Uploaded by Saiful Islam

Assignment 2 2496966 1548677163

advertisement
1
Effective and clear communication between people is of paramount importance. It is noticed that
the communication between men and women sometimes ends in frustration, misunderstanding,
quarrels and conflicts. The communication practices of men and women are similar, but there are
fundamental differences in the way each gender interprets the message which leads to difficulty
and frustration. Men and women are also frustrated with each other’s communication behaviours
due to a lack of clear and effective communication, differences in communication styles, and
different expectations and purposes of communication.
Every behaviour is a form of communication. Communication comprises a broad spectrum of
behaviour ranging from verbal communication to nonverbal, emotional cues, body language and
even silence. "Non-verbal communication channel is necessary where noise or physical distance
prevents effective verbal exchanges and it includes facial gestures, voice intonation, physical
distance, and even silence (McShane, Tasa, Steen, 2021)." In simple terms, communication is the
process by which we exchange ideas and information. For communication to be effective, the
conveyer transmits ideas and information in such a way that it is easy for the receiver to interpret
and understand it clearly. "Miscommunication reflects instances where the meaning attributed to
an intentional message by the receiver is different than that intended by the sender (Henningsen,
2004)." When the misunderstandings are not corrected, the interaction between the speaker and
the listener ends up in miscommunication.
The primary reason for having difficulty in communication between men and women is that each
gender fundamentally interprets each other's messages differently (Tennen, 1990) Due to this
misinterpretation lack of clear and effective communication arises which leads to frustration in
each other's behaviour. We primarily use language to communicate and convey ideas. Language
itself is a system of arbitrary signs, but it gives us a common ground for understanding and
interpreting a shared mental imagery and mental model. For example, the word "CAT" helps
give us a shared mental imagery of an animal. But when it comes to expressing complex ideas,
conceptualizing and sharing similar mental models is less viable and hence less effective
exchange of ideas. Misunderstanding arises from the different interpretations of the same
message or idea. Furthermore, interpreting non-verbal communication correctly is much harder.
Nonverbal communication is often subtle and hard to decipher as it is ambiguous but
communicates a great deal of information in face-to-face conversation which the conveyer
2
transmits unconsciously (McShane, Tasa, Steen, 2021)." Furthermore, the difficulty increases
when men and women have different expectations during communication and there are
differences in communication styles.
"Men and women talk differently"(Locke, 2011). Academic research on communication
differences across genders has shown that men and women differ in communication
characteristics and traits (Merchant, 2012). Men are assertive in their communication and the
tone of voice is to advise and exchange information efficiently. Men "frequently depict
themselves as a masterful person, a man who stands up for himself, gets away with things, is not
to be toyed with or taken for granted, and who emerges from every contest a winner – possibly
even a hero."(Locke, 2011) This perception of men is reflected in their communication styles as
"for most men, talk is primarily a means to preserve independence and negotiate and maintain
status in a hierarchical social order "(Tannen, 1990) which most women finds frustrating. By
contrast, women are polite and expressive in their conversation as they communicate to connect
socially and build relationship as "women’s stories feature people and family, and they typically
include intimate details about others and themselves."(Locke, 2011). “For most women, the
language of conversation is primarily a language of rapport: a way of establishing and
negotiating relationships."(Tannen, 1990)
Men and Women have different expectations during communication. This is because each
gender has a different view of the purpose of the conversation. Women offer solutions by
engaging in affectionate behaviour and deal with problems by sharing their feelings and
emotional concerns. "Females appear to engage in more rapport building behaviours such as
encouragement, reassurance, lowered dominance and positive talk and may also exhibit more
affective behaviours such as concern, empathy and sympathy (Jefferson, Bloor, Birks, Hewitt,
Bland, 2013)." Women also deal with problems by talking about them and sharing their feelings
with others. Whereas men focus on advice and facts to deal with their problems. Receiving
affection and sympathy can be frustrating to men as they seek facts and immediate solutions as
"men’s stories often focus on action and conflict."(Locke, 2011) Whereas for women receiving
advice is frustrating as they seek to match their experiences with someone who can understand
them rather than someone exerting power and dominance.
3
In conclusion, due to difficulty in interpreting each other's message correctly, differences in
communication styles and traits and different expectations and purposes of engagement in a
conversation, men and women are sometimes frustrated with each other’s communication
behaviours.
4
References cited
Henningsen, D.D. (2004). Flirting with Meaning: An Examination of Miscommunication in
Flirting Interactions. Sex Roles 50.
Jefferson, L., Bloor, K., Birks, Y., Hewitt, C., Bland, M. (2013). Effect of physicians’ gender on
communication and consultation length: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of
health services research & policy, 18(4), 242–248. https://doi.org/10.1177/1355819613486465
Locke, J.L. (2011). Duels and duets : why men and women talk so differently. Cambridge
University Press, New York.
McShane, S., Tasa, K., Steen, S.L. (2021). Canadian Organizational Behavior (Eleventh
Edition). McGraw-Hill Ryerson.
Tannen, D. (1990). You Just Don’t Understand: Women and Men in Conversation. Ballantine
Books, New York.
Download