NCFE Level 2 Certificate in Principles of Customer Service COMMUNICATION PRODUCTS EXPECTATIONS ORGANISATIONS SERVICES POLICIES Workbook 2 How to use your learning materials This course is delivered on a flexible learning basis. This means that most of your study will take place away from your Assessor/Tutor. It helps to carefully plan your studying so that you get the most out of your course. We have put together some handy tips for you below. Study Guidance Try to plan an outline timetable of when and where you will study. Try to complete your work in a quiet environment where you are unlikely to be distracted. Set realistic goals and deadlines for the various elements of your course. Plan what you are going to study during each session, and try and achieve this each time. After each session, reflect on what you have achieved and plan what you hope to complete next time. Remember that not only do you have the support of your Assessor/Tutor, but it is likely that your family, friends and work colleagues will also be willing to help. Assessor/Tutor Support Your Assessor/Tutor will be available to support and guide you through the programme. They are experts in your area of study and are experienced in helping many different types of learners. They can help you to improve the standard of work you submit and will give you useful feedback on areas in which you have excelled, as well as where you can improve. Remember to listen to, or read, their feedback carefully. Ask if you are unsure about any of the feedback you receive as your Assessor/Tutor is there to help. Make note of any tips they give. Refer to the learning materials as they contain the information you need to complete the end-of-unit assessments. Look out for areas in which you can improve, and set yourself an action plan to make sure you complete the required work. Take positive feedback on board; this demonstrates you are doing things right and have a good understanding of the subject area. Use the feedback to avoid repeating any mistakes you may have made. Enjoy your studies! 2 © LCG 2018 NCFE Level 2 Certificate in Principles of Customer Service Workbook 2 Workbook Contents In this workbook, we will look at verbal and written communication with customers. We will look at the importance of effective communication, language and non-verbal signals. We will also look at the benefits, limitations and data protection implications of written communication. Contents This workbook contains five sections:Page Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers 4 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships 40 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers 68 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues 93 Section 5: Extension activities117 Each section has a corresponding assessment that must be completed in order to achieve this part of the programme. The assessments for this workbook can be found in: Assessment 2 NCFE Level 2 Certificate in Principles of Customer Service Assessment 2 Learner contact details: Name: Contact address: Postcode: Contact number: Email: When you have completed this workbook you should attempt the assessment. Your Assessor/Tutor will then give you detailed written feedback on your progress. Learner declaration I confirm that the answers in Assessment 2 were completed by me, represent my own ideas and are my own work. Learner signature: Assessment date: If you need any help in completing these assessments, refer to the relevant section within Workbook 1, or contact your Assessor/Tutor. Please tick one of the boxes below to show what your status will be when you complete this course. GAP 1 Gap year before EMP 1 In paid employment for 16 hours or more starting HE per week EMP 2 In paid employment for less than 16 hours EDU 1 Traineeship per week EDU 2 Apprenticeship EMP 4 Self-employed for 16 hours or more per week EDU 3 Supported Internship EMP 5 Self-employed for less than 16 hours per week EDU 4 Other FE* (Full-time) NPE 1 Not in paid employment, looking for work and EDU 5 Other FE* (Part-time) available to start work EDU 6 HE NPE 2 Not in paid employment, not looking for work OTH # (please state) and/or not available to start work (including retired) VOL 1 Voluntary work ……………………………… Assessment 2 1 Workbook 2 3 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Introduction In this section, we are going to look at how to communicate with customers. We will consider the effects of tone, word choice, body language and questioning techniques when using verbal communication. We will also examine how to communicate in writing, looking at the benefits and limitations of different methods, and the implications of confidentiality and data protection. The importance of effective communication Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 1. Many different situations arise in the customer service role that require communication with customers, for example: greeting people at reception dealing with queries and requests answering questions and giving out information having a chat and building a customer relationship dealing with orders, sales and purchases dealing with complaints collecting feedback giving aftercare service Effective communication relies on active listening skills, good questioning skills plus a range of other verbal and non-verbal communication skills, which we will cover in more detail in this workbook. 4 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers The different communication skills all have the same priority – to make sure that messages are received successfully. The cycle of communication can be seen in this diagram: Sender of messages Feedback Methods of communication: verbal non-verbal formal informal Messages Recipient of messages Senders of messages – e.g. team members, managers, customers, shareholders or the marketing department Messages – e.g. product information and prices, deadlines and delivery times, solutions for problems, requests for information, or the organisation’s policies and procedures Recipients of messages – e.g. customers, employees, media or potential customers Feedback – e.g. responses, complaints or praise from customers Workbook 2 5 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Effective communication in customer service is important because it means that organisations can: send and receive information accurately share information effectively give a good impression of the organisation and its workforce deal with problems effectively develop useful and productive working relationships between colleagues, customers and others If communication is effective, organisations can develop a better understanding of their customers’ needs, expectations and perspectives. Similarly, customers can find out more about the products and services on offer and give useful feedback. Organisations can maintain and improve their profitability, reputation and sustainability by communicating effectively. They can do this by, for example, asking the right questions, listening to the answers, and making sure that the service offer meets or exceeds everyone’s needs and expectations. Tone, language, body language and listening skills Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 2. When we communicate with each other, we all make subtle judgements that are based on someone’s tone of voice, choice of words, body language and how they listen to us. This is true in a customer service environment too. Customers’ perception of the whole customer service experience can be affected by how staff talk to them. This can influence how they feel about the staff member, the products and services on offer, and the whole organisation. To make sure that we communicate effectively with customers, and to make sure that they have a positive impression of us, the service offer and the organisation, we need to be aware of how we come across. When communication is successful, customers are put at their ease and are far more likely to make purchases and have a good perception of the whole experience. 6 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Speaking skills There are several things to bear in mind when using verbal communication: Choice of expression The vocabulary that we use is very important. We need to use simple, straightforward words if possible. People may not understand us, and they may be too shy to ask for an explanation. This can happen, for example: if we use long, complicated and specialist words; if we use local sayings and slang, especially with a strong accent; if English is not their first language; if they have hearing problems and cannot follow us. Tone of voice The tone of voice is an important part of verbal communication as it shows the emotion behind the words. If we use a harsh or sharp tone of voice, it shows that we are annoyed, angry or stressed. If our tone of voice is soft and gentle, we show sensitivity and understanding. If we use a confident and energetic tone of voice, we show authority and enthusiasm. Pitch of voice Using a high or low voice also gives extra information to the listener. Some people cannot hear high-pitched sounds, but some will respond better to a high voice. Volume People are sensitive to volume. Some need a high volume, and some find noise painful and irritating. The volume needs to be adapted according to the individual’s needs and wishes, and to the situation and location. The main thing is to be clear. We need to speak clearly and not too quickly, and we need to use simple words. If someone cannot hear and understand us and needs us to repeat information, we need to face them, speak slowly and clearly, and use straightforward language. If they still do not understand and need us to repeat, we need to try different words rather than shouting the original words. Verbal messages need to be: as short as possible, without being rude the point and accurate – e.g. giving the correct facts about the subject or to instructions in simple, clear English – avoiding slang, swearing and jargon Workbook 2 7 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers delivered in a way that is appropriate for the situation and the other person – e.g. using clear and slow speech, especially for people with language or hearing problems Good speaking skills are important in face-to-face communication. They are even more important when speaking on the telephone, as there are no visual clues to help if people have problems with understanding the messages. Body language and gestures A huge number of messages are sent non-verbally. How people stand, how close they are ‘in someone’s space’, eye contact, fidgeting and hand movements all add to verbal messages. A person who frowns, looks at the floor and sits with their arms folded gives off very negative messages. A person who sits or stands upright, and who smiles and uses good eye contact, is far more approachable and less threatening. Good examples include: having an open and relaxed posture facing the person but not standing too close – about an arm’s length away is comfortable for most people smiling when appropriate – although it is important to be friendly, we need to show that comments are taken seriously using facial expressions to show sympathy or reassurance using eye contact – although we need to be aware that some people (and cultures) find too much eye contact inappropriate and threatening being sensitive to the customer’s own body language being flexible about our own body language and gestures so that we do not appear threatening or unapproachable Gestures can also be used to reinforce verbal communication – e.g. pointing or waving to show where something is; miming an action that is hard to explain. Open body language that supports what is being said can help the customer to feel more relaxed and valued. If we use negative, closed body language, it shows that we are not engaged with the customer, that we do not care and are not interested in what they have to say. This would leave them with a very negative perception of the organisation and its standard of customer service. 8 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers We need to be aware of cultural and personal differences when considering body language. For example, some cultures find certain gestures offensive, such as direct eye contact or standing too close. Touching can also be inappropriate and some people do not like to be touched at all. It is important to be very aware of someone else’s personal space and expectations so that we do not make each other feel uncomfortable or threatened. Knowledge Activity 1: Imagine you are a customer in a small shop, waiting to be served. The two staff at the counter are talking to each other, chewing gum and ignoring you. One of them turns towards you eventually. They do not look at you, they slouch and look completely uncaring and disinterested. They start to scan your items without even saying hello or acknowledging you. How does this make you feel? How do you feel about the customer service in the shop? If you have a query, how do you think these staff members will handle your request for information? How do you feel about returning there in the future? Listening skills It is important to listen to the customer, and understand what they are saying. By using ‘active listening skills’, we can show that the customer’s issues are understood and being taken seriously. Active listening skills include: using eye contact nodding the head in agreement actively focusing on what is being said Workbook 2 9 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers using open body language to show that we are receptive to what is being said taking notes if the matter is complicated repeating back key information in a summary of what has been said Good listening skills enhance the verbal communication and help us to make sure that we have understood the customers’ comments and requests. It also helps to reinforce the message that the customer and their views are valued. Knowledge Activity 2: Imagine that you are talking to a customer face-to-face about the features and benefits of a product. They cannot understand everything you are saying and it turns out that they have a hearing impairment and need to be able to read your lips when you speak. How would you handle the situation? What could you do about your body language to help? How would you adapt the way that you speak? 10 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Customer service language Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 3. As we saw in the first workbook, customer service language is important to support a brand promise. As well as having set phrases about the products and services, general phrases to use with customers also have value and can be useful in all aspects of customer service. The idea behind customer service language is to, for example: reassure and put customers at ease – without making them feel inferior provide a framework, focus and standard level of communication for staff to help them deal with all situations support the identity of the brand and the organisation confirm the link between the customer, the brand and the organisation Customer service language can be used in many situations, for example: when greeting customers – e.g. making sure that customers are addressed correctly when customers are enquiring about services and products – e.g. to check customers’ needs and expectations and make sure that the brand promises are all covered when customers ask extra questions – e.g. to use standard phrases that are accurate, truthful and in accordance with the organisation’s policies and procedures during sales pitches to attract new business – e.g. following procedures to tell people what is on offer using standard short phrases during the transaction or sale – e.g. following set routines and phrases to process payments, set up warranties and aftercare services when there are opportunities to upsell – e.g. to increase the value of the order by selling extras or related products and services when dealing with problems and complaints – e.g. to show empathy, then apologise, explain and deal with the problem during advertising and marketing campaigns – e.g. using new phrases that support a new or relaunched brand promise Workbook 2 11 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Organisations will usually have phrases that they like their staff to use in different situations. This helps to establish a standard level of service and bring continuity and consistency from different members. If their staff use the same, or similar, styles of customer service language, an organisation can make sure that all customers receive a similar level and standard of communication from all of their staff members. For example, supermarket checkout staff in some supermarkets are trained to look each new customer in the eye and greet them warmly with similar expressions, including: “Good morning, thanks for waiting.” “Hello, how are you today?” “Good afternoon. Sorry about the delay. Would you like me to pack for you?” “Hi there. Do you need help with your packing today?” “Is this your first time here?” (if it is a new store) The end of a transaction is important too, as it is the opportunity to leave the customer with a good impression of their experience. At the end of the checkout process, for example, staff members might say: “Here’s your receipt. Thank you. Bye.” “My pleasure. Enjoy your weekend.” “Thank you. See you again.” “Don’t forget your card… Thank you, bye.” Being able to chat comfortably with customers can help to build a relationship with each customer. This makes their experience more positive and pleasant, which helps to develop their loyalty for the organisation and recommend it to others. Communication needs to be appropriate for the situation and the individual customer, but ‘small talk’ can be useful in many situations when we want to put customers at their ease – e.g. talking about the weather, a seasonal festival, positive news or events. Sometimes customers want to be left alone and do not wish to engage in conversation. This needs to be respected as well, even if they appear rude. It is important to avoid being judgemental if communication is awkward or lacking – we just need to remember to treat each customer as an individual. Some organisations want their customer service staff to be quite formal when addressing customers – e.g. saying “sir” or “madam”. The standards and guidelines will be set out in the organisation’s policies, procedures and training materials. 12 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Knowledge Activity 3: Make a few notes about customer service language that you use at work or hear when you are a customer. Which phrases do you prefer to use and hear? Why? Which phrases do you dislike, and why? How do you feel when you are a customer and staff do not bother to use any welcoming or helpful customer service language? Questioning techniques Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 4. Questioning focuses the attention on the customer and helps us to find out about their wants, needs and expectations. Selecting the right questioning technique for the situation can help us to collect the right information. We can use, for example: Closed questions These can be answered with a “yes” or “no” and are useful when no further detail is required – e.g. “Have you had any accidents in the last 12 months?” or “Do you want fries with your burger?” These questions do not usually invite further discussion and are not always helpful in a customer service situation. They often need to be followed up with other questions. Open questions These cannot be answered with a “yes” or “no”. They are useful when we want the customer to reflect and come up with their own ideas, opinions and suggestions – e.g. “Tell me about...” “What are your feelings about the project?”, “What do you want?”, “What’s important?”, “What’s the first step?”. Workbook 2 13 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Probing questions These are used to find out more detail. For example, if a customer who wants car insurance has had an accident in the last 12 months, further questions will be needed to obtain the relevant details. Leading questions These are useful when we want to guide customers to reflect on a particular problem or aspect – e.g. “If we’ve covered all of your points, are we ready to go ahead?” Rhetorical questions These are questions that do not need an actual answer. They are useful to help the customer to reflect and maybe commit to a course of action – e.g. “Wouldn’t it be great if we could get this problem sorted today?” There is no need for an answer as we can reasonably assume that the customer is ready to proceed and sort things out as soon as possible. When questioning previous, current and potential customers, it is important to allow them plenty of time to think of their answers – only offering a suggestion, prompt or guidance when the individual becomes uncomfortable. It is also important to remember to use language that shows support and empathy for the customer – e.g. using sympathetic language if dealing with a difficult problem; setting the level of vocabulary or technical language to suit the individual. Verbal and non-verbal signals Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 5. Understanding verbal and non-verbal signals can be important when dealing with customers, as the signals help us to pick up extra information about their wants, needs and expectations. A great deal of information will be collected when we listen to what customers say, but other verbal and non-verbal signals can help us to understand how they may be feeling. Understanding how customers feel can help us to: show empathy and understanding of their particular issues develop better relationships with them and inspire loyalty 14 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers work out their priorities and establish what is most important to them identify queries and potential problems quickly find solutions that suit the situation and the individual help us to prevent any problems escalating Spoken words may not always be enough for customers to communicate with us successfully. For example, customers might: have English as a second language – e.g. with limited vocabulary to describe their wants and needs be shy – e.g. not wanting to say what they really feel unable to express themselves due to impairment – e.g. difficulties with speech be or hearing have the technical knowledge or language to describe what they need – e.g. not not having enough knowledge about computers to be able to say what they need in detail To put customers at their ease, develop useful customer relationships and keep complaints to a minimum, customer service staff need to use active listening skills and observe verbal and non-verbal signals that describe how they feel. Signals could include, for example: Verbal stuttering, stammering and hesitating – e.g. using “er” or “um” a great deal because they feel nervous, unsure or unable to say what they want grunts and other noises – e.g. when unable to speak or find the right words shouting or screaming – e.g. to show anger or distress singing – e.g. to show pleasure in a social environment whispering or speaking very quietly – e.g. to show embarrassment laughing and giggling – e.g. to show pleasure, relief or maybe lack of attention Non-verbal smiling and nodding – e.g. to show agreement and pleasure relaxed, open posture – e.g. to indicate a relaxed, interested and engaged attitude shrugging shoulders – e.g. to show begrudging acceptance of something, or maybe defeat Workbook 2 15 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers aggressive eye contact – e.g. staring at someone to dominate and show anger lowering of eyes and refusing to make eye contact – e.g. to indicate shyness, embarrassment or cultural behaviour standing very close – e.g. to show dominance and make the other person feel uncomfortable slouching and chewing gum – e.g. to show boredom, lack of respect or care hitting furniture – e.g. thumping a desk to show frustration or anger crying – e.g. to show distress, fear, anger or frustration yawning – e.g. to indicate boredom If anyone becomes violent in the workplace, it is extremely important to take care of your own safety and the safety of others – e.g. other customers or colleagues in the area. If there is an incident, it is vital to follow the organisation’s procedures and call for assistance from people who are trained to deal with violent and difficult people – e.g. a qualified security guard or police officer. If staff intervene when they are not trained, the violent person could harm the staff member, other people in the area or themselves – maybe leading to long-term or permanent injuries or side effects. Knowledge Activity 4: Imagine that you are dealing with an angry customer. They are extremely angry because they feel that they have been fobbed off several times, and that nobody is taking their complaint seriously. Describe some verbal and non-verbal signals they might use to illustrate their anger and frustration. How would you tackle the situation? 16 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Types of information Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 6. When communicating with customers, it is important to be well-prepared so that things go smoothly. This helps us to give a professional impression of ourselves and the organisation. On a practical level, examples of the information that we need to have ready before talking to a customer include, for example: details of the products or services that may be of interest up-to-date information about all aspects of the service offer – e.g. current discounts, special offers, delivery and availability alternative options for the customer the organisation’s policies and procedures – e.g. about returns details about competitors’ service offers information about new technology or products in development – e.g. details of products due to arrive soon details of previous services or products they have used or purchased background details about any query, problem or complaint We also need information about the customer so that we can treat them as an individual and deliver the best-quality customer service. For example, we need information about: their wants, needs and expectations – e.g. based on an enquiry special access needs – e.g. if they need wheelchair access or somewhere to any put a pushchair communication issues – e.g. if they need a Braille version of instructions; if any they have a hearing impairment that may cause difficulties during discussions or a meeting sensitivity of the subject to be discussed – e.g. privacy will be needed to the discuss financial or medical issues whether they need or want to have someone with them – e.g. during a hospital consultation Workbook 2 17 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Knowledge Activity 5: If you go into a shop to buy a new mobile phone, what information do you expect the customer service staff to have and collect? Written communication with customers Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 7. When communicating with customers or others at work, we need to select the best method of communication. Sometimes we will use our speaking, listening and body language skills, and sometimes we will communicate in writing. When choosing the right communication method, we need to consider: the type of information being sent the people who are going to read or hear it the security and confidentiality of the information how it will be circulated and shared 18 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Good communication skills are essential to make sure that: errors and misunderstandings are kept to a minimum the right level of detail can be provided the organisation’s positive and professional image is maintained communication method follows good business practice and is in line with the the organisation’s policies and procedures confidentiality is protected, when appropriate Written communication methods When communicating with customers in writing, we need to think about reading, writing, pictures, symbols and other visual communication. We need to choose and adapt the method to suit the customer, the subject matter and the general situation. We need to bear in mind that someone may need to wear glasses to see the information properly, or have a large print or Braille version. Or they may have literacy or language problems, in which case signs, symbols, pictures, gestures and verbal communication may be needed to support the written information. Methods of written communication in the workplace include, for example: emails formal letters leaflets, newsletters and brochures reports and certificates drawings, graphs, illustrations and designs forms information notices and signs websites social media notes and memos Workbook 2 19 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Emails Emails can be formal or informal and are often used when communicating with customers to, for example: send information to one person – e.g. to answer a customer’s question send information to many thousands of people – e.g. to provide information about new products to customers who have given consent to be contacted deal with customers’ queries, complaints and comments arrange a meeting make or confirm purchases and orders When used informally, emails are rather like postcards, memos or short notes. When used formally, emails need to be similar to formal letters. Organisations usually have their own styles, policies and procedures about how to write emails for different situations. Texts Texts are used quite often to let customers know about products, services and customer service. They can be used to, for example: confirm that a customer’s order is ready for collection or delivery remind customers about booked delivery times let customers know that the courier or engineer is on their way alert customers to their bank balance provide an extra security measure for online banking inform customers about special offers and other marketing information Formal letters These will be on headed notepaper and will be used in formal situations, especially if a permanent record is needed. They are particularly useful when information is confidential and sensitive and needs to be kept private, for example: when following complaints procedures when writing to customers about serious, confidential or sensitive matters Formal letters reflect the organisation at its most professional and serious, so good grammar, vocabulary and presentation are essential. 20 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Leaflets, newsletters and brochures Leaflets, newsletters and brochures are generally quite formal and need to be factually correct. They can be illustrated and include graphs and technical information and have many uses – e.g. to give instructions and extra information about products and services; promote the organisation’s image using glossy pictures, background information, logos and news; keep customers up to date. Reports and certificates Reports can be formal or informal, paper-based or electronic. They can be for just one customer or be widely shared with many people. In some circumstances, certificates might be issued as well. Reports and certificates can be very important as they are often kept as evidence to show that policies and procedures have been followed. For example: an MOT certificate and report about a car’s test results annual accounts and accountants’ reports for customers’ businesses a surveyor’s report when buying a house a medical report a college certificate to prove a qualification Drawings, graphs, illustrations and designs Drawings, illustrations and designs are used when information needs to be presented in a visual format – e.g. an architect’s drawings; a graphic designer’s brochure design; a fashion designer’s sketches for a client; a set of instructions about how to build flatpack furniture. Graphs are used when presenting data in a visual and mathematical format – e.g. flowcharts to show a customer a sequence of steps when making a complicated claim. Workbook 2 21 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Forms Many organisations design and use their own forms. The idea is to simplify the process of collecting information so that the customer can complete the form as easily as possible. The organisation can target the information that they need and want, so that time and resources are not wasted on processing unnecessary answers and data. Forms can be used for many functions, including, for example: surveys and feedback comments from customers orders and sales finance applications – e.g. when asking for a loan or mortgage compliance with legislation – e.g. when gaining consent to comply with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) requirements Information signs and notices Information signs need to be clear and very easy to understand. The language used needs to be straightforward and clearly written to maximise the chances of the message being understood, for example: directions to different departments instructions about how to operate machinery – e.g. how to use the self-scanning equipment in a supermarket instructions about what to wear or how to behave – e.g. please be quiet, exam in progress; safety helmets must be worn information for visitors – e.g. expected waiting times for their appointments car park signs prices and special offers in retail outlets Pictures and symbols can be really useful when the information is important, especially if language is an issue. We see them used on information signs all around us at work and in public places, for example: health and safety information in green to imply safety – e.g. emergency exit signs and first-aid signs warning signs in yellow to show danger – e.g. yellow trip hazard signs fire information in red – e.g. about fire extinguishers and fire alarms mandatory (compulsory) information on blue signs – e.g. about hand-washing or instructions to wear personal protective equipment 22 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Chemicals will also have symbols on the packaging to back up the information about the product. Websites Websites are now common in organisations, and they are a useful way of communicating with an infinite number of people. They use language, pictures, symbols, graphs and other visual elements. Websites can carry a vast amount of information, including, for example: detailed information about products and services background information about the organisation and its structure policies and procedures photographs and other graphics to give visual examples of the organisation’s products and services legal information testimonials and other feedback from customers and others links to related pages, websites or other information connected with the organisation availability and booking systems payment systems specifications and instruction manuals – e.g. for staff or customers to use Websites need to be well-presented and kept up to date. They can reach a wide number of people so they need to give a good, professional impression of the organisation and its workforce. Social media A great deal of sales and marketing material is now shared using social media. Many organisations now have a team of people whose job it is to monitor and manage social media communications so that an instant response can be given if necessary. Social media can be used to, for example: monitor and react to complaints – e.g. by train companies if their customers are complaining about a problem followers and customers know the latest news – e.g. announcing a new let participant at an air show or music festival offer promotions and special offers encourage followers and customers to engage with the organisation – e.g. to send their views to a live TV or radio programme, which shows advertisers the level of interest from different people in the audience Workbook 2 23 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Notes and memos Notes and memos in the workplace can be very quick and useful. They are generally informal and used between colleagues, although they might be given to customers. Notes can be addressed personally or left for everyone to see, depending on who needs to see the contents, for example: to pass on a telephone message – e.g. to a hotel customer remind people about something – e.g. the date, time and location of a meeting to or training course Writing skills Most of us have to write at work, either as a large part of our job or as a communication method we just use occasionally – e.g. emails, notes, reports, minutes, agendas or newsletters. Good writing skills are important to maintain a good quality of presentation – it helps to: plan what needs to be written keep it short and simple – use clear and simple language, and try to keep to the point write clearly and think about the size of the text – bearing in mind that people may need glasses or have sight problems think about the tone – who is going to read it, and will they understand it? Is it polite? Is it friendly and professional? If the task involves writing a longer piece of business English, the following technique can really help: think about the conclusions first – then we know where the letter or report is heading the main body of the letter/report – use a new do paragraph for each topic, and try to use good grammar finally, do the introduction – as the content is designed now, the introduction almost writes itself 24 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Conventions and samples of written communication Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 8. Organisations will often have their own conventions about how they want to present written communication to customers. The procedures, templates and ‘house styles’ will cover things such as: when to use a formal letter how to word emails to customers which font and style to use standard phrases for the greetings, contents and how to close a letter or email grammar, vocabulary and tone what to include – e.g. sending a brochure or form with each letter The purpose, type, style and timing for producing written communication for customers will take into account: the type of information who is going to read the communication security and confidentiality how and when the information will be circulated and shared Conventions about written communication Organisations usually have guidelines about how they want all of their documents to look and how they want them to be prepared. The idea is that all documents have the same levels of style, standards and quality so that customers and others see a united and professional image at all times. The corporate image is more important than the individual’s own style, so all of the employees will follow the same, agreed guidelines when producing documents. This makes sure that they all present very similar, positive images of the organisation. Workbook 2 25 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers In order to achieve this harmony when preparing documents, organisations will have conventions about each aspect, for example: The purpose of the written communication For example, an informal piece of information can be sent via email but a legally binding communication about a formal complaint needs to go by formal letter. The content and layout All staff need to use similar content and layout to harmonise different aspects of the organisation’s letters, brochures, website and so on, so that the overall impression is the same and everyone knows what can and cannot be included. Staff need to use similar vocabulary, grammar standards and tone of language, so that the contents are of a standard that meet the expectations of the reader. For example, the organisation may have a standard structure for the contents of business emails that includes instructions about: how to address the reader and sign the email using short paragraphs only using a helpful and polite tone the level of detail to be given in an email avoiding sending confidential details and sensitive information by email pointing the reader to the website and helpline for more information The expected standards of quality The quality of a document leads customers to make subtle judgements about the organisation. Anything that is produced and sent out by the organisation says a great deal about it. Letters, emails, reports and so on can all be kept as permanent records, so it is vital to take care when producing them to meet or exceed the customers’ needs and expectations. 26 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Documents need to: be factually correct legible – e.g. using a large enough font; using suitable colours that everyone be can see have accurate figures – e.g. that balance and add up have a good standard of English – e.g. with correct grammar and spelling use language that is appropriate for the intended readers – e.g. avoiding jargon look balanced and well-presented – e.g. with headings and indents in the right places Producing documents that are consistently accurate and correct helps to: avoid operating errors – that can be a result of poor communication save time – from having to redo work and send it out again maintain a professional and positive image of the individual, team and organisation To make sure that the grammar, spelling and layout are up to standard, we can, for example: use a spell-check facility ask a colleague to check and proofread the document follow training notes and procedures look things up in a dictionary or on a search engine if we are not sure – there are many free, online dictionaries, but we need to make sure that we use UK spelling and not US spelling Workbook 2 27 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Here are some examples of different formats that are commonly used by organisations. Formal business letters When writing a formal letter to a customer, the organisation’s conventions might include, for example: use the printed letterhead or standard letter show the date, reference numbers and a heading about the subject use appropriate language for the purpose and the customer – e.g. avoiding jargon and technical language that may not be understood use a professional and respectful tone – e.g. showing the right level of respect for the intended reader make sure that grammar and spellings are correct follow the standard content and layout for the organisation check whether to use ‘Yours sincerely’ or ‘ Yours faithfully’ Dear Mr and Mrs Customer Name ends with Yours sincerely Dear Sir/Madam ends with Yours faithfully It also helps to have a structure when preparing formal letters, so that the layout is logical and the content is easy to follow. For example: Introduction – this contains a greeting and a sentence about the reason for writing – e.g. an apology when responding to a complaint; a brief introduction to information about new products and services. Main body – this is where the main messages and information are delivered in detail, using a new paragraph for each new topic – e.g. explanations about the complaint and how it is being handled; different features and special offers about new products. Conclusion – this is a quick summary of the main messages and reassurance about the future – e.g. extra apology, summary of actions being taken and reassurance about future service; brief summary about the new product and an offer to be of assistance in the future. 28 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Here is a sample business letter sent as a response to a complaint from a customer: Organisation’s letterhead: Old Oak Hotel 45 Willow Street, WOODHAM AB1 2CD Tel: 01234 567890 Email: info@writingexample.com Website: www.writingexample.com Recipient’s name and address: Mrs Ava Coffee 123 Milk Street TEAVILLE TE4 6UP Date: 20 September 2018 Salutation: Dear Mrs Coffee Heading: Your complaint about accommodation Introduction: Thank you for your letter of 16 September 2018. We are sorry that your room was not cleaned for the second night of your stay with us. Main body: We regret that, due to a misunderstanding, your room number was not put on the housekeeper’s list of rooms to be cleaned on Saturday morning. This was an oversight and we apologise for any inconvenience caused. We appreciate your feedback and we have reviewed our procedures following your comments. The system has now been changed to try to prevent this happening again. We value your custom. As a token of our appreciation, we would like to offer you breakfast with our compliments next time you stay here at the Old Oak. Conclusion and sign off: Please accept our sincere apologies for the problems during your last visit. We hope to be able to welcome you here again in the near future. Close: Yours sincerely Sender’s name: Heidi High Designation: Customer Service Manager Workbook 2 29 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Emails Organisations use different email programmes and they will set out their standard formats and conventions for their staff to follow. Emails can be formal or informal, so it is important to get the tone and style right for the situation and purpose. Important elements to remember include, for instance: Who is the email going to? The email address for the recipient might just come up when we press ‘Reply’ on their original email, or we might address our email to people in the Contacts List on the system. Do we need to send copies of the email? If we press ‘CC’, we can send copies of the same email to specific people, and the recipient will know that we have sent copies. CC means ‘Carbon Copy’, a term that was used when typists used a sheet of carbon paper to make a second, third or fourth copy of the original letter. If we press ‘BCC’, we send a ‘Blind Carbon Copy’ to someone else, and the recipient does not know that we have sent this. If we press ‘Reply all’, our email will go to everyone who was copied in on the sender’s email. This can be very annoying and unnecessary, so we need to be careful about using this facility if it is not needed. The subject heading This helps people to know what the email is about before they open it, and it helps us to track old emails by looking quickly for the subject as we scan email folders. The organisation’s style Protocols for how to address people are important and we need to know how to greet someone – e.g. Hi Chris, Dear Chris, Dear Ms Smith, or Good afternoon Chris. The structure of the email This can be similar to the structure of a formal letter if the subject is quite complicated – e.g. introduction, main body then conclusion. 30 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Is any of the information sensitive? Emails are not usually a safe and secure way of sending data. If data is encrypted, as used for Internet banking for instance, it is safer to send confidential details. It is important to follow the organisation’s guidelines about what information can be sent. How to sign off or close Organisations need to let staff know how to sign off their emails, usually called an email signature – e.g. Best regards, Cheers, Yours sincerely or Kind regards. The sender’s name and job title needs to appear as well, along with any standard privacy statements and contact information set out by the organisation. Here is a sample of an informal email for a customer: To: MyCustomer@work; MyCustomer@home CC: My manager BCC: Subject: Your sofa fabric – sofa order reference 2626723 Message: Good afternoon Ms Smith I’m just writing to let you know that the extra fabric you want to match your sofa has been ordered. The details are: Pattern: Sample Red Stripe Amount ordered: 6 metres (width is 1.5m) Cost: £30 per linear metre = £180 Expected delivery to store: by 28 November I will let you know when it arrives here. If you have any queries in the meantime, do let me know. Best regards Alex Alex Starr Customer Services Bloggs and Co Workbook 2 31 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Texts A sample text about a product delivery could be: Dear Mr Jones. Order reference for Bloggs and Co sofa 1672889. Your item will be delivered tomorrow between 0700 and 1200. The driver will call you 30 minutes before arrival. Any queries call our helpline on 0123456789 and quote your reference. Thank you. Bloggs and Co. Benefits and limitations of written communication Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 9. Organisations need to use a balance of verbal and written communication with their customers. The communication method needs to match the situation and the individual customer to make sure that the customer service is compliant and of the highest quality. There may be legal or contractual requirements to have things in writing, so written communication might form part of the delivery of the service offer. 32 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Benefits of using written communication can include, for example: the organisation and customers have a written record of the transaction – e.g. a receipt or delivery note there is a permanent record to track progress and provide evidence if there is a query – e.g. a contract or schedule of works when a builder does a house extension compliance with legal requirements – e.g. a landlord giving a gas safety certificate to the tenant of a let property confirmation of a verbal agreement – e.g. a booking form to confirm a holiday booking the organisation has the customers’ contact details on their database – e.g. to use for marketing if they have permission the customers can refer to a hard copy of information – e.g. operating instructions or marketing materials the communication can be personalised – e.g. Christmas cards or thank-you cards with handwritten messages sent to customers by the organisation private information can remain confidential – e.g. sending a personal letter about medical issues or results information can be sent to a large number of people – e.g. via websites, newsletters or marketing materials Written communication can also have limitations. It can, for example: be impersonal – e.g. brochures and newsletters need to be general and cannot be tailored to an individual’s needs poorly written and give a bad impression – e.g. showing that the organisation be does not pay attention to detail, so might not be considered trustworthy poorly written and be misunderstood – e.g. instructions that do not make be sense or are hard to follow ignored by the customer – e.g. printed marketing information can often be be recycled without even being read not be backed up by verbal and non-verbal cues at the time – e.g. sorting queries and complaints in writing, without a meeting or telephone conversation, can take longer and be less sensitive about personal issues deny the chance to gauge the customers’ reactions face-to-face – e.g. the opportunity to gain instant feedback (good or bad) is lost Workbook 2 33 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers It can be important to choose the right method for certain situations. The following table gives some hints about advantages and disadvantages of different forms of communication: Method: Emails Benefits: Quick and simple Can be formal or informal Easy to keep a copy and track the messages coming in and going out Limitations: Cannot always get instant feedback or an answer from the other person – some people do not deal with emails every day; need to check this if the matter is urgent Provide a clear record of what has been discussed Texts People often get too many emails, so it is hard to make important ones stand out Texts can be left for someone to Texts do not always go through read when they are ready – e.g. as expected, and might not be read quickly after a meeting Quite personal Formal letters Leaflets, newsletters and brochures Drawings, graphs, illustrations and designs Good for short messages Suitable where very personal approach needed – e.g. when dealing with a formal complaint © LCG 2018 Usually take longer to prepare, check and send Formal permanent record Can be formal or informal Can go out of date quite quickly Good for sending information in a permanent form to a large number of people Often discarded unread, or hardly read, which is a waste of resources Can be left for people to help themselves – e.g. in a doctor’s surgery waiting area Strong visual impact Expensive to produce and store Data can be hard to understand if people are not familiar with Can explain plans, results or achievements very quickly when the format data is presented correctly Helps people to imagine a threedimensional plan or design 34 Not suitable for confidential details and information Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Forms Easy to complete Logical Designed for a specific purpose Information signs and notices Can pass information to wide range of people – e.g. in the customer waiting area or entrance to the building Cannot always have room for additional information Questions and boxes might not be entirely suited to the nature of the answers needed Not suitable for personal or confidential information Some symbols can be harder to understand if they are unfamiliar Symbols and colour-coding make them easy to understand Websites Good for general information or announcements Can be tailor-made for the organisation or department Relatively cheap and easy to use to reach a very wide audience Social media Notes and memos The internal search engine within the website can be inadequate and make it hard to navigate Information can be irrelevant if Can hold a vast amount of data, not kept up to date Website can be hard to find on pictures and information search engines – e.g. Google Can link to other pages, information and websites Quick, easy and inexpensive to Needs to be monitored operate and updated all of the time – especially for customer Can reach extremely large comments that might need a numbers of followers instantly response Good for short messages Bad news can travel fast – e.g. negative customer feedback or complaints Can give specific information or Might be missed if left in wrong request place Person has a written record Need to be aware of possible literacy or language issues Workbook 2 35 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Knowledge Activity 6: You work in the customer service department of a large company that makes vacuum cleaners. There is a problem with a new cleaner that has been on sale for six months. Which methods of communication could the company use to contact its customers, and why? Confidentiality and data protection Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 10a and 10b. As we have already seen, maintaining confidentiality is very important when managing information, and this applies to written communication with customers too. Maintaining confidentiality When using written communication methods, staff need to keep private details about customers, customers’ businesses, colleagues or the organisation absolutely confidential. Personal details, operational data and any other sensitive information need to be kept confidential. Confidentiality is essential to protect the organisation’s reputation, and to gain and maintain the trust of customers, staff and other people involved in a business environment. The legal rights of individuals, about how their personal data is handled, need to be protected. Information should only be passed to people who are authorised to receive it, and who need to receive it, so that it cannot be passed to competitors or used for criminal or antisocial purposes. 36 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers For example, when dealing with written communication, staff need to be very careful about who can see information about: someone’s bank account and financial affairs medical history and records personal contact details – e.g. email addresses or mobile phone numbers private activities – e.g. who has been staying in a customer’s hotel room security details – e.g. how to access a building what has been said in private – e.g. in a meeting with a customer confidential details about the organisation – e.g. profits, plans, potential contracts or security arrangements details about customers and their businesses – e.g. how their business is performing or a new sales contract that has not been announced yet Data protection As mentioned before, there are legal obligations to protect information. The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) deals with the security of information that is held by an organisation. This could include: bank account or credit card details tax or other financial details full names, addresses and dates of birth CCTV footage and voice recordings medical records biometric data – e.g. fingerprints or eye scans There are very strict guidelines about how confidential information can be accessed, used and stored. Organisations need to apply a lawful basis before processing personal data, and information cannot be given to anyone who simply asks for it, which is why we go through a series of security and consent questions when we need to discuss or access personal data. Organisations have procedures about how to collect, store, use and destroy data, to make sure that confidential information is not disclosed. For example, there may be very strict guidelines about what information is allowed to go into an email, and papers containing sensitive data will be shredded when they need to be destroyed. All staff and contractors need to follow the procedures to comply with the legislation. Workbook 2 37 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Individuals and organisations can be prosecuted under the GDPR for misusing confidential data. This can lead to fines, or even imprisonment, as well as a loss of trust in the individual and the organisation. Implications of confidentiality when communicating in writing When communicating with customers in writing, organisations need to have safeguards in place to make sure that they protect confidentiality and comply with the GDPR. These can have an impact on how they deliver their service offer and run their operations. For example: making sure that the name and address on personal letters to customers are correct obtaining the right consents before processing personal data restricting employees’ access to personal information – e.g. with passwords storing data carefully – e.g. storing legal files in a locked, fireproof cupboard destroying data correctly – e.g. making sure that papers containing personal details are shredded properly having encryption systems – e.g. for customers’ financial and banking details leaving files out where they can be seen – e.g. not having medical records on not view at the reception desk The implications if things go wrong with confidentiality and data protection can be very serious, for example: customers being put in compromising, embarrassing or difficult situations following a breach – e.g. from leaked information about their finances loss of reputation for the organisation loss of trust in the organisation’s ability to deal with customers possible fines and other legal action for the incorrect use or handling of data loss of business or even complete failure of the organisation – e.g. following on from loss of trust or from legal action 38 © LCG 2018 Section 1: Understand how to communicate with customers Knowledge Activity 7: Imagine that you hear two of your colleagues laughing and commenting about your latest appraisal report, which they have found in the photocopier (the manager left it there by accident after copying it). Make a few notes about: How you would feel The accidental breach in confidentiality What you would do when you photocopied sensitive documents in future Summary In this section, we have considered how to communicate with customers verbally and in writing. We have looked at: the importance of effective communication tone of voice, language and body language why customer service language is used different questioning techniques verbal and non-verbal signals information needed when communicating verbally with customers different written methods that are used for different purposes samples of written communication the benefits and limitations of different methods the importance of confidentiality and data protection Workbook 2 39 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Introduction In this section, we are going to look at how to develop relationships with customers. We will consider customer loyalty, retention and expectations, plus the use of feedback and customer relationship management (CRM) systems. We will also look at how to support customer service improvements. Developing customer relationships Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 11, 12, 13 and 14. There are many different types of customer relationship, for example: Some customer relationships are very brief – e.g. at the till in an electrical retail outlet or department store. Some customers become regulars and build a rapport with staff – e.g. in a small, local supermarket where the same customers go to shop several times a week. Some customer relationships are quite close for a short time only – e.g. when a customer needs in-depth advice about buying the right mobile telephone or computer. Some relationships are intensive for a few weeks or months but are not repeated very often – e.g. between homeowners and their builders during a house renovation or building project. Some relationships between customers and organisations develop over many years – e.g. between accountancy staff and their clients; between GPs and their patients. Some organisations have customer relationships with people they never meet – e.g. online suppliers who serve customers all over the world; telephone call centres and helplines. 40 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships The importance of developing customer relationships In any customer service role, it is important to develop relationships with customers and deliver customer service in a professional and positive way. It is vital to establish and develop a relationship with each customer, whether it is a one-off, brief transaction or an ongoing, long-term business relationship. The relationship is valuable even if the financial aspect is small or non-existent – e.g. a £5 transaction in a retail or fast-food outlet, or a long-term relationship between a counsellor working for a charity and a service user who receives their services without charge. Whatever the customer service role or financial impact, developing relationships with customers is important to: promote or maintain customer loyalty – e.g. making customers feel valued so that they want to use a certain brand and recommend it to others encourage or improve customer retention – e.g. inspiring customers to stay with the organisation because they receive good service encourage referrals – e.g. giving customers incentives and the confidence to introduce their friends, family and other contacts maintain or increase revenue – e.g. developing repeat business to secure future sales and job security improve and maintain high levels of customer satisfaction – e.g. to reduce the number of complaints and rejected goods maintain and improve the organisation’s reputation – e.g. portraying a good image of how a business treats and values its customers; showing how customer rights are respected and upheld create and maintain a competitive advantage – e.g. delivering a better service offer than competitors Customer loyalty and retention Customer loyalty and retention are extremely important to any organisation, especially in a highly competitive marketplace. If the supply of customers decreases or disappears, the organisation is no longer viable and will usually fail or be taken over, for example: In the private, commercial sector – a business that loses too many customers suffers an ongoing loss of revenue and cannot sustain its operations. It has to make staff redundant and may close down or be taken over by a competitor. Workbook 2 41 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships In the public sector – a government department that fails to provide efficient, effective and well-managed services that meet its customers’ needs and expectations is likely to be reviewed. This can lead to a cut in services and revenue, or may lead to services being done by an outside provider, leading to a loss of jobs within the government department. In the third, voluntary sector – a charity needs to maintain a good supply of customers in its shops to provide revenue for its services. If the shops fail due to poor stock, lack of volunteers or a lack of people spending money there, the charity will be unable to sustain its services to those in need. Retaining customers and encouraging them to remain loyal is critical to long-term planning and development for the organisation. If customers do not feel loyal towards an organisation, they are far more likely to leave it and take their business elsewhere. As the saying goes, “If you don’t look after your customers, someone else will”. By creating an emotional bond and a valuable relationship with each customer, an organisation can help its customers to feel satisfied with their service offer and inspired to return to them in the future. Loyal customers are also far more likely to recommend an organisation or brand to their contacts. The value to an organisation of customer loyalty and retention can be measured in several ways, for example: repeat business – from previous and current customers reduced costs and increased profits – e.g. lower marketing and advertising costs from having an established customer base, plus new customers who try the service offer following recommendations reduced risk – e.g. higher chance of success from launching new products and services based on in-depth knowledge about loyal customers’ buying habits a good reputation – for treating customers well and valuing their custom and input reduced numbers of complaints and problems – e.g. from making sure that the service offer is targeted and delivered correctly to satisfy established customers’ needs and expectations 42 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships How customers’ expectations can change Knowing what previous and current customers want and expect is important when the organisation is making sure that the delivery of its service offer is relevant and satisfactory. In general, customers want and expect: efficient and polite service – before, during and after buying or using a product or service good-quality products and services – in line with the standards promised in catalogues, brochures, websites, customer charters, company policies etc. complaints and problems to be dealt with properly – politely and quickly, with an effective outcome their opinion to matter – when dealing with staff, when giving feedback or when discussing a problem As we have already seen, customers’ expectations are based on what they believe the product or service is supposed to do to meet their needs. The example we used was the vacuum cleaner and the customer expectations were that: The chosen vacuum cleaner should: do everything that was promised be reliable be easily available, preferably in stock to take away that day come with good customer service and guarantees Staff should: be polite, friendly and knowledgeable be able to answer queries make the transaction easy and straightforward make the customer feel valued and respected The retail outlet should: be easy to get to, with free parking outside be clean, tidy, well-lit and well-ventilated be well laid out with logical sections have enough knowledgeable staff on duty have plenty of stock and choice Workbook 2 43 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships However, customers’ expectations can change. Organisations need to be aware of changes so that they can react and amend their service offer to satisfy the revised expectations as far as possible. Expectations can change over time for a variety of reasons that include, for example: Changes in technology As the scope of what technology can do changes, customers’ expectations change too. For example, they want constantly improving performance and security measures, and new versions of phones, tablets and other mobile devices. Some technology changes make old products obsolete, such as digital radio and television replacing old broadcasting formats. Changes in the customer’s own circumstances Changes in a customer’s own life can lead to a change in expectations. For example, if their income goes up, they may decide that they want to buy more expensive wine, clothes, cars and so on. Conversely, if their income goes down, they may have to adjust their spending habits and adapt to different products or cancel unnecessary services. Expectations can also change when lifestyles change – e.g. when a couple starts a family, retires, divorces or moves to a new part of the country. Changes in trends and fashions Trends and fashions can change for many reasons. For example, as new research emerges about different foods, such as the amount of sugar and fat we consume, expectations change when customers adopt the new strategies and they want more low-fat and low-sugar options. Changes in competitors’ service offers If one organisation changes its service offer to attract new business, customers become aware of different options that may affect their expectations. For example, when one bank offers a new current account that pays generous interest and offers many other bonus features, customers see a different way of operating their account and expect more from their own bank. 44 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Knowledge Activity 8: Think about a time when you upgraded a piece of technology, such as a mobile phone. Describe the new or upgraded features you expected from the new device that your old device did not have – e.g. processing speed, camera functions or memory capacity. Using feedback When feedback is given freely, it is a valuable resource. This is true even if the customer is dissatisfied and makes a complaint. Some feedback can give a real insight into what customers want and expect, especially if it is collected by experienced third parties who are used to collecting information from people, such as reputable survey companies. The feedback is more likely to be more honest as the customer does not feel that they have to be polite to the staff who have just served them. They can make honest comments to the survey company without feeling embarrassed. Organisations can benefit from handling feedback correctly. Customers nearly always have choice. By taking customers’ views and ideas seriously, organisations can improve their products and customer service and encourage customer loyalty. This helps to ensure the long-term success of the organisation and its staff by keeping up with customers’ expectations: Feedback data can be used in several ways, for example: to improve the service and products on offer – e.g. after finding out about customers’ changing expectations to identify strengths in the service offer – e.g. from praise about the product or customer service Workbook 2 45 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships identify weaknesses and opportunities for improvement – e.g. lower scores to about operating instructions leading to redevelopment of leaflets and labels show staff how well they are doing – e.g. from praise about an individual to or team to encourage innovation – e.g. to anticipate trends and fashions based on changing expectations and requirements find out exactly what the customer wants and expects – e.g. how they wish to to be contacted in future to rectify issues and catch major problems early – making any necessary changes as soon as possible before more complaints arrive Customer service staff can treat feedback as part of a conversation when developing customer relationships. They can listen to what the customer has to say and use it as the basis for their next contact with the customer. Positive feedback is useful to show where the organisation is doing well and how it needs to continue. Negative feedback is useful to show when the service offer can be improved. Both give the opportunity for discussion and further development of customer relationships if handled sensitively, positively and politely. Working within the limits of authority Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 15. When working for an organisation, it is always important for us to work within the limits of our authority. This is true when dealing with all aspects of the service offer, too. The organisation should set out the limits of authority clearly so that staff know which decisions they can make on their own, and which decisions they need to escalate – e.g. to their line manager or sales manager. The limits might be set out in, for example: the employment contract the job description training materials policies and procedures product information 46 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Alternative service offers might include, for example: product replacements or upgrades refunds compensation additional support extended warranties Each staff member needs to know exactly what their organisation agrees to offer before entering into negotiations with customers. If staff offer something that has not been approved or agreed, it can lead to serious problems, for example: breaches of regulations or legislation – e.g. not complying with consumer rights laws loss of revenue or profit for the organisation – e.g. from giving something away when it should be charged for health and safety issues – e.g. from not dealing with faulty electrical goods properly disciplinary procedures against the individual – e.g. for not following policies, procedures and training When making decisions about alternative service offers, organisations need their staff to: work within the established decision-making process have the relevant knowledge about alternatives ask if they are not sure This makes sure that the service offer is consistent and that changes are agreed centrally – to protect the consumers, employees and organisation. Workbook 2 47 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Knowledge Activity 9: Make a few notes about the alternative service offers you are permitted to make to customers in your organisation. Using customer relationship management (CRM) systems to meet customers’ expectations Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 16 and 17. Organisations with a main focus on customer service will often have customer relationship management (CRM) systems. These systems can be software applications or paper-based systems and they are used to manage customer data. CRM refers to the policies, procedures, strategy and technology that an organisation uses to analyse and monitor all aspects of relationships with customers. It is designed to attract and retain customers in a cost-effective way. The CRM systems can be tailor-made to suit an organisation’s particular environment, industry and operational needs, and will help to track products and services through all parts of the sales and customer-facing processes – e.g. marketing, sales, orders, customer support, feedback and adjustments to the service offer. The systems and processes are useful tools to use when working to meet customers’ expectations because they give details about how the organisation handles every element of the service delivery. The different organisational functions – from production to sales and customer care – have an impact on each other. CRM systems track and manage these to make sure that customers’ expectations are met or exceeded. 48 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships This diagram shows a simple CRM system that a car dealership could follow when selling cars to its customers. The company needs to make sure that it complies with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) when using personal data to contact and stay in touch with customers and potential customers. 6. Adjustments to service offer – e.g. to improve products and services; to keep up with customers’ changing expectations; to match or exceed competitors’ offers 1. Marketing – e.g. run a marketing campaign for a new car; announce features of the new model; provide customers with relevant information; update with any changes 2. Sales – e.g. generate sales leads from previous, current and potential customers; track opportunities CRM 3. Orders – e.g. prepare and follow up quotes; generate sales orders and invoices; arrange delivery; keep customers informed of progress 5. Feedback – e.g. collect comments from customers about their new cars; listen carefully; assist with any problems 4. Customer support – e.g. provide follow-up actions and after-sales service for customer Workbook 2 49 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships The systems under each of the headings would be very detailed about how to deal with all aspects of marketing, sales, orders, customer support, feedback and how the organisation reviews and amends its service offer. Using CRM systems and processes can have several benefits that include, for example: focus on the customer – rather than the products or services a streamlined service offer that targets individual customers’ needs reduction in stress for the workforce – from having established procedures and a standards to follow a clear buying and selling process a clear system to follow when implementing change within the organisation The structure and transparency aid communication at all levels and help everyone to work together to meet or exceed customers’ expectations. By being open, organisations can make sure that they review their service offer and adapt to change, which helps them to remain competitive and customer-focused. Knowledge Activity 10: Make some notes about the CRM system that your organisation uses. If they do not have a recognised system, find a company on the Internet and make a few notes about how their customer-facing processes work together to help build customer relationships. 50 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Regular communication Regular communication is important when developing relationships with internal and external customers. As we have already seen, internal customers are people within the same organisation who work for a different department or team that uses the products and services on offer – e.g. lecturers in a college can be seen as customers of the printing and copying department. External customers are from outside the organisation – e.g. members of the public who are customers in a retail outlet. Communication with internal customers helps to, for example: keep staff from different departments up to date develop a unified, high-quality customer service relationship that benefits the organisation and external customers promote a sense of shared goals make staff from different departments take ownership and be accountable Communication with external customers helps to, for example: develop openness and honesty enhance feelings of loyalty and trust make them feel valued and respected keep them informed about changes and potential problems make sure that changes in expectations are monitored Workbook 2 51 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Whilst complying with the GDPR, staff members need to provide regular communication before, during and after transactions with internal and external customers. For example, they may need to: Before the transaction: understand different customers identify different needs and expectations During the transaction: engage with the customer and take genuine interest give accurate, up-to-date and relevant information deal with queries, comments and complaints ensure that the customer’s legal rights are respected and protected After the transaction: give aftercare service respect and protect legal rights provide ongoing maintenance and support ask for feedback from customers that can be used to improve the service offer Knowledge Activity 11: Think about an organisation that communicates with you regularly – e.g. with emails, texts or leaflets to let you know about their new products or services. Make a few notes about: How you feel about them staying in touch Whether you feel more valued as a result of the communication Your feelings about returning to them for repeat purchases Recommending them to other people 52 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Exceeding customers’ expectations Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 18. The level of customer service that an organisation gives often distinguishes it from its competitors. Striving to exceed customers’ expectations is part of giving excellent customer service. How customers form their expectations When looking for ways to exceed customers’ expectations, it is important to look at how they form their expectations in the first place. This gives us clues about what we can do to influence customers’ impressions of the organisation and its service offer. Customers’ expectations can be described as what they expect the product or service to do to meet their needs. This can include, for example: features of the product or service competitive prices a good choice of goods and services fast service and response times personal service and aftercare fast and reliable delivery of goods excellent data security good guarantees and warranties Expectations are formed when customers learn about the organisation and its service offer. They can find information in a wide variety of places that include, for example: talking to customer service and sales staff – e.g. discussing features and benefits of products and services online or face-to-face advertisements – e.g. magazines, newspapers, social media, television and radio marketing materials – e.g. articles and promotions within brochures, leaflets, mailshots, websites and social media product or service information – e.g. in product descriptions, service level agreements or contracts; in instructions and user guides sponsorship – e.g. as a major sponsor of a sports league or tournament that reflects the organisation’s place in the market Workbook 2 53 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships media coverage about the organisation – e.g. in newspapers, magazines or online news feeds customer forums and reviews – e.g. on independent review sites or magazines, or through comments attached to the organisation’s own website personal contacts – e.g. information from friends or family who recommend or criticise the organisation and its service offer previous dealings with the organisation – e.g. repeat customers basing their opinions on earlier experiences If they know how their customers form their expectations, organisations can act to try to make sure that this has some influence over how the organisation and service offer are portrayed. For example, if research shows that customers form opinions and expectations on their advertising campaigns, organisations can use their resources effectively by making sure that they target the right products at the right people in a way that catches their interest. It is not always possible to exceed expectations. As customers, our expectations continue to increase as we become better educated about our rights and choices. The Internet has made it quite easy to research products and services in depth, which means that we can all be very well informed about our options before we even approach an organisation. Staff working in a customer service role need to keep some perspective as not all customers will be perfectly satisfied, even if the service offer is excellent, and there may be a limit to what they can do. The main ways in which organisations can aim to exceed customers’ expectations are by constantly reviewing their service offer, listening to feedback, considering comments and making adjustments to the service offer so that they can satisfy customers’ needs and expectations. New developments in products and services can give them something that really will exceed expectations for a while, but each ‘new’ thing becomes ‘old’ after a while. We just need to think about the fashion industry to see how organisations constantly look for ways to exceed their customers’ expectations. They launch new products every season, set trends, inspire innovation and keep reinventing themselves. Inevitably, fashions will repeat after a while and ‘retro’ becomes the new, big trend. From time to time, new materials and accessories will be invented, but organisations need to work hard and be imaginative about how to try to exceed expectations every season. 54 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Knowledge Activity 12: Think about one of your favourite gadgets. Make a few notes about how you felt about the buying process and service offer. What were your expectations before you purchased it? Which features of the service offer met or exceeded those expectations? What could the supplier have done to improve the buying experience and exceed your expectations? How legislation, policies and procedures can limit the service offer Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 19. In the first workbook, we briefly looked at legislation that has an impact on customer service delivery. Some of this legislation can affect and limit the service offer by setting guidelines that must be followed, to protect the consumers, employees and organisation. Similarly, the organisation’s own policies and procedures can also set limits to the service offer. The regulations and legislation that can limit the service offer include, for example: Trade Descriptions Act 1968 Consumer Rights Act 2015 Consumer Credit Act 2015 (incorporating the 1974 Act) Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 Workbook 2 55 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 General Data Protection Regulation Legislation or regulation: Trade Descriptions Act 1968 Consumer Rights Act 2015 Consumer Credit Act 2015 56 © LCG 2018 Main points: How the service offer might be limited: This covers the description Customers have rights if they of goods and services. believe that they have been Descriptions must be accurate, misled by false claims. The and the consumer has rights organisation needs to take if the product, service or great care to make sure they accommodation is not as describe their service offer described. accurately and limit the offer to what they can truthfully deliver. The Act covers the supply of Consumers have the right to goods, services and digital reject goods and claim repair or content through sales, hire and replacement, which limits the hire-purchase, and in work/ organisation’s options on how materials contracts. to deal with faulty goods and services. The goods must: of satisfactory quality be be fit for a particular purpose match the description, sample or model be installed correctly (when this is part of the contract) This deals with the licensing and controlling of credit and hire-purchase agreements. Customers can challenge unfair relationships with creditors and there is an ombudsman scheme to hear complaints. Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), customers have rights when they enter into credit or hirepurchase agreements. For example, there are rules about guarantors, high-cost-shortterm credit, and management of arrears. The strict rules can limit the organisation’s ability to offer credit to customers. Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 (and later amendments) The regulations ban traders from using unfair practices. Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 General Data Protection Regulation The regulations cover refunds. The General Data Protection Regulation deals with the security of information about customers that is held by an organisation – e.g. bank account details, email addresses, CCTV footage, medical records, tax records, full names, date of birth and contact details. Customers have the right to honest market practice and to enter into a contract in good faith. They are protected from misleading practices and aggressive sales techniques – limiting the organisation in how it portrays itself and its service offer. Consumers can change their minds within 14 days of receiving goods in most cases. This regulation needs to be included within the organisation’s own limits on the service offer. Customers have legal rights about how their personal data is used and managed. Organisations must be careful about collecting, using, sharing and releasing confidential information, which may limit the service offer – e.g. there may be delays whilst waiting for authority to share financial or personal information. The organisational policies and procedures that can limit the service offer will vary for each organisation. Policies and procedures include relevant legislation and explain exactly how actions should be carried out. They establish ground rules and operational standards. An organisation’s policies and procedures will be based on the industry, environment, operational activities and other variable factors, and could include, for example: A returns policy This could state the time limits for returning goods and the condition in which they can be returned. Some retailers allow returns, even though there is no legal obligation to do so. They do this as a goodwill gesture that supports their reputation for excellent customer service. Workbook 2 57 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Gift receipts Many business will give out gift receipts that do not show the price to enable the recipient to exchange the items if they wish. The policy will usually be clear about time limits and the requirement for goods and packaging to be in satisfactory condition. Gift vouchers The policy will usually state what the gift vouchers can be used for, and their expiry date. The availability of the service offer The service offer can be limited by availability. The policy and procedures will inform staff and customers about factors that may affect availability – e.g. time limits for special offers; offers only available while stocks last; extensions of sales periods. Restrictions on the service offer The organisation might put restrictions on the service offer. For example, they may only allow a maximum of twelve special offer items per customer or household; a supermarket might restrict the amount of bottled water it will deliver to 12 litres due to the weight and low profit margin of the items. The type of information that can be given out In line with data protection legislation, organisations will often have clear guidelines about what information can be disclosed – e.g. a GP surgery’s receptionist might only be allowed to telephone a patient to make an appointment but will not be able to discuss or release medical results. A cancellation policy A cancellation policy can put a limit on the service offer as it will state the circumstances under which products and services can be cancelled. For example, if a music event is cancelled due to the artist being ill at the last minute, the policy will state how to obtain a refund or rebook for another date. Similarly, the policy will state what happens if the customer cancels the product or service. 58 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Emergency procedures These can limit the service offer and customers will need to accept that the service offer will be affected in the event of an emergency – e.g. having to evacuate a stadium in the event of fire or public disorder. The cancellation policy will probably cover what happens if the service offer is subsequently cancelled or cannot resume to an acceptable standard. Knowledge Activity 13: Imagine that you go to a large music concert. When you get there, you find that the concert has been cancelled due to illness of one of the main band members. Makes some notes about: What the organisers are likely to offer you How you would feel What the organisers could have done to let fans know about the changes Workbook 2 59 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Giving customers added value Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 20 and 21. As we have seen already, it is not always possible to change the product or service to exceed customers’ expectations. There can be legal and operational reasons for limiting the service offer, and, in many organisations, it is not possible to constantly introduce innovation and inventions to make the products and services exceed expectations. If the core products and services cannot change, organisations need to find other ways to tempt and please customers, and they do this by giving customers added value. This means that they offer additional products or services that complement the main offer at very little extra cost. As we have seen already, customers usually expect as standard: efficient and polite service good-quality products and services problems to be dealt with effectively their opinion to matter To go beyond these expectations, organisations need to offer more so that customers perceive that they are receiving added value – things that are in addition to their standard expectations at little or no cost to themselves. This helps them to feel valued and that the organisation is doing its best for them. Typical examples of added value include, for example: having special offers – e.g. buy one get one free (BOGOF); seasonal sales; multipacks; two meals for the price of one on Wednesdays only grouping complementary products together in an offer – e.g. when supermarkets offer a main course, a side dish or pudding, plus a bottle of wine for a set combined price the organisation being customer-focused – e.g. going the extra mile when dealing with customers’ requests; being attentive towards customers; treating each person as an individual making the environment and image attractive – e.g. setting out a shop in a pleasing and logical way; using attractive packaging and branding; having good lighting and air conditioning 60 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships staff having good product knowledge – e.g. giving free advice to customers who are browsing before making their choice different delivery options – e.g. free delivery when the customer spends a certain amount free or inexpensive installation – e.g. when selling kitchen appliances extended guarantees and warranties – e.g. extra cover that is beyond customers’ statutory rights offering customers generous options to return or exchange goods – e.g. beyond the customer’s statutory rights giving good aftercare service – e.g. offering further services, helplines and other support taking follow-up action – e.g. when answering queries or sourcing supplies for customers offering loyalty points and cards – e.g. points and vouchers that can be redeemed for other goods and services offering membership and privilege cards – e.g. cards that give discount on certain items, or a free coffee and newspaper when the customer spends over a certain amount Organisations identify when they should build added value into their service offer by observing and reacting to their customers. Several things can trigger a review of when to add value, for example: data from surveys identifies changes in customers’ needs and expectations – e.g. following an improvement in technology customers leave comments and feedback about their reaction to the service offer – e.g. showing what they like and what needs to be improved customers let the organisation know they are thinking about switching to a competitor sales figures show changes in customers’ spending patterns – e.g. spending less, cancelling contracts or shopping elsewhere competitors’ activities – e.g. offering something that may attract their customers planning a marketing campaign – e.g. to attract new customers, launch a new product or retain loyal customers planning for traditions, festivals and seasons – e.g. offering money-saving deals after Christmas to sell excess stock; offering special deals on barbecue food in the summer Workbook 2 61 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships supply exceeds expected demand – e.g. when a supermarket has ordered too much food that has a short use-by date and needs to be sold quickly opportunities to make sales by following trends – e.g. offering special deals on fresh vegetables when the media are covering the benefits of healthy eating Customer-facing staff in the organisation need to know when added value has been built into the service offer. This means that they are well-prepared to tell customers about the latest version of the service offer, and offer the additional services that have been advertised and promoted. Knowledge Activity 14: Make a few notes about the added value features that you appreciate when you are a customer. 62 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Supporting improvements in customer service Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 22, 23 and 24. As we have seen, it is important for staff members to work together and follow standardised policies and procedures, to make sure that they can provide consistently high-quality customer service. Working together is important when supporting improvements, too. Communication is vital to make sure that everyone understands the service offer, how improvements can be implemented and how to make changes smoothly for the benefit of the organisation, its staff and its customers. Identifying ways of improving customer service Feedback from customers can be very useful when developing customer relationships. It can be requested or it may be left voluntarily by the customer, and can be collected from, for example: informal comments made to staff complaints – formal or informal, verbal or written comment or suggestion cards – e.g. at reception or in hotel rooms satisfaction surveys and questionnaires – face-to-face, by telephone or online feedback forms – e.g. filled in by learners after a training course focus groups – as part of a market research initiative unsolicited letters and emails from customers online forums and blogs – where people leave honest comments about their experience the media and social media – e.g. letters to a local newspaper about the organisation; comments on Facebook, Twitter, TripAdvisor or other sites Not all customers give feedback, so it can be quite difficult finding out about how they felt and how satisfied they were. However, organisations should not pester customers for feedback as this becomes irritating and can affect the customer relationship. Pestering for feedback can actually put customers off returning and recommending the service or product to other people. For example, in a restaurant where the food is excellent, customers will not be satisfied with their experience if front-of-house staff ask if everything is all right every ten minutes. Customers will be very irritated, will spend less and will be less likely to return and recommend the restaurant to their friends and family. Workbook 2 63 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Once organisations have identified ways of improving their customer service, they can: react to customer feedback – e.g. respond to customers where appropriate; reflect on the comments and review the service offer as appropriate adapt their service offer – e.g. to adopt practical, useful and profitable changes inform their staff about the changes – e.g. through ongoing training courses or informally via line managers change policies and procedures – e.g. to clarify how the new features of the service offer will work in practice Constraints on suggested improvements Organisations need to balance customers’ expectations with operational requirements, so there will be constraints when implementing suggestions on how to improve customer service. These could include, for example: Financial resources The organisation may not have the money to implement all or any of the suggestions, or they may have to implement the changes over a period of time. They need time to work out budgets and cost implications of changes before making final decisions. Staff resources The organisation may not have sufficient staff resources to cope with changes, especially in the short term. They may need time to, for example: train current staff recruit more staff with the required, new skillset arrange cover from agency staff set up training programmes – in-house or with external training providers adjust the allocation of staff between tasks Physical resources The suggested improvements may need a change in physical resources – e.g. materials, premises, equipment or transport. These changes need to be managed and financed. They may already be working at full capacity, in which case the organisation will need to assess whether investment or restructuring the operation are necessary or worthwhile. 64 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Time The organisation may not have time to implement suggested improvements, especially if deadlines are tight. For example, a campsite may not be able to develop its toilet facilities in time for the summer season due to delays in the planning process. Different perceptions of what is required Customers, staff members and the organisation may have different views about what improvements need to be made, and how change should be achieved. Differing perceptions could constrain improvements unless full understanding and a compromise can be achieved. Legislation and regulations Legislation and regulations can constrain many suggested improvements to customer service. For example: requests to increase and improve parking facilities could be affected by planning laws and local government regulations; suggestions to increase the number of people at a public venue will be constrained by fire and other safety legislation; anti-discrimination legislation, the Equality Act 2010, could constrain improvement plans for buildings as organisations need to consider access for people with mobility problems. Working within limits of authority when making improvements As with all aspects of employment, it is important for all staff members to work within the limits of their authority when implementing customer service improvements. Everyone needs to, for example: know the details of their level of responsibility within the organisation keep their knowledge about products and services up to date – especially following changes work within the limits of their expertise, experience and knowledge of procedures experienced colleagues or their line manager for assistance or advice if they ask are not sure escalate problems and queries that are not within their limits of authority report issues and problems as soon as possible – so that adjustments can be made for the whole organisation if necessary Workbook 2 65 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships Each staff member needs to know exactly what the agreed improvements are before communicating with customers. If staff members offer something that has not been approved or agreed, it can lead to serious problems, for example: breaches of regulations or legislation loss of revenue or profit for the organisation health and safety issues a poor reputation for the organisation – e.g. from being seen as unreliable disciplinary procedures for the individual – e.g. from not following the correct procedures and training Working within agreed and established limits of authority makes sure that the service offer is consistent and that changes are agreed and implemented smoothly and consistently – to maximise the benefit of making improvements and exceeding customer expectations. Organisations need to hear from staff members to be able to judge and analyse how improvements are going. If the suggested improvements are going well, managers need to know this so that they can observe, praise and support staff members, and encourage them to continue in the same way. If there are problems with the suggested improvements, managers need to know as soon as possible, so that they can make adjustments and address minor issues before they become major problems. Knowledge Activity 15: Consider recent improvements that have been made to customer service in an organisation you know well. Make a few notes about: The changes that were planned The changes that were made How the organisation let you know about the improvements 66 © LCG 2018 Section 2: Understand how to develop customer relationships How the staff told customers about the improvements Summary In this section, we have considered how to develop customer relationships, exceed customer expectations and support customer service improvements, including: the importance of developing relationships with customers the value of customer loyalty and retention changes in customers’ expectations using feedback working within the limits of authority CRM systems the importance of regular communication how to identify ways of improving customer service potential constraints when implementing suggestions the limits of authority when making improvements Workbook 2 67 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Introduction In this section, we are going to look at how to resolve problems, deliver customer service to challenging customers and deal with customer complaints and feedback. We will consider how organisations deal with challenging customers, and how to deal with different types of challenging behaviour. We will also look at how organisations deal with complaints, the causes of complaints, techniques for dealing with angry or agitated customers, and the collection of customer feedback. How organisations deal with challenging customers Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 25 and 26. When delivering customer service, it is important to adapt to different customers to meet and expect their expectations, where possible, and present a positive image of the organisation. Being able to understand and deal with challenging customers can help us tackle situations that might feel rather awkward and difficult, and do our best to provide excellent customer service. In all communication with customers, however challenging they might be, it is important to remember to follow the requirements of different regulations and legislation, for example: Equality Act 2010 – to avoid discrimination based on any of the protected the characteristics General Data Protection Regulation – to uphold customer rights and maintain confidentiality consumer-related legislation – to protect the customers’ rights Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 – to minimise the risk of harm to staff the members, customers and others 68 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Different types of challenging customers As we saw in the first workbook, customers can present extra challenges at work for a variety of reasons. People might exhibit challenging behaviour or make extra demands as a result of: reasons outside the organisation’s control reasons within the organisation’s control a mixture of the two Challenging customers may be angry, unreasonable, confused, distressed, demanding, difficult to communicate with, or in need of extra assistance. As mentioned before, the reasons behind their challenging behaviour can include, for example: additional needs or requirements poor communication skills language barriers cultural barriers personal problems an incident, emergency or trauma dissatisfaction and disappointment being impatient, indecisive, talkative, overly assertive, confident or intimidating It is important to collect information about the reasons behind a challenging customer’s behaviour as this helps us to work out how to react and take appropriate action. Organisational procedures and standards of behaviour Organisations have their own policies and procedures about how to deal with challenging customers. Some organisations deal with customers with particular challenges as part of their day-to-day activities, and their working practices are geared up to deal with difficulties that their staff face as part of their normal job, especially in the public sector. For example, staff working in GP surgeries, care homes or hospitals will have training, guidance and support about how to deal with challenging patients, residents, family members and other visitors. Workbook 2 69 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Some organisations in the private and voluntary third sectors also specialise in dealing with challenging customers. For example, staff working in the customer complaints section of a call centre or as counsellors for a charity will have their own strict guidelines about procedures and standards. Staff members’ behaviour Although some organisations rarely have to deal with challenging customers, all organisations need to have policies and procedures about how to behave, so that staff members know how to handle themselves and the situation if necessary. Standards and codes of behaviour could include instructing staff members to, for example: stay calm and polite at all times welcome and greet each customer be patient – e.g. allow the customer plenty of time to express themselves listen carefully to the customer – e.g. use active listening skills and good questioning techniques show empathy – e.g. show that they understand the customer’s position apologise sincerely for problems caused by the organisation – e.g. let the customer know that they are sorry and will do all that they can to help put things right find realistic and satisfactory solutions – e.g. offer solutions within the limits of authority ask for help and escalate the problem when required – e.g. ask for advice or guidance when the possible solutions are not within the limits of authority Providing assistance for customers with additional needs and requirements As well as training their staff in how to deal with challenging customers, organisations can also provide a range of aids to support customers with different needs. These might include, for example: ramps for wheelchair users – also useful for pushchairs and people with walking difficulties loop systems for those with hearing difficulties – a special microphone system that hearing aids can be tuned into to boost the sound, often found in theatres, meeting rooms, churches, village halls and so on subtitles on training or information DVDs – for hearing impaired and also useful for those whose first language is not English translation services – particularly where there are legal implications, such as in a police station following arrest 70 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers wide doors and corridors, adapted kitchen units – to allow space for a wheelchair assistance for people with sight impairments – large print forms, Braille forms and signs, large computer screens, facilities for guide dogs accessible lifts and doors – that open automatically or have an accessible button to press for access evacuation chairs for emergencies – for specially trained staff to use when lifts are out of action, during a fire for instance handrails and grab rails adapted changing and toilet facilities – now called accessible toilets, most have wide doors, room for wheelchairs, accessible handrails, sinks and driers childcare facilities – crèches, nappy-changing rooms Organisations have to make ‘reasonable adjustments’ to make their products and services accessible to customers. In some small, old buildings, for instance, it is not possible to put in ramps, so there may be a special button outside for wheelchair users to press to call a staff member who will come out and offer assistance. Respecting cultural diversity and language issues Organisations usually have policies, procedures and training to promote equality, encourage respect and make it clear that discrimination is not tolerated, even when dealing with challenging customers. In the customer service role, staff can do several things to embrace and respect cultural diversity. We can, for example: observe, understand and respect different dress codes and symbols – e.g. customers wearing a cross, a hijab or a turban be respectful and aware of how different genders can be treated in other cultures – e.g. some cultures can seem quite sexist to us in the UK, with the husband making all of the decisions during a transaction, for instance be sensitive to the person’s gender – e.g. female patients may prefer or insist on seeing a female doctor be very discreet and allow privacy – e.g. in a changing room learn about festivals and customs for other cultures – so that they understand the main points and can hold an informed conversation with the customer be polite, courteous and friendly at all times Workbook 2 71 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers speak clearly and slowly, avoiding local sayings – especially if English is not the customer’s first language repeat very clearly if requested – maybe using different words, gestures or a diagram to help the customer understand something stay calm when they are not sure about how to handle the situation The main thing is to treat every customer as an individual, with respect and patience, whatever their background or culture. Knowledge Activity 16: You need to find out about your organisation’s procedures and standards of behaviour when dealing with challenging customers to be able to answer the assessment question. Make a few notes here about: The types of challenging customer you are likely to have to deal with – and the reasons behind their challenging behaviours The main points of your organisation’s procedures The standards of behaviour they expect from you The backup and support you can call for if you cannot cope with the situation 72 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Challenging behaviour Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 27, 28 and 29. Customers can have underlying issues that lead to challenging behaviour, or they may just be reacting to difficult circumstances. In any situation, if any staff member feels unsafe, they should not risk their own personal safety. They should always take care of themselves, their colleagues and other customers, and call for support and assistance if they feel that they may not be able to handle the customer or their companions, friends and relatives. Staff should call the manager or security staff if they are in any doubt at all. If we wade into a situation that is out of control, we can easily get hurt. Trying to deal with a violent customer, then ending up hurt and off work, does not help anyone in the long run. For example, if a nurse on duty in a busy hospital gets injured when they intervene in a fight in the reception area: there might be long-term or permanent damage to their own health the nursing team suffers as it tries to cover for the missing staff member when they are off sick the level of service to other patients is compromised due to the team being shortstaffed Even if that nurse manages to help one person in the fight, if they get hurt and are off work for several weeks, they cannot help hundreds of other patients who would benefit far more from their help. By leaving the trained security staff to sort out the fight, the valuable, experienced nurse can devote their time and energy to helping people with medical needs. Different challenging behaviours As we saw in the first workbook, staff in a customer service role may have to deal with customers who are angry, distressed, upset, violent or dissatisfied with the service offer. Challenging behaviours can include, for example: aggression – e.g. threatening or bullying staff or others; being violent; standing very close to someone and intimidating them; using threatening gestures frustration – e.g. getting angry and making inappropriate comments; refusing to accept limitations and procedures; crying or losing control of their temper Workbook 2 73 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers irritation – e.g. being impatient and bad-tempered; questioning the competence of staff or the organisation confrontation – e.g. arguing with staff making unreasonable demands – e.g. expecting solutions that cannot be delivered; being unrealistic about deadlines or the limits of the service offer Difference between assertive and aggressive behaviour There is a difference between assertive and aggressive behaviour, and it is important to be able to differentiate between the two behaviours. Assertiveness If people are being assertive, they stand up for themselves and strive to maintain relationships. They can use verbal and non-verbal communication methods and will work hard to make themselves heard, stand up for their rights and keep the channels of negotiation open. Assertive behaviour can include, for example: being self-assured and confident – e.g. using a clear voice and positive, open body language making a confident, clear and honest declaration – e.g. stating clearly what, how and when they want something to happen being aware and clear about rights – e.g. a customer knowing their rights and being clear about what they want being proactive – e.g. taking action rather than just waiting for something to happen respecting boundaries – e.g. respecting other people’s personal boundaries and knowing how far they can go when negotiating being willing to defend a position – e.g. not giving in to aggressive behaviour Aggression If people are being aggressive, they force their point of view on others, and can violate the rights of others. Their behaviours can be emotional and unpredictable, for example: angry outbursts – e.g. swearing, shouting or screaming physical violence or threats aggressive body language – e.g. standing extremely close to someone or shaking their fists 74 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers When customers are angry, they may: use a stern voice – with clipped and harsh pronunciation use tense body language – hunched shoulders, clenched fists, aggressive stance go red in the face with eyes wide and staring clench and grit their teeth breathe loudly and quickly through their nose suddenly erupt and lash out – especially if alcohol or drugs have been taken Some aggressive behaviours are quite passive and non-threatening. For example, challenging customers might use sarcasm, or come across as resentful or obstructive. Techniques for dealing with challenging behaviour Sometimes staff in a customer service role have to deal with customers who are upset, and it is important for the staff member to respond professionally and appropriately. This is to safeguard the personal safety of the staff member, their colleagues, the customer, and others who may be affected. As we become more experienced at dealing with customers and difficult situations, we can develop a range of techniques for dealing with challenging behaviour. The main aims are to: diffuse emotions identify the problem agree and implement solutions take appropriate follow-up action When selecting techniques to deal with challenging behaviour, staff can, for example: welcome and greet the customer introduce themselves – giving their name and role in the organisation offer to move or change the environment – e.g. to find somewhere quiet to discuss everything in private; to remove the customer from the cause of anxiety; to protect the health and safety of staff, customers and others speak clearly and ask open questions – to encourage the customer to explain their needs and expectations Workbook 2 75 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers use active listening skills – e.g. use good eye contact, nod, smile, use open body language, make notes if necessary, and ask related questions show empathy and give the customer full attention – to appreciate the customer’s point of view focus on the desired outcome – e.g. finding solutions to the customer’s problem with the service offer; calming a customer down so that they can explain themselves clearly explore and agree a solution – e.g. arranging a refund; making another appointment; setting a new deadline; escalating the problem to a line manager agree and take follow-up action – e.g. chasing suppliers for a replacement item; calling the customer to make sure that the problem has been put right It is important to speak normally, keep calm and not raise our voices, even if the customer is being very difficult. We need to focus on the customer, present a solution, take action and follow it up. The techniques need to be adapted to suit the individual customer and the circumstances. Here are some examples: A customer with additional needs or requirements due to a hearing impairment If a customer gets frustrated and angry because they are hard of hearing and cannot understand everything that is being discussed, the staff member might, for example: offer to speak to the customer in private – so that they can discuss confidential or sensitive details away from other customers, and not worry about speaking too loudly repeat information slowly and clearly let the customer see their face so that they can lip-read use written instructions or diagrams to illustrate important points The staff member might also speak to the customer’s companion if permission has been given – e.g. a family member who has accompanied them to an appointment with a doctor. 76 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers A distressed customer who has witnessed an accident If a customer is extremely distressed because they have just witnessed an accident, they may be very confused, upset and liable to go into shock, especially if they know the person in the accident. They need reassurance and for staff to be kind, patient and sensitive. It may not be possible to solve the problem or cause of the distress, so listening is the most important support in the first instance. If the customer is in shock, maybe following bad news or an accident, they may not make much sense. Shock can cause severe medical problems, so it is advisable to call a first-aider or other qualified person, especially if the customer looks pale and feels sick and dizzy. Customer service staff who work in hospitals and other healthcare organisations will have special training in how to recognise and deal with shock. If in doubt, ask for backup and help. Knowledge Activity 17: Make some notes about your organisation’s procedures for dealing with customers who are: Upset Aggressive Violent Workbook 2 77 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Levels of authority Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 30. It is important to know the established levels of authority so that staff know what they can agree to when negotiating with customers. Staff need to know: what they can offer within the terms of the service offer what actions they can take that are outside the service offer This is especially true when faced with challenging customers who might be emotional and difficult to deal with. Under pressure, it can be very tempting to agree to the demands of someone who is in an emotional state, just to find a quick solution. However, everyone within an organisation needs to work to agreed standards, procedures and policies to provide consistent and high levels of products, services and customer service, so staff need to know what they are permitted to offer. Actions within the service offer As we saw in the first workbook, the service offer can cover many things, such as: the range of goods and services offered pricing – e.g. stating the price including Value Added Tax (VAT), or maybe excluding VAT for trade customers discounts – e.g. buy one get one free; 10% off if customers buy today delivery options – e.g. free for standard delivery when customers spend above a minimum amount; charges for overnight or weekend delivery installation options – e.g. charges for installing household appliances like washing machines warranties – e.g. extended warranties on electrical goods that guarantee repairs or replacement if there are faults after the period covered by the manufacturer returns policies – e.g. rules about exchanges or refunds on returned items that are not faulty other value-added features – e.g. loyalty card points 78 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Actions outside the service offer In addition to the details of the service offer, organisations set out the levels of authority for each work grade or individual staff member to show what actions they can and cannot agree to. The information can usually be found in, for example: employment contracts job descriptions training materials operations manuals and notes The details of actions staff can agree outside the service offer will show, for example: what the individual is allowed to agree to without referring to a line manager – e.g. discounts and special offers; delivery times and installation costs; small refunds what the individual needs to escalate to a line manager – e.g. large refunds; items that have been returned outside of the statutory time limits; product faults that need to be reported to the manufacturer The organisation needs to clarify what each individual staff member can agree with customers when using their own discretion. For example, if customers spend over £500 in an electrical retail outlet, staff are allowed to offer free delivery and installation at their own discretion during a promotion period, even though this is not shown in the service offer. Knowledge Activity 18: You need to be able to describe your own levels of authority of agreeing actions outside the service offer to answer the assessment question. To prepare for this, make a few notes here about: The main points of your organisation’s service offer What you are allowed to agree using your own discretion How customers react to the ‘extras’ that you are allowed to offer Workbook 2 79 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Keeping colleagues informed Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 31. Sometimes it is not possible to find and implement effective solutions to the problems raised by challenging customers. This can happen for a variety of reasons, for example: recurrence of the original fault after being repaired and returned to the customer a – adding to their anger and frustration with the product missed delivery slots – due to a breakdown in communication within the organisation and its suppliers problems outside the organisation’s control – e.g. bad weather stopping deliveries from the wholesaler; a fire at a warehouse recurring IT problems – e.g. losing the customer’s request or order colleagues making mistakes – e.g. agency staff who do not know the systems making errors that affect the customer’s order or query customer having learning and communication difficulties and making the exaggerated or false claims – e.g. if they are unable to operate a product correctly customer being ill or confused and reporting the same problem again and again the – e.g. forgetting previous actions because they are suffering from dementia In such situations, customers will often reopen their original complaint or enquiry, and maybe demand that the matter is escalated to the line manager. It is important to inform colleagues when customers do reopen or escalate a complaint for two main reasons: may not be available when the customer makes contact, so a colleague has to we step in and deal with the problem our line manager may need to be brought in if the problems is being escalated Giving fellow team members or line managers all of the details enables them to, for example: a picture of what has happened already – e.g. details of the original problem, get the actions taken and what has happened since deal with the customer from a position of knowledge support the decisions and actions that have already been made offer alternatives with some authority – e.g. offer solutions that have not been tried before 80 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers In addition to helping them to gain full knowledge of the current position and previous actions, there are wider benefits for the organisation. If colleagues and managers are well briefed: everyone knows where they stand because they are all following the organisation’s established procedures customer can be dealt with effectively and without having to repeat themselves the too often the organisation’s reputation with its customers can be maintained customer loyalty can be developed and maintained managers can be fully informed, which helps them to make effective decisions about the problem and the escalation process staff members can be supported if persistent and unreliable challenging customers make repeated accusations and unjustified complaints Complaints procedures to resolve customer service problems Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 32 and 33. It is important for organisations to resolve customer service problems effectively so that they can meet or exceed their customers’ needs and expectations, develop and maintain a good reputation, and survive in the marketplace. Although complaints can be difficult to handle, if the organisation is told about issues, it does have the opportunity to put things right, improve their service offer and avoid future complaints. To provide consistently high-quality customer service, organisations set up and follow customer service and complaints procedures to show their staff how to deal with customers and different types of problem. Customer service procedures Organisations need to give their staff guidelines about how to communicate with customers in all aspects of customer service. Customer service procedures cover many tasks and functions, for example: quality, image and presentation of products and services quality, image and presentation of staff promotion of services contact and communication with customers Workbook 2 81 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers the delivery of products to customers monitoring and improving products and services finance compliance with legislation and regulations Communication with customers is extremely important before, during and after a transaction, and the standards and procedures will show how staff need to be able to, for example: Before the transaction: understand different customers identify different needs and expectations check the customer environment – e.g. is the waiting area clean and tidy? check that high-quality products and services are ready and available During the transaction: welcome and greet the customer engage with the customer and take genuine interest give accurate, up-to-date and relevant information make sure that the customer’s environment is prepared and comfortable use the best communication methods and techniques for the customer and the situation deal with queries, comments and complaints ensure that the customer’s legal rights are respected and protected end the transaction with positive comments and body language After the transaction: give aftercare service respect and protect legal rights provide ongoing maintenance ask for feedback from customers deal with complaints and feedback effectively 82 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Effective customer complaints procedures Part of excellent customer service delivery is having robust and effective complaints procedures. Some large organisations have a customer service department and the staff there will deal with complaints. Others have special complaints teams that focus purely on handling issues raised by customers. Smaller organisations and businesses will rely on their staff and managers to handle complaints themselves. Whatever the size of the organisation, complaints need to be handled in a consistent way throughout. Features of complaints procedures could include standardised processes about, for example: who deals with complaints what each staff member is allowed to say and agree timescales for resolution how to deal with each situation and which solutions can be offered when to escalate the problem up the management line what happens if the organisation cannot agree a satisfactory outcome with the customer – e.g. the customer’s rights under consumer legislation customers’ statutory rights The complaints procedures will give details about how staff members should deal with each complaint, instructing them to, for example: listen to or read the details of the complaint – maybe making notes about the details apologise to the customer – and show that they understand and sympathise with the customer explain the background to the problem or issue – or offer to investigate if the cause of the problem is not obvious outline solutions and keep the customer informed at all stages of the process – even if it takes many weeks to resolve the problem apologise again, reassure and thank the customer for their patience and custom Workbook 2 83 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers They may be advised to use the HEAT method when applicable: hear – listening to the customer’s complaint properly empathise – showing that they understand the customer’s position, frustration etc. apologise – saying sorry is incredibly important take ownership – taking the problem seriously, seeing it through to a satisfactory end, keeping the customer informed, passing on feedback to the organisation Complaints need to be dealt with quickly and effectively to defuse the anxiety and stop the complaint becoming more serious. It may be that staff need to diffuse the situation before they pass on the complaint to a manager, the customer service team or the complaints team. If they are the first point of contact with the complaining customer, their role is vital to keep everything calm and polite, even if they cannot solve the problem. In all customer service situations, staff need to bear in mind any possible communication problems. The customer may be nervous and a little aggressive due to nerves about making the complaint. They may also have visual, speech, reading, writing or hearing problems, or not have English as their first language. Staff need to take these factors into account when responding to keep the anxiety levels as low as possible. Knowledge Activity 19: You need to describe your own organisation’s customer service and complaints procedures to answer the assessment question. To prepare for this, ask your employer (or an organisation that you know well) for a copy of their complaints procedure, or look up a company online and find theirs. Make a few notes to outline their procedures for handling complaints. 84 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Customer service problems and their causes Complaints can arise for a variety of reasons, including: faulty goods or missing parts poor-quality products or services incorrect or incomplete delivery of items bad customer service – e.g. from rude or unhelpful staff the service or product does not match the description – not meeting the customer’s expectations delays and missed deadlines – maybe leading to fines and interest charges lack of information – e.g. when transport is delayed inefficient systems – e.g. call centres passing customers from one advisor to another when they call for help; long queues that are badly managed unfair treatment – e.g. for receiving a parking ticket when the signs were unclear or absent impact on the environment – e.g. the location of wind turbines; noise from neighbours or traffic; dealing with waste inefficiently negative consequences of someone’s actions – e.g. medical problems missed during an examination that lead to serious health issues; someone slipping on a wet floor in a hotel when the cleaner had forgotten to put out a warning sign The problems and causes can be identified by tracking information from, for example: customer feedback and complaints feedback from staff who encounter the problems or deal with customers’ comments returned and rejected goods internal audit and monitoring records external reports – e.g. from governing bodies legal action customer surveys, reviews and forum comments Workbook 2 85 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Dealing with angry or agitated customers Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 34 and 35. We have already covered techniques that can be used when dealing with challenging behaviour. These techniques can also be used when dealing with angry or agitated customers. To summarise: welcome and greet the customer introduce yourself offer to move or change the environment speak clearly and ask open questions use active listening skills show empathy and give the customer your full attention focus on the desired outcome explore and agree a solution agree and take follow-up action When dealing with angry or agitated customers, the first thing is to make sure that the angry customer does not pose a threat to the personal safety of the staff member, their colleagues, customers or other people. If there is no immediate threat, staff should deal with the angry customer by following the general techniques. It can be very important to offer to move to somewhere quiet as this can help to diffuse the situation because: the customer can discuss their details in private they can be removed from the source of their anxiety – e.g. a fight in a pub or street; a crowd of people who are reacting emotionally or erratically other customers are not upset or distracted by angry outbursts When customers are angry, they usually ‘run out of steam’ quite quickly if people just listen to them using good active listening skills. Arguing with them just gives them an excuse to carry on ‘ranting’ and is like throwing petrol on a fire. Listening and apologising are the best ways to defuse anger. 86 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Staff dealing with angry customers need to be very aware that anger can quickly lead to violence. If there is a possible threat to personal safety, during a heated argument between customers in a bar for instance, it is usually best to let specially trained security staff handle the situation. Experienced staff may be able to offer advice, but fights can flare up extremely quickly and it is not worth getting too close. Other conflict resolution techniques There are many theories about conflict resolution, and these techniques may also help when dealing with angry or agitated customers: Conflict resolution technique: Win-win or collaborating Details: The organisation and customer confront and solve a problem by working together The organisation or customer firmly pursue their Forcing or competing own concerns Smoothing or accommodating The organisation soothes the customer and accommodates their views The organisation and customer look for a mutually Compromising acceptable solution that satisfies all parties The organisation and/or the customer ignore or Withdrawing or avoiding step away from the conflict When dealing with any customer complaint about the organisation’s products or services, it is important to: listen to or read the details of the complaint apologise to the customer explain the organisation’s reasons for the problem or issue outline solutions and keep the customer informed at all stages of the process apologise again, reassure and thank the customer for their patience and custom This system is useful for all customers as it makes them feel valued and respected and shows that their concerns are being taken seriously. A sincere apology can diffuse anger very quickly, especially if the customer is emotional because they are nervous and tense about having to speak up for themselves. Workbook 2 87 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Keeping people informed when there is a problem, delay or complaint reduces anxiety and gives them the opportunity to adapt to the changes in the plans. Sometimes customers can reduce the impact on themselves by making alternative arrangements. Sometimes they will just feel reassured that something will happen, that their opinion and input matter and that the organisation cares about them as an individual. Limits of authority when resolving problems As we have seen before, working within the limits of authority is important. This applies to resolving customers’ problems as well, and staff members need to make sure that they are authorised to make promises. The limits of authority, and how to escalate a problem that is outside those limits, will be set out in, for example: the employment contract the job description organisational policies, procedures or standards training materials Working within the limits protects: individual staff member – by making sure that they act legally and are fully the supported in their decisions and promises if they have worked in line with the organisational procedures customer – by making sure that their legal rights have been observed and the respected organisation – helping it to maintain a good reputation for being fair and the consistent If staff members fail to operate within the limits of their authority, they can find that they may have: acted illegally – e.g. by promising something that does not support the customer’s consumer rights offered something that is impossible to deliver – e.g. due to cost or lack of available resources caused a health, safety or security problem – e.g. trying to mend an electrical appliance when they are not qualified to do so 88 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers themselves at risk – e.g. trying to hold down a violent customer instead of put calling properly trained security staff to deal with them Knowledge Activity 20: You need to explain the limits of your own authority for resolving customers’ problems and making promises to answer the assessment question. To prepare for this, find documents that show the limits of your authority in this area and make a few notes about: What you are allowed to promise Examples of what you and your colleagues promise and provide when resolving problems Customer feedback Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 36 and 37. Encouraging customers to give feedback Organisations need to collect positive and negative feedback from their previous, current and potential customers so that they can review their products and services and make sure that they are satisfying customers’ expectations. They need to review the feedback to evaluate the customer service and: see what changes are needed – to adapt to changes in trends, expectations, technology etc. find out what is working – so that they can develop and support the strong areas within the operation find out what is not working – so that they can rectify issues and catch major problems early, and make any necessary changes as soon as possible find the most effective and successful ways of handling queries and complaints Workbook 2 89 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers make sure that customers feel valued – to build customer loyalty make sure that they are complying with relevant legislation and regulations If the feedback is good and customers are generally satisfied, organisations need to, for example: give praise and credit to the staff reassure everyone that they are doing well maintain good standards and procedures monitor the service offer to make sure that high standards are maintained check external forces and trends to make sure that success is sustainable continue with research and development to make sure that future products, services and customer service are up to date and relevant Encouraging customers to provide feedback We all like to feel valued and that our opinions matter. Customers cannot be forced to provide feedback. However, there are many things that organisations can do to encourage people to give the useful feedback they need when reviewing their operations. Staff who deal with customers have many opportunities to make them feel included and important, and the organisation might have standards and guidelines about how to do this by, for example: engaging in small talk whilst serving someone face-to-face, online or on the telephone using active listening skills when dealing with feedback from a customer reassuring them, if they are making a complaint, that their views are being taken seriously asking for feedback and reacting to it in a genuine way The organisation can add to this with comments about how they value their customers in letters, advertising, brochures, websites etc. 90 © LCG 2018 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Various methods can be used to collect the feedback from customers. Working within the guidelines of the GDPR, these can include, for example: questionnaires and surveys – in person, online or by telephone comment or suggestion cards – e.g. at reception or in hotel rooms feedback forms – e.g. after a training course focus groups – as part of a market research initiative unsolicited letters and emails from customers online forums and social media – where people leave honest comments about their experience via the media – e.g. letters to a local newspaper about the organisation informally gathered chance remarks to staff or other customers The information gathered from monitoring complaints can be used in the planning process to improve customer service throughout the whole organisation. Many organisations have teams of customer service staff who monitor social media and other communication methods to capture and react to feedback comments. Organisations need to hear from their customers so that they can make sure that their service offer is well received, up to date and competitive. The data that is collected gives an insight into customers’ expectations and requirements. Knowledge Activity 21: Imagine that you own a small café. You have received some positive feedback about the coffees that you provide, but some very poor feedback and complaints about the teas on offer. How would you use the positive feedback about the coffees? How would you use the negative feedback about the teas? Workbook 2 91 Section 3: Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Summary In this section, we have looked at: different types of challenging customers organisational procedures and standards different behaviours techniques for dealing with challenging behaviour levels of authority keeping colleagues informed complaints procedures how to deal with angry or agitated customers collecting customer feedback 92 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Introduction In this section, we are going to look at how to develop working relationships with colleagues. We will consider the benefits of effective team working, giving constructive feedback, conflict resolution and communicating with colleagues. We will also look at the role of a ‘buddy’ in the workplace. Effective team working Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 38. For a team to work effectively, they have to develop productive and positive working relationships that are based on: clear lines of communication – so that people know where to go to ask questions, or report and discuss issues openness – giving and receiving correct and appropriate information mutual trust and respect – where everyone listens to each other, and acknowledges feelings and opinions Roles within a team People play different roles within a team, and an effective team will have people with very different skills and attributes. People cannot all be the same, so it important to have a variety in an effective and balanced team. In the 1970s Dr Meredith Belbin identified the types of role that members of a team take on when working together. During this research, Belbin discovered that a team’s success was not dependent on factors such as the intelligence of its members, but more on their behaviour and how they related to each other in working towards a common goal, purpose and/or objective. Workbook 2 93 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Belbin’s theory of the roles that people in a team play: 1. Chair/co-ordinator – able to get others working to a shared aim; confident, mature; good at making decisions and delegating. The co-ordinator clarifies group objectives, sets the agenda, establishes priorities, selects problems, sums up and is decisive, but does not dominate discussions. 2. Shaper – motivated, energetic, assertive and competitive; thrives under pressure; achievement-driven, keeping the team focused. The shaper gives shape and energy to the team effort. They can ‘steam-roller’ the team, but can get results. 3. Innovator/plant – innovative, inventive, creative, original, imaginative, unorthodox. The innovator/plant is the source of original ideas, suggestions and proposals. 4. Monitor evaluator – serious, prudent, critical thinker, analytical, impartial and even-tempered. The monitor evaluator contributes a measured and dispassionate analysis and, through objectivity, stops the team committing itself to a misguided task. 5. Implementer/company worker – systematic, loyal, structured, reliable, dependable, practical, disciplined, efficient; uses common sense but can be inflexible about change. The implementer turns decisions and strategies into defined and manageable tasks, sorting out objectives and pursuing them logically. 6. Resource investigator – good communicator, enthusiastic, networker, outgoing, affable, seeks and finds options, negotiator. The resource investigator goes outside the team to bring back ideas, information and developments. This person is the team’s salesperson, diplomat, liaison officer and explorer. 7. Team worker – supportive, sociable, flexible, adaptable, perceptive, listener, calming influence, mediator, dislikes confrontation, hard-working. The team worker operates against division and disruption in the team, maintaining harmony, particularly in times of stress and pressure. 8. Completer finisher – attention to detail, accurate, high standards, quality orientated; delivers to schedule and specification; good at finding errors. The completer finisher maintains a permanent sense of urgency with relentless follow-through and attention to detail. 9. Specialist – technical expert, highly focused capability and knowledge, driven by professional standards and dedication to personal subject area. 94 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Belbin discovered that a team without all of the nine roles would struggle to complete its task. For example, a team without an innovator/plant would find it difficult to come up with ideas, and if they didn’t have a shaper they would lose direction and focus. A balanced team has all of the nine roles within it and is, therefore, more likely to succeed. A team leader should be aware of the requirements for a balanced and effective team. Knowledge Activity 22: Make a few notes about which of the Belbin roles apply to you in your job, and why. Benefits of effective team working When people work together well as a team, there can be benefits for the individual team members, the team and the organisation. A group of people working together can achieve things that the individuals cannot achieve on their own. Team sports show this all of the time – we just need to think about how a football, rugby or netball team works together to meet their joint objectives and achieve goals. Single team members all have a valuable part to play and they could not win the match on their own. Effective team working brings a variety of benefits: for individual team members for teams for the organisation Workbook 2 95 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues For individual team members Individuals can benefit from, for example: feeling proud to be associated with a successful and effective team – e.g. a sense of belonging and job satisfaction feeling supported when tackling tasks or learning new skills – e.g. being able to develop their skills and stretch their talents with the help of others feeling secure and confident – e.g. from knowing that they are delivering highquality goods and services other team members’ knowledge, skills and experience – e.g. making the whole team more successful opportunities for creativity and career development – e.g. from team members supporting each other and being innovative increased motivation – e.g. to stay on a good team and help it to succeed by doing their best feeling valued – e.g. knowing that their input is important and that their opinions matter For teams Teams can benefit from, for example: working towards shared objectives – e.g. working together effectively towards agreed, shared goals team members who are flexible and able to do several tasks – e.g. multiskilled team members who can be moved around between tasks or cover for each other’s holidays, sickness etc. balanced and supported environment – e.g. from being a happy team where a the members support each other and tackle objectives and problems together bringing together expertise of team members for the benefit of the whole team – e.g. having people with different strengths and attributes For the organisation The benefits of effective team working can be considerable for an organisation, for example: successful achievement of organisational objectives – e.g. to meet or exceed sales or production targets access to a wide range of talents and strengths within the workforce – e.g. pooling different talents that work together well to achieve major goals 96 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues good internal communications – e.g. where team members and different teams communicate well with each other to improve operational productivity increased efficiency and less duplication of work – e.g. where teams understand each other’s tasks and needs, then work together to streamline their operations more flexible workforce – e.g. where team members can cover for each other a and perform a variety of tasks to maintain consistency and continuity better relationships with customers – e.g. from offering consistently high-quality customer service better relationships with others connected to the organisation – e.g. from having a reputation for being a reliable, consistent and smooth-running operation Feedback in the workplace Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 39. We all need feedback to find out how well we are doing, and this is an important part of effective team working. When feedback is good, it gives us positive reinforcement and gives us the confidence to carry on and develop our strengths further. The negative aspects of feedback are useful too because they show us where we need to make changes. Feedback can be formal or informal. Formal feedback will usually be documented and more detailed, and be given in meetings or on forms. Informal feedback is often unplanned and can be a brief message or comment, verbal or written. If we do not give and receive feedback, we have no way of knowing how we are doing from an objective point of view. Our efforts need to be measured against outside standards and opinions to reflect a realistic, three-dimensional picture of our performance in the workplace. Giving constructive feedback It is important to give feedback that is constructive. If someone just gives an emotional response and says that they do not like something, their feedback is not constructive because we cannot learn from it. Just knowing that someone is unhappy, disappointed or angry about something that we have said or done is not enough. We need to know the details about what went wrong and how we could have done better. When giving constructive and useful feedback, it is important to consider the person receiving the feedback. If the feedback is positive, it is a good opportunity to give Workbook 2 97 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues praise and encouragement. This empowers and motivates the individual or team to continue doing well and not lose focus. They feel valued and respected and will benefit from feeling appreciated and recognised. If some of the feedback is negative, this needs to be delivered carefully and objectively. The best way can be to use a ‘sandwich’ technique, where negative news is put between two bits of positive news, for example: praise the individual or team for a good aspect of their performance mention and explain areas that need to be improved, and give guidance and support about how to improve finish on a high note about positive aspects, plans and hopes for future developments and improvements When we are asked to give feedback about someone else, it can be a good idea to only say things that we would say to that person’s face. This helps us to keep our comments objective, fair, valid and useful. When delivered tactfully, constructive criticism and genuine praise are both valuable and welcome. To give useful and constructive feedback, we need to, for example: have a clear purpose for giving the feedback – e.g. being very clear on why we are giving feedback and what we need to achieve as a result respect the need for privacy and sensitivity – e.g. having a chat about problems in private rather than in a big team meeting specific – e.g. about what went well, what needs improvement and what needs be to be done in the future focus on the issue or behaviour rather than the person – e.g. concentrate on the facts rather than the emotional reaction to events check that the feedback has been understood – e.g. by asking questions or inviting comments have a balance between positive and negative feedback – e.g. using the ‘sandwich’ technique offer support – e.g. retraining or shadowing for an individual who needs to develop their skills following negative feedback 98 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Knowledge Activity 23: Think of two occasions when you received feedback at work. How did you feel? How did you react? What happened next? Write a few lines about what happened when: You received negative feedback You received positive feedback If this hasn’t happened to you yet, just imagine how you would feel and react. Resolving team conflicts Please read the following as it will help you to answer question 40. Conflict is an emotive word and its meaning can vary. In dictionaries, definitions include: a serious disagreement or argument, typically a protracted one a serious incompatibility between two or more opinions, principles or interests to be incompatible or at variance with something or someone According to the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (Acas), conflict falls into two broad categories: conflict between individuals – e.g. between colleagues or between team members and their team leader or manager conflict between groups – e.g. between teams or between large groups of employees and management Workbook 2 99 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Examples of causes of conflict at work could include: dissatisfaction with the workload or work slippages – e.g. increased workloads or missed deadlines lack of appreciation and perceived unfairness – e.g. someone feeling that they have not received appropriate credit for their efforts misunderstandings and poor sharing of information – e.g. concerned discussions and arguments due to not knowing what is happening external problems that affect the team or individuals – e.g. a supply problem leading to the team’s failure to finish on time and receive a bonus differences of opinion – e.g. between individuals, teams or organisations about working methods people having different objectives – e.g. some wanting to do overtime to finish the task on time whilst others want to leave and get home on time incompatible objectives and rivalry – e.g. between different teams bullying, harassment or personality clashes between individuals Conflict management techniques There are several techniques that can be used to minimise and resolve conflict at work. For example: win-win or collaborating – confronting and solving a problem by working with the other parties forcing or competing – when individuals only consider their own concerns and force their views on others smoothing or accommodating – when individuals smooth things over and accommodate other people’s views, needs, demands and requests compromising – when people look for a mutually acceptable solution that satisfies everyone withdrawing or avoiding – when people ignore the problem and step away from the conflict 100 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues The following table explains when the different techniques may be useful, as well as the different strengths and weaknesses: Way to manage or resolve conflict Win-win or collaborating Confronting and solving a problem by working with the other parties. Useful when: the long-term relationship is important consensus and commitment of others is important environment is the collaborative addressing the interests of many different people Strengths solves the actual problem leads to win-win situation with mutually beneficial results reinforces positive relationships, mutual trust and is a basis for future collaboration win-win solution might a not exist, or it may not be easy to find there is more respect for someone who is a good negotiator The individual firmly pursues their own concerns. can increase selfesteem Useful when the person resolving the conflict: can gain respect for being able to deal with hostility and aggression needs a quick resolution may take more effort and time less stressful quick resolution needs to resist aggression and pressure requires commitment from all parties and trust cannot be lost responsibility is shared there is a high level of trust Forcing or competing finds that less forceful methods do not work, and this is the last resort Weaknesses can have a negative effect on relationships can cause the opponent to react in the same way cannot compromise and accept the good points made by the opponent approach requires a the lot of energy and courage; can be exhausting to some Workbook 2 101 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Smoothing or accommodating The individual soothes others and accommodates their views. Useful when the person resolving the conflict: can protect more important interests while giving up on smaller issues gives opportunity to reassess from a different angle wants to put other people’s concerns first can be abused as the opponent can try to take advantage can affect confidence about dealing with aggressive situations difficult to move to the win-win situation supporters may consider the negotiator as weak is in the wrong needs temporary relief whilst finding long-term solutions has no choice and continued competition would be damaging Compromising Looking for a mutually acceptable solution that satisfies all parties. Useful when: goals are only moderately important temporary or fast a settlement is needed for complex issues it is used as a first step collaboration or forcing do not work 102 © LCG 2018 faster resolution of issues can provide a temporary solution reduces stress and tension parties might all be dissatisfied with the outcome does not contribute to trust in the long term might need close control and monitoring to see it through Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Withdrawing or avoiding Ignoring or stepping away from the conflict. Useful when the person resolving the conflict: believes the issue is trivial and not worth the time or effort considers other priorities more important can withdraw until the time and place are more appropriate can take time to gather information, evidence etc. can concentrate on more important priorities first can lead to losing or weakening the position where multiple parties are involved, can affect the relationship with parties who expect action needs more time to consider solutions thinks the time and place are inappropriate does not want to deal with hostility cannot deal with hostility due to personal issues passes the problem on to someone else for action Everyone needs to make sure that they work within the limits of their authority within an organisation, including when resolving conflicts. If we find that we do not have the authority, experience, skills or knowledge to resolve an issue, we need to make sure that we refer the matter to our line manager or a senior member of staff. The organisation’s procedures should show when to escalate a problem, but, if we are in any doubt, we should ask for advice and assistance. Workbook 2 103 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Knowledge Activity 24: Think about a time when you witnessed or experienced conflict – maybe at work, in school or in your private life. Make a few notes about: What caused the conflict How you felt at the time How it was resolved Whether it could have been dealt with differently 104 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Discussions in the workplace Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 41 and 42. Communication is vital for effective teamwork. All team members need to be able to let the right people know what is going on and keep them up to date. By discussing progress, issues, problems and changes, the relevant people will be able to react and make decisions that are right for the team as a whole. Discussing work progress and issues Information needs to flow in many directions and team members need to be able to tell their colleagues, team leaders and managers about their work progress and issues that arise at work when performing their tasks. For example, when discussing progress and issues, team members can: discuss their progress and compare it to work schedules – e.g. to see if they are behind or ahead of schedule with each task check that they are working to agreed standards – e.g. reporting issues that may affect quality or output help to avoid misunderstandings – e.g. making sure that everyone understands any problems they are facing identify and discuss any problems – e.g. discuss issues to see if others have experienced the same things agree actions that are needed – e.g. find solutions and corrective actions that work for everyone develop their skills – e.g. by practising negotiation and conflict resolution techniques develop working relationships – e.g. building trust and awareness that encourage team building, motivation and loyalty provide information to help managers with planning – e.g. team member who is ahead can be allocated to help a team member who is behind schedule due to illness Discussions about work progress and issues can be part of a team’s day-to-day activities. They might have team meetings or briefings so that everyone can report their own progress and issues in an open group, enabling everyone to discuss everything and find solutions. Meetings might take place at the beginning or end of each shift, for example, or when a product, service or procedure is being introduced or changed. Workbook 2 105 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Team members also need the opportunity to be able to discuss work progress and issues in private, maybe with a supervisor or manager. This is particularly important if there are personal issues that might be affecting their work performance – e.g. illness or serious family problems. Organisations need to make sure that team members know how to ask for a private discussion – maybe asking for a one-to-one meeting with their line manager, or sending a confidential email to human resources (HR). Team members also need the opportunity to discuss progress and issues as part of their career development. This can be during formal, quarterly appraisals, for example, or during informal, unplanned discussions. We all need the chance to give and receive feedback about work progress, with constructive comments and plans about how to develop our skills, knowledge and experience to enhance our career opportunities. Warning colleagues about problems and changes When discussing progress and issues arising at work, problems can come to light that might affect other people. These problems need to be communicated to the right people so that relevant colleagues at all levels can be warned. For example, if a team member who works on a food production line finds that a machine is working slower than usual, this might indicate that there is a major fault within the machine. Colleagues need to be warned because, for example: parts of the machine might have ended up in the food, so the production line needs to be stopped and checked immediately colleagues using similar machines might have the same problem the machines might cause injury to team members If it turns out that there is a serious problem with the machine, this would affect several other teams within the food production factory. For example: the maintenance team needs to be called quality assurance team needs to be warned that there may be contamination the in a batch of food packaging team needs to know that there will be a delay in producing finished the products for them to pack delivery drivers need to know that there may be delayed or cancelled products the that will not be available in time for delivery slots managers need to know about delays and problems so that they can make decisions and reschedule where possible 106 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues As we can see in this example, some problems can lead to changes that affect colleagues. They need to be aware of these so that they can adapt their tasks and procedures. For example, the breakdown of the food production machine may lead to changes that colleagues need to know about, such as: rescheduled production rotas for the next shift – e.g. closing the affected production line and increasing output for the other lines to compensate changes in inspection procedures for all machinery changes in the way food items are inspected for contamination – e.g. extra x-ray machines to check for metal parts changes in the quality control checks – e.g. extra visits or tests changes in orders from the supermarkets who can no longer have the cancelled product If team members warn their colleagues about problems or changes that may affect them, colleagues can work together as an effective team and, for example: anticipate work problems and changes – e.g. from having as much notice as possible avoid problems or stop them before they become serious – e.g. taking early action to prevent something happening share accurate information – e.g. about causes of problems or the corrective actions to be taken prepare for changes – e.g. by giving them the time and information needed to plan and adapt to changes keep the delivery of products and services on track – e.g. by pulling together as a team and working to catch up and bring output up to a reasonable level share and build trust between individuals and teams – e.g. by being honest about the knock-on effect of a problem or change for other individuals or teams make sure they understand the changes – e.g. by ensuring that important messages have been received, understood and actioned give and receive support – e.g. by being ready to assist colleagues to adapt to changes Workbook 2 107 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues How to buddy a colleague Please read the following as it will help you to answer questions 43a, 43b, 44 and 45. It is often useful to have support in the workplace or place of study, especially if we are new to the organisation or the role. Having someone to help us find our way can help us settle in and become productive more quickly. The term ‘buddy’ Many organisations now use the term ‘buddy’ to describe the role and actions of someone who is allocated to look after and mentor a new or less experienced colleague. A buddy is any colleague who is teamed with another colleague to provide them with ongoing support, training, development, feedback, mentoring and constructive criticism. For example: A buddy or mentor will be the experienced person who is given the task of looking after a new person. There can be a buddy relationship between the experienced colleague and the new recruit. word can be used as a verb that describes the action of ‘looking after’ – e.g. the The experienced colleague will buddy the new person for the next week; a colleague will buddy another experienced colleague who has come over from a different team. The new person can be new to: the whole organisation – e.g. a new employee on their first day team – e.g. coming over from another established team on a temporary or the permanent basis task – e.g. learning about a new task from a colleague who has just done the the training course and is ready to train and help others 108 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues What is expected of a buddy? A buddy’s main role is to help a colleague to develop their knowledge and skills so that they can settle in quickly and become a productive member of the team. A buddy is not usually expected to fully manage or train the new person, but they are expected to be a supportive, informative, approachable and friendly colleague. For example, a buddy might be expected to: reassure the new person and make them feel welcome show them around the building, campus or work area introduce them to their new work colleagues explain the organisational policies and procedures and maybe show them how to perform tasks show them where to find the physical resources they need – e.g. in a stationery cupboard, locked store cupboard or warehouse show them how to access support and information – e.g. from their line manager, training materials or company website make sure that they know that they can ask the buddy if they have queries arrange regular meetings to check their progress and answer any questions patient – e.g. if the new person asks lots of questions, sometimes more be than once A buddy needs to treat all information as confidential, so that the new person feels comfortable about confiding in them and showing their vulnerability. Workbook 2 109 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Knowledge Activity 25: Imagine that you are a new employee and it is your first day. Your buddy has shown you around and shown you what to do. You overhear them telling colleagues about you and laughing about how you do not have a clue about what to do and where to go. How would you feel about your buddy discussing you like this? Would you trust your buddy and feel able to confide in them? How should your buddy deal with things that you say and do as you find your way around? How to give positive feedback and constructive criticism In the previous section, we looked at giving constructive feedback. The techniques covered can be used in a buddy relationship. When giving feedback and constructive criticism to a buddy, it is important to: Start and end with positive comments Using the ‘sandwich’ technique makes negative comments much easier to give and receive. As the experienced colleague, it is really hard to give negative feedback to someone, even if it is well meant. By ending on a positive note, it is easier to deliver the ‘bad’ news as we know that we are going to follow it with something positive and useful. The recipient needs a positive comment at the end so that they do not feel completely negative – e.g. deflated, useless, depressed, hopeless or unacceptable. 110 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues For example, if a new employee in a supermarket makes a couple of mistakes on their first day on the checkout, their buddy might say: Positive Examples of suitable comments You did really well today. Well done, you coped very well. You seemed to enjoy that, well done. Negative to avoid try personal comments give practical advice about how to improve Positive You learned all that really quickly, well done. There was just one thing that we need to think about… when you have a query it’s important to tell the customer and not just ignore them. Next time it happens, just smile and explain briefly so that the customer does not feel abandoned. There were a couple of issues… it’s important to say hello to each customer and look them in the eye. This helps them to feel welcome. You were so good with the customers, though, you really engaged with them. You were very quick with the scanner and seemed to work it all out… well done. A really good first day, you should be very proud. You learn really quickly and you’re a great addition to the team. Well done. Focus on the issue not the person As we can see from the examples, it is important to concentrate on the issue or behaviour and not make the comment personal when the feedback is a bit negative. The objective is to help the new person to improve their knowledge and skills, not to put them down and make them feel inadequate. To achieve this objectivity, it helps to avoid saying “you” when giving constructive criticism. For example: “It’s important to say hello to the customer. It helps to make them feel welcome, relaxed and positive about the organisation.” This approach reinforces the standard that is required without making a personal comment about the new staff member. It encourages them to adopt the standard procedure. “You didn’t do that right. You didn’t say hello to the customer. You must greet them.” This is harsh and very personal, and is likely to leave the new staff member feeling very negative and bullied. Workbook 2 111 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Keep eye contact at all times when giving feedback Good eye contact reinforces authority and gives someone confidence that we know what we are saying. It focuses attention on the person receiving the feedback and helps them to concentrate. We can also see if they are listening. If they look us in the eye and engage with the comments, they are likely to absorb the feedback and information and follow the advice given. If they look away too much, look bored or do not engage at all, they are likely to ignore the feedback and disregard the advice on how to improve. This could cause problems as the new team member will find it hard to integrate and become a productive part of the team if they are unwilling to listen and learn. Use humour when applicable The role of the buddy is to be supportive, friendly and approachable, and the use of appropriate humour at the right time can help the new person to relax and become an integrated member of the team. Humour can be a great tool for building relationships and loyalty within a team. People that know each other and get on well will share funny comments, friendly banter, comic stories and gentle teasing. For a new person joining a group, the first few encounters can be rather anxious times – the group is well-established, with lots of shared history and values, and they are expected to join in. Humour needs to be appropriate for the newcomer, probably avoiding contentious issues, swearing and too much jargon that could offend them or make them feel left out. As working relationships develop, people will find their own level, common interests and sense of shared humour. The main thing is to make a new person feel welcome and to give them a chance to feel part of the team. Be specific and include examples Feedback and constructive criticism need to be targeted and specific. The objective is to help the new person to improve, so they need to be very clear about what is expected. In the example of the new staff member working on the supermarket checkout, the feedback is very specific – e.g. about saying hello to customers and not ignoring them if there is a problem. The issues are specific and the advice needs to be specific as well. Within the negative feedback comments are suggestions about how to address each issue – e.g. “…it’s important to say hello to each customer and look them in the eye. This helps them to feel welcome.” 112 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Choose a suitable time and place to give feedback As we have seen, confidentiality is important, especially if some of the feedback is negative and constructive criticism is required. It is usually acceptable to give someone general praise in public, although some people find this very embarrassing and awkward. However, it is not usually acceptable to give negative comments in front of others, such as colleagues or customers, and this can be seen as harassment or bullying. The organisation’s procedures should cover how and when feedback and criticism can be given – e.g. in the office after a shift; in a quiet corner of the staff canteen during a break when comments cannot be overheard. The timing of comments can vary. Sometimes a planned, full debrief that covers all aspects is required – e.g. at the end of a shift or at the end of the week. This may take some time and probably needs to be in a private office environment so that both people can freely discuss queries, problems and solutions. Sometimes an unplanned comment is needed, especially if there is an urgent problem or safety concern. This may need to happen in the work area to prevent an accident or major problem occurring. If possible, a full, private discussion needs to take place soon after, to explain the consequences and offer training and support. For example, if a new colleague makes a mistake on a production line, the experienced colleague will probably need to intervene straight away to prevent an accident or problems that could affect the whole production line. Once things have been stopped or put right, the buddy needs to explain in detail and offer support to the new person, maybe in a private meeting after the shift. Establishing a rapport with a buddy As we have seen, the buddy’s role is to help someone to find their way around an organisation, team or task. A buddy relationship is a friendly, supportive, one-to-one mechanism to help a new person to settle in and make progress in a new environment. As the two people work closely together for a while, it is important to build a rapport. The experienced colleague who acts as the mentor or buddy can, for example: Be friendly and approachable – e.g. be welcoming, patient and ready to answer a lot of questions; maintain confidentiality throughout the process Be trustworthy and supportive – e.g. maintain confidentiality throughout the process; take the new person’s opinions and concerns seriously Organise structured plans to cover all aspects – e.g. have a list of tasks to be covered in the first meeting; make sure that they are up to date themselves; have leaflets or other training materials to hand Workbook 2 113 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Arrange structured sessions for feedback and questions – e.g. to share information and build confidence in a private and organised way Give constructive feedback and criticism – using the ‘sandwich’ technique to tackle negative points Make sure that communication is balanced and not one-sided – e.g. encouraging the new person to speak by asking them open questions available to answer questions about day-to-day issues – e.g. face-to-face, Be on the telephone or via email Work hard to present a positive and welcoming image of the organisation or team – e.g. to help make the new person feel supported and confident about joining a worthwhile operation It is important to take into account the new person’s background and experience when deciding on the buddying techniques that will be best for them. For example, if the new person has been working for the same company for years and has just switched over to a new team for a few weeks, they will know where to find the canteen and toilets, but they may not know where to find the physical resources they need for the new tasks. They may know many people within the company, but may need to be introduced to key people on the new team. If the new person is new to the organisation but has previous job experience in the same industry, they may understand the procedures and how to perform their tasks, but they will not know where to find the canteen and toilets. If the new person has come straight from college, the chances are that they will not know the organisation’s procedures and working practices, so they will need to find out about their surroundings and what they are expected to do. The buddy’s approach needs to be flexible so that they can establish a rapport with the new person and support their individual needs and requests. By finding out about their previous experience, the buddy can tailor their support to the individual and help them to find their way and integrate smoothly and quickly. 114 © LCG 2018 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Knowledge Activity 26: Imagine that you have been asked to buddy a new person who is joining your organisation or college course. Make a few notes about: The practical things you would show them – e.g. toilets, stores or work areas Who you would introduce them to A basic outline of the work they are likely to cover on day one Questions you would ask them to help build a rapport How you would tackle giving them negative (but constructive) feedback about a piece of work Workbook 2 115 Section 4: Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Summary In this section, we have looked at the principles of effective team working and how to buddy a colleague, in particular: giving constructive feedback conflict management techniques importance of communicating with colleagues about progress, problems and the changes establishing a rapport with a buddy 116 © LCG 2018 Section 5: Extension activities Further your knowledge and understanding of the topics in this workbook by completing the following extension activities. Understand how to communicate with customers Extension Activity 1: Prepare a formal letter following the conventions of your own organisation, or following the example in this workbook. Write a letter to a customer to apologise for the delay in the delivery of their new sofa. Delivery is expected to be a month late due to a fire at the factory. You can offer them a refund or a goodwill gesture of a 10% discount plus free delivery. Design the letterhead as well, making sure that you include all contact details of the organisation. Don’t forget to include reference numbers, the date, a greeting and polite close at the end of your letter. Workbook 2 117 Section 5: Extension activities Extension Activity 2: Find some samples of written communication that your organisation sends out – e.g. brochures, leaflets, forms or pages from their website. Make some notes about the language, expressions and tone used in the samples, and how the customers probably feel about the written communications they receive. Understand how to resolve problems and deliver customer service to challenging customers Extension Activity 3: Imagine that you work in an insurance call centre. You are having great difficulty understanding a customer who has called to complain. What could be the causes of the communication difficulties? How would you deal with the situation? 118 © LCG 2018 Section 5: Extension activities Extension Activity 4: Think about a time when you witnessed or experienced an angry or agitated outburst of aggression or violence – maybe at work, in school or in your private life. Make a few notes about: What caused the outburst How you felt at the time How the situation was resolved Whether it could have been dealt with differently Workbook 2 119 Section 5: Extension activities Understand how to develop customer relationships Extension Activity 5: Find a café, restaurant, pub or hotel that you know on the TripAdvisor website. Describe: a selection of the comments left by customers the establishment’s reaction to them the potential impact on the establishment – positive or negative how you would handle the situation if you were given the task of managing the customer feedback 120 © LCG 2018 Section 5: Extension activities Extension Activity 6: Have a look online for details about different CRM systems. Entering ‘CRM system’ in a search engine, then selecting ‘Images’ can produce some interesting ideas. Find three different versions and make notes about their features. 1. 2. 3. Workbook 2 121 Section 5: Extension activities Understand how to develop working relationships with colleagues Extension Activity 7: Have a look on the Acas website and find resources about conflict resolution. List some of their recommendations for resolving conflicts between individuals. 122 © LCG 2018 Section 5: Extension activities Extension Activity 8: Look at your organisation’s induction process and how they use the buddy system (or their own equivalent). Make some notes about: the good features of the induction process how it could be improved how you can help new people who join your team or organisation Well done! You have now completed Workbook 2 and should attempt the assessments. If you require any help or guidance please contact your Assessor/Tutor. Workbook 2 123 REPUTATION PROCEDURES Disclaimer Copyright 2018 Every effort has been made to ensure that the information contained within this learning material is accurate and reflects current best practice. All information provided should be used as guidance only, and adapted to reflect local practices and individual working environment protocols. All rights reserved. All material contained within this manual, including (without limitation): text; logos; icons; and all other artwork is copyright material of Learning Curve Group (LCG), unless otherwise stated. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise), without the prior permission of the copyright owners. All legislation is correct at the time of printing, but is liable to change (please ensure when referencing legislation that you are working from the most recent edition/amendment). Neither Learning Curve Group (LCG); nor their authors, publishers or distributors accept any responsibility for any loss, damage or injury (whether direct, indirect, incidental or consequential) howsoever arising in connection with the use of the information in this learning material. If you have any queries, feedback or need further information please contact: Learning Curve Group 1-10 Dunelm Rise Durham Gate Spennymoor, DL16 6FS info@learningcurvegroup.co.uk www.learningcurvegroup.co.uk This resource has been endorsed by national Awarding Organisation, NCFE. This means that NCFE has reviewed it and agreed that it meets the necessary endorsement criteria. LCG-PCS October 2018 Version 2