicidal ideation analysis,
were associated with all forms of suicidal behavior”(Stickley et al.). Many of these paths
can lead to a parallel road of self harm as well, as kids without parental guidance
naturally turn towards themselves as dangerous places to vent their unanswered
curiosities.
The source article sought to establish research into the concern about suicidal
outcomes from childhood neglect, using data collected from the NCS-R. To do this, data
from the NCS-R was used to examine trends between childhood neglect and suicidal
behavior. The trends were very prevalent, making strong evidence for the claim of their
causal relationship. The qualitative data from the experiment even proved the claim
beyond common mental disorders in the adults observed, and proceeded to call to
action more research to better understand how more specific subtypes of maltreatment
result into adult behavior. Not nearly enough research has been done on the topic of
mental health and its ties to childhood neglect, but this article shines light on the
prominence of adults’ familial experiences as a young child affecting their mental health
later in life.
As far as strengths and weaknesses in the insights sought through the article, I found
the drive for understanding the exact relationship, or relationships, between childhood
neglect and mental health later on in life to be the article’s greatest strength. But,
likewise, the greatest weakness for the NCS-R investigation was that little to no
previous data could be relied on to structure a more effective or verifiable survey on
how much maltreatment of minors affects their futures. The conclusion of the article
clearly states that, “an extended discussion of the mechanisms that might link childhood
neglect and subsequent suicidal behavior is not within the scope of this study although it
is possible that several factors might be involved.”(Stickley et al.) The experiment
worked well with the sample size of over 5500 participants giving qualitative data, and
differentiating different types of child neglect to pair with specified tiers of self harm had
its merits in the research. But, once more, the single most limiting factor of this research
is the lack of additional information. More research is needed to be done on specific
correlations to find the most clean-cut results for the question of how childhood neglect
can rupture one’s abilities to have a healthy adulthood.
To really grasp the effect that childhood neglect can have on its victims, it is necessary
to consider the greater outcome for society if these practices were to be more
widespread than they are. I personally am inclined to believe they are, but that could
easily be due to my personal experiences. I like to think that raising children is
indifferent to having a pet goldfish: it was once believed that they grow as much as their
physical space allows them to, but, in truth, their growth is most dependent on how well
they are cared for. With the size of the bowl representing opportunities in a kid’s life,
said bowl size falls short in priority to the wellbeing and maintenance needed for the
child to thrive. I feel the only true answer to the problem of child-neglect as a full scale
issue is to approach how society’s parents raise their kids as communities looking for a
healthier way to bring up younger generations. So that, as adults, we no longer have to
lament over the experiences we spent with a parent over the past twenty years. To do
this, more research must be done on the specific causes and effects in the range of
child care deficiencies explored in the study.
In writing this essay, I limited myself to a single information source from the web. This
allowed me to focus the information from the text straight into my essay. The article itself
was about a group of sociological researchers that compiled data from the NCS-R
survey into a experiment on the trends between suicidal behavior following a childhood
where they experienced neglect from their parents. This article wasn’t perfectly fit for the
format of my essay, information wise, for it really only had one effect from the topic of
child neglect. But the depth at which this source went allowed me to manifest three
separate effects to match the causes, balancing the essay’s content. Following this topic
on child neglect also allowed me personal insight on how my life has been shaped in
part by my mom’s influence, contrasting my experiences throughout my life up to this
point.
Sources
Stickley, Andrew, et al. “Childhood Neglect and Suicidal Behavior: Findings from the
National Comorbidity Survey Replication.” Child Abuse & Neglect, vol. 103, May 2020,
p. 104400, www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0145213420300557,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2020.104400. Accessed 25 Sept. 2024.