HAS 871 Assessment 3 - ALOHA worksheet There are two parts to this worksheet. You need to complete both parts: Part 1 – Pool fire and thermal radiation calculations Part 2 – Toxic gas release and toxicity calculations When you have entered information into ALOHA record it in the right hand column and answer any questions asked. Part 1 - Pool Fire – n-octane Step 1 – Insert Site Data Set up your session for Metric units Go to menu tab “ Display” Go to “Display Options” Select “Metric” You need to do this every time you use ALOHA List your location – Select Wollongong Location: Wollongong, NSW, AU Building: single storied with unsheltered surroundings Select Date and Time – this may be important if you are choosing a stability class and windspeed that can only occur at certain times eg night. You may need to select more than one time. Date and Time:12th April 2022 22:30 (Stability D) Date and Time: 12th April 2022 12:00 (stability A) Step 2 - Setup Select Chemical Select n-octane Chemical: n-octane N-octane is a chemical that has similar properties to petrol. Select Atmospheric Data Windspeed – 4 m/s Wind Direction North Measurement height above ground 3m (stability D) Windspeed 4m/s Wind Direction N Measurement height above ground 3m (stability A) Windspeed 1m/s Wind Direction N Measurement height above ground 3m Select Ground Roughness This impacts on the amount of mixing that the gas will do due to boundary effects and water can affect vapourisation rates due to temperature Select Open country Select Cloud Cover This changes the amount of incoming solar radiation which can impact of evaporation rates and mixing of atmospheres Cloud Cover: partly cloudy Select Air Temperature Enter 25 degree Celcius Stability Class Initially select D with wind speed of 4 m/s. You will need to vary this to complete the table below Inversion Height Humidity This impacts on the amount of heat radiation absorbed in the water in the air Select Humidity : Medium(50%) Part 3 - Source Set Up Using the “set up” tab from the menu select Source -source type Tank Select vertical cylinder Ground roughness: open country Cloud Cover: partly cloudy Air Temperature: 25 C (step please see below graph) Initial Selection: D No inversion (step please see below graph) Humidity: 50% Tank Type: Vertical Tank diameter: 20m Height: 10m Volume of tank: 3142m3 Enter tank diameter = 20m Enter tank height = 10m What is the volume of the tank in cubic m? Chemical State and State of the chemical in the tank: Liquid Temperature Chemical stored at: 25 C Enter the state of the chemical liquid Enter the storage temperature – 25 deg Celsius Volume in the tank – 90% full Volume in tank : 90% full = 2827m3 Type of Tank Failure Select: Leaking tank, chemical is burning and forms a pool fire Circular opening 0.3 m diameter Short pipe or valve Height from bottom of tank 0.5m What is the scenario? Leaking tank, chemical is burning and forms a pool fire. Size of puddle in square meters 900 m2 Area and type of leak Circular opening 0.3 m diameter Short pipe or valve Height from bottom of tank 0.3m Size of puddle in square meters 900 m2 Opening diameter: 0.3 m Leak is through: short pipe / valve Height of the tank opening Height above the bottom of the tank 0.5m Height above the bottom of the tank: 0.5m Maximum puddle size Enter Maximum area 900m2 Maximum puddle size: maximium area: 900m2 Part 4 – Results – part 1 effect of wind speed on Radiation levels From the calculated results list Maximum flame length: 37m the following information: Burn Duration: limited to 1 hour by ALOHA Maximum flame length Max Burn rate: 3090 kg/min Burn Duration Total amount burned: 183603kg Max Burn rate Puddle diameter: 28m Total amount burned Puddle diameter Heat radiation levels Select “Display” from menu Red threat zone: 23 kW/m2 Select “Threat Zone” Orange threat zone: 12.5 kW/m2 Enter your own level of concern Yellow threat zone: 4.7 kW/m2 (LOC) 23.0 kW/m2 12.5 kW/m2 4.7 kW/m2 Stability Class : A Stability Class : D Document Results Record results Wind Speed: 1 m/s Wind Speed: 4m/s Vary the wind speed and here: stability class to determine 23.0 kW/m2 39m 53m 2 effect of wind speed on 12.5 kW/m 57m 69m 2 radiation levels 4.7 kW/m 95m 104m Cut and paste Threat Zone data from text and thermal radiation threat zone plot from text summary here: Stability class D, 4 m/s information Stability class A, 1 m/s information (0.3) Part 4 – Results – part 2 – Effect of distance on radiation levels Using Stability class D, 4 m/s Max Thermal Radiation Downwind distance (m) Radiation Levels at a (kW/m2) nominated distance Select “Display” from menu 20 92.3 Select “Threat at Point” 40 38.6 Enter “downwind distance”: variable 60 17.4 Enter “cross wind distance”: 0 m 80 8.89 Record Maximum thermal radiation in table below – use information from 100 5.18 the text summary page 120 3.35 Document Results 140 2.32 Vary the downwind distance to 160 1.69 determine effect of distance on thermal radiation levels 180 1.29 200 1.01 Insert at least one Screen shot of Text Summary and graphic for “Threat at Point” Graph your results in excel and display here Graph the effect of how the radiation levels change with distance. Max Thermal Radiation (kW/m2) Max Thermal Radiation level (kW/m2) along downwind distance (m) 100 80 60 40 20 0 0 50 100 150 200 250 Downwind distance (m) Table 1. Max thermal radiation level (kW/m2) along downwind distance(m) The table shows the max thermal radiation level decreases with further downwind distance. Sensitivity Analysis. A sensitivity analysis is when you consider the impact of changing a variable on another variable. 1) Comment on the difference that the different stability classes and wind speed make on the radiation levels at different distances. Why might this be the case? The radiation tend to spread wider under a more stable atmosphere with higher wind speed. The stability and wind speed can explain this phenomenon. Under a less stable class (i.e. class A), the dispersing gas mixes to atmosphere rapidly since there is more turbulent due to incoming solar radiation. With low wind speed, the gas is not spreading wide as it tend to develop and mix vertically, vice versa. Therefore the threat zone of class A low wind speed is short than class D high wind speed. 2) Comment on how the thermal radiation level (kW/M2) changes with distance. Shorter the downwind distance, the higher the radiation level. The trend decreases exponentially along with longer distance, the radiation level reduced to one-third per 20m further from downwind distance. Application of thermal radiation levels to humans. If you were fighting the fire, with normal work clothes, how close could you be. Explain your reasoning. Using class D with 4m/s case, if I were fighting fire with fire fighting PPE, I would be able to withstand maximum 3kW/m2 (NSW Rural Fire Service, 2010), which indicates 126m is my closest distance to pool of fire (as shown in Figure 2). However, with only normal clothings, the limitation of heat flux can be received by a person is no more than 1.5 kW/m2 (Raj, 2008). By adjusting the thermal radiation threat zone, the closest distance is 168m from the pool of fire (as shown in Figure 1). Figure 1 Threat zones under normal clothings Figure 2 Threat zones under fire fighting PPE Part 2 – Toxic gas release - chlorine Step 1 – Insert Site Data Set up your session for Metric units Go to menu tab “ Display” Go to “Display Options” Select “Metric” You need to do this every time you use ALOHA List your location – Select Wollongong Location: Wollongong Infiltration Building Parameters Select Building Type – this impacts on the amount of toxic chemical that can enter the building Select: single storied dwelling Building Surroundings: Unsheltered surroundings Building Type: single storied building Building Surroundings: unsheltered surroundings Select Date and Time – this may be important if you are choosing a stability class and Time: 13th April 2022 02:00 (night) windspeed that can only occur at certain times eg night. Select time suitable for : Stability Class F Windspeed 1 m/s What is the windspeed and atmospheric conditions required for Stability Class F? Class F is the most stable class. Windspeed: low wind speed Atmospheric condition: low temperature, clear sky Step 2 - Setup Select Chemical Select Atmospheric Data Windspeed – 1 m/s Wind Direction North Measurement height above ground 3m Select Ground Roughness This impacts on the amount of mixing that the gas will do due to boundary effects and water can Chlorine Use these values for sensitivity analysis in step4.1 Windspeed – 1 m/s Wind Direction North Measurement height above ground 3m (steps please see above) Ground roughness: Open country (steps please see above) affect vapourisation rates due to temperature Select Open country Select Cloud Cover This changes the amount of incoming solar radiation which can impact of evaporation rates and mixing of atmospheres Cloud Cover: clear Select Air Temperature Enter 10 degree Celsius Stability Class Initially select F with wind speed of 1 m/s. Cloud Cover: Clear (Steps please see above) Air Temperature: 10 C Initial Selection: F See table below You will need to vary this to complete the table below Inversion Height Humidity This impacts on the amount of heat radiation absorbed in the water in the air Select Humidity : Medium(50%) Step 3 - Source Set Up Using the “set up” tab from the menu select Source -source type Tank Tank Size and Orientation Tank orientation – horizontal cylinder Tank Diameter 0.76 m Tank Length – 2 m No inversion (Please see steps above) Humidity: 50% (Medium) (Please see steps above) Tank orientation – horizontal Tank Diameter – 0.76m Tank Length – 2m Volume – 0.91 m3 Chemical State and Temperature Enter the state of the chemical – Tank contains liquid Chemical stored at ambient temperature Chemical state in tank: liquid Ambient temperature: 10 C (environmental temp) Mass or pressure of gas: Mass in tank: 1000 KG Enter the mass in the tank: 1000kg – Liquid Volume is: 0.69m3 the program will calculate the liquid %full is: 76.4% level Area and Type of Leak Opening type: Circular Opening diameter 0.01 m Leak: Short pipe or valve Opening type: circular Opening diameter: 0.01 m Leak: short pipe/valve Height of Tank Opening 0.01m above the bottom of the tank. % of the way to the top of the tank: 1.32% Part 4 .1 – Results – Effect of distance on toxic concentration Toxic Concentrations Results at each LoC Select “Display” from menu Red LoC(m): 364 m Select “Threat Zone” Orange LoC (m): 1800 m Enter the following level of concern Yellow LoC(m): >10000 m (LOC) Fatal dose – 150 ppm IDLH – 10 ppm Odour threshold- 0.1 ppm Cut and paste Toxic Threat Zone graphic here Shelter in place as an option. Impact inside a “shelter in place” location varying no of room changes per hour. Assume location 200m downwind. No of room changes per hour Indoor concentration inside room 200m away from source (ppm) Outdoor Concentration, 200m from source 2.04 6.08 19.8 56.3 157 309 449 449 449 449 449 449 PPM from 200m downwind 0.01 0.03 0.1 0.3 1 3 Graph your results in excel and display here 500 400 300 200 100 0 0,03 0,1 0,3 1 3 No of room changes per hour Indoor concentration inside room 200m away from source (ppm) Outdoor Concentration, 200m from source The maximum concentration with 3 rooms of change per hour. Part 4 .2 – Results – Effect of wind speed and stability class on toxic concentration Toxic Concentrations Red LoC(ppm): 150 ppm Select “Display” from menu Orange LoC (ppm): 10 ppm Select “Threat Zone” Yellow LoC(ppm): 0.1 ppm Enter the following level of concern (LOC) Fatal dose – 150 ppm IDLH – 10 ppm Odour threshold- 0.1 ppm Day temperature 25 deg Celsius Night temperature 10 deg Celsius Select Date and Time Choose 11:00am for a day time Choose 11:00pm for night time. Stability Class and Wind Speed. Notation: Example F 1 F refers to the Stability Class 1 refers to the wind speed in (m/s) Insert Screen shot of Text Summary for the each “Threat Zone” for each F1, A1 and B1 conditions Day Time: 1100 25 C Night Time: 2300 10 C Stability class and Wind Speed Distance to 150 ppm (m) A1 B1 B2 B3 C3 D4 D5 D6 F1** 330 342 278 222 267 225 209 193 364 *assume max distance 10Km ** remember to change to night conditions – temp and time Distance to 10 ppm (m) Distance to 0.1 ppm *(m) 1400 1600 1100 912 1100 996 895 815 1800 8800 9900 10000 9300 10000 10000 9900 9000 10000 distance to certain concentration (PPM) A1 text summary B1 text summary F1 text summary Graph the stability classes and distances to 150ppm and 10ppm in excel and display here 2000 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 A1 B1 B2 B3 C3 D4 D5 D6 F1 Stability classes and Wind Speeds Distance to 150 ppm (m) Distance to 10 ppm (m) Reflect on what you have learnt about these two sensitivity analyses. 1) How changing the no of room changes per hour impacts on the indoor concentration levels The higher the changing rate, the difference between indoor and outdoor decreases, as air change rate increased, more gas from outdoor will be ventilated to indoor, eventually increase indoor concentration. 2) How the stability class and wind speed change the distances to different concentration levels The distance to 150 ppm is not affected much by stability classes and wind speed, however, for 10 ppm, it shows the stronger the wind speed, the shorter the distance to 10ppm (comparing B1, B2, B3). While in an atmospheric stable environment, the distance to reach 10 ppm is further with a calmer stability class (comparing A1, B1, F1). Consider the implications for designing a location to shelter in place for Chlorine and also the importance of understanding the weather conditions during an emergency situation (max 250 words). In ideal situation, chlorine should be stored in an indoor place, where gates and doors can be sealed if leakage occurred in order to prevent the spread. For the location to shelter in place, the closer to the place of incident, the lower the number of room change of the shelter should be in order to avoid contaminant got indoor through ventilating system, such as switching off air conditioning, and close all doors and windows (Bennett, 2009). Door gaps or holes that may let gas get indoor should be covered by wet towel in order to create a safe room (Bennett, 2009). Under different weather conditions, the spread of leakage of chlorine will be affected. The higher the wind speed, the longer the distance of contaminant will spread, as well as a narrower wind direction confidence lines. Whilst with low stability, such as daytime, with low wind speed, the distance of spread will be shorter however, the potential affected area will be wider since mixing of air is active, the contaminant is not tend to spread along downwind (Law and Gimbun, 2020). Since the potential affect area is larger, more residents should be informed to take shelter in place to prevent injuries. Moreover, under F1 stability class, which may be at midnight, extra time for informing residents should be expected as people will be asleep. BENNETT, J. S. 2009. A systems approach to the design of safe-rooms for shelter-in-place. Building simulation, 2, 41-51. LAW, W. P. & GIMBUN, J. 2020. Modeling the effect of hypothetical chlorine leakage from Malay-Sino Chemical Industries using ALOHA software and development of an emergency evacuation route around Teluk Kalong industrial area. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 736, 72015. RAJ, P. K. 2008. A review of the criteria for people exposure to radiant heat flux from fires. Journal of hazardous materials, 159, 61-71. The National Diet of Japan. 2012. The official report of The Fukushima Nuclear Accident Independent Investigation Commission. The National Diet of Japan. Japan, Viewed 20th Apr 2022, <https://www.nirs.org/wp-content/uploads/fukushima/ naiic_report.pdf>