SUMMER INTERNSHIP PROJECT-II SUBJECT CODE: PWME681 ON SHAPE MEMORY ALLOY Submitted in the requirement of partial fulfilment for The 3rd year 6th Semester course of BACHLOR OF TECHNOLOGY IN MECHANICAL ENGINEERING Submitted By Moinak Roy(15800718132) Sudarshan Dey(15800719014) Under the Guidance of Mr. Suman Mandal DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING MALLABHUM INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY BISHNUPUR , BANKURA West Bengal 2021 DEPERTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING MALLABHUM INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY BISHNUPUR,BANKURA WEST BENGAL CIRTIFICATE This is to certify that the Summer Internship Project -II report entitled “SHAPE MEMORY ALLOY” carried out by MOINAK ROY, SUDARSHAN DEY 3rd year 6th semister B.Tech. Mechanical Engineering student of section 2020-21 in partical fulfilment of B.Tech 3rd year 6th semister course of Bacholer of Technology in Mechanical Engineering. MR.SUMAN MANDAL ASSISTANT PROFESSOR Depertment of Mechanical engineering Mallabhum Institute Of Technology Guide HEAD OF THE DEPERTMENT Depertment of Mechanical Engineering Mallabhum Institute of Technology ACKNOWLEDGEMENT We would like to express our sincere gratitude to Mr. Suman Mandal, Assistant professor, Mechanical Engineering Department. Mallabhum Institute of Technology. Bishnupur for his guidance and help extended at every step of this project work we are deeply indebted to him for giving us a definite direction and moral support would like to thanks Mr. Suprakash Mondal, Head of the Mechanical Engineering Department for providing us this opportunity to prefer a report on this topic selected of our interest and for guiding us by giving his valuable comments for concening manuscript Last but not the least we extend our gratitude to other faculty members of the Department for their valuable advice in every step for successful completion of this report By: Moinak Roy Sudarshan Dey Date:- CONTENTS CERTIFICARTE ACKNOWLEDGEMENT LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF TABLES ABSTRACT Chapter 1…………………………………………………………………………….1 INTRODUCTION…………………………………………………………………..2 Chapter 2…………………………………………………………………………….3 ORIGIN OF THE SHAPE MEMORY EFFECT…………………………………. .4 Chapter 3……………………………………………………………………………6 SMA BEHAVIOUR………………………………………………………………..7 Chapter 4…………………………………………………………………………... 8 THE TECHNOLOGY……………………………………………………………...9 Chapter 5…………………………………………………………………………..12 ONE WAY AND TWO WAY SHAPE MEMORY …………………………...…13 Chapter 6……………………………………………………………………….….15 MATERIALS AND APPLICATION OF SHAPE MEMORY ALLOY…….……16 LIST OF FIGURES Sl.No Fig.No Description Page.No 1 Fig.no:1 Binary phase diagram of Ti-Ni alloy 4 2 Fig.no:2 Stress-strain curves for a Ti-50.6Ni alloy 7 3 Fig.no:3 SMA tyre 9 4 Fig.no:4 SMA tyre 9 5 Fig.no:5 Martensite vs Austenite of shape memory alloy 10 6 Fig.no:6 One way and two way shape memory 13 7 Fig.no:7 Stress vs strain graph 14 8 Fig.no:8 SMA Material 16 9 Fig.no:9 NASA rover 18 10 Fig.no:10 Wheel of NASA rover 18 LIST OF TABLES SL NO Table No Description Page no 1 Table.1 Alloys having a shape memory effect 11 ABSTRACT Shape memory alloys (SMAs) show a particular behaviour that is the ability to recuperate the original shape while heating above specific critical temperatures (shape memory effect) or to withstand high deformations recoverable while unloading (pseudoelasticity). In many cases the SMAs play the actuator’s role. Starting from the origin of the shape memory effect, the mechanical properties of these alloys are illustrated. This paper presents a review of SMAs applications in the aerospace field with particular emphasis on morphing wings (experimental and modelling), tailoring of the orientation and inlet geometry of many propulsion system, variable geometry chevron for thrust and noise optimization, and more in general reduction of power consumption. Space applications are described too: to isolate the micro-vibrations, for low-shock release devices and self-deployable solar sails. Novel configurations and devices are highlighted too. Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION 1 INTRODUCTION Shape memory alloys (SMAs) are metals able to recuperate a preset shape just while heating up to a critical transformation temperature. The physical principle they are based on is a particular martensitic transformation (thermoelastic) occurring in some metallic alloys. The list includes but is not limited to NiTi, CuAlNi, CuZnAl, AuCd, and many others. Buehler et al. in 1963 were the first to evidence the shape memory effect in near equiatomic Ti-Ni alloys. The shape memory effect was found earlier in Au-47.5% Cd and In-Tl but without attracting attention from the researchers. On the contrary, equiatomic Ni-Ti alloys became popular thanks to Naval Ordinance Laboratory, hence the name Nitinol. The real understanding of the phenomena occurring during the martensitic transformation was not immediate. The main reason may be ascribed to the complexity of the Ti-Ni phase diagram (Figure 1) and to the formation of a multiplicity of precipitates under certain heat treatments (TiNi, Ti2Ni, TiNi3, Ti2Ni3, Ti3Ni4). Moreover, the R-phase (rhombohedral) transformation, considered to be a pre-martensitic phenomenon, appears under certain conditions while cooling. Now it is established that the R-phase itself is a martensitic transformation and contends with the successive martensitic transformation. Due to the excellent mechanical properties, corrosion, and abrasion resistance Ni-Ti shape memory alloys have been widely employed in many technological applications: stent, guide wire, antenna for mobile phones, coffee maker, orthodontic wire, flap for air-conditioner, and many others. The main aim of this review is to identify and exemplify a detailed list of novel applications of SMA in the aerospace field in the most updated manner without the claim of comprehensiveness, according to available recent literature in terms of relevance, number of articles, and novelty of the proposals. Ni-Ti alloys are the most employed ones, but the subject is not limited to them. 2 Chapter 2 ORIGIN OF THE SHAPE MEMORY EFFECT 3 ORIGIN OF THE SHAPE MEMORY EFFECT For the comprehension of the basic principles regarding the shapememory effect and pseudoelasticity, many contributions are useful. The crystallography of martensite, the transformation temperatures, and rate of martensite formation are discussed in details by Nishiyama Figure 1. Binary phase diagram of Ti-Ni alloy . Figure 1Reprinted fromMaterials,Vol. 12 (5),Chekotu, J.C.; Groarke, R.; O’Toole, K., Brabazon, D., Advances in Selective Laser Melting of Nitinol Shape Memory Alloy Part Production, 2019. The macrostructure consequences of the microstructure and the shape memory effect have been highlighted by Bhattacharya .The design of some shape memory alloy actuators were focused on by Otsuka and Wayman .National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) report SP5111 published in 1972 provides experimental results, although the base mechanism was not fully understood at that time .The phase transformation occurring on an SMA is peculiar because it coexists with great strain and is fully recoverable, so that in a uniaxial tensile test in NiTi it can reach also 10% .For this reason, SMAs belong to the family of the “active materials” .SMAs can also provide high forces and wide displacements when activated, if compared to other active materials. Novel application fields continue to be identified .Biomedical industry is the most served one, together with the aerospace industry. SMAs can be identified also into the class of the “smart materials”: an SMA component, with structural or functional purpose, can make a system simpler in comparison with the same manufactured piece adopting conventional know-how (for instance electromechanical or hydraulic). High activation loads and displacements generates great energy density. These properties are welcome especially in the aerospace field, hence the main reason of this review. The technological requirements of the aerospace field are more important than any considerations about the technology cost and this aspect can be identified as the real reason of the success of SMAs. 4 CRYSTAL STRUCTURE Many metals have several different crystal structures at the same composition, but most metals do not show this shape-memory effect. The special property that allows shape-memory alloys to revert to their original shape after heating is that their crystal transformation is fully reversible. In most crystal transformations, the atoms in the structure will travel through the metal by diffusion, changing the composition locally, even though the metal as a whole is made of the same atoms. A reversible transformation does not involve this diffusion of atoms, instead all the atoms shift at the same time to form a new structure, much in the way a parallelogram can be made out of a square by pushing on two opposing sides. At different temperatures, different structures are preferred and when the structure is cooled through the transition temperature, the martensitic structure forms from the austenitic phase. 5 Chapter 3 SMA Behaviour 6 SMA Behaviour In an extremely simplified manner, the main phases involved in an SMA are being austenite stable at higher temperature (parent phase) and martensite stable at lower temperature with tetragonal or monocline structure [1,8,12]. A lot of stress-strain curves obtained in tensile tests for the Ti-50.6Ni alloy at different and constant temperatures are reported in Figure 2 [13], highlighting the mechanical behaviour from low temperature to high temperature. At lower temperatures (Figure 2a–i), it is evident the shape memory effect: after an initial linear stage a plateau of stress is evident, followed by residual strain while unloading. After that, the shape recovery (not shown in the graph) on heating starts at As (Austenite start temperature) and finishes at Af (Austenite finish temperature). At temperatures higher than Af (Figure 2j–p), austenite is the only stable phase. Tensile behaviour exhibits a loading path with a plateau at higher stress than that in the martensitic phase. During unloading, the strain is fully recovered and the classic flag-type diagram is evidenced, without the necessity of further heating. The higher the temperature, the higher the temperature, the higher the level of stress for the plateau. Figure 2.Stress-strain curves for a Ti-50.6Ni alloy showing shape memory effect (a–i) and pseudo elastic effect (j–p) .Figure 2 Reprinted from Scripta Metallurgica, Vol. 15,Miyazaki, S.; Otsuka, K.; Suzuki, Y., Transformation pseudoelasticity and deformation behaviour in a Ti-50.6Ni alloy, 1981, with permission from Elsevier. The aerospace industry is actively looking for novel solutions and applications based on the integration of the SMAs in the actual technologies as well as the definition and development of new ones. SMA adoption allows to increase the simplicity of the systems as well as to reduce the weight and the volume of such active devices allowing it to achieve more compact structures. SMAs are attractive as a solution to complex engineering problems, along with high actuation stresses and strains due to their intrinsic great power/weight ratio. Integrating actuators and structures means it is possible to achieve high reliability and compact arrangements, reliable also for a high number of activation cycles [14,15]. Systems activated by SMAs have been widely examined in many studies and pieces of research in substitution of standard actuation systems, hydraulic and electric. 7 Chapter 4 The Technology 8 The Technology This innovation comprises a non-pneumatic, compliant tire utilizing shape memory alloys (mainly NiTi and its derivatives) as load bearing components. These shape memory alloys are capable of undergoing significant reversible strain (up to 10%), enabling the tire to withstand an order of magnitude more deformation than other non-pneumatic tires before undergoing permanent deformation. Commonly used elastic-plastic materials (e.g. spring steels, composites, etc.) can only be subjected to strains on the order of ~ 0.3-0.5% before yielding. Hence, the use of a NiTi shape memory alloy produces a superelastic tire that is virtually impervious to plastic deformation. In addition, the utilization of shape memory alloys provides enhanced control over the effective stiffness as a function of the deformation, providing increased design versatility. For instance, the Glenn Superelastic Tire can be made to soften with increased deflection, reducing the amount of energy transferred to the vehicle during high deformation events. In addition, the use of shape memory alloys in the form of radial stiffeners, as opposed to springs, provides even more load carrying potential and improved design flexibility. This type of compliant tire would allow for increased travel speeds in off-road applications. FIG:3 FIG:4 9 Martensite vs Austenite of shape memory alloy Shape memory alloys display two distinct crystal structures or phases. Temperature and internal stresses (which play a part in super-elasticity) determine the phase that the SMA will be at. Martensite exists at lower temperatures, and austenite exists at higher temperatures. When a SMA is in martensite form at lower temperatures, the metal can easily be deformed into any shape. When the alloy is heated, it goes through transformation from martensite to austenite. In the austenite phase, the memory metal "remembers" the shape it had before it was deformed. From the stress vs. temperature graph below, one can see that at low stress and low temperature, martensite exists. At higher temperature and higher stress, austenite exists. Stress vs. NiTinol Temperature graph for FIG:5 Memory alloys also demonstrate great rates of super-elasticity. For example, eyeglass frames are in a martensite phase. Bending the arms in half (at room temperature) introduces a phase change at the bend to austenite. Austenite is not stable at room temperature, and because systems always seek lower energy states, the austenite will change back to the martensite phase, and to do this, the arm must bend back. The most common memory metal is called NiTinol, consisting of equal parts of nickel and titanium. 10 Alloys having a shape memory effect Composition Atomic or Weight Percent Transformation Temperature Range (Celsius) -190 to -50 30 to 100 -140 to 100 Cu - Sn 44/49 at.% 46.5/50 at.% 14/14.5 wt% 3/4.5 wt% approx. 15 at% Cu - Zn 38.5/41.5 wt% -180 to -10 Cu - Zn - (Si,Sn,Al) In - Ti Ni - Al Ni - Ti Fe - Pt Mn - Cu a few wt.% of (Si, Sn,Al) 18/23 at% 36/38 at% 49/51 at% approx. 25 at% Pt 5/35 at% Cu -180 to 200 60 to 100 -180 to 100 -50 to 110 approx. -130 -250 to 180 Alloys Ag - Cd Au - Cd Cu - Al - Ni -120 to 30 PROPERTIES The copper-based and NiTi-based shape-memory alloys are considered to be engineering materials. These compositions can be manufactured to almost any shape and size. The yield strength of shape-memory alloys is lower than that of conventional steel, but some compositions have a higher yield strength than plastic or aluminum. The yield stress for Ni Ti can reach 500 MPa. The high cost of the metal itself and the processing requirements make it difficult and expensive to implement SMAs into a design. As a result, these materials are used in applications where the super elastic properties or the shape-memory effect can be exploited. The most common application is in actuation. One of the advantages to using shape-memory alloys is the high level of recoverable plastic strain that can be induced. The maximum recoverable strain these materials can hold without permanent damage is up to 8% for some alloys. This compares with a maximum strain 0.5% for conventional steels. 11 Chapter 5 One-way and two-way shape memory 12 One-way and two-way shape memory Shape-memory alloys have different shape-memory effects. Two common effects are a oneway and two-way shape memory. A schematic of the effects is shown below. FIG:6 The procedures are very similar: starting from martensite (a), adding a reversible deformation for the one-way effect or severe deformation with an irreversible amount for the two-way (b), heating the sample (c) and cooling it again (d). One-way memory effect When a shape-memory alloy is in its cold state (below As), the metal can be bent or stretched and will hold those shapes until heated above the transition temperature. Upon heating, the shape changes to its original. When the metal cools again, it will retain the shape, until deformed again. With the one-way effect, cooling from high temperatures does not cause a macroscopic shape change. A deformation is necessary to create the low-temperature shape. On heating, transformation starts at As and is completed at Af (typically 2 to 20 °C or hotter, depending on the alloy or the loading conditions). As is determined by the alloy type and composition and can vary between −150 °C and 200 °C. Two-way memory effect The two-way shape-memory effect is the effect that the material remembers two different shapes: one at low temperatures, and one at the high temperature. A material that shows a shape-memory effect during both heating and cooling is said to have two-way shape memory. This can also be obtained without the application of an external force (intrinsic two-way effect). The reason the material behaves so differently in these situations lies in training. Training implies that a shape memory can "learn" to behave in a certain way. Under normal circumstances, a shape-memory alloy "remembers" its low-temperature shape, but upon heating to recover the high-temperature shape, immediately "forgets" the low-temperature shape. However, it can be "trained" to "remember" to leave some reminders of the deformed low-temperature condition in the high-temperature phases. There are several ways of doing this.[15] A shaped, trained object heated beyond a certain point will lose the two-way memory effect. 13 FIG:7 14 Chapter 6 Materials AND Applications for Shape Memory alloys 15 MATERIALS A variety of alloys exhibit the shape-memory effect. Alloying constituents can be adjusted to control the transformation temperatures of the SMA. Some common systems include the following (by no means an exhaustive list): • • • Ag-Cd 44/49 at.% Cd Au-Cd 46.5/50 at.% Cd Co-Ni-Al • • • • • • • • • • FIG:8 • • • • • • • • Co-Ni-Ga Cu-Al-Be-X(X:Zr, B, Cr, Gd) Cu-Al-Ni 14/14.5 wt.% Al, 3/4.5 wt.% Ni Cu-Al-Ni-Hf Cu-Sn approx. 15 at.% Sn Cu-Zn 38.5/41.5 wt.% Zn Cu-Zn-X (X = Si, Al, Sn) Fe-Mn-Si Fe-Pt approx. 25 at.% Pt Mn-Cu 5/35 at.% Cu Ni-Fe-Ga Ni-Ti approx. 55–60 wt.% Ni Ni-Ti-Hf Ni-Ti-Pd Ni-Mn-Ga[46] Ni-Mn-Ga-Cu Ni-Mn-Ga-Co Ti-Nb Applications for Shape Memory alloys Bioengineering: Bones: Broken bones can be mended with shape memory alloys. The alloy plate has a memory transfer temperature that is close to body temperature, and is attached to both ends of the broken bone. From body heat, the plate wants to contract and retain its original shape, therefore exerting a compression force on the broken bone at the place of fracture. After the bone has healed, the plate continues exerting the compressive force, and aids in strengthening during rehabilitation. Memory metals also apply to hip replacements, considering the high level of superelasticity. The photo above shows a hip replacement. Reinforcement for Arteries and Veins: For clogged blood vessels, an alloy tube is crushed and inserted into the clogged veins. The memory metal has a memory transfer temperature close to body heat, so the memory metal expands to open the clogged arteries. 16 Dental wires: used for braces and dental arch wires, memory alloys maintain their shape since they are at a constant temperature, and because of the super elasticity of the memory metal, the wires retain their original shape after stress has been applied and removed. Anti-scalding protection: Temperature selection and control system for baths and showers. Memory metals can be designed to restrict water flow by reacting at different temperatures, which is important to prevent scalding. Memory metals will also let the water flow resume when it has cooled down to a certain temperature. Fire security and Protection systems: Lines that carry highly flammable and toxic fluids and gases must have a great amount of control to prevent catastrophic events. Systems can be programmed with memory metals to immediately shut down in the presence of increased heat. This can greatly decrease devastating problems in industries that involve petrochemicals, semiconductors, pharmaceuticals, and large oil and gas boilers. Golf Clubs: a new line of golf putters and wedges has been developed using sma. Shape memory alloys are inserted into the golf clubs. These inserts are super elastic, which keep the ball on the clubface longer. As the ball comes into contact with the clubface, the insert experiences a change in metallurgical structure. The elasticity increases the spin on the ball, and gives the ball more "bite" as it hits the green. Helicopter blades: Performance for helicopter blades depend on vibrations; with memory metals in micro processing control tabs for the trailing ends of the blades, pilots can fly with increased precision. Eyeglass Frames: In certain commercials, eyeglass companies demonstrate eyeglass frames that can be bent back and forth, and retain their shape. These frames are made from memory metals as well, and demonstrate super-elasticity. Tubes, Wires, and Ribbons: For many applications that deal with a heated fluid flowing through tubes, or wire and ribbon applications where it is crucial for the alloys to maintain their shape in the midst of a heated environment, memory metals are ideal. 17 Application of SMA in NASA Mars Rover (curiosity) FIG:9 SMA has a great application in the curiosity rover wheel as because mars have a very rough terrain and the temperature of mars is very low (approx:- 80 degrees Fahrenheit) So, it is very difficult for the material of the wheel to withstand the rough environment of mars . Because rubber looses it’s elastic property and became a brittle material and for this reason scientist has developed a wheel made of Shape Memory Alloy. This wheel/ tyre is also known as super elastic tyre. FIG:10 The novel use of shape memory alloys capable of undergoing high strain as load bearing components, instead of typical elastic materials, results in a tire that can withstand excessive deformation without permanent damage. Using shape memory alloy as radial stiffening elements can also increase the load carrying capacity of the tire. The Superelastic Tire offers traction equal or superior to conventional pneumatic tires and eliminates both the possibility of puncture failures and running "under-inflated", thereby improving automobile fuel 18 efficiency and safety. Also, this tire design does not require an inner frame which both simplifies and lightens the tire/wheel assembly. Benefits ➢ Safe: Eliminates the possibility of puncture failure ➢ Strong: Can withstand excessive deformation ➢ Robust: Can be configured for high traction on various terrains ➢ Simple: Eliminates the need for air ➢ Versatile: Tire stiffness can be designed to limit energy transferred to vehicle ➢ Lightweight: No inner frame needed for the tire/ wheel assembly. Practical limitations SMA have many advantages over traditional actuators, but do suffer from a series of limitations that may impede practical application. In numerous studies, it was emphasised that only a few of patented shape memory alloy applications are commercially successful due to material limitations combined with a lack of material and design knowledge and associated tools, such as improper design approaches and techniques used. The challenges in designing SMA applications are to overcome their limitations, which include a relatively small usable strain, low actuation frequency, low controllability, low accuracy and low energy efficiency. 19 Summary In the last two decades, many applications of SMAs in the aerospace field have been identified, designed, modeled, and tested. Many others will be conceived and developed in the near future. The present review confirms that SMAs attracted researcher’s attention especially in the applications in which the added value is more important than the pure economic saving. Extensive studies, results of analytical and numerical modeling, and experimental tests have been found in literature regarding SMA. In many cases, the SMAs play the role of an actuator. Starting from the basic principle and the mechanical behavior (shape memory effect and pseudoelastic), many applications regarding the wing morphing have been presented (experimental and modeling) as well tailoring of the inlet geometry of various propulsion systems. Variable geometry chevron actuated by SMA has been illustrated for thrust, noise, and general e_ciency optimization. Also, space applications have been described for isolating the micro-vibrations, for low-shock release devices and self-deployable solar sails. The development stage in many cases is limited to prototypes tested in laboratories or in wind tunnels, with only a few actually flown and even fewer in use. The main limitations may be ascribable to the higher weight, in some cases complexity of the systems, and the structural and functional fatigue phenomena in cycling applications. In the near future, many other SMAbased applications will be identified and conceived in which the actuation due to the shape memory effect or the pseudoelasticity will be based on. 20 REFERANCE 1.Otsuka, K.; Ken, X. Physical Metallurgy of 11-N-based shape memory alloys. Prog. Mater. Sci. 2005, 50, 511-678. [CrossRef] 2. Buehler, W.J.; Gilfrich, J.W.; Wiley, R.C. Effect of Low-Temperature phase change on the mechanical properties of alloys near compositions TiNi. J. Appl. Phys. 1963, 34, 1475-1477. [CrossRef] 3. Chang, L.C.; Read, T.A. Plastic deformation and diffusionless phase changes in metals-the gold-cadmium beta phase. Trans. AIME 1951, 189, 47-52. [CrossRef] 4. Burkart, M.W.; Read, T.A. Diffusionless phase change in the Indium-Thallium system. Trans. AIME 1953, 197, 1516-1524. 5. Bazinski, Z.S.; Christian, J.W. Crystallography of deformation by twin boundary movements in indium thallium alloys. Acta Metall. 1954, 2, 101-113. [CrossRef] 6. Nishiyama, Z. Martensitic Transformations, 1st ed.; Academic Press: New York, NY, USA, 1978. 7. Chekotu, J.C.; Groarke, R.; O'Toole, K.; Brabazon, D. Advances in Selective Laser Melting of Nitinol Shape Memory Alloy Part Production. Materials 2019, 12, 809. [CrossRef] 8. Bhattacharya, K. Microstructure of Martensite: Why it Forms and How it Gives Rise to the Shape Memory Effect,1st ed.; Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK, 2003. 9. Otsuka, K.; Wayman, C.M. Shape Memory Materials; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1998. 10. GOOGLE images 11. wikipedia