13 Behind the paper: distribution concerns. Clearing up protein pro natural By Alan Aragon 16 Half-natural interview with bodybuilder Alberto Nunez. By Alan Aragon Copyright © February 1st, 2018 by Alan Aragon Home: www.alanaragon.com Correspondence: support@alanaragon.com 2 Muscle hypertrophy: Are all reps created equal? Formalizing the theory of “effective reps” Carl Juneau, PhD. 6 Effect of Low-Fat vs Low-Carbohydrate Diet on 12-Month Weight Loss in Overweight Adults and the Association With Genotype Pattern or Insulin Secretion: The DIETFITS Randomized Clinical Trial. Gardner CD, Trepanowski JF, Del Gobbo LC, Hauser ME, Rigdon J, Ioannidis JPA, Desai M, King AC. JAMA. 2018 Feb 20;319(7):667-679. [PubMed] 9 Does high-carbohydrate intake lead to increased risk of obesity? A systematic review and metaanalysis. Sartorius K, Sartorius B, Madiba TE, Stefan C. BMJ Open. 2018 Feb 8;8(2):e018449. [PubMed] 11 No superior adaptations to carbohydrate periodization in elite endurance athletes. Gejl KD, Thams LB, Hansen M, Rokkedal-Lausch T, Plomgaard P, Nybo L, Larsen FJ, Cardinale DA, Jensen K, Holmberg HC, Vissing K, Ørtenblad N. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2017 Dec;49(12):2486-2497 [PubMed] Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 1 Muscle hypertrophy: Are all reps created equal? Formalizing the theory of “effective reps” Carl Juneau, PhD _________________________________________________ Abstract Volume is a key driver of muscle hypertrophy. More reps lead to more volume, but not all reps are created equal. In this article, I argue that the closer a rep is to failure, the more effective it is at building muscle, formalizing the theory of “effective reps”. As this theory would predict, some studies have shown that lifters who perform more effective reps build more muscle, even when similar volumes are used. Effective reps also seem more efficient, reducing workout time by about half. Mechanistically, I argue that effective reps build more muscle because they increase metabolic stress. Restpause or drop sets can be used to maximize effective reps, but lifters new to using them should monitor their progress carefully to avoid overtraining. Introduction When I first started lifting weights in 2002, I was looking for “the” secret to build muscle. I was small and skinny, so I thought I‟d be smarter than everyone else, find the shortcut, and get big in no time. Turns out, there was no real shortcut, and the secret isn‟t as sexy as I would have hoped. Now, 17 years of lifting and coaching later and a PhD under my belt, I can say with some confidence: the secret (if there‟s one) is progression. Progression along two key variables: tension and volume. In this article, I will focus on a basic component of volume: repetitions (reps). Specifically, I will try to answer the following question: “Are all reps created equal?” In doing so, I will formalize the theory of effective reps and briefly review the literature in support and against it. Are all reps created equal? Schoenfeld et al. (2017) have shown that volume is a key driver of muscle growth. Reps increase volume. Are all reps created equal? I argue that they are not, and that reps closer to failure are more effective at building muscle. Take the following example: workouts cause identical muscle hypertrophy? I argue that they would not, because the reps of workout A are taken closer to failure than the reps of workout B. To be exact, 4 of the 5 reps are more effective at building muscle, because they are performed closer and closer to failure. I argue that the closer a rep is to failure, the more effective it is at building muscle, and that “effective reps” are reps closer to failure. The term “effective reps” seems to have been used for the first time by Fagerli (2012) in the comments of a blog post. Frederick (2017) also defined a similar concept as “exertion load”. However, to my knowledge, these concepts have never been formalized into a theory. Formalizing the theory of effective reps A theory is “a set of logically interrelated propositions about empirical reality” (Schutt, 2012). For this theory, I propose that: (1) Failure is “the point during a set when muscles can no longer produce necessary force to concentrically lift a given load” (Schoenfeld, 2010). (2) Effective reps are reps closer to failure. (3) The closer a rep is to failure, the more effective it is at building muscle. A good theory is parsimonious and it has good predictive precision (Gabaix and Laibson, 2008). Finally, it should serve to form hypotheses (Schutt, 2012). Based on the theory of effective reps, we can hypothesize that lifters who perform more effective reps build more muscle, even when similar volumes are used. Studies have tested this (or similar) hypotheses, providing evidence for or against the theory of effective reps. Evidence for the theory of effective reps Research by Goto et al. (2005) supports this theory. In that study, two groups of lifters did the same training protocol (35 sets @ 10RM). There was just one difference between groups: lifters in group 2 rested for 30 seconds at the midpoint of each set. So, volume was equal between groups, but more “effective reps” were performed by lifters in group 1. As the theory of effective reps would predict, lifters in group 1 gained significantly more (p < 0.01) muscle crosssectional area (12.9%) than lifters in group 2 (4%). Workout A: 1 set of 5 reps @ 85% 1RM (to failure) Workout B: 5 sets of 1 rep @ 85% 1RM (far from failure) Research by Gieβsing et al. (2016) also supports this theory. In that study, lifters who trained to failure gained more lean mass than lifters who did not. Volume was similar between groups. For both workouts, a total of 5 reps @ 85% 1RM are performed. So, volume is exactly the same. Would both Recently, Prestes et al. (2017) and Fink et al. (2017) have also published research that provides supports for this theory. Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 2 Prestes et al. (2017) studied rest-pause sets. A rest-pause set is a series of reps carried out to failure, followed by a short rest, followed by more reps to failure. In this study, subjects “performed an initial set with 80% of 1RM until failure with subsequent sets performed with a 20-second inter-set rest interval until completing a total of 18 repetitions.” The control group performed 3 “normal” sets of 6 reps @ 80% 1RM with 2-3 minutes between sets. So, volume was not different between groups (18 reps @ 80% 1RM). Both groups trained for 6 weeks. After 6 weeks, lifters in the rest-pause group gained more muscle thickness in the thigh (11% vs. 1%, p < 0.05). However, other differences between groups in muscle thickness (for arm and chest) were not statistically significant. Fink et al. (2017) studied drop sets. In that study, lifters in group 1 performed a single drop set of cable triceps pushdowns. They started with a 12RM weight. When they hit failure, their load was decreased by 20% 3 times. Lifters in group 2 performed 3 normal sets @ 12RM with 90 seconds between sets. The paper states that no significant betweengroup differences in volume were found (p > 0.05). However, their mesure of volume was not standard. I emailed the corresponding author. Based on our correspondence, I estimated that total volume was actually lower for the dropset group (by about 1,756 lbs). However, I was not able to test for statistical differences between group, leaving this issue unresolved. At any rate, drop sets took less than half the time to perform (145.4 seconds, on average) than normal sets (315.5 seconds, on average). This difference was significant (p < 0.001). Both groups trained for 6 weeks. After 6 weeks, lifters in both groups gained triceps cross-sectional area (10% in group 1 and 5.1% in group 2, no significant differences between groups). Effect size was higher in the drop-set group (0.47) than in the normal-set group (0.25); however, statistical differences in effect sizes between groups were not assessed. Collectively, these results suggest that reps closer to failure are more effective at building muscle. In Goto et al. (2005), lifters who performed more effective reps gained more muscle cross-sectional area, even if volume was not different. In Gieβsing et al. (2016), lifters who trained to failure gained more lean mass than lifters who did not, even if volume was similar between groups. In Prestes et al. (2017), lifters in the rest-pause group gained more muscle thickness in the thigh, even if volume was also not different. In Fink et al. (2017), effect sizes seemed to favor the drop-set group, even if volume was not different (or actually lower) in that group. Additional evidence is found in Schoenfeld (2016), who reviewed 2 more studies on training to failure. Of those, one found greater gains in hypertrophy when training was carried Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 out to failure (Schott et al. 1995). The other found similar gains between groups (Sampson and Groeller, 2016). However, in that study, the group not training to failure actually performed one set to failure at the end of every week, confounding results. Evidence against the theory of effective reps It should be noted that Angleri et al. (2017) found no differences between drop sets and normal sets. However, in that study, drop sets were sometimes interrupted to equate for volume between groups, reducing the number of “effective reps” that could be performed by lifters in the drop-set group. Similarly, Martorelli et al. (2017) found no differences between repetitions to failure and repetitions not to failure when volume was equalized, although gains (17.5% vs 8.5%) and effect size were (not significantly) higher in the repetitions to failure group (0.31 vs. 0.13). A limitation of that study is that subjects were untrained young women. Discussion In summary, volume is a key driver of muscle hypertrophy. More reps lead to more volume, but not all reps are created equal. I have argued that the closer a rep is to failure, the more effective it is at building muscle. This is the central proposition of the theory of effective reps. As this theory would predict, looking at published data, lifters who performed more effective reps got better gains, even when similar or lower volumes were used (Goto et al. 2005; Gieβsing et al. 2016; Prestes et al. 2017; Fink et al. 2017). Effective reps were also more efficient, reducing workout time by about half (Fink et al. 2017). So, there is evidence to support this theory, with the majority of studies reviewed providing support (Prestes et al. 2017; Fink et al. 2017, Goto et al. 2005; Gieβsing et al. 2016; Schott et al. 1995). However, not all the evidence supports it (Angleri et al. 2017; Sampson and Groeller, 2016). How might we explain that reps closer to failure are more effective? I believe that the most likely mechanism is metabolic stress. Schoenfeld (2010) identified metabolic stress as one of three key drivers of muscle hypertrophy. Reps closer to failure increase metabolic stress in two ways. First, they produce more metabolites of anaerobic glycolysis, “which theoretically augments postexercise anabolism” (Schoenfeld, 2016). Second, they restrict blood flow longer. This leads to “greater acute hypoxia in the working muscles, which may further contribute to hypertrophic adaptations” (Schoenfeld, 2016). This theory and its application have some limitations. First, training to failure repeatedly may increase risk of [Back to Contents] Page 3 overtraining (Schoenfeld, 2016), especially with rest-pause or drop sets. Therefore, total training volume should be carefully manipulated (do not turn all your normal sets into rest-pause and drop sets at once; a good guideline is 1 rest-pause or drop set = 3 normal sets). As well, stay on the lookout for overtraining (if your performance drops, you may be overdoing it). Second, some of the studies I have reviewed were carried out with untrained subjects. Third, I have not carried out a systematic review of the literature. So, it is likely that I have missed relevant papers. I propose this theory as a work in progress. If you are aware of more evidence for or against this theory, please email me (carl@drmuscleapp.com). I‟d love to hear from you. Practical applications What‟s the best way to apply the theory of effective reps? I suggest the following: 1. First, get familiar with rest-pause or drop sets. I prefer rest-pause sets, because I find they‟re more convenient (no need to change the weight you lift during your set). Try them out during an experimental session. 2. Next, choose one exercise you‟re familiar with, and that you can execute to failure repeatedly safely. A machine chest press might be a good option. 3. Next, replace 3 normal sets by 1 rest-pause or drop set for that exercise. 5. Continue monitoring your progress as you slowly transition to using rest-pause or drop sets on more (or even all) of your exercises. Watch for overtraining, and make sure you continue making similar or better gains across the board. For a detailed application of rest-pause sets, see Fagerli (2012). _________________________________________________ Dr. Carl Juneau is an exercise scientist with a PhD in physical activity epidemiology. He's been a coach and a lifter for 16 years. He's also the founder of Dr. Muscle. Dr. Muscle is a new phone app that helps you build muscle faster using AI with a smart program that updates every time you work out. To try it out, learn more, or get your first month free, use this special link: https://drmuscleapp.com/48.html. _________________________________________________ References Angleri V, Ugrinowitsch C, Libardi CA. Crescent pyramid and drop-set systems do not promote greater strength gains, muscle hypertrophy, and changes on muscle architecture compared with traditional resistance training in well-trained men. Eur J Appl Physiol. 2017 Feb;117(2):359-369. [Pubmed] Based on Fink et al. (2017), for drop sets, I would recommend decreasing your load by 20% 3 times. Fagerli B. Myo-reps in English. Retrieved from http://borgefagerli.com/myo-reps-in-english/. 2012 May. b. Based on my own experience, for rest-pause sets, I would recommend doing reps to failure, resting for 40 seconds, doing more reps to failure, resting for 40 more seconds, and doing yet again more reps to failure. In other words, use two 40-second rests. I‟ve found 40 seconds works better than the 10-20 seconds used in the literature for intermediates and advanced lifters who handle heavier weights (resting for 20 seconds did not allow us to perform more than 1-2 extra reps). Fink J, Schoenfeld BJ, Kikuchi N, Nakazato K. Effects of drop set resistance training on acute stress indicators and long-term muscle hypertrophy and strength. J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 2017 Apr 26. [Pubmed] a. Frederick R. Monitoring Training Stress With Exertion Load. Retrieved from http://www.strongur.io/monitoring-trainingstress-with-exertion-load/. 2017 Jul. Gabaix, Xavier and David I. Laibson. 2008. The seven properties of good models. In The Foundations of Positive and Normative Economics : A Handbook, ed. A. Caplin and A. Schotter. Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Harvard] 4. Carefully monitor your progress. Are you making gains using rest-pause or drop sets? Better or worse gains than when you did normal sets? Also, are you saving time? The theory predicts that you should make similar or better gains with less workout time. If that turns out to be true, you may want to use rest-pause or drop sets more and more. Gieβsing J, Fisher J, Steele J, Rothe F, Raubold K, Eichmann B. The effects of low-volume resistance training with and without advanced techniques in trained subjects. J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 2016 Mar;56(3):249-58. [Pubmed] Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 4 Goto K, Ishii N, Kizuka T, Takamatsu K. The impact of metabolic stress on hormonal responses and muscular adaptations. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2005 Jun;37(6):955-63. [Pubmed] Martorelli S, Cadore EL, Izquierdo M, Celes R, Martorelli A, Cleto VA, Alvarenga JG, Bottaro M. Strength Training with Repetitions to Failure does not Provide Additional Strength and Muscle Hypertrophy Gains in Young Women. Eur J Transl Myol. 2017 Jun 27;27(2):6339. [Pubmed] Prestes J, Tibana RA, de Araujo Sousa E, da Cunha Nascimento D, de Oliveira Rocha P, Camarço NF, Frade de Sousa NM, Willardson JM. Strength And Muscular Adaptations Following 6 Weeks Of Rest-Pause Versus Traditional Multiple-Sets Resistance Training In Trained Subjects. J Strength Cond Res. 2017 Apr 4. [Pubmed] Sampson JA, Groeller H. Is repetition failure critical for the development of muscle hypertrophy and strength? Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2016 Apr;26(4):375-83. [Pubmed] Schutt, Russell K. 2012. “Quantitative Methods.” Pp. 55-72 in The Wiley-Blackwell Companion to Sociology, edited by George Ritzer. Oxford, England: Blackwell Publishing. [UCLA] Schoenfeld BJ. The mechanisms of muscle hypertrophy and their application to resistance training. J Strength Cond Res. 2010 Oct;24(10):2857-72. [Pubmed] Schoenfeld BJ. Science and Development of Muscle Hypertrophy. Human Kinetics; 1 edition. July 28, 2016. [Amazon] Schoenfeld BJ, Ogborn D, Krieger JW. Dose-response relationship between weekly resistance training volume and increases in muscle mass: A systematic review and metaanalysis. J Sports Sci. 2017 Jun;35(11):1073-1082. [Pubmed] Schott J, McCully K, Rutherford OM. The role of metabolites in strength training. II. Short versus long isometric contractions. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol. 1995;71(4):337-41. [Pubmed] Acknowledgement Thanks to Lyle McDonald teaching me so much over the years, to Brad Schoenfeld for his monumental contribution to the field, and to Steve Hall for feedback. Conflict of interest My team is building a workout app that automates advanced training methods for hypertrophy, including rest-pause sets. Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 5 Effect of Low-Fat vs Low-Carbohydrate Diet on 12Month Weight Loss in Overweight Adults and the Association With Genotype Pattern or Insulin Secretion: The DIETFITS Randomized Clinical Trial. Gardner CD, Trepanowski JF, Del Gobbo LC, Hauser ME, Rigdon J, Ioannidis JPA, Desai M, King AC. JAMA. 2018 Feb 20;319(7):667-679. [PubMed] IMPORTANCE: Dietary modification remains key to successful weight loss. Yet, no one dietary strategy is consistently superior to others for the general population. Previous research suggests genotype or insulin-glucose dynamics may modify the effects of diets. OBJECTIVE: To determine the effect of a healthy low-fat (HLF) diet vs a healthy low-carbohydrate (HLC) diet on weight change and if genotype pattern or insulin secretion are related to the dietary effects on weight loss. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: The Diet Intervention Examining The Factors Interacting with Treatment Success (DIETFITS) randomized clinical trial included 609 adults aged 18 to 50 years without diabetes with a body mass index between 28 and 40. The trial enrollment was from January 29, 2013, through April 14, 2015; the date of final follow-up was May 16, 2016. Participants were randomized to the 12-month HLF or HLC diet. The study also tested whether 3 singlenucleotide polymorphism multilocus genotype responsiveness patterns or insulin secretion (INS-30; blood concentration of insulin 30 minutes after a glucose challenge) were associated with weight loss. INTERVENTIONS: Health educators delivered the behavior modification intervention to HLF (n = 305) and HLC (n = 304) participants via 22 diet-specific small group sessions administered over 12 months. The sessions focused on ways to achieve the lowest fat or carbohydrate intake that could be maintained long-term and emphasized diet quality. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Primary outcome was 12-month weight change and determination of whether there were significant interactions among diet type and genotype pattern, diet and insulin secretion, and diet and weight loss. RESULTS: Among 609 participants randomized (mean age, 40 [SD, 7] years; 57% women; mean body mass index, 33 [SD, 3]; 244 [40%] had a low-fat genotype; 180 [30%] had a lowcarbohydrate genotype; mean baseline INS-30, 93 μIU/mL), 481 (79%) completed the trial. In the HLF vs HLC diets, respectively, the mean 12-month macronutrient distributions were 48% vs 30% for carbohydrates, 29% vs 45% for fat, and 21% vs 23% for protein. Weight change at 12 months was 5.3 kg for the HLF diet vs -6.0 kg for the HLC diet (mean between-group difference, 0.7 kg [95% CI, -0.2 to 1.6 kg]). There was no significant diet-genotype pattern interaction (P = .20) or diet-insulin secretion (INS-30) interaction (P = .47) with 12-month weight loss. There were 18 adverse events or serious adverse events that were evenly distributed across the 2 diet groups. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 this 12-month weight loss diet study, there was no significant difference in weight change between a healthy low-fat diet vs a healthy low-carbohydrate diet, and neither genotype pattern nor baseline insulin secretion was associated with the dietary effects on weight loss. In the context of these 2 common weight loss diet approaches, neither of the 2 hypothesized predisposing factors was helpful in identifying which diet was better for whom. TRIAL REGISTRATION: clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT01826591. SPONSORSHIP: This study was supported by grant 1R01DK091831 from the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, grant T32HL007034 from the Nutrition Science Initiative, grant 1K12GM088033 from the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, and the Stanford Clinical and Translational Science Award. Strengths A standout design strength was the 12-month duration. The majority of diet research is much shorter than this, due to financial and logistical constraints. Long-term diet trial results are inherently better reflective of what happens with dieters in „real life‟ versus a few weeks under the microscope of the research personnel. Another strength was the large number of subjects (609). The dietary intervention involved a 1-month run-in period where weight maintenance was objectively established prior to the hypocaloric period. Over the course of 12 months, there were 22 dietitian-led instructional sessions for each group. Sessions designed to educate and bolster compliance were held weekly for 8 weeks, then every 2 weeks for 2 months, then every 3 weeks until the sixth month, and monthly thereafter. The diets were robustly disparate from each other in terms of carbohydrate and fat content, which circumvented the issue of previous diet comparisons not testing the effects of “true” low-carb diets. The present trial‟s low-carb diet prescription involved 20 g/d during the first 8 weeks. Thereafter, subjects gradually added carbs back to their diets in weekly increments of 5-15 g/day until they reached the lowest intake they believed could be permanently maintained. This same protocol was done in the low-fat group, except with a gradual increase in dietary fat. An important design element was the emphasis on keeping both diets “healthy” in order to put them on a level playing field regarding clinical outcomes. Subjects in both groups were specifically instructed to maximize vegetable intake, focus on nutrient-dense, whole/minimally processed foods, prepare food at home [Back to Contents] Page 6 whenever possible, and minimize added sugars, refined flours, and trans fats. Limitations The authors acknowledged the following limitations: Subjects lived in a geographic area with relatively high education levels and capacity to access high-quality food options, thus potentially challenging the applicability of the findings to less educated or affluent populations. There are many alternate indices to consider other than INS-30 as a surrogate measure of insulin secretion. Due to inadequate initial funding, there were 3 missing anthropometric and metabolic measures (body fat percent, resting energy expenditure, and respiratory exchange ratio) for the first 78 subjects enrolled in the study. This funding problem subsequently resolved for the subsequent participants. Physical activity was self-reported via the Stanford 7-day Physical Activity Recall tool, which the authors conceded was a crude measure of total energy expenditure, particularly compared with objective assessment techniques such as doubly labeled water. Despite the well-done assessment of insulin sensitivity, there has been significant progress in the potential genetic assessment variables underlying dietary response since this trial was designed. Thus, further work needs to be done in this area. Randomization & stratification of subjects according to genotype or insulin sensitivity was not done, thus causal inference with these variables is limited. Macronutrient proportions of the LC & LF diets at the end of the 12-month trial were 29.8 vs 48.4 for carbohydrates, 44.6 vs 28.7 for fat, and 22.9 vs 20.6 % for protein. While the carb intake in the LC group at this point probably would not satisfy die-hard proponents of very-low-carb/keto diets, it‟s important to note that subjects were specifically assigned a very aggressively low intake of carbohydrate for the first 8 weeks (20 g/day), and this amount would increase in small weekly increments until only the lowest amount indefinitely sustainable was reached. In essence, the protocol was an autoregulated exploration in adherence & tolerability for low intakes of carbohydrate (or in the case of other group, fat). It‟s interesting to observe the degree of increase of carb & fat intake through the course of the trial in the following table (larger image here): Comment/application The main findings of this study are a big disappointment for those hoping for a magic bullet. No significant weight loss differences occurred between the low-carb (LC) and the lowfat (LF) diets after 12 months. Weight loss was in LC & LF were 6.0 & 5.3 kg, respectively. Baseline insulin action and genotype pattern both failed to show an association or influence on weight loss with either diet. This is in contrast to the findings of two previous studies,1,2 but both involved much smaller subject numbers and/or shorter trial duration. I found it interesting that insulin sensitivity and glucose control improved similarly in both groups. It‟s also notable that differences in glycemic index and glycemic load between the diets had no bearing on the outcomes. This is likely due to the emphasis placed on both groups to make healthy dietary choices (nutrient-dense, whole/minimally refined foods). Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 Notably, although the carb target in the LC group was 20 g/day for the first 8 weeks, but by 3 months subjects consumed 96.6 g/day (23.1% of total kcal). At the 6 & 12month points, 113.2 & 132.4 g/day (26.5 & 29.8%, respectively) were consumed. This falls in-line with the conclusions of a recent meta-analysis by Huntriss et al on low-carbohydrate diets for managing type-2 diabetes:3 “The majority of studies in this review demonstrated that participants in the LCIA were not able to achieve the carbohydrate prescription as set out by the investigators. However, the average carbohydrate consumption across LCIAs was 106 g/day showing that achievement of a lowcarbohydrate diet is realistic and its demonstration was seen in many studies. Adherence to a very lowcarbohydrate diet (<50 g/day), although achieved in one [Back to Contents] Page 7 study, seems an unrealistic target for the majority of patients within this population group.” A similar phenomenon occurred in the LF group. Fat intake was targeted to be 20 g/day of the first 8 weeks, with small weekly increments occurring thereafter, with the objective of the increase being the least possible that still allows permanent adherence. Fat intake in the LF group at 3, 6, and 12 months was 42, 50.3, & 57.3 g/day (24.0, 26.4, 28.7%) respectively. These findings are in-line with the general body of literature on low-fat diets showing that prescribed restriction to 20% of total energy intake from fat is difficult to achieve since actual intakes range 26-28%.4 4. Aragon AA, et al. International society of sports nutrition position stand: diets and body composition. J Int Soc Sports Nutr. 2017 Jun 14;14:16. [PubMed] 5. Hall KD, Chen KY, Guo J, Lam YY, Leibel RL, Mayer LE, Reitman ML, Rosenbaum M, Smith SR, Walsh BT, Ravussin E. Energy expenditure and body composition changes after an isocaloric ketogenic diet in overweight and obese men. Am J Clin Nutr. 2016 Aug;104(2):32433. Am J Clin Nutr. 2016 Aug;104(2):324-33. [PubMed] Overall, this large, well-designed & executed study meaningfully adds to the body of literature showing that a wide range of macronutrient proportions can work similarly well for long-term weight loss. Alternatively, it can be said that there‟s no single diet type that outperforms all other types. These findings strengthen the principle that weight loss diets can be flexibly individualized according to preference of low-carb, low-fat, or somewhere along the continuum. In a twist of irony, one of the sponsors of this study is the Nutrition Science Initiative (NuSI), an organization cofounded by low-carb journalist/diet book author Gary Taubes. This is the second NuSI-funded study that showed null findings rather than the superiority of low-carb; the first study was by Hall et al.5 It‟s good to know that although the NuSI is providing financial support for these studies, it thus far does not seem to influence their results. References 1. Ebbeling CB, Leidig MM, Feldman HA, Lovesky MM, Ludwig DS. Effects of a low-glycemic load vs low-fat diet in obese young adults: a randomized trial.JAMA. 2007 May 16;297(19):2092-102. [PubMed] 2. Pittas AG1, Das SK, Hajduk CL, Golden J, Saltzman E, Stark PC, Greenberg AS, Roberts SB. A low-glycemic load diet facilitates greater weight loss in overweight adults with high insulin secretion but not in overweight adults with low insulin secretion in the CALERIE Trial. Diabetes Care. 2005 Dec;28(12):2939-41. [PubMed] 3. Huntriss R, Campbell M, Bedwell C. The interpretation and effect of a low-carbohydrate diet in the management of type 2 diabetes: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2017) doi:10.1038/s41430-017-00194. [EJCN] Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 8 Does high-carbohydrate intake lead to increased risk of obesity? A systematic review and metaanalysis. Sartorius K, Sartorius B, Madiba TE, Stefan C. BMJ Open. 2018 Feb 8;8(2):e018449. [PubMed] OBJECTIVES: The present study aimed to test the association between high and low carbohydrate diets and obesity, and second, to test the link between total carbohydrate intake (as a percentage of total energy intake) and obesity. SETTING, PARTICIPANTS AND OUTCOME MEASURES: We sought MEDLINE, PubMed and Google Scholar for observation studies published between January 1990 and December 2016 assessing an association between obesity and high-carbohydrate intake. Two independent reviewers selected candidate studies, extracted data and assessed study quality. RESULTS: The study identified 22 articles that fulfilled the inclusion and exclusion criteria and quantified an association between carbohydrate intake and obesity. The first pooled strata (highcarbohydrate versus low-carbohydrate intake) suggested a weak increased risk of obesity. The second pooled strata (increasing percentage of total carbohydrate intake in daily diet) showed a weak decreased risk of obesity. Both these pooled strata estimates were, however, not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: On the basis of the current study, it cannot be concluded that a high-carbohydrate diet or increased percentage of total energy intake in the form of carbohydrates increases the odds of obesity. A central limitation of the study was the non-standard classification of dietary intake across the studies, as well as confounders like total energy intake, activity levels, age and gender. Further studies are needed that specifically classify refined versus unrefined carbohydrate intake, as well as studies that investigate the relationship between high fat, high unrefined carbohydrate-sugar diets. PROSPERO REGISTRATION NUMBER: CRD42015023257. SPONSORSHIP: This study was partly funded through the MRC South Africa (University of KwaZulu-Natal Gastrointestinal Cancer Research Centre (GICRC)). majority (14 studies) were scored a low risk of bias. Heterogeneity was assessed via the I² statistic, and publication bias was assessed via funnel plots and Eggers test. An additional strength is that this is the first systematic review of observational studies assessing obesity risk risk on the basis of a high versus low carbohydrate intake across low income, middle income countries and high income countries. Limitations The authors acknowledged that there is a scarcity of studies in this area. Also, there was heterogeneity across studies in terms of dietary intake assessment instruments. Furthermore, there was potentially confounding variation in the classification of carbohydrate types and staple carbohydrate sources. Socioeconomic changes over the past three decades have the potential to introduce further variability and unaccounted factors. A final limitation they acknowledged was a standard one in pooled analyses: heterogeneity of design and methodological quality across studies. I would add to this that observational studies are subject to confounding from a lack of control of dependent and independent variables, unlike the case of randomized controlled trials (RCTs), which can demonstrate causation. Observational studies are limited to drawing potential associations/correlations, and generating hypotheses subject to more rigorous testing in RCTs. Comment/application Strengths This was a systematic review in addition to a meta-analysis. It‟s possible to merely conduct either one, but this was both. The authors utilized the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA),1 which is widely considered the „gold standard‟ set of criteria by which systematic reviews and meta-analyses are conducted. Methodological quality was appraised via the Risk of Bias Tool for Prevalence Studies developed by Hoy et al.2 One study had a high risk of bias, 7 scored a medium risk, and the Shown above (larger image here) are forest plots of the two main stratifications of the analysis: association between high and low carbohydrate intake and obesity (Stratum 1, left), and the association between percentage of total carbohydrate intake and obesity (Stratum 2, right). When reading the forest plots above, note that the line of no effect is the solid in the middle (at zero), and the dots to either side of this line represent the studies in the analysis. Each study is plotted somewhere in the range of showing decreased to increased Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 9 risk for the aforementioned associations. Stratum 1 showed a slight positive relationship between high-carbohydrate intake and obesity, but this did not reach statistical significance. Stratum 2 showed slightly the opposite; there was a slightly decreased risk associated with increasing percentage of carbohydrate intake. Again, this result was not strong enough to reach statistical significance. These findings – both of them being contradictory and weak/nonsignificant associations – led the authors to conclude that a high-carbohydrate diet, or increased percentage of total energy intake in the form of carbohydrates, does not increase the odds of being obese. The previous study I reviewed in this issue by Gardner et al1 who did not find a weight loss advantage to the low-carb vs. a high-carb diet was funded in part by NuSi, an organization co-founded by low-carb advocate Gary Taubes. In a similar twist of irony, the authors of the present study thanked noted low-carb activist Timothy Noakes for helping with the study‟s design. Ultimately, the present analysis does not support the low-carb-for-all campaign by the likes of Taubes and Noakes. It bears reiterating that this was an analysis of observational studies which are incapable of showing cause-and-effect. Meta-analyses of RCTs comparing low-carb versus low-fat diets are mixed, but largely in favor of low-carb diets, and this tends to be dependent on whether or not protein and total calories were equated between the diets.2 When the latter variables are equated, then the weight/fat loss & thermic advantages of the lower-carb interventions disappear.3 The present study adds to the body of data challenging the popular idea that carbs per se are the bad guy in the battle against obesity. References 1. 2. 3. Gardner CD, Trepanowski JF, Del Gobbo LC, Hauser ME, Rigdon J, Ioannidis JPA, Desai M, King AC. Effect of Low-Fat vs Low-Carbohydrate Diet on 12Month Weight Loss in Overweight Adults and the Association With Genotype Pattern or Insulin Secretion: The DIETFITS Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA. 2018 Feb 20;319(7):667-679. [PubMed] Aragon AA, et al. International society of sports nutrition position stand: diets and body composition. J Int Soc Sports Nutr. 2017 Jun 14;14:16. [PubMed] Hall KD, Guo J. Obesity Energetics: Body Weight Regulation and the Effects of Diet Composition. Gastroenterology. 2017 May;152(7):1718-1727. [PubMed] Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 10 No superior adaptations to carbohydrate periodization in elite endurance athletes. Gejl KD, Thams LB, Hansen M, Rokkedal-Lausch T, Plomgaard P, Nybo L, Larsen FJ, Cardinale DA, Jensen K, Holmberg HC, Vissing K, Ørtenblad N. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2017 Dec;49(12):2486-2497 [PubMed] PURPOSE: The present study investigated the effects of periodic carbohydrate (CHO) restriction on endurance performance and metabolic markers in elite endurance athletes. METHODS: Twenty-six male elite endurance athletes (maximal oxygen consumption (V˙O2max), 65.0 mL O2·kg·min) completed 4 wk of regular endurance training while being matched and randomized into two groups training with (low) or without (high) CHO manipulation 3 d·wk. The CHO manipulation days consisted of a 1-h highintensity bike session in the morning, recovery for 7 h while consuming isocaloric diets containing either high CHO (414 ± 2.4 g) or low CHO (79.5 ± 1.0 g), and a 2-h moderate bike session in the afternoon with or without CHO. V˙O2max, maximal fat oxidation, and power output during a 30-min time trial (TT) were determined before and after the training period. The TT was undertaken after 90 min of intermittent exercise with CHO provision before the training period and both CHO and placebo after the training period. Muscle biopsies were analyzed for glycogen, citrate synthase (CS) and β-hydroxyacyl-coenzyme A dehydrogenase (HAD) activity, carnitine palmitoyltransferase (CPT1b), and phosphorylated acetyl-CoA carboxylase (pACC). RESULTS: The training effects were similar in both groups for all parameters. On average, V˙O2max and power output during the 30-min TT increased by 5% ± 1% (P < 0.05) and TT performance was similar after CHO and placebo during the preload phase. Training promoted overall increases in glycogen content (18% ± 5%), CS activity (11% ± 5%), and pACC (38% ± 19%; P < 0.05) with no differences between groups. HAD activity and CPT1b protein content remained unchanged. CONCLUSIONS: Superimposing periodic CHO restriction to 4 wk of regular endurance training had no superior effects on performance and muscle adaptations in elite endurance athletes. SPONSORSHIP: This study was supported financially by Team Danmark, The Danish Ministry of Culture and The Swedish National Centre for Research in Sports. intensity due to different glycogen levels,3 and exercise tests with short duration (at or less than 1 hr).4-8 Diets in both groups were calorically and macronutritionally matched in order to rule out the confounding effects of different intakes between groups. To mimic actual race conditions and maximize performance, subjects consumed identical bodyweight-standardized meals on test days (5.7 kcal/kg consisting of 65% carbohydrate, 14% protein and 21% fat), every second hour from 7 AM until 60 mins prior to starting the test. This is the first study to collect muscle biopsies to assess myocellular responses in elite endurance athletes. Limitations This study is methodologically solid and very diligent in its design (especially its respect for real-world conditions), so its limitations are the usual/generic suspects, and the following are somewhat of a stretch, given the greater limitations of the existing studies on this topic. The number of subjects was relatively small (26), but not comparatively small in the larger picture of controlled interventions on elite athletes. The duration was relatively short (4 weeks), but not short compared to the body of studies on this topic in elite athletes which typically don‟t exceed 3 weeks. The results seen in this study could potentially be limited to athletes engaged in a similar volume of training (16 hrs [12 to 20 hrs] of training per week (triathletes averaged 17 hrs [14-20 hrs]; road cyclists avgeraged 14 hrs [12-17 hrs]). Questions still remain as to the effect of carbohydrate periodization when exercise testing exceeds the 2 hours imposed in the present study – but once again, the majority of studies on this topic have employed tests that are substantially shorter than 2 hours. Comment/application Strengths This study helps to fill in the scarcity of studies on the performance effects of “training low” (periodically restricting carbohydrate intake) on exercise performance in elite endurance athletes undergoing protocols that reflect realworld race conditions. This study alleviates the shortcomings of previous research on this topic including shorter trial durations, fasted exercise testing,1 and the use of subjects who are only moderately trained,2 differences in training Shown above (larger image here) is the carbohydrate periodization scheme designed to execute the high intensity training sessions with ample glycogen available, but undergo Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 11 the less intense training sessions with periodic carbohydrate restriction. However, despite the carefully planned manipulation of carbohydrate intake to achieve the aforementioned objectives (3 days per week - MWF, carbohydrate intake was manipulated in the “train low” group), this failed to improve the maximal power output during a 30-minute time trial preceded by 90-minutes of intermittent exercise compared to a non-periodized carbohydrate intake. Increases in glycogen content citrate synthase activity (a pace-setting enzyme in the initial step of energy production in the Krebs cycle), and phosphorylated acetyl-CoA carboxylase (a enzyme involved in fatty acid metabolism) were not significantly different between groups. The activity of β-hydroxyacyl-coenzyme A dehydrogenase and carnitine palmitoyltransferase (enzymes involved with fatty acid oxidation) were unaffected through the trial. The authors thus arrived at the following conclusions: In 4 weeks of endurance training in elite athletes, employing either periodic carbohydrate restriction or a carb-enriched diet, resulted in similar exercise performance. Endurance performance, VO2max, glycogen availability and markers of mitochondrial adaptations all increased to the same extent with high and periodically low CHO availability. Importantly, these findings occurred under isocaloric/isomacronutritional intakes between groups. The lack of group differences could be due to the modest glycogen depletion in the Low group after the CHO manipulation, suggesting that more aggressive manipulation protocols may be necessary to exploit the ergogenic possibility of carbohydrate periodization in elite endurance athletes. 3. Yeo WK, Paton CD, Garnham AP, Burke LM, Carey AL, Hawley JA. Skeletal muscle adaptation and performance responses to once a day versus twice every second day endurance training regimens. J Appl Physiol (1985). 2008; 105(5):1462-70. [PubMed] 4. Burke LM, Ross ML, Garvican-Lewis LA et al. Low Carbohydrate, High Fat diet impairs exercise economy and negates the performance benefit from intensified training in elite race walkers. J Physiol. 2017 May 1;595(9):2785-2807. [PubMed] 5. Cochran AJ, Myslik F, MacInnis MJ, Percival ME, Bishop D, Tarnopolsky MA, Gibala MJ. Manipulating carbohydrate availability between twice-daily sessions of highintensity interval training over 2 weeks improves time-trial performance. Int J Sports Nutr Exerc Metab. 2015; 25:463-70. [PubMed] 6. Van Proeyen K, Szlufcik K, Nielens H et al. Training in the fasted state improves glucose tolerance during fatrich diet. J Physiol. 2010; 588(Pt 21):4289-302. [PubMed] 7. Morton JP, Croft L, Bartlett JD et al. Reduced carbohydrate availability does not modulate traininginduced heat shock protein adaptations but does upregulate oxidative enzyme activity in human skeletal muscle. J Appl Physiol (1985). 2009; 106(5):1513-21. [PubMed] 8. Hansen AK, Fischer CP, Plomgaard P, Andersen JL, Saltin B, Pedersen BK. Skeletal muscle adaptation: training twice every second day vs. training once daily. J Appl Physiol (1985). 2005; 98(1):93-9. [PubMed] Although still scarce, the research evidence to date indicates that highly trained endurance athletes are less responsive to a “train low, compete high” protocol. References 1. Hulston CJ, Venables MC, Mann CH, Martin C, Philp A, Baar K, Jeukendrup AE. Training with low muscle glycogen enhances fat metabolism in well-trained cyclists. ed Sci Sports Exerc. 2010 Nov;42(11):2046-55. [PubMed] 2. Marquet LA, Brisswalter J, Louis J, Tiollier E, Burke LM, Hawley JA, Hausswirth C. Enhanced endurance performance by periodization of carbohydrate intake: "sleep low" strategy. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2016 Apr;48(4):663-72. [PubMed] Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 12 Given this convergent range of total daily protein dosing to maximize muscle growth, along with the per-meal doses to Behind the paper: clearing up protein distribution concerns. By Alan Aragon _________________________________________________________________ maximize MPS, it makes sense to frame the total daily protein guideline as 1.6 to 2.2 g/kg. It makes sense for the per-meal dosing range to begin at the Morton et al-derived figure of 0.4 g/kg, and multiplying this over 4 meals would conveniently arrive at the meta-analytical figure of 1.6 g/kg. An upper end for this range is most logically based on splitting up 2.2 g/kg per day into 4 meals at 0.55 g/kg. Inside scoop: I wanted to round this up to 0.6 g/kg in the paper, but one of the peer reviewers was highly skeptical of the higher ranges, so Brad and I opted to not push our luck. In practice and in presentations, I‟ll likely issue the upper-end recommendation of 0.6 g/kg since it bugs me to speak in hundredths of a gram. But, muh huge protein intake per day Background The above screenshot is of a freshly published review paper by Brad Schoenfeld and I (full text available here),1 which has garnered a viral level of interest. With as much praise as it has received, there were questions raised. My aim is to cover the most frequently raised points of concern. With that said, bear in mind that we ultimately concluded the following: “It is therefore a relatively simple and elegant solution to consume protein at a target intake of 0.4 g/kg/meal across a minimum of four meals in order to reach a minimum of 1.6 g/kg/day – if indeed the primary goal is to build muscle. Using the upper CI daily intake of 2.2 g/kg/day over the same four meals would necessitate a maximum of 0.55 g/kg/meal.” The meat behind the above recommendation is rooted in several key pieces of research. The aggregate findings by Morton et al2 led them to conclude that 0.4 g/kg is the permeal protein dose that maximally stimulates muscle protein synthesis (MPS). Moore et al3 reported that maximizing MPS in some older individuals can require up to 0.6 g/kg. Our recent systematic review/meta-analysis on protein supplementation and resistance training adaptations,4 which is the most comprehensive of its kind to date, found that muscular size and strength gains were maximally attained in non-dieting athletes at 1.62 g/kg/day. The upper 95% confidence interval (CI) was 2.2 g/kg/day. Coincidentally, Bandegan et al5 also reported an upper CI of 2.2 g/kg/day in a sample of bodybuilders, via the indicator amino acid oxidation technique. Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 I received some dissent online that our upper end recommendation of total daily protein dosing (2.2 g/kg) might not be “the max” since doses beyond this have not been examined. My response to this challenge was presenting recent research by Antonio et al,6 who compared protein dosed at 2.3 vs 3.4 g/kg over an 8-week period in resistancetrained subjects. Both groups gained the same amount of fatfree mass (1.5 kg). This was despite the significantly greater protein and kcal intake in the higher-protein group. Therefore, at least in non-dieting, drug-free trainees, exceeding 2.2 g/kg does not appear to further enhance muscle growth. This is not to dismiss the potential benefits on satiety/hunger control or muscle retention in dieting athletes with amounts exceeding 2.2 g/kg. In last month‟s AARR issue, I reviewed a case study of high-level natural bodybuilders, and those with the higher placings had a protein intake ranging 2.7-3.3 g/kg.7 But, muh huge protein intake per meal Next were concerns raised by those involved with intermittent fasting (IF), who generally were worried or defensive about their consumption of less than 4 protein feedings per day (in many cases total daily protein was consumed in 1-2 meals per day with roughly 70-100 g protein per meal. The questions were along the lines of, “Why am I still making gains if you‟re saying I need to eat 4 meals?” or “Are you saying that half of the protein in my meals is going to waste or getting oxidized?” My response to these questions was mainly a correction of a misperceived message. Specifically, Brad and I never claimed that muscular gain or maintenance could not be achieved on low frequency or less spread-out distribution of protein feedings. Of course gains can be made, and of course muscle can be maintained on all of the IF variants. However, per the current evidence, it does [Back to Contents] Page 13 not appear that rates of muscle gain can be maximized by consuming your day‟s protein in 1-2 meals. Acute (short-term) data point to the superior anabolic response of 4 feedings compared to 2 or 8.8,9 Longitudinal studies systematically comparing within-day protein feeding frequency thresholds are painfully lacking. A glaring scarcity is the comparison of 3 meals per day versus higher frequencies in designs that include resistance training. This is why I still hesitate to say with ironclad certainty that 3 protein feedings would be measurably inferior to 4 for the purpose of gaining muscle, as long as the daily total is optimized. Nevertheless, as the research evidence stands currently, 4 feedings appears to have the most support. But, muh huge steak, bro What about huge protein meals with a slow-digesting food source like steak? Can you maximize muscle growth with 1-2 giant steak bombs that amount to your total daily protein target? There are a couple of studies that challenge this assumption. Back in 2009, Symons et al10 used lean beef to compare the resting/non-exercising MPS response of 30 g protein with 90 g protein, and no difference between doses was detected. Recently (2016), Kim et al11 found an equal MPS increase via 40 and 70 g via ground beef within a mixed meal in both the post-exercise and resting state. maximizing rates of muscle gain. They are more applicable to competitive athletes and athletes toward the advanced end of the spectrum, pushing the limits of their potential. Recreational trainees at the beginning or intermediate level seeking to generally improve body composition (or maintain improvements in body composition) don‟t need to burden themselves with the details of our review paper. While these recommendations can be helpful to keep in mind for the purpose of optimization, a far greater focus should be placed on daily macronutrient totals. Let‟s not forget that this is two researcher/practitioners‟ interpretation of the evidence. It‟s not universal or set in stone. Individual responses, goals, and circumstances are always the overriding factors when implementing research data. References Another misguided concern is when recreational trainees read our protein distribution paper and start freaking out that they‟re not following the exact protocol outlined in the concluding recommendations. It‟s easy to overlook that these recommendations are specifically for the primary goal of 1. Schoenfeld BJ, Aragon AA. How much muscle can the body use in a single meal for muscle-building? Implications for daily protein distribution. J Int Soc Sports Nutr (2018) 15:10 https://doi.org/10.1186/s12970018-0215-1 [JISSN] 2. Morton RW, McGlory C, Phillips SM. Nutritional interventions to augment resistance training-induced skeletal muscle hypertrophy. Front Physiol. 2015 Sep 3;6:245. [PubMed] 3. Moore DR, Churchward-Venne TA, Witard O, Breen L, Burd NA, Tipton KD, Phillips SM. Protein ingestion to stimulate myofibrillar protein synthesis requires greater relative protein intakes in healthy older versus younger men. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2015;70(1):57–62. [PubMed] 4. Morton RW, Murphy KT, McKellar SR, Schoenfeld BJ, Henselmans M, Helms E, Aragon AA, Devries MC, Banfield L, Krieger JW, Phillips SM. A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of the effect of protein supplementation on resistance training-induced gains in muscle mass and strength in healthy adults. Br J Sports Med. 2017 Jul 11. pii: bjsports-2017-097608. [PubMed] 5. Bandegan A, Courtney-Martin G, Rafii M, Pencharz PB, Lemon PW. Indicator amino acid-derived estimate of dietary protein requirement for male bodybuilders on a nontraining day is several-fold greater than the current recommended dietary allowance. J Nutr. 2017;147(5):850–7. [PubMed] 6. Antonio J, Ellerbroek A, Silver T, Orris S, Scheiner M, Gonzalez A, Peacock CA. A high protein diet (3.4 g/kg/d) combined with a heavy resistance training program improves body composition in healthy trained men and women--a follow-up investigation. J Int Soc Sports Nutr. 2015 Oct 20;12:39. [PubMed] Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] A potential issue is the lack of assessment of muscle protein breakdown (MPB) in the aforementioned research. However, MPB‟s role in muscle anabolism is minor in comparison to MPS, especially in eucaloric (caloric maintenance) and hypercaloric conditions. Changes in MPS have been reported to be 4-5 times greater than MPB in response to stimuli such as training and feeding.12 Furthermore, a very recent review by Tipton et al13 stated that, “Taken together, at least until we accumulate more information on the role of degradation of various proteins in muscle remodeling, nutrition recommendations to enhance training adaptations most likely should focus primarily on the response of MPS.” Populations in context I was also asked whether the recommendations of our paper apply to women. I responded by citing our recent metaanalysis3 reporting that, “Based on limited data we observed no overtly apparent sex-based differences but acknowledge that far less work has been done in women than men.” Page 14 7. Chappel AJ, et al. Nutritional strategies of high level natural bodybuilders during competition preparation. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition (2018) 15:4 DOI 10.1186/s12970-018-0209-z [JISSN] 8. Areta JL, Burke LM, Ross ML, Camera DM, West DW, Broad EM, Jeacocke NA, Moore DR, Stellingwerff T, Phillips SM, Hawley JA, Coffey VG. Timing and distribution of protein ingestion during prolonged recovery from resistance exercise alters myofibrillar protein synthesis. J Physiol. 2013;591(Pt 9):2319–31. [PubMed] 9. Moore DR, Areta J, Coffey VG, Stellingwerff T, Phillips SM, Burke LM, Cleroux M, Godin JP, Hawley JA. Daytime pattern of post-exercise protein intake affects whole-body protein turnover in resistance-trained males. Nutr Metab (Lond). 2012;9(1):91. -7075-9-91. [PubMed] 10. Symons TB, Sheffield-Moore M, Wolfe RR, PaddonJones D. A moderate serving of high-quality protein maximally stimulates skeletal muscle protein synthesis in young and elderly subjects. J Am Diet Assoc. 2009 Sep;109(9):1582-6. [PubMed] 11. Kim IY, Schutzler S, Schrader A, Spencer HJ, Azhar G, Ferrando AA, Wolfe RR. The anabolic response to a meal containing different amounts of protein is not limited by the maximal stimulation of protein synthesis in healthy young adults. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab. 2016;310(1):E73–80. [PubMed] 12. Morton RW, McGlory C, Phillips SM. Nutritional interventions to augment resistance training-induced skeletal muscle hypertrophy. ront Physiol. 2015 Sep 3;6:245. [PubMed] 13. Tipton KD, Hamilton DL, Gallagher IJ2. Assessing the Role of Muscle Protein Breakdown in Response to Nutrition and Exercise in Humans. Format: AbstractSend to Sports Med. 2018 Mar;48(Suppl 1):5364. [PubMed] Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 15 competition. What were the biggest mistakes you made as a rookie competitor either before, during, and/or after prep? Half-natural interview with pro natural bodybuilder Alberto Nunez. By Alan Aragon _________________________________________________ Hey Alberto, first off, thanks very much for doing this interview. I consider you one of the legends in the sport of natty bodybuilding, so this is really an honor. With that said, there are still some people who don't even "FATHER FLEX" - so let's kick this off with a bit of self-intro. How did you get started in bodybuilding, and what would you cite as your proudest accomplishments, either in or outside of competition? "Started from the bottom now we're here" Started in the living room with some ankle weights, now we on the AARR! In all seriousness, it above all sports it was my first true passion. While it was a journey that started in 1999 as recreational bro, I quickly took it too far and by 2007 I was a natty pro bro. I had a knack for it, but I also spent the majority of my early 20's partying less than I do now. In hindsight, it was certainly worth it I feel. When I stop and reflect on everything that has happened between then and now a few key moments come to mind. I won my natural pro card during a time when they weren't found at the bottom of a Craker Jack box back in 2008. Then comes the formation of 3DMJ, and through that platform having the chance to be an ambassador for drug-free bodybuilding. Through all that of course, FATHER FLEX is still my "Ron Mexico" when it's appropriate. A scotch kinda guy eh! Of course, after 18 years of training, you are bound to have a few bloopers to add to the reel. To start I think as with many ambitious young gym rats I was often in a rush. Creaky joints and getting way too fat in my early 20s was my trademark. So much of this could have been solved had I just outsourced my bodybuilding early on, but like many newbs, I thought I knew more than I actually did. Looking back now I totally had the right people around me, and I can only imagine where I would be today had I reached out for help. Part of my rationale was thinking that I would learn more by just simply going through the ropes on my own. In an industry that was even wilder a decade ago, it can be very easy to put the wrong information into play. Even today it is a little frustrating to think back because I had access to the likes of Dr. Mel Siff, Dr. Joe Klemczewksi, and yes even you dude. It was a different time, and it wasn't easy to find the good guys of the fitness world, but I had. I just wasn't open to getting the right help because it was not a part of the culture yet. This mistake cost me valuable time before, during, and after preps. I agree that good coaches are crucial to preventing a lot of the error that comes with the trial. Let's talk about genetics versus "out-working." People can do an image search on your name and run into some really crazy conditioning pics. You mentioned making the mistake of getting too fat in your early 20's... How has your bodyweight fluctuated or changed since then? What's your off-season vs contest weight? Another thing I'm curious about is how you'd rate yourself along the spectrum of gifted versus crappy genetics for getting lean. Ron Mexico? That's amazing, as I closely identify with Ron Burgundy. My next question is about your journey through Certainly not good enough that I could just lift some weight sign-up for a show and blow the competition away. I needed some serious polishing, but overall I had a pretty decent base. I was always active and played every sport I could growing up, and this certainly contributed to my base. Growing up I would hear that Iggy Pop was my doppelgänger because I was just that skinny, veiny, and see through. My dad looked like a mini Mike Tyson despite having only lifted weights briefly in his 30s. I certainly got his body fat set point, but not his size. I mostly did the skinny guy sports growing up and the 100-400 meter races were my jam. During my freshman year of college, I had a foot injury that would not heal, and this injury leads me to the weight room. More than ever before got I got into the bodybuilding culture and decided to drop everything else. The current trend of looking like an underwear model on testosterone replacement therapy was not in yet. Guys such as Branch Warren, Johnny Jackson, and Ronnie Coleman were in and I wanted to mimic that. Over Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 16 the next three years, I went from 130lbs to roughly 230240lbs because I thought was the right thing to do. As with many guys in their early twenties I gave myself too much credit and figured I could at least make it 80% of the way without the use of anabolic. That was a rude awaking, to say the least, and since 2006 I have seen a single day over 200lbs. These days I do most of my deep offseason work in the 185195lb range and compete in the low 160s. By no means would I say I am from Mars genetically, but I am very fortunate in that my body doesn't totally hate me. I can easily say that fat loss is my thing, but I feel that it‟s such an outlier trait that the shape and muscle mass I do have is often overlooked. Upon reflecting, I would say I got it pretty good genetically, but man educating myself on the science behind sets, reps, and protein took me from a standout gym bro to an elite level natural bodybuilder. I have eyes on me now and I like that I can be an ambassador of sorts for the evidencebased movement. I look the part, but my posse is not who you would assume. I'm here to pervert the masses. I enjoy the idea of educating the masses, but what the heck, might as well join your cause and pervert them too. Let talk for a minute about the process pf contest dieting - from a psychological angle. There are plenty of well-known saboteurs of prep, not the least of which are hunger & temptation & lapses in resolve. Do you have a special "bag of tricks" or set of go-to psychological tactics for dieting process that you feel keeps you more focused, motivated, and on track? Being able to disconnect from how you feel at times is imperative to being a successful athlete in any sport I feel. At a certain point of a contest prep, almost everything in your life feels a little wrong, and everything in your DNA is telling you to go finish that box of cereal. You plain and simply can't trust your emotions or the way you feel during certain legs of the process. You need to make sure your system allows you to stay as objective as possible. It can come in the form of a coach, or in my case just collecting as much data as I possibly can each week. The important decision should be made at a designated point and time, and while sifting through the last batch of data. This is how my system works, and because of this whatever I might be feeling while I am laying in bed one day gazing at my ceiling in hunger doesn't matter. By removing the ability to make decision on the fly you can prevent these emotional errors from ever taking place. I take my time to make the decisions for the week, and upon putting them in play there is no more negotiating. Damn it, man, no wonder people think bodybuilders are wack jobs. obviously obsessive but effective maneuver) is how some guys commit to not EVER eating meals out during prep. This reminds me of the infamous 6 foods that work (video clip here). Do you have your own "6 foods" so-to-speak, or are you more flexible and macro-based? How far do you take the allowance or avoidance of foods/dishes outside of the your competition menu? How do you balance or manage rigid versus flexible dieting in this case? Oh man, I have been that dude, but thankfully it was only long enough to reap some of the benefits and get out! I have been the orthorexic bodybuilder with the gallon jug sidekick. What I got out of being that "robot" is a boost to my willpower, but ironically enough the physique didn't see as much of an upgrade despite. It did teach me to grind, sacrifice, and commit, however, the major downfall is that all my efforts were going into the wrong variables. Eventually, I learned the rules of the game according to science rather than from the big guy at my gym. The transition was a complicated one because I was breaking so many rules that at some point were non-negotiable to me. I understood the variables at play, but imagine Eric Helms' nutritional pyramids looking like some sort of Picasso piece. These days I even enjoy alcohol in moderation through most of my contest prep diet. My food selection and meal frequency can vary immensely each week, but of course, all this takes place within my macronutrient targets. If I am over four weeks out from a show I can still eat out with friends when the opportunity allows. A much less experience physique athlete could probably use a bit more rigidness during their first few contest prep diets. Mostly because it takes some time to learn the rules of the game, and be able to make the right calls on the fly. Eventually, you do want to improve how dynamic you can be with your contest prep, but this will take some time. This will not only help you integrate this sport into the rest of your life, but greatly improve your bottom line. Imagine a heavy leg day is coming right up, and I feel a bit behind the recovery curve, I can perhaps use 110 grams of my daily carb intake rather than my usual 40-50 grams preworkout carbs. Or I can even wait another day and increase my likeliness of having a good training session. Being a pliable and educated physique athlete is important if you want to be able to maximize your efforts. If the 24-year-old version of myself could see me now he would choke on his asparagus, to be honest. To be fair, most of the guys I've seen do well in contests go into "robot" or "cyborg" mode - especially if they are going solo without a coach during prep. What's interesting (and kind of an Very interesting to see that you've evolved from rigid to flexible AND you've been getting better results. This makes sense, given the 'experience gainz' you've made, and as you said, a keener sense of how better decisions can be made on the fly. Speaking of an evolution of intake, I believe it was Eric Helms who Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 17 mentioned that you've tried the full gamut of low-carb/high-fat to high-carb/low-fat, and ended up settling on the latter. Can you describe your experiences with trial-and-error of different proportions of carbs & fat in the diet & how they impacted your physique during prep? I'm interested in this question because the answers I get from competitors are all over the map, but I know that you are much more astute and methodical with your approach than the typical competitor who often chooses his favorite approach based on emotion & bias rather than data/results. A phenomenon that I find very intriguing and one that is near and dear to my heart. As Eric has mentioned, I have experienced this personally. Some people do better on lowcarb/high-fat diets and some (such as myself) do better on high-carb/low fat. I see this almost every day with some my athletes, but I got to live through my own memorable lowcarb/high fat experience which I still remember so vividly. This was during my first contest prep diet back in 2007 when there was still some tug-of-war as to who was right: the high carb and nearly fat-free generation of the 80‟s…. or the 90s anti-carbohydrate craze. By no means was I on a ketogenic diet, but my fat was hovering around 35-40% of my total caloric intake, which certainly came at the cost of precious carbs. I have some athletes with weekly refeeds who actually do well around this range. In my case, even with bi-weekly refeeds… fat loss was not very good outside of the first month. After the first-week… my training suffered. I kept going with it because I figured this was how a prep was supposed to feel. I ended up at what I would call 10-11% body fat, but so watery and stringy that it looked more like 13%. Hormonally, I was a wreck through most of the prep (girlfriend at the time was not happy) and it took me what seemed like forever to feel normal again. The following year, I went on a diet that had my fat at about 20-25% of my total calories. It was night and day. I felt as amazing as you can while dieting for months on end both in and out of the gym. Fat loss was predictable, sex-drive stayed put, and I went from looking decent to way ahead of my time. The real kicker is that my caloric intake on both diets were almost identical, but I did about half the cardio on the high-carb/low-fat diet. Over the years, I have pulled my fat intake even lower during the final weeks and it‟s led to more of the same good stuff. To be honest, very few physique athletes need their fat intake to be above 35% of their total calories. I mean, it makes sense considering what substrates fuel most bodybuilder-type workouts. Based on what I have seen through my athletes, it doesn‟t really matter with about two-thirds of athletes… you can have them roam between 20-30 percent of their calories coming from fat. Then the last third can be split into two camps, where some athletes do better with their fat intake Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 over 30% of total calories the whole way, and a batch of weirdos (like myself) whom would much rather stay below 20% throughout the whole prep. Putting either 15% towards the wrong substrate can be the difference between looking average and standing out… as I found out myself. I hope that, over time, there is more research in regards to individual responses of fat to carb distribution within a high protein diet. Final say, I lost weight on both diets, and that is what is most important. However, a more “Berto-friendly” version of that intake gave me that 10% that I needed… allowing me to have the will to do what it takes as an athlete. I care less for sweets than I do for savory fatty foods even deep into my hypoglycemic stages of a contest prep. Mind if we throw some numbers around? Over the years, I've read about your infamous carb intakes that made people jealous, and flat-out angered carbophobes. What are your typical offseason grams of P/C/F offseason versus prep? How do you personally "non-linear-ize" your carb intake during prep -are carb-ups/refeeds more planned, or are they autoregulated? Back in the early 2000's, Lyle had a major influence on popularizing systematic refeeds. Many have had success with UD2-style refeeds, which are rather substantial. Some folks take a more subtle approach to carb cycling during prep, while a minority don't cycle carbs at all. Would love to hear the approach you personally use. To be honest, off-season isn‟t too interesting. For the most part, I only aim for two definite targets. 1) I try to have at least five protein feedings throughout the day and 2) I do my best to keep my dietary fat below the century mark (100g per day). I enjoy carbohydrates as I please, however, it‟s quite auto-regulated based on how flat/full I am feeling. When I think about it, it‟s quite hilarious that I can flex my muscles and decide how much food (more or less and coming mostly from carbs) that I need in the next few hours. Once contest prep rolls around, I usually start off with five days at 400 grams of carbs and two days at 600 grams of carbs. Refeeds/high carb days are always a 48-hour event, at the minimum. Protein is steady at about 200 grams per day while dietary fat stays around 50-60 grams. I try to have the high days in sync with training to help manage training fatigue more efficiently. And I always plan for one of the high days to fall on a full rest day. As I get into the deeper stages of prep, I might have to dip into the lower 300 carbohydrate range, but this usually only lasts for about 4-5 weeks. At this point, I bring my dietary fat down to 10-12% of my total calories. When this happens, I‟ll limit my low days to about 3-4 times a week and commit to 72-96 hour refeed periods. I not only feel that this method helps preserve muscle better by aiding recovery when it's most “spotty”, but if also controls [Back to Contents] Page 18 the rate at which I mobilize the remaining fat stores. I can only speak from experience, but it‟s almost as if you can stimulate fat loss away during that last leg of prep. The thermic effect of recovery, if you will. When you do throw a little extra at the system, it almost behaves like an NFL rookie with their first paycheck. It's a win-win in that your system gets to patch up some hormonal dents, training picks up, and you often come back a little tighter before starting the next string of low days. Stopping to refeed or making the decision to run a full diet break can almost seem counterintuitive to a bodybuilder with a deadline. However, the less invasive you can make a prep.... the more your body will work with you in achieving the ridiculous condom filled with walnuts look. A contest prep without weekly refeed days seems as sensical as a training split without off days from training. Love that NFL rookie analogy (not to mention the condom filled with walnuts visual), I think you have a creative writing career ahead of you once this iron game loses steam … Last question to close this out. If you could speak to your rookie self who just got started in the game of bodybuilding competition -- and you could only give ONE piece of advice -- what would that be? The more playtime you get, the better you will be! Stay healthy. Your biggest droughts will not come from small errors in a fundamentally sound strategy, rather from working around pain or full-on layoffs due to injuries. _________________________________________________ Alberto Nuñez first stepped on a competitive stage in 2007, and then the very next year he earned his pro status in virtually every major natural organization. While Alberto Nunez is relatively new to the sport of competitive bodybuilding he has played a vital role in promoting the natural movement. His contributions as a coach, athlete, and author have helped propel some of the growth the sport has seen over the last decade. Despite all this success, Nuñez claims his most successful accolade comes in the fact that he gets to be called Coach Nuñez. “My biggest thrill is that I was lucky enough to be one of the founders of Team 3DMJ. I can honestly say we as a team have changed this sport we love for the better. Every day I am thankful that I get to be part of this movement, alongside Coach Helms, Loomis, Alberts and Valdez.” 3DMJ: http://3dmusclejourney.com/about/alberto-nunez/ Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/nunez3dmj/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/WNBF.BERTO Snapchat: https://www.snapchat.com/add/nunez3dmj Twitter: https://twitter.com/nunez3dmj Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 19 “Desire reveals design, and design reveals destiny.” – John Eldridge If you have any questions, comments, suggestions, bones of contention, cheers, jeers, guest articles you‟d like to submit for consideration, send it over to support@alanaragon.com. Alan Aragon’s Research Review – February 2018 [Back to Contents] Page 20
0
You can add this document to your study collection(s)
Sign in Available only to authorized usersYou can add this document to your saved list
Sign in Available only to authorized users(For complaints, use another form )