1
Aaron Zhu
Professor Schendan
Political Theory
02 August 2025
The US Government: A Republic vs Pure Democracy
Madison uses human nature’s instinct of self-interest to undermine the idea of pure
democracy or majoritarianism. He believes that humans naturally seek their own interests rather
than justice for all of society. (Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 65) When men are given liberty,
people will form different opinions on different subjects, because there is no universal “right”
answer. (Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 63-64). The subjects that people form different opinions on
can include government, property, religion, and more. (Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 64).
Predictably, people will gather and be friends who agree with them, and create factions. For
example, in current times, people are united for or against abortion, tighter gun control, and
universal healthcare. Although there are arguments for each, there is no right answer that people
agree on because there are so many opinions for each.
In the Federalist Papers, Madison, Jay, and Hamilton write to the people of New York to
convince them to vote for the New Constitution(Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 62). Madison argues
against a pure democracy, a political system where an entire population votes on an issue,
because of its threat to a minority. (Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 67) For example, consider if
eighty percent of the population were Christian and 20 percent were not. According to Madison:
“A common passion or interest will, in almost every case, be felt by a majority of the whole; a
2
communication and concert results from the form of government itself; and there is nothing to
check the inducements to sacrifice the weaker party, or an obnoxious individual.” In this case,
the “majority of the whole” would be the Christians and the non-Christians who would be the
minority. The “majority of the whole” can form a faction, interested in Christian interests, rather
than justice and fairness. Therefore, in a pure democracy setting, the majority could oppress the
weaker party through religious persecution, because there is nothing to prevent them.
Consider the faculties of man and how they relate to property. Madison wrote: “the most
common and durable source of factions has been the various and unequal distribution of
property.” (Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 64). People have unequal and different faculties
(Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 64), which are evaluated by the market(Schendan Lecture,
Federalist Fifty-One lecture two, 0:00). Consider why an unskilled laborer makes minimum
wage while artificial intelligence researchers are making hundreds of thousands of dollars a year.
The value they bring to society is much greater than that of an unskilled laborer, which almost
anyone can do. To encourage more people to develop skills like those in artificial intelligence,
jobs that demand these skills pay significantly better than unskilled labor. Therefore, with
unequal and diverse faculties, people earn varying amounts of money, which in turn purchases a
varying amount of property. These principles have remained true from the 1780s till now.
People who own significant property band together to keep their property and argue that
private property is a right and that rich people have properly earned their money and the right to
keep it. Those with little to no property want the property to be redistributed because they
believe it is more fair and just for property to be distributed, and selfish if someone keeps it all to
3
themself. As Madison said, it is human nature to form factions based on your interests(Madison,
Federalist 10, pg. 64) . Property is significant because it is a family’s personal space.
Madison points out that” A body of men are unfit to be both judges and parties at the
same time”(Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 65). If a body of men is unfit to be both judges and
parties at the same time, there must be an impartial judge. That judge must be in the best interest
of the whole society. Inherently, it seems that a single wise judge could be a great option, but
everyone has bias! In fact, the Founders were afraid that one person to have so much power like
a King in England. (Schendan Lecture, Federalist Fifty-One lecture two, 9:58).
Madison introduces the concept of a republic, which elects a delegation to rule over a
large country. (Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 67) Madison believes that the general public is an
unthinking mob (Schendan Lecture, Federalist Ten lecture two, 4:54), another reason why pure
democracy wouldn’t succeed. Through the election of wise delegates, the delegates will be able
to form and modify ideas (from the people they represent) in the best interest of society. These
delegates would be elected for a term in office and would have a sense of love and patriotism for
the country, so they can act justly(Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 67). A large country is more
favorable than a smaller country because there will be more factions. With more factions, those
that are corrupt will be diluted. The president of the US will be elected by the whole nation, so
that the smartest and most capable leader will be elected, rather than a candidate who can
deceive and manipulate. (Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 68) Madison says: “Extend the sphere, and
you take in a greater variety of parties and interests”. That is why it is the United States of
America, rather than separate states. In this republic structure, all people and views will be
represented. The result is hopefully an impartial judge where justice will be sought for society.
4
Our government structures control factions by having a separation of powers between
departments, but also by controlling the different interest groups within the department.
(Schendan Lecture, Federalist Fifty-One lecture two, 0:00). Simply put, these different interest
groups are controlled by each other’s ambition. (Schendan Lecture, Federalist Fifty-One lecture
two, 1:00). Hamilton explains in Federalist 51: “by comprehending in the society so many
separate descriptions of citizens, as will render an unjust combination of a majority of the whole,
very improbable, if not impracticable.” (Hamilton, Federalist 51, pg.356) Every district in the
United States is unique, so they must have unique interests. For example, consider California: in
the South Bay Area, representatives will consider tech workers and big tech corporation
interests, but in the Central Valley, representatives will consider agricultural interests. (Schendan
Lecture, Federalist Fifty-One lecture two, 2:00) Even in the Central Valley and Bay Area, there
are conflicting interests, which will make a united majority of the US improbable because
everyone has different concerns. Therefore, everyone’s ambitions control another’s ambition and
power.
Next, consider how the different departments, executive, judicial, and legislative
branches, keep each other’s powers in check. According to Hamilton, the legislative branch is the
strongest in the federal government. (Hamilton, Federalist 51, pg. 355). Congress introduces
legislation with a simple majority, but the President has the power to veto the bill. Nevertheless,
since Congress is stronger, Congress can override the veto with a two-thirds majority. After a bill
is passed, the courts can rule a bill unconstitutional. (Schendan Lecture, Federalist Fifty-One
lecture One, 11:00) Congress comes up on top still because they can make a constitutional
5
amendment, but that is extremely difficult because a united two-thirds of Congress is
improbable.
Therefore, the founders made the U. S. government so that it is hard and at times
impossible to do policymaking. According to the lecture, the 116th Congress had a 99% failure
rate regarding introduced legislation. (Schendan Lecture, Federalist Fifty-One lecture two, 7:30)
Madison wrote: “The different governments will control each other; at the same time that each
will be controlled by itself.”(Hamilton, Federalist 51, pg. 356). With so many checks and
balances, it makes sense why legislation needs so much negotiation and compromise. This brings
up the question of whether this government was made by and for the wealthy to prevent
progressive laws. Madison, as well as all the other founders, were rich men. (Schendan Lecture,
Federalist Fifty-One lecture two, 9:56) They certainly didn’t want high taxes because that took
away their wealth. If they could limit the government’s powers, change would come slowly
The election of the different offices also separates the powers. The congressmen are
voted for by each state’s citizens and legislators(Schendan Lecture, Federalist Fifty-One lecture
two, 0:29) while the President is voted for by the state’s legislators(Madison, Federalist 10, pg.
68). In both cases, the state legislators are voted for by the people. However, the judicial branch
is nominated by the President and approved by the Senate. (Schendan Lecture, Federalist
Fifty-One lecture one, 4:53) That may seem to be a problem because the judicial branch’s
elections are seemingly controlled by the executive and legislative branches. Therefore, judges
may act in favor of politicians' desires. However, when electing a judge, one must consider
someone’s qualifications, which politically capable people like the President and Senate
members are experienced in. The general public is unable to consider a judge’s qualifications and
6
may be deceived. (Hamilton, Federalist 51, pg. 354) Furthermore, since the tenure of a judge is
for life, they will not need to depend on the President’s approval and may act in the best interest
of justice.
However, America has double security because there are state and federal governments.
Each state government replicates the federal government and takes care of the more local
concerns. (Madison, Federalist 10, pg. 69.) That way, state legislatures can focus on matters
concerning the state directly, while federal congressman can focus on national issues affecting
their state.
7
Works Cited
Autor: Alexander Hamilton, et al. The Federalist Papers. Penguin, 1961.