LESSON 1: PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON THE SELF SOCRATES (Know thy self – ‘gnothi seauton’) No historical document proves that Socrates really existed Socrates posited that if a person knows who he or she is, all basic issues and difficulties in life will vanish and everything will be clearer and simpler Self-knowledge means knowing one’s degree of understanding about the world and knowing one’s capabilities and potentials. Possession of knowledge is virtue and ignorance is vice. Answers will always be subjective and there is no right or wrong answer to the questions posited by Socrates He is a dualist He believed that man has soul The ruler of the body is the soul Body – mortal ; Soul – immortal For him, soul pre-existed the body, and soul is what makes the body alive. If the soul gives life to the body, it makes the body and the soul dependent on each other PLATO (The self is an immortal soul) Student of Socrates and a teacher of Aristotle Plato’s idealism insisted that empirical reality we experience in the experiential world is fundamentally unreal and is only a shadow or a mere appearance; observations to verify (to see is NOT to believe) while ultimate reality is real Soul – enduring self (unchanging; stable self) The soul is eternal and constitutes the enduring self, because even after death, the soul is continues to exist ST. AGUSTINE (The self has an immortal soul) St. Augustine’s reflections on the relations between time and memory greatly influenced many fundamental doctrines of psychology Time is measured within their own memory “Property of the Mind” Exist: Time past – memories; Time present – direct experience; Time future – expectations Past & Future – exist but not real Introspection- awareness of one’s own mental processes Self-consciousness what makes us humans superior over other organisms RENE DESCARTES (I think therefore I am) Best known for his dictum “cogito ergo sum or I think, therefore I am” The existence of anything that you register from your senses can be doubted The self is real and not just illusion. He also reassured that the self is different from the body. Hence, self and body exist but differ in existence and reality. The self for Descartes is nothing else but a mind-body dichotomy. Thought (mind) always precedes action (body) Self as Thinking thing. JOHN LOCKE (The self is consciousness) the self is founded on consciousness or memory For him, consciousness is the perception of what passes in a Man’s own mind Self is not in brain but in one’s consciousness the body may change, while the consciousness remains the same. “tabula rasa” or blank slate, and the content is provided by one’s experiences over time. DAVID HUME (There is no self) There is no self Mind is nothing but a heap or collection of different perceptions. The self is a bundle of perceptions (object of the mind) of interrelated events Soul – product of imaginations Personality and cognition – machine can be activated or not. IMMANUEL KANT (We construct the self) Consciousness is formed by one’s inner and outer sense. The inner sense is comprised of one’s psychological state and intellect The outer sense consists of one’s senses and the physical world Consciousness of oneself and of one’s psychological state (or inner sense) was referred to by Kant as empirical self-consciousness while consciousness of oneself and of one’s state via acts of apperception is called transcendental apperception All representational states are in the inner sense such as moods, feelings, and sensations including pleasure and pain self organizes sensations and thoughts into a picture that makes sense to a person As opposed to Hume, Kant stressed the self is something real, yet is neither an appearance nor a thing in itself since it belongs to a different metaphysical class GILBERT RYLE (The self is the way people behave) Opposed to Rene Descartes ‘Thinking thing’ He maintained that the mind is not separate from the body (not a dualist) His theory is called logical behaviorism or analytical behaviorism- a theory of mind which states that mental concepts can be understood through observable events The disposition to know, believe, feel, and act is called the mind He said that, the mind is not the seat of self but the behavior (opposed to Descartes’ immaterial mind in a material body) The self is the way people behave; combination of mind and body. PAUL CHURCHLAND AND PATRICIA CHURCHLAND (The self is the brain) Neuropsychology Eliminative Materialism- common sense do not actually exist. Our beliefs and attitudes are supported by our feelings, which include mental states like joy and sorrow, or anxiety and relief. Self is inseparable from the brain. If the brain is gone, there is no self. Patricia Churchland, if we want to understand more about ourselves, we must study the Brain not just the mind. MAURICE MERLEAU-PONTY (The self is embodied subjectivity) He distinguished the body in two types: Subjective Body- as lived and experienced Objective Body- as observed and scientifically investigated Ponty says that the mind and body are so intertwined that they cannot be separated from one another (not a dualist) Self as embodied subjectivity Consciousness is both perceiving and engaging; must be embodied. Man’s living body, thoughts, emotions and experiences are all one Maurice Merleau-Ponty’s aphorism I am my body Lesson 2: The Self from the Sociological Perspective GEORGE MEAD SOCIAL SELF He argued that the self is not biological but social He proposed the idea that the self develops through social interaction; that social interaction involves the exchange of symbols (i.e. language); and that understanding of symbols involves being able to take the role of another. Two parts of Social Self Self – Awareness – conscious knowledge of one’s character feelings etc. Self – Image – The idea of one has of one’s ability etc. Role playing is the process in which one takes on the role of another by putting oneself in the position of the person with whom he or she interacts For Mead, self is not inborn. Babies cannot interpret the meaning of other people’s behavior. Learned during childhood in these stages: Imitation or the Preparatory stage- a child imitates the behavior of his or her parents (sweeping the floor) Play stage- involves the child playing the role of others (act like teacher or parent) Game stage- To play the game, the child must be aware of his or her relationship to other people and place himself/herself in their roles in order to appreciate his/her particular role in the game PHASES OF SELF For him, self is essentially a social process going on between the I and Me. The I is the phase of the self that is unsocialized and spontaneous. “Free and Unique”. It is also the subjective part of the self. The Me, on the contrary, is the self that results from the progressive stages of role playing or role-taking and the perspective one assumes to view and analyze one’s own behavior. It represents the conventional and objective part of the self Mead describes Generalized others as an organized community or social group which gives to the individual his or her unity of self. (ATTITUDE OF ONE IS ATTITUDE OF ALL) CHARLES HORTON COOLEY LOOKING GLASS SELF The looking glass self is a social psychological concept. In this view, the self is developed as a result of one’s perceptions of other people’s opinions. It is made up of feelings about other people’s judgments of one’s behavior. SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT Self is an individual’s awareness of personal identity. PRIVATE SELF, PUBLIC SELF, AND COLLECTIVE SELF Private Self- or individual self is the cognition that involves traits, states, and behaviors Example: I am generous- shows one’s knowledge of his or her attributes that differentiate him or her from the others Public Self- is the cognition concerning the generalized other’s view of the self. Example: People think I am religious- shows one’s relation with others and the role one assumes in that relationship Collective Self- is the cognition concerning a view of the self that is found in memberships in social groups Example: When a person is activist – attributes of being an activist (campaigns to bring about political or social change) HENRI TAJFEL SOCIAL IDENTITY THEORY Social identity theory has been defined as the person’s sense of who he or she is according to his or her membership to a certain group Group membership is an important source of pride and self-esteem. It gives sense of identity and belongingness to the social world Henri Tajfel pointed out that, the world is divided into “us” and “them” through the process of social categorization forming the social groups. POSTMODERN VIEW OF THE SELF POSTMODERNISM In the postmodernist view, self is not the creator of meaning, nor the center of starting a point of sociological inquiry. MICAEL FOUCAULT Self is seen as product of modern discourse Self turned into text. ANDERSON There are four basic postmodernist ideas about the self (Anderson): Multiphrenia- refers to the many different voices speaking about “who were are and what we are” (You can be a student, a sibling, a friend, GF/BF) Protean- a self is capable of changing constantly to fit the present conditions. (You may not be at ease to talk with gays and lesbians as a teenager, but now you are not bothered at all) De-centered- no self at all. The self is constantly being redefined or constantly undergoing change. Self-in-relation- which means that humans do not live their lives in isolation but in relation to people and to certain cultural contexts WILLIAM GRAHAM SUMNER William Graham Sumner further divided these social groups into two: In-group- is an esteemed social group commanding a member’s loyalty “a person belongs” Out-group- one feels competition or opposition. “a person does not belong” A person has an inherent feeling of enhancing the status of the group. TAJFEL AND TURNER (1986) Tajfel and Turner identified three mental processes in evaluating “us and them” Social Categorization - how people categorize things Social Identification - people adapt the identity of the group to which they have categorized themselves (ex. When we categorize Christians, chances are they will adopt the identity of a Christian) Social Comparison - after categorizing and identifying a group, they tend to compare that group with other groups (discrimination) No “I” self since people don’t have fixed identities. Traditional society – by role Modern society – by achievements Postmodern society – fashion / style Postmodern social condition is dominated by two realities: The rise of new media technologies The dominance of consumerism Lyon argued that the predicament of the self in postmodern societies is complicated by the advent of electronic-mediated virtual interactions of cyber selves and the spread of information technology GREEN (1997) The self is digitalized in cyberspace Essay “Email and Harmony” LESSON 3: The Self from the Anthropological Perspective CULTURAL IDENTITY AND NATIONAL IDENTITY CULTURE - Latin word “cultura” or “cultus” meaning care or cultivation. Individual has both personal identity and collective identity. Personal Identity – the ways how one sees him’herself as an individual Collective Identity - The way he/she sees himself/herself as member of a certain group. IDENTITY - “who the person is”; Qualities and traits of an individual than make him/her different from others. CULTURAL IDENTITY - Identity or feeling of belongingness to a certain culture group. Cultural Identity Theory - explains why a person acts and behaves the way he or she does. Nation - Group of people built on the premise of shared customs etc; Observed as a group of people who share the same cultural identity. NATIONAL IDENTITY - Identity or feeling of belongingness to one state or nation; socially constructed. Material Culture - refers to the physical objects, resources, and spaces that people use to define their culture. Non-Material Culture - refers to the nonphysical ideas that people have about their culture, including beliefs, values, rules, norms, morals, language, organizations, and institutions. Self-Categorization - One must identify himself or herself from other nations. BRIAN MORRIS’S ANTHROPOLOGY OF THE SELF “The self is not an entity but a process that orchestrates and individual’s personal experience.” THE CONCEPT OF “SELF” AND “OTHER” ACCORDING TO BRIAN MORRIS SELF - defined as an individual’s mental representation of his or her person, as kind of self-representation. OTHER – (in relation to self) refers to how one perceives the mental representation of others. • The relationship between the self and others is also a function of culture. -The self is engaged in a process of positioning and counter positioning in a globalizing society (spatial perspective) - Self is part of positioning in collective history (Temporal POV) Internal I-position - refers to how one functions in himself or herself. External I-position - refers to how one identifies himself or herself based on particular factors. • When positions are silenced or suppressed the self becomes monologic instead of dialogic. • Culture can be seen as the collective voices that shape the social positions of the self. • The relational self can be positioned at the intersection of time and space. INDIVIDUAL SELF, RELATIONAL SELF & COLLECTIVE SELF 3 FUNDAMENTAL SELVES Individual Self - reflects the cognition related to traits, states, and behaviors that are stored in memory. Relational Self - reflects cognitions that are related to one’s relationship. Collective Self - reflects cognitions that are related to one’s group. IDENTITY STRUGGLES - A term introduced by Anthony Wallace and Raymond Fogelson. -It characterizes the discrepancy between the identity a person claims to possess and the identity attributed to that person by others. ADDITIONAL Identity refers to the qualities and traits of an individual that make him or her different from others Wallace and Fogelson introduced Identity Struggles National Identity refers to the identity or feeling of belongingness to one state or nation. It also requires the process of Self Categorization HUBERT HERMANS Dialogical Self Theory Self as the “society of Mind.” Sense of self Lesson 4: The Self From The Psychological Perspective WILLIAM JAMES’S SELF THEORY The perception of the self was divided into two categories: I-Self- refers to the self that knows who he or she is. (Thinking self) Me-Self- is the empirical self. It refers to the describing the person’s personal experiences He claimed that understanding the self, the self can be contextualized in three categories: ▪ Material Self- consists of things that belong to a person such as the body, family, clothes, money, house etc. that contributes to one’s selfimage. ▪ Social Self- refers to who and how a person acts on social situations. James believed that we have different social selves depending on the social situation ▪ Spiritual Self- refers to the most intimate and important part of the self that includes the person’s purpose, core values, conscience, and moral behavior. ▪ Pure Ego- the most puzzling aspect of the self. It is conceived by understanding that it can recognize its own thoughts and that these thoughts possess a particular warmth that separate the ego* Empirical Self James said that, these sub-categories are related in a hierarchical way, with material self at the bottom, the spiritual self at the top, and the social self in between. Together, they constitute what James called EMPIRICAL SELF. Feelings and Emotions Aroused (SelfFeelings) - the self was categorized by this concept because of his or her knowledge and appraisal of his or her empirical existence in the world. Action the Self prompt (Self-seeking) - it is the effort of every individual to preserve and improve oneself based on one’s selfknowledge and resulting self-feelings. CARL ROGERS’S SELF THEORY Rogers’ believe that the self does not exist at birth; it is developed gradually during childhood wherein one differentiates the self from non-self. He said that by means of free choice and action, one can shape himself or herself based on what he or she wants to be. The choices an individual makes are based on his or her set of values. REAL SELF It is the who an individual actually is, intrinsically. How one thinks, feels, looks and acts It is the self that feels most natural, comfortable, and true to what and who one really is. It is the self that one continuously needs to accept, take care of, and improves The real self is one’s self image IDEAL SELF Is the perception of what a person would like to be or thinks he or she would be. It is an idealized image that has developed over time based on the influence of the environment and the people one interacts with This self is product of expectations and pressures from other people It is dynamic and forever changing -The greater the discrepancy between the real and ideal self, the greater the frustration and distress one will experience. Hence, once should address the discrepancy by either addressing the issue or accepting the issue if it cannot be resolved. -Ex. You want to be a professional basketball player but you lack the ideal height Self-worth is high when the real self and ideal self are close to each other. SELF CONCEPT It is defined as the totality of complex, organized, and dynamic system of learned beliefs, attitudes, and opinions that each person holds to be true about his or her personal existence It is a social product, developing out of interpersonal relationships and striving for consistency. It is also the individual’s beliefs about him or herself which includes attributes ASPECTS OF SELF-CONCEPT There are two aspect of self-concept: Existential Self- when an individual recognizes his or her existence as a separate entity from others and realizes that he or she will continue to exist over a period of time and space. It usually starts in infancy up to early childhood. This is evident when a child can relate to the outside world (i.e. responds by clapping, touching objects, move objects) Categorical Self- starts after a child recognize his or her existence as a separate entity and become aware that he or she is an object in the world. Like objects with physical properties, one begins to categorize him or herself in terms of age, sex, height, weight. THREE COMPONENTS OF SELF-CONCEPT 1. Self worth or self-esteem- is what one thinks about oneself. This develops in early childhood stage resulting from interaction of the child with his or her mother and father 2. Self-Image- is how one sees him or herself, which is important for good psychological health. Self-image includes the influence of body image on inner personality. At a simple level, one might look at oneself as either good or bad and the like. 3. Ideal Self- is the person that one wants to be. It consist of one’s dreams and goals in life, and it is continuously changing. GLOBAL VS. DIFFERENTIATED MODELS This model looks into a human being in his or her totality, as an invisible entity that cannot be broken down into parts. Two prominent schools of thought in this model: Gestalt Psychology- is guided by the principle that “the whole is greater than the sum of all its parts”. Humanistic Psychology- is guided by the principle that “human beings, as humans, supersede the sum of their parts”. They cannot be reduced into components. It is better understand one’s emotions and experiences in order to know more about one’s identity The differentiated models look into a human being through examining its parts for it is divisible or can be broken into components. SIGMUND FREUD (Multilayered Self) For him, self is multi-layered: Id- exist since birth “instincts”, obsessions related to sexual “libido” and aggressive desires. It operates in the Pleasure principle Ego- operates in the Reality principle. It is developed by means of socialization at home, school, church, etc. It has two system: Conscience which can sanction the ego by feeling of guilt; Ideal Self rewarded by the superego when conforms to the standards Superego- dominant, a law-abiding, morally upright and socially acceptable individual appears. Operates on the Moral principle Freud and Jung, both Psychoanalyst studied the human psyche and its structure that is essential in understanding personality and identity. For Freud, the psyche is composed of three parts (id, ego, superego). While for Carl Jung divided the psyche into three parts: Ego- is the center of consciousness. It is the person’s sense of identity and existence. It organized the thoughts, feelings, senses and intuition. Personal unconscious- refers to all information stored in a person’s mind that are readily accessible to consciously recall. Collective unconscious- refers to the unconscious mind shared by all human beings such as instincts and archetypes (models or people, personalities, and behavior). ALBERT BANDURA’S AGENTIC THEORY OF THE SELF To be an agent means to be capable of intentionally influencing one’s own functionality and life circumstances An agent recognizes his or her own ability to make life decisions. The agentic theory of the self rejects the notion that the selfhood is culturally influenced or controlled by urges, rather, it looks upon every human being as capable of thinking, deciding, foreseeing, and controlling his or her actions, free to decide for himself or herself. This capability is called human agency, which is the capability of an individual to exert influence over the course of his or her actions. For him, there are four core properties of human agency: Intentionality- is manifested in how an individual forms intentions with action plans and strategies to realize them Forethought- refers to how an individual positions his or her plans in the future. How he or she visualizes him or herself in a future state of existing Self-reactiveness- an individual needs to self-regulate in order for one’s intentions and foresight to produce successfully. This includes adapting personal standards, constructing appropriate courses of action, monitoring activities, and regulating them by making use of self-reactions. Self-reflection- signifies that people are capable of self-examining their own functioning. They reflect on their life pursuits, the meaning of the actions they take in order to accomplish these pursuits, their thoughts, and personal efficacy. Bandura’s theory views the self as a person and not as a distinct entity responsible for bearing information and regulating behavior. As agents, individuals exercise control over their own functioning Since the self is situated in an environment where the interplay of interpersonal and intrapersonal activities occur, the self functions as a product of these influences making the individual responsible for how he or she lets these various influences affect how he or she functions. Carl Jung divided the human psyche into three parts namely: the ego, the personal unconscious, and the collective unconscious Personal Unconscious refers to all information stored in a person’s mind that is readily accessible to consciously recall. Apperception is the faculty that allows for application of concepts. It is the act of apperceiving that allows one to synthesize or make sense of a unified object Self Reflection signifies that people are capable of selfexamining their own functioning. ADDITIONAL Self-knowledge means knowing one’s degree of understanding about the world and knowing one’s capabilities and potentials. Freud, the self is multi-layered and it is composed of three structures of the human mind the id, ego and superego the Material Self consists of one’s body, clothes, family, home and other material possessions. Pure Ego is the most puzzling aspect of the self. It is conceived by understanding that it can recognize its own thoughts and that these thoughts possess particular warmth that separates the ego. Carl Rogers believes that the self does not exist at birth. It is developed gradually during childhood wherein one differentiates the self from non-self. Self Concept is defined as the totality of complex, organized and dynamic system of learned beliefs, attitudes and opinions that each person holds to be true about his or her personal existence. Self Worth talks about what an individual thinks about oneself. Gestalt Psyhology is a school of thought is interested in looking at the entirety of the self – the mind, body, physical attributes, behaviors Superego is the reservoir of moral standards. It ensures compliance with the norms, values and standards imposed by society. Lesson 5: THE SELF IN WESTERN AND EASTERN THOUGHTS INDIVIDUALISM AND COLLECTIVISM Individualism is an orientation concerned with the independence and self-reliance of the individual. Individualistic cultures put more emphasis on promoting the individual and the immediate family’s welfare The western conception of the self is individualistic; it gives more emphasis on freedom and choice Self-orientedness Does not promote isolation An individual has the capacity to consider his or her own best interest. Everyone is free to decide whether to take it or not in solving societal problems Collectivism is an orientation characterized by belongingness to larger groups or collectives. Collectivistic cultures, on the other hand, give more importance to loyalty to the in-group, which in turn takes care of the individual’s welfare The eastern conception is collectivistic; it gives more importance on relationships, roles, duties, obligations, and the preservation of culture and tradition. It prioritizes the needs and goals of society over the needs and desires of every individual. Others-oriented BUDDHISM In Buddhism, there is no such thing as the Atman (Self). It is regarded as illusion (atman), an imaginary concept born as a product of evolved consciousness and misguided thinking of humans. What is perceived by one’s sense becomes one’s reality. There is nothing permanent, but change It does not consider humans as persons with a fixed and unified identity. Instead, a human being is a product of five changing processes, the physical body, feelings, perceptions, responses, and the flow of consciousness-that experiences them all. CONFUCIANISM It regards an individual as a member of a larger whole, not as a separate being. The ethical teachings of Confucius are based on human relationship as reflected in his concept of Five Cardinal relationship/Five bonds: Between the ruler and minister Between father and son Between husband and wife Between brothers Between friends If individuals perform their respective roles, there will be harmony Individual identity is defined by membership in the reference group to which one belongs (Relational Self) Subdued Self is conditioned to respond to perceptions, not of its own needs and aspirations but of social requirements and obligations. To subdue oneself means to practice ren-(humanheartedness) Ren is a virtue characterized by altruistic “selfless” behavior that must be nurtured in every person A subdue self means being a “person for others” TAOISM Living with harmony with the Tao (way or path), is a religion and a philosophy at the same time Tao is nothing but the expression of the unity of the universe and of the path which human beings must take to preserve that unity. Going against the will of the nature or the universe disrupts the cosmic order (Ying and Yang) It contradicts the idea of Confucius since it does not consider the self as extension of social relationships; rather, the self is but one of the countless manifestations of the Tao. HINDUISM The atman, referred to as the self, spirit and soul, is the same self described in the creation. In Hinduism, the atman is one with the Brahman (the absolute, transcendental power). It has been stated that Brahman is an absolute reality, while Atman (soul or spirit), the true knowledge of self, is identical to Brahman. The atman is viewed as a spiritual, immaterial being that must be detached from the material world and worldly possessions Law of Karma is the most important doctrine of Hinduism All actions are subject to Karma (Good or Bad)