FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS Financial statement analysis – involves careful selection of data from financial statements in order to assess and evaluate the firm’s past performance, its present condition and future business proposals. What is the purpose of financial statement analysis? The objective of financial statements analysis is to determine the extent of a firm’s success in attaining its financial goals, namely: (1) to earn maximum goals; (2) to maintain solvency and (3) to attain stability. 1) 2) 3) The three major financial statement user groups and what they hope to learn from financial statement analysis: Creditors – want to be assured of receiving prompt payments from the company a) Short-term creditors – include trade creditors and lending institutions b) Long-term creditors – lending institutions and corporate bondholders Equity investors – want to determine if the company will be able to distribute dividends in the future and if its shares will rise in value Management – objective is to monitor the company’s overall performance There are at least four traditional techniques of interpreting financial statements, namely: 1) HORIZONTAL (COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS) – presents the differences in absolute amount and in percentage between two periods (i.e., years, quarters etc..), two companies, actual and budgeted date, and other bases of analyses. The difference could either be an increase or a decrease both in amount and in percentage. the percentage change is computed as follows: PERCENTAGE CHANGE = AMOUNT OF CHANGE / BASE TREND ANALYSIS – the purpose of trend analysis is to track down what happened in the past and provide on what may happen in the coming years. It uses indexes and ratios to simplify the visible complications and annoying presentation of numbers contained in the financial reports. Financial data expressed in indexes and ratios are easily readable than those presented in terms of millions. Indexes are expressed in hundreds while ratios are expressed in normal decimal places 2) VERTICAL ANALYSIS (common size analysis) – gets the proportional component of each of the variables in the financial statements in relation to a chosen base. As in horizontal analysis, the financial statements are treated individually and each is analyzed independent of the others. • • • FINANCIAL STATEMENT Income statement Balance sheet Statement of cash flows BASES (100%) Net sales Total assets May be the total cash available for use 3) FINANCIAL MIX RATIOS In the horizontal, trend and vertical analysis, each financial statement is considered a stand-alone report. The truth is, these financial statements are interrelated and interlocked with one another. Examples contained in the income statement are directly related with information contained in the balance sheet and cash flows as shown in the diagram: Income statement Net sales Cost of goods sold Balance sheet Cash; trade receivables Cash; trade payables Statement of Cash flow Operating activities Operating activities Cash; Prepaid expenses Operating activities Accrued expenses Accumulated depreciation Operating activities, Cash; Bonds payable Investing activities and Discount/Premium on Financing activities Other items bonds, non-current assets Operating activities, Cash; Deferred income Investing, Financing and Income tax tax; Property and Operating activities equipment *non-cash items are Long-term debt; Material excluded cash shortage; Cash surrender value of life insurance, Since the financial statements are fundamentally-related, theetc... information contained in one statement could be related to the Operating expenses information found in another. This is the essence of financial mix ratio analysis. In computing the financial mix ratios, the amount used from the income statement is the net figures (i.e., net sales) while that from the balance sheet is the average amount (i.e., average inventory, etc.) Four classification of financial mix ratio analysis: • Profitability ratios – ability of the business to generate profit. It measures the ability of the business to generate profit in relation to sales, investments, assets, equities or common shares outstanding. • Growth ratios – are indicative of the organization’s potential and attractiveness as an investment option. • Liquidity ratios – refers to the ability of the business to pay its obligations in cash as they mature. Therefore, the focal point of the liquidity analysis is cash. It includes the ability of the management to convert its current assets into cash in a quick, stable 1 and regular manner. It also deals with the ability of management to use trade credits and stretch the payments to trade credits in financing operating activities. In short, the liquidity position of an organization is directly related to its operating activities and determines the speed of revolving cash in the operating cycle. • Financial Leverage ratios – refers to the use of debt to increase shareholders’ equity. Using debt to finance business activities would mean greater exposure to the risk of insolvency. The more leveraged the business, the higher the risk of insolvency is. Financial leverage is a measure of risk. SUMMARY OF FINANCIAL MIX RATIOS RATIOS FORMULAS COMMENTS PROFITABILITY RATIOS – measures earnings in relation to some base, such as assets, sales or capital COST MANAGEMENT RATIOS – measures how well a firm controls its costs Return on Sales Net income / Net sales ✓ Also called as net profit rate; net profit margin; measures profit percentage per peso sales Gross profit rate Gross profit / Net sales ✓ Measures gross profit percentage on sales to recover operating expenses ✓ Measures overall asset profitability; indicates how well assets have been employed by management Net income Average stockholders’ equity ✓ Measures percentage of income derived for every peso of owners’ equity. Net income Average common stockholders’ equity ✓ Earnings available to common stockholders’ equals net income less preferred dividends; this ratio measures percentage of profit derived for every peso of common equity money used; when compared to the return on total assets; it measures the percentage of profit derived for every peso of common equity money used; when compared to the return on total assets, it measures the extent to which financial leverage is working for or against common stockholders. Contribution margin Earnings before interest and taxes (Operating income) ✓ Measures the number of times profit will increase or decrease in relation to change in net sales. Net income Preferred dividend requirements ✓ Measures the adequacy of current earnings to meet preferred dividend payments. Net income + Interest expense (net of tax) Average total assets Return on total assets Net Income Average total assets Earnings Before Interest and Taxes Average total assets Return equity Return on common stockholders’ equity Operating leverage Times preferred dividend earned on stockholders’ LIQUIDITY RATIOS – provides information about the firm’s ability to pay its current obligations and continue operations ASSET MANAGEMENT RATIOS – measure how the firm uses its assets to generate revenue and income Operating turnover Collection period + Inventory days ✓ Measures the speed of the business cycle; the number of days cash was invested in the normal business operations until it was recovered back Inventory turnover Cost of goods sold Average Inventory ✓ Indicates the number of times inventories were acquired and sold during the period Inventory days number of days in a year inventory turnover ✓ Indicates the length of time spent before the average inventory is sold to customers. (note: know what will be the number of days to be considered) ✓ Receivable turnover Net CREDIT sales Average trade receivables ✓ Indicates the efficiency in credit and collection policies; trade receivables include open account and on notes Collection period Number of days in a year Receivable turnover ✓ Measures quickness in collecting trade receivables Payable turnover Net credit purchases Average trade payables ✓ Measures effectiveness in using trade credit facility from suppliers Payable days Number of days in a year Payable turnover ✓ Indicates the number of days spent before paying liabilities to merchandise suppliers Materials turnover Materials USED Average materials inventory ✓ Indicates the number of times materials were used on the average during the period Work-in-process inventory turnover Cost of goods MANUFACTURED Average work-in-process inventory ✓ Indicates the number of times average work-inprocess inventories is converted to finished goods Finished goods inventory turnover Cost of goods SOLD Average finished goods inventory ✓ Indicates the number of times average finished goods is sold during the period Cash turnover Cash operating expenses Average cash balance ✓ Measures the ability of the business to meet operating expenses payments given a particular cash balance 2 Days to expenses pay operating Number of days in a year Cash turnover ✓ Indicates the number of days spent before meeting operating expense payments Working capital turnover Net sales Average working capital ✓ Measures the adequacy and effective use of working capital; indicates reasonableness of the amount of current assets Asset turnover Net sales Average total assets ✓ Measures effectiveness of assets utilization Current assets turnover Net sales (excluding depreciation and amortization) Average current assets ✓ Indicates the reasonableness of the amount of current assets Net working capital Current assets – Current liabilities ✓ Indicates the amount invested by the business to operate its normal business activities Current ratio Current assets Current liabilities ✓ Rough estimate on the ability of the business to meet its currently maturing obligations; this ratio varies in great disparity from one industry to another Quick assets ratio (acid test ratio) Quick assets Current liabilities ✓ A more severe test of immediate liquidity to meet currently maturing obligations Quick assets include: cash, marketable securities and receivables Defensive interval ratio Defensive assets Average daily expenditures ✓ Measures the number of days defensive assets are available to meet daily cash expenses Defensive assets include: cash, marketable securities and trade receivable GROWTH RATIOS – measure the changes in the economic status of a firm over a period of time VALUATION RATIOS – measure the shareholder value as reflected in the price of the firm’s stock Earnings per share (Net income – Preferred dividends) Average common shares outstanding ✓ Perhaps the most frequently quoted ratio of earnings and growth performance; measures the value of common stock by attributing to it a portion of the company’s earnings Price-earnings ratio Market price per share Earnings per share ✓ Measures the number of period investment in stock will be recovered; measures the profitability of the firm in relation to the market value of the stock; measures investors’ beliefs on the growth potential of the stock Dividend yield ratio Dividend per share Market price per share ✓ Measures rate of cash return to investment in stock Dividend payout ratio Dividend per share Earnings per share ✓ Represents the percentage of net income distributed as dividends; a low ratio may indicate the reinvestment of profits by a growth-oriented firm Book value per share Stockholders’ equity Average shares outstanding ✓ Indicates the value of the stock on cost perspective; the relevance of this ratio diminishes when the balance sheet valuation does not approach fair market values; may be computed for both common and preferred stocks LEVERAGE RATIOS (Solvency ratios or Stability ratios) – B measures the company’s use of debt to finance assets and operations. Financial leverage – the use of debt to finance assets and operations; it is advisable to trade on equity when earnings from borrowed funds exceed the cost of borrowing. (1)As leverage increases, the risk borne by creditors as well as the risk that the firm may not be able to meet its maturing obligation increases. (2) Since interest expense is tax deductible, leverage increases the company’s return when it is profitable Debt-to-equity ratio Debt-to-assets ratio (debt ratio) Equity-to-assets (equity ratio) Equity multiplier Times interest earned Financial leverage ratio Total debt Net stockholders’ equity ✓ Measures the use of debt to finance operations; provides a measure of the relative amount of resources contributed by the creditors and owners Total debt Total assets ✓ Measures the relative shares of creditors over the total resources of the firm Net stockholders’ equity Total assets ✓ Measures the amount of resources provided by the owners in the firm Total assets (equity) Net stockholders’ equity Or 1/ equity ratio ✓ Indicates the number of times owners’ equity is multiplied Earnings before Interest and Taxes (EBIT) Interest expense ✓ Measures the long-term debt paying ability of the firm; a high number of times interest is earned ratio indicates that the business is under-leveraged and its return on common equity could still be improved. Earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) (EBIT – Interest expense – Preferred dividends before tax ✓ Measures the risk associated in using debt to finance investments 3 Total (combined) leverage Degree of operating leverage x Degree of financial leverage ✓ Measures the overall leverage of the business; it indicates the variability of the stockholders’ equity with respect to changes in contribution margin, earnings before interest and taxes, interest expense and preferred dividends before tax Fixed charges rate Cash flows before fixed charges Total fixed charges ✓ Measures the ability to meet fixed charges by cash Examples of fixed charges: rent, insurance, taxes and depreciation Total assets-to-total liabilities ratio Total assets Total liabilities ✓ Rough estimate of the firm’s ability to meet interest payments to creditors Non-current assets-tolong-term liabilities ratio Non-current assets Long-term liabilities ✓ Shows the capability to meet non-current liabilities using non-current resources CASH FLOW RATIOS Earning power – The capacity of the firm’s operations to produce cash inflows RATIOS FORMULAS Cash flow adequacy Cash from operations + Long-term debt paid + Purchases of assets Long-term debt payment Dividend payout on cash from operations Dividends Cash from operations Reinvestment Purchase of assets Cash from operations Total debt coverage Total liabilities Cash from operations Depreciation-amortization impact Cash flow to sales Cash flow to net income Cash flow return on sales Cash flow liquidity ratio Long-term debt payments Cash from operations Depreciation + Amortization Cash from operations Cash from operations Sales Cash from operations Income from ordinary operations Cash from operations Total assets Cash + Marketable securities + Cash flow from operating Activities Current liabilities OTHER RATIOS OPERATING CYCLE (liquidity & management efficiency) Average collection period of receivable + Average conversion period of Inventories + Days Cash CAPITAL INTENSITY RATIO (liquidity & management efficiency) Total Assets Net sales SALES TO FIXED ASSETS (PLANT ASSET TURNOVER) (liquidity & management efficiency) RATE OF RETURN ON OWNERS’ EQUITY (solvency) DIVIDENDS PER SHARE (stability) RATE OF RETURN ON AVERAGE CURRENT ASSETS (stability) DAYS CASH (liquidity and management efficiency) PERCENT OF EACH CURRENT ASSETS TO TOTAL CURRENT ASSETS Net sales Average Fixed Assets (net) Net income Average Owners’ equity Or Return on Assets x Equity multiplier Dividends paid/declared Common shares outstanding Net Income Average Current Assets Average cash balance Cash operating costs Number of days in a year Amount of each current assets Total current assets One of the most popular representation of cash from operations is the EBITDA or EARNINGS BEFORE INTEREST, TAX, DEPRECIATION AND AMORTIZATION. FINANCIAL GEARING RATIOS – measure the financial risk of a company’s financial structure. Business risk can be calculated by calculating a company’s operational gearing. TWO GEARING RATIOS: Financial gearing ratio 4 Ways to compute financial gearing ratio: 1) FGR = Prior Capital Charged / Equity Capital 2) FGR = Prior Capital Charged / Total capital employed *Prior capital charged – capital employed in the business which has the right to receive interest and preference dividends before any distribution is made to ordinary (common) shareholders (e.g. preference shares, interest-bearing long-term capital, and interestbearing short-term debt capital). In an alternative calculation of prior capital charged, the interest-bearing short-term debt capital may be excluded. *Equity capital – refers to the interest of the ordinary shareholders include that of the share capital, share premium and retained earnings *Total capital employed – sum of the non-current assets and net working capital. Operating gearing ratio – same as operating leverage (Contribution Margin / Operating Income or EBIT) EXERCISES 1. Which of the following is not a limitation of financial statement analysis? a. Cost basis c. Diversification of firms b. Use of estimates d. Availability of information 2. Horizontal analysis is also known as a. Linear analysis b. Vertical analysis c. d. Trend analysis Common size analysis 3. Ratios are used as tools in financial analysis a. Instead of horizontal and vertical analysis b. Because they can provide information that may not be apparent from inspection of the individual components of a particular ratio c. Because even single ratios by themselves are quite meaningful d. Because they are prescribed by GAAP 4. A drop in the market price of a firm’s common stock will immediately affect its: a. return o common stockholders’ equity c. dividend payout ratio b. current ratio d. dividend yield ratio 5. Issuing new shares of stock in a five-for-one split of common stock would a. decrease the book value per share of common c. increase total stockholders’ equity stock d. decrease total stockholders’ equity b. increase the book value per share of common stock 6. If current assets exceed current liabilities, prepaying an expense on the last day of the year will a. decrease the current ratio c. decrease the acid test ratio b. increase acid test ratio d. increase the current ratio 7. A company’s current ratio and acid test ratios are both greater than 1. issuing bonds to finance purchase of an office with the first instalment of the bonds due in the current year would a. decrease net working capital c. decrease the acid test ratio b. decrease the current ratio d. affect all of the above as indicated 8. Assume the current ratio is greater than 1. What is the effect of the collection of accounts receivable on the current ratio and net working capital, respectively? a. b. c. d. Current ratio No effect Increase Increase No effect Net working capital No effect Increase No effect Increase 9. What is the effect of a purchase of inventory on account on the current ratio and on working capital, respectively? (assume a current ratio greater than one prior to this transaction) a. b. c. d. Current ratio Decrease No effect Decrease No effect Working capital No effect Decrease Decrease No effect 10. At the beginning of the year, a company’s current ratio is 2.2 to 1 and its acid test ratio is 1.0 to 1. At the end of the year, the company has a current ratio of 2.5 to 1 and an acid test ratio of 0.8 to 1. Which of the following could help explain the divergence in the ratios from the beginning to the end of the year? a. an increase in credit sales in relationship to c. an increase in the collection rate of accounts cash sales receivable b. an increase in inventory levels during the d. selling marketable securities at a price below current year cost 11. A company’s current ratio and acid test ratio are both greater than 1. The collection of a current accounts receivable of P29,000 would a. increase the current ratio c. not affect the current ratio or the acid test b. decrease the current ratio ratio d. decrease the acid test ratio 5 12. Angel Corporation has a current ratio of 2 to 1 and an acid test ratio of 1 to 1. A transaction that would change Angel’s acid test ratio but not its current ratio is a. sale of short term marketable securities for c. collection of accounts receivable cash that results in a profit d. payment of accounts payable b. sale of inventory on account at cost 13. Assuming stable business condition, an increase in the accounts receivable turnover ratio would be explained by a. stricter policies with respect to the granting of c. slowdown in the collecting accounts receivables credit to customers from customers b. easing of policies with respect to the granting d. none of these of credit to customers 14. KC had net income of P 2million in 2006. using the 2006 financial elements as the base data, net income decreased by 70 percent in 2007 and increased by 175 percent in 2008. the respective net income reported by KC for 2007 and 2008 are: a. P600,000 and P5,500,000 c. P1,400,000 and P3,500,000 b. P5,500,000 and P600,000 d. P1,400,000 and P5,500,000 15. Assume that Princess reported a net loss of P50,000 in 2006 and net income of P250,000 in 2007. the increase in income of P300,000 a. can be stated as 0% c. cannot be stated as a percentage b. can be stated as 100% increase d. can be stated as 200% increase 16. Bea Company is preparing common-size financial statements. Bea has provided the following information: Accounts receivable Inventory Total current assets Total assets Bonds payable P10,000 20,000 35,000 84,000 21,000 Retained earnings Sales revenue Cost of goods sold Income taxes expense P7,000 75,000 62,000 22,000 1) How would Bea’s inventory appear on a common size balance sheet? a. 11.9% b. 23.8% c. 57.15% d. 65.3% 2) How would Bea’s retained earnings appear on a common size balance sheet? a. 8.3% b. 9.4% c. 20.0% d. 33.3% 17. Financial statements for Maja Company for the most recent year appear below: Cash Accounts receivable Inventories Prepaid expenses Plant and equipment Accumulated depreciation Patents Total assets Sales Cost of goods sold Gross profit Operating expenses Net operating income Interest expense Net income before income tax Income tax Net income Maja Company Balance sheet December 31 (in thousands) P90 Accounts payable 150 Accrued expense payable 150 Income tax payable 10 Interest payable 300 Long-term bonds payable (110) Common stock (P1 par) 10 Additional paid in capital Retained earnings P600 Total liabilities and equity Maja Company Income statement For the year ended December 31 (in thousands) P150 25 20 5 100 20 120 160 P 600 P1,200 750 P450 340 P110 10 P100 40 P60 The balances in the cash, accounts receivable, inventory, bonds payable, common stock, and additional paid in capital accounts are unchanged from the beginning of the year. A P0.75 per share dividend was declared and paid during the year. On December 31, Maja Company’s common stock was trading at P24 per share. 3) Maja Company’s current ratio at December 31 was closest to a. 1.95 to 1 b. 2.67 to 1 c. 1.33 to 1 d. 2.00 to 1 4) Maja Company’s times interest earned ratio for the year was closest to a. 11.0 to 1 b. 10.5 to 1 c. 12.0 to 1 d. 22.0 to 1 5) Maja Company’s quick ratio at December 31 was closest to a. 0.45 to 1 b. 0.83 to 1 c. 2.00 to 1 d. 1.20 to 1 6) Maja Company’s inventory turnover ratio for the year was closest to a. 8x b. 3x c. 5x d. 7.5x 7) Maja Company’s average collection period (age of receivables) for the year was closest to (use 365 days) a. 72 days b. 8 days c. 120 days d. 46 days 8) Maja’s price earnings ratio at December 31 was closest to a. 3 b. 8.25 c. 8 d. 7.25 9) Maja Company’s book value per share at December 31 was closest to 6 a. P7 b. P15 c. P24 10) Maja Company’s dividend payout ratio for the year was closest to a. 75% b. 25% c. 5% 11) Maja Company’s debt to equity ratio at December 31 was closest to a. 0.33 to 1 b. 0.50 to 1 c. 0.67 to 1 12) Maja Company’s dividend yield ratio for the year was closest to a. 3.125% b. 12.500% c. 9.125% d. P30 d. 3.125% d. 1.00 to 1 d. 25.000% 18. Selected financial data from Iza Company for the most recent year appear below: Sales Cost of goods sold Dividends declared and paid P100,000 60,000 5,000 Interest expense Operating expenses The income tax rate is 30 percent. 1) Net operating income as a percentage of sales was closest to: 2) Net income as percentage of sales was closest to 3) Gross margin as a percentage of sales was closest to P8,000 18,000 a. 0.14 a. 0.22 a. 0.40 b. 0.17 b. 0.14 b. 0.45 c. 0.22 c. 0.40 c. 0.35 d. 0.09 d. 0.10 d. 0.22 19. Financial statements for Karylle Company appear below: Current assets: Cash & marketable securities Accounts receivable (net) Inventory Prepaid expenses Total current assets Non-current assets: Plant & equipment (net) Total assets Sales (all on account) Cost of goods sold Gross margin Operating expenses Net operating income Interest expense Net income before taxes Income tax (30%) Net income Karylle Company Statement of Financial Position December 31, 2002 and 2001 (in thousands) 2002 2001 Current liabilities: P160 P150 Accounts payable 200 190 Accrued liabilities 200 190 Notes payable (short-term) 40 40 Total current liabilities P600 570 Non-current liabilities: Bonds payable P1,360 P1,360 Total liabilities Shareholders’ equity: Preferred stock P5 par 15% Common stock P15 par Additional paid in capital-common stock Retained earnings Total stockholders’ equity P1,960 P1,930 Total liabilities and stockholders equity Karylle Company Income statement For the year ended December 31, 2002 (in thousands) 2002 2001 P100 80 110 P290 P130 80 130 P340 P450 P740 P500 P840 P100 180 180 760 P1,220 P1,960 P100 180 180 630 P1,090 P1,930 P2,780 1,940 840 330 P510 50 P460 138 P322 Dividends during 2002 totaled P192 thousand, of which P15 thousand were preferred dividends. The market price of a share of common stock on December 31, 2002 was P310. 1) Karylle’s earnings per share of common stock for 2002 was closest to a. P1.60 b. P25.58 c. P26.83 d. P38.33 2) Karylle’s dividend yield ratio on December 31, 2002 was closest to a. 0.3% b. 5.2% c. 4.8% d. 4.4% 3) Karylle’s return on total asset for 2002 was closest to a. 0.173 b. 0.166 c. 0.148 d. 0.184 4) Karylle’s current ratio at the end of 2002 was closest to a. 0.39 to 1 b. 0.49 to 1 c. 1.31 to 1 d. 2.07 to 1 5) Karylle’s accounts receivable turnover for 2002 was closest to a. 14.5x b. 14.3x c. 9.9x d. 9.6x 6) Karylle’s average sale period for 2002 was closest to (use 365 days) a. 25.6 days b. 36.7 days c. 25.6 days d. 36.9 days 7) Karylle’s times interest earned for 2002 was closest to a. 10.2x b. 16.8x c. 6.4x d. 9.2x 20. Kathryn Company is calculating its earning power ratios for the year ended December 31, 2013. here is the relevant information: Net income Tax rate Total dividends paid – preferred Market price – preferred share Total shares outstanding – preferred Ending total assets Ending stockholders’ equity P500,000 40 percent P42,500 110 85,000 shares P7 million P2.5 million Interest expense Total dividends paid – common Market price – common share Total shares outstanding – common Beginning total assets Beginning common stockholders’ equity P30,000 120,000 40 120,000 shares P6 million P2 million Kathryn’s preferred stock is convertible. Each share of preferred stock is convertible into two shares of common stock. Compute for the following: 7 1) Earnings per share? 2) Fully diluted earnings per share? 3) Dividend yield ratio? a. P2.44 a. P1.58 a. 0.9% b. P3.81 b. P1.72 b. 1.5% c. P4.17 c. P2.44 c. 2.5% d. P5.38 d. P2.94 d. 4.0% 21. Toni Company has an acid rest ratio of 2.5 to 1. it has current liabilities of P40,000 and non current assets of P70,000. If Toni’s current ratio is 3.1 to 1, its inventory and prepaid expenses must be a. P12,400 b. P24,000 c. P30,000 d. P40,000 22. Anne Company has an acid test ratio of 1.5 to 1 and a current ratio of 2.5 to 1. current assets equal P200,000 of which P10,000 is prepaid expenses. Anne’s inventory must be: a. P30,000 b. P110,000 c. P70,000 d. P80,000 23. Coleen Company has a current ratio of 3.2 to 1 and an acid test ratio of 2.4 to 1. there are no prepaid expenses and inventory equals P40,000. Coleen’s current liabilities must be a. P40,000 b. P120,000 c. P50,000 d. P32,000 24. Julia Corporation asked you to interpret the following ratios provided by its accountant: Acid test ratio Times interest earned Gross margin ratio 1.2 8 40% Inventory turnover Debt to equity ratio Ratio of operating expenses to sales 6 times 0.9:1 15% Total stockholders equity on December 31, 2013 was P900,000. Gross margin for 2012 amounted to P600,000. Beginning balance of merchandise inventory was P200,000. the company’s long-term liabilities consisted of bonds payable with interest at 15 percent. You decided to reconstruct the company’s financial statements based on the limited information given to serve as basis for further analysis. 1) Operating income was computed at: a. P525,000 b. P300,000 c. P375,000 d. none of these 2) Bonds payable totalled: a. P312,500 b. P350,000 c. P400,000 d. none of these 3) Total current liabilities would be: a. P462,500 b. P497,500 c. P504,500 d. none of these 4) The company’s total asset amounted to: a. P317,000 b. P597,000 c. P697,000 d. none of these LONG PROBLEMS WITH SOLUTIONS 1) (VERTICAL ANALYSIS) A comparative statement is given below for Jessy Company: Sales Cost of sales Gross margin Selling expenses Administrative expenses Total expenses Net operating income 2002 Amount Percentage P5,000,000 (3,160,000) P1,840,000 P900,000 680,000 P(1,580,000) P260,000 2001 Amount Percentage P4,000,000 (2,400,000) P1,600,000 P700,000 584,000 P(1,284,000) P316,000 The president is concerned that net income is down in 2002 even though sales have increased during the year. The president is also concerned that administrative expenses have increased since the company makes a concerned effort during 2002 to “fat” out the organization. Required: Express each year’s income statement in common-size percentages. Carry computations into one decimal place. Answer: 2002 Sales Cost of sales Gross margin Selling expenses Administrative expenses Total expenses Net operating income Amount P5,000,000 (3,160,000) P1,840,000 P900,000 680,000 P(1,580,000) P260,000 Percentage 100% 63.20% 36.8% 18.00% 13.6% 31.6% 5.2% 2001 Amount Percentage P4,000,000 100% (2,400,000) 60% P1,600,000 40% P700,000 17.5% 584,000 14.6% P(1,284,000) 32.1% P316,000 7.9% 2.4 million/ 4 million Income statement base amount under vertical analysis is the SALES or Net Sales 2) (HORIZONTAL ANALYSIS) Gretchen’s sales, current assets and current liabilities (all in thousands of pesos) have been reported as follows over the last four years (Year 4 is the most recent year): Sales Current assets Current liabilities Year 4 P5,400 1,448 318 Year 3 P4,950 1,332 324 Year 2 P4,725 1,368 330 Year 1 P4,500 1,280 300 Sales Current assets Current liabilities Year 4 120 113.1 106 Year 3 110 104.1 108 Year 2 105 106.9 110 Year 1 100 100 100 Express all of the assets, liabilities and sales data in trend percentages (show percentages in each item). Use year 1 as the base year and carry computations to one decimal place. Answer: (P4,725,000 / 4,500,000) * 100 3) (FINANCIAL RATIOS) You have just been hired as a loan officer at Cristine Security Bank. Your supervisor has given you a file containing a request from Jodi Company, a manufacturer of auto components, for a P1 million five-year loan. Financial statement data on the company for the last two years are given below: Assets Current assets Jodi Company Comparative balance sheet This year Last year 8 • Cash P320,000 • Marketable securities 0 • Accounts receivable (net) 900,000 • Inventory 1,300,000 • Prepaid expenses 80,000 Total current assets P5,700,000 Liabilities and stockholders’ equity Liabilities • Current liabilities P1,300,000 • Bonds payable, 10% 1,200,000 Total liabilities P2,500,000 Stockholders’ equity Preferred stock 8% P30 par value P600,000 Common stock P40 par value 2,000,000 Retained earnings 600,000 Total stockholders’ equity P3,200,000 Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity P5,700,000 Jodi Company Comparative income statement This year Sales (all on account) P5,250,000 Cost of goods sold (4,200,000) Gross margin P1,050,000 Operating expenses (530,000) Net operating income P520,000 Interest expense (120,000) Net income before tax P400,000 Income tax (30%) (120,000) Net income P280,000 Dividends paid: • Preferred stock P48,000 • Common stock 72,000 Total dividend paid P(120,000) Net income retained P160,000 Retained earnings – beginning of year P440,000 Retained earnings – end of the year 600,000 P420,000 100,000 600,000 800,000 60,000 P4,960,000 P920,000 1,000,000 P1,920,000 P600,000 2,000,000 440,000 P3,040,000 P4,960,000 Last year P4,160,000 (3,300,000) P860,000 (520,000) P340,000 (100,000) P240,000 (72,000) P168,000 P48,000 36,000 P(84,000) P84,000 P356,000 P440,000 Bea Rose Santiago, who just two years ago, was appointed president of Jodi Company, admits that the company has been “inconsistent” in its performance over the past several years. But Bea argues that the company has its costs under control, and is now experiencing strong sales growth as evidenced by the more than 25 percent increase in sales over the last year. Bea also argues that investors have recognized the improving situation at Jodi Company as shown by the jump in the price of its common stock from P20 per share last year to P36 per share this year. Bea believes that with strong leadership and modernized equipment that the P1 million loan will permit the company to buy, profits will be even stronger in the future. Anxious o impress your supervisor, you decide to generate all the information you can about the company. You determine that the following ratios are typical of companies in Jodi Company: Current ratio Average age of receivables Return on assets Times interest earned 2.3:1 31 days 9.5% 5.7 Determine the following ratios for this year: Acid test ratio Inventory turnover Debt to equity ratio Price-earnings ratio 1.2:1 60 days 0.65 to 1 10 a) Return on total assets j) Working capital b) Return on common equity k) Current ratio c) Is the company’s leverage positive or negative? l) Acid-test ratio d) Earnings per share m) Accounts receivable turnover e) Dividend yield ratio for common n) Average age of receivables (assume 365 days) f) Dividend payout ratio o) Inventory turnover g) Price earnings ratio p) Inventory conversion period (assume 365 days) h) Book value per share common q) Debt to equity ratio i) Gross margin percentage r) Number of times interest was earned Answer: a. Return on total assets: Answer • Net income + [Interest x (1-tax rate)] P280,000 + [(1,200,000 x 0.10) x (1-0.30)] 0.068 Average total assets [(5,700,000+4,960,000) / 2] • Net income / Average total assets P280,000 / [(5,700,000+4,960,000)/2] 0.0525 • Operating income / Average total assets P520,000 / [(5,700,000+4,960,000)/2] 0.0976 b. Return on common equity: • (Net income – Preferred dividends) [P280,000 – (P600,000 x 0.08)] Average Stockholders’ equity-common [(3,200,000+3,040,000)/2]-600,000 0.092 c. Leverage is positive for this year, since the return on common equity is greater than the return on total asset . d. Earnings per share: • (Net income – Preferred dividends) P232,000 / (P 2 million / P40 par value) P4.64 Average # of common shares outstanding e. Dividend yield ratio • Dividend per share / market price per (P72,000 / 50,000 shares) / P36 0.04 share f. Dividend payout ratio • Dividend per share / earnings per share (P72,000 / 50,000 shares) / P4.64 0.31 g. Price earnings ratio • Market price per share / Earnings per P36 / P4.64 7.8 share 9 h. Book value per share • Common stockholders’ equity Number of common shares outstanding i. Gross margin percentage • Gross margin / sales j. Net working capital • Current assets – Current liabilities k. Current ratio • Current assets / Current liabilities l. Acid-test ratio • Quick assets / Current liabilities m. Accounts receivable turnover • Net credit sales / Average receivable n. Average age of receivables: • Number of days in a year Accounts receivable turnover o. Inventory turnover • Cost of sales / Average Inventory p. Inventory conversion period • Number of days in a year Inventory turnover q. Debt to equity ratio • Total liabilities / Stockholders’ equity r. Times interest earned • Earnings before Interest and Taxes Interest expense (P3,200,000 – 600,000) / 50,000 shares P52 P1,050,000 / P5,250,000 0.20 P2,600,000 – P1,300,000 P1,300,000 P2,600,000 / P1,300,000 2:1 P1,220,000 / P1,300,000 0.94 to 1 P5,250,000 / [(900,000+600,000)/2] 7 times 365 days / 7 times 52 days P4,200,000 / [(1,300,000+800,000)/2] 4 times 365 days / 4 times 91 days P2,500,000 / 3,200,000 0.78:1 P520,000 / P120,000 4.3 times 4) (EFFECTS OF TRANSACTIONS ON VARIOUS FINANCIAL RATIOS) Selected amounts from Alex Company’s balance sheet from the beginning of the year follow: Cash Accounts receivable (net) Prepaid expenses Accounts payable Notes due within one year P70,000 350,000 8,000 200,000 100,000 Marketable securities Inventory Plant and equipment (net) Accrued liabilities Bonds payable in 5 years P12,000 460,000 950,000 60,000 140,000 During the year, the company completed the following transactions: a) b) c) d) e) f) g) Purchased inventory on account, P50,000 Declared cash dividends P30,000 Paid accounts payable P100,000 Collected cash on accounts receivable P80,000 Purchased equipment for cash P75,000 Paid a cash dividend previously declared P30,000 Borrowed cash on a short-term note with the bank P60,000 h) i) j) k) Sold inventory costing P70,000 for P100,000, on account Wrote off uncollectible accounts in the amount of P10,000. The company uses the allowance method of accounting for bad debts. Issued additional shares of capital stock for cash, P200,000 Paid off all short-term notes due P160,000 Required: 1. Compute the following ratios as of the beginning of the year: Working capital, Current ratio and Acid-test ratio Answer: • Working capital • Current ratio • Acid test ratio P900,000 – P360,000 900,000/ 360,000 432,000 / 360,000 P540,000 2.5 to 1 1.2 to 1 2. Indicate the effect of the transactions given above on working capital, current ratio and acid test ratio. Give the effect in terms of INCREASE, DECREASE or NONE. Answer: a) b) c) d) e) f) g) h) i) j) k) l) Entry Merchandise Inventory Accounts payable Retained earnings Dividends payable Accounts payable Cash Cash Accounts receivable Equipment Cash Dividends payable Cash Cash Notes payable due 1 year Accounts receivable Sales Cost of sales Merchandise inventory Allowance for bad debts Accounts receivable Cash Loss on sale of MS Marketable securities Cash Common stock Notes payable Cash Working capital None Effect on Current ratio Decrease None Increase Increase None None None None None None Decrease Decrease Decrease None Increase Increase None Decrease Decrease Increase Increase Increase None None None Decrease Decrease Decrease Increase Increase Increase None Increase Increase Acid test ratio Decrease The best way in answering the effects of every transaction on ratio is by making an entry 10 5) (CONSTRUCTION OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS USING RATIOS) Financial analysis may b used to test the fairness of the relationship among current financial data against those of prior financial information. Given established financial relationships and few key amounts, a CPA could also prepare projected financial statements. Jessy Corporation has in recent prior years maintained the following relationships among data on its financial statements: Net income rate on net sales Ratio of selling expenses to net sales Current ratio Inventory turnover Asset turnover Ratio of total assets to intangible assets Ratio of accounts receivable to accounts payable Ratio of working capital to stockholders’ equity Number of times interest earned 5 percent 15 percent 3:1 5 times 1 per year 20:1 1.5:1 1:1.6 Gross income rate on net sales Acid test ratio Accounts receivable turnover Composition of quick assets: Cash Marketable securities Accounts receivable Ratio of total liabilities to stockholders’ equity Ratio of accumulated depreciation to cost of fixed assets 35 percent 2:1 5 times 10 percent 30 percent 60 percent 1.4:1.6 1:3 2 For 2013, the company projects to have a net income of P150,000 which will result to P10 per share of common stock. Additional information includes the following: Common stock has a par value of P50 per share and was issued at 20% premium 8% preferred stock has a par value of P50 per share and was issued 10% premium Preferred dividends paid in 2012, P10,000 the same amount will be paid in 2013 The company’s purchases and sales are all “on account”. For projection purposes, it is assumed that the above relationships among the data on the financial statements of Jessy Corporation shall also hold true for 2013. Required: Prepare a projected balance sheet for the year 2013 and a projected income statement for the ended December 31, 2013. ignore income tax Answer: Net sales Cost of goods sold Gross margin Jessy Corporation Projected Income statement For the year ended December 31, 2013 0.05 = P150,000 / net sales Net sales = P150,000 / 0.05 ~ P3,000,000 P3,000,000 – P1,950,000 ~ P1,950,000 0.35 = Gross margin / P3,000,000 Gross profit: P3,000,000 x 0.35 ~ P1,050,000 Expenses: Selling expenses Administrative expenses Interest P3,000,000 x 0.15 P1,050,000 – (P150,000+450,000+150,000) 2 = (P150,000 + Interest) / Interest 2 Interest = P150,000 + interest Interest = P150,000 Total expenses Net income (GIVEN) P 3,000,000 (1,950,000) P1,050,000 P450,000 300,000 150,000 P(900,000) P150,000 Jessy Corporation Projected balance sheet As of December 31, 2013 ASSETS: Current assets: Cash Marketable securities Accounts receivable Inventory Prepaid expenses Total current assets Fixed assets Land, building and equipment Accumulated depreciation Land, building and equipment (net) Intangible assets Total assets Liabilities and Stockholders’ equity Liabilities Current liabilities: Accounts payable Miscellaneous payable Total current liabilities Bonds payable Total liabilities Stockholders’ equity 8% preferred stock A/R = 60% of quick assets Quick assets = P600,000 / 0.60 ~ P1,000,000 Cash = P1,000,000 x 0.10 ~ P100,000 P1,000,000 x 0.30 ~ P300,000 5 = P3 million / Accounts receivable Accounts receivable = P3,000,000 / 5 ~ P600,000 5 = P1,950,000 / Inventory Inventory = P1,950,000 / 5 ~ P390,000 P1,500,000 – (P1,000,000+390,000) 3 = Current assets / P500,000 Current assets = P500,000 x 3 ~ P1,500,000 1,350,000 / (1 – 1/3) ~ P2,025,000 P2,025,000 x 1/3 P3,000,000 – (1,500,000+150,000) ~ P1,350,000 20 = P3,000,000 / Intangible assets Intangible assets = P3,000,000/20 ~ P150,000 1= P3,000,000 / total assets Total assets = P3,000,000 x 1 ~ P3,000,000 600,000 / 1.5 ~ P400,000 500,000 – 400,000 + 100,000 2= P1,000,000 / Current liabilities Current liabilities = P1,000,000 / 2 ~ P500,00 P100,000 300,000 600,000 390,000 Since the problem does not state the beginning balance of AR, it is assume that the 600,000 is the ending balance of the accounts receivable. There is no need to multiply it by 2 since there is no data concerning the beginning balance of AR 110,000 P 1,500,000 P2,025,000 (675,000) P1,350,000 150,000 P3,000,000 P400,000 100,000 P500,000 P900,000 P1,400,000 P125,000 11 Common stock Premium on stock Retained earnings Total liabilities and SHEquity (140,000+125,000) 700,000 152,500 622,500 P3,000,000 12