The Enlightenment The Enlightenment Essential Question How much power should governments have? Review- Renaissance and Scientific Revolution • Before the Enlightenment took hold of Europe, the Renaissance had occurred. The Renaissance led to the Scientific Revolution. All of these time periods are defined by a sense of inquiry, or questioning the established order to find better ways of doing things. What was the Renaissance? Golden Age of arts and literature in Western Europe Rebirth of classical learning What was the Scientific Revolution? Scientists begin to question traditional beliefs Use of logic and reason, observation and experimentation What was the Enlightenment? • A time period also known as the Age of Reason • It took place in Europe during the 18th century (1700s) The Enlightenment • Also known as the Age of Reason, the Enlightenment grew out of the Scientific Revolution of the 1500s & 1600s • If scientists could understand the physical world using reason, then reason could also be used to discover natural laws which shape the human experience. Natural Laws- unchanged moral principles, discovered through reason, that govern all human conduct WHAT DO YOU THINK THE LIGHTBULB REPRESENTS? THE ENLIGHTENMENT OCCURRED B/W 1650 -1789 Thinkers believed reason could be used to uncover the laws that govern human life Once the laws were known people could make society better Believed that reason was a much better guide than faith or tradition Reason is the “light” that reveals human error and showed the way to truth The Enlightenment… • Using methods of modern science, reformers set out to study human behavior and solve the political, social and economic problems of society using reason • Enlightened thinkers, called philosophes, were concerned with the relationship between government and the people, and their ideas were used by many modern nations in the creation of government • Resulted in the move away from absolutism and divine right (religion) and toward democracy and individual rights (secularism) encouraged revolutionary leaders throughout Europe and the Americas What did the Philosophers Despise? • Absolute Monarchs • Land-Owning Nobles • The Catholic Church’s Abusesf power Absolutism Knowledge is Power! • The Catholic Church and Absolute Monarchs saw new ideas and education as threats to be suppressed. WHY? • How does this tie in the Enlightenment? Age of Reason l (18th century Enlightenment) Natural laws apply to government as well as science! l Rights to Life, Liberty, and Property l A FAIR society is based on REASON, not “Divine Right” l • • • • • • • • What society worked best? Why were laws unjust? How did the universe operate? Was there a God? Was the Earth really 4,000 years old? Were there natural laws that governed people? Who had the power to rule? How did the human mind work? Review • In what way was the Enlightenment similar to the Scientific Revolution? A. BOTH focused on government and society B. BOTH highly valued reason and observation. C. BOTH denied the existence of God. D. BOTH were unimportant. Review • In what way was the Enlightenment similar to the Scientific Revolution? B. BOTH highly valued reason and observation. Review • What is another name for Enlightenment? • The Enlightenment took the reason of the Scientific Revolution and used it for_________ Review • What is another name for Enlightenment? • Age of Reason • The Enlightenment took the reason of the Scientific Revolution and used it for_________ • Government Central Concepts of the Enlightenment A. The methods of ______________ should be used to understand all aspects of life through the use of ___________. B. Discover the ____________ of human society as well as the natural world (“social science”) C. The idea of ____________ - The confidence in human power, human reason to improve society Central Concepts of the Enlightenment A. The methods of natural science should be used to understand all aspects of life through the use of REASON B. Discover the natural laws of human society as well as the natural world (“social science”) C. The idea of progress - The confidence in human power, human reason to improve society Central concepts of the Enlightenment [cont] D. Rejection of ___________ and ___________. E. Tolerance and _________ F. ___________ - God does not intervene in the world through miracles; he created the world, and then removed himself from it Central concepts of the Enlightenment [cont] D. Rejection of superstition and tradition E. Tolerance and equality F. Deism - God does not intervene in the world through miracles; he created the world, and then removed himself from it Pair Share Activity A period of intellectual growth that led to the development of new ideas on society, government, philosophy, economics, and religion. Marks the beginning of the modern world. Can be captured in the words of Immanuel Kant “Dare to know! Have the courage to use your own understanding is therefore the motto of the Enlightenment.” “Dare to know! Have the courage to use your own understanding is therefore the motto of the Enlightenment.” ~Immanuel Kant Turn to your partner and discuss: • What do you think this motto means? • Does this motto relate to our world today? • Why or why not? Defining The Enlightenment • Principal targets: Religion and the domination of society by hereditary aristocracy. • In other words, the church and the state, who often worked hand-inhand. Major Enlightenment Ideas • Every social, political and economic problem could be solved through the use of reason • Governments are created to secure an orderly society • Separation of powers is the best way to protect human liberties • All men are created “free and equal” • A free market should be allowed to regulate trade Enlightenment Philosophes Each had a different view about : HUMANS Locke Voltaire Hobbes Rousseau AND HOW GOVERNMENT SHOULD CONTROL THEM Enlightenment Song Thomas Hobbes • Argued that people are cruel, greedy, and selfish- as a result government (law) protects people from each other • Without government, people would fight, rob, and oppress one another • Social Contract- an arrangement where people give up their rights to be protected by the government • Supported absolute monarchs • Wrote about his ideas in The Leviathan Leviathan-(1651) A Leviathan (Sea Monster) Taken from Biblical book Of Job John Locke • Believed that people are basically moral and reasonable. They want to do the right thing. • All people are born free & equal with three natural rights- life, liberty, and property • Government exists at the consent of the governed to protect their rights. If the government fails to protect these rights, the contract is broken and the people may change or replace the government. • Wrote Two Treatises of Government stressing the best governments had limited power—not an absolute monarchy John Locke Thomas Jefferson’s Declaration of Independence drew from ideas of Locke and others Montesquieu • Criticized absolute monarchies—admired Britain's limited monarchy and said it protected people’s rights. • Believed having 3 branches in government would prevent tyranny – Having a separation of powers would prevent any one branch from gaining too much power over the other two “In order to have…liberty, it is necessary that government be set up so that one man need not be afraid of another.” Tyranny: absolute ruler abuses power; unfair and harsh rule Montesquieu Believed gov’t should be split into these three branches, and that each branch should be able to serve as a check on the other two: -Executive (enforces laws) -Legislative (makes the laws) -Judicial (applies laws) Name one country that adopted Montesquieu’s idea of separation of powers Believed in separation of powers in government- Voltaire • Believed in the freedom of press and used it to expose the abuses of corrupt political and church leaders. • Fought for civil liberties- rights/freedoms of citizens – Freedom of Speech – Freedom of Religion – Separation of Church and State • Believed that humanity’s worst enemies were intolerance, prejudice & superstition • His writings angered government and church officials. He was imprisoned and forced into exile. To stop his ideas from spreading his books and writings were outlawed and burned. “I do not agree with a word you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.” • Voltaire • One of his most famous sayings “ I disagree with what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it” Jean Jacques Rousseau • Believed that people were naturally good, but were corrupted by society • Unequal distribution of property was an especially great evil of society • Stressed the importance of the general will- the will of the people as a whole • Believed the good of the community should be placed above individual interests- common good • Hated all forms of political and economic oppression Jean Jacques Rousseau • Social Contract-1762 Humans were better off in primitive stage, not civilization Rousseau’s Social Contract • Rousseau wrote The Social ContractRemember— a social contract is an arrangement where he lays out his ideas of where people give up their government and society rights to be protected by the • Society places too many limits on government peoples’ behavior- some controls are necessary but should be minimal • Only governments that had been freely elected should impose law • Sovereignty (the power to make laws) should be in the hands of the people, and therefore the only good government is a direct democracy Enlightenment for Women • Natural Rights were for men only. Though enlightened thinkers said that women had natural rights, they were limited to the areas of home and family. • Some women were exposed to enlightened philosophy through salons. Prominent and wealthy women would host informal parties where enlightened thinkers could gather and discuss literature, the arts, science, philosophy and politics. • Salons allowed Enlightenment ideas to spread- because they were hosted by women, guests Vernacularcommon language Enlightened Women • Mary Astell – Wrote A Serious Proposal to the Ladies (1694) – Questioned the lack of educational opportunities for women – Criticized the unequal relationship between men & women in a marriage • Mary Wollstonecraft – Wrote A Vindication of the Rights of Women (1792) – Women need education to participate equally in public life The Spread of Enlightenment In addition to salons, the theories of enlightened thinkers spread rapidly through the distribution of pamphlets and books. People began to question the “traditional way” of doing things. Before After -Absolute monarchs rule by divine right -Government should work to protect the people -Church has authority -Flexible social classes- all people have rights -Strict separation between nobles and peasants -Suffer in life and be rewarded in heaven -Happiness on earth Review Writers of the Enlightenment were primarily interested in 1.changing the relationship between people and their government 2.supporting the divine right theory 3.debating the role of the church in society 4.promoting increased power for European monarchs Review John Locke and Jean Jacques Rousseau would be most likely to support 1.a return to feudalism in Europe 2.a government ruled by a divine right monarchy 3.a society ruled by the Catholic Church 4.a society in which the people chose the ruler Review Which statement best describes a change that occurred during both the Renaissance and the Enlightenment? 1.feudalism became the dominant political system 2.a new questioning spirit and attitude emerged 3.technology and science were considered unimportant 4.the use of reason and logic were discouraged Review Which statement reflects an argument of Enlightenment philosophers against the belief in the divine right of kings? 1.god has chosen all government rulers 2.independence is built by military might 3.the power of the government is derived from the governed 4.a capitalist economic system is necessary for democracy Five Key Ideas of the Enlightenment The five important philosophical concepts are 1. Reason 2. Nature 3. Happiness 4. Progress 5. Liberty Five Key Ideas of the Enlightenment • Urged the use of: – Reason: absence of intolerance, bigotry or prejudice in one’s thinking; beliefs should be rational and free of biases – Nature: natural laws exist w/out man’s creation; what was natural was good and reasonable; God is found in nature – Happiness: a person who lives by nature’s law finds happiness; argued against medieval notion that people should accept misery as part of life’s circle; Philosophes believed in well-being on earth – Progress: Philosophes believed individuals could seek perfection and in return, society seek perfection; looked at human being as capable of progress, making something better – Liberty: freedoms should not be merely granted, but expected; beliefs that we are born with liberties in nature Reason • Truth can be discovered through reason (logical thinking). • Reason= unbiased thinking – open to new ideas Denis Diderot “ Encyclopédie 1766 All things must be examined, debated, investigated without exception and without regard for anyone’s feelings…” - Summarize & promote knowledge Nature • What is natural is good and reasonable • Natural laws affect economics and politics just as natural laws guide science (ex: motion). The Social Contract, 1762 How could this fraudulent contract of government be made legitimate? Jean-Jacques Rousseau 1712-1778 “Man is born free; and everywhere he is in chains. One thinks himself master of others, and still remains a greater slave than they. How did this change come about? I do not know. What can make it legitimate? That question I think I can answer.” “The General Will” “I have never made but one prayer to God, a very short one: ‘Oh Lord, make my enemies ridiculous.’ And God granted it.” “Almost everything that goes beyond the adoration of a Supreme Being and submission of the heart to his orders is superstition. One of the most dangerous is to believe that certain ceremonies entail the forgiveness of crimes. Do you believe that God will forget a murder you have committed if you bathe in a certain river, sacrifice a black sheep…? … Do better miserable humans, have neither murders nor sacrifices of black sheep.” God is a comedian playing to an audience too afraid to laugh. It is dangerous to be right when the government is wrong. I may not agree with what you have to say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it. Example of Deism Happiness *This was a time period of optimism. *Believed every man had the right to develop his full potential. *Focus on secular issues to make life better on earth. Happiness • Living by Nature’s Laws brings happiness. • Happiness for all is possible. Liberty *Guaranteed freedoms/rights that everyone should have like press, speech, religion. *Exploring the issues of equality amongst races and gender. *Exploring what is the best form of government and why. *Create a government that will help overcome human cruelty and violence by using its power to further social improvements. Liberty • Envied liberties of English (Glorious Revolution; Bill of Rights) • Society could be set free through reason. Progress • A SCIENTIFIC approach can lead to perfect humanity and science. Influences or Effects of Enlightenment F.A.S.T 1. (F)uel revolutions such as French and American Singing of Decl. of Independence • Storming of the Bastille 2. (A)pplied Reason to the human world (government and law 3. (S)timulated religious tolerance • (T)aught that our rights come from natural law NOT the government • Natural Rights Centers of the Enlightenment Legacy of the Enlightenment Summarize using a mind map Absolutists in the 18th century attempted to apply the principles of the Enlightenment in their kingdoms. “Enlightened Despots” • Most of Europe was ruled by absolute monarchs Enlightened Monarchs • Frederick II, Prussia • Catherine the Great, Russia • Maria Theresa, Austria • Joseph II, Holy Roman Empire • Gustav III, Sweden • Napoleon I, France Impact of the Philosophes • Believed the best form of government was a monarchy in which the ruler respected the people’s rights • Tried to convince monarchs to rule justly • Some thinkers ended up corresponding with or advising European monarchs Voltaire advised Fredrick the Great Enlightened Despots • Some monarch’s embraced the new ideas and made reforms that reflected the enlightenment ideals • However, they had no intention of giving up any power • The changes they made were motivated by two desires: – to make their countries stronger – to make their own rule more effective “Let us admit the truth: the arts and philosophy extend to only the few; the vast mass, the common people and the bulk of the nobility, remain what nature has made them, that is to say savage beasts.” -- Frederick the Great to Voltaire TOLERANCE of religious minorities REFORM of institutions ABSOLUTISM (DUH!) PATRONAGE of the philosophes The Enlightened Absolutists Catherine II (Russia) Frederick II (Prussia) Joseph II (Austria) Frederick the Great of Prussia (1740–1786) • Enlightened Reforms • Granted religious freedoms • Reduced censorship • Improved education • Reformed the justice system • Abolished the use of torture Frederick the Great • Fredrick believed that serfdom was wrong but did nothing to end it since he needed the support of the wealthy landowners • As a result, he never tried to changed the existing social order • This demonstrates the limitations of his devotion to Enlightenment ideals Fredrick the Great • Most important contribution was his attitude toward being king • Called himself “the first servant of the state” • His goal was to serve and strengthen his country • Wanted to transform Prussia into a modern state PATRONAGE Frederick corresponded with Voltaire, who was a regular guest at his court before their relationship soured. Catherine the Great Russia (1762–1796) • Took over the government after she had her husband arrested and confined • Determined to “westernize” Russia • Introduced Enlightened ideals to the Russian elite • Backed efforts to modernize industry and agriculture PATRONAGE Frederick corresponded with Voltaire, who was a regular guest at his court before their relationship soured. Frederick inspects a potato harvest. Potatoes were introduced as a new crop in Prussia during Frederick’s reign. I like science... and progress... and food. Religious Toleration Frederick expanded religious toleration in Prussia, but still favored Protestants for key government posts. Some rights reserved by disavian MILITARISM Frederick continued to support a highly militarized state, contrary to the principles of the Enlightenment. Catherine “the Great” Russia Assassination? Catherine’s husband, Peter III, died less than a year after taking the throne – likely by assassination. And I helped! PATRONAGE Catherine purchased Diderot’s library... Then paid him a salary to be her “librarian.” Some rights reserved by geishaboy5 Queens Dig Me! Catherine corresponded with Voltaire, who appreciated her flattery. Catherine the Great • In 1767, she formed a commission to review Russia’s laws • Proposed reforms to the legal code based on the ideas of Montesquieu • She recommended allowing religious toleration and abolishing torture and capital punishment • The commission accomplished none of her goals Catherine the Great • She did little to improve the lives of the Russian peasants • Her views about enlightened ideas changed after a massive uprising by serfs in 1773 • After the revolt, she was convinced she needed the support of the nobles to maintain her throne – She gave the nobles absolute power over the serfs, who lost all freedom Catherine the Great • Greatest contribution was land expansion • Controlled the northern shore of the Black Sea • Gained access to the Mediterranean sea through the Ottoman controlled straights • Expanded westward in to Poland Joseph II Austria MOST Radical LEAST Effective Co-Ruler with Maria Theresa 1765-1780 Joseph II Austria (1765–1790) • Most radical royal reformer • Reforms • Legal reforms • Freedom of the press • Freedom of worship Religious Toleration Joseph’s generous religious toleration policy included private worship for Jews. Some rights reserved by disavian Map of the Austria n Empire Multi-Ethnic Empire Centralization of Administration REFORM REFORM Joseph abolished “serfdom” and granted more rights to peasants (although landlords retained some control). Joseph II • Most radical reform was the abolition of serfdom • He ordered all peasants be paid for their labor in cash • The nobles firmly resisted the change • After his death, many of his reforms were undone Changing Relationship Between Ruler and State Old Idea • As Louis XIV reportedly said “I am the state.” • The state and its citizens exist to serve the monarch. New Idea • As Fredrick the Great said, a ruler is only “the first servant of the state.” • The monarch exists to serve the state and support citizen’s welfare. Task: • Create a 3 column character chart for Catherine, Joseph II, and Frederick II • Using your books, write examples of Enlightenment ideas adopted by these individuals. • Include examples of anti-Enlightenment ideas.