2.2 AGGREGATE DEMAND AND AGGREGATE SUPPLY 2.3 MACROECONOMIC OBJECTIVES: PHILLIPS CURVE DIAGRAM ECONOMIC GROWTH 1. Distinguish between the microeconomic concept of demand for a product and the macroeconomic concept of aggregate demand. The microeconomic demand curve has the “price” of the one good on the y-axis, the macroeconomic aggregate demand curve has a measure of the average price level of all goods and services. Where the microeconomic demand curve has the “quantity” of the one good on the x-axis, the macroeconomic aggregate demand curve has The total quantity of all goods and services, which is national output. (Real GDP) 2. Construct an aggregate demand curve. AGGREGATE DEMAND: The total (or aggregate) real expenditures on final goods and services produced in the domestic economy that buyers would willing and able to make at different price levels, during a given time period (usually a year). Aggregate demand (AD) relates the economy's price level, measured by the GDP price deflator, and aggregate expenditures on domestic production, measured by real gross domestic product. The aggregate expenditures are consumption, investment, government purchases, and net exports made by the four macroeconomic sectors (household, business, government, and foreign). 2. Construct an aggregate demand curve. The aggregate demand curve: The AD curve shows the relationship between AD and the price level. It is assumed that the AD curve will slope down from left to right. This is because all the components of AD, except imports, are inversely related to the price level. The horizontal axis measures aggregate output, or real GDP, and the vertical axis measures the general price level in the economy, which is an average over the prices of all goods and services. 3. Explain why the AD curve has a negative slope. Trade, liquidity and wealth effects: The AD curve slopes down because the components of AD are inversely related to the price level. There are three main effects to consider: 1. The price level and international trade – the ‘trade’ effect A rise in domestic prices makes exports less competitive and imports more competitive; hence exports (X) are likely to fall and imports (M) are likely to rise. Falling net exports represents a fall in quantity of output demanded or an upward movement along the AD curve. (and visa versa) Both of these reactions combine to create a trade effect, with lower aggregate demand at the higher price level. 3. Explain why the AD curve has a negative slope. 2. The price level and liquidity – the ‘liquidity/interest rate’ effect When the price level increases, households and firms need to spend more money to continue to consume the scarce resources they need. This makes them relatively ‘short of cash’ than they were at the lower price level. The liquidity of an asset refers to how easily it is converted to cash, with cash itself being ‘perfectly liquid’. The loss of liquidity associated with a rise in the price level forces some households and firms to borrow from banks, which reduces the liquidity of banks. In response, banks are likely to raise interest rates as compensation for this lost liquidity. The banks need to keep a certain amount of their reserves in a highly liquid form to meet any unexpected increase in demand for cash. As a result of the lost liquidity, interest rates are forced to rise, and both household and corporate spending may fall. Hence, aggregate demand is lower at the higher price level. 3. Explain why the AD curve has a negative slope. 3. The price level and the value of wealth – the ‘wealth’ effect Given that interest rates will rise as financial markets readjust to the higher price level, there are likely to be further ‘knock on’ effects on household (and corporate) wealth. (Wealth is not the same as income; wealth is the value of assets that people own, i.e. Houses, stocks, bonds, & etc.) Higher rates may lead to a fall in house prices, or at least slowdown house price inflation, and create a negative wealth effect. Rising interest rates tend to reduce corporate profits and reduce share values - again creating a negative wealth effect. A lower price level will, of course, have the reverse effect, that is to create a positive wealth effect on AD. The combined effect of these wealth effects is to alter consumer and corporate spending, and hence alter the level of AD. 4. Describe consumption, investment, government spending and net exports as the components of aggregate demand. Aggregate demand consists of the amount households plan to spend on goods & services, called consumption (C), plus planned spending on capital investment, (I) + government spending, (G) + exports (X) minus imports (M) from abroad. The standard equation is: AD = C + I + G + (X – M) Aggregate demand can be illustrated by reference to the circular flow of income: 5. Explain how the AD curve can be shifted by changes in consumption due to factors including changes in consumer confidence, interest rates, wealth, personal income taxes (and hence disposable income) and level of household indebtedness. Determinates of Household spending (Consumption) consumer confidence Consumer confidence is a measure of how optimistic consumers are about their future income and the future of the economy. Consumer Confidence Index - CCI interest rates (monetary policy) Some consumer spending is finance borrowing, and so is influenced by interest rate changes. Higher interest rates make borrowing more expensive, thus lower consumer spending. wealth An increase in consumer wealth makes people feel wealthier; therefore, they spend more. personal income taxes and hence disposable income (fiscal policy) Disposable income is the income left over after personal income taxes have been paid, thus a rise in taxes on households means less disposable income and so less spending. level of household indebtedness. Indebtedness refers to how much money people owe from taking out loans in the past. Thus more debt the household has the less is available for spending on new purchases. 6. Explain how the AD curve can be shifted by changes in investment due to factors including interest rates, business confidence, technology, business taxes and the level of corporate indebtedness. Determinates of Investment Spending (Business spending) business confidence Business confidence refers to how optimistic firms are about their future sales and economic activity. Business confidence index (BCI) interest rates (monetary policy), An increase in interest rates raises the cost of borrowing and forces businesses to reduce investment spending financed by borrowing. Technology Improvements in technology should increase productivity and thus lower the cost of operation for firms. business taxes (fiscal policy) If the government raise taxes on businesses they will have less profits after taxes and thus less spending for capital. the level of corporate indebtedness If businesses have high levels of debt then they will have less money available to spend. 7. Explain how the AD curve can be shifted by changes in government spending due to factors including political and economic priorities. Determinates of Government Spending Political priorities Governments have discretionary spending that can change over time when political priorities change. A more conservative government might want more spending on military and defense whereas a more liberal government may want more spending on social issues. Economic priorities (fiscal policy) The government can use its own spending as part of a deliberate attempt to influence aggregate demand through the use of its fiscal policy tools. 8. Explain how the AD curve can be shifted by changes in net exports due to factors including the income of trading partners, exchange rates and changes in the level of protectionism. Determinates of Net Exports Spending National income of trading partners If a nations trading partners national income increases, then it is more likely going to also demand more goods and services from its trading partners. Thus, exports should increase to the countries with the increase national income. Exchange rates If a countries currency was to rise in value to another currency that they trade with, (appreciation) then that country will see its export volume decrease as the exports prices become uncompetitive and likewise the volume of imports should increase as the price of imports become more attractive to that country. The net effect is a fall in net exports. Changes in the level of trade protectionism For a country that places or increase the level of trade protectionism, their level of imports will fall, if exports are unaffected by this, then net exports will improve. For the country who exports and now has high trade barriers to deal with, their export volume will fall and thus net exports will fall. Illustrate aggregate demand and shifts in aggregate demand Shifts in AD: A change in any of the components of aggregate demand will cause a shift in the aggregate demand curve. An increase in AD, such as that caused by an increase in household spending, is shown by a rightward shift in the whole AD curve. The shift in demand will have an effect on the price level and national output, but the effects may not be uniform because aggregate supply (AS) may not be linear. 9. Define the term aggregate supply. The short-run in macroeconomics is the period of time when prices of resources are roughly constant or inflexible. (especially wages) The long-run in macroeconomics is the period of time when the prices of all resources, including the price of labor are flexible and change along with changes in price levels. The distinction between the short-run and the long-run in macroeconomics dose not affect aggregate demand, but is very important for aggregate supply. 9. Define the term aggregate supply. Aggregate supply (AS) is defined as the total amount of goods and services (real GDP) produced and supplied by an economy’s firms over a period of time at different price levels. It includes the supply of a number of types of goods and services including private consumer goods, capital goods, public and merit goods and goods for overseas markets. At higher price levels across the economy firms expect that they can sell their final products at higher prices, and there will be a positive relationship between the price level and aggregate supply. 10. Explain, using a diagram, why the short-run aggregate supply curves (SRAS Curve) is upward sloping Short run aggregate supply (SRAS) shows the relationship between the price level and the quantity of real output (real GDP) produced by firms when resources prices (especially wages) do not change. In the short run, the SRAS curve is assumed to be upward sloping (i.e. it is responsive to a change in aggregate demand reflected in a change in the general price level) because producers respond positivity to higher output prices and since resource price (inputs prices) are unchanged, profitability goes up. (and visa versa) The up sloping SRAS curve indicates a direct relationship between the price level and the amount of real GDP that firms will offer for sale. 10.Explain, using a diagram, why the short-run aggregate supply curves (SRAS Curve) is upward sloping 11. Explain, using a diagram, how the AS curve in the short run (SRAS) can shift due to factors including changes in resource prices, changes in business taxes and subsidies and supply shocks. Changes in resource prices (Input Prices): Any change in the price of the factors of production (resources/inputs) will cause the cost of production to or either rise or fall. This in turn will effect the profitability of the firms. Generally a fall in resource prices will lead to more profits and thus a shift of SRAS to the right. A rise in resource prices will most likely lead to less profits and thus a shift of the SRAS o the left. Any change in the price of imported resources will have the same effect as stated above. 11. Explain, using a diagram, how the AS curve in the short run (SRAS) can shift due to factors including changes in resource prices, changes in business taxes and subsidies and supply shocks. Changes in Government intervention like (business taxes and subsidies): Government intervention with the production of goods and services can effect the cost of production of the firm. Business taxes (corporate tax rates) are an additional cost of firms which can raise or lower their profitability. In general, a rise in business taxes would raise cost and lower profits and thus the SRAS would shift left. (and visa versa) Government subsidies to producers would have the opposite effect as business taxes. Government subsidies would lower the coat of production and thus potentially raise the profits of the firm and thus the SRAS would shift right. Government regulations toward businesses also act as an additional cost to firms. In general, the more government regulations placed on businesses the higher the cost of compiling to these regulations. Thus, the cost of production is increased and the profitability is lowered and this results in a leftward shift of the SRAS. 11. Explain, using a diagram, how the AS curve in the short run (SRAS) can shift due to factors including changes in resource prices, changes in business taxes and subsidies and supply shocks. Supply Shocks: Supply shocks are events that have a sudden and strong impact on the SRAS. Some supply shocks directly affect aggregate supply. Negative supply side, like a war or violent conflict can result in destruction of physical capital and destruction of the economy. Leading to lower output produced and a leftward shift of the SRAS curve. Unfavorable weather conditions can cause a fall in agricultural output, also shifting SRAS curve to the left. Supply shocks sometimes work by producing sudden changes in a firms cost of production. For example, a sudden increase in the price of a major input (such as oil) increases a firms cost. Other examples, include natural disasters, internal & external conflicts, sudden stoppage of trade flows. Positive supply shocks such as unusually good weather conditions would lead to a rightward shift. Productivity increases due to favorable condition like better use of resources or better technology can also lead to a rightward shift of the SRAS curve. 11. Explain, using a diagram, how the AS curve in the short run (SRAS) can shift due to factors including changes in resource prices, changes in business taxes and subsidies and supply shocks. A change in aggregate supply is caused by any factor affecting supply EXCEPT the price level. 12. Explain, using a diagram, that the monetarist/new classical model of the long-run aggregate supply curve (LRAS) is vertical at the level of potential output (full employment output) because aggregate supply in the long run is independent of the price level. Monetarist/new classical economists builds on the work of the classical economists of the 19th century. Both schools of thought are built on the following principles: The importance of the price mechanism in coordinating economic activities; the concept of competitive market equilibrium; and thinking about the economy as a harmonious system that automatically tends towards full employment. The Monetarist/new classical approach to aggregate supply rest crucially on the distinction between the macroeconomic short-run and long-run. It examines what happens to aggregate supply when the economy moves into the long-run, when all resources prices including wages change to match changes in the price level. 12. Explain, using a diagram, that the monetarist/new classical model of the long-run aggregate supply curve (LRAS) is vertical at the level of potential output (full employment output) because aggregate supply in the long run is independent of the price level. According to the monetarist/new-classical perspective, the long-run aggregate supply (LRAS) curve is vertical at the full employment level of output, or potential GDP, indicating that in the long run the economy produces potential GDP, which is independent of the price level. A vertical LRAS curve means that in the long run a change in the price level does not result in any change in the quantity of real GDP produced. In the long-run, since wages and other resource prices are now changing to match output prices change, firm’s cost of production remains constant even as the price level changes. Therefore, as the price level increases or decreases, with constant real costs, firms’ profits are also constant, and firms no longer have any incentive to increase or decrease their output levels. 12. Explain, using a diagram, that the monetarist/new classical model of the long-run aggregate supply curve (LRAS) is vertical at the level of potential output (full employment output) because aggregate supply in the long run is independent of the price level. A monetarist/new classical long run aggregate supply (LRAS) is perfectly inelastic at the level of potential output (full employment level of output). They believe that the potential output of the economy is dependent on the quantity and quality (productivity) of the factors of production, not on the price level. Thus the LRAS curve is independent of the price level. 13. Explain, using a diagram, that the Keynesian model of the aggregate supply curve has three sections because of “wage/price” downward inflexibility and different levels of spare capacity in the economy. Keynesian economists base their ideas on the work of John Maynard Keynes. Keynes questioned the monetarist/new classical economists’ view of the economic system as a harmonious system that automatically tends towards full employment, and showed that it is possible for economies to remain in a position of short-run equilibrium for long periods of time. In the Keynesian model, inflexible wages and prices mean hat the economy cannot move into the long-run. Inflexible wages are mainly due to labor contracts, minimum wage legislation, workers and union resistance to wage cuts. Keynes main reason for the stickiness or rigidly of resources is due to the following: The Sticky-Wage Theory: An unexpectedly low price level raises the real wage, which causes firms to hire fewer workers and producer a smaller quantity of goods and services. The Sticky-Price Theory: An unexpectedly low price level leaves some firms with higher-than-desired prices, which depresses their sales and leads them to cut back production. The Misperceptions Theory: An unexpectedly low price level leads some suppliers to think their relative prices have fallen, which induces a fall in production. 13. Explain, using a diagram, that the Keynesian model of the aggregate supply curve has three sections because of “wage/price” downward inflexibility and different levels of spare capacity in the economy. Keynesian AS: shows three possible phases: In the horizontal range (section I) there is low levels of economic activity. There is excess capacity so very little price pressure and high unemployment. Firms can easily increase their output by employing the unemployed capital and other unemployed resources, without having to bid up wages and other resource prices. The horizontal part of the curve is based on the Keynesian idea that wages and prices do not move downward. 13. Explain, using a diagram, that the Keynesian model of the aggregate supply curve has three sections because of “wage/price” downward inflexibility and different levels of spare capacity in the economy. Keynesian AS: shows three possible phases: In the upper sloping range (section II), the economy is approaching full employment so there is price pressure and increase in real GDP so lower unemployment. The reason is that as output increases, so does employment of resources, and eventually bottlenecks in resource supplies begin to appear as there is no longer excess capacity in the economy. Wages and other resource prices begin to rise, which means that costs of production increases. The only way that firms will be induced to increase their output is if they can sell it at higher prices. Full employment level of real GDP (Yf), which is when potential output levels are equal to the economies natural rate of unemployment, should be reached in section II of the Keynesian model. 13. Explain, using a diagram, that the Keynesian model of the aggregate supply curve has three sections because of “wage/price” downward inflexibility and different levels of spare capacity in the economy. In the vertical range (section III), the economy is at full employment and it’s impossible to increase output. There is only price pressure. Real GDP has reached a level beyond which it cannot increase anymore; at this point, the price level rises very rapidly. Real GDP can no longer increase because firms are using the maximum amount of labor and all other resources in the economy. 13. Explain, using a diagram, that the Keynesian model of the aggregate supply curve has three sections because of “wage/price” downward inflexibility and different levels of spare capacity in the economy. Keynes argued that relying on markets to get to full employment was not a good idea. He believed that the economy could settle at any equilibrium and that there would not be automatic changes in markets to correct this situation. Thus the need for government intervention to correct the market outcome. 13. Explain, using a diagram, that the Keynesian model of the aggregate supply curve has three sections because of “wage/price” downward inflexibility and different levels of spare capacity in the economy. A “Keynesian” long run aggregate supply 14. Compare and contrast, using the two models above, the way that factors leading to changes in the quantity and/or quality of factors of production (including improvements in efficiency, new technology, reductions in unemployment, and institutional changes) can shift the aggregate supply curve over the long term. Shifts in long-run aggregate supply curve are usually gradual and anticipated, unlike shifts in the SRAS which can be dramatic and unanticipated. LRAS and the Keynesian AS curve can shift for many of the same reasons, including: Increases in quantities of the factors of production. Examples can include, an increase in the quantity of physical capital, or quantity of land (like a discovery of new oil reserves) means that the economy is capable of producing more real GDP. Improvements in the quality of factors of production (resources) Greater levels of education, skills or health lead to improvement in the quality of labor resources. More highly skilled and educated workers or healthier workers can produce more output than the same number of unskilled or less healthy workers. Improvements in technology An improved technology of production means that the factors of production using this technology can produce more output in the same amount of time. 14. Compare and contrast, using the two models above, the way that factors leading to changes in the quantity and/or quality of factors of production (including improvements in efficiency, new technology, reductions in unemployment, and institutional changes) can shift the aggregate supply curve over the long term. Increases in efficiency When there is an increase in efficiency in production, it makes better use of its scarce resources, and can as a result, the economy can produce a greater quantity of output. Institutional changes For example, the degree of private ownership as opposed to public ownership of resources, the degree of competition in the economy, the degree and quality of government regulation of private sector activities, and the amount of bureaucracy can each affect the quantity of output produced. Reductions in the natural rate of unemployment The natural rate of unemployment is the unemployment that is ‘normal’ or ‘natural’ for an economy when it is producing its ‘full employment’ level of output. The natural rate can differ from country to country and can change over time. If it decreases, the economy is making better use of its resources, and can therefore produce a larger quantity of output. 14. Compare and contrast, using the two models above, the way that factors leading to changes in the quantity and/or quality of factors of production (including improvements in efficiency, new technology, reductions in unemployment, and institutional changes) can shift the aggregate supply curve over the long term. long-run aggregate supply curve 15. Explain, using a diagram, the determination of short-run equilibrium, using the SRAS curve. In the AD-AS model, the equilibrium level of output (or real GDP) occurs where aggregate demand (AD) interests aggregate supply (AS). In the short run, equilibrium is given by the point of intersection of the AD and the SRAS curves, and determines the price level, the level of real GDP and the level of employment. The short-run equilibrium can be at three general outcomes: Recessionary (deflationary) gap A Recessionary (deflationary) gap occurs when equilibrium real GDP lies to the left of potential GDP (LRAS), and unemployment is greater than the natural rate of unemployment. The recessionary gap has been created because at the current price level, the amount of real GDP that aggregate demand wants to buy is less than the economies potential GDP. There is not enough total demand in the economy to produce at potential GDP (LRAS). On the business cycle, actual GDP is below its long run potential GDP. 15. Explain, using a diagram, the determination of short-run equilibrium, using the SRAS curve. Inflationary gap An inflationary gap is when the equilibrium real GDP lies to the right of potential GDP (LRAS). When real GDP is larger than potential GDP, unemployment will be less than the natural rate of unemployment. An inflationary gap arise because aggregate demand that wants to buy real GDP output at the current price level is greater than the economies potential output. On the business cycle, the actual GDP is above its long run potential GDP. Full employment equilibrium The full employment equilibrium level is when real GDP is equal to potential GDP. At this point, unemployment is equal to the natural rate of unemployment and there are no recessionary or inflationary gaps. On the business cycle, actual GDP is equal to the long run potential GDP. 15. Explain, using a diagram, the determination of short-run equilibrium, using the SRAS curve. Recessionary Gap Inflationary Gap Full Employment Neo-classical models Keynesian models 16. Examine, using diagrams, the impacts of changes in short-run equilibrium. Short-run aggregate market equilibrium means the economy is at full-employment with no price level pressure and potential GDP is at actual GDP which is at the natural rate of unemployment. However, whenever there is a change in any of the determinates of either aggregate demand or short-run aggregate supply the short-run equilibrium will change as well. An increase in aggregate demand (shift right) could lead to higher price levels depending where they are on the Keynesian aggregate supply curve and higher levels of real GDP. A decrease in aggregate demand (shift left) could lead to lower price levels depending on where they are on the Keynesian aggregate supply curve and lower levels of real GDP. 16. Examine, using diagrams, the impacts of changes in short-run equilibrium. A increase in the short-run aggregate supply curve (shift right) could lead to lower price levels and higher levels of real GDP. A decrease in the shortrun aggregate supply curve (shift left) could lead to higher price levels and lower levels of real GDP. 17. Explain, using a diagram, the determination of long-run equilibrium, indicating that long-run equilibrium occurs at the full employment level of output. The long-run equilibrium occurs at the full employment level of output, when there is equilibrium in the labor market. In the monetarist/new classical approach, while there may be short-term fluctuations in output, the economy will always return to the full employment level of output in. As there is a long run equilibrium in this theory that AD shifts around, so too is the theory that business cycle fluctuations should not be inevitable and should be avoidable if the correct policies are followed. The theory is that the economy would grow at a constant rate along with the increase in the LRAS without inflation or recessions if the government didn’t intervene. This is logical as the macro-economy is basically stable. The long-run equilibrium will change as the LRAS shifts right with long run growth; increased capital or the technology of capital. 17. Explain, using a diagram, the determination of long-run equilibrium, indicating that long-run equilibrium occurs at the full employment level of output. In the Keynesian AD/AS diagram, that the economy may be in equilibrium at any level of real output where AD intersects AS. If the economy is in equilibrium at a level of real output below the full employment level of output (where the AS is vertical), then there is a deflationary (recessionary) gap. In contrast to the monetarist/new classical model, the economy can remain stuck in a deflationary (recessionary) gap in the Keynesian model. If AD increases in the vertical section of the AS curve, then there is an inflationary gap. Keynesians said that it was the role of government, through their policy, to ensure that the economy reaches full employment. 18. Examine why, in the monetarist/new classical approach, while there may be short-term fluctuations in output, the economy will always return to the full employment level of output in the long run. The Classical economists assumed that if the economy was left to itself, then it would tend to full employment equilibrium. This would happen if the labor market worked properly. If there was any unemployment, then the following would happen: Unemployment labor Fall in wages Increase demand for equilibrium restored at full employment Classical economists had complete faith in markets. They believed that the economy would always settle - automatically - at the full employment equilibrium in the long-run. Due to flexible prices and wages. However, they did acknowledge that there might be a slightly different reaction in the short run as the economy adjusted to its new long-run equilibrium. 18. Examine why, in the monetarist/new classical approach, while there may be short-term fluctuations in output, the economy will always return to the full employment level of output in the long run. Eliminating a deflationary gap: A fall in AD from its original equilibrium (1), causes the economy to move in the short-run to a recessionary gap. Real GDP has fallen below the fullemployment level of output and price levels have most likely fallen. (2) The economy economy can’t remain there in the long run, because the fall in price levels is matched by a fall in wages and other resource prices. As a result, the SRAS curve shifts the right until the economy is back to the LRAS curve (Assuming wage and price flexibility). (3) In the end, the recessionary gap is eliminated, and the only thing that changes is the price level. 18. Examine why, in the monetarist/new classical approach, while there may be short-term fluctuations in output, the economy will always return to the full employment level of output in the long run. Eliminating an inflationary gap: An increase shift in AD from its original equilibrium (1), in the short-run causes the economy to move to an inflationary gap. Real GDP is beyond the full-employment level of output and price levels have most likely have risen. (2) Once again, the economy can’t stay there in the long-run, because wages and prices of other resources increase to match the increase in the price level. This causes the SRAS curve to shift the left until it is at the LRAS curve. (3) In the long-run the inflationary gap is eliminated and the only thing that changes is the price level. 19. Examine, using diagrams, the impacts of changes in the long-run equilibrium. With monetarist/new classical economists, changes in aggregate demand (AD) can have n influence on real GDP only in the short-run; in the long-run, they only result in changing the price level, having no impact on real GDP, as this remains constant at the level of potential GDP output and the LRAS curve. 20. Explain, using the Keynesian AD/AS diagram, that the economy may be in equilibrium at any level of real output where AD intersects AS. Keynes argued that relying on markets to get to full employment was not a good idea. He believed that the economy could settle at any equilibrium and that there would not be automatic changes in markets to correct this situation. He argued that wages would be 'sticky downwards'. In other words workers would not be happy about taking wage cuts and would resist this. This would mean that wages would not necessarily fall enough to clear the market and unemployment would linger. This unemployment he termed demand deficient unemployment. 20. Explain, using the Keynesian AD/AS diagram, that the economy may be in equilibrium at any level of real output where AD intersects AS. Keynes didn't distinguish between the short-run and the long-run as Classical economists tend to. He argued that the economy could settle at any equilibrium level of income at any time, and it was the government job to use appropriate policies to ensure that this equilibrium was a good one for the economy. Keynesian The Ratchet Effect The Ratchet Effect This effect states that prices are "sticky" or inflexible in a downward direction. Therefore, aggregate demand will not move downward very freely. Causes for the Ratchet Effect: Wage Contracts - contracts prevent firms from decreasing wages, which are a major cost for a firm. Morale and Productivity - employers are not willing to reduce wage rates because doing so reduces worker morale and labor productivity. Training Investments - firms put an investment in workers when they train them. If workers leave because of lower wages, firms do not get a return from that investment. Minimum Wage - firms cannot reduce wages below minimum wage. Monopoly Power - many firms have sufficient monopoly power to resist price cuts for a time when demand declines The Ratchet Effect 21. Explain, using a diagram, that if the economy is in equilibrium at a level of real output below the full employment level of output, then there is a deflationary (recessionary) gap. A deflationary gap exists when there is insufficient demand available in the economy to generate a fullemployment equilibrium. In other words there is not enough being bought to provide jobs for everyone who wants them. Deflationary or recessionary gap, where actual unemployment is greater than the natural rate of unemployment. Occurs where AD intersects the SRAS curve at a level of real GDP that is below LRAS. On the business cycle, the actual GDP is below potential GDP and actual GDP is usually falling. 22. Discuss why, in contrast to the monetarist/new classical model, the economy can remain stuck in a deflationary (recessionary) gap in the Keynesian model. Keynesian economists believe that free markets are volatile and not self correcting. Free market volatility: • The free-market system is naturally prone to periods of recession & depression • The volatility of aggregate demand (AD = C+I+G+X-M) can be explained by changes in consumer and business sentiment – also known as animal spirits. • In a world of stagnation or depression direct intervention in the economy may be essential Free markets are not always self-correcting: • When a recession or a depression occurs, the free market system is not necessarily self-correcting – indeed en-masse, individuals can become trapped in a deflationary depression which is in no one’s interest but which, left on our own, no one can counter-act. • Persistent deflation can be as costly as high inflation – it can be damaging especially in economies where there is a huge level of private & public sector debt • You cannot always rely on new inventions / innovations and other natural stabilizers to drag an economy out of a recession 22. Discuss why, in contrast to the monetarist/new classical model, the economy can remain stuck in a deflationary (recessionary) gap in the Keynesian model. According to Keynes, because of inflexible wage and other resource prices and insufficient aggregate demand, the economy can remain in a recessionary gap indefinitely. This means that the government must intervene in the economy with specific measure to help it come out of this gap. Keynesian analysis is therefore essentially a short-run analysis. They do not accept the idea that the economy can move into what monetarist/new classical economists define as the long-run (where there is full resource and product price flexibility). Therefore, in the Keynesian perspective the economy does not automatically tend toward full employment equilibrium. 23. Explain, using a diagram, that if AD increases in the vertical section of the AS curve, then there is an inflationary gap. Inflationary gap, is where there is strong aggregate demand, actual unemployment has fallen below its natural rate, and as the economy approaches its maximum capacity (full-employment output level), price level has increased. This occurs where AD intersects the SRAS curve at a level of real GDP that is above LRAS curve. With too much demand in the economy, this excess level of demand will tend to lead to demand-pull inflation. In the Keynesian model, once AD passes the full-employment level there is no more excess capacity and thus only price level pressure. Prices are the only changing variable. On the business cycle, actual GDP is above potential GDP and GDP is rising. 24. Discuss why, in contrast to the monetarist/new classical model, increases in aggregate demand in the Keynesian AD/AS model need not be inflationary, unless the economy is operating close to, or at, the level of full employment. In the Keynesian model when the economy is in the horizontal part of the AS curve, increases in aggregate demand lead to increases in real GDP without affecting the price level. This is because there is excess capacity and as AD increase there is no price pressure. Cost of production does not increase and firms are reluctant to raise prices with still low AD. It is only when the Keynesian AS curve begins to slope upward, when it is close to the full employment level of output, that further increases in aggregate demand begin to result in changes in the price level as well. Excess capacity is being reduced, cost of production starts to rise and thus firms must start to raise prices. Once AD surpasses the full-employment level of output, the economy is at its production capacity and the only way to allocate output is through price increases. 24. Discuss why, in contrast to the monetarist/new classical model, increases in aggregate demand in the Keynesian AD/AS model need not be inflationary, unless the economy is operating close to, or at, the level of full employment. Whereas, in the monetarist/new classical model, increases in aggregate demand always result in price level increases. In the short-run, as AD shifts to the right causing a movement along an upward-slopping SRAS curve, an increase in real GDP and an increase in the price level results. In the long run, increases in aggregate demand give rise only to increases in the price level, leaving real GDP unaffected. 24. Discuss why, in contrast to the monetarist/new classical model, increases in aggregate demand in the Keynesian AD/AS model need not be inflationary, unless the economy is operating close to, or at, the level of full employment. 25. Explain, with reference to the concepts of leakages (withdrawals) and injections, the nature and importance of the Keynesian multiplier. Multiplier: The multiplier is concerned with how national income changes as a result of a change in an injection, for example investment. The multiplier was a concept developed by Keynes that said that any increase in injections into the economy (investment, government expenditure or exports) would lead to a proportionally bigger increase in National Income. This is because the extra spending would have knock-on effects creating in turn even greater spending. The size of the multiplier would depend on the level of leakages. Multiplier effect The theory that a particular increase in private or government spending (C, I, G, or Xn) in an economy will lead to a larger overall increase in GDP than the initial change in spending, due to the fact that the increase in incomes that result will lead to further increases in private spending throughout the economy. The size of the multiplier effect depends on the spending multiplier. 25. Explain, with reference to the concepts of leakages (withdrawals) and injections, the nature and importance of the Keynesian multiplier. The Multiplier effect comes about because injections of new demand for goods and services into the circular flow of income stimulate further rounds of spending – in other words “one person’s spending is another’s income”. This can lead to a bigger eventual final effect on output and employment. What is a simple definition of the multiplier? It is the number of times a rise in national income exceeds the rise in injections of demand that caused it. The Multiplier and links to Keynesian Economics The concept of the multiplier process became important in the 1930s when John Maynard Keynes suggested it as a tool to help governments to maintain high levels of employment. This “demand-management approach”, designed to help overcome a shortage of capital investment, measured the amount of government spending needed to reach a level of national income that would prevent unemployment. 25. Explain, with reference to the concepts of leakages (withdrawals) and injections, the nature and importance of the Keynesian multiplier. The value of the multiplier depends on: Propensity to import Propensity to save Propensity to tax Amount of spare capacity Avoiding crowding out The multiplier will have a large effect on the economy when: The propensity to spend extra income on domestic goods and services is high The marginal rate of tax on extra income is low The propensity to spend extra income rather than save is high Consumer confidence is high (this affects willingness to spend gains in income) Businesses in the economy have the capacity to expand production to meet increases in demand Evaluation: Time lags and the multiplier effect It is important to remember that the multiplier effect will take time to come into full effect. Another problem is that the actual value of the multiplier effect is likely to change at different points of the economic cycle. 25. Explain, with reference to the concepts of leakages (withdrawals) and injections, the nature and importance of the Keynesian multiplier. Key points: The higher is the propensity to consume domestically produced goods and services, the greater is the multiplier effect. The government can influence the size of the multiplier through changes in direct taxes. For example, a cut in the rate of income tax will increase the amount of extra income that can be spent on further goods and services Another factor affecting the size of the multiplier effect is the propensity to purchase imports. If, out of extra income, people spend their money on imports, this demand is not passed on in the form of fresh spending on domestically produced output. It leaks away from the circular flow of income and spending, reducing the size of the multiplier. The multiplier process also requires that there is sufficient spare capacity for extra output to be produced. If short-run aggregate supply is inelastic, the full multiplier effect is unlikely to occur, because increases in AD will lead to higher prices rather than a full increase in real national output. In contrast, when SRAS is perfectly elastic a rise in aggregate demand causes a large increase in national output. Crowding out – this is where (for example) increased government spending or lower taxes can lead to a rise in government borrowing and/or inflation which causes interest rates to rise and has the effect of slowing down economic activity. Thus the multiplier effect will be reduced. 25. Explain, with reference to the concepts of leakages (withdrawals) and injections, the nature and importance of the Keynesian multiplier. 25. Explain, with reference to the concepts of leakages (withdrawals) and injections, the nature and importance of the Keynesian multiplier. 26. Calculate the multiplier using either of the following formulae 1/ (1-MPC) or 1/ (MPS + MPT + MPM) The multiplier = change in real GDP/initial change in expenditure Marginal propensity to consume (MPC): Is the proportion of each extra dollar of disposable income spent by households on consumption of domestically produced goods and services. . For example, if a person earns 1 more and consumes 60% of it, then the MPC is 0.6. Marginal propensity to Save (MPS): Is the proportion of each extra dollar of disposable income saved by households. Marginal propensity to tax (MPT): Is the proportion of each additional income taxed. Marginal propensity to import (MPM): Is the proportion of additional income spent on imported goods and serves. 26. Calculate the multiplier using either of the following formulae 1/ (1-MPC) or 1/ (MPS + MPT + MPM) The complex multiplier is the multiplier principle in Keynesian economics. The multiplier applies to any change in independent expenditure, in other words, an externally induced change in consumption, investment, government expenditure or net exports. Each of these operates to increase or reduce the equilibrium level of income in the economy. The size of the multiplier should take account of all leakages from the circular flow of income and expenditure occurring in all sectors. Complex Multiplier = 1 / (sum of the propensity to save + tax + import) or Complex multiplier = 1/ (MPS + MPT + MPM) Therefore if there is an initial injection of demand of say $400m and: The marginal propensity to save = 0.2 The marginal rate of tax on income = 0.2 The marginal propensity to import goods and services is 0.3 Then the value of national income multiplier = (1/0.7) = 1.43 An initial change of demand of $400m might lead to a final rise in GDP of 1.43 x $400m = $572m 26. Calculate the multiplier using either of the following formulae 1/ (1-MPC) or 1/ (MPS + MPT + MPM) The Simple Formula: (Got to know) The simple expenditures multiplier is the ratio of the change in aggregate production to an independent change in an aggregate expenditure when consumption is the only induced expenditure. This multiplier is as simple as it gets while capturing the fundamentals of the multiplier. The simplistic multiplier, that is the reciprocal of the marginal propensity to save is a special case used for illustrative purposes only. Simply multiplier = 1/ (1-MPC) =1/MPS If, for example, the MPC is 0.80 (and the MPS is 0.20), then an autonomous $400m change in investment expenditures results in a change in aggregate production of $2 trillion. M = 1/(1-.80) = 1/.20 = 5, so $400 x 5 = $2 trillion Tax Multiplier Simple Tax Multiplier: (Got to know) The simple tax multiplier measures changes in aggregate production caused by changes in taxes when consumption is the only induced expenditure. The Simple Tax multiplier represents the multiple by which GDP increases (decreases) in response to a decrease (increase) in taxes charged by governments. There are two versions of the tax multiplier: the simple tax multiplier and the complex tax multiplier, depending on whether the change in taxes affects only the consumption component of GDP or it affects all the components of GDP. Simple Tax Multiplier = MPC x 1/MPS = -MPC/MPS Simple Tax Multiplier (nice to know) The key feature of the simple tax multiplier that differentiates it from the simple expenditures multiplier is how taxes affect aggregate expenditures. In particular, taxes do not affect aggregate expenditures directly (as do government purchases or investment expenditures). They affect aggregate expenditures indirectly through disposable income and consumption. This gives rise to two important differences compared to the simple expenditures multiplier. First, a change in taxes causes an opposite change in the disposable income of the household sector. An increase in taxes decreases disposable income and an decrease in taxes increases disposable income. This is why the simple tax multiplier has a negative value. Second, the household sector reacts to the change in disposable income caused by the change in taxes by changing both consumption and saving. How much consumption changes is based on the MPC. The MPC means that for each one dollar change in taxes, consumption and thus aggregate expenditures change by a only fraction. The fraction is equal to the MPC. The reason, of course, is that the taxes affect income and income is divided between saving and taxes. Complex Tax Multipliers (nice to know) Complex Tax Multipliers The complex tax multiplier, is so named because it also includes other induced expenditures and components, including induced investment expenditures, induced government purchases, induced taxes, and induced exports. Complex Tax Multipliers = -MPC/ {1-[MPC + MPI + MPG – (MPC x MPT) – MPM]} Balanced-Budget Multiplier (nice to know) Balanced-Budget Multiplier: The balanced-budget multiplier measures the combined impact on aggregate production of equal changes in government purchases and taxes. The simple balanced-budget multiplier has a value equal to one. The logic behind this multiplier comes from the government's budget, which includes both spending and taxes. In general, a balanced budget has an equality between spending and taxes. As such, the balanced-budget multiplier analyzes what happens when there is an equality between changes in government purchases and taxes, that is, actions that keep the budget "balanced." In other words, the balanced-budget multiplier indicates the overall impact on aggregate production of a change in government purchases that is matched (that is, paid for) by an equivalent change in taxes. The balanced-budget multiplier, as such, is actually the sum of the expenditures multiplier (for government purchases) and the tax multiplier. Balanced-Budget Multiplier = 1/MPS + -MPC/MPS = 1-MPC/MPS = MPS/MPS = 1 27. Use the multiplier to calculate the effect on GDP of a change in an injection in investment, government spending or exports. Calculating the value of the multiplier Between 2009 and 2010, Germany’s national income increased by $100 billion. As a result: Taxes increased by $20 billion Household spending (on all goods, including imports) increased by $70 billion Savings increased by $10 billion Imports increased by $10 billion Thus: MPT = .20 MPC = .60 ~($70b -$10b = $60B) MPS = .40 MPM = .10 Complex multiplier = 1/ (MPS + MPT + MPM) = 1/(.40 + .20 + .10) = 1/.70 = 1.43 $100 billion x 1.43 = $143 billion Simple multiplier = 1/(1-MPC) = 1/(1-.60) = 1/.40 = 2.5 $100 billion x 2.5 = $250 billion Simple tax multiplier = -MPC/MPS = -.60/.40 = 1.5 $100 billion x 1.5 = $150 billion 28. Draw a Keynesian AD/AS diagram to show the impact of the multiplier. 28. Draw a Keynesian AD/AS diagram to show the impact of the multiplier. 28. Draw a Keynesian AD/AS diagram to show the impact of the multiplier. The Multiplier with Price Level Changes: Multiplier is smaller if price level varies. When the Aggregate Demand curve shifts and the Aggregate Supply curve is upward sloping, the multiplier effect is smaller. The economy moves from point A to point C, instead of going to point B when the Aggregate Supply curve is horizontal. The smaller effect results because Aggregate Demand is partially dampened as the price level rises. With an upward sloping Aggregate Supply curve, the impact of an increase in Aggregate Demand goes towards higher output and prices. In the extreme case of a perfectly vertical Aggregate Supply curve, the output multiplier is zero. Explain the Accelerator effect of investment on national income. Accelerator: The principle states that a given change in demand for consumer goods will cause a greater percentage change in demand for capital goods. The principle is used to help explain business cycles. The accelerator theory suggests that the level of net investment will be determined by the rate of change of national income. If national income is growing at an increasing rate then net investment will also grow, but when the rate of growth slows net investment will fall. There will then be an interaction between the multiplier and the accelerator that may cause larger fluctuations in the trade cycle. 2.3 Macroeconomic objectives: Phillips curve diagram 29.Discuss, using a short-run Phillips curve diagram, the view that there is a possible trade-off between the unemployment rate and the inflation rate in the short run. In economics, the Phillips curve is a historical inverse relationship between the rate of unemployment and the rate of inflation in an economy. Stated simply, the lower the unemployment in an economy, the higher the rate of inflation. While it has been observed that there is a stable short run tradeoff between unemployment and inflation, this has not been observed in the long run. 29. Discuss, using a short-run Phillips curve diagram, the view that there is a possible trade-off between the unemployment rate and the inflation rate in the short run. Aggregate demand and the Short-run Phillips curve (SRPC) share similar components. The rate of unemployment and rate of inflation found in the short-run Phillips curve correspond to the real GDP and price level of aggregate demand. Changes in aggregate demand translate as movements along the Short-run Phillips curve. If there is an increase in aggregate demand, such as what is experienced during demandpull inflation, there will be an upward movement along the short-run Phillips curve. As aggregate demand increases, real GDP and price level increase, which lowers the unemployment rate and increases inflation. 29. Discuss, using a short-run Phillips curve diagram, the view that there is a possible trade-off between the unemployment rate and the inflation rate in the short run. The key to understanding this trade-off is to consider the possible inflationary effects in both labor and product markets arising from an increase in national income, output and employment. The labor market: As unemployment falls, some labor shortages may occur where skilled labor is in short supply. This puts extra pressure on wages to rise, and since wages are usually a high percentage of total costs, prices may rise as firms pass on these costs to their customers Other factor markets: Cost-push inflation can also come from rising demand for commodities such as oil, copper and processed manufactured goods such as steel, concrete and glass. When an economy is booming, so does demand for these components and raw materials. Product markets: Rising demand and output puts pressure on scarce resources and can lead to suppliers raising prices to widen profit margins. The risk of rising prices is greatest when demand is out-stripping supply-capacity leading to excess demand (i.e. a positive output gap) 29. Discuss, using a short-run Phillips curve diagram, the view that there is a possible trade-off between the unemployment rate and the inflation rate in the short run. 30. Explain, using a diagram, that the short-run Phillips curve may shift outwards, resulting in stagflation (caused by a decrease in SRAS due to factors including supply shocks). Events in the 1970’s and 1980’s upset the line of thinking that there was a long term stable relationship between inflation and unemployment. The supply shocks of higher oil prices brought on by the actions of OPEC and severe droughts resulted in a very high increase in the cost of energy and food. The results of these events led to an inward shift of the short-run aggregate supply which resulted in higher unemployment with a decrease in real GDP. This is called, stagflation or cost-push inflation. This phenomenon is inconsistent with the logic of the short-run Phillips curve, and was interpreted to involve an upward shift of the short-run Phillips curve. 30. Explain, using a diagram, that the short-run Phillips curve may shift outwards, resulting in stagflation (caused by a decrease in SRAS due to factors including supply shocks). 30. Explain, using a diagram, that the short-run Phillips curve may shift outwards, resulting in stagflation (caused by a decrease in SRAS due to factors including supply shocks). Shifting the Phillips Curve with a Negative Supply Shock 30. Explain, using a diagram, that the short-run Phillips curve may shift outwards, resulting in stagflation (caused by a decrease in SRAS due to factors including supply shocks). 31. Discuss, using a diagram, the view that there is a long-run Phillips curve that is vertical at the natural rate of unemployment and therefore there is no trade-off between the unemployment rate and the inflation rate in the long run. It was Milton Friedman and Edmund Phelps who showed that the Phillips relationship between unemployment and inflation was valid over the short run but not over the long run. Over the long run, the natural rate of unemployment would be unaffected by prices. This accords with the principle of monetary neutrality, which simply states that nominal quantities, such as prices, cannot affect real variables, such as output and employment. If prices go up, incomes generally follow. Hence, the long-run Phillips curve is vertical, which means that it does not depend on money growth or inflation in the long-run. 31. Discuss, using a diagram, the view that there is a long-run Phillips curve that is vertical at the natural rate of unemployment and therefore there is no trade-off between the unemployment rate and the inflation rate in the long run. The long-run Phillips curve is vertical at the economy’s natural rate of unemployment for the same reason that the long run aggregate supply curve is vertical at the full employment level of output. (A) Suppose that in the short-run there is an increase in aggregate demand. Remember that wages and other resource prices are constant, but price levels have increased, which gives firms an increased profitability as output increases and unemployment falls. (B) But in the long-run, wages and other resource prices rise to meet the increase in price levels (because they are flexible in the long run), causing the SRAS curve to shift to the left, back to the LRAS curve. Real GDP has fallen back to its full employment output level but price levels have increased. The SRPC has shifted to the right as a result of the SRAS shift. (C) This shows that price levels are independent of unemployment levels in the long run. Aggregate Demand Shifts and the Phillips Curve 31. Discuss, using a diagram, the view that there is a long-run Phillips curve that is vertical at the natural rate of unemployment and therefore there is no trade-off between the unemployment rate and the inflation rate in the long run. The long run Phillips Curve (LRPC) is normally drawn as vertical – but the long run curve can shift inwards over time. An inward shift in the long run Phillips Curve might be brought about by supply-side improvements to the economy – and in particular a reduction in the natural rate of unemployment. For example labor market reforms might be successful in reducing frictional and structural unemployment – perhaps because of improved incentives to find work or gains in the human capital of the workforce that improves the occupational mobility of labor. 2.3 Macroeconomic objectives: Economic Growth 32. Describe, using an LRAS diagram, economic growth as an increase in potential output caused by factors including increases in the quantity and quality of resources, leading to a rightward shift of the LRAS curve. 32. Describe, using an LRAS diagram, economic growth as an increase in potential output caused by factors including increases in the quantity and quality of resources, leading to a rightward shift of the LRAS curve. Economic growth is an increase in the value of goods and services produced by an economy over time. Actual growth (GDP) Potential growth (trend growth) The percentage annual increase in a country’s real gross domestic product over a period of time The long run expansion of an economy’s productive potential The % annual increase in national output The increase in the capacity of the economy to produce Caused by an increase in aggregate demand Caused by an increase in aggregate supply Potential output is that which could be produced if there was full employment of resources 32. Describe, using an LRAS diagram, economic growth as an increase in potential output caused by factors including increases in the quantity and quality of resources, leading to a rightward shift of the LRAS curve. Causes of shifts in the long run aggregate supply curve: Any change that alters the natural rate of growth of output shifts LRAS Improvements in productivity and efficiency or an increase in the stock of capital and labor resources cause the LRAS curve to shift out. An increase in the size of the productive capital stock of a country will also shift out the LRAS e.g. arising from the effects of infrastructure investment or an injection of investment from overseas (FDI) 32. Describe, using an LRAS diagram, economic growth as an increase in potential output caused by factors including increases in the quantity and quality of resources, leading to a rightward shift of the LRAS curve. Key factors that affect the long run aggregate supply: 1.Higher Productivity of Labor and Capital i.e. a rise in output per person employed or increased efficiency of technology 2.Increased Labor Market Participation (Growing Labor Supply) - what policies can help increase employment? 3.Demand and Supply-Side gains from Innovation and Enterprise - two key factors that determine competitiveness 4.Capital Investment – including capital spending by domestic businesses, inward investment from overseas and Public Sector (Government) 32. Describe, using an LRAS diagram, economic growth as an increase in potential output caused by factors including increases in the quantity and quality of resources, leading to a rightward shift of the LRAS curve. Policies to increase long run aggregate supply: Expanding the labor supply - e.g. by improving work incentives and relaxing controls on inward labor migration. In the long term many countries must find ways of overcoming the effects of an ageing population and a rising ratio of dependents to active workers Increase the productivity of labor – e.g. by investment in training of the labor force and improvements in the quality of management of human resources. Productivity can be measured in several ways including output per person employed and output per hour worked Improve mobility of labor to reduce certain types of unemployment for example structural unemployment caused by occupational immobility of labor. If workers have more skills and flexibility, they will find it easier to get work. Conversely when unemployment remains high, the economy loses out on potential output and there is a waste of scarce resources Expanding the capital stock – i.e. increase investment and research and development Increase business efficiency by promoting greater competition within markets Stimulate invention and innovation – to promote lower costs and improvements in the dynamic efficiency of markets. Innovation creates new goods and services and encourages investment 33. Evaluate the view that increased investment is essential to achieve economic growth. The three factors of production: land, or natural resources; labor, or human resources; and physical capital, can be looked at as types of ‘capital’. Physical Capital: is the result of investment spending to produce machines, tools, equipment, etc. Human Capital: is the result of investment spending on education, training, provision of health care services, etc. Natural Capital: includes everything under the land, plus everything on the land, plus a country’s overall natural environment and ecosystem. Investment can be undertaken by the private sector (firms or private individuals) or by the public sector (the government). 33. Evaluate the view that increased investment is essential to achieve economic growth. Physical capital, technology and economic growth An increase in the quantity of physical capital involves an increase in the number of machines, tools, equipment etc. Whereas an improvement in the quality of physical capital depends on technological advances, which lead to new and better machines, tools and equipment. So the use of capital goods that embody a new technologies leads to a larger quantity of output produced and thus economic growth. Investment and economic growth But by investing more in capital today a nation must forgo current consumption which might reduce the standard of living in the short-run. Also, new technology might lead to structural unemployment form displace workers who’s jobs are lost to innovation. The increase in physical capital might lead to more external cost to society from increase pollution. 33. Evaluate the view that increased investment is essential to achieve economic growth. Human resources, human capital, and economic growth An increase in the quantity of labor are unlikely to be a source of economic growth by itself, but improvements in the quality of labor, arising from investment spending in human capital are among the most important sources of growth. This is because a highly skilled, well-educated and healthy labor force is more productive than an unskilled, uneducated and unhealthy one. However, increases in labor might not match the skills needed in the market place. Example, an influx of unskilled workers would not match an economy with high skill needs. This in turn could lead to a burden on social programs and services. A nation would have to commit long term to funding an educational system which would be very costly and ongoing. A nation would have to commit long term to funding a healthcare system to make the quality of labor productive, which would be very costly and ongoing. 33. Evaluate the view that increased investment is essential to achieve economic growth. Natural resources, natural capital and economic growth Marketable commodities are commodities that are bought and sold like timber, minerals, coal & oil. Whereas ecological resources include soil quality, rivers, clean air and are mostly known as common access resources. The role of marketable commodities Marketable commodities can contribute to growth but are not essential. Example include countries like Japan, South Korea and others that have achieved high growth rates in spite of producing few marketable commodities. The role of ecological goods and common access resources Ecological goods and common access resources are crucially important to longterm growth because of the concept of sustainability. For example, environmental destruction on a large scale means that future generations will have fewer and lower quality of resources available to them. 33. Evaluate the view that increased investment is essential to achieve economic growth. If an economy chooses to produce more capital goods than consumer goods, then it will grow by more than if it allocated more resources to consumer goods,. To achieve long run growth the economy must use more of its capital resources to produce capital rather than consumer goods. As a result, standards of living are reduced in the short run, as resources are diverted away from private consumption. However, the increased investment in capital goods enables more output of consumer goods to be produced in the long run. This means that standards of living can increase in the future by more than they would have if the economy had not made such as short-term sacrifice. Hence economies face a choice between high levels of consumption in the short run and the long run. 33. Evaluate the view that increased investment is essential to achieve economic growth. The effects of an increase in capital investment: The initial impact of investment is on the AD curve, which shifts to the right as investment is a component of AD. In the long run, the investment will increase the economy's capacity to produce, which shifts the LRAS curve to the right. Finally, it is likely that production costs will fall as new technology increases efficiency and reduces average costs. This means that the SRAS curve shifts to the right. The combined effects are that the economy grows, both in terms of potential output and actual output, without inflationary pressure. 34.Evaluate the view that improved productivity is essential to achieve economic growth. Productivity which refers to the quantity of output produced for each hour of work of the working population. For an economy as a whole, productivity can be measured as real GDP divided by the total number of hours worked. Improvements in productivity leads to economic growth, because each hour of work now produces more output. The factors that lead to an improvement in productivity are basically the same factors as with investment. (physical capital, labor & ecological resources) 34.Evaluate the view that improved productivity is essential to achieve economic growth. Improvements in productivity arise from factors that make labor more productive, so that each hour of work produces more output. These factors include: Increase in quantity and improvements in quality of physical capital (through investments in physical capital and technological change) Improvements in the quality of labor (through investments in human capital) Improvements in (or at least maintenance of) the quantity and quality of ecological resources (through investments in natural capital). 34.Evaluate the view that improved productivity is essential to achieve economic growth. The main drivers of growth are the availability of natural resources and productivity. Shortages of natural resource can be overcome through trade or innovation. Productivity can be increased through investment in physical or human capital, as well as technology. In addition, institutions that align individual incentives with growth and promote entrepreneurship help the economy expand. The production function relates total output to land, labor, capital and technological advancement. 34.Evaluate the view that improved productivity is essential to achieve economic growth 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability Impacts on living standards: Economic growth tends to lead to higher standard of living for the average person. Higher real income per head enables people to spend more money to meet their needs and wants, thus helping to eliminate absolute poverty in the country. Economic growth offers the potential to achieve improvements in human development and standards of living, these improvements do not occur automatically as a result of economic growth but require appropriate policies to make effective use of the resources growth makes available. 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability Benefits of economic growth: Increased consumption Consumers can benefit from consuming more goods and services. An assumption of economics is that consumption is related to utility, so in theory, with higher consumption levels, there is greater prosperity. Improved public services With increased tax revenues the government can spend more on important public services such as health and education (Merit Goods). Improved health care can improve quality of life through treating diseases and increasing life expectancy. Increased educational standards can give the population a greater diversity of skills and literacy. This enables greater opportunity and freedom. Education is seen as an important determinant of welfare and happiness. Reduced unemployment and poverty Economic Growth helps to reduce unemployment by creating jobs. This is significant because unemployment is a major source of social problems such as crime and alienation. 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability There are economic and social costs of a fast-expanding economy: Why economic growth may not bring increased happiness: Diminishing returns Often as economic growth increases incomes, people increasingly save their money (higher marginal propensity to save) this is basically because they struggle to find anything meaningful to spend their money on. Externalities of growth Economic Growth with involves increased output causes external side effects, such, as increased pollution. The economic and social costs could potentially be greater than all the perceived benefits of recent economic growth. Economic growth can cause increased inequality It is perhaps a paradox that higher economic growth can cause an increase in relative poverty. This is because those who benefit from growth are often the highly educated and those who own wealth. 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability Why economic growth may not bring increased happiness: Increase in crime and social problems It is another paradox that as incomes increase and people are better off the level of crime has increased as well. One reason why crime rates increase is that quite simply there are more things to steal. Higher economic growth has led to more hours worked In the past couple of decades higher incomes have actually led to people working longer hours. It seems people are unable to enjoy their higher incomes. Feeling the necessity or preferring to work longer hours. This suggest people are valuing earning money more than leisure. Diseases of affluence Economic Growth has enabled improved health care treatments, but at the same time there has been an unexpected rise in the number of diseases and illnesses related to increased prosperity. One example is obesity. 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability Economic growth due to the short-term fluctuations of the business cycle can mainly reduce and possibly eliminate cyclical unemployment, but with only a temporary impact on natural unemployment. Sustained reductions in natural, and particularly structural unemployment may result from long-term economic growth, involving increases in potential output. However, not all increases in potential output lower natural unemployment. Depending on the particular factors that cause potential output to increase, natural and therefore structural unemployment may increase, decrease, or remain the same. 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability In certain situations, economic growth may itself lead to increases in structural unemployment. This could occur when growth results from technological changes leading to a fall in the demand for certain labor skills. Economic policies pursued by government can also work both ways. Supply-side, market-based policies based on labor market reforms, and certain interventionist policies including investment in human capital, can work to reduce the natural rate of unemployment. Other market-based policies, such as privatization, and trade and market liberalization, may work to increase this type of unemployment. 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability Since the Keynesian model and the classical/monetarist model have different views on the shape of the aggregate supply curve, there are different outcomes on price levels in the respective models. In the horizontal part of the Keynesian AS curve, any increase in AD will have a constant price level due to excess capacity and unemployed resources in the economy. In the classical/monetarist AS curve, which is upward slopping, any increase in AD will result in increases in the price levels. 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability However, there is agreement between the two models when economic growth leads to an increase in AD at or beyond the level of full employment there is inflationary pressure. Both models also agree if there an increase in potential output involving an increase in either the SRAS or AS curves. In both cases inflationary pressure should be reduced as productive capacity of the economy has increased due to economic growth. 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability Economic growth often creates greater disparities in the distribution of income and wealth, widening the gap between rich and poor. However, economic growth also leads to greater tax revenues, enabling the government to redistribute income and wealth. With that said, there is no clear relationship between growth in GDP per capita and income distribution; instead, what happens to income distribution as a country grows is a reflection of particular conditions in each country and the kind of growth policies that are pursued. In both developed and developing countries, a major factor behind increasing income inequalities has been the growing use of market-based supply-side policies. With a move towards more economic and trade liberalization, there has been a rise in both winners and losers. While those who can take advantage of new opportunities gain, many become worse off, if they are less educated or skilled, cannot get credit, are geographically isolated, have nothing to produce for export, lose their jobs due to privatization or reductions in the size of the government sector, and so on. 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability. In looking at the relationship between economic growth and the current account balance of a country, we find economic growth leading to a larger deficit or smaller surplus in the upward phase of the business cycle. This is due to the increasing incomes leads to an increase in the demand for imports. However, over the longer term we likely to find that there is no clear relationship: as the economy grows, the current account balance may improve, stay the same or worsen, depending on what happens to the following factors. The international competitiveness of domestic industries Exchange rates The degree of export orientation of the economy Growth of incomes of trading partners The degree of protectionist trade policies faced by exports 35. Discuss the possible consequences of economic growth, including the possible impacts on living standards, unemployment, inflation, the distribution of income, the current account of the balance of payments, and sustainability. Experience shows that growth, especially rapid growth, often leads to unsustainable resource use particularly in the case of common access resources. Industrialization based on fossil fuels has been a major source of pollution. Increasing incomes lead to consumption patterns also based on greater fossil fuel consumption. Experiences like these have led to the widespread belief that economic growth and environmental sustainability are conflicting objectives. However, modern growth theory shows that both of these issues are in fact consistent with each other, and can be successfully pursued together under certain conditions. Examples include: Governments implement market-based policies that ‘internalize the externalities’, but also by providing incentives for sustainable resource use and promotion of green technologies. Governments pursue more environmental regulations that encourage pollution-free technological change. An increased emphasis on ‘green’ investments, which promote growth while not hurting the environment.