Rutherford scattering
Rutherford’s Scattering Experiment
Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden worked with Ernest Rutherford in his
Manchester laboratories in 1909. They fired alpha particles (which they knew
to have a positive charge) of a few MeV into a thin piece of gold foil. This was
done in an evacuated chamber connected to a vacuum pump.
When the alpha particles passed through the gold foil they hit a zinc sulphide
screen which emits light whenever an alpha particle strikes it. This screen was
observed using a moving microscope in a dark room.
At the time the accepted structure of the atom was like a plum pudding:
positive dough spread evenly with negative electrons scattered through out it
like plums in a pudding.
Results
Geiger and Marsden found that almost all of the alpha particles passed through with
little or no deflection. Rutherford suggested moving the microscope in front of the
foil, when they did they found that about 1 in every 8000 was ‘reflected’ back or
scattered through an angle of more that 90°.
If the plum pudding model was the structure of the atom this would be like firing a
bullet at a piece of toilet paper and it bouncing back!
The Nuclear Model
Rutherford used these results to make the following conclusions:
Most of the mass must be gathered in one small volume – the nucleus.
They can repel a fast moving alpha particle
The nucleus must be positively charged.
They repel positive alpha particles
Most of the atom is empty space.
Only 1 in 8000 alpha particles are deflected
Negative electrons orbit the nucleus at a large distance from it.
Negative charges are needed to keep the atom neutral
Which Particle to Use?
There are two things to consider when using scattering to find the structure of
things: the particle and the energy
Alpha Scattering: Rutherford used alpha particles with energies around 4MeV, any
higher and it would be close enough to the nucleus to experience the strong nuclear
force.
Electron Scattering: Electrons are accelerated to high energies of around 6GeV. They
have enough energy to be scattered within protons and neutrons; discovering
quarks. Electrons travelling at this speed have a de Broglie wavelength 1000 times
smaller than visible light meaning we can see more detail.
X-ray Scattering: X-ray photons have short wavelengths and can be scattered or
completely absorbed by atomic electrons. If the electron is tightly bound or the
photon has very little energy the electron remains in the atom and the photon loses
no energy. This is known as elastic or coherent scattering. If the photon has enough
energy it knocks the electron out of orbit (ionisation) and does lose energy.
Neutron Scattering: Very useful because they are not charged but this limits the
energies they can be accelerated to. Neutrons interact weakly with other nuclei and
do not interact with electrons at all, because of this they can penetrate further. Their
wavelengths are similar to that of atomic spacing, meaning that diffraction will occur.
2
1. State what may be concluded about the structure of the atom from the following observations made
in the Rutherford α-scattering experiment:
a) Most of the α-particles went straight through the gold foil with much scatter.
b) A very small percentage of the positively charged α-particles were scattered through larger
angles by the gold foil.
2. The diagram shows the trajectory of an α-particle as it
travels past the nucleus of a gold atom.
a) Copy the diagram, adding arrows to show the
directions and magnitudes of the forces experienced by
the gold nucleus and the α-particle when the α-particle
is at point A.
b) State a value for the typical size (diameter) of the
nucleus.
3. Name three techniques for investigating the crystalline structure of matter.
4. High speed electrons are diffracted by atomic nuclei.
a) Suggest what electron diffraction demonstrates about the nature of high-speed electrons.
b) Suggest a typical wavelength for the high-speed electrons used to investigate the size of atomic
nuclei.
5. Th e spacing between atoms in a solid is typically 2.0 × 10-10 m. For diffraction of either X-rays or
particles by the solid, the incident wavelength must be comparable to or less than this spacing. For a
wavelength of 2.0 × 10-10 m, calculate:
a) The frequency of the X-rays.
b) The speed of electrons.
c) The speed of neutrons.
6.
The diagram shows the typical diffraction
pattern formed when high-speed electrons are
diffracted by the nuclei of a target material. The
angle θ for the “first diffraction minimum” is
related to the diameter d of a single nucleus and
the de Broglie wavelength λ of a high-speed
electron by the equation:
sin$ =
1.22)
*
3
The wavelength λ of a high speed electron is related to its kinetic energy E, the Planck constant h and the
speed of light in vacuum c by the equation: ) =
!"
#
a) The angle θ is 52° for 420 MeV electrons fired into carbon. Determine the diameter of a nucleus of
carbon (1 eV = 1.6 × 10-19 J).
b) The mass of a single nucleus of carbon is 2.0 × 10-26 kg. Determine the mean density of the carbon
nucleus.
c) The density of matter is about 103 kg/m3. What does
your value for the density of the nucleus suggest about
the structure of atoms?
7. The diagram shows the apparatus used by Rutherford
in his α-scattering experiment. Explain why:
a) The gold foil and the α-source were placed in a
vacuum.
b) The gold foil had to be very thin.
8. List three key conclusions about the nature of the atom that can be drawn from the α-scattering
experiment.
9.
The diagram shows the diffraction
“rings” produced when X-rays of wavelength
2.5 × 10-11 m are diffracted by a thin sample of
copper.
a)
What causes the diffraction of the X-
rays?
b)
State the approximate size (diameter) of
an atom in metres.
c)
A similar diffraction pattern is obtained
when electrons are fired into the copper sample. Estimate the speed of an electron with a de
Broglie wavelength the same as that for the X-rays.
d) Explain why the diffraction pattern formed by the electrons of wavelength 2.5 × 10-11 m cannot
be due to the atomic nuclei of copper.
4
Q1.
The figure below represents an experiment on Rutherford scattering in which α particles are directed at a
gold foil. The detector is shown in two positions in the evacuated chamber.
(a)
Why is it necessary to remove the air from the apparatus?
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(b)
Explain why the gold foil should be very thin.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(c)
Explain why the count rate from the α particle detector in position 1 is much greater than that in
position 2.
What can be deduced from this observation about the structure of the atom and the properties of
the nucleus of gold?
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(Total 6 marks)
5
Q2.
In an experiment to investigate the structure of the atom, α particles are directed normally at a thin
metal foil which causes them to be scattered.
(a)
(i)
In which direction will the number of α particles per second be a maximum?
______________________________________________________________
(ii)
State what this result suggests about the structure of the atoms in the metal.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(b)
A small number of α particles are scattered through 180°.
Explain what this suggests about the structure of the atoms in the metal.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(c)
The figure shows the path of an α particle passing near a nucleus.
(i)
Name the force that is responsible for the deflection of the α particle.
______________________________________________________________
(ii)
Draw an arrow on the diagram in the direction of the force on the α particle in the position
where the force is a maximum.
(iii)
The nucleus is replaced with one which has a larger mass number and a smaller proton
number.
Draw on the diagram the path of an α particle that starts with the same velocity and position
6
as that of the α particle drawn.
Q3.
(a)
The radius of a nucleus may be determined by electron diffraction. In an electron diffraction
experiment a beam of electrons is fired at oxygen-16 nuclei. Each electron has an energy of 5.94 ×
10−11 J.
The approximation, momentum =
(i)
can be used for electrons at this energy.
Show that the de Broglie wavelength λ of each electron in the beam is about 3.3 × 10−15 m.
(2)
(ii)
The graph shows how the relative intensity of the scattered electrons varies with angle due to
diffraction by the oxygen-16 nuclei. The angle is measured from the original direction of the
beam.
The angle θ of the first minimum in the electron-diffraction pattern is given by
Calculate the radius of an oxygen-16 nucleus using information from the graph.
radius = ____________________ m
(1)
7
(b)
Rutherford used the scattering of α particles to provide evidence for the structure of the atom.
(i)
Sketch a labelled diagram showing the experimental arrangement of the apparatus used by
Rutherford.
(2)
(ii)
State and explain the results of the scattering experiment.
Your answer should include the following:
•
•
•
the main observations
the significance of each observation
how the observtions placed an upper limit on the nuclear radius.
The quality of your written communication will be assessed in your answer.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(6)
(Total 11 marks)
8
Nuclear radius
Rutherford gave us an idea of the size of the nucleus compared to the atom but more experimental work has
been done to find a more accurate measurement.
Closest Approach of Alpha Particles
Rutherford fired alpha particles at gold atoms in a piece
of foil. They approach the nucleus but slow down as the
electromagnetic repulsive force become stronger.
Eventually they stop moving, all the kinetic energy has
been converted into potential energy as the particles
come to rest at a distance r from the centre of the nucleus.
EK = EP à EP = qV where V is the electric potential at a distance of r from the centre
EP = q
Q
4pe 0 r
à
EK = q
Q
4pe 0 r
à
r=q
Q
4pe 0 E K
This gives us the upper limit of the radius of a nucleus.
Calculating the nuclear radius this way gives us a value of r = 4.55 x 10-14 m or 45.5 fm (where 1 fm = 1 x 10-15 m)
Modern measurements give us values of approximately r = 6.5 fm
(Remember that 1 eV of energy is equal to 1.6 x 10-19 J)
Electron Diffraction
A beam of electrons were fired at a thin sample of atoms and the
diffraction pattern was detected and then examined.
The graph shows a minimum at a
value of θmin. We can use this to
find a value of the nuclear radius.
sin q min =
0.61l
D
Where D is the nuclear radius and λ is the de Broglie wavelength of the beam
of electrons. We can calculate this as follows:
The kinetic energy gained by the electrons is EK = eV where e is the charge
on the electron and V is the potential difference used to accelerate it. So we now have:
mv 2 = eV à mv 2 = 2eV à m 2 v 2 = 2meV à
m 2 v 2 = 2meV à mv = 2meV
h
h
We can now substitute this into the equation for de Broglie wavelength: l =
à l=
mv
2meV
1
2
Nuclear Radius
From the experimental results a graph was plotted of R against A. A graph like the
one to the right was obtained. They saw that R depends not on A, but on A⅓.
When they plotted the graph of R against A⅓ they found a straight line that cut the
origin and had a gradient of r0. (r0 is a constant representing the radius of a single
nucleon and has a value of between 1.2 and 1.5 fm)
1
R = r0 A 3
The radius of a nucleus has been found to be:
Nuclear Density
Now that we have an equation for the nuclear radius we can calculate the density of a nucleus.
If we have a nucleus of A nucleons, we can assume the mass is Au and the volume is the volume of a sphere:
r=
m
V
à
r=
4
3
Au
pR 3
à
r=
4
3
Au
1
p (r0 A 3 ) 3
à
r=
4
3
Au
pr0 3 A
à
r=
4
3
u
pr0 3
We can see that the density is independent of the nucleon number and gives a value of: 3.4 x 1017 kg m-3.
33
Rutherford scattering: Energy and closest approach
Scattering of alpha particles
Rutherford did not have a particle accelerator. Instead he used alpha particles, typically of energy 5 MeV, from radioactive decay.
These questions are about how close an alpha particle can get to different nuclei.
An alpha particle has charge 2e, where e = 1.60 10–19 C. A nucleus has charge Ze, where Z is the number of protons in the
nucleus (and the number of electrons in the atom). The electrical potential energy of the two charges at a distance r is:
electrical potential energy =
–12
where ϵ0 = 8.85 × 10
2 –1
2e ´ Ze
4pe0 r
–1
C J m .
–19
The electrical potential energy in electron volts is obtained by dividing by 1.60 × 10
–1
J eV
Calculating the potential energy
1.
Show that the units of energy from the expression
electrical potential energy =
2e ´ Ze
4pe0 r
are joules.
2.
Show that the energy in MeV is given by
2Ze
´ 10- 6.
4pe 0r
Alpha scattering by gold
This graph shows the energy in MeV of an alpha particle at distances r from a gold nucleus, Z = 79.
Approach of alpha particle to nucleus
Z = 79 (gold)
25
20
15
10
5
0
0
2
4
6
distance from nucleus /
8
10–14
10
m
3.
Make an arithmetical check to show that at distance r = 1.0 × 10–14 m the electrical potential energy is between 20 MeV
and 25 MeV, as shown by the graph.
4.
How does the electrical potential energy change if the distance r is doubled?
5.
From the graph, at what distance r will an alpha particle with initial kinetic energy 5 MeV colliding head-on with the
nucleus, come to rest momentarily?
34
6.
From the graph, at what distance r will a 5 MeV alpha particle have lost half its initial kinetic energy?
7.
From the graph, what energy would an alpha particle need to approach as close as 2.0 × 10–14 m in a head-on collision?
Alpha scattering by tin
The next graph shows, on the same scale as before, the electrical potential energy of an alpha particle near a nucleus of tin, Z =
50.
Approach of alpha particle to nucleus
Z = 50 (tin)
25
20
15
10
5
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
distance from nucleus / 10–14 m
8.
Why are the values of the electrical potential energy smaller at the same values of r in this second graph?
9.
At r = 5.0 × 10–14 m the electrical potential energies of an alpha particle are 4.55 MeV for gold, Z = 79 and 2.88 MeV for
tin, Z = 50. Explain the ratio, 1.58, of the two energies.
10.
Approximately how close can a 5 MeV alpha particle get to a tin nucleus, in a head-on collision?
Alpha scattering by aluminium
The next graph shows the potential energy of an alpha particle close to an aluminium nucleus, Z = 13.
Approach of alpha particle to nucleus
Z = 13 (aluminium)
25
20
15
10
5
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
distance from nucleus / 10–14 m
11.
From the graph, how close could a 5 MeV alpha particle get to a nucleus of charge? Z = 13, in a head-on collision?
12.
The radius of an aluminium nucleus is approximately 3 × 10–15 m. Does a 5 MeV alpha particle get close to the nucleus,
compared with the dimensions of the nucleus itself? Could the pattern of scattering be affected?
35
Heavy ion colliders
Recently, to investigate very high-energy collisions, accelerators have been used to make head-on collisions between lead nuclei
travelling in opposite directions.
13.
How much kinetic energy is needed to get two lead nuclei, Z = 82, within 1.0 × 10–14 m of one another? (Assume that
electrical forces are the only forces operating.)
Electrons measure the size of nuclei
Scattering by small particles
Hold a glass plate smeared with a little milk, or dusted with lycopodium powder, in front of a point source of light and you may
see rings of light round the source. The photons are diffracted by globules of fat in the milk or by the lycopodium spores.
Similarly to diffraction by a small hole of diameter d, there is a first minimum intensity at an angle θ of order of magnitude given
by sin θ = λ / d. (For circular objects or apertures a more exact expression is sin θ = 1.22 λ / d.)
Angles and wavelengths
1.
Show that if you see a first dark ring at θ = 30°, the circular objects have diameter approximately twice the wavelength.
2.
Use the expression sin θ = 1.22 λ / d to find the angle of the first dark ring for particles four wavelengths in diameter.
Wavelengths for electrons
The de Broglie wavelength λ of an electron of momentum p is given by λ = h / p, where h is the Planck constant, 6.6 × 10–34 J Hz–1.
Since the rest energy of an electron is 0.5 MeV, at energies of hundreds of MeV, the rest energy can be ignored as part of the
total energy E. In this case the momentum p is given to a good approximation by p = E / c.
3.
Calculate the energy in joules of an electron with energy 100 MeV
(take 1 eV = 1.6 × 10–19 J).
4.
Use the value of the energy from question 3 to calculate the momentum of the electron.
5.
Use the value of the momentum from question 4 to calculate the de Broglie wavelength of 100 MeV electrons.
6.
The radius of a single proton or neutron is of the order 1.2 × 10–15 m. What approximately is the ratio of the wavelength
of the electrons to the diameter of a proton or neutron?
7.
Using the relations p = E / c and λ = h / p show that the de Broglie wavelength is inversely proportional to the energy E.
8.
Use the result of question 7 and the answer to question 5 to show that the de Broglie wavelength for 400 MeV electrons
is about 3.0 × 10–15 m.
Electron scattering by nuclei
You have seen that electrons of a few hundred MeV have de Broglie wavelengths comparable to the diameter of a nucleus.
Suppose that in an experiment a beam of 400 MeV electrons is scattered by carbon-12 nuclei. The angle θ at which the scattering
is first a minimum is 42°, for which sin θ = 0.67.
9.
Calculate the ratio λ / d of the de Broglie wavelength to the diameter of a carbon-12 nucleus.
10.
Use the de Broglie wavelength of 400 MeV electrons from question 8 to show that the radius of a carbon-12 nucleus is
–15
about 2.7 × 10 m.
11.
You might expect the volume occupied by the 12 nucleons of carbon-12 to be 12 times the volume occupied by one
nucleon. The radius of a nucleon is about 1.2 × 10–15 m. Show that the ratio of the volumes is about 12 (expect some
rounding error in these figures).
12.
A uranium-238 nucleus has a radius of about 7.4 × 10–15 m. What roughly would be a good energy of electrons to use to
determine its radius by scattering?
36
Q1.
An α particle with an initial kinetic energy of 4.9 MeV is directed towards the centre of a gold nucleus of
radius R which contains 79 protons. The α particle is brought to rest at point S, a distance r from the
centre of the nucleus as shown in the diagram below.
(a)
Calculate the electric potential energy, in J, of the α particle at point S.
electric potential energy = ___________________ J
(2)
(b)
Calculate r, the distance of closest approach of the α particle to the nucleus.
r = ___________________ m
(3)
(c)
Determine the number of nucleons in the gold nucleus.
R, radius of the gold nucleus = 7.16 × 10−15 m
R0 = 1.23 × 10−15 m
37
number of nucleons = ________________
(3)
(d)
The target nucleus is changed to one that has fewer protons. The α particle is given the same initial
kinetic energy.
Explain, without further calculation, any changes that occur to the distance r. Ignore any recoil
effects.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 10 marks)
38
Q2.
(a)
The radius of a nucleus may be determined by electron diffraction. In an electron diffraction
experiment a beam of electrons is fired at oxygen-16 nuclei. Each electron has an energy of 5.94 ×
10−11 J.
The approximation, momentum =
(i)
can be used for electrons at this energy.
Show that the de Broglie wavelength λ of each electron in the beam is about 3.3 × 10−15 m.
(2)
(ii)
The graph shows how the relative intensity of the scattered electrons varies with angle due to
diffraction by the oxygen-16 nuclei. The angle is measured from the original direction of the
beam.
The angle θ of the first minimum in the electron-diffraction pattern is given by
Calculate the radius of an oxygen-16 nucleus using information from the graph.
radius = ____________________ m
(1)
39
(b)
Rutherford used the scattering of α particles to provide evidence for the structure of the atom.
(i)
Sketch a labelled diagram showing the experimental arrangement of the apparatus used by
Rutherford.
(2)
(ii)
State and explain the results of the scattering experiment.
Your answer should include the following:
•
•
•
the main observations
the significance of each observation
how the observtions placed an upper limit on the nuclear radius.
The quality of your written communication will be assessed in your answer.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(6)
(Total 11 marks)
40
Q3.
(a)
Scattering experiments are used to investigate the nuclei of gold atoms.
In one experiment, alpha particles, all of the same energy (monoenergetic), are incident on a foil
made from a single isotope of gold.
(i)
State the main interaction when an alpha particle is scattered by a gold nucleus.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(1)
(ii)
The gold foil is replaced with another foil of the same size made from a mixture of isotopes of
gold. Nothing else in the experiment is changed.
Explain whether or not the scattering distribution of the monoenergetic alpha particles
remains the same.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(1)
(b)
Data from alpha−particle scattering experiments using elements other than gold allow scientists to
relate the radius R, of a nucleus, to its nucleon number, A.
The graph shows the relationship obtained from the data in a graphical form, which obeys
the relationship R = r0
(i)
Use information from the graph to show that r0 is about 1.4 × 10–15 m.
41
(1)
(ii)
Show that the radius of a
V nucleus is about 5 × 10–15 m.
(2)
©
Calculate the density of a
V nucleus.
State an appropriate unit for your answer.
Density ____________________ unit __________
(3)
(Total 8 marks)
42