WT/TPR/M/372 13 August 2018 (18-5078) Page: 1/56 Trade Policy Review Body 12 and 14 June 2018 TRADE POLICY REVIEW COLOMBIA MINUTES OF THE MEETING Chairperson: H.E. Mr Eloi Laourou (Benin) CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTORY REMARKS BY THE CHAIRPERSON ....................................................... 2 2 OPENING STATEMENT BY THE REPRESENTATIVE OF COLOMBIA .................................. 4 3 STATEMENT BY THE DISCUSSANT .............................................................................. 10 4 STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS ........................................................................................ 12 5 REPLIES BY THE REPRESENTATIVE OF COLOMBIA AND ADDITIONAL COMMENTS..................................................................................................................... 48 6 CONCLUDING REMARKS BY THE CHAIRPERSON ......................................................... 55 Note: Advance written questions and additional questions by WTO Members, and the replies provided by Colombia are reproduced in document WT/TPR/M/372/Add.1 and will be available online at http://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/tpr_e/tp_rep_e.htm. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia -21 INTRODUCTORY REMARKS BY THE CHAIRPERSON 1.1. The fifth Trade Policy Review of Colombia was held on 12 and 14 June 2018. The Chairperson, H.E. Mr Eloi Laourou (Benin), welcomed the delegation of Colombia, headed by Mrs. Olga Lucía Lozano, Vice Minister of Foreign Trade; the rest of the delegation; and the discussant, H.E. Ambassador José Luis Cancela (Uruguay). 1.2. The Chairperson recalled the purpose of the Trade Policy Reviews and the main elements of the procedures for the meeting. The report by Colombia was contained in document WT/TPR/G/372 and that of the WTO Secretariat in WT/TPR/S/372. 1.3. Questions by the following delegations had been submitted in writing before the deadline: Mexico; Canada; Singapore; Switzerland; Chile; Australia; Costa Rica; China; Indonesia; United States; Dominican Republic; Japan; European Union; Norway; Argentina; and Trinidad and Tobago. The following delegations submitted written questions after the deadline: Brazil; New Zealand; Thailand; Ecuador; Honduras; Guatemala; Korea, Republic of; Turkey; El Salvador; and Malaysia. 1.4. During its previous Review in 2012, Members had praised Colombia for weathering successfully the global financial crisis through the use of anticyclical policies. Members had commended Colombia for maintaining open trade and investment regimes and for using trade policy to promote sustainable growth. Several Members had welcomed Colombia's success in reducing poverty. The measures taken to facilitate trade, including the creation of a single window had been noted. Colombia was encouraged to continue in the path of trade facilitation, to reconsider the use of indicative prices for customs valuation, as well as to step up efforts to comply with its WTO notification obligations and to improve some aspects of the implementation of its SPS and technical regulations regime. 1.5. At the time of the previous Review, Members had also commended Colombia for the unilateral tariff reduction it had implemented. However, they had expressed concerns with respect to the use of import restrictions, the import licensing regime, some aspects relating to customs valuation, and the rationale for some SPS measures. Other issues of interest to Members at the time of the previous Review in 2012 had included: incentives; IPR law and enforcement; government procurement and GPA participation; and sectoral issues relating to services and reforms in agriculture. The advance written questions for this TPR covered many of the same issues. 1.6. Turning to the current review period, as noted in the Secretariat's report, Colombia's economic growth had slowed down somewhat in recent years, prompting the authorities to put in place a programme of reforms, which included tax incentives, tax and import tariff reductions, changes in the investment regime, and investment in infrastructure. 1.7. Colombia's trade and investment regime had experienced a large number of changes since the last Review, in the light of the implementation of Colombia's trade agreements with the United States, the European Union, and through its participation to the Pacific Alliance. 1.8. Colombia had taken several trade facilitation measures over the last six years, including the introduction of a risk management system, the move to an automated clearance process, the introduction of Authorized Economic Operators, the use of advance rulings and the establishment of a Single Window for exports and imports. Colombia had a relatively open trade regime and tariffs were relatively low, with an average MFN rate of 7.1% in 2017; some 50% of tariff lines were zero-rated. Few non-tariff barriers were applied, with the exception of import licensing which was widely used. Tariffs on certain textile and clothing products could be raised when valued below a reference price. Colombia continued to use the Andean Price Band System for 161 tariff subheadings. It also implemented a number of domestic support programmes in agriculture. 1.9. Colombia was an active participant in the multilateral trading system: it had participated in the ITA negotiations and had accepted the amendment to the TRIPS Agreement. However, it had yet to ratify the Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA). Colombia had also been active in the negotiation of preferential trade agreements, which had become an increasingly important element of its trade policy. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia -31.10. The Chairperson drew Members' attention to some other issues they raised in their advance written questions for this TPR. These included: customs procedures; new antidumping regulations; incentives; merger notification and competition policy reform; protection and enforcement of IPRs; development of renewable energy; cross border trade in insurance services; and market access conditions in telecommunications and transport. 1.11. This meeting was to be a good opportunity for Members to discuss in greater detail issues of interest to them and of systemic importance to the multilateral trading system. The Chairperson was looking forward to a productive exchange of views. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia -42 OPENING STATEMENT BY THE REPRESENTATIVE OF COLOMBIA (MRS. OLGA LUCÍA LOZANO) 2.1. Mr Chairperson, Ambassador Laourou, in your capacity as Chairperson of the Trade Policy Review Body, please accept our warm greetings, which we likewise extend to Ambassador José Luis Cancela, from the Republic of Uruguay, who is serving as the Discussant in our fifth trade policy review. 2.2. My thanks go to the Secretariat for preparing the report and for its constant and dedicated work in coordinating and lending support to Colombia's technical group. We also thank WTO Members for attending this review and for their interest in learning more about Colombia, as evidenced by the 370 questions we received from 26 Members concerning various aspects of our trade policy. 2.3. It is a great honour for me, as Vice-Minister of Foreign Trade, to lead the delegation which today will share, before this very Body, Colombia's most important economic and trade developments since 2012, at a time when the multilateral trading system is of particular relevance for a developing country such as Colombia. 2.4. Colombia has had occasion in various forums to assert that, now more than ever, the multilateral system needs to be strong and to provide certainty to economic operators. Trade liberalization and the elimination of distortions contribute to economic growth, job creation, and increased participation in value chains. In Colombia's case in particular, this should enable us to consolidate the benefits ensuing from the peace process. 2.5. The fifth review of our trade policies is a valuable exercise that enables us to report to Members on the trend in our main economic variables and on the implementation of programmes as well as general and sectoral measures relating to Colombia's trade policy over the period 2012-2018. Developments in Colombia since its fourth trade policy review 2.6. Exactly six years ago, in this same context, we told you how Colombia had overcome the international financial crisis and had resumed the path to growth and stability. Many events have occurred over the past six years, two of which were of signal importance, namely the signing of the Peace Agreement after more than 50 years of conflict and Colombia's recent entry into the OECD as the latter's 37th member. Economic environment 2.7. Over much of the review period, the Colombian Government, having drawn up the National Development Plan "All together for a new country", addressed the task of building a peaceful, equitable and educated Colombia, aligned with international best practice and standards, under an approach based on long-term planning in line with the country's sustainable development goals. 2.8. In addition to the three core pillars (Peace, Equity and Education), the Plan incorporated a number of cross-cutting strategies, that is, competitiveness and strategic infrastructure; social mobility; rural development; security, justice and democracy for peace-building; good governance; and green growth. It also included regional strategies to address the priorities of the six areas into which the country has been divided with a view to promoting economic development. 2.9. As is common knowledge, the key outcome was the signing of the Peace Agreement in November 2016, following arduous negotiations, thanks to the determination of the President of the Republic and the cooperation of many Colombian citizens. I would like to take this opportunity to thank the international community and the governments of various countries attending this review meeting today. 2.10. In recent years, Colombia has been facing significant challenges in building peace. The Colombian economy has received international recognition for its stability and growth. The country WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia -5retained a good position in World Bank and IDB rankings during the review period as an open, competitive economy with a suitable environment for doing business in Latin America and the Caribbean. 2.11. Over the six-year period under review, Colombia continued to implement an orderly macroeconomic policy that responded effectively to the new international environment. As a result, the Colombian economy was able to maintain a growth rate above the average for Latin America and the Caribbean, despite the fall in commodity prices to their lowest level since 2004. 2.12. As regards the economic environment, Colombia achieved the following: an annual average growth rate of 3.3% between 2012 and 2017; a narrowing of the deficit in the balance-of-payments current account from 6.4% to only 3.3% between 2015 and 2017; a reduction in multidimensional poverty from 30.4% in 2010 to 17.8% in 2016; the creation of 3.5 million new jobs, thus lowering the unemployment rate to a single-digit figure; and a five percentage point reduction in inflation. 2.13. The risk rating agencies maintained Colombia's investment-grade sovereign debt credit rating, generating a good level of confidence among investors. As part of the policy to attract foreign direct investment (FDI), the Government introduced measures to increase business interest in Colombia. 2.14. The results are clear in that FDI recorded in 2017 exceeded US$14,500 million, or 4.8% more than in the prior year, and accounted for 4.7% of GDP. Another noteworthy point was the broad diversification in the sectors receiving FDI. In 2010, only 23.5% of inflows had gone to sectors other than the extractive industries, but this trend was reversed as the percentage increased in 2017 to 70% in sectors such as telecommunications, transport, storage, and manufactures. 2.15. Policies to attract FDI included a regulation issued in 2017 to modernize the foreign investment regime and increase the competitiveness of the Colombian market. 2.16. In addition to improving its performance in attracting FDI, Colombia reinforced its position as a source of investment in other countries, chiefly the Pacific Alliance countries and the United States. During the review period, the process aimed at internationalizing domestic enterprises led to the consolidation of Colombia's status as the region's fourth largest exporter of capital, with average outflows of US$3.8 billion. There was a six-fold increase in total investment by Colombian businesses abroad between 2005 and 2016. 2.17. After a period of 18 years, Colombia's Central Bank recently updated the country's foreign exchange regime in order to bring it into line with the new global and domestic realities, addressing new developments and providing for risk mitigation. 2.18. As regards the external sector, Colombia continued to implement strategies to diversify exports as part of its commitment to economic growth and more extensive use of trade agreements. 2.19. Thanks to initiatives that included boosting export supply, implementing processes to ensure compliance with sanitary requirements, and providing support for domestic enterprises and foreign buyers by organizing business round tables and drawing up trade agendas, progress was made towards the export diversification goal. 2.20. By end-2017, exports of non-mining/energy goods had risen by 5.3% and total exports by 19% compared to 2016. Non-mining/energy exports remain on an upward trend, having recorded WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia -612.5% growth between January and April 2018. This performance was further enhanced by a 12% expansion in services exports between 2014 and 2016. Peace approach spells better opportunities for our country 2.21. The implementation of the peace accords opens up new opportunities for the production sector, investment and foreign trade. This concerns the agricultural sector in particular, Colombia having defined its agricultural boundaries as encompassing 40 million hectares suitable for agro-forestry exploitation. This confirms the FAO's assessment that Colombia is poised to become one of the world's seven agricultural breadbaskets. Colombia's potential is considerable, and it is currently using only about 15% of that potential. 2.22. In order to take advantage of this situation, we have designed various instruments to promote and consolidate scattered rural areas. Efforts will be targeted at the most affected areas, encompassing 344 municipalities, in order to narrow the development gap and integrate the population victim of the conflict by granting favourable tax conditions over a period of ten years to production-oriented enterprises and businesses in these areas. 2.23. Moreover, the Congress has adopted the Law on Zones of Interest for Rural, Economic and Social Development, covering areas that can be used for agriculture, livestock farming, forestry and aquaculture, where the State provides support for competitiveness, regional economic growth, social development and environmental sustainability. 2.24. The gains that we hope will arise from the new peace scenario also entail challenges to be overcome in terms of competitiveness, internationalization of the economy and integration in global value chains. Colombia is aware that successfully addressing these challenges will open up real possibilities of achieving high growth rates, generating quality employment, and reducing poverty. 2.25. In order to promote productivity through business competitiveness and overcome the lags in capital stock, especially in physical transport infrastructure, in 2016 Colombia adopted the National Productive Development Policy, comprising a set of sectoral and cross-cutting tools to address market, governance and structural failings that impede growth in productivity or make it difficult to upgrade and modernize the Colombian production system. Trade policy 2.26. As emphasized in our Government report, increased internationalization of the economy and transformation of domestic production are key, in Colombia's view, to achieving greater economic development and reducing poverty. 2.27. In pursuing this objective during the review period, Colombia successfully developed and implemented its global economic integration strategy, seeking to increase trade and investment flows within a transparent, predictable and inclusive multilateral system, complemented by regional and bilateral efforts. 2.28. We have strengthened our integration with the Latin American and Caribbean region, with the Andean Community and the Pacific Alliance serving as our core trade policy mechanisms. During the review period, this policy was enhanced by the trade rapprochement with Europe and Asia, following the negotiation and entry into force of the trade agreements with the European Union, the countries of the European Free Trade Association and South Korea, in addition to the entry into effect of the Agreement with Costa Rica and the Pacific Alliance in 2016, and the deepening of our Agreement with MERCOSUR in 2017. We also signed agreements with Panama and Israel, which are pending implementation, and were involved in negotiations which we hope to complete shortly with Japan and Turkey. 2.29. Special mention should be made of the Pacific Alliance negotiations with four candidate associate members (Australia, Canada, New Zealand and Singapore), as a platform for integration into the Asia-Pacific region. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia -72.30. Thus, Colombia currently has 16 trade agreements in force with 62 countries numbering more than 1.5 billion consumers and accounting for 58% of global GDP. 2.31. Colombia has also made substantial improvements to its foreign investment facilitation, promotion and protection policy. During the period under review, we negotiated and reviewed the scope of several international investment agreements in order to provide for a clearer focus to continue strengthening the investment climate, while preserving room for robust regulatory action by the State. The agreements included those reached with France and the United Arab Emirates, and a renewal of Colombia's Agreement with Spain. Joint interpretative statements were drawn up to adjust essential points in the Agreements with Canada and India. Colombia and the multilateral trading system 2.32. This is a particularly valuable opportunity to emphasize the importance of the rules-based multilateral trading system. Compliance with the WTO rules and the pursuit of a more transparent economic and trade environment is the way to increase the resilience of a system that has lately been under threat. 2.33. Colombia's trade policy focuses on integration into the global market for goods and services. We will now highlight the key topics of interest. Colombia considers it essential that the multilateral trade negotiations should lead to outcomes in agriculture that will level the playing field and remove the distortions in agricultural trade. 2.34. Tangible outcomes in the agriculture negotiations will be decisive for delivering the benefits of the peace process. 2.35. We have been very active in the negotiations on harmful subsidies that contribute to illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing, overfishing and overcapacity, in line with Sustainable Development Goal 14.6. Colombia has been leading the discussion on the Sustainable Development Goals; in this connection, support for the negotiations on fisheries subsidies is crucial. 2.36. We are interested in forging ahead with important topics such as e-commerce and domestic regulation in services, on which we have worked with other Members to create negotiating frameworks for the establishment of multilateral rules. Moreover, we are involved in initiatives being explored in other areas, such as those concerning micro, small and medium enterprises, investment facilitation, and trade and women's empowerment. 2.37. For Colombia, illicit trading and customs fraud are a critical topic that cuts across all the multilateral issues. Such practices have an impact on trade in goods since they involve smuggling and money laundering and are used to finance criminal activities. They also extend to trade in services, leading to the violation of intellectual property laws, and are not specifically addressed at the WTO. We think that the problem should be reviewed jointly through an open dialogue among Members. 2.38. Colombia has made a few contributions in this respect by organizing two working sessions at the 2015 and 2017 Public Forums, and is keen to see the issue forming part of the WTO agenda, as the Minister of Trade, Industry and Tourism said at the Eleventh Ministerial Conference. 2.39. Colombia has suffered the effects of this scourge and is therefore committed to working hand in hand with other interested Members and organizations to identify actions that can capture its characteristics and complex workings. Moreover, the Lawfulness and Fight against Smuggling and Customs Fraud strategy has been strengthened, in coordination with the private sector, Colombian government agencies, and international customs and intelligence authorities. 2.40. The issue is being addressed from various angles in organizations such as the WCO, the OECD and some private agencies. The WTO cannot remain on the sidelines of this debate. We reiterate our interest in continuing to work on identifying international cooperation strategies and actions to address the collateral effects of this problem resulting from globalization. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia -8Cross-cutting, sectoral and regulatory policies 2.41. Sectoral policies include the implementation of the Colombia Siembra (Colombia Sows) Plan, aimed at boosting agricultural supply in order to rehabilitate post-conflict rural areas, guarantee food security and increase agro-industry exports. The programme also seeks to improve producers' incomes and strengthen technological development to encourage people to return to the countryside and rehabilitate major areas that used to be occupied by groups operating outside the law. 2.42. This has led to an expansion of land under crops from 25,000 hectares to over 1,200,000 newly planted hectares every year over the past three years. 2.43. Aware of the role of telecommunications in the digital age, Colombia has made significant progress since the previous review, strengthening the institutional framework by giving increased autonomy to the Communications Regulatory Commission, and promoting greater competition and better mobile services coverage, among other things. 2.44. The results are encouraging, with 30.3 million broadband Internet connections in 2018 compared to 2.6 million in 2010. We also have more than 62 million mobile phone lines, and, as regards computer coverage in basic education, the number of children per computer fell from 24 to four in the same period. 2.45. Another services sector worthy of note is tourism, where the number of foreign visitors entering the country rose by 150% between 2010 and 2017. Earnings from passenger travel and transport increased by 68% over those same years. 2.46. An equally major development to be shared with Members of this Organization is the progress made with trade facilitation, especially the results being achieved with the new customs regulations, the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade (VUCE), simultaneous inspection systems, non-intrusive inspection, the automation of foreign trade operations, and the strengthening of risk management systems in order to avoid delays and break the bottlenecks in import, export and transit processes. 2.47. In this connection, we would like to inform Members that the internal process for ratifying the WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement will be completed before end-2018, in accordance with Colombia's established procedures for all international agreements. 2.48. Interest was expressed by 24 Members, which submitted a total of 357 questions, in our overall trade policies and practices by measure, as well as the sectoral policies reflected in the reports. 2.49. Colombia is one of the first Members to have used the electronic question-and-answer system, which proved most useful. We received 81 questions from eight countries via the system, and we urge Members to make use of this tool. 2.50. A strong and solid World Trade Organization that actively addresses the problems affecting trade and seeks ways and means to solve them, is essential for us all. Colombia has been, and will continue to be, a staunch supporter and promoter of the multilateral trading system and the WTO. 2.51. We have been affected by the rise in trade tensions and are concerned about the risk of escalation. We invite Members to refrain from applying restrictive measures and to comply with the rules established in the multilateral framework. We cannot place the global governance system at risk in order to solve short-term problems. 2.52. We hope that this fifth trade policy review will give Members a more comprehensive picture and a better understanding of our policies and measures. 2.53. The period under review also saw our accession to the OECD. This was a truly transformative process that led to substantial reforms in order to bring Colombia's legislation and policy into line with the highest international standards. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia -92.54. We are aware that the reforms introduced with a view to joining the OECD, our active participation in the multilateral negotiations and new areas of interest, and our compliance with WTO commitments are part of an ongoing process that needs to be kept up if we are to achieve international best practice standards and more extensive integration into a globalized world. 2.55. Mr Chairperson, our policies are open to evaluation by all Members. Ambassadors, distinguished delegates, we are ready to hear and benefit from your comments. Thank you. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 10 3 STATEMENT BY THE DISCUSSANT 3.1. First of all, I would like to say what a great honour it is for me to have been appointed Discussant for Colombia's fifth trade policy review, covering the period 2012-2017. 3.2. I also wish to congratulate the people and Government of Colombia on the country's entry into the OECD on 30 May of this year. This bears witness to the wide-ranging programme of reforms introduced in order to modernize the Colombian economy by making it more inclusive, efficient and competitive. The programme involves consolidating a number of processes already analysed in the 2012 trade policy review and the launching of new initiatives, such as the National Development Plan "All together for a new country", which, as indicated in Colombia's Government report, covers part of the current review period, from 2014 to 2018, and addresses the task of building a peaceful, equitable, educated Colombia, among other measures adopted by the Colombian authorities. 3.3. Over the five-year period under review and as indicated in the Secretariat report, the Colombian economy continued to grow at an average annual rate of 3.3% despite a decline in exports, particularly oil and other raw materials, and a slowdown in domestic demand. The adoption of a Fiscal Rule made it easier to lessen the impact of the external shock. As stated earlier, a wide-ranging reform agenda, including tax rebates, fiscal incentives, changes to the investment regime and infrastructure improvements, was implemented in order to return to the higher growth rates recorded at the beginning of the period. 3.4. Another point to be highlighted is the decrease in poverty, although figures remain high and further efforts will be required to achieve a steeper decline. Poverty levels fell to 28% in 2016 compared to the 34% recorded in 2011. 3.5. Unemployment, for its part, reached one of its historical lows at 9.4% in 2017, and inflation stood at 3.99% in that same year. 3.6. While it is obvious that a country's economic performance cannot be analysed without taking account of the context in which it evolves, this is particularly true of Colombia in the years under review. The Peace Agreement putting an end to the American continent's longest-running conflict, which lasted for 50 years and claimed more than 8 million victims, was signed in November 2016. As a Uruguayan and Latin American citizen, I am proud to say that this was a historical event that transcended national borders and became a regional and international milestone. To express this in words more suited to the subject matter at hand, "Colombia is beginning to reap the dividends of peace". 3.7. Although market and product diversification remains a significant challenge for the country, progress was made on both scores during the review period. As can be seen from the Secretariat report, mining exports, chiefly oil and coal, accounted for almost 54% of the total in 2017, compared to 66% in 2012. The share of agriculture increased from 11% in 2012 to 20.7% in 2017. It should also be emphasized that the authorities have been seeking to promote exports of services and non-traditional manufactures. 3.8. Concerning markets, the review period saw the entry into force of five new trade agreements, with the Pacific Alliance, Costa Rica, the Republic of Korea, the European Union and the United States. Preferential agreements were signed with Israel and Panama, and negotiations with Japan and Turkey are under way. In the Pacific Alliance framework, free trade agreements are being negotiated with Australia, Canada, New Zealand and Singapore. 3.9. Colombia has introduced major changes concerning, among other things, its customs legislation, the periodic revision of technical regulations, intellectual property and investment facilitation, as well as initiatives and actions aimed at capitalizing on areas for rural and tourism development. Tourism is unquestionably a peace dividend. 3.10. Moreover, as stated in its Government report, Colombia has continued to provide support for micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs), with the creation in 2017 of Colombia Productiva (Productive Colombia), a programme offering comprehensive assistance to MSMEs (around 400 businesses), with support from the World Bank and the Andean Development WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 11 Corporation. The programme is being held up as an example to other countries in the region. Colombia has a strong institutional support network for MSMEs, comprising the National Support System and a legal framework defined by the MSME Law of 2000 and a number of subsequent, amending and supplementary regulations, as well as various decrees, which, according to the Secretariat report, provide a set of tools and instruments in support of such enterprises. 3.11. Initial estimates under the 2017 Action Plan, drawn up by the National Support System for MSMEs, were for 368,063 enterprises to receive approximately Col$17,890 million (some US$6.4 million), including both refundable and non-refundable resources. In the period 2012-2016, credit operations for MSMEs totaled some US$680 million in favour of 114,922 enterprises. For its part, in 2016 FINAGRO disbursed around US$4.6 million in loans for 600,752 MSMEs. Various state funds also put up guarantees running into the millions over the review period. Lastly, two points worthy of mention are the participation of MSMEs in the secondary securities market to generate financing, and the use of the government procurement regime to promote MSME participation in procurement procedures by applying preference margins and criteria for breaking tie bids. 3.12. In the period 2012-2017, Colombia continued to implement the Structural Tariff Reform, with an average MFN applied tariff rate of 7.1% in 2017. However, it should be pointed out that the average tariff for agricultural products is about three times higher than the average tariff for non-agricultural products, the highest average duties being applied to dairy products, clothing, and animals and animal products, with average tariffs of 55.1%, 40% and 20.3%, respectively. It would appear advisable to pursue the tariff reduction process, providing, in particular, for greater liberalization of agricultural trade. 3.13. We also invite Colombia to continue streamlining its regulatory regime. Particular mention should be made of the import licensing system, which still covers a large number of tariff lines and maintains the existence of domestic production criterion to evaluate and decide on non-automatic import licenses. 3.14. Lastly, I encourage Colombia to proceed with the prompt ratification of the Trade Facilitation Agreement, which, according to available information, is before the Constitutional Court for consideration, meaning that it appears to have already reached the final stage of the relevant constitutional procedures. 3.15. I would like to conclude by highlighting Colombia's commitment to the multilateral trading system, as stated in the section of the Government report dealing with the multilateral environment and evidenced by the country's firm support for the World Trade Organization, its efforts to help overcome the current impasse facing the dispute settlement system's Appellate Body, its active engagement in the various Agreements and its open, inclusive readiness to negotiate, as demonstrated daily by the Colombian delegation to this Organization and the hard work done by Ambassador Juan Carlos González and his staff. Thank you. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 12 4 STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS MEXICO 4.1. I would like to take this opportunity to acknowledge the active work done by the team at the Colombian Mission, under the distinguished leadership of Ambassador Juan Carlos González, in taking a constructive part in the WTO negotiations on topics such as fisheries subsidies, agriculture, investment facilitation and e-commerce, and by assuming the chairmanships, during the review period, of the Trade Policy Review Body, the Council for Trade in Services in Special Session and the Working Party on State Trading Enterprises. 4.2. We also welcome the successful conclusion of the negotiations with the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia and the ensuing Peace Agreement, which put an end to 50 years of conflict. According to official estimates, this could lead to average additional GDP growth of almost 2% over the next ten years. 4.3. Another positive achievement for which I would like to congratulate Colombia is the country's recent accession to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), on 30 May of this year. This will undoubtedly help Colombia pursue its path towards greater inclusion in the global economy, as it brings its standards into line with international best practice. 4.4. Colombia is one of Mexico's leading trading partners, not only at the WTO but also under regional agreements, such as the Latin American Integration Association (LAIA) and the Pacific Alliance, to which both countries belong. 4.5. Mexico and Colombia are deeply committed to maintaining a strong bilateral relationship. This is evidenced by the latest visit of President Enrique Peña Nieto to Colombia in October 2016, marked by the establishment of nine cooperation agreements and announcing the creation of a Strategic Council, which now governs bilateral relations in matters relating to security, trade, migration, technical cooperation and culture. 4.6. As regards Colombia's trade policies, while the extractive sector's share of total exports has declined, it still remains considerable (50%), entailing major risks given the volatility of commodity prices. 4.7. We are pleased to note the timely implementation of the Colombia Repunta (Colombia Bounces Back) programme in response to the fall in international oil prices, which made it possible to mitigate the adverse impact of this decline on the economy. 4.8. Despite these commendable achievements, our private sector has raised serious concerns about two measures in particular: Colombia has had a "scrapping" programme for several years now, which, as already mentioned in the context of the country's accession to the OECD, is a measure that distorts the market. We therefore welcome the abolition of the one-for-one scheme as of 31 December 2018. In the Mexican industry's opinion, the "temporary registration system", aimed at gathering information on the size of the freight vehicle fleet, is a costly and bureaucratic measure. We are grateful for the information provided, which will be very useful for our authorities and private sector. 4.9. Conversely, we acknowledge Colombia's following achievements in the field of information and communications technology: the absence of restrictions on foreign holdings in companies in the telecommunication sector; the reduction in access or interconnection charges, with the caller now paying the access charge, and the regulation of tariffs for the national roaming service; WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 13 the adoption of measures to increase competition among mobile service operators in the market, including automatic national roaming, no blocking of bands, equalization of on-net and off-net charges, all of which have lowered user rates. 4.10. We also congratulate Colombia for implementing the Tourism Sector Plan to Build Peace 2014-2018, taking steps to ensure better air connections and seeking to promote and diversify the tourism offering, which is beginning to translate into increased income for the sector and places Colombia among the ten most tourist-friendly destinations in Latin America, according to the World Economic Forum Report for 2017. 4.11. To conclude, we thank Colombia for its replies to our delegation's questions and wish it every success in this review. CANADA 4.12. If you allow me, I would first like to take a minute to recognize Colombia's remarkable achievement since its last review in 2012, namely the historic peace agreement it signed in 2016 with the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC). This agreement not only brought to an end the last major internal armed conflict in our hemisphere but it carried with it the prospect of lasting peace in Colombia. Peace that can provide the foundation upon which a safer and more prosperous Colombia can be built. 4.13. Since its last Trade Policy Review in 2012, Colombia has maintained its commitment to the multilateral trading system and trade liberalization. For instance, at the last Ministerial Conference, Colombia, like Canada, has signed on to the new initiatives on electronic commerce, investment facilitation and MSMEs. I would also like to commend Colombia for being among the 121 Members, including Canada, that have endorsed the Buenos Aires Declaration on Women and Trade. 4.14. Colombia also has ambitious aspirations for increased global responsibility and strong governance standards. In this respect, we would like to congratulate Colombia for the signature on an accession agreement on 30 May to become a member of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). 4.15. I would also like to take this opportunity to highlight the productive relationship that exists between Canada and Colombia. For instance, Canada is proud to support two initiatives of the Global Alliance for Trade Facilitation in Colombia, namely the establishment of a center for trade facilitation and good practices and the implementation of a risk management system for Colombia's National Food and Drug Surveillance Institute. We are convinced that these initiatives will benefit Colombia. 4.16. However, doing business in Colombia is not without challenges and Canada would like to identify 2 main areas today that merit special attention in Colombia: the regulatory and legal environment for businesses and the existence of a discriminatory entry tax that unfarily targest Canadians. 4.17. Up to this day, investors in Colombia remain too often confronted to counter-productive regulatory and fiscal frameworks, as well as legal and regulatory uncertainty. Although some progress has been noted in the current review cycle, further improvements have been hampered by the frequent introduction of amendments and their lengthy implementation. 4.18. Companies often face other challenges related to security and the weak rule of law, particularly in remote areas that have been at the epicenter of the armed conflict and where private investments are expected to give impetus to the peace process. A successful peace implementation in these areas will hinge on rural and economic development across various sectors, including infrastructure, education and social services, and security. In this delicate context, we encourage Colombia to make further efforts to ensure a more efficient, predictable and stable climate for investors. 4.19. I would also like to shed some light on the second area I mentioned earlier, a concern that is very specific to Canada and that is frequently raised as an irritant by Canadian business people in relation to cross-border movements. Since December 2014, and in retaliation for the WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 14 introduction by Canada of visa biometric data requirements, Colombia has imposed a special entry tax which applies solely to Canadian visitors upon their entry. We strongly believe that this measure is not only discriminatory as it only targets Canadians and no other major partners with similar biometric requirements such as the United States, the United Kingdom, and Australia, but that it also hurts Colombia's business and tourism industry. We also question the alleged reciprocity of the measures, as this entry tax is imposed every time a Canadian enters Colombia, where, in contrast, Canadian biometric fees are, in most cases, payable once for multiple entries and can be valid for up to ten years. We respectfully ask Colombia to lift this discriminatory and unfair entry tax on Canadian visitors. 4.20. In closing, I would like to emphasize the fact that sustainable and inclusive economic growth in Colombia must be accompanied by longer term, structural economic and financial reforms that can enhance competitiveness, foster diversification, create a more stable and predictable investment environment, and promote greater inclusivity of rural communities, marginalized Indigenous and Afro-Colombian populations, and women. To promote economic prosperity for all Colombians, further efforts must also be made in the area of labour, including ensuring the enforcement of labour laws, protecting the freedom of association and collective bargaining and tackling violence against union leaders. We note in this respect our joint commitment to the ambitious objectives of the Labour Chapter of the Free Trade Agreement between Canada and Colombia. 4.21. While we remain confident in its resilient economy, we encourage Colombia to continue advancing its work on ensuring fiscal sustainability, streamlining of the tax revenue system, as well as the pension plan and the expenditure structure of the health and education systems. 4.22. We look forward to having a constructive exchange of views on all aspects of Colombia's economy. We wish the delegation the utmost success during this review. SINGAPORE 4.23. In 2017, Colombia was Singapore's 6th largest trading partner in the Latin America and Caribbean region. Total bilateral trade in goods between Singapore and Colombia amounted to 698 million SGD, which was an increase of 53.9% from 2016 to 2017, while bilateral trade in services increased by 68.3% between 2015 and 2016. Singapore's direct investment abroad into Colombia was 440 million SGD as at end-2016. Several Singapore-based companies have a presence in Colombia, with more companies actively pursuing project opportunities. 4.24. Our economic ties are set to become even closer, with Singapore currently engaged in FTA negotiations with the Pacific Alliance which Colombia is part of. We note the positive progress made in the Pacific Alliance FTA negotiations so far and welcome Colombia's initial offer. With continued good progress, negotiations could conclude by end-2018. 4.25. Singapore deeply appreciates Colombia's robust engagement in the rules-based multilateral trading system and its advocacy of the WTO's important role as a global public good. At the WTO, Colombia is an active and important player, and contributes significantly to the work both in negotiations and in the regular committees, as well as in other initiatives. For instance, Colombia recently took over as the coordinator for the Joint Statement Initiative on Investment Facilitation for Development, and we look forward to working under their coordinator-ship. Singapore commends Colombia's commitment to safeguarding the WTO dispute settlement mechanism and its support for a swift resolution to the issue of Appellate Body appointments, as stated in its Government Report. 4.26. We note Colombia is in the process of ratifying the Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA). We look forward to Colombia's acceptance of the TFA very soon. As for the Agreement on Government Procurement, we note that Colombia has been an observer since 1996, and would like to encourage Colombia to consider accession as a full member. At the same time, we would also like to encourage Colombia to take steps to fulfil the outstanding notifications in areas such as agriculture, services and import licensing which were highlighted in the Secretariat's report. 4.27. Singapore looks forward to continuing our warm and constructive cooperation with Colombia, including through its capable Mission in Geneva, to uphold the multilateral trading WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 15 system. Colombia's 5th TPR comes just after Ambassador Juan Carlos González's successful chairmanship of the Trade Policy Review Body in the past year; we take this opportunity to again express our appreciation for his personal contribution to the system. We wish Colombia every success for this TPR. SWITZERLAND 4.28. Switzerland and Colombia enjoy fruitful economic ties. The trade relationship of our two countries has been strengthened by a comprehensive free trade agreement which was concluded together with our partners from the European Free Trade Association EFTA. It has been in force for Switzerland since 2011. Its implementation more or less coincides with the current trade review period. 4.29. Colombia has become Switzerland's fourth most important partner when it comes to exports into South America. Our exports to Colombia have increased by almost 20 % over the last five years. On the other hand, our imports from Colombia have registered a decrease in value terms after having spiked briefly right after the entry into force of the trade agreement. This decline has to do with the volatility of world market prices for gold and precious stones. These commodities make up a large part of our purchases from Colombia. On the whole, Colombia enjoys a trade surplus in its dealings with Switzerland. 4.30. Switzerland is also an important investor in the country. Foreign direct investment worth about a billion dollars is responsible for the employment of about 12'000 Colombians by Swiss companies. Colombia has also been a focus country for our technical cooperation for almost a decade now. 4.31. It is worth mentioning that these ties have raised our awareness of the importance of the peace process in a country having to come to grips with internal conflicts. The peace process should provide a favorable backdrop for structural reforms. 4.32. As the Secretariat's report has pointed out, Colombia's national income seems too dependent on exports of petroleum and other mining products. Economic development is too contingent upon the vicissitudes of the price movements on international commodities markets. The deterioration of Colombia's terms of trade and the depreciation of the national currency may be viewed as an opportunity. They underline the necessity to redouble efforts to diversify the nation's export base. The recent increases in oil prices should not distract from this objective. 4.33. We commend Colombia for its open investment regime. An environment conducive to stable inflows of FDI has contributed to making a persistent current account deficit more sustainable. We take note of the explanation given by the Colombian authorities why certain sectors are subject to specific authorizations as mining calls for coordination activities. 4.34. Diversification of the export base could be given a special impetus by improving the economy's productivity. Moreover, growth potential could also be enhanced by an increase in productivity. As Switzerland herself has experienced, this is far from easy to achieve. In Colombia's case, however, we have the impression that government procurement is a sector which seems to lend itself to more productivity gains. Public procurement makes up a large part of the country's economy. It is true that measures were taken to make tendering more efficient. 4.35. Nevertheless, more competition could be injected. This could be done by opening up to foreign competition of course. Colombia could contemplate joining the Government Procurement Agreement, though we understand that the Colombian government uses government procurement to aid domestic industry and employment. 4.36. We have followed with great interest Colombia's policy for improving the framework for the protection of intellectual property rights. We will continue to monitor the implementation of rules governing the use of compulsory licenses and the separation of marketing authorization from pricing criteria for medicine. 4.37. Colombia's support for the call on the international community to increase efforts to phase out subsidies to fossil fuels as a major contribution to climate change mitigation deserves special WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 16 mention. We therefore encourage Colombia to continue being engaged on this issue, including on discussions linked to trade-related aspects that are taking place at the WTO. 4.38. We look forward to Colombia's notifications on restrictions it maintains both for imports and for exports. Switzerland submitted a follow-up question with respect to the so-called Colombia Siembra plan, which supports domestic agriculture. We thank Colombia for having provided detailed and timely replies to our questions. 4.39. We commend Colombia for its commitment to the multi-lateral trading system and its active participation in WTO activities and its substantive contributions to its work. 4.40. In concluding, we wish Colombia a successful outcome of this Trade Policy Review. CHILE 4.41. Relations between Chile and Colombia date back to the time of independence. Since then, the relationship between the two countries has been marked by growing cooperation and understanding, born of similar ideals and political views. We were extremely pleased to have been able play a small part in the peace process, and congratulate Colombia for the positive results achieved. 4.42. At the political level, ties between Chile and Colombia are optimal. We have a set of bilateral integration and cooperation mechanisms, as well as 11 treaties and agreements in various spheres, among which the Free Trade Agreement (FTA) signed by the two countries in 2006 is worthy of mention. 4.43. As regards the functioning of this FTA, I would emphasize the role of its Administrative Commission, which last convened in 2015 and mainly addressed market access, regulatory and intellectual property matters, with particular emphasis on the commitments made in regard to updating the lists of entities in the government procurement chapter and the agreement reached on an Environmental Cooperation Action Plan. 4.44. Today, our ties are also centred on expanding political and economic relations through our participation in a deep integration area such as the Pacific Alliance. This initiative, launched together with Mexico and Peru, is aimed at our joining efforts so that we can act as a bloc in matters regarding trade and investment and ensure the free movement of goods, services, capital and persons. 4.45. We believe that both countries would greatly benefit from identifying areas of convergence between the Pacific Alliance and the topics on the agenda of the Administrative Commission of the Agreement so as to strengthen bilateral relations. In this connection, I take this opportunity to invite the Colombian authorities to organize the next meeting of the FTA Administrative Commission in Santiago de Chile. 4.46. Thanks to the range of agreements signed between Chile and Colombia, bilateral trade integration has been on the rise. Overall trade between Chile and Colombia amounted to US$1,885 million in 2017, representing an increase of 22.4% over the previous year. Although this is a most encouraging figure, average annual growth declined to -9.5% between 2012 and 2017. We hope that the increase recorded in this past year will be sustained and reverse the five-year trend that preceded it. 4.47. Turning to direct investment flows, we would emphasize that Colombia is the third largest destination of Chilean foreign investment, which totals close to US$18 billion. Some 150 Chilean businesses are currently involved in more than 300 direct investment projects in Colombia, mostly in the services sector, especially retail trade and financial services. Colombian investments in Chile already exceed US$3.9 billion. We hope that the future will bring an increase in these bilateral investment flows. 4.48. The reports submitted for this review show that since Colombia's previous review in 2012 the country's authorities have introduced a reform programme that includes fiscal incentives, WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 17 reductions in tariffs and other taxes, changes to the investment regime, and increased investment in infrastructure, with a view to boosting the economy. 4.49. During the review period, Colombia also undertook to simplify and harmonize its regulatory framework. We encourage the authorities to continue the process and solve the complexities ensuing from the changes introduced. 4.50. As regards trade facilitation, we welcome the improvements made to Colombia's customs system with a view to modernizing and simplifying its regulations and bringing them into line with international best practice. Such measures represent a step forward and we encourage the authorities to continue on this path. We hope that they will soon ratify the Trade Facilitation Agreement. 4.51. We also underscore the ongoing support to promote micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs). 4.52. As regards Colombia's road infrastructure, we would like to point out that despite negative growth of -0.1% in 2017 – far from the double-digit expansion forecast at the beginning of the year – progress has been made in the legal sphere by (i) adopting the so-called "standard specifications" to improve practices in regional procurement; and (ii) providing greater legal certainty for "bona fide third parties" in the event of revocation/invalidity of contracts. In view of the foregoing, we hope that Colombia will resume its road infrastructure development in the medium term. 4.53. To conclude, and although the prospects for economic growth and inflation are favourable, we would emphasize that a number of structural problems still pose significant challenges, including the need to continue promoting economic diversification and reducing poverty levels. We wish Colombia every success in addressing the challenges before it in this post-conflict phase. 4.54. Moreover, we underscore the Secretariat report's observation that Colombia continues to be a staunch supporter of the rules-based multilateral trading system and, in these difficult times for the world economy, that it advocates further trade liberalization. In our opinion, these are fundamental principles today and are therefore worthy of mention. 4.55. Chile submitted nine questions for this fifth review and welcomes the replies received. We wish Colombia a successful trade policy review. AUSTRALIA 4.56. Australia congratulates Colombia on the significant progress it has made in creating an open and competitive trade regime since its last Trade Policy Review in 2012. 4.57. In particular, we join others in congratulating Colombia on its recent accession to the OECD and commend Colombia on achieving this important milestone. 4.58. Australia appreciated Colombia's commitment to bring about important policy reforms on its path to OECD membership and welcome Colombia's continued efforts to align with OECD standards, including on labour issues, corporate governance of state-owned enterprises, anti-bribery, and foreign investment. 4.59. We note the achievements Colombia has made in modernising its legal framework and in facilitating trade. This includes a number of improvements to its customs system, such as the strengthening of its Single Window for Foreign Trade and the introduction of a risk management system, which has led to fewer inspections and reduced clearance times. 4.60. We look forward then to Colombia ratifying the Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA) and appreciate that this is presently before Colombia's Constitutional Court. We highlight that Colombia has included approximately 97% of TFA implementation commitments in Category A with all remaining commitments in Category B to be implemented by February 2022. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 18 4.61. Colombia is an active and engaged WTO Member and Australia has enjoyed working closely with Colombia to support the multilateral trading system and across the range of WTO negotiations, particularly in agriculture. 4.62. We greatly appreciate Colombia's contribution as an active member of the Cairns Group. Colombia has been a Member since the Cairns Group's formation in 1986, and has played a vital role in pursuing the Group's shared interests of ongoing agricultural trade policy reform. 4.63. We also appreciate Colombia's active engagement in the Buenos Aires Joint Statement Initiatives on electronic commerce, services domestic regulation, investment facilitation for development, MSMEs, and Women's Economic Empowerment, which are helping to re-energise the organisation. 4.64. We encourage Colombia to continue to work to ensure that it is up to date with all of its WTO notification commitments and also encourage Colombia to submit the required changes to its schedules to implement the Nairobi Ministerial Decision on export subsidies as soon as possible. 4.65. Australia's bilateral trade with Colombia is growing steadily off a modest base, with two-way goods and services trade valued at over $600 million and Australia's investment in Colombia valued over $3 billion. There is good potential for our economic relationship to grow further, particularly in the areas of mining, equipment, technology, services, agriculture, tourism and investment. 4.66. In this regard, we encourage Colombia to continue to improve the implementation and enforcement of legislation governing foreign investment along with further development of national legal institutions and judicial reforms on the governance of actions for protection. 4.67. Colombia continues to work on strengthening regional economic integration through free trade agreements negotiated within the framework of the Pacific Alliance. Australia and the Pacific Alliance launched negotiations for a free trade agreement on 30 June 2017 and we look forward to concluding a comprehensive high quality agreement as quickly as possible. 4.68. We also welcome Colombia's expression of interest in joining the TPP-11, and that of any country willing to and able to meet the TPP-11's high standards, including comprehensive tariff elimination on trade in goods. 4.69. Finally, Australia again congratulates Colombia on its achievements since 2012 and wishes Colombia a very successful and constructive Trade Policy Review. COSTA RICA 4.70. Costa Rica is pleased to take part in this trade policy review of Colombia, with which we have had a Free Trade Agreement since 2016 and share common interests and initiatives. Colombia is the leading destination of our exports to South America and the second supplier of our goods imports from that region; it was our third largest source of FDI in 2017, after the United States and Switzerland. 4.71. Costa Rica acknowledges Colombia's constructive role in the WTO and its firm support for the multilateral trading system. 4.72. Costa Rica and Colombia have been driving forward common initiatives aimed at liberalizing trade in services, information technology and agriculture. 4.73. Costa Rica also shares Colombia's interest in areas such as the promotion of e-commerce, MSMEs and women's empowerment in trade. 4.74. As regards this review, our first point of emphasis is the signing of the Peace Agreement with the Revolutionary Armed Forces (FARC) in 2016, a historic event in Colombia which we believe will contribute to create a climate more conducive to investment and will help boost trade. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 19 4.75. Despite the economic slowdown since 2015 due to the decline in oil prices, Colombia has maintained a prudent macroeconomic policy and introduced a set of sound reforms in order to deal with the situation. 4.76. The policy of integration in the world economy and the law on the monitoring of regional trade agreements can make a decisive contribution to the much needed process of Colombian export diversification. Innovation may also play an important role in the process, and hence we note with interest that the objectives set out in the National Productive Development Plan aim to increase productivity and diversification of the production system, with a focus on more sophisticated goods and services. 4.77. Trade facilitation can also increase the Colombian economy's competitiveness and, in that respect, the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade (VUCE) and the issuing of the new Customs Statute are positive developments recorded during this review period. We note the progress achieved in the process of ratifying the Trade Facilitation Agreement and hope that Colombia will be able to complete this process as soon as possible. 4.78. As regards energy policy, we note that Colombia has adopted fiscal measures to stimulate investment in the exploration and extraction of fossil fuels in response to greater demand for energy. We would like to know how these incentives compare with those also offered for the use of renewable energy and what the Colombian Government's projections are for developing this type of more environmentally friendly source of energy. 4.79. The above-mentioned positive developments notwithstanding, we are concerned about some aspects of Colombia's trade policy, especially the marked increase in the number of anti-dumping investigations. According to the Secretariat report, Colombia initiated 45 anti-dumping investigations over the review period, as compared with 25 investigations initiated during the previous period, meaning that Colombia practically doubled its use of this trade protection instrument. Given the potential trade impact of this type of measure on its trading partners, cautious resort to such measures would be advisable. 4.80. As regards the Andean Price Band System (SABP), we are concerned about the uncertainty to which implementation of the system may give rise among trade operators and would therefore like to know whether there are any short- or medium-term plans to change, replace or abolish the system. 4.81. Lastly, I wish to congratulate Colombia on its recent entry into the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). 4.82. For this trade policy review, Costa Rica submitted a few questions concerning investment, financial services and international maritime transport. I would like to thank Colombia for the attention it has given to these questions, and to end my statement by wishing it every success in this trade policy review. CHINA 4.83. We are pleased to see the remarkable progress that Colombia has achieved in economic and trade since the last review. The GDP growth rate averaged 3.3% between 2012 and 2017. Such growth was driven primarily by high increase in domestic demand, in the context of the structural reform and the National Development Plan "All together for a new country". We expect Colombia to maintain the growth momentum through the Economic Reform Programme, enhancing productivity, improving the business climate and ultimately achieving the sustainable development. 4.84. We note that Colombia has made tremendous efforts in reversing the sharp fall in the value of exports of oil and other minerals, there have been increase in its agricultural export and service exports since the last review. It is encouraging to see that Colombia is implementing a diversification strategy, opening up its trade regime and promote exports of services and non-traditional manufactured products. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 20 4.85. As a founding member of the WTO, Colombia has been a strong supporter of the multilateral trading system and actively participated in WTO works. We note that Colombia has accepted the Protocol Amending the TRIPS Agreement and was a signatory to the Information Technology Agreement (ITA). Of course, we are expecting Colombia to soon rectify the Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA). In addition, Colombia has signed the Joint Ministerial Statement on Investment Facilitation for Development at MC11 and served as new coordinator to further promote the structured discussion on "Investment Facilitation for Development". 4.86. Recent years have seen rapid growth in bilateral trade and investment between China and Colombia. China is Colombia's second largest trading partner. The Sino-Colombian bilateral trade has reached US$11.3 billion in 2017, increased by 21.5%. By the end of 2016, China has invested in Colombia US$362 million in total, mostly in the areas of energy, telecommunications and services. By the end of first quarter of this year, Colombia has invested in China 146 projects with value of US$17.73 million in the areas of manufacture, distribution and commercial services. 4.87. In order to better understand the latest development in trade policy, we have raised some questions regarding agricultural trade promotion policy, and market access in express services. We appreciate the replies provided by Colombia to our questions which we would study carefully. 4.88. In this regard, we note that the number of anti-dumping measures initiated by Colombia has increased during the review period. We are concerned with some unfair practices in the antidumping investigations by Colombia including the "analogue country" methodology. 4.89. China will further promote cooperation with Colombia through the Belt and Road Initiative, strengthening synergy between the development strategies, boosting economic growth in Colombia in the Latin America and Caribbean regions, with priorities in areas of infrastructure, energy, transportation, industry, agriculture and tourism. 4.90. We expect to realize the consensus reached by our leaders on signing a free trade agreement between our two countries at an earlier date. And we readily welcome more Colombia enterprises and products to enter into China's market. 4.91. Currently, the WTO is facing serious challenges that have to be dealt with by all WTO Members. China would work together with Colombia and other Members to preserve the basic principles of this Organization, fight against unilateralism and protectionism, and collectively safeguard the multilateral trading system. 4.92. To conclude, I wish this Review a complete success. INDONESIA 4.93. In the last five years between 2013 and 2017, the total trade between Indonesia and Colombia has been experiencing a decrease trend of 2.75%, with trade value reaching a five-year high of US$154.3 million in 2014. Some of Indonesia products that have a good market in Colombia include textile products, electrical machinery and equipment, rubber, footwear, organic chemical, paper, essential oil and so forth. We hope that the economic reform programme in Colombia which includes tax incentives, reductions in tariff and other taxes will stimulate further improvement in our bilateral trade performance. 4.94. There are also some concerns that Indonesia tries to raise during this review process. We have addressed the details of these concerns in our written questions, which include among others, issues related to the threshold established in the Decrees No. 1.744 and No. 1.745, clarification on the goods covered in the Decree No. 925 of 2013 classified in Automatic Licensing, and the frequent amendments to Colombia regulations and the certain peculiarities of its system that make the implementation of those amendments become lengthy. 4.95. We thank Colombia for the replies to these advanced written questions, which we received in Spanish. We, in Geneva and in Jakarta, are looking forward to have the English version. And to this, Indonesia wishes to use this opportunity to convey much appreciation to Colombia Genevan-based delegation on the excellent cooperation accorded to the Indonesian delegation in Geneva, and on their very active engagement in various issues of common concern. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 21 4.96. Lastly, Indonesia wishes much success to Colombia in this fifth Trade Policy Review. UNITED STATES 4.97. Much has changed in Colombia since its last TPR in June 2012, and the United States commends Colombia for all that it has since achieved. We note that, at the time of Colombia's last TPR, the United States-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement had only recently entered into force in May 2012. The U.S.-Colombia TPA is a comprehensive free trade agreement that covers trade in goods and services, and provides important disciplines in areas such as intellectual property rights, investment, telecommunications, and labour and environmental protection. Colombia undertook a number of reforms to implement the U.S.-Colombia TPA. We believe that these measures contribute not only to our bilateral trade relationship, but also to the multilateral trading system and the expansion of global trade, and in turn, benefit Colombia's other trading partners. 4.98. As Colombia's number one trading partner, the United States has a strong, positive and growing commercial relationship with Colombia. According to the U.S. trade statistics, our total two-way goods trade during 2017 was US$26.8 billion, and Colombia is currently the United States' 26th largest goods trading partner. 4.99. Of course, Colombia has not only focused on tis trade relationship with the United States. As the Secretariat's report notes, Colombia also has implemented new trade agreements covering goods and services with the Pacific Alliance, Costa Rica, the Republic of Korea, and the European Union, and the agreement with EFTA (European Free Trade Association) has now entered into force with all the EFTA countries. We also congratulate Colombia on completing the technical reviews of its accession to the OECD and look forward to Colombia's full participation once its deposits its instrument of accession to the OECD. Finally, I would like to commend Colombia on its major accomplishment of the Peace Accord with the Revolutionary Armed Forces (FARC) that was signed in November 2016 – this achievement clearly contributes to Colombia's economic stability and generates new impetus for an expansion in Colombia's trade relations. 4.100. As in its 2012 TPR, Colombia has identified both attracting foreign investment and further diversifying its economy and exports as key elements of its overall economic growth and trade policy strategy. We agree that those are important objectives. 4.101. The United States welcomes the positive steps Colombia has taken in many areas. For example, the Secretariat's report points to accomplishments and advances in the areas of customs and the simplification and harmonization of Colombia's regulatory framework. While Colombia could do more in the intellectual property (IP) area, we note that it has taken many positive actions in the IP space since the last TPR in 2012. Colombia has changed a number of laws and regulations in order to implement the trade agreements that it entered into since the last TPR, including, as noted earlier, the U.S.-Colombia TPA. These changes were significant and transformative actions. However, to facilitate investment and market openness and in turn fully realize the benefits of these changes, Colombia should ensure a higher level of regulatory transparency, including opportunities for public comment. The Secretariat's report also noted in several places that Colombia has made a number of notifications to the WTO in some areas, but not in others. We encourage Colombia both to increase its efforts towards regulatory transparency and to make more extensive and effective use of WTO notification procedures, including in the areas of agriculture, services, and import licensing. We urge Colombia to update its notifications in these areas. 4.102. The United States has some specific concerns as well. With respect to customs practices, the Secretariat's report notes that Colombia adopted a new Customs Statute in 2016, but many of the provisions have not yet been implemented. Passage of the new customs statute is an important step forward. However, traders and other stakeholders will only benefit from the new provisions when they are implemented in practice. We are concerned that Colombia is delaying implementation on many of the provisions by 15 months, from August 2018 to November 2019, according to the Secretariat's report. We also note that many of the customs measures the Secretariat's report states are not yet in force were reported by Colombia as Category A under the Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA). We remind Colombia that measures notified as Category A were to be implemented upon entry into force of the TFA in February 2017. We urge Colombia to redouble its efforts to fully implement the 2016 Customs Statute as soon as possible. We also urge WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 22 Colombia to deposit its letter of acceptance for the TFA with the Director General as soon as possible. Taking note of the Secretariat's report, we further urge Colombia to be mindful of the prohibition on the use of reference prices for customs valuation, including when it seeks to create databases and set guarantees. 4.103. We have submitted a short list of questions about specific issues in Colombia's trade regime. We look forward to reviewing and discussing Colombia's responses. 4.104. The United States appreciates Colombia's active participation in our work here at the WTO. We especially wish to recognize the various important leadership roles that Ambassador González has assumed within this Organization; we also greatly value Colombia's dedicated involvement and hard work in our negotiations regarding fisheries subsidies. 4.105. The United States is committed to building on our current strong trade and economic partnership with Colombia, and supports Colombia's progress along the path of global economic integration that it has so strongly pursued. We commend Colombia on its active participation in the WTO and for showing leadership and ambition in the pursuit of trade liberalization. We remain committed to continued close cooperation with Colombia to deepen our relationship bilaterally as well as in the WTO. DOMINICAN REPUBLIC 4.106. The Dominican Republic shares close bonds of friendship with Colombia dating back to 1936, and these ties between two countries belonging to the same region have grown stronger over time. 4.107. The Dominican Republic commends Colombia for its successful economic performance over the review period, during which the country's GDP grew at an average annual rate of 3.3% in spite of the slowdown experienced since 2015. We are interested to see the reforms introduced by Colombia with a view to boosting economic growth, which comprise fiscal incentives, reductions in tariffs and other taxes, changes to the investment regime, and increased investment in infrastructure. 4.108. We also note that Colombia still faces the challenge of export diversification, as it remains heavily dependent on oil exports, which, according to the Secretariat report, accounted for 40% of the country's exports in 2017. A major drop in value ensued from the decline in oil prices. We therefore urge Colombia to pursue its efforts to diversify its export base. 4.109. We commend Colombia for maintaining an open investment regime, providing for foreign private investment in all sectors, except where prohibited on security grounds. As regards the trade regime, we are pleased to note that it is equally open and that the review period saw the implementation of trade facilitation measures such as the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade (VUCE) and the introduction of the risk management system, which has reduced the number of inspections and clearance time. Another achievement was the adoption of a new Customs Statute with a view to modernizing and simplifying customs regulations and bringing them into line with international best practice. We take a very favourable view of the relatively low average MFN applied tariff rate, which stood at only 7.1% in 2017. 4.110. During the review period, Colombia also adopted measures to enhance its intellectual property regime and adapt it to technological developments and its international commitments. The changes focused on adjusting the rules; optimizing the administration of intellectual property rights; streamlining registration procedures; consolidating interinstitutional coordination; and strengthening enforcement. 4.111. Lastly, the Dominican Republic asked Colombia a number of questions concerning, inter alia, anti-dumping investigation procedures, the price band system and export incentives. We appreciate receiving its replies, which we shall examine with care. In closing, we can only urge Colombia to continue on the path of progress and wish it every success in this fifth trade policy review and in the future. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 23 JAPAN 4.112. According to the Secretariat report, Colombia has maintained a steady growth in GDP since the last review. It is true that its economy highly depends on the export of petroleum and petroleum products which account for approximately 40% of total exports; however Japan is aware that the country is now undertaking relevant reforms to diversify its export base in order to make its economy more resilient to exogenous shocks. Japan positively evaluates its efforts and expects the Government of Colombia to continue its reforms. 4.113. When it comes to its trade policies, Colombia's active engagement in the WTO activities is, first and foremost, commendable. During the review period, Colombia participated in the 17 cases as a third participant. Furthermore, Colombia has actively taken part in initiatives in the WTO by like-minded Members, such as the Joint Statement Initiative on e-commerce. Japan highly appreciates Colombia's contribution to the Multilateral Trading System. 4.114. In terms of measures which facilitate trade, we particularly commend the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade (VUCE). VUCE, which was created in 2004, has been improved since the last review. Among others, the simultaneous inspection system (SIIS) for containerized export cargo and the risk management system (SAR) are commendable. 4.115. As for its efforts on trade liberalization, though the Secretariat Report notes that the Government of Colombia has undertaken Structural Tariff Reform (REA), there still remain some rooms for improvement. For instance, we have been reported of its high MFN applied tariff rates from the Japanese companies in Colombia. As written in the Secretariat Report, the average MFN applied tariff rate rose by 0.9 percentage points from 6.2% in August 2011 to 7.1% in 2017. Furthermore, we reported that some Japanese companies expect sanitary controls and trademark registration process to be simple and more transparent. Japan encourages Colombia to pay attention to those areas and continue its efforts on trade liberalization. 4.116. In conclusion, I would like to express our strong wish to continue our cooperation between Colombia and Japan. We wish Colombia a successful and productive TPR. EUROPEAN UNION 4.117. Let me start by highlighting that Colombia is an important strategic and economic partner of the European Union. 4.118. Colombia is the fourth largest economy of Latin America and its trade with the EU accounts for €11.6 bn. The EU is Colombia's second trading partner and our bilateral Trade Agreement – provisionally applied since August 2013 – helps strengthen our trade relations, and has contributed to a significant diversification of Colombia's exports. As regards investment, the EU is the biggest foreign investor in Colombia. These figures show the strength and depth of our bilateral trade and investment relationship. 4.119. With reference to Colombia's economic policy, the EU acknowledges the progress Colombia has made in recent years, and we congratulate your efforts to cut red tape, simplify the tax system, and implement necessary structural reforms. We encourage Colombia to keep up its efforts, while pursuing the goal of social cohesion and further opening of the economy. Undoubtedly, the successful process of joining the OECD has provided an important stimulus for sectoral reforms, and we hope that these reforms will further increase productivity and boost sustainable growth in the coming years. 4.120. Focusing on Colombia's trade policy, we would like to express our support for the improvements recorded in the period under review. For example: The EU welcomes Colombia having adopted a reform of the spirits import regime which facilitated market access and removed a large part of the previous discrimination against imported spirits. We look forward to the full implementation of Colombia's commitments in line with the GATT principle of national treatment, notably through the even application of the so-called "exploitation charges" levied in some departments. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 24 The EU also appreciates the measures taken to facilitate the imports of heavy trucks, and looks forward to the effective termination of the national scrappage policy no later than the end of this year. 4.121. The EU welcomes Colombia's strong support for the multilateral trading system and its interest in regional and bilateral negotiations. 4.122. The EU thanks Colombia for its overall positive approach to complying with WTO notification obligations. Yet, the EU notes that Colombia has not notified subsidies under Article 25.1 of the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures since 2011 and calls on Colombia to do so without further delay. 4.123. At a multilateral level, I wish to convey the EU's appreciation for the constructive approach of Colombia in the WTO negotiations, particularly in the fisheries subsidies negotiations where Colombia has been an active proponent. The EU trusts Colombia will continue to be fully engaged in the multilateral trading system and to display leadership in the negotiations of substantive outcomes in the WTO, and is particularly committed to continue working together with Colombia on fisheries subsidies. 4.124. At a bi-regional level, the EU is monitoring the deepening of the Pacific Alliance and its negotiations with other trade partners and associate countries. Regarding our bilateral Trade Agreement, we appreciate Colombia's constructive approach with regard to the accession of Ecuador to the Agreement, and also Colombia's active and constructive participation in the annual Trade Committee and Sub-Committees. 4.125. Despite the positive overall trading relationship we also have a series of concerns and suggestions. Turning now to these, I would like to highlight some of them which are of particular interest to the EU: 4.126. First of all, more efforts are needed to cut red tape and procedures for effectively accessing Colombia's market. EU operators are concerned with the highly burdensome and costly import procedures that often require a disproportionally high number of documents, for example for sanitary registrations. There is also significant potential to improve and expedite border procedures and joint inspection by Colombian government agencies. 4.127. In our written questions, we have also asked Colombia to explain the rationale of some technical barriers to trade, such as labelling requirements on imported beers in several departments, which raises concerns from a national treatment angle. Regarding imported beers, we would also like to encourage Colombia to review its current taxation rules, which in many cases result in a higher tax burden on imported products. 4.128. In addition, as discussed during Colombia's OECD accession process, we would like to highlight the need for the transparent and accountable implementation of provisions concerning Intellectual Property Rights related to pharmaceuticals in the National Development Plan. 4.129. Finally, the EU would encourage Colombia joining the Government Procurement Agreement in the future. 4.130. On behalf of the EU, I look forward to a constructive exchange of views during this review and I wish delegation of Colombia great success during its Trade Policy Review. NORWAY 4.131. Norway is pleased to note Colombia's economic growth over recent years. We encourage the Government to continue its work to promote poverty reduction and a more equal income distribution. The work towards implementation of the peace accord has been more complicated and slower than expected, but must continue. 4.132. To be able to perform well in the programs, reforms and strategies already agreed upon, it will be highly important to strengthen institutions especially in the rural areas, and assure that WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 25 progress is made in the infrastructure projects, which are essential to improve Colombia's competitiveness internationally. 4.133. Colombia is an active Member of the WTO, and a founding Member of the Organization. We highly value Colombia's many contributions to the work of the WTO, and its support to the multilateral trading system. Paragraph 3.2.1 in the Government's report, deals with compliance with WTO rules in general. We have a specific question in this regard and wonder whether Colombia could confirm information provided during the February meeting of the Committee on Agriculture that revised schedules for export subsidies will be forwarded in the third quarter of 2018. 4.134. Norway is pleased to note that the Government report explicitly states that Colombia firmly believes that the WTO dispute settlement process is an asset to the multilateral trading system and must be safeguarded. We are also appreciative of Colombia's work to reach consensus on a comprehensive outcome document from the negotiations on fisheries subsidies, including a ban on subsidies to illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing. We would furthermore like to thank Colombia for its active participation in different joint initiatives from Buenos Aires and note in particular its work as coordinator of the informal dialogue on investment facilitation for development. 4.135. Norway would like to congratulate Colombia on its work that resulted in the signing of Colombia's accession agreement to the OECD membership on the 30th of May this year. We are pleased to note that since Colombia's last TPR in 2012, the EFTA-Colombia free trade agreement has entered into force between our two countries. 4.136. Norway attaches great importance to international trade in maritime transport services. Maritime transport provides essential infrastructure for trade in general, investments and economic development. It is a longstanding interest of Norway that all Members contribute to predictability and openness in this key sector through binding commitments. Against this background, we appreciate that trade in international maritime transport services is open for foreign participation in Colombia, thus providing a good basis for future commitments. 4.137. Climate change is a challenge facing all Members. Norway urges Colombia, being a part of the International Communique on fossil fuel subsidy reform, to continue its efforts to reduce harmful fossil fuel subsidies. 4.138. Norway wishes Colombia a successful Trade Policy Review. ARGENTINA 4.139. Colombia is an important trading partner for the Argentine Republic. Our country exports vehicles, barley, soybean oil and machinery to Colombia. Our imports from Colombia include non-agglomerated bituminous coal, polypropylene in primary form, herbicides, insecticides, and fungicides. Approximately 93% of Colombia's tariff lines have been liberalized for Argentina and around 94% of the Argentine market has been liberalized for Colombia. 4.140. Argentina is pleased to note that Colombia's GDP grew at an average annual rate of 3.3% during the review period. This economic growth was accompanied by a major reform agenda comprising fiscal incentives, tariff reductions, changes to the investment regime, and increased investment in infrastructure. 4.141. We also note the introduction of a tax reform law aimed at improving revenue collection. Equally commendable are the country's efforts to diversify the export base, which is chiefly concentrated in petroleum and petroleum products, coal, chemical products, coffee and flowers. 4.142. Argentina recognizes Colombia as a staunch supporter of the multilateral trading system. We welcome the international integration strategy that Colombia has been implementing in recent years. This policy has involved, among other things, entering into new regional trade agreements with Costa Rica; the European Union; Korea, the Republic of; the Pacific Alliance; and the United States. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 26 4.143. Our country is interested to note that foreign direct investment (FDI) is permitted in almost all sectors of the economy, except in specific cases where it is prohibited on security grounds. Foreign investors may set up business through commercial companies and may have subsidiaries in the country. The procedures for registering foreign direct investment made under contractual arrangements were simplified in 2017. 4.144. As regards Colombia's trade regime, we note that it has been bolstered by measures to modernize the legal framework for trade and facilitate trade. Among other initiatives, the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade (VUCE) and the introduction of the risk management system are worthy of mention. Likewise, in 2016 Colombia adopted a new Customs Statute, which we are confident, will help simplify customs regulations and bring them into line with international best practice. 4.145. Argentina welcomes the measures aimed at enhancing the role of micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs). We underscore the implementation of special tax regimes for MSMEs and the financing provided through the Colombian Fund for Modernization and Technological Development of MSMEs (FOMIPYME). 4.146. We thank Colombia for its replies to our questions relating to this trade policy review, which will be carefully examined by the authorities in Buenos Aires. 4.147. To conclude, we reiterate our appreciation of this renewed opportunity to exchange comments on Colombia's trade practices and wish the Colombian authorities a successful conclusion to this review. TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO 4.148. Trinidad and Tobago and Colombia enjoy a cordial relationship with trade and security cooperation being key areas of our bilateral relations. We consider it a privilege to be involved in this fifth review of Colombia's trade policies and practices, and our active involvement today reflects the value we accord to the relationship with Colombia. 4.149. The importance of Colombia's Cooperation Strategy with the Caribbean Basin, in promoting technical cooperation in the areas of national security and energy security as well as education, in particular, language training, should be acknowledged. 4.150. Colombia is a significant trading partner of Trinidad and Tobago and that relationship is governed by the CARICOM-Colombia Agreement on Trade, Economic and Technical Cooperation. As a signatory to the Agreement, Trinidad and Tobago benefits from two-way trade liberalization and trade facilitation with Colombia. Trinidad and Tobago has generally been a net importer of goods from Colombia. 4.151. The Colombian Government's policy of democratic prosperity is indeed worthy of praise. Trinidad and Tobago applauds the efforts of the Colombian Government in securing the Agreement for the Construction of a Lasting, Stable Peace with the Revolutionary Armed Forces (FARC) in November 2016. The projections for average growth in GDP in the years following signature of the Agreement are encouraging. We are heartened that areas affected by the conflict are already reaping benefits of the peace. A revitalized tourism sector has significant potential to contributing to the growth of the economy. With Colombia being a land of diverse landscapes, it may be quite true that with a sustained peace, "the only risk is wanting to stay". We acknowledge Colombia's ranking by the World Bank as the fourth best place for doing business in Latin America and the Caribbean. 4.152. Colombia is Trinidad and Tobago's second largest trading partner in the Americas. We support the efforts of the Colombian Government to make full use of trade and investment agreements to promote diversification of the economy and reduce the level of poverty and unemployment, and increase the productivity of its businesses. 4.153. We commend the strategies and programmes to stimulate the economy, namely the Productivity and Employment Promotion Plan 2.0, Colombia Bounces Back, the National Productive Development Policy, the Scientific Colombia Programme, the "Lawfulness and Combatting WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 27 Smuggling" strategy, the Single Window for Business (VUE), the Productive Transformation Programme (PTP), the Productive Colombia programme, the "Tourism Sector Plan to Build Peace 2014-2018", and the National Tourism Register. 4.154. My delegation has submitted a number of questions and we thank Colombia for its written responses. 4.155. We also note the focus on transport, education, security and combatting corruption. 4.156. Trinidad and Tobago wishes Colombia a successful Trade Policy Review. BRAZIL 4.157. First of all, the Brazilian delegation expresses its recognition, admiration and support for the Colombian Government's efforts to drive the peace process forward. We believe that consolidation of this new environment will offer Colombia new opportunities for trade, investment, tourism and development, and will have positive effects for the entire region. 4.158. The Colombian economy managed to withstand the strong impact of the crisis ensuing from the fall in international commodity prices, especially oil prices, on the country's exports, precisely during the period covered by this report, that is, between 2012 and 2017. In spite of everything, sound fiscal and monetary policies and overall openness to trade enabled Colombia to maintain positive growth rates and low levels of unemployment. 4.159. The Brazilian delegation expresses its recognition, admiration and support for the Colombian Government's efforts to drive the peace process forward. We believe that consolidation of this new environment will offer Colombia new opportunities for trade, investment, tourism and development, and will have positive effects for the entire region. 4.160. Brazil congratulates Colombia on assuming the pro tempore presidency of the Pacific Alliance and for its leadership in the joint efforts to unite the two regional blocs, namely MERCOSUR and the Pacific Alliance. This dialogue has real potential for boosting trade, investment, and the integration of value chains in Latin America. We are committed to seeking effective economic integration, which will deliver tangible benefits for our citizens. 4.161. In accordance with our roadmap, adopted at the MERCOSUR Summit in Mendoza in July 2017, our two blocs are taking a proactive approach in addressing matters relating to cumulation of origin, production chains and customs procedures, barriers to trade, and services trade facilitation. 4.162. As indicated in Colombia's report for this trade policy review, Economic Complementarity Agreement (ACE) No. 72, signed in July 2017 between Colombia and the founding members of MERCOSUR, provides tangible evidence of our commitment to free trade. We can say with certainty that following the entry into force of ACE No. 72 in December 2017 trade between Brazil and Colombia became almost entirely duty free. 4.163. Brazil also congratulates Colombia on its recent entry into the OECD. The expansion of the Organization, which now numbers 37 members, can contribute to broadening and diversifying its agenda. 4.164. Brazil and Colombia are linked not only by close bonds of friendship and shared values, but also by trade and mutual investment, which are further bolstering the relationship between our countries. In 2017, trade flows returned to their US$4 billion level. Colombia's sales to Brazil in that year rose by around 59% to US$1.44 billion, reflecting the resumption of income from Colombian oil and mineral exports to Brazil and the rest of the world. Last year, Brazil was Colombia's fourth largest product supplier and the seventh largest market for Colombian exports. 4.165. As regards investment, we would emphasize the substantial increase in the number of Brazilian businesses investing in Colombia, which has risen from 40 to 84 over the past four years and reflects the growing confidence of Brazilian entrepreneurs in our neighbouring country's more favourable business environment. For its part, Colombian investment in Brazil is also on the WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 28 increase, especially in the energy, chemicals and services sectors. I am pleased to highlight the fact that Brazil and Colombia signed an Investment Cooperation and Facilitation Agreement in 2015. Once it enters into force – hopefully in the very near future – this Agreement will give an even greater boost to our mutual investments and thus contribute to increased integration of our economies and societies. 4.166. Our two countries are continuing to work together and look jointly towards the future. During the recent visit of President Juan Manuel Santos to Brasilia on 20 March last, we took further steps to deepen our economic and trade relationship, with the signing of important agreements to promote cooperation among our small and medium enterprises and to use digital certificates of origin, which will cut through the red tape in bilateral trade. 4.167. On the other hand, we should not settle for what we have achieved so far. Brazil believes that the time has come for both countries to recognize the equivalence of sanitary measures and guarantees provided for livestock production and trade and meat processed within our respective jurisdictions. Different approaches and standards still stand – unnecessarily – between the two countries and have an undesirable impact on our regional efforts to address common challenges. 4.168. To conclude, I thank the delegation of Colombia for its replies to Brazil's questions, which have been forwarded to our capital for consideration and follow up. We wish Colombia a most productive trade policy review. NEW ZEALAND 4.169. New Zealand has an active interest in Colombia's trade and investment policies and congratulates Colombia for its recent accession to the OECD. The accession process has been valuable to supporting Colombia's domestic reforms and we look forward to working closely with Colombia in that forum to deliver better well-being for our people. 4.170. New Zealand and Colombia share a strong commitment to trade liberalization and regional economic integration. We are currently exploring opportunities to boost our trading partnership to the Pacific Alliance and New Zealand particularly values Colombia's leadership of the Alliance over the past year. 4.171. We commend Colombia's efforts to maintain the momentum of trade liberalization in the region and its continued interest in connecting with the wider Asia-Pacific region of which we are part. 4.172. During the period of this review, the Government of Colombia successfully negotiated a peace agreement with the FARC putting an end to more than 50 years of civil conflict. Not only is this an impressive achievement in and of itself, but it has also offered space for Colombia to focus on necessary economic reforms. New Zealand believes that Colombia's continued economic performance and its population's well-being would be enhanced by the dividends produced by the successful implementation of the peace agreement. 4.173. We would like to acknowledge Colombia's achievements on poverty reduction and we would like to encourage Colombia to deepen its efforts in this area. 4.174. New Zealand congratulates Colombia for the regulatory reforms undertaken during this period to facilitate trade and foreign investment. While there remains implementation hurdles, New Zealand acknowledges Colombia's efforts to open-up its markets. 4.175. We also congratulate Colombia for the structural tax reform carried out in 2016 where corporate taxation was redefined, revenue collection was improved, and measures to avoid tax evasion were applied. 4.176. During the review period, Colombia showed moderate GPD growth rate with a downward trend since 2015. The collapse of oil prices to some extent affected this outcome. Nevertheless, during the same period, Colombia maintained a low and stable inflation rate. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 29 4.177. New Zealand encourages Colombia to follow this positive path. We also recognize Colombia's efforts to diversify its exports in order to decrease its dependency on raw materials, especially on oil and its derivatives. 4.178. New Zealand supports Colombia's efforts to increase the use of renewable energy sources. 4.179. We appreciate the responses Colombia has provided to New Zealand's questions and we would like to touch in particular on two areas. New Zealand highly values Colombia's support for the Friends of Fossil Fuel subsidies reform communiqué in 2015 and welcomes its efforts to promote the development of renewable energy sources. 4.180. New Zealand encourages Colombia to continue its efforts to combat illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing and to strengthen the sustainable development of fishing and aquaculture. 4.181. New Zealand thanks Colombia for its continued commitment to the multilateral trading system and emphasizes our appreciation for the constructive engagement we enjoy with or Colombian colleagues here in Geneva. We work closely together as fellow members of the CAIRNS Group of agricultural products to achieve further liberalization through the WTO of trade in agriculture. 4.182. We welcome the positive steps that Colombia has taken in reforming and growing its economy since its last Trade Policy Review in 2012. These steps have been achieved under difficult circumstances and we sincerely hope that Colombia continues to enjoy the economic dividends of peace in the coming years. 4.183. We look forward to further discussions on the issues we have raised during the course of the review. THAILAND 4.184. Thailand and Colombia have a stable bilateral trading relationship. Colombia is the sixth largest trading partner of Thailand in Latin America. In 2017, total trade between the two countries amounted to US$250 million. 4.185. During the review period, Colombia's GDP increased at an average annual rate of 3.3% and inflation remained relatively low and stable. Since 2012, Colombia has launched an economic reform programme in order to stimulate the economy, which includes, for instance, tax incentives to promote private investment, reductions in tariffs and other taxes, changes in the investment regime to simplify the procedures for the registration of foreign investments, and increased investment in infrastructure. In terms of trade, Colombia has continued to implement a policy of greater integration into the global economy, seeking better market access conditions for its exports and imports, while reducing its production costs. 4.186. Thailand welcomes Colombia's consistent efforts in modernizing the legal framework and promoting trade facilitation. For instance, it has introduced a number of improvements to the customs system, including the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade and the implementation of the risk management system. In 2016, Colombia also adopted a new Customs Statute to modernize and simplify its regulations and bring into line with best international practices. 4.187. Regarding agriculture, it is considered as Colombia's strategic sector, on account of its contribution to GDP and employment. Its share in GDP increased in the period under review, rising from 5.8% in 2012 to 6.5% in 2016. The sector is, moreover, a key source of employment, providing jobs for 3.5 million people and absorbing 14.5% of the labour force in 2016. In this regard, we commend Colombia as a Cairns Group member, for its active and constructive role in bringing about a free, fair in agricultural trade including being a champion for agricultural reform as mandated in Article 20 of Agreement of Agriculture. 4.188. Thailand is pleased to learn about the implementation of the Colombia Siembra ("Colombia Sows") plan with a view to boosting agricultural supply in order to guarantee food security in the country, expanding production area and yields and promoting agricultural and agro-industry WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 30 exports, stimulating the development of trade in agriculture in order to improve incomes for producers, and strengthening technological development and services in the agricultural sector. 4.189. Moreover, Thailand appreciates Colombia's efforts to strengthen its intellectual property regime and adapt it to technological developments and to its international commitments. 4.190. Thailand continues to value Colombia's contribution and commitment to preserving and strengthening the multilateral trading system. Colombia participates in both the ITA and ITA Expansion Agreements, acceded to the Protocol amending the TRIPS Agreement, and was in the process of ratifying the Trade Facilitation Agreement. 4.191. In this review, Thailand submitted a set of questions, covering the policies and measures of our interests such as the advanced ruling practices, non-tariff measures, investments in travel and tourism sectors, and business development in service sectors. Thailand thanks Colombia for the timely responses to our questions and will study them in detail with great interest. 4.192. In conclusion, we wish Colombia every success in this Trade Policy Review. ECUADOR 4.193. Ecuador has a major interest in participating in this review, not least because Colombia is our neighbour, one of our main trading partners and a party, as we are, to various agreements such as the Andean Community, LAIA and the Multiparty Agreement with the European Union. 4.194. Colombia is the fifth largest destination of Ecuador's non-oil exports, capturing 6% of sales. As regards non-oil imports, Colombia is Ecuador's fourth largest supplier market, with a 10% share. 4.195. Ecuador's non-oil trade balance with Colombia was in deficit for Ecuador by US$760 million in 2017. 4.196. In that same year, Ecuador's non-oil exports to Colombia amounted to US$747 million, down by 7% compared to 2016. Non-oil imports were worth US$1,507 million. 4.197. Ecuador's leading goods exports to Colombia are palm oil, canned tuna, wood-based panels, shrimp and cane sugar. We shall closely follow developments regarding the entry of Ecuadorian rice into the Colombian market. 4.198. Ecuador's main goods imports from Colombia are medicines, fungicides, freight transport vehicles, motor cars and cane sugar. 4.199. Turning to the Secretariat report for this trade policy review, I would like to underscore the active and important role played by Colombia in regional trade. 4.200. We welcome the fact that Colombia is taking steps to improve internal tax collection and is actively implementing an export diversification strategy. 4.201. Ecuador emphasizes the importance of the exercise in transparency and insight into public policy afforded by trade policy reviews at the WTO. In this connection, my country asked the delegation of Colombia a few questions, one of which emphasized Ecuador's concern regarding National Drugs Council Resolution No. 001-2015 of 8 January 2015 prohibiting the entry of Ecuadorian cement through our common land border at Ipiales, because it is considered a chemical substance or product that may, directly or indirectly, be used or destined for the extraction, processing and refining of drugs. 4.202. In Ecuador's view, the Resolution is an internal control measure, as those subject to control are natural or legal persons engaged in activities relating to the production, distribution, purchase, consumption, importation or storage of controlled chemical substances and products. The establishment of specific customs districts through which Ecuadorian cement may enter for control purposes, located at a distance from the border at Ipiales, defeats the objective of the measure and turns it into a restriction on Ecuadorian exports. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 31 4.203. We hope that Colombia will review the inclusion of cement as a substance subject to control. The CONCEPTO 30976 document, issued by Colombia's National Tax and Customs Directorate (DIAN) in May 2011, specified that the limitation, under the Leticia Special Customs Regime, on importing "narcotic drug precursors" does not affect cement since it is not classed as a precursor, despite the special control to which it is subject pursuant to National Drugs Council Resolution No. 9 of 2009. 4.204. We would also like more information in response to question 4/6 in document RD/TPR/934 concerning Law No. 223, which provides that "the tax paid by foreign products may never be lower than the average tax paid by domestically produced products"; what we would like is details as to how Colombia ensures that foreign products are taxed neither at a lower rate nor at a higher rate than that applied to domestic products. 4.205. In closing, we thank the Colombian delegation in anticipation for its replies to our questions on various specific aspects of Colombia's trade policy, which will serve as important inputs for strengthening relations with this country. HONDURAS 4.206. Colombia is Latin America's fourth largest economy. We are pleased to note that Colombia recovered well from the shock caused by the drop in international oil prices. Continued implementation of the Peace Agreement, coupled with the Government's structural reform agenda, which includes an efficient tax reform, has contributed to a stable economic environment. 4.207. We welcome the Colombian Government's efforts to diversify the economy, as embodied in the National Development Plan, which seeks to increase exports of non-mining goods and, in so doing, to contribute to more sustainable growth, with gains across the board, by boosting productivity. 4.208. According to the Secretariat report, Colombia consolidated its main macroeconomic indicators in 2016. In 2017 the Government built on this foundation with the Colombia Repunta (Colombia Bounces Back) programme, an economic stimulus plan that granted tax incentives to encourage private-sector investment, increase public investment in the 4G network, the tertiary roads network and house building, promote more extensive use of royalties for regional investment purposes, and provide resources for the peace process. 4.209. We are very pleased to note the country's strong performance in reducing poverty and unemployment. As stated in the Government report, multidimensional poverty in Colombia has continued to fall since 2010, and by 2016 it had decreased by approximately 41%. Unemployment dropped to a historic low of 9.4% in 2017. 4.210. We are also glad to learn that the internal process for ratifying the Trade Facilitation Agreement is now reaching completion and that Colombia will very soon be able to deposit its ratification instrument. As regards customs regulation, we welcome the substantial changes made to customs legislation with a view to modernizing and simplifying the regulations and bringing them into line with international best practice. We appreciate the replies to the questions submitted by our delegation in this respect. 4.211. Our bilateral trade relationship with Colombia is based on long-standing fraternal and neighbourly relations between our two countries, inspired by the need to expand our markets. 4.212. We have a free trade agreement that has been in effect since 26 March 2010. Trade between Colombia and Honduras amounted to around US$163,000 in 2017. There is no doubt as to the potential of our trade relations with Colombia, and the Honduran Government is keen to consolidate and further develop the relationship. 4.213. To conclude, we wish Colombia a successful fifth trade policy review and welcome the extraordinary achievements of our Colombian neighbours, especially the historic Peace Agreement and the country's entry into the OECD on 30 May last. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 32 GUATEMALA 4.214. Guatemala and Colombia share common interests and ideals on several fronts in this Organization, and we are convinced that both countries will continue to build trust and work tirelessly to expand their strategic alliances, both here and in other regional and subregional forums. 4.215. In connection with this review, we highlight the efforts made by the Colombian Government to promote a series of measures and strategies to strengthen the country's various production and services sectors, such as the tourism sector, where continuous training programmes are provided for tourism personnel and tax incentives are given for investing in the sector, for example the 9% income-tax rate and follow-up incentives over a period of 20 years for the construction and refurbishment of hotels in settlements with fewer than 200,000 inhabitants. 4.216. The country's strong performance in reducing poverty and unemployment is also worthy of note. 4.217. We welcome the implementation of trade facilitation measures, such as the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade (VUCE), created in 2004, and the introduction in 2012 of the simultaneous inspection system (SIIS) for containerized export cargo, which enables four control entities to participate in a single inspection, thus reducing inspection time for import and export operations. Another advance has been the implementation since 2015 of the risk management system (SAR) for import and export registration applications submitted to the VUCE. 4.218. As regards the MSME sector, it should be pointed out that with its amendments to the 2011 law on MSMEs, the Colombian Government is providing a set of tools and instruments in support of such enterprises. The overriding aim is to promote development of the sector, create jobs and establish new production chains. 4.219. As to bilateral relations, Colombia is a very important trading partner for Guatemala in the Latin American region. In 2017, Colombia ranked 26th among Guatemala's export trading partners and seventh in terms of imports. As far as bilateral trade is concerned, Guatemala's main imports from Colombia include various mineral products, plastics and plastic products, pharmaceuticals, insecticides, fungicides and disinfectants, perfumery, toilet and cosmetic preparations, electromechanical domestic appliances, machinery and mechanical equipment for electrotechnical use, various products of the chemical industry, other base metal manufactures, and vehicles and transport equipment. 4.220. Colombia's foreign direct investment (FDI) in Guatemala amounted to US$160.2 million in 2017, representing 14% of total FDI inflows. The key investment sectors were banking and insurance, electricity, manufacturing and telecommunications. 4.221. In addition, it is important to highlight Colombia's trade in services achievements, as a result of which the services sector now accounts for almost half of GDP and employment in the country. 4.222. In conclusion, Guatemala's wish is that, in implementing its economic and trade policies, Colombia may reap further success in terms of economic growth and development. Guatemala is confident that our two countries will continue to strengthen their commercial and neighbourly ties. 4.223. We appreciate the replies to our questions and wish the Colombian delegation a successful conclusion to this exercise. REPUBLIC OF KOREA 4.224. At first, Korea would like to join in congratulating Colombia on its recent accession to the OECD. 4.225. Korea and Colombia have developed a strong economic partnership since the establishment of diplomatic relations in 1962. Our economic relations have continued to deepen further since the Korea-Colombia FTA came into force in 2016. As a result, the volume of bilateral WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 33 trade increased up to US$1.5 billion in 2017 from US$1.3 billion in 2016. Bilateral trade volume is expected to expand continuously as almost all tariffs are set to be eliminated within 10 years after the FTA came into effect. 4.226. From a trade policy perspective, as the Secretariat's report noted, the growth rate of the Colombian economy decreased down to 3.3% during the review period from more than 4% during 2012 to 2014. This slowdown resulted from a decrease in exports, particularly those of oil and other raw materials as well as a decline in growth for domestic demand. 4.227. However, Korea believes that the Colombian economy has greatly strengthened its potential through the various efforts that the Colombian government has made. Since 2012, Colombia has implemented new regional trade agreements covering trade in goods and services with the Pacific Alliance, Costa Rica, the Republic of Korea, the United States and the European Union. Moreover, it has adopted a number of measures to modernize its legal framework and facilitate trade. 4.228. Colombia, as a founding Member of the WTO, has participated actively in the WTO such as by ratifying the Protocol Amending the TRIPs Agreement and participating in the ITA. However, it has not ratified the Trade Facilitation Agreement. Furthermore, it initiated up to 45 anti-dumping investigations during the review period, which is much more than 25 cases between 2006 and 2011. We hope that Colombia will expedite the process for ratifying the TFA and refrain from excessive recourse to anti-dumping measures. 4.229. Korea hopes to continuously develop our economic relationship with Colombia going forward. In addition, we expect Colombia to continue to contribute towards strengthening the multilateral trading system. 4.230. With this, we would like to express our deep appreciation to the Colombian delegation for its hard work and wish them every success in this TPR. TURKEY 4.231. Being the fourth biggest economy in Latin America and one of the most important emerging markets in the world, Colombia is an important partner for Turkey. In the review period, we see that inflation rate remained within the range pursued by the Central Bank around 4%, and the unemployment rate kept stable around 9%. At the same period, Colombia has had a modest growth rate of 3.3%, which seems to have been limited by the falling prices of oil and oil products, a major category of Colombia's exports. It is understood that a major challenge for the Colombian economy is to diversify the exports base and to minimize the negative effects of the dependency on oil and other raw materials, so that the significant decrease in the overall trade volume during the review period would not repeat again. Poverty ratio has improved from 34% in 2011 to 28% in 2016, thanks to the ability of Colombia's economy to create new jobs and the comprehensive macro policies pursued. No need to mention that there is still room to further decrease this figure. Similarly, Colombia is better to continue implementing necessary strategies to decrease the public sector deficit. We believe that trade policy objectives in the National Development Plan will help the Government to reach the overall macro targets. 4.232. We are also glad to see that Colombia became the 37th member of the OECD in 2018. We believe that Colombia's economic and trade policy will benefit from the accession to the OECD. 4.233. We are glad to see that Colombia continued its efforts to make its trade and investment regime more open in the review period. The improvements in the customs systems such as the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade and the adoption of a new Customs Statute to modernize and simplify the customs regulations are also positive developments. In this regard, in alignment with all these efforts, we are of the belief that Colombia's ratification of Trade Facilitation Agreement would be another stepping stone for further integration of Colombian into global economy. New trade agreements signed with the Pacific Alliance, Costa Rica, Korea, the U.S. and the EU in the review period show the great importance of trade for Colombia. The efforts of the Government to make public procurement system more efficient and transparent as well as to strengthen the intellectual property rights system will help the Colombian economy to become more competitive in future. At this point, let me also applaud our Colombian colleagues in Geneva, WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 34 for their hard work and valuable contribution to the activities under this roof. For instance, we appreciate Colombia's constructive engagement in the fisheries subsidies negotiations as a member of the 6 Latin American countries. Colombia is a valuable and third biggest trading partner of Turkey in Latin America. Nevertheless, our trade volume is still far away from mirroring our excellent political relations (Turkey's export to Colombia was US$185 million and import from Colombia was US$1.69 billion in 2017). In this direction, a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) is currently being negotiated between our countries. We held the seventh round of negotiations in Bogota this year. We hope to conclude these negotiations and sign an FTA with Colombia as soon as possible. 4.234. We are also pleased that Pro-Colombia, the trade promotion agency of Colombia has an office in Istanbul to intensify our trade relations. 4.235. Turkey and Colombia signed a Bilateral Investment Treaty in 2014. We hope that Colombia will finalize its domestic procedures soon. Finally, we would like to mention our appreciation to be given the opportunity to make our points known on the trade policy of Colombia and we wish Colombia a very successful review (and a successful World Cup). EL SALVADOR 4.236. We note from the Secretariat report that the Colombian economy grew steadily during the review period. GDP rose at an average annual rate of 3.3%, with a peak of over 4% in 2012-2014, and, despite a slowdown that began in 2015 owing to the decline in – chiefly oil – exports, it recorded 1.8% growth in 2017. Thanks to Colombia's inflation-targeting system, inflation remained relatively low and stable, and as regards the exchange rate, the country also managed to maintain the stability of the peso, following a sharp downturn mainly due to the fall in oil prices and the national currency's subsequent recovery. 4.237. We are pleased to note that Colombia has opted for modernization, especially by simplifying and harmonizing its regulatory framework, updating the legal framework for trade, trade facilitation and customs regulation, adopting new competition rules and a policy to improve the regulatory framework and corporate governance of State-owned enterprises, and upgrading the government procurement and intellectual property systems. 4.238. Like all other Members, Colombia obviously still has challenges to overcome, such as reducing poverty and diversifying its export base. Nonetheless, it has adopted support policies that have benefited its production sectors, such as credit incentives for businesses, tax incentives for MSMEs, the Colombia Siembra (Colombia Sows) Plan to diversify crops, and the Price Stabilization Funds for agricultural products. 4.239. Colombia has also turned to new technologies and innovation for micro and small enterprises and in the financial and telecommunication sectors. 4.240. Furthermore, Colombia is to be congratulated on its entry into the OECD. 4.241. At the bilateral level, diplomatic relations between Colombia and El Salvador were established in 1825. 4.242. Today, aside from the trade topics to which I shall refer later on, there has been an increase in institutional development cooperation, especially in the justice sector, on matters such as assistance to victims and transitional justice, the fight against corruption, accountability of judicial and police officers, and disciplinary proceedings. 4.243. On the trade front, El Salvador and Colombia have been stepping up their bilateral relations since 1984, initially under a partial scope agreement and then under a free trade agreement since 2007. Until a year ago, El Salvador was Colombia's tenth largest investment destination in Latin America. Colombia is one of El Salvador's ten main sources of imports, essentially consisting of chemical products, such as medicines, perfumes, cosmetics and pesticides, and commodities such as refined petroleum and polymers of propylene. El Salvador's leading exports to Colombia are chemical products, such as ready-packed medicines, cleaning WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 35 products and sulphates, as well as food products, including raw sugar, processed fish, flavoured water and fruit juice. 4.244. We would like to underscore our acknowledgment of Colombia's work and involvement in the proceedings of this Organization, driven by the country's remarkable team in Geneva under the efficient guidance of Ambassador González. 4.245. I cannot fail to mention Colombia's historical circumstances, marked by events very similar to those experienced in Salvadoran history. Both countries have known episodes of violence, which ended in peace agreements that ultimately enabled our peoples to benefit from a phase of national reconstruction. Based on practical experience, we should emphasize that this kind of process is not simple. It involves risks and challenges for all the parties involved. The Colombian people, having expressed themselves through the ballot box, succeeded in consolidating peace in 2016. It is truly admirable that Colombians, in a show of great courage and fortitude and using the tools of democracy, laid the foundations on which to build the road to peace, development and well-being in this fellow Latin American country. 4.246. In light of the foregoing, it only remains for us to congratulate Colombia for its outstanding performance and to wish it every success in this exercise. MALAYSIA 4.247. We would like to extend our congratulations to Colombia on the various policies and initiatives implemented by the Government during the period under Review. 4.248. In 2017, Colombia was ranked Malaysia's 73rd largest trading partner in the world and 7th largest trading partner among the Latin American countries. Malaysia's total trade with Colombia increased by 43.3% from US$112.9 million in 2016 to US$155.8 million in 2017, with exports to Colombia grew by 21.0% to reach US$97.7 million. 4.249. Trade continued to grow strongly in the first quarter of 2018, with total trade increased by 28.2% to US$49.1 million, and exports to Colombia grew by 32.6% to US$34.1 million. In investment, we continue to encourage Colombian companies to establish operations in Malaysia in the manufacturing and services sector. 4.250. It is important to highlight that Colombia is one of the most dynamic economies, with the third-highest GDP growth rate in the Latin American region. We applaud Colombia's effort to liberalize trade and participate in global value chains through its membership in the Pacific Alliance along with Chile, Mexico and Peru, including through FTAs with other trading partners. 4.251. At the multilateral front, we commend Colombia for showing strong commitment towards progressive trade and investment policies under the WTO such as acceding to the Protocol Amending the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPs Agreement) and participating in the Information Technology Agreement (ITA). Colombia is also an active Member and has subscribed as Malaysia to the Joint Statements adopted at the previous 11th Ministerial Conference on Electronic Commerce for Development, MSMEs and Investment Facilitation. Malaysia looks forward to working closely with Colombia and all other Members on moving these initiatives forward in the WTO. 4.252. We note that Colombia is in the process of ratifying the Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA) and we would encourage Colombia to expedite the notification process of the remaining commitments. 4.253. While welcoming the trade initiatives and further liberalization undertaken by Colombia over the review period, we would like to seek further clarity on some of policy. Among those, the higher application of the tariff levels applied to the agricultural sector to non-agricultural goods; the IP policy and in relations to pharmaceutical products, and self-certification in Colombia. We also look forward to hearing more on MSMEs in in Colombia. Such, we look forward to the replies to our written questions on certain aspects of its trade policy. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 36 4.254. We would also like to express our appreciation to the Permanent Representative of Colombia, Ambassador Juan Carlos Gonzales and his committed team for their tireless efforts and constructive engagement with other delegations here in Geneva. 4.255. We wish Colombia a productive and successful Fifth Trade Policy Review. INDIA 4.256. During the period under review from 2012-17 the GDP of Colombia grew at an average rate of 3.3% driven, mainly by domestic demand. The key challenges for Colombia include the shrinking of the mining sector which came down from 11% of GDP in 2012 to 5.3% in 2017 and decline in exports due to the votality of international oil prices and addressing issues related to poverty alleviation and human development indicators. We commend the Government of Colombia for the concerted efforts and various initiatives being taken to address these challenges which include the comprehensive National Development Plan 'All Together for a New Country' which aims to build a peaceful and equitable country. The strategies under the Plan include strengthening infrastructure, competitiveness, economic development and attracting foreign investment. 4.257. India and Colombia share warm, close and multifaceted relations. There are regular exchanges between both countries including exchange of business delegations for promoting trade and investment. The bilateral trade between two countries stood at US$1.53 billion registering a growth over the previous year. There is tremendous potential to promote trade between both countries in areas like metals, minerals, textiles, automobiles, gems and jewellery, pharmaceuticals and agricultural products. The number of Indian companies is growing in Colombia with investments in areas like IT, pharmaceuticals, agro chemicals, plastics and automobiles. ONGC Videsh, an Indian public-sector company, is also engaged in a joint venture for oil exploration and production operations in Colombia. 4.258. For capacity building and human resources development, India is regularly offering slots in various training institutions to professionals from Colombia under India's Economic and Technical Cooperation programme. India also offers scholarships to Colombian Students under cultural scholarship schemes. Both countries have also signed agreements in science and technology, IT, sports, health and other areas for promoting technical assistance and cooperation. 4.259. We wish to also highlight some issues which are impacting the vast underlying potential in our relations: The complex and bureaucratic export procedures are making it difficult for Indian companies to invest and export to Colombia. Indian Goods including basmati rice and finished textiles products face tariff barriers in exports to Colombia. The number of Indian companies in IT and Services sector which are contributing to the development of Colombia are growing. However, these companies face quota restrictions for getting Indian IT professionals to Colombia to expand their operations. Relaxation in these requirements will help to promote trade in services. Colombia has imposed a minimum import price for fibre, yarn fabrics, man-made apparel and footwear. Indian companies in the area of agro chemicals and pharmaceuticals face difficulties in trade and investment in Colombia due to the complex regulatory procedures and requirement of environmental clearances. The trade of Indian agricultural products is also being affected due to the stringent sanitary and phytosanitary requirements. We would urge the Government of Colombia to look into these issues to address them. India also stands ready to constructively engage bilaterally to discuss and resolve these for mutual benefit. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 37 4.260. To conclude, we look forward to working closely with the authorities of Colombia for further expanding and harnessing the potential of our trade and investment ties for mutual benefit. We wish the delegation of Colombia a productive and successful TPR. THE SEPARATE CUSTOMS TERRITORY OF TAIWAN, PENGHU, KINMEN AND MATSU 4.261. Since Colombia's last trade policy review in 2012, it has made substantial efforts to boost the country's economic activity, and in the 5 years under review between 2012 and 2017 it has succeeded in achieving positive economic growth at an average annual rate of 3.3%. We commend the Colombian government on the series of reforms it introduced to adjust tariffs, promote investment, and facilitate trade with foreign partners, as well as its vigorous efforts to improve governance in the public sectors. We hope that Colombia will continue to implement further measures to help keep the trade regime open, efficient and transparent in the future. In addition, of course, we especially applaud its conclusion of the "Peace Agreement", signed in late-2016, which ends half-a-century of tragic internal violence, and creates the conditions of peace and stability that are so essential for the future development of the country and its people. 4.262. We are also delighted to see Colombia's successful accession to the OECD as its 37th Member, on the eve of this TPR on 30 May 2018. This serves to confirm its serious commitment to pursuing international standards in areas such as the justice system, labour, state-owned enterprises, and many others. 4.263. As Columbia is one of the original founding Members of the WTO and such an active player in the work of this Organization, we hope to see it continuing to support the strengthening of the Multilateral Trading System, and help to advance discussions on initiatives such as E-commerce, MSMEs, and Trade and Women's Economic Empowerment. In the same context, with Columbia currently being an observer to the Government Procurement Agreement (GPA) and considering that government procurement accounts for an important part of its GDP, hopefully Columbia will become a full signatory to the Agreement in the near future, as well as the fast ratification of Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA). 4.264. We have also been closely following Colombia's progress on its stated policy objectives of greater integration in the world economy, with its signing of bilateral trade agreements with major trading partners like the US, the EU, and South Korea, and the recent trade negotiations between the Pacific Alliance and four Associate Members (Australia, Canada, New Zealand and Singapore) in the Asia-Pacific region to further broaden trade flows and investment. 4.265. As far as our own bilateral trading relations with Columbia are concerned, we are actively seeking to find opportunities to expand the volume of our two-way trade in the fields of agriculture, mining, industrial products, and the renewable energy sector, which would be mutually beneficial to our SMEs and MSEMs in particular. 4.266. In conclusion, the Separate Customs Territory of Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu appreciates the opportunity of participating in this review. We look forward to continuing close cooperation with Colombia in both the bilateral and the multilateral forums. May I wish the Colombian delegation a most successful and fruitful Trade Policy Review. 4.267. Thank you very much for giving me the floor. ICELAND 4.268. We welcome the positive developments in Colombia's trade policies since its last TPR and we congratulate the Government of Colombia on the signature of the Peace Agreement in November 2016. 4.269. We welcome the emphasis on trade and open markets in the new National Development Plan. Statistics indicate strongly that trade openness can be measured in terms of economic growth productivity, higher standards of living and even promotion of peace. 4.270. Open economies grow faster than closed economies. It is encouraging to read from the report that the economy of Colombia is stable and growing. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 38 4.271. Colombia and Iceland cooperate closely when it comes to trade, here at the WTO, as well as on the basis of our Free Trade Agreement that was signed in 2008. 4.272. We commend Colombia on its support to the multilateral trading system in general, as well as for its valuable engagement in the discussions here at the WTO, including by chairing this Body last year, as well as coordinating the dialogue on investment facilitation for development. 4.273. We also would like to commend Colombia for its engagement in the fisheries subsidies negotiations. 4.274. On the occasion of the 11th Ministerial Conference in Buenos Aires last December, more than 120 Members and Observers launched a joint Declaration on Women and Economic Empowerment that aims, inter alia, at sharing best practices and working together in the WTO to remove barriers for women's economic empowerment and increase their participation in trade. Colombia is a supporter of the Declaration and we welcome the emphasis placed on the issue and the report by the Government of Colombia. It was interesting to read about the experience of the flower sector in Colombia in relation to economic empowerment of women. These examples of how the empowerment of women can have a positive effect on trade and the economy as a whole are in the spirit of our declaration and exactly what we need to move our discussion forward. We thank the Government of Colombia for sharing it with us. 4.275. In closing, Iceland reiterates its appreciation for Colombia's active engagement in the WTO. We wish the Colombian delegation every success with its trade policy review and we look forward to continuing our close cooperation with Colombia, both bilaterally and here at the WTO. THE PHILIPPINES 4.276. The Philippines and Colombia enjoy 72 years of friendship, which has been revitalized recently through the first opening of an Embassy in Manila in September 2017, with Colombian Deputy Foreign Minister Patti Londoño gracing the milestone event. 4.277. It may also be recalled that Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos Calderon visited Manila to attend the Informal Dialogue between APEC and Pacific Alliance leaders at the APEC Summit held in Manila in 2015. 4.278. It was during a bilateral meeting between the two leaders at the sidelines of this summit where mutual interests were expressed to further enhance trade relations between the two countries. The Philippines welcomes Colombia's active engagement as an observer in the APEC process and appreciates its contributions to trade and investment facilitation and cooperation in the Asia-Pacific region. 4.279. During the 3rd Bilateral Consultation Mechanism in September 2017, a process which was first established between the two members in 2009, senior officials from both countries exchanged views on regional and multilateral issues impacting both East Asia and Latin America. 4.280. The Philippines is committed to deepen relations with Colombia and remains open to opportunities for bilateral cooperation, particularly in the areas of trade and investment, defense, the peace process and anti-drug war, where Colombia can share with the Philippines many lessons. Given the strengths of Colombia's industrial sector, the Philippines would also like to explore cooperation in the areas of chemicals, textiles, and clothing and footwear manufacturing. 4.281. Trade between the Philippines and Colombia is quite modest but continues to grow in the recent years. Philippine exports to Colombia increased by an impressive 71.59% in 2017 reaching trade value of US$18.11 million compared to the previous year's US$10.55 million; while imports from Colombia stood at US$12.84 million, representing an increase of 7.87% for the same period. Major Philippine exports to Colombia include input or output units of data processing machines, desiccated coconuts, other articles of plastics, and other agricultural products. Major Philippine imports from Colombia include fungicides, continuous-action elevators and conveyors, and citric acid salts and esters. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 39 4.282. Growing of trade among non-traditional trade partners can show the value of the WTO in expanding trade and investment when major players are questioning the value of increased trade and investment to their economies. 4.283. Colombia's average annual GDP growth rate of 3.3 per cent from 2012 to 2017 is driven by domestic consumption—quite similar to the Philippine economy. The Colombian economy has also shown its resilience by maintaining a growth rate above the average for Latin America and the Caribbean countries despite the fall in commodity prices. Although the prospects for economic growth and inflation are favorable, we are confident that Colombia will overcome the structural challenges it faces, including the need to continue promoting diversification of the economy and reducing poverty which stands at 28% in 2016. 4.284. The Philippines commends the Colombian government's efforts under its National Development Plan 2014-2018 to address the task of building a peaceful, equitable, and educated Colombia through cross-cutting strategies on competitiveness, social mobility, rural development, security, good governance, and green growth. We also laud Colombia's National Productive Development Policy, which aims to expand the supply of exportable goods and services in order to make full use of trade agreements and develop participation in global value chains. 4.285. Colombia is a founding Member of the WTO and has signed the protocols on telecommunications and financial services annexed to the GATS and the protocols amending the TRIPS. It participates in the Information Technology Agreement, and we look forward to its prompt ratification of the Trade Facilitation Agreement, which all APEC economies have already ratified. It is also an active member in the various formal and informal committees in the WTO, including the Friends of MSMEs Group, which recognizes the important role of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises. 4.286. The Philippines looks forward to continue working with Colombia to further strengthen the economic relations between our two countries through bilateral, regional, and multilateral fora. 4.287. The Philippines also thanks former TPR Chair, Colombian Ambassador Juan Carlos Gonzalez who served as Chair of the Philippines' TPR held in March 2018. SRI LANKA 4.288. My delegation noted the modest growth performance of the Colombian economy at an annual average rate of 3.3% over the review period from 2012-2017 despite the world economic shocks. As a country heavily depends on energy and mining exports, makes it vulnerable to fluctuations in world commodity prices. We believe that the recently launched economic reform programme, which includes tax incentives, tariff other tax reductions, changes in the investment regime, and increased infrastructure investment, will help stimulating the economy on the fast track. Like many other developing countries, including Sri Lanka, Colombia faces difficulties in overcoming its current account deficit owing to high dependency on imports. 4.289. We note with interest the number of measures that Colombia has undertaken to open up its trade regime, including modernization of legal framework, improvements to the customs system, including the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade and introduction of the risk management system with fewer inspections and reduced clearance time. 4.290. Although Colombia maintains 13 different tariff rates ranging from 0-98%, almost half of its tariff lines are zero-rated. Colombia has bound all its tariff lines at an average rate of 42% whereas the average applied MFN tariff rate is 7.1%. Only 6.2% of tariff lines are subject to a rate exceeding 15%. However, the product categories such as clothing, dairy and animal products are subject to highest average tariffs. In addition, Colombia temporarily applies the WTO bound tariff to imports of footwear and clothing entering to Colombian market at prices below or equal to certain thresholds established. Moreover, more than 6,000 tariff lines are subject to automatic licensing requirements, while 180 tariff lines are subject to non-automatic licences. 4.291. As a founding Member of the WTO, Colombia, in particular the Permanent Mission in Geneva, plays an active role. The dynamic role played by His Excellency the Ambassador Mr. Juan Carlos González and his team in Geneva in proactively engaging in ongoing activities of the WTO is WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 40 highly commendable. Ambassador González played an interesting role chairing this Committee until he handover the chairmanship to Ambassador Laourou. 4.292. We invite the delegation of Colombia to accelerate its process of ratifying the Trade Facilitation Agreement, as more than one and half years have been lapsed since entering into force of the agreement. Also, we note that Colombia takes part in the negotiation son TISA, and participated in the Information Technology Agreement. It is interesting to note that Colombia is an active user of WTO's trade remedies, in particular anti-dumping measures. It has initiated 45 anti-dumping investigations, as compared to 25 during the previous review period. It has also initiated 4 safeguard investigations during the period. 4.293. In the bilateral front, Colombia and Sri Lanka maintain very friendly relations. The bilateral trade stands at a moderate level but in an increasing phase. Balance of trade is always in favour of Sri Lanka except in 2009 and 2010. Export of Ceylon Cinnamon, which is well-known among the Latin American Region is the dominant export item which accounts for 70% of Sri Lankan exports to Colombia in 2017. Sri Lanka's imports from Colombia during the last several years are comparatively at a negligible level and do not witnesses a regular pattern as well. 4.294. In concluding, my delegation sincerely wishes the delegation of Colombia a successful deliberation on its fifth Trade Policy Review. URUGUAY 4.295. Uruguay maintains friendly and constructive relations with Colombia in the various spheres covered by their bilateral relationship, which includes not only policy, the economy and trade, but also cooperation and culture. 4.296. First of all, Uruguay wishes to congratulate Colombia for its progress in the trade policy field thanks to consolidation of the peace process, which has enabled conflict-ridden areas to reap the benefits of peace. 4.297. Since Colombia's last trade policy review in 2012, political and trade relations between the two countries have grown stronger. 4.298. The Fourth Meeting of the Uruguay-Colombia High-Level Political Mechanism took place in April 2017, with Uruguayan Foreign Minister Rodolfo Nin Novoa and Colombian Foreign Minister María Ángela Holguín leading their respective delegations. 4.299. The meeting addressed bilateral trade between the two countries, emphasizing the need to hold new consultation meetings with a view to consolidating the Memorandum of Understanding on Strategic Partnership and further deepening the Economic Complementarity Agreement between MERCOSUR and Colombia. 4.300. As regards trade proper, Uruguayan exports were worth close to US$65 million (including the free zones) in 2017 and consisted chiefly of essential oils, miscellaneous edible preparations, fish and crustaceans, pharmaceuticals, various products of the chemical industry, milk and milk products, and meat and edible meat offal. 4.301. Uruguayan imports from Colombia are mostly mineral fuels, plastics and plastic products. 4.302. Although Uruguay enjoys good conditions of access to Colombia's market, it would be most important for Uruguayan producers to secure access for citrus products, pears, blueberries and honey, among others. 4.303. In terms of investment, the Zonamerica company in Cali is one of the largest investments made by a Uruguayan firm in Colombia. The project covers an area of 38 hectares and will comprise 18 office buildings, a data centre and staff qualified to provide support services to businesses and their clients. Once completed, it is expected to provide employment for more than 17,000 people. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 41 4.304. The three Gilinski Groups. largest Colombian investments in Uruguay are the Éxito, Sura and 4.305. Turning to development, Uruguay wishes to highlight Colombia's National Development Plan, aimed at increasing Colombia's exports of non-mining/energy goods and services by making full use of trade and investment agreements. 4.306. It should be noted that one of the Plan's strategic pillars is to boost the productivity of Colombian businesses by making the production base more sophisticated and diversified, increasing the production capacity of 2,000 enterprises and developing a range of programmes and strategies for micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs). 4.307. The period under review saw the registration of 884 MSMEs, which raised their productivity levels and turned from underdeveloped production units into stronger enterprises seeking to continuously improve their processes. 4.308. It is also interesting to cite a few key laws and programmes forming part of the regulatory framework for MSMEs in Colombia, namely the MSME Law of 2000, the National Support System for MSMEs of 2004, the National Guarantee Fund, and iNNpulsa Colombia. 4.309. Uruguay accordingly encourages Colombia to continue taking an active part in the WTO Informal Working Group on MSMEs, and invites it to share its experience in implementing national strategies, which might be helpful in promoting the successful integration of MSMEs into international trade. 4.310. Furthermore, Uruguay wishes to highlight the work done by Colombia in order to join the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), which culminated in an invitation to become the Organization's 37th member. 4.311. Lastly, we reaffirm our interest in continuing to work towards a positive outcome at the Twelfth Ministerial Conference and in protecting a multilateral trading system based on predictable, transparent and balanced rules. 4.312. Uruguay wishes Colombia every success in its fifth trade policy review. PANAMA 4.313. Panama and Colombia are not only neighbouring countries but are also bound together by ties dating back to pre-Columbian times. In the nineteenth century, Colombia, then known as New Granada, and Panama, together with Ecuador and Venezuela, formed part of Gran Colombia until we separated in 1903. One hundred and fifteen years later, Colombia is still one of Panama's main trading partners, a major user of the Panama Canal, and the largest investor in our part of the Latin American region. 4.314. Over the past 20 years we have seen Colombia turn into a stronger, more diverse economy that is more open to the world. We highlight the efforts made by Colombia in the framework of its bilateral trade partnerships with other countries, the Andean region, LAIA and the Pacific Alliance, and its entry into the OECD. 4.315. On the other hand, we note Colombia's continued heavy reliance on raw materials and the way in which the latter affected the country's growth and currency exchange value in recent years. We therefore take a positive view of the processes and programmes implemented over these past few years in order to simplify trade, as well as those aimed at encouraging and increasing exports. 4.316. As we have already said, Colombia is an important trading partner for Panama, and in the past three years, our trade has averaged US$400 million per year. A small portion of this amount represents Panama's exports of food and chemical products to Colombia. The bulk of our trade consists of Colombian exports of medicines, fuels and electronic products to Panama. 4.317. It should be emphasized that this does not sum up trade between our countries, as Colombia is the sixth largest user of the Panama Canal and a major buyer in our Colón free trade WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 42 zone, where Panama's re-exports to Colombia reached one billion in 2017. Nonetheless, these have contracted by 50% since 2013 as a result of the slowdown in the Colombian economy, the depreciation of the peso, and unilateral measures implemented by Colombia, restricting goods imports. 4.318. As is common knowledge among the WTO Membership, for over ten years now Panama has had to resort to the dispute settlement mechanism on account of measures affecting Panama's re-exports of apparel and footwear to Colombia. The various measures have ranged from restrictions on ports of entry, indicative prices and compound tariffs exceeding the bound levels to measures which take the form of special customs controls on these goods and whose consistency with the relevant WTO Agreements is currently being examined by compliance panels. 4.319. Panama wishes to draw special attention to these customs control measures, imposed by Colombia on imports of apparel and footwear under Decree 1745 of 2016, replaced by Decree 2218, which appear to be inconsistent with this Organization's rules on customs valuation and have also been challenged by other Members in the course of the proceedings. 4.320. It is our hope that once the compliance proceedings have been completed we will find a solution to this dispute without further delay. 4.321. We congratulate the Colombian State for its active participation in the multilateral system and especially for the major changes and efforts made in moving towards a market economy more open to world, as well as Colombia's achievements on the security front. Although specific points remain to be addressed, we view these endeavours and changes in a positive light. 4.322. Colombia has been, and will continue to be, an important trading partner for Panama. We wish Colombia every success in this review and wish to highlight the admirable work of its delegation in Geneva. PERU 4.323. Peru and Colombia enjoy a very close relationship, rooted in geographical proximity and a common historical and cultural tradition. For many years now, we have pursued like-minded policies to promote economic integration with partners both within and outside the region, driving our economies towards higher levels of competitiveness underpinned by vigorous economic liberalization and a strong international reach. Accordingly, Colombia and Peru both firmly believe that a rules-based multilateral trading system is a cornerstone of the global economy and provides stability for international trade. In addition to this common vision, we are also members of the Pacific Alliance, the Andean Community and LAIA, which enable us to boost regional trade and productive linkages in the region and to export quality products to other continents. 4.324. As a result of all these endeavours, annual bilateral trade has grown in recent years. In 2017, trade between Peru and Colombia exceeded US$2 billion, a 14% increase over the previous year. Peru's exports to Colombia have become more diversified, targeting the iron and steel, chemical and agricultural sectors. 4.325. These efforts are also evidenced by policy and economic cooperation and coordination at the highest level. One example is the holding of four Binational Cabinet meetings to date, in which our Presidents reached decisions on a wide-ranging, cross-cutting common agenda that naturally encompasses economic and trade matters. 4.326. At the WTO, we work as a team with a view to the adoption of effective disciplines on fisheries subsidies; establishing commitments on domestic regulation in services; promoting agricultural market liberalization within the CAIRNS Group; furthering the integration of small and medium enterprises in international trade; and enhancing transparency and predictability among Members in establishing maximum residue limits (MRLs) under the Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures, among other important issues on the WTO agenda. We also jointly support the dispute settlement pillar of the WTO and, generally speaking, the validity and value of the multilateral trading system. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 43 4.327. In short, we are very much on the same page with Colombia. This is why we welcome the successful achievement of domestic peace in Colombia, and the country's recent entry into the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) – a goal towards which Peru is taking major steps and which it hopes to reach in the near future. We also acknowledge and encourage the reforms being implemented by Colombia to revive its economy, boost trade and investment, consolidate its macroeconomic balance, and increase its level of export diversification. 4.328. Peru will continue to work in collaboration with Colombia, not only at the multilateral level within the WTO but also in other relevant forums, further seeking to promote sustainable growth and economic development for our countries. We look forward to pursuing and strengthening our common journey towards economic integration and cooperation, within the Pacific Alliance and the Andean Community as well as on a bilateral basis. On behalf of the Peruvian delegation, it only remains for me to wish Colombia every success in its fifth trade policy review. PAKISTAN 4.329. Pakistan and Colombia enjoy very good bilateral relations; however, in trade, the potential is under-exploited. At the WTO, Pakistan and Colombia are jointly working in three groups; FEDs and FIFD and Friends of MSMEs, and Ambassador Gonzalez is the coordinator of FIFD. His role as FIFD coordinator is highly appreciated by Pakistan and all FIFD members. 4.330. During the review period, between the beginning of 2012 and the end of 2017, Colombia's GDP grew at an average annual rate of 3.3% and growth is expected to pick up in 2018. During the review period between 2012 and 2015, inflation did remain relatively low and stable at 30%. The current deficit account has seen an improvement, it was at 4.6% of the GDP in 2016 and stood at 3.3% in 2017. 4.331. Colombia has a diverse export mix of over 4,800 different products, but it remains heavily dependent on exports of petroleum and petroleum products, which accounted for approximately 40% of its total exports in 2017, followed by coal, chemical products, coffee and flowers. 4.332. In the agricultural sector, Colombia boasts a relatively high degree of food sufficiency despite the concentration of its exports, an estimated 85% of internal demand for food being met by domestic production. 4.333. Colombia is implementing a strategy to diversify its export base accordingly; it is trying to promote exports of services. Colombia's main trading partners are the United States, the European Union, China, Mexico and Brazil. 4.334. Colombia is a founding Member of the WTO and has acceded to the Protocol amending the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights and participates in the Information Technology Agreement. Pakistan would encourage Colombia to ratify the TFA even though Colombia has notified the WTO of its "Category A" commitments. 4.335. Pakistan appreciates that during the review period, Colombia adopted measures to strengthen its intellectual property regime and adapt it to technological developments and to its international commitments. At the same time, enforcement measures relating to trademark rights were strengthened, a general enforcement strategy was developed. 4.336. Pakistan commends that Colombia has an open investment regime: foreign private investment is allowed in all sectors, except where prohibited on security grounds. Foreign investors may set up business through commercial companies and may have subsidiaries in the country. 4.337. Colombia has been seeking to open up its trade regime, and since its last Review, it has adopted a number of measures to modernize the legal framework and facilitate trade. 4.338. In the financial services area, foreign banks and insurance companies may establish branches in Colombia, and since 2013, they may set up subsidiaries. Cross-border trade in insurance has also been allowed since 2013. During the period under review, Colombia strengthened the institutional framework for its financial system and telecommunications, giving WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 44 increased autonomy to the Communications Regulatory Commission in the decision-making process. Colombia has continued to liberalize the provision of air transport services. Companies wishing to provide tourism services in Colombia have to be listed in the National Tourism Register. 4.339. In 2016 Colombia also adopted a new Customs Statute with a view to modernizing and simplifying its regulations and harmonizing them with best international practices. In 2017, the Colombian tariff contained 7,708 ad-valorem lines at the 2017 HS ten-digit level. The average MFN applied tariff rate in 2017 was 7.1%. The average tariff for agricultural products (WTO definition) was 15.4% in 2017, whereas the average tariff on non-agricultural products was 5.8%. 4.340. During the period under review, Colombian authorities continued to promote micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs), by making them benefit from special tax regimes and financing by the Colombian Fund for Modernization and Technological Development of MSMEs as well as benefiting from mechanisms of financial and non-financial support provided by National Support System for MSMEs. 4.341. In the end, we would like to wish Colombia a very fruitful and successful TPR. RUSSIAN FEDERATION 4.342. The Russian Federation follows with great interest the economic performance of Colombia. During the review period, Colombia's GDP grew at an average annual rate of 3.3%, which is quite impressive. Despite somewhat slowdown in 2017 to 1.8%, growth is expected to pick up in 2018. We are confident that the ambitious programme of reforms, which includes tax incentives, reductions in tariffs and other taxes, changes in the investment regime, and increased investment in infrastructure will contribute to this performance. 4.343. On 19 May 2018, Russia and Colombia celebrated an important anniversary, 160 years since the establishment of interstate relations. On this day in 1858, the Emperor of Russia Alexander II sent a letter to the President of New Granada (now Republic of Colombia) Mr. Rodríguez with a proposal to establish friendly relations between our countries. 4.344. Colombia is an important and reliable partner for Russia in Latin America. Our relations are built on mutual respect and trust. We enjoy the positive dynamics in the development of political dialogue and multidimensional bilateral cooperation. 4.345. The volume of bilateral trade between Russia and Colombia more than doubled in 2017 and has reached US$464 million. According to our data, last year Russia's exports amounted to US$352 million, while imports from Colombia reached US$113 million. 4.346. The main items of Russian exports are mineral products (in particular oil and oil products), chemical products (mainly fertilizers), metal products, machinery and equipment. We import from Colombia fresh cut flowers, coffee, tropical fruits, some mineral and chemical products. 4.347. Under these circumstances, our key task is to expand investment and cooperation in non-primary and high-tech sectors. We proceed from the existing resource base in Russia and Colombia, the capacity of regional markets, as well as the potential demand for certain types of industrial products, services and technologies. 4.348. In particular, we note that Colombia directs significant efforts to the development of transport infrastructure, and the Russian side is ready to act as a reliable partner in this process. Our companies can quickly organize the supply of equipment for rail, sea and air transport, as well as equipment for the repair of roads and railways. Russian business is aimed at participating in shipbuilding enterprises, development of port infrastructure, modernization and equipping of airports with modern air traffic control systems. 4.349. An important instrument for the progressive development of bilateral relations in the trade and economic sphere is the Russian-Colombian Intergovernmental Commission on trade, economic, scientific and technical cooperation established in July 1979. Its 6 th session took place in Bogotá in April 2017. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 45 4.350. The development of bilateral trade and economic relations is facilitated by the ColombianRussian Chamber of Commerce established in 2008, which actively promotes direct contacts between business persons of both countries. 4.351. During this TPR, the Russian delegation has not addressed any written questions to Colombia. Should the need arise, we will be ready to discuss bilaterally. 4.352. To conclude, we look forward to work with Bogotá in order to expand our trade and investment ties for mutual benefit. We wish the delegation of Colombia a successful Trade Policy Review. ISRAEL 4.353. At the outset, Israel is pleased to note that international trade has continued to play an essential role in the Colombian economy, which has largely maintained an open trade regime and has pursued liberal trade and investment policies, driven by a strong internal demand, economic reforms, domestic expenditure and a flourishing services sector. 4.354. We note that during the period under review, the Colombian economy grew at an average rate of 3.3% annually. The average MFN applied tariff rate in 2017 was 7.1%, around 49.7% of lines were duty free, while 6.2% were subject to a rate exceeding 15%. The average tariff for agricultural products was 15.4% in 2017, whereas the average tariff on non-agricultural products was 5.8%. The highest average duties continued to be for dairy products, clothing, and animals and animal products, with average tariffs of 55.1%, 40% and 20.3%, respectively. In addition to tariffs, the VAT regime applied to imports continues as before on the same rates as for domestic products. 4.355. Over the past few years, relations between Israel and Colombia have further strengthened at all levels. The framework of the Israeli trade with Colombia includes various Cooperation agreements on technical, institutional and commercial matters, as well as the Colombia-Israel FTA -- which was concluded in 2013 and it is still in the process of ratification in Colombia. When entered into force, the FTA will reduce or completely eliminate tariffs on industrial and agricultural products and enable the business community to enjoy its benefits. 4.356. Israeli exports to Colombia include medical and communications equipment, machinery, electronic and mechanical devices, monitoring, security and irrigation systems, and chemical products. Colombian exports to Israel consist chiefly of extractive and agricultural products. The annual average of the bilateral trade has reached USD $677 million during the period under review with a balance in favour of Colombia. We look forward to the opportunity of informing Members factually on the benefits of our FTA in due time. 4.357. I would now like to turn to certain aspects of the Secretariat and Government reports of Colombia that are of particular interest to us and which have already been mentioned by some speakers before me. Regarding non-tariff measures, although we welcome the serious legislative harmonization effort Colombia has embarked upon, we remain concerned about the persistence of non-tariff barriers mentioned in the Secretariat report, particularly those relating to registration requirements, non-automatic import licensing and the high number of regulations in certain sectors. In addition, we are interested in learning more about unilateral measures raising tariffs in certain goods such as fertilizers. 4.358. At the same time, we are also interested in learning more details about Colombia's investment subsidies and incentive programmes, such as Colombia Repunta. Equally, Israel as a country immersed in efforts to reduce the cost of living, would like to know more about Colombia's efforts to promote competition and reduce inflation. 4.359. At the multilateral level, Israel values Colombia's contribution to the WTO, where we have shared values and supported common areas of interest in the DDA context. We have in addition collaborated in various fora such as Friends of the System, and participated in plurilateral initiatives such as the ITA expansion and TiSA. In the context of our collaboration, we take this occasion to congratulate Colombia for recently becoming a member of the OECD. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 46 4.360. It is Israel's view that Colombia has stood firmly as a strong advocate of the multilateral trading system during the period under review. 4.361. In closing, we would like to take this opportunity to once again extend our appreciation and wish Colombia every success in this Trade Policy Review. BENIN 4.362. The delegation of Benin would like to pay tribute to Colombia's efforts during the review period 2012-2017. 4.363. The Colombian economy recorded annual growth rates of more than 4% between 2012 and 2014 before experiencing a decline in exports, particularly oil and other raw materials, and a slowdown in domestic demand. GDP rose by 2% in 2016 and by 1.8% in 2017. These figures show that Colombia withstood the fall in commodity prices in an environment marred by external shocks. 4.364. The sound economic fundamentals of the Colombian economy are underpinned by an orderly macroeconomic policy. The country ranks third in the Latin American and Caribbean region in terms of both growth and ease of doing business. 4.365. The various structural reforms undertaken by Colombia to boost productivity, further consolidate the country's main macroeconomic indicators, introduce export diversification strategies, set sanitary standards, promote financial inclusion and introduce a tax reform, have helped enhance its economic performance and build further trust among investors. 4.366. The positive trends in external trade, reflected by a 12% annual increase in services export value between 2014 and 2016, are also worthy of mention. 4.367. As regards multilateral trade commitments, Colombia has signed the protocols on telecommunications and financial services annexed to the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS). 4.368. The delegation of Benin welcomes the decisive part played by Colombia in the Doha Round of multilateral trade negotiations. In this connection, it wishes to express its deep appreciation to the Ambassador and Permanent Representative of Colombia to the World Trade Organization (WTO), H.E. Mr Juan Carlos González, and his staff, for their engagement and constructive role in the WTO trade negotiations. 4.369. Among his other responsibilities, Ambassador González served as an excellent Chairperson of the WTO Trade Policy Review Body in 2017. 4.370. The delegation of Benin is grateful to Colombia for the constructive support it provides for LDCs, promoting their interests and priorities in the ongoing Doha Round negotiations. 4.371. It welcomes the trusting and cooperative ties between Benin and Colombia, which have led to cultural exchanges, partnership in development between the C-4 and Colombia, and Colombia's support in the WTO trade negotiations on cotton. 4.372. It hopes that the efforts, initiatives and reforms undertaken by Colombia will continue, delivering outcomes in support of inclusive sustainable development in the short, medium and long term. 4.373. The delegation of Benin thanks the WTO Secretariat and the Government of Colombia for their highly informative reports relating to the current trade policy review of Colombia. 4.374. It wishes Colombia every success and a productive trade policy review. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 47 PARAGUAY 4.375. The steady growth in GDP over the review period and the Colombian authorities' strong commitment to their reform programme bode well for the future. It is encouraging for a country such as Paraguay to see how the Colombian Government has overcome obstacles, achieving peace and building an equitable and educated economy aligned with international best practice and standards. We congratulate Colombia on joining the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development. 4.376. The setting of targets, continuous improvement of indices and the environment for doing business, financial inclusion, and poverty reduction should lead to sustainable development. Signs of diversification of the export base and in the sectors receiving foreign investment, along with the success achieved in terms of non-traditional exports, could well boost a structural transformation of the Colombian economy. 4.377. On the other hand, there are still challenges to overcome. The setback caused by the fall in oil revenue has affected the country's finances and hence its risk rating. This suggests the need to step up diversification efforts and to continue working towards greater competitiveness and productivity. 4.378. With respect to the latter, it is necessary for the reform process to continue focusing on market-based solutions. Mechanisms such as the price band system, especially as applied to certain agricultural products, provide producers with artificial protection, entail additional costs for consumers and affect the transparency and predictability of foreign trade. 4.379. I should highlight the excellent bilateral relations between my country and Colombia, not only in the economic sphere, but also at the political, social and cultural levels. We are two neighbouring countries united by history. Solidarity between the Colombian and Paraguayan peoples is well known and widely recognized by Colombians and Paraguayans alike. A range of joint cooperation projects are under way in all areas. 4.380. At the WTO, we work in coordination on various issues and share a strong interest in promoting agricultural reform. The delegation of Colombia has been proactive and is a staunch defender of the multilateral system. We are grateful for the cooperation we have been receiving from that delegation for many years now. 4.381. Economic and trade relations between the two countries are governed by the long-standing MERCOSUR-Andean Community Economic Complementarity Agreement, under which we are seeking to deepen complementarity and promote regional integration. In this connection, Economic Complementarity Agreement (ACE) No. 72, signed between MERCOSUR and Colombia in July 2017, contains further specific provisions concerning industrial goods such as textiles, made-up articles, metal-mechanical products and vehicles, and will help boost economic relations. 4.382. Trade between Colombia and Paraguay is significant albeit still well below potential. Colombia's main exports to Paraguay include industrial goods and pharmaceuticals, while Colombia's leading imports from Paraguay are pharmaceuticals, cotton and meat products. 4.383. I would like to offer renewed congratulations to those leading this review and to the delegates from the Permanent Mission of Colombia in Geneva for their invariably active involvement in the different areas of the WTO's work. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 48 5 REPLIES BY THE REPRESENTATIVE OF COLOMBIA AND ADDITIONAL COMMENTS 5.1. I should like to begin this second session by thanking both you and the Secretariat for your outstanding commitment and constant support during the conduct of our fifth trade policy review. I likewise thank all Members of the Organization for their active participation, the questions received, the comments and recommendations made and the high level of attendance, all of which testifies to the importance of this exercise in transparency. I should also like to extend particular recognition to Ambassador José Luis Cancela for his sound analysis and recommendations in regard to our policies and programmes. 5.2. For me personally and for my delegation it was especially meaningful to listen to Members of this Organization last Tuesday when reference was made to the peace process and to Colombia's accession to the OECD. 5.3. The importance we accord within our country to these two milestones in our recent history becomes even greater with the realization that these events extend beyond our national boundaries, given the significant impact they are sure to have on the future of Latin America. 5.4. We bear a great responsibility as we address the tremendous challenges of this post-conflict phase while continuing to strive for the highest standards in our public policies. What is certain is that a peaceful context will afford us more space within which to devote our energies to other priority areas such as education, innovation and enhanced competitiveness. 5.5. This new Colombia will continue to advance along the path of development, its trade policy playing a central role in achieving our ultimate ongoing objective of eliminating poverty and improving the quality of life of our citizens. 5.6. As we mentioned last Tuesday, today more than ever we need the multilateral trading system to ensure a context within which we can maximize our potential as a world food supplier. 5.7. For this reason, considerations such as enhanced transparency and predictability in the establishment of maximum residue limits will be a key factor in seizing the opportunities that have been created with the strategy of international market integration. 5.8. At the same time, we hope that our steel and aluminium exporters, which have been affected by recent unilateral measures, will be able in the very short term to recover the preferential access which in many cases gave rise to significant investment that is now threatened by circumstances entirely beyond their control. We are likewise concerned about the announcements that have been made regarding auto parts and the measures that might be taken in that regard. 5.9. Regarding the comments by Ambassador Cancela, to whom we reiterate our gratitude for his contribution to this review, we should like first to address the question of export diversification. We are on the right track because we have succeeded in reversing the tendency to concentrate on mining/energy exports and have this year continued to post positive results. 5.10. The latest figures, reflecting performance from January to April of this year, reveal that total exports rose by 16.6%, while exports of manufactures achieved an increase of 22.4% over the same period the previous year. 5.11. These results are the fruit of the measures taken to derive greater benefit from the trade agreements in force. In addition to improving the supply conditions, we have stepped up our dealings with the health and technical authorities of the new markets in the interests of securing speedy and efficient access for our main export products. 5.12. We would also like to highlight two key strategies which are currently being pursued by Colombia and which were the subject of questions from a number of Members interested in learning about the corresponding goals and objectives. 5.13. The first of these, known as Alianzas Agroexportadoras (Agro-Export Alliances), is the result of a consolidated effort between the authorities responsible for foreign trade, agriculture and WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 49 inspection, surveillance and sanitary control, in the interests of boosting the share of agricultural exports in our total external sales. 5.14. Under this initiative, we are developing 29 projects aimed at enhancing the quality, productivity and marketing of exportable agricultural products including cocoa, palm oil, tropical fruits and fish farming products. A good proportion of the projects will be implemented in the most conflict-affected areas, bringing the benefits of international trade to the communities whose need is greatest. 5.15. Also, as part of the National Productive Development Policy approved in August 2016, the Government has developed a range of tools designed to build the capacity of enterprises, including MSMEs, to innovate, adopt an entrepreneurial approach and to absorb and transfer knowledge and technology. 5.16. To conclude this first part relating to general considerations, I should like to refer to the country's macroeconomic situation, taking into account the comments made by the Discussant. 5.17. Since Colombia's last trade policy review in June 2012, the country's economy has experienced a number of adverse events, both external and internal, that have threatened its macroeconomic balance. 5.18. Since mid-2014 the abrupt fall in international raw material prices, particularly oil, coal and other mining goods, provoked a deterioration in the terms of trade and a consequent drop in national revenue. 5.19. This situation coincided with an economic slowdown among our main trading partners which had a negative effect on our exports. All of this, compounded by a reduction in the food supply due to an adverse climatic event in mid-2015, slowed economic growth and pushed up inflation levels. 5.20. The Colombian economy absorbed these adverse shocks through the depreciation of its currency, the implementation of a tax reform aimed at compensating for the loss of oil revenue, and moderate interest rate increases to curb inflationary pressures. 5.21. Colombia's handling of this situation confirms once again that its macroeconomic policies are rooted in prudent management and include important tools for countering external shocks. The country's economy achieved an orderly adjustment thanks to the timely response of the monetary, exchange and fiscal authorities, in the latter case in line with the fiscal rule, deemed positive by the Discussant. Thematic aspects 5.22. Let me now turn to some of the specific points raised by Ambassador Cancela and by Members, both in their statements and in their questions. I shall focus on recurring issues, since we have replied to all of the concerns expressed. 5.23. Regarding the concerns as to difficulties and delays with regulatory changes and the entry into force of the Trade Facilitation Agreement and other international commitments, it is important to be aware that Colombia's domestic procedures, in addition to requiring the approval of two authorities, namely the Congress and the Constitutional Court, have been subject to additional delays owing to the priority accorded to the instruments for implementing the peace agreements. We are confident that that situation will soon have been resolved. 5.24. In response to the comments regarding regulation, I would note that during the process of our accession to the OECD, and on the recommendation of the Committee on Public Governance, the National Government took the following measures: 1. Standardization of the period of public consultation for all decrees to 15 days. 2. Guide on the conduct of public consultations as part of the law-making process. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 50 3. Development of a single platform for public consultation on regulatory drafts issued by ministries and administrative departments. 4. Elimination of some 1,300 processes in order to simplify life for citizens, and establishment of the Regulatory Improvement Group. 5.25. With the implementation of these changes we are confident that the business climate in Colombia will improve even further and that a higher degree of legal certainty will be afforded to domestic and foreign entrepreneurs. 5.26. Where maritime services are concerned, we take note of the interest expressed by Members in regard to cabotage services. In the area of financial services, last May saw the publication of the draft decree and of the supporting documents for the regulatory proposal that should complete our alignment with Basel III. 5.27. As regards telecommunication services, we share information on Colombia's comprehensive strategy for development of the digital economy, seeking to ensure that the country leads the region in the development of information technology-based industries through, among other things, the implementation of strategic actions to improve the institutional framework, and the development of a policy on digital content, talent and digital security, among other things. We also explain in detail the rules of competition that apply within this sector. 5.28. We reiterate the fact that Colombia is committed to respecting intellectual property rights at both regional and multilateral level. We have ratified the main treaties in that regard, and in some areas our domestic legislation affords higher levels of protection than those provided for in the WTO Agreements. In recent years, Colombia has been working to improve enforcement, build institutional capacity and promote intellectual property as a driver for development. 5.29. The Colombian State respects intellectual property rights, and frames that respect within the principles of fairness, reasonableness and balance between holders' rights and the public interest. We are therefore adopting into our domestic legislation the limitations and flexibilities provided to us by the multilateral environment, in all cases within the domestic and international framework and in line with the country's bilateral commitments. 5.30. Thus, Colombia identified the need to clarify the concept of declaration of public interest for compulsory licensing purposes and therefore issued a regulation to the effect that the sole purpose of this procedure is to determine whether or not a compulsory licence should be granted in respect of patented products or processes. 5.31. On the matter of investment, we thank you for your comments regarding the level of openness of Colombia's legislation and the significant reforms adopted during the review period. 5.32. We wish to refer especially to the comments that a number of Members made in regard to the need to reduce tariff protection in the agricultural sector. In this regard, it should be noted that Colombia has continued to play an active role in the agriculture negotiations aimed at achieving substantial progressive reductions in domestic support and tariffs. From the Cairns Group and with other Members we have co-sponsored a number of technical and negotiating documents. We reiterate our commitment to the achievement of progress in various pillars. 5.33. Some countries pointed out that Colombia continues to maintain measures that impede trade, such as import prohibitions, non-automatic licensing for a considerable number of goods, and complicated registration procedures. 5.34. It should be clarified in this regard that import prohibitions and non-automatic licensing are applied for the protection of human, animal and plant health, public morals, the environment and national security. 5.35. The registration requirement for the importation of goods into Colombia does not constitute an additional requirement. It arises when a government authority has to certify compliance with a sanitary or technical requirement. The procedure has been streamlined by means of the Single WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 51 Window for Foreign Trade, which groups together over 135 procedures that were previously handled by 21 different entities. Non-automatic licensing, for its part, is applied to only 2.4% of tariff lines covering goods which, by their nature, require special controls. 5.36. I should like to turn now to a number of customs policy matters that were the subject of questions and comments from various Members. 5.37. The first of these concerns the fulfilment of commitments under the Agreement on Trade Facilitation, which Colombia placed in category A and which will become a requirement once it has ratified the Agreement before the WTO. In this regard, it should be mentioned that, within the context of our customs modernization strategies, in addition to amending the legislation we have made progress on strengthening the risk management system by evaluating the behaviour of foreign trade operators and through the comprehensive automation of the operations in question. 5.38. Notwithstanding the extension to November 2019 of the time-frame for full implementation of the new customs regulations, we have made progress on the most relevant processes. We will shortly be testing processes relating to freight, customs transit, express delivery and courier services, and in the latter part of the year we intend to complete work on the customs clearance process, thereby covering 60% of the operations provided for in the customs legislation. 5.39. Furthermore, certain provisions have now come into effect, such as those relating to international logistical distribution centres; advance rulings; origin verification processes; preshipment inspection; reshipping; laboratory testing; the option of not using a customs broker to carry out customs operations; application for reconsideration; publication and availability of information; risk management; approved exporter and benefits for authorized economic operators. Some of these form part of the Trade Facilitation Agreement. 5.40. With respect to the comments by one delegation regarding the use of reference prices, which the delegation described as prohibited where customs valuation is concerned, it is to be noted that Colombia applies them by virtue of the reasonable means provided for in Article 7 of the WTO Agreement on Customs Valuation. In the same vein, the WCO also views reference prices as a component of the risk management system. 5.41. The tariff and customs measures for imports of apparel and footwear, which are clearly explained in the Secretariat report, are being examined by a panel, and for this reason we prefer not to make any further comments within this forum. At the same time, however, we would call for enhanced cooperation between customs authorities on the exchange of information at the different stages of control of the entry and exit of goods in each country. 5.42. We have come to the end of this fifth trade policy review with a feeling of satisfaction at the recognition and confidence that Members have expressed in the economic policies and reform programmes we have undertaken. 5.43. We are pleased to note that many Members highlighted the fact that, despite the challenging international economic circumstances, Colombia's economy has continued to perform positively. 5.44. We are encouraged by the constructive spirit of the recommendations made by the Discussant and by Members. Our country is unquestionably engaged in an ongoing process of transformation, in which numerous policies have to be consolidated and strengthened. Both the implementation of the Peace Agreement and the current global economic context present us with many challenges and tasks. You may rest assured that we shall remain firm in our commitment to improving our policies and practices. 5.45. We are pleased to note that Members have recognized Colombia's commitment to a stable, transparent and rules-based multilateral trading system. We once again express our gratitude to the Secretariat for the support provided, and our special thanks to the interpreters for their work. 5.46. Finally, our first Nobel prize winner, Gabriel García Márquez, said: "I believe it is not yet too late to construct a utopia that allows us to share the earth". WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 52 5.47. It is not too late … Colombia achieved peace. 5.48. It is not too late … Colombia is building a society with more openings for women. 5.49. Nor, indeed, is it too late for dreaming about a utopia in which Colombia can win the World Cup that kicks off today. Thank you. DISCUSSANT 5.50. I should like to begin by congratulating the Vice-Minister of Foreign Trade of Colombia, Mrs. Olga Lucía Lozano, and her delegation on the success of this fifth trade policy review, as was clearly evidenced by the 39 statements delivered last Tuesday, 12 June, and by the questions submitted by Members, the number of which exceeded by far the number of days in a year. 5.51. It is also worth recalling that attention was drawn to the importance of the Peace Agreement in Colombia and of the dividends it is already beginning to yield, and that Colombia was commended for its strong commitment to the rules-based multilateral trading system, to trade liberalization and to the wide-ranging reform process in which it is engaged. 5.52. Without prejudice to what has already been stated, I would like to point out that in the course of the presentations made during the first session, Members were particularly clear on, among other things, the following: They highlighted the need for greater export diversification. They noted the desirability of imparting more transparency and stability to the environment of the legal and regulatory provisions governing economic and trade matters, and also expressed the view that the task of reforming the licensing system should continue. They stressed the need to submit outstanding notifications, particularly in regard to agriculture. They mentioned the need to make changes in the schedules in order to implement the Nairobi Ministerial Decisions. They underlined the need to continue with the process of simplifying and standardizing the regulatory framework and with the reform, and to make the licensing regime more transparent. They highlighted the increasing number of anti-dumping investigations in relation to the previous trade policy review, pointing out that that tool should be used in moderation. A number of delegations underscored their concern at the use of reference prices for customs valuation and at certain customs control procedures. Concern was also expressed at the import restrictions that could result from the Andean Price Band System. A number of Members invited Colombia to become a full member of the WTO Agreement on Government Procurement. Members affirmed the significance of the road taken by Colombia towards implementation of the Trade Facilitation Agreement and emphasized the need to proceed to final ratification. The importance of Colombia's accession to the OECD as its 37th Member was highlighted. Attention was also drawn to the country's positive international integration through the Pacific Alliance, and through the negotiation, signing and entry into force of new free trade agreements. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 53 Colombia's legislation and programmes relating to MSMEs was highlighted. 5.53. Finally, the work of the Permanent Representation of Colombia to the WTO was commended, as was that of Ambassador Juan Carlos González as Chairperson of the Trade Policy Review Body during 2017. 5.54. To conclude, I would like to acknowledge the fact that the Vice-Minister of Foreign Trade has just responded thoroughly and comprehensively to the concerns raised by Members in the previous session, having also pointed out that Colombia replied to all the advance written questions. I once again congratulate the Vice-Minister and her delegation, as well as the delegation in Geneva, on their participation and on the success of this trade policy review. EUROPEAN UNION 5.55. Let me first thank the Colombian delegation for the comprehensive overview of the recent economic developments in Colombia presented on Tuesday and this morning that provided a good opportunity to gain a better understanding of the main developments occurred during the period under review and to assess the trade and investment climate based on the comments of a large number of Colombian trading partners. 5.56. The EU would like to congratulate Colombia on its progress in implementing the peace agreements which will further sustainable economic development. Furthermore, the EU would like to highlight that the EU-Colombia Trade Agreement contributed to a diversification of Colombia's economy as the share of mineral products in its exports decreased from 73% in 2012 to 46% in 2017 and we have also taken good note of the efforts Colombia is pursuing in this regard. 5.57. The EU is confident that this review will help Colombia to adopt the appropriate measures in order to overcome some of the issues that are considered as a concern by several Members. In particular, the EU would like to underline once more its encouragement to cut red tape and procedures for effectively accessing Colombia's market, to simplify the overly complex taxation regime, and to eliminate the most distorting technical barriers to trade. We have again taken good note of the statement this morning. 5.58. The EU appreciates the timely and exhaustive replies provided to the EU questions by Colombia. Nevertheless, we have submitted a few follow-up questions and look forward to their replies in due time. UNITED STATES 5.59. The delegation of the United States would like to express its appreciation to Deputy Minister Lozano for her excellent stewardship at Colombia's fifth trade policy review, to Ambassador Cancela for his insightful remarks which helped guide us through the review and the excellent efforts and contributions of Colombia's Geneva Mission and officials in Bogotá in providing responses to Members' questions, and to the Secretariat staff for their hard work in preparing the policy review documents that made our discussion possible. 5.60. The large number of questions from Members highlight the keen interest we have in trade related developments in Colombia. In particular, we appreciate the remarks this morning acknowledging our and other Members' interest in gaining further clarity in Colombia's efforts to diversify its economy, the status of Colombia's TFA ratification, Colombia's use of non-automatic licensing and burdensome and costly import procedures. 5.61. We thank Deputy Minister Lozano for her remarks today and her efforts to address the comments offered by Members during this review. 5.62. The United States submitted a number of written questions to Colombia and we appreciate the written responses we have received. These responses will be helpful to us as we continue our engagement with Colombia, bilaterally and here at the WTO. We also submitted some follow-up questions to clarify some of Colombia's earlier responses. We look forward to Colombia's written responses to those follow-up questions. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 54 5.63. However, as the United States noted in its opening statement on Tuesday, we remain concerned that many of the provisions of the 2016 customs statute are not yet implemented and that Colombia is delaying implementation on many of the provisions, according to the Secretariat report by 15 months until November 29. If possible, we would appreciate it if Colombia could provide a more detailed status update today on its efforts to implement that customs statute and what efforts it could contemplate making to accelerate implementation. 5.64. In conclusion, we appreciate the opportunity to participate in Colombia's trade policy review and reiterate our commitment to support your reform efforts however we can. We offer our congratulations to Deputy Minister Lozano and the entire delegation on a useful and successful Trade Policy Review. MRS. OLGA LUCÍA LOZANO (HEAD OF DELEGATION) 5.65. Thank you, Mr Chairperson. I should like to thank the European Union and the United States for their statements, and to reiterate our gratitude to the Discussant for his work and for his comments with respect to Colombia's trade policy. 5.66. I shall be very brief. Most of the matters to which you have referred will be addressed in our follow-up responses to the questions we have received. 5.67. On the matter of streamlining procedures, where we understand there to be some concern, we would like to point out that Colombia is implementing a policy known as Menos Trámites Más Simples (Fewer formalities with less red tape), the aim of which is to analyse the steps involved in a range of procedures in Colombia with a view to their simplification. We hope that in the coming months we will have results in the form both of executive and congressional instruments. 5.68. As regards notifications, which have also been mentioned, we undertake to effect the notification arising from the Nairobi commitments during the course of this week. 5.69. Where the subject of customs is concerned, we remain very keen to facilitate trade. The only reason why our customs provisions are being implemented gradually is because of the need to upgrade computer systems, and we are sure that we will be able to comply both with our trade facilitation commitments and with our commitment to make import and export procedures increasingly simple. 5.70. I reiterate our thanks to Members for the manner in which they participated in this trade policy review. Thank you. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 55 6 CONCLUDING REMARKS BY THE CHAIRPERSON 6.1. This fifth Trade Policy Review has allowed us to deepen our understanding of Colombia's trade and investment policies, and in particular, of the several reforms and changes introduced since the last Review in 2012. I would like to thank the Colombian delegation headed by Mrs. Olga Lucía Lozano, Vice-Minister of Foreign Trade, for her very constructive engagement throughout this exercise. I would also like to thank our discussant, Ambassador José Luis Cancela, Permanent Representative of Uruguay to the WTO, for his interesting and insightful remarks, as well as the 39 delegations which took the floor the first day, for their active participation in this review. 6.2. Colombia was praised for its commitment to trade liberalization and for achieving economic growth during the review period, with real GDP expanding at an annual average rate of 3.3% between 2012 and 2017, while maintaining a relatively low level of inflation. Members also commended Colombia for implementing an economic reform programme that included tax incentives, reductions in tariffs and other taxes, improvements in the investment regime and increased infrastructure investment. Members encouraged Colombia to continue its reform efforts. Colombia was also congratulated for its recent signature of an accession agreement to the OECD, which was seen as further proof of its commitment to structural reforms and adherence to high international standards. 6.3. Members also welcomed Colombia's signature of an internal peace agreement in 2016 that was considered an essential foundation for the country's stability and future economic and social development. 6.4. While commending Colombia for these achievements, Members also noted the challenges remaining in some areas, including the need to step up efforts to diversify the production and export base, and simplify the regulatory framework, as well as alleviating poverty and promoting social inclusion, particularly in rural areas. 6.5. Members acknowledged Colombia's strong commitment to the rules-based multilateral trading system and its active participation in the WTO. In particular, they praised its leadership as coordinator of the Joint Statement Initiative on Investment Facilitation for Development; its contribution to the negotiations on agriculture and on fisheries subsidies; and the Colombian Ambassador's excellent recent chairmanship of the TPRB, H.E. Ambassador Juan Carlos González. It was also noted that Colombia was a signatory to the MC11 initiatives on e-commerce, domestic regulation in services, SMEs and women's economic empowerment. Noting that Colombia was still in the process of ratifying the Trade Facilitation Agreement, Members urged it to conclude its procedures to accept the TFA as soon as possible. The Representative of Colombia stated that this would be done by the end of 2018. Some Members also encouraged Colombia to put up to date its WTO notifications in areas such as domestic support in agriculture, import licences, subsidies, and services, and to submit the required changes to its schedules to implement the Nairobi Ministerial Decision to eliminate export subsidies in agriculture. 6.6. Members noted that, during the review period, Colombia had also actively pursued regional integration and the conclusion of free trade agreements, including the Pacific Alliance and other bilateral and regional agreements with key trading partners. 6.7. Members expressed their appreciation for the recent measures adopted by Colombia aimed at improving its investment regime, which were seen as providing new opportunities for foreign direct investment. Interest was also expressed with respect to the financial and non-financial incentives provided for Small and Medium Enterprises. 6.8. It was acknowledged that since the last Review, Colombia had adopted a number of measures to modernize its legal framework and facilitate trade. For example, the strengthening of the Single Window for Foreign Trade, the implementation of a risk management system and a simultaneous inspection system for containerized cargo, the introduction of an Authorized Economic Operator scheme, and the promulgation of a new Customs Statute. However, some Members noted that a number of provisions of the Customs Statute had not yet been implemented. Overall, Colombia was encouraged to improve the implementation and enforcement of legislation and to increase efforts towards regulatory transparency. WT/TPR/M/372 • Colombia - 56 6.9. Members appreciated that Colombia has a relative open trade regime with an average MFN tariff of 7.1% in 2017. However, they expressed concern over certain areas and invited Colombia to address them. These include: the widespread use of registration and import licensing requirements; the use of reference prices for imports of textiles, clothing and footwear; taxation rules on beer; complex customs procedures; certain labelling requirements; and the scraping scheme for trucks. Members also noted the increased use of trade contingency measures, in particular the greater number of antidumping investigations initiated during the review period. 6.10. Members acknowledged the changes introduced by Colombia to improve efficiency in government procurement, and invited Colombia to consider becoming a party to the GPA in light of the importance of this sector to its economy. 6.11. Colombia was also commended for the improvements made to its framework for the protection of intellectual property rights (IPRs) since the last review. However, some Members highlighted the need for a transparent and accountable implementation of the IPRs provisions related to pharmaceuticals in the National Development Plan; others stated that they would monitor the implementation of rules relating to the use of compulsory licences. 6.12. Some Members praised Colombia for playing an active role in pursuing agricultural policy reform, while others noted that imports of agricultural products face higher tariffs than imports of non-agricultural products. Some concerns were expressed regarding the effect of the Andean Price Band System and Sanitary and Phytosanitary requirements on trade flows. 6.13. Members commended Colombia for maintaining an open services regime. Some referred in particular to improvements in the telecommunications sector; others highlighted progress made in air connectivity and the efforts to promote tourism, which had produced some good results. Colombia's open regime in maritime transport was also welcomed. In the energy sector, Colombia was invited to continue its efforts to reduce fossil fuel subsidies. 6.14. Colombia has provided answers to almost all the 370 advance written questions raised by Members. This TPR will be successfully concluded once Colombia has replied to all outstanding questions that emerged during the meeting in a month's time as it is the practice. I believe Members felt heartened by the reforms undertaken and the good results achieved by Colombia and encouraged it to persevere in that path and address the remaining challenges. I hope that the discussion held during this review will prove useful to Colombia in the continued implementation of economic and trade reforms and in its pursuit of policies to achieve sustainable growth and increase competitiveness. __________