CMCE10001 Assignment 2 Rubric Weighting 10% 10% 30% 30% Criteria Appropriate article selected Introduction and conclusion Summary of article Integration with existing understanding of sustainable commerce 10% Written style is appropriate for an academic audience. 10% Referencing using APA 7th edition referencing style. Highy proficient Article selected is: - Relevant to sustainable commerce - From a reputable source - Less than 10 years old or is a seminal work Proficient Article selected is: - Not directly relevant to sustainable commerce - From a reputable source - Less than 10 years old or is a seminal work Competent Article selected is: - Not directly relevant to sustainable commerce and/or - From a reputable source, and/or - More than 10 years old Development Required Criteria Unfulfilled Article selected is: A new article was not provided - Not directly relevant to sustainable commerce and/or - Not from a reputable source, and/or - More than 10 years old Provides a concise and complete introduction and conclusion that explains the purpose of the report, outlines the format of the report, and summarises the key ideas in the report linking back to the assignment task. Provides a complete introduction and conclusion Provides an introduction and conclusion that Provides an introduction and conclusion that that explains the purpose and format of the explains some of the purpose and format of the does not adequately explain the purpose and assignment. assignment. format of the assignment. Could be improved by being more concise. Could be improved by being more concise and more complete. Could be improved by being more concise and more complete. Provides a complete response to the assignment question including: - Explanation of the thesis statement - The key findings - Supporting argument(s) - The analytical methods used Provides a strong answer that may not fully explore the key areas of: - Explanation of the thesis statement - The key findings - Supporting argument(s) - The analytical methods used Provides a basic answer that only partially explores the key areas of: - Explanation of the thesis statement - The key findings - Supporting argument(s) - The analytical methods used Provides an answer that needs more A summary of the article was not provided. development to meet the required standard for university work. Key areas may not be discussed, or may be discussed in a simplistic way. Demonstrates a strong understanding of the article. Could be improved by having a more balanced discussion of all aspects of the article. May not answer all key areas, or may lack appropriate depth of analysis and discussion. Could be improved by deeper understanding of the article. Knowledge from the article has been integrated with your understanding of sustainable commerce. Synthesises the article with the three required readings in this subject and knowledge from the lectures and tutorials. Knowledge from the article has been integrated with your understanding of sustainable commerce. Provides some synthesises with the required readings and subject materials. Knowledge from the article has been integrated with your understanding of sustainable commerce. May not provide an adequate synthesises with the required readings or subject materials. Knowledge from the article has not been integrated with your understanding of sustainable commerce. May provide a description of the various sources. May not provide an adequate synthesises with the required readings or subject materials. Uses an appropriate writing style for university, including excellent spelling, grammar, and structure. Uses a mostly appropriate writing style for university, including excellent spelling, grammar, and structure. May containg minor areas for grammatical and/or structural improvement. Only contains very minor spelling errors. Uses a writing style that is acceptable for university writing but needs significant improvement. May contain areas for grammatical and/or structural improvement. May contain spelling errors. Written style is not yet at a standard that is Written style is completely unacceptable for acceptable for university writing. Writing may university work. contain significant spelling, grammatical, and/or structural problems. All sources have been referenced appropriately both in-text and in the reference list using APA 7th edition referencing style. All sources have been referenced appropriately both in-text and in the reference list using APA 7th edition referencing style. May contain minor errors in referencing style. All sources have been referenced appropriately both in-text and in the reference list using APA 7th edition referencing style. May contain errors in referencing style All sources have NOT been referenced appropriately both in-text and in the reference list. And/or, APA 7th edition referencing style is not used. And/or care has not been taken to reference appropriately. An introduction and/or conclusion was not provided. The answer may be descriptive only and not provide appropriate depth of analysis. No attempt was made to integrate knowledge from the article with your understanding of sustainable commerce. No attempt has been made to reference any sources.
