TRANSFORMING THE MSME LANDSCAPE Introduction Public Development Banks (PDBs) and Development Financial Institutions (DFIs) are uniquely and strategically positioned to deliver on a country’s public policy objectives and to address pressing societal challenges and crises. As the unprecedented Covid-19 pandemic has highlighted, governments play an important role in directing and guiding public policies and resources in the public interest (Romero, 2020). This is because investments with high social returns are less likely to attract sufficient private capital if capital allocation is left purely to the market. However, while public finances and service delivery are more strained than ever in the wake of the protracted pandemic, it will always be the first building block (Saeed, 2022). As such, governments – through PDBs and DFIs, for example – are expected to pursue affirmative actions and improve their performance in mobilizing public sector resources in order to catalyze private resources towards increased social investments. CORPORATE PROFILE This distinguishes SBCorp from other BSP Supervised Financial Institutions (BSFIs), including those that are stateowned, such as the Development Bank of the Philippines (DBP) and the Land Bank of the Philippines (LBP). In fact, SBCorp is the only government financial institution (GFI) established and mandated to specifically serve the financing needs of the Philippine MSME Sector. In contrast, other GFIs, i.e., DBP and LBP, have broad policy mandates, including assisting large enterprises as part of their development financing strategies. Furthermore, SBCorp is strategically placed to: 1) address potential market failure by filling gaps in access to MSME credit; 2) undertake both sector-specific and cross-cutting measures such as directing financial resources to vulnerable sectors and/or regions on more favorable terms; 3) incubate, grow and graduate enterprises; and, 4) promote economic stability by playing an important countercyclical role. The Corporation has demonstrated that it can direct public finance to vulnerable sectors and/or regions, enabling effective access to a wide range of financial services. It has likewise performed a critical countercyclical role in times of crises, including during the immediate aftermath of Typhoon Yolanda in 2013 and the current protracted Covid-19 pandemic. Mandate The Small Business Corporation (SBCorp), as a GovernmentOwned and Controlled Corporation (GOCC) classified as a non-bank financial institution (NBFI) by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP), has a clear public policy mandate expressly provided under Republic Act (RA) No. 9501 or the Magna Carta for Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) to “implement comprehensive policies and programs to assist MSMEs in all areas including, but not limited to, finance and information services, training and marketing”. Governance Structure The policymaking body of SBCorp is its Governing Board composed of 11 members, two (2) of whom are ex-officio members (Secretaries of Trade and Industry and Finance) and the rest are Appointive Directors – one (1) private sector representative, one (1) Director to be elected by the Board as President and Chief Executive Officer from among its ranks as provided under Section 18 of RA No. 10149 otherwise known as the GOCC Governance Act of 2011, and seven (7) representatives of the common shareholders based on proportional distribution. Stockholders’ Equity The authorized capital of SBCorp is PhP10.0 billion divided into 80 million common shares and 20 million preferred shares with a par value of PhP100 per share. The enactment of RA No. 11494 or the Bayanihan to Recover as One Act (Bayanihan 2 Act) provided for an additional capital infusion of PhP10.0 billion to SBCorp. Per said Act, the infusion of the capital shall be specifically allocated “to the COVID-19 Assistance to Restart Enterprises (CARES) Program and other financing programs of SBCorp, as well as interest subsidy, to be extended to MSMEs, cooperatives, hospitals, tourism industry and Overseas Filipino Workers (OFWs) affected by the Covid-19 pandemic and by other socioeconomic reversals”. With the downloading of PhP8.08 billion in equity from the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) to SBCorp in November 2020, the PhP10.0 billion authorized capital of SBCorp has been fully subscribed. However, with the expiry of the Bayanihan 2 Act in 30 June 2021, the remaining PhP1.92 billion in supposed additional capital infusion to SBCorp was no longer downloaded by DBM. The same could have been treated as a share premium resulting to an additional paid in capital (APIC) of SBCorp1. The APIC would have been beneficial to the Corporation as it could later act as a safety net against expected future losses in net income arising from the mandated objectives, purposes, and features of the CARES Program as provided for in the Bayanihan 2 Act. This is consistent with the purpose of APIC, which is to provide a layer of defense against potential losses. CORPORATE PERFORMANCE Positive Net Income Since 1991 SBCorp’s PhP10.0 billion capital is intact and has not been impaired at any point in time since inception in 1991. This is despite being significantly undercapitalized for almost 30 years, or up until November 2020. Losses on the SBCorp’s financing programs arising from failure of borrowers to pay have been within the pricing returns and earning capacity of SBCorp’s financing products and investments. SEC Opinion No. 14-13 dated 11 June 2014 – Additional Paid in Capital (APIC) is any contribution of stockholders over the par value of shares. Incidentally, share premium is also defined as the amount received by a firm over the par value of its share. APIC can be infused purposely to eliminate deficit and to support the company’s operations. 1 Cumulatively Issued PhP724.5 Million in Dividends to Stockholders In 2021, SBCorp was able to remit PhP58.6 million in dividends to the National Government and to its other stockholders, bringing the cumulative dividends issued to stockholders to PhP724.5 million as of end-December 2021. This is despite the enormous scale and ongoing challenges arising from the pandemic. The level of dividends – while relatively small compared to those remitted by higher capitalized GOCCs – reflects the needed balancing act between sustainability and developmental objectives required and is expected from the Corporation. Towards this end, SBCorp shall continue to assiduously deliver on its mandate through a corporate governance lens by engaging in an equitable and efficient allocation of the resources and investments entrusted to it by the stockholders while at the same time exacting accountability for the stewardship of said resources. ISO 9001 Certified Since 2015 In 2021, SBCorp was able to maintain its ISO 9001:2015 Quality Management System (QMS) certification for its Head Office and South Luzon Group Office in Makati City and its North Luzon Group Office in Baguio City and secure an ISO 9001:2015 certification for its Mindanao Group Office in Davao City. The Visayas Group Office in Cebu City shall be for ISO 9001:2015 certification in 2022. SBCorp’s ISO 9001:2015 QMS was pursued in accordance with Executive Order (EO) No. 605, series of 2017, which directs the adoption of QMS in the public sector. Being certified as compliant to the international standards on QMS provides comforting reassurance to the public and is part of the organization’s effort to streamline business processes, systems and procedures and promote a culture of excellence. Nevertheless, SBCorp remain committed and shall regularly review its business processes, systems and procedures as well as train and professionalize its workforce to ensure continuous compliance with the requirements of ISO 9001:2015. SEC-OGC Opinion No. 19-14 dated 28 March 2019 – APIC is considered “a premium paid over and above the price of shares,” wherein the amount paid for the shares (as recorded on the balance sheet) is increased but there is no further issuance of shares. APIC will increase owner’s equity (net worth). 2 Strong Corporate Governance, Ranking in the Top 10 in Terms of the Corporate Governance Scorecard for GOCCs from 2018 to 2020 provide the sufficient level of financing needed to help countries and economies successfully emerge from crisis situations. SBCorp ranked Number 7 in 2018, further improved to Number 5 in 2019 and is in the Top 10 (no ranking indicated) in terms of the Corporate Governance Scorecard (CGS) out of the 82 GOCCs in the country. Established on 8 October 2015, CGS is a quantitatively-driven evaluation tool based on existing and globally accepted standards and practices. It is an instrument that assesses the corporate governance initiatives of GOCCs through a methodology benchmarked against the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Principles (OECD Principles) and the ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard (ACGS). SBCorp’s Important Role in Terms of Enterprise Rehabilitation Financing The CGS annually assesses the Corporate Governance performance of GOCCs to help identify and evaluate their strengths and weaknesses compared to existing corporate governance provisions and adherence to best practices and international standards. Along with the Performance Scorecards of GOCCs, the CGS ensures the transparency of GOCCs on their corporate governance initiatives and practices. PRS A Rating with Stable Outlook from PhilRatings Since 2007 In 2021, SBCorp was assigned an Issuer Credit Rating of PRS A with a Stable Outlook by the Philippine Rating Services Corporation (PhilRatings). A company rated PRS A is somewhat more susceptible to the adverse effects of changes in circumstances and economic conditions than higher-rated corporates. Still, the obligor has an above average capacity to meet its financial commitments relative to that of other Philippine corporates. IMPORTANT COUNTERCYCLICAL ROLE The Covid-19 pandemic has demonstrated the central role that governments play in directing and guiding public policies and resources in the public interest. Given efforts to situate policy responses to the pandemic under a building back better approach, it is imperative to rethink the role of PDBs and DFIs in potentially channeling development finance in times of socioeconomic crisis. As Romero (2020) posits, the “right type” of finance needs to flow through the “right type” of institutions as private banks and other private financial institution (PFIs) are unlikely to SBCorp swiftly responded to the unprecedented challenges posed by the Covid-19 pandemic with decisive, targeted, and generous actions, confronting the dual health and economic crisis head-on. Armed with clear and accountable public purpose mandate, the Corporation took full advantage of its built-up expertise and experience in enterprise rehabilitation financing (ERF) by offering appropriate, timely and directed interventions to allow MSMEs some much needed time to breathe and overcome the worst of the crisis. Further, given that SBCorp is within the public sphere, the Corporation was able to effectively work with its public sector partners, e.g., Congress, DTI Negosyo Centers, Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE), among others, and has proactively championed the provision of financing assistance and payment relief to MSMEs adversely affected by the pandemic through the following sector-specific and cross-cutting measures: 1. Approval in April 2020 of the Covid-19 Assistance to Restart Enterprises (CARES) Program. The CARES Program is a PhP1.0 billion special financing facility for micro and small enterprises (MSEs) adversely affected by the pandemic. 2. Approval in May 2020 of the SME PPE Program. This is in view of the steady rise of confirmed Covid-19 cases and the continuing shortage of personal protective equipment (PPE) and Covid-19-specific medical devices such as ventilators and respirators. 3. Approval in June 2020 of the Helping the Economy Recover through OFW Enterprise Start-ups (HEROES) Program. HEROES is a PhP100.0 million special financing facility for repatriated or returning Overseas Filipino Workers (OFWs) due to the pandemic. 4. Payment moratorium on principal repayment for a period of six (6) months to SBCorp borrowers beginning June 2020. As demonstrated by the SBCorp’s swift and decisive response during the pandemic and similar to when Typhoon 3 Yolanda devastated Central Visayas in November 2013, the limited capitalization did not deter the Corporation from fulfilling its mandate to assist MSMEs especially in times of crisis. Perhaps in recognition of SBCorp’s crucial role and proven track record in enterprise rehabilitation financing, Congress approved an additional capital infusion of PhP10.0 billion to SBCorp under RA No. 11494 or the Bayanihan to Recover as One Act (Bayanihan 2 Act), of which PhP8.08 billion was eventually downloaded by the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) to the Corporation in November 2020. SBCorp’s Fundamental Purpose and Important Countercyclical Role SBCorp’s fundamental purpose as expressed in its Mission Statement is to “relentlessly champion the neglected business segments of the country to get them to access the capital needed to grow successfully”. In pursuit of its fundamental purpose and important countercyclical role in MSME financing, SBCorp bucked the trend of risk aversion shown by the Philippine Banking Sector in general and higher capitalized banks, i.e., universal, commercial and thrift banks, in particular amid uncertainty over the protracted dual health and economic crisis. In fact, SBCorp decisively acted countercyclically, more than doubling (115.2%) its MSME loan portfolio, from PhP5.9 billion in end-2019 (pre-pandemic) to PhP12.7 billion in end-2021 (Table 1). Financial Institution Banking Sector UKBs TBs RCBs Microfinance NGOs SBCorp End-Dec 2019 579.1 463.5 73.5 42.1 50.9 5.9 End-Dec 2020 480.5 373.7 64.3 42.5 53.2 7.4 It is also important to highlight that SBCorp’s significant MSME portfolio growth has been achieved through an affirmative action of government under a direct retail credit delivery strategy powered by an internally-developed digital customer onboarding platform and loan origination system. This further lends credence to the countercyclical role of SBCorp in confronting societal challenges in the public interest, in contrast to the firm profit maximization objectives by private banks and other PFIs. The challenges and limitations that the pandemic created prompted SBCorp to enter the digital space. With its business processes, applications and systems going through a continuous process of review and enhancements under an accelerated platformification strategy, this can only lead to more efficient MSME credit delivery systems. As the rapid and significant MSME portfolio generation has demonstrated, SBCorp as an institution has collectively responded to the urgent call to action and implemented immediate and innovative approaches to credit delivery and risk management in light of the unique and unprecedented challenges presented by the pandemic. TRANSFORMING THE MSME LANDSCAPE Table 1. Lending to MSMEs (in billion pesos) End-Dec 2018 574.8 452.8 82.4 39.6 45.0 4.7 spillover from the financial sector to the real economy and support lending in a downturn2 (Bank for International Settlements, 2010). Available BSP data would support this as capital adequacy ratios (CAR) of local banks immediately prior to the pandemic (end-December 2019) indicate that they had sufficient capital buffers to absorb potential losses at the beginning of the pandemic (Glindro et al., 2020). End-Dec 2021 463.1 348.8 68.0 46.3 61.4 12.7 Value Proposition SBCorp’s value proposition is to advocate for the full capitalization of the Philippine MSME development finance agenda, making inroads in unchartered territories and sharing viable financing models with the marketplace. On the other hand, lending by the Philippine Banking Sector contracted by 20 percent during the same two-year period. This is consistent with the procyclical behavior by banks, despite availability of regulatory capital buffers to act as a buffer to absorb shocks arising from financial and economic stress, regardless the source, in order to reduce the risk of As part of the Basel III capital reforms, the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision introduced a series of measures to promote the buildup of regulatory capital buffers in good times that can be drawn upon in periods of stress to support new business or lending activity. 2 4 STRATEGIC INITIATIVES Focus on Serving the Unfinanceable The current economic conditions have further exposed the significant MSME credit supply gap in the country, posing both challenges and opportunities in SBCorp’s pursuit of its mandate to focus on serving “unfinanceable” MSMEs, or those that pose higher risks which banks and other PFIs are unwilling to finance. SBCorp further defines unfinanceable MSMEs to include those that operate as ongoing businesses yet are unable to access credit at non-usurious rates. To this end, SBCorp will continue to pursue purposeful, directed and strategic interventions in the following six (6) identified MSME segments located in areas or sectors with low economic activity and/or with high poverty incidence, namely: 1) micro and small agri-aqua enterprises; 2) micro retailers; 3) small-island economies; 4) MSMEs requiring rehabilitation arising from disasters; 5) Indigenous Peopleowned enterprises; and, 6) first time small businesses. SBCorp aims to accomplish this by continuously developing loan products based on credible, data-driven research and analysis to be able to offer loans that are more responsive to the needs of MSMEs on the ground. By providing the necessary ‘bridge financing’ to the above identified MSME segments, the Corporation aspires to eventually make these MSMEs bankable, enabling them to access the formal financing system at non-usurious rates. Institutionalize Innovation and Cultivate an Innovation Mindset During the onset of the pandemic in March 2020 when severe mobility restrictions and lockdowns are prevalent, much of the world moved online, accelerating a digital transformation that has been underway for decades. Consumers, banks and other financial service providers promptly entered the digital space, driving a global surge in digital engagements and digital payments. Against the backdrop of unprecedented challenges and prompted by the urgent need to extend credit to MSMEs – which lack sufficient access to credit even prior to the pandemic – SBCorp developed using its own personnel and resources, a digital loan origination system characterized by 3 electronic customer onboarding and digitized loan application, evaluation, approval, and disbursement of loan proceeds. This could not have come at a more crucial time as this enabled the Corporation to assist more MSMEs, exponentially increasing its direct retail borrowers from only around 7,000 unique MSME accounts pre-pandemic to more than 45,000 unique MSME accounts to date. SBCorp aims to institutionalize innovation powered by an organizational culture that support and nurture an innovation mindset. As part of its digitalization efforts, the Corporation has submitted its Information Systems and Strategic Plan (ISSP) to the Department of Information and Communications Technology (DICT), formalizing SBCorp’s commitment in providing for major upgrades in its servers/equipment and network connectivity that should be able to support the projected a 70,000 unique MSME borrower base by 2025. Enhance Customer Experience The drastic behavioral change due to the Covid-19 pandemic – marked by a historical shift from in-person to remote life – has permanently altered the way people interact with banks and other financial service providers. However, the accelerated shift towards digital transformation also brings with it bad actors who themselves are increasingly attempting to capitalize on this shift. This is notwithstanding the need for banks and other financial service providers to abide by data protection, information security, Know-Your-Customer (KYC), AntiMoney Laundering/Combating the Financing of Terrorism (AML/CTF) laws and controls, which further complicates the customer experience (CX). Fully aware that customer-centricity and customer experience are the driving forces behind digital innovation, SBCorp has taken a closer look at its MSME CX journey. To ensure timely service delivery, SBCorp has updated its Citizen's Charter in October 2022 to reflect the prescribed turnaround time (TAT) per lending facility from loan application to loan releasing stage. For retail lending, the TAT is 14-33 working days while wholesale lending would entail 20-25 days of TAT.3 As customers continue to demand and expect a seamless and secure digital experience, incorporating robust regulatory compliance solutions to deliver better and faster online customer remain a significant challenge for all Office Order No. 046, Series of 2022 - Rationalization of the Turnaround Time for the Loan Origination Process 5 financial institutions in the digital space. In this regard, SBCorp is fully cognizant of the importance of crafting comprehensive CX strategies in terms of customer onboarding, retention and maintaining long-term relationship with new customers. While in-house talents and resources have enabled SBCorp to successfully digitalize up to this point, the next stage in the Corporation’s customer experience initiatives could involve engaging with highly competent third-party technologybased solutions and customer experience providers. Advocate for Funding of the Philippine MSME Development Agenda Through an Increase in the Capitalization of SBCorp to PhP100.0 Billion Rethink and Enhance SBCorp’s Business Model 1. The importance of MSMEs to the Philippine economy require an affirmative action of government. With SBCorp being under the purview of the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), it is only fitting for its business model to be geared towards helping MSMEs grow and support local industries by providing effective financing access. However, a government financial institution such as SBCorp is also required by law to abide by BSP regulations and financial targets as directed by the Governance Commission on GOCCs (GCG). The act of balancing the Corporation’s social and economic thrusts with the financial risks both entail remains a challenge. SBCorp is currently implementing its collection plan, which formalizes the referral of past due accounts to third-party collection agencies, and its Real and Other Properties Acquired (ROPA) disposal plan, which lists down foreclosures under the name of SBCorp and maps out the schedule of its disposal. While these plans could contribute in SBCorp’s income, the steady increase in the Corporation’s loan portfolio also requires more manpower and resources, which is currently insufficient. In order to ensure organizational sustainability, government intervention is needed to cover for losses brought by lending to high-risk borrowers, which is the bulk of SBCorp’s clients. It is worth looking into dividing the loan portfolio between high-risk and low-risk borrowers vis-à-vis the lending facility (wholesale or retail), striking a balance between serving the underserved and protecting SBCorp from capital impairment. This would require the development of specific and highly-targeted loan products in order to attract and cater to both types of borrowers. SBCorp shall advocate for the funding of the Philippines MSME Development Agenda through an increase in the capitalization of the Corporation from PhP10.0 billion to PhP100.0 billion based on the following guiding principles and assumptions: 2. The significant MSME Credit Gap in the Philippines which was further exacerbated by the pandemic. 3. As a recognized well-governed, agile, and top performing GOCC, SBCorp is best-placed to strategically direct public resources and catalyze private financing and investments to the MSME sector. 4. The need for SBCorp to have sufficient scale in order for the organization to meet pressing societal needs and more effectively perform and deliver its unique mandate and enhanced enterprise incubationgraduation business model. 5. SBCorp has demonstrated its relevance, importance, and countercyclical role in times of crisis. Nevertheless, there is a need to set-up a credit risk subsidy fund in order to avoid capital impairment and ensure organizational sustainability. 6. As an agile organization free from expensive legacy systems, SBCorp can easily leverage and harness financial technologies in its digitalization efforts to expand effective access to financing of MSMEs. 7. SBCorp shall advocate and act to reduce risks associated with MSME lending through innovative financing products and services (e.g., data-driven and out-of-the-box financing models) and by partnering with MSME stakeholders from both the public sector (e.g., Negosyo Centers, Bureau of Internal Revenue, Credit Information Corporation, Department of Labor and Employment, Social Security System, Anti-Red Tape Authority, local government units, etc.) and private sector (e.g., Cooperatives, Microfinance NGOs, Rural Banks, private corporations, credit bureaus, etc.). 6 References Bank for International Settlements (2010). Consultative Document: Strengthening the resilience of the banking sector. Retrieved on October 9, 2021, from https://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs164.pdf Glindro, E., Parcon-Santos, H., Cacnio, F. & Oliva, M. (2020). Shifting macroeconomic landscape and the limits of the BSP’s pandemic response. BSP Working Paper Series, Series No. 2020-05. Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, Manila. Romero, M.J. (2020). The Need to Reclaim Public Development Banks. Public Banks and COVID-19: Combatting the Pandemic with Public Finance (pp. 27-50). Brussels, Belgium. Saeed, A. (2022). Mobilizing Financial Resources for Post COVID-19 Economic Recovery [Speech transcript]. Asian Development Bank. 7