Newsletter National Council of Acoustical Consultants Winter 2013 Mission: President’s Winter Message “Enhancing the stature and effectiveness of the acoustical consulting profession for the mutual benefit of the public and the member firms” Teaming and Cooperative Relationship Opportunities Highlights Project Case Study page 4 Smart Device Use for Acoustic Measurements Page 7 Scott Pfeiffer Named ASA Fellow and Vern Knudsen Distinguished Lecturer Page 16 IEEE Honors Leo Beranek Page 18 New Staff at Cavanaugh Tocci Associates Page 22 Visit us at <www.ncac.com> Established in 1962 Kerrie G. Standlee Daly-Standlee & Associates, Inc. kstandlee@acoustechgroup.com A s I enjoy a few days with my family on the Oregon coast during my daughter’s spring break week, I think about the fact that I am writing a President’s Message for a Winter Newsletter with the outside conditions being more like spring than winter. The low, hanging clouds roll in from the ocean to cover the mountaintops a soft and billowy shade of gray while the temperature hovers around a mild 55 degrees Fahrenheit. I ask myself, ‘How can I write a Winter Newsletter article when everyone knows that it is spring?’ Then I remember that there are member firms in our organization located in the Midwest and the Northeast that probably would like to know when the winter of 2013 will lose its grip on their business operations. The fact that we have member firms in different regions of the country experiencing such varying weather conditions makes me think about how the NCAC may have member firms located in a region of the country that has provided them with the opportunity to gain more expertise in a particular area of acoustics than firms located in other areas; basically due to the fact that there is more of a demand for the type of work within the region in which they are located. For example, it may be possible that member firms located in an area of the country with a large timber-based economy have more experience in developing noise controls for sawmills, planer mills and plywood mills than firms located in other areas. Firms located in an area with a significant high-tech based economy may have more experience in dealing with the design of wafer fabrication facilities or the design of clean room facilities. Or member firms located in an area of the country with a high number of recording studios may have had the opportunity to gain more experience than the typical member firm. Given this possibility, I want to suggest that if you find your firm invited to work on a project which you may not have the experience as you would like, you may want to look at the membership directory and find an NCAC member firm located in an area where that expertise may be in more demand. Contacting that firm to see if they would consider collaborating with your firm may be a cost effective way to get the experience you need and allow you to develop a working relationship with a Continues on page 3 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 1 The NCAC Newsletter is published quarterly by the National Council of Acoustical Consultants as a service to its membership and all interested parties. 2012-2014 NCAC Officers/Directors Kerrie Standlee President Kenric Van Wyk President-Elect James Phillips Vice President/Membership Michael Yantis Vice President/Finance Stephanie Adams-Ball Vice President/Marketing and Communications Directors-at-Large Stephanie Adams-Ball David Braslau Richard Riedel Eric Reuter Richard Schrag Joseph Soker Joseph Bridger Individual Member Representative Bennett Brooks Immediate Past President Jackie Williams Executive Director Neil Thompson Shade nts@akustx.com Newsletter Editor William Cavanaugh Newsletter Associate Editor Regional Editors Tracie Ferguson Northwest US, Canada, Western Canada, and Eastern Pacific Scott Pfeiffer Central US, Europe, Middle East, Central America, and South America Jeff Fullerton Eastern US and Eastern Canada Tony Rosa Newsletter Graphics & Layout Headquarters 9100 Purdue Road, Suite 200 Indianapolis, IN 46268 (317) 328-0642 • FAX (317) 328-4629 <www.ncac.com> E-mail info@ncac.com Upon written request to the Executive Director of NCAC, articles from the NCAC Newsletter may be reprinted with proper acknowledgment to the author(s) and newsletter issue(s) from which the original article appeared. Such requests should include a statement on the possible further distribution of the reprint(s). 2 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter From the Editor Neil Thompson Shade nts@akustx.com I cost of $400,000 with the objective of incorporating the latest in marketing and shopping technology. The goal was to make shopping fun and not a chore. To that end, Selfridge’s had a 5-star restau- normally do not get sucked into too many television shows, but I do have a particular weakness for I normally do not get sucked into too anything Britmany television shows, but I do have a ish on Sunday particular weakness for anything British nights. My latest guilty on Sunday nights. pleasure, now that ‘Downton Abbey’ has rant, library, women’s gun club (since concluded its season, is ‘Mr. Selfridge’. emancipation was in the works), rooftop It is the story of Harry Selfridge, the golf course, and other amenities to keep rags-to-riches Wisconsin ex-pat who the customer in the store for as long as moved to Edwardian England and possible. established the namesake department A true innovator, master of the store Selfridge & Co. in 1908. What does ‘sizzle and not the steak’, he was able to this have to do with acoustics you might leverage the newspapers to promote his ask? Well, nothing really, but the show business with stunts like having French is a great view and I have learned a few aviator Louis Blériot’s monoplane (1909) things about history and marketing. on display at the store, the first public Selfridge helped to support his demonstration of television (1925), mother and her children, starting first a seismograph installed to monitor with a paper route at the age of 10. At 12 earthquakes, public concerts, and other obtained a job at a dry-goods merchant, educational endeavors. The public loved which he advanced in responsibility and it, competitors hated it, and the cash latter left to work at an insurance agency. registers kept on ringing. And now I He moved to Chicago to work at the understand why department stores have Marshall Field Department Store for 25 the one-half acre perfume counter front years advancing to junior partner. While and center at the store’s entrance: another there he came up with the expressions Selfridge shopping innovation. ‘___ shopping days until Christmas’ and This issue features a case study of ‘The customer is always right.’ the Michener Museum audio/visual sys In London on a vacation (sorry, tem by Metropolitan Acoustics, technical ‘holiday’) around 1906 he was appalled feature on ceiling plenum sound attenuat the department stores and the formal ation by Noral Stewart, an equipment way in which customers were treated, review by Herb Singleton use of smart particularly how merchandise was not devices for acoustic measurements, readily accessible to touch, without a along with firm member and NCAC salesperson having to retrieve it. news. As always, your comments, news A man of eternal optimism, he items, and concerns should be addressed knew he could do better than the stuffy to the editor at nts@akustx.com. Edwardians and decided to open the largest department store in London at a President’s Message Continued from page 1 firm that could lead to more work in the future. And speaking of the membership directory, by now, you should have received your membership update packet from the NCAC business office requesting that you update your company location and experience information for the next membership directory. Please take the time to respond to that request and know that the information you provide can be an asset to your firm on the NCAC website – so give it the time it deserves. And remember, other member firms use the directory as well as the general public so let your co-members know about you. While you are in the mode of updating your information, go the NCAC are Sound Solutions of Tucson, AZ and website to make sure your firm name WAVE Engineering of Denver, CO. Two shows up on the interactive map in the other firms are in the works for becomcorrect state. If it doesn’t, let Emily ing new NCAC members but I will leave Fiock at the NCAC business office know those unnamed until they have received (efiock@ncac.com) and she will see to it that the error gets corrected. And, while And remember, other member firms use the you are on directory as well as the general public so let the interactive map, go your co-members know about you. ahead and see where your next possible collaborating final approval. member firm might be located. Until next time, enjoy reading the Finally, I want to recognize the Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter. most recent two firms that have joined the NCAC and ask that you reach out and extend a welcome to them. They networked soundmasking systems by Dynasound are 100% addressable Full audio control for every speaker Uses standard PoE network hardware designed for today, engineered for tomorrow Each speaker has independent access to 8 audio channels and multiple masking generators. Dynasound, Inc. 6439 Atlantic Blvd. Norcross, GA. 30071 800.989.6275 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 3 Project Case Study The James A. Michener Museum in Doylestown, PA Felicia Doggett and Saben Shawhan felicia@metropolitanacoustics.com T he James A. Michener Museum in Doylestown, PA recently completed construction of an ambitious new addition, The Edgar J. Putnam Pavilion. The pavilion hosts public programs ranging from jazz nights to lectures, plus private events like wedding receptions and corporate gatherings. The new pavilion is a 2,500 sf space with three 23 ft tall structural glass walls that overlook the sculpture garden and, perhaps more uniquely, the 23 ft wall of the former Bucks County Prison, dating to 1884. The project architect, KieranTimberlake, desired a clean look throughout the pavilion. The three glass walls are the largest self-supporting glass units in North America and were manufactured in Germany. The remaining wall is the connection point to the existing building and a new catering kitchen. The entire space is covered with an oak hardwood floor. To reduce the reverberation time in the pavilion, BASWAphon was used on the ceiling and upper part of the connection wall to the building. The measured reverberation time in the mid frequencies after completion was approximately 1.25 seconds unoccupied, which is favorable for the events that take place in the space. To maintain the clean, sleek, and inspiring look of the space and ceiling, the architects designed a recessed trough system that ran across the ceiling to house the sprinklers, lighting, and the sound system loudspeakers. This required a careful approach to the audio/ video design. Metropolitan Acoustics designed the audio system in a manner that minimizes sound reflecting from the glass walls and back to the listeners. An EASE model was built to help finalize the loudspeaker selection and to determine the best possible locations and quantity required. Several loudspeaker manufacturers, models, and locations were evaluated before we decided on the JBL AC28/95 loudspeak- 4 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter Exterior of the Michener Museum Ceiling Trough Hiding Lighting and Loudspeakers. ers which utilize two high output 8 inch low frequency transducers and a rotatable 90° by 50° coverage waveguide with a 1 inch compression driver. Due to their compact size, sixteen (16) loudspeakers were strategically placed within the ceiling alcoves to provide the approContinues on page 6 Need to Tune Your Room ? Variable Acoustics for Low Frequencies AqFlex by ® US Patent # 79053023 Distributed in the USA by acouStaCorp The AqFlex system is the only ceiling mounted variable acoustic system that targets low frequencies. ® AqFlex Testing Data ® Estimate on basis of certified measurements of absorption coefficients in the OFF positions working in entire ceiling area 1.00 0.90 absorp coefficients 0.80 0.70 0 60 0.60 0.50 0.40 0.30 0.20 0.10 0.00 0 OFF 63 125 250 500 Frequency, Hz 1000 2000 4000 When on/off baffles are deflated they minimally impact room acoustics; leaving the room reverberant. AqFlex Testing Data ® Estimate on basis of certified measurements of absorption coefficients in the ON positions working in entire ceiling area 1.00 0.90 absorp coefficients 0.80 0.70 0 60 0.60 0.50 0.40 0.30 0.20 0.10 0.00 0 ON (( (( Applications Theaters Concert Halls Music Schools/Studios Multi-Use spaces Arenas Gymnasiums (( ( ( 63 125 250 500 Frequency, Hz 1000 2000 4000 At the press of a button the on/off baffles are inflated. The baffles absorb low-mid frecquency energy; reducing the reverberation time. acouStaCorp Variable Acoustic Solutions for technical details & budget pricing contact Ted Ohl - tedohl@pdoinc.com www.acouStaCorp.com | 1-800-275-7361 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 5 Project Case Study Continued from page 4 priate coverage over the listening area while minimizing reflections from the walls. Michener Museum requested that a full video presentation system be included within the Putnam Pavilion in order to accommodate special events that would take place throughout the year. Just as glass requires special acoustic consideration, it also presents a handicap to video presentation systems. Compounding this challenge, only solar shades were installed, not blackout shades. In order to combat the natural light that floods the space during the day, a powerful 10,000 lumen Christie WX10K-M projector was chosen and mounted in a Draper SLX-17 motorized lift that draws up into the ceil- ing when not in use. To accommodate the viewing angles and distances from attendees to the projection screen, a 15 ft wide by 9 ft high, 16:10 aspect ratio electric projection screen was specified. The screen stays out of sight by retracting into the space between the ceiling and glass wall when not in use. The projection system delivers an excess of 70 lumens per sf, which is about 30 lumens more than most common design goals. The Putnam Pavilion presented a challenge for Metropolitan Acoustics. A rewarding challenge, however as the success of the design has already been recognized: The Putnam Pavilion was the recipient of the AIA Philadelphia Gold Merit Award for 2012. ACOUSTIC TEST FACILITIES Felicia Doggett and Saben Shawhan of Metropolitan Acoustics. NOISE-ISOLATING ENCLOSURES SOUND-ABSORBING PANELS ECKEL NOISE CONTROL SYSTEMS . . . cost-effective solutions for improving the acoustic environment of industrial, commercial, and institutional facilities, & for determining the acoustic characteristics of products and com p o n e n t s High Performance Facilities for All of Your Acoustic Evaluation/Measurement Needs • Anechoic Chambers • Hemi-Anechoic Chambers • SuperSoft Test Rooms • Reverberation Rooms • Test Cells Guaranteed performance. Quality-engineered for reliable, longterm acoustic integrity. Integrated design & engineering service. Rugged, Free-Standing Acoustic Enclosures/Walls for Reducing Machinery Noise • Eckoustic Modular Panel (EMP) & Heavy-Duty EMP Enclosures/Walls Ideal for effectively reducing noise from machinery and equipment to acceptable OSHA levels. A truly modular system – all of the basic components are removeable and interchangeable. Easy to 6 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter install, to disassemble, and to re-erect. Also excellent for constructing noise-isolating control rooms and offices/work stations. Versatile Architectural Acoustic Wall & Ceiling Panel Systems for Lowering Background Noise & Reverberation • Eckoustic Functional Panels (EFPs) • Delta-Acoustic Panels • Acoustic Lay-in Panels (ALPs) • TEC Noise Barrier Panels • Textured Functional Panels (TFPs) Outstanding acoustic performance combined with attractive appearance & long-term durability. Eckel Industries, Inc., Acoustic Div. 155 Fawcett St., Cambridge, MA 02138 Tel: 617-491-3221 • Fax: 617-547-2171 e-mail: eckelncac@eckelusa.com w w w.eckelusa.com • Smart Device Use for Acoustic Measurements Herb Singleton, PE Cross Spectrum Acoustics hsingleton@csacoustics.com Editor’s Note: A trend in the past couple of years is software developers releasing acoustic measurement software to work on smart devices such as the Apple iPad or iPhone and Android enabled telephone. A primary hardware issue is the microphone has been optimized for telephony, not acoustic measurements. Herb Singleton’s article should shed some light on the issues affecting this rapidly changing technology. [NTS] I n the fall of 2007 I was contracted to work on a project that required me to work with a Brüel & Kjær 2250 sound level meter. It was my first time working with the meter, and upon receiving the instruction manual from the client, I became extremely excited. The meter had everything (on paper at least): time history logging, spectral logging, voice annotation, expandable memory via compact flash or secure digital cards, and (what I considered most important at the time), a flexible touch-screen interface that provides interactivity during measurement operations. It was everything I could have dreamed of. Looking at the screenshots in the manual, I suspected that the 2250 was built on a Windows CE platform. A quick look at the Microsoft license holo- gram in the battery compartment proved my suspicion to be correct. But I was still excited to try out the meter. Well, I used it for a week, and I was none too pleased with it. I believed that we could do better. Something else happened in mid 2007 – Apple released its first iPhone. I didn’t (and still don’t) own an iPhone, but at that time I had played around with it enough to see that the multi-touch, stylus-free touchscreen interface was the future of portable computing. I wanted to use a meter that incorporated these technologies. Around this time I was talking to Andrew Smith, a well-respected sound level meter developer. He developed the Audio Toolbox Plus under the TerreSonde name. While at TerraSonde I emailed him a number of times with technical support questions and he demonstrated a good understanding of the standards process and a willingness to help customers. I was excited to see what he could come up with in using the iPhone (or iPod Touch) as a development platform for acoustic measurement equipment. Andrew Smith’s new company, Smith Studio Six Digital < http://www. studiosixdigital.com >, has introduced two products that puts them well on their way to my Utopian vision: the Audio Tools suite of iOS apps < http://www. studiosixdigital.com/audiotools/ > (and it is a suite, more on that later), and the iAudioInterface < http://www.studiosixdigital.com/iaudiointerface2/ >. The iAudioInterface Modules with iPhones iAudioInterface provides the iPhone/ iPod with a precision microphone analog input. I was able to get my hands on an iAudioInterface and a 3rd generation iPod touch (note that the iAudioInterface will not work with the current 4th generation iPhone/iPod touch or the iPad) and put it through it paces. As an aside, care has to be taken with comparing iPhone units, I was speaking with someone involved in the iPhone supply chains and they mentioned that Apple sources microphones from several different suppliers, so there is a good chance that an audio signal generated from the internal microphone of one batch of iPhones may differ from that of another batch, at least outside of speech frequencies. That said I’ve told clients that an iPhone SLM app may be useful to determine a change in noise levels (say, measuring a generator before and after an enclosure was built, provided that the same iPhone was used for both measurements) but for most other things, you probably want a real SLM (and an experienced user to go with it). The AudioTools app is a $20 basic audio measurement program that can also perform more advanced measurements through additional app modules that are available for $8 to $60 each. The AudioTools app alone gets a recording function, a basic sound meter (basically simulating the Radio Shack analog SLM), a basic one-third octave band meter, and a basic signal generator. Available modules include FFT functions, logging sound meter, SPL ‘traffic light’ (which triggers when a SPL threshold is met), impedance measurement tools, and many more functions. As with the Audio Toolbox hardware, the meter functions are designed to meet ANSI and IEC specifications. The iAudioInterface consists of a breakout box with a dock connector to mate with the iPhone/iPod, an included Studio Six Digital-branded microphone, line input, headphone output (for monitoring) and a mini-USB port for powContinues on page 8 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 7 Smart Device Continued from page 7 ering the iAudioInterface and iPhone/ iPod using a 5-volt power supply. For my purposes, I want to use the iAudioInterface/AudioTools combination for unattended noise-monitoring applications. Since these measurements may have to meet legal scrutiny, the first casualty of the iAudioInterface setup is the microphone – by all accounts the microphone may be suitable for non-critical (and perhaps even critical) acoustical measurement work, but since it does not meet ANSI/IEC specifications, it really cannot use it. Instead, I substituted a precision measurement microphone (BSWA MP201) and ICP power supply connected via the aforementioned line input. Now that I have the iAudioInterface mated with a Type 1 microphone, the obvious question is: how accurate is the data that collect with this combination? To answer this, I decided to deploy the iAudioInterface/AudioTools instrument alongside a calibrated Larson-Davis 820 integrating SLM. I mounted the microphones side-by-side on a microphone stand and let them run in my backyard between 12 to 13 March 2011. Both instruments were calibrated using the same acousti calibrator and were programed to measure A-weighted sound levels and 1-second Leq values. The verdict: data from the two instruments were the same to well within 1 dB. The figure posted above is typical; over this 10 minute period, it’s difficult to distinguish between the two data sets. Comparison of iAudioInterface/AudioTools and Larson-Davis 820 SLM The iAudioInterface plus iPod touch combo sips power – after running the instrument for a weekend, there was barely in reduction in the charge of my 14V/9Ah Li-ion battery. At that rate, I figure the combo could go for a couple of weeks, although I haven’t tested this. Coupled with a 32 GB iPod touch, the instrument can be used for fairly longterm noise monitoring of A-weighted sound levels (as well as WAV file recording). Unfortunately the AudioTools suite doesn’t include a module for octave band logging, but hopefully this will change in the future (I imagine that enough feature requests would convince Andrew to add it.) The only downside I’ve come across is that the noise floor of the iAudioInterface line input is fairly high, such that using a microphone with 25 mV/Pa sensitivity or lower will result in a noise floor around 33 dBA. Applying gain or using a more sensitive microphone helps, at the cost of the microphone power supply using more power. All in all, the Studio Six Digital iAudioInterface along with an iPod touch, AudioTools software, and precision microphone makes an effective long-term noise monitor. I expect that we’ll see features added to the AudioTools suite over time that will make the combination competitive with high-end meters like the B&K 2250 but at a significantly lower cost. BBN Computer History Book Available A revised edition of A Culture of Innovation: Insider Accounts of Computing and Life at BBN A 60-Year Report, is now available on-line for 8 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter downloading. Dave Walden and Ray Nickerson edited the book that features articles by 19 former BBN staff highlighting the development and use of computers at BBN including the foundations of ARPA computer network. To download a copy, please visit: < http://walden-family.com/bbn/bbnprint2.pdf >. Insertion loss field test of a garage door drive unit isolated with two (2) Unibrace L Brackets. Sound levels measured in bedroom above. UniBrace by Kinetics Noise Control Isolation Solutions for Unique Resilient Connections Applications include: Wall mounted TV,s, Projectors, Cabinets, and Hand Rails. Double Walls and Soffits. Garage door motors and more….. Tensile Loading Sheer Loading UniBrace Double F Max Load: 50 lbs (or 25 lbs per side) UniBrace F Max Load: 35 lbs UniBrace Double L Max Load: 50 lbs UniBrace L Max Load: 35 lbs or UniBrace Double L Max Load: 100 lbs or UniBrace L Max Load: 50 lbs www.kineticsnoise.com/unibrace/ sales@kineticsnoise.com 1-800-959-1229 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 9 AIA 2013 National Convention Stephanie Adams-Ball, Vice President Marketing NCAC SAdams@dlaa.com Kenric van Wyk, President Elect NCAC kvanwyk@acousticsbydesign.com O nce again, the National Council of Acoustical Consultants will be exhibiting at the American Institute of Architects (AIA) National Convention. Exhibiting at the Convention is part of a long term marketing strategy to strengthen the relationship between the two organizations, to educate architects about the acoustical consulting profession, and to gather relevant leads of ‘real projects’ to pass on to our member firms. The nation’s architects and design industry meet 20-22 June 2013 in Denver, CO. The AIA has announced that General Colin L. Powell, USA (Ret.), former Secretary of State (2001 – 2005), joins Cameron Sinclair, co-founder and chief eternal optimist of Architects for Humanity, and Blake Mycoskie, founder and chief shoe giver of TOMS, as keynote speakers for the 2013 AIA National Convention. The AIA Convention is architecture’s largest annual gathering to keep current with innovative design solutions and the latest products and services that architects specify for the clients and communities they serve. The 2013 ‘Building Leaders’ theme will give architects and design professionals opportunities to learn, share, and demonstrate the essential qualities that define leaderters, the AIA advocates for public poliship today. cies that promote economic vitality and ‘Architects are more likely leadpublic well-being. Members adhere to ing teams of talented professionals than a code of ethics and conduct to ensure working in the isolated, stereotypical the highest professional standards. The way we see them in popular culture,’ AIA provides members with tools and said AIA Presidentelect, Mickey This is the fourth year that the NCAC has Jacob, FAIA. ‘The Building exhibited at the AIA National Convention, Leaders conand volunteers will be needed in our booth. vention theme is focused on better preparing architects to contribute creative soluresources to assist them in their careers tions with lasting positive impact on the and business as well as engaging civic health and well-being of society. General and government leaders, and the public Powell, Blake Mycoskie, and Cameron to find solutions to pressing issues facing Sinclair will inspire us through their inour communities, institutions, nation and sights and experiences to bring more to world. our roles in business, architecture, and This is the fourth year that the civic life.’ NCAC has exhibited at the AIA Nation In addition to the keynote presentaal Convention, and volunteers will be tions, the AIA National Convention will needed in our booth. If you are willing offer hundreds of education sessions and and able to help out for at least a twotours of Denver architecture relevant to hour slot, please contact Stephanie Adthe way architects practice today. Nearly ams-Ball, Vice-President of Marketing 800 companies will showcase their new NCAC, at sadams@dlaa.com. Volunteers tools, materials, and services that archireceive a free access pass to the exhibit tects can use in all phases of building hall, and are eligible for a reduced rate projects; from concepts to commissionpass to the rest of the AIA Convention. ing. NCAC is always trying to find more Founded in 1857, members of the ways to help serve its members. American Institute of Architects con If there are additional conferences sistently work to create more valuable, or conventions you feel should be conhealthy, secure, and sustainable buildsidered for future NCAC exhibits, please ings, neighborhoods, and communities. advise Jackie Williams (jwilliams@ncac. Through nearly 300 state and local chapcom) at NCAC. Charles P. Boner – University of Texas Physics Department T he following web link provided by Richard Boner contains information on his late father, Charles P. Boner, and the University of Texas Physics Department. Included in the Charles P. Boner tribute is a link to a 1935 recording of Dr. Boner playing ‘Organ Reveries’ on a pipe organ built by physics graduate students, in the Physics Building. 10 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter Among those graduate students were Bob Newman and Laymon Miller. The ‘Organ Reveries’ were a weekly broadcast during the mid-1930s, direct from the Physics Building to the local radio station. For additional information visit < http://www.ph.utexas.edu/utphysicshistory/UTexas_Physics_History/ Charles_P._Boner.html >. Editor’s Note: Thanks to Richard Boner for providing the following web link. There are many NCAC members who learned directly under Dr. Boner, for whom NCAC’s C. Paul Boner Medal is named, or read his papers in the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America or the Audio Engineering Society Journal. TUNE INTO ZERO’s SOUND SOLUTIONS ZERO is a world-wide leader in high-performance acoustical control for doors, windows and walls. Nobody does sound control better — we use advanced technology and testing to master the challenges of creating an effective barrier and preventing gaps in that barrier for the life of the assembly. Our systems are rated for use in sound studios and recording facilities, music halls, etc — up to 55 STC. Let us help you close the door on noise — contact us for a copy of our 20 page Sound Control brochure, and our 92 page Product Catalog, or download from our website. on Sound Transmissi Loss (TL) W HA T DOES ...P RACTICA L I T M EA N A PPLICA T O TION Y OU ? S is called its sound to reduce noise ven under standing valueagibasic a With A door's ability veness. TL is loss (TL) effecti sound of acoustical barrier s and transmission by measuring is determined sourc eyou can their ratings, in the in decibels, which ain frequency at a gi ven cert s in the now return to Figure 1 also factor pressure levels The calculation with a and adjusts to begin assessing your recei ving rooms. rooms, comes in contact and two the sound by When n shared of the as problem and (known "sound a door , some area of the partitio acoustic "li veness barrier , such as rs to the room's n transfe ving ns whatbetwee you need to solve vibratio for the recei d dif ference energy from the ns in time"). The adjuste it. TheTL, difthe ference resulting vibratio "reverberation . The higher the the door . The in TL of the door between the sound level you want to then set the air two levels is the the door itself the door— . achieve and the unwanted noise you need to block other side of better the result motion on the ns. simple a vibratio is the required STC rating of your door opening. For using sound illustrate creating more at need to block 90 dB-level sound from adjustments to example, if you is 100 dB Leaving out the measurement of source room dB at factory in order to maintain normal a noisisy,60 adjacent g and stif fness example, if the measurement The mass, dampin ce to recei ving room office Hz.sound levels of around 50 dB, you will need a ine its resistan 300 Hz and the is 40 dB at 300 the barrier determ waves. The sound door assembly with a 40 STC rating. Increasing the TL of the barrier Hz, sound of 300 e the passag is to ASTM that to 50E90 STC will pro vide sound levels suitable ngrating , the less sound accordi greater the mass of in test laboratories ement the barrier . Mass for a pri vate office. Very high ratings are typically TL is measured tory Measur transmit ted through Method for Labora itions."soundproof rooms for recording needed Part to create tant for bloc king "Standard Test Loss of Building without sound core is especially impor Transmission studios—and to isolate performance halls from frequencies. Airborne Sound sound at lower exterior noise. Relati vely lower ratings will usually g materials , d using dampin reduce ) be l suff(STC ice for less demanding applications, such as ns can Damping materia Sound vibratio mission Classsolving aa range ss materials. Trans of noise problem in an apartment building limp-ma d y Soun typicall which are taken across material in for a door are or a doctor's office. used as core TL measurements to compare the is sometimes the highes t mak es it dif ficult sion class d to pro vide frequencies, which door s designe s. Sound tr ansmis In addition to value sound ratings, it may be necessary of dif ferent door control. effecti veness by gi ving a single levels of sound by that problem to consider other criteria for the door inedperformance determ ratings solve is STC (STC) . for a door assembly . Durability is also performance frequencies ,is a special concern for door s of the barrier to acoustical The stif fness taken over 16 e of TL values installed inby schools and other high-traf fic, high-abus e transmission. the ASTM a weighted averag a factor in sound method defined s transmit on.ratings are required for door s in to a curve in a locations. Insulati And fire flexible barrier which are fitt ed Although more Rating Sound s Standard for the stairwells and other codefire-rated partitions, practical reason the rating—and E413 Classification less sound, for made better lly the STC value, designated locations. door s are genera The higher the in Figure 2. sound-control Unles s ance, as shown stif f materials. better the perform from very dense, g layer s of dampin SS they contain inner ly MISSION CLA sound will inevitab SOUND TRANS material, some . On the (STC) TA BLE through the door ls be transmit ted DESCRIPTION dense, stif f materia RMANEC those PERFO hand, STC other heard back Loud sounds at reflecting sound Excellent not at all. or also work well s -60 faintly 50 door with sound core Most acoustical faintly to its source. with Loud speech heard of w ood or steel Very Good 40 - 50 are constructed to any but not unde rstood. but barrier batts added stif fness and Loud speech heard . Good le . inside the door hardly intelligib 35 - 40 hollow cavity rstood door s varies Loud speech unde of sound-control Fair vari y well. 35 effecti veness man fairly 30 the so , ly Natural of materials. With unde rstood will combinations Normal speech a particular door with dif ferent well . Poor how distinctly of easily and 25 - 30 we determine effecti veness ables, how can . we compare the And how can Low speech audible block sound? Very Poor 20 - 25 s? Figur e 2 dif ferent door T HE M S OUND OF ECHANICS T R ANSMISSION Figur e 3 STC 45 Door Source Room db SPL Level=100 Receiving Room db SPL Level=55 performance the#770 used to define n in sound STC values are a specified reductio for achieving ving room. requirements room to a recei from a source ines how transmission door also determ of an installed sourc e The STC rating between a gi ven n is possible reductio noise 3) much Figure ving room. (See room and recei Sound Trap fo r Double Door s E XPER T H EL P F ROM ...W IT H A P ROMISE Z ERO SOUND TRAP-52 SEALING SY STEM PRODUCT CODE STC 2 Once you have completed a preliminary assessment, specialists in ZERO’s Engineering Department can help clarify your needs— and then identify your options for achieving the desired level of sound control for your door opening. ZERO offers dozens of specializ ed acoustical seals configured in various SOUND TRAP gasketing systems designed to achieve optimum ratings for specific door s and assemblies. All SOUND TRAP systems are tested and rated with operable door s. Installed with hinges and seals in a test assembly , the door is opened and closed a number of times before measurements are taken. The results therefore represent the STC rating for the opening–not the wa ll partition in whic h the door wa s tested . Trapped Air Solid Neoprene #119W .914" (23.2) .500" (12.7) 1.250" 950 Cam Hinge (38.1) SMS #770 Head & Jamb Seal Stainless Steel Adjusting Screw 12.00" O.C. Range: .310"(7.9) SLIMPORT sound rated window (optional) Headand Jamb Seal Meeting Stile Astragal Sadde l AutomaticDoor Hinge Bottom SOUND TRA P Product Cod e JD6S #367 #950 #564 .916" (23.3) magnet 1.90" (48.3) 950 Cam Hinge steel plate #367 Automatic Door Bottom Surface Mounted Double Neoprene Seal .500" (12.7) —6— #119W #564 #910DB #770 SLIMPO sound rated RT window (optional) SOUNDTRAP Model 770 -P AIRS #362 #362 362 #564 For a simila r configuratio you need Model #383 n with suitable wood astrag als #383 pr ov door s, for ides three sets of seals the meeting stile . neoprene bulb to bloc k soun primary seal with extra “lip” of d: the neoprene at the meet in neoprene “finger” for ing edge, plus anoth the er added soun against the d cushioning acti ve door . - PA I RS SY STEM #8 x .750" #383 .387" (19.1) FHSM Solid Neopre ne (9.8) .307" 1.625" (41.2) 1.271 " (32.3) .531" Magnet Vinyl 52 STC Rated (13.5) (7.8) .062" (1.6) #40 Magnetic Astragal Door Solid Neoprene #362 Automatic Door Bottom #770 Head & Jam b Seal Neoprene Trapped Air #770 #770 40 910DB STCRating #40 #910DB 564 #910DB Hinge 55 STC Rated Door However , that model only works with frames that have no stop. In addition, if your door has a low sound rating—or is not rated at all—it will not be possible to achieve the full benefit of the #770. In those circumstances, we recommend other models . Pair s of door s pose addit ional ch alleng control beca use there es for soun are more d need for addit openings ional corne to seal. The r s and a meet there will alw ays be ing stile mean relati vely through pair s more soun assemblies d leakage than with SOUND TRAP single door -PAIRS syste s. ZERO’s an STC rating m for meta l door s achie of 42—suffici ves office conv ent to pr ov er sations—w ide pri vacy ith an optim for that balan ces those al configuratio limitations n effecti ve techn with appro ology . priate, cost - 41 System tested with STC 52 acoustical The Product door (rated Code for orderi as a panel ng the SOUN ). D TRAP-Pairs system is JD6S. #950 #770 #119W The component that primarily distinguishes between the two systems is the gasket that seals the head and jamb of the door . Our Model #770 adjustable jamb-applied gasket , whic h has achieved an excellent track record in a wide range of applications, is recommended for ensuring the highest possible rating for most purposes. The adjustable design of the #770 allows you to maintain that high level of sound control for the long term. When clearances increas e from the inevitable shif ting and settling of buildings and door s over time, all it takes to restore a sound-tight seal is a few turns of a Phillips screwdri ver. The year s of experience and advanced technology reflected in our SOUND TRAP systems allow ZERO to set the standard for acoustical gasketing. In practical terms, that means we are able to guarantee performance within two STC points of the published rating of your door using our integrated gasketing systems. (31.8) #8 x 1.50" To simplify our discussion, we will focus on two SOUND TRAP systems that together can satisfy a wide range of common commercial and industrial sound-control needs for single door s. The STC ratings of our SOUND TRAP -52 and SOUND TRAP -4 9 systems are built into their names. —3— Level SPL-Sound Pressure STC Neoprene 1.250" (31.8) .914" — 10 — Stainless Steel (23.2) Adjusting Screw —8— T HE N OISE P ROBLE De f ining Your Noise Pr oblem: The Fir st Step to Solving It M To define your specific problem, you need a basic unde rstanding of how to quantify both your unw anted noise and the sound level that will be acceptable. The difference between those two values is the degree of sound control you need to achieve with your door opening. That unde rstandin g requires a brief overview of the science of sound and its measurement . for lly bad it's especia and e—and s hearing everyon rs e hur ts re impair g employe Loud nois d exposu exposin l-being, s. Continue levels, busines tional wel ti vely low ines emo loyee n at rela underm on emp n lities. Eve drai liabi a costly to potential can be d noise ante y. unw ucti vit from and prod isolation morale demand cer t halls nature ld. Con by their iences ide wor inesses the outs nt for aud Some bus nds of enchantme world of si ve sou it their the intru ld forfe external with ter s wou r s of the function and thea y reminde studios cannot nois to ide. d ng the outs subjecte Recordi street. sions from and y intru lobb nd iscule sou kspaces even min mon wor shield com ns of need to distractio ities the t facil Other es from HVAC plan e employe from the and offic nating rooms. noise ema resident equipment r heavy mercial and othe s of com d all type es equippe Virt ually need offic n. And the buildings ver satio con tiality is for pri vate olute confiden abs anding need for ct of exp byprodu ns . a modern operatio security national We begin with a few impo rtant definitions : Soun d is vibrations in air moving in waves. The rate of sound pulsations measured in cycles per second is called frequenc y —also known as hertz (Hz). The range of human hearing is considered to be 20 to 20,000 Hz. FREQUEN CY DI STRUBUTION CHART re ities whe for all facil s to hospital problem es and inherent don ’t rs' offic n is an ings we m docto s con ver satio tant–fro me in sett audible disruption is impor unw elco In fact, e, of noisy ication be equally impact er to hom commun s. Clos Noise can pri vate sider the routine center s. s. ” Con at churche n ines ling eve , tions counse with “bus popular on the other func oming associate n you're ices and are bec usually ty of serv . And whe d with systems tranquili equippe pleasure e theater on the listening s are not rated hom with room if integ interfere where of irritation noise can door s. ses a lot household icating often cau s and l noise or commun problem road, hote entrance and/ of noise nce of less list ated The scie the end sound-r gories. sound tions to basic cate onding The solu into two ed corresp es fall yielded is determin challeng s—has lication ustic aco Their app : sound— niques. e problem ment tech particular nois age d man re of the ov ing soun by the natu ess of rem , that is is the proc Typically osed Abso rp tion within a room. erials exp mat us from poro energ y g soft , ished usin accompl through up sound. of sound to soak through vement the mo of sound sion i s transfer es and Tr ansmis Preventing the clearanc r tise . through ed expe ifically a medium specializ s—spec ning ires the ope pages. door r s—requ following nd doo d in the usse gaps arou disc niques and tech —1— Figure 1 Soun d pressure levels are measured in decibel s— or dB.The scale of measurement used to simulate sound across the audible frequency range is denoted as dBA . Figure 1 illustrates the impact of dramatic changes in dB levels. It is also impo rtant to note that the human ear perceives changes in loudness caused by even small changes in those levels. Each 10 dB increase doubles the sound reception—and the annoyance or discomfo rt that goes with it. Federal (OSHA) cod e prohibits exposur e to noise lev el s whi ch excee d these limits : Duration Hour s Per Day 8 6 4 3 2 1-1/ 2 1 1/ 2 1/4 or less Sound Level in dBA 90 92 95 97 100 102 105 110 115 To go from definitions to practical applications, we first need to unde rstand how sound is transmi tted from its source through a barrier. Next we will explain how a barrier is rated for its ability to inhibit or blo ck sound . That gives us the ability to compare different barriers. With that information, we can examine the role of gasketing systems in optimizing the performance of doo rs that function as sound barriers. —2— Phone: 1-800-635-5335 / 718-585-3230 • Fax: 718-292-2243 Email: zero@zerointernational.com • Web Site: www.zerointernational.com Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 11 Arup Integrates Artec Consultants, Inc. Into its Global Practice 13 Acoustics, Audiovisual and Theatre Consultants Join Arup A rup and Artec Consultants, Inc. have announced the integration of their acoustics, audio/visual, and theater consulting practices. The merger of two of the world’s premier practices specializing in the planning, design, and engineering, of venues for performing arts, contemporary entertainment, education, conference, convention, sports, and worship was announced at the end of March, 2013. ‘Our expanded team offers clients around the world unrivaled knowledge, experience, skills, and cutting-edge tools to plan and design innovative venues for the 21st century,’ said Principal Raj Pa- tel, Americas Arts and Culture Business Leader for Arup. ‘Joining forces with Arup enhances our collective ability to provide highly specialist skills anywhere in the world, through the resources of a large, global organization, serving projects of any scale, with the best international design thinking, delivered to clients locally from start to finish,’ said Tateo Nakajima, former Partner at Artec and now a Principal at Arup. Arup has integrated former Artec staff, comprising 13 acoustics audio/ visual, and theater consultants, into the New York Acoustics, Audio Visual and Theatre Consulting team led by Arup’s Raj Patel. Tateo Nakajima, Ed Arenius, Todd Brooks, Christopher Darland, and Tom Clark join the leadership team at Arup in this move. They will work closely with Arup’s regional leaders, Andrew Nicol (Australasia), Sam Tsoi (East Asia), Rachid Abu-Hassan (Europe), and Rob Harris (UK, Middle East, and Africa). This enhanced team strengthens Arup’s ability to provide clients and their projects whole life relationships. From cultural master planning, project inception and concept development, through design, construction, and post-opening. The holistic service supports owners, operators, and users in delivering performances to their audiences. Augment sound reflections and diffusion in music and listening spaces with suspended bent-wood acoustic reflectors. Custom, beautifully-crafted reflectors in spherical or cylindrical shapes, with sizes, radii, and finishes per your specifications. www.nwwr.com • tbooth@pacinfo.com • 541.228.0196 12 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter ENHANCE THE ACOUSTICS AND AESTHETICS OF ANY VENUE DIVA® ACOUSTICAL SHELL Wenger offers a full line of acoustical shells to fit every performance space. Whether you have a small auditorium, gymnasium or performing arts center, Wenger has the acoustical treatment for you. The Diva Acoustical Shell is, without a doubt, the most advanced full stage acoustical shell of its kind... visually stunning and audibly superior for your full auditorium needs. Wenger's newest acoustical solution is the Forte Acoustical Shell, which enhances acoustics for both the ensemble and audience in small-to-medium sized performance spaces. The Legacy Acoustical Shell combines portability and ease of set up with acoustical projection in a variety of venues. Contact your Wenger representative today to design the right shell set for your space. DIVA® ACOUSTICAL SHELL WENGER FORTE™ SHELL WENGER LEGACY® SHELL 1 . 5 0 7 . 4 5 5 . 4 1 0 0 • w w w.we n g e r c o r p.c o m 800-4WENGER (493-6437) • wengercor p.com/theatre Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 13 Technical Feature Sound Transmission Between Rooms with Common Plenum: Better Prediction of Field Results from Laboratory Data Noral D. Stewart, Ph.D. Stewart Acoustical Consultants noral@sacnc.com W hen faced with predicting the noise reduction (NR) between two rooms where sound is traveling primarily through a partition, calculations can performed – assuming no sound flanking – if we have the partition transmission loss (TL), the size of the partition, and the receiving space absorption. The derivable theoretical relationship between the TL and NR and these two other factors is amazingly simple. However, the situation becomes much more complex if sound is traveling through a common ceiling plenum over a partition separating the two rooms. Richard Hamme pioneered the measurement method that evolved into ASTM E1414, Standard Test Method for Airborne Sound Attenuation Between Rooms Sharing a Common Ceiling Plenum, and published the first results in the January 1959 issue of the Acoustical Society of America publication, Noise Control. Thomas Mariner of Armstrong identified the many variables that influence the noise reduction between spaces, developed a theoretical relationship and published his findings in the November 1959 issue of the same journal. These papers are available through the ASA website. The variables identified by Mariner are illustrated in Figure 1. Figure 1. Variables for Calculating Ceiling Plenum Noise Reduction The ASTM E1414 test is specifically for 25 ft, B rooms where L + M 15.25 ft, h 2.5 ft, γ > 0.65 at 125 Hz and > 0.8 at higher frequencies, δ < 0.10, and the absorption in the source and receiving room is very small except for that due to the ceiling. The variables β, τ, and A are determined by the properties of the ceiling under the test. Steps are taken to assure no significant sound transmission except through the ceiling 14 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter Figure 1. plenum path. The ASTM test is performed either with the ceiling continuous over the top of the separating partition, or with that partition extending through the ceiling not more than 2 inches above the bottom edge of the ceiling. There is nothing in the standard concerning sealing the partition and ceiling and this may be different than in the field. Otherwise except for the effective transmissivity of the ceiling (including grid leakage) and absorption of the top surface of the ceiling, the standard fixes the variables, or in the case of the absorption of the bottom surface of the ceiling, normalizes it from the result. However, in the field, many of the variables that are fixed in the laboratory will vary, the absorption of the ceiling panel top may be modified, and the absorption of the ceiling will add to the total absorption in the receiving room, all influencing the results. Mariner assumed no transmission through the partition between rooms and no leakage between the ceiling and partition. He realized absorption and transmissivity varied with angle and that grazing values were appropriate in some cases, but assumed use of random incidence values. He did not examine any difference between a continuous ceiling and one interrupted by a penetration by the partition. He did examine the effect of all the other variables, but unfortunately his results were too complex for easy use in those pre-computer days and were not carried through to a form easily relatable to the data available from the modern ASTM test. In a paper I presented at the ASA meeting in Cancun, Mexico in 2010, I started from the work of Mariner and the conditions defined in the ASTM standard, found a simplified approximation for the effect of absorption of the top of the ceiling panel on the laboratory reported result, and came up with a relationship that can be programmed in a spreadsheet that relates the noise reduction in the field to the result reported by ASTM E1414 and the variables illustrated in Figure 1. The slides from that presentation with the equations are available on the ASA website at the following link: < http://scitation.aip.org/ confst/ASA/data/13/4pAAa3.pdf >. The calculations do require estimating or having data for the absorption of the surfaces in the plenum including the top of the ceiling panels, the plenum walls, and the upper surface of the plenum. The results include the effect of the absorption added to the receiving Continues on page 15 Technical Feature Continued from page 14 room by the ceiling that is factored out in the result reported by the ASTM standard test. The overall equation presented in the slides can be simplified under certain conditions, if for instance the plenum is very large laterally compared to the rooms of concern, or if the plenum is not more than 2.5 ft high and highly absorptive. Using the derived relationship, I examined the effect of some of the variables involved on the noise reduction. In theory making either the top surface of the ceiling or the upper plenum surface highly absorptive improves the noise reduction by about 5 dB for a 2.5 ft plenum depth. Making both highly absorptive in theory gives a 10 dB improvement. The noise reduction increases as the depth of the plenum (between ceiling and deck above) is increased, except that if the plenum space is highly absorptive (already giving better noise reduction) the improvement for depths greater than 2.5 ft is very small. In the ASTM test, the wall surfaces of the plenum are highly absorptive, simulating an infinite plenum. If the adjacent rooms are somewhat similar in size to the rooms used for the laboratory tests, and the plenum is the same size with non-absorptive plenum walls, the noise reduction in theory is about 6 dB less than would be achieved with absorptive plenum wall surfaces or with a laterally infinite e maintains its shape atplenum. all 90º Consider that everything in this llation ofstudy extra reinforcement. is theoretical, based on diffuse ct increases efficiency, roomsystem theory and assumed average levels rooms.All Results may be different reasing over profits. products very close to the dividing partition the best in our industry. between rooms. A good collection of field data with known conditions, or possibly laboratory tests with the plenum conditions modified, would be helpful to verify the theory. A few conclusions and cautions are in order: Available E1414 laboratory data on ceiling attenuation between rooms is good for the conditions under which it is measured and the assumptions in the definition of the reported result which include normalization to a fixed room absorption eliminating effects due to variation of absorption among ceiling panels. However, in the field the absorption added to a space by the ceiling and the varying geometry and plenum conditions will influence the observed noise reduction between spaces. It is possible in theory to estimate the noise reduction between two adjacent rooms via the ceiling path with reasonable accuracy. However, this path is considerably more complex than the 6M R6 8" Diameter simple case where the primary path is through the common partition between rooms without significant flanking paths. Experimental data would be desirable to verify the theory. The theory is based on diffuse room theory and average transmitted levels over the receiver room. Results may be poorer in some circumstances near the partition between the adjacent rooms. Experiments should investigate such variations. dB A 2 3 4 B ands 5 34.0 20.3 28.6 32.7 34.8 6 7 8 35.4 33.3 29.4 Six (6) Fo o t Sample 500 FP M with a 90°bend FLEXMASTER U.S.A. MECHANICAL LOCK FLEX Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 15 Scott Pfeiffer Named ASA Fellow and Vern Knudsen Distinguished Lecturer Lily Wang, Ph.D. lwang@central-acoustics.com Associate Professor, Architectural Engineering Program Coordinator, University of Nebraska, Lincoln S cott Pfeiffer was recently named a Fellow of the Acoustical Society of America (ASA) at the Society’s last conference in Kansas City in October 2012, ‘for excellence in the acoustical design of performing arts facilities’. Scott has established a successful career in the field of architectural acoustics. He received a Bachelor’s of Science degree in Physics with honors in Music from Moravian College in Bethlehem, PA. He subsequently studied at the Technical University of Denmark in the Acoustic Technology group. Upon returning to the US, he joined Kirkegaard Associates where he worked for 13 years, becoming a Senior Consultant and Director of Personnel. In 2006, he founded Threshold Acoustics with partner Carl Giegold. Dawn Schuette joined as Partner a year later and in addition to the three partners, has 13 employees. Over his 20+ year career, Scott has had a hand in over 100+ major building projects, including many performing arts facilities around the world. These include the Silva Concert Hall (Eugene, OR); the Holland Performing Arts Center (Omaha, NE); the Alaska Center for the Performing Arts (Anchorage, AL); and many others. Scott has been an active member of the ASA. He is involved with the Technical Committee on Architectural Acoustics (TCAA), having been a session chair and presenter of 11 papers in TCAA sessions at ASA conferences. He has furthermore served as General Chair of the Fall 2001 ASA conference in Chicago, and as president of the Chicago regional chapter of the ASA. He also brings architectural acoustics into related professional societies, by participating and presenting at conferences of the Audio Engineering Society, the League of Historic American Theaters, and the United States Institute of Theater Technology. What particularly distinguishes Scott in my mind from other acoustical consultants, though, is his willingness to take risks in design, risks that can push the boundaries of our field – not by advising the design team to do what has worked many times before, but working with them to try something different, based on measurements and scientific study as allowable in the consulting world. In his position at Kirkegaard, he was responsible for their scale modeling test facility and for a large number of measurements made at assorted performing arts facilities around the world. He is an artist grounded in science. At the Fall 2012 meeting of the ASA in Kansas City, Scott was invited to present the prestigious Vern O. Knudsen Lecture in Architectural Acoustics, entitled: ‘The consultant’s risk is an invitation to academia – An exploration of the greatest successes in a design career thus far, and the research-based foundations that made them possible.’ He presented his philosophy on engaging science in design, challenging the acoustical consulting industry to engage with academia more to push the bounds of science in architectural acoustics. In this, as in many other areas, Scott Pfeiffer is a strong role model for architectural acousticians to follow. Editor’s Note: The membership of NCAC congratulates Scott on his wellearned ASA Fellowship. [NTS] Bob Coffeen Elected to SCN Hall of Fame B ob Coffeen was elected to the Sound and Communications News magazine 2nd annual 2013 Hall of Fame ‘Honoring Those Who Define the A/V Industry.’ The announcement was made in the January 2012 issue. The article highlighted Bob’s contributions to acoustics education in both professional trade associations and at Kansas University. Six individuals ranging from software developers, consultants, manufacturer’s representatives, and contractors were the 2013 recipients. 16 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter Chuck Wilson of the National Systems Contractor’s Association (NSCA) stated that Bob ‘is an educator throughand-through’. Currently, Bob is Professor at the Kansas University School of Architecture and Design and a former coordinator for Acoustical Society of America’s Student Design Competitions. Known for his work in large spaces such as stadia, convention centers, and airports, he was cited for early work at Burns and McDonnell Engineering Company and forming his consulting company that eventually became Coffeen Fricke and Associates. Bob was awarded the National Systems Contractor Association Educator of the Year three times and in 2011 received the Acoustical Society of America Rossing Prize in Acoustics Education. The full article in Sound and Communications News can be viewed at: < http://www.avnetwork.com/people/0008/ scns-hall-of-fame-bob-coffeen/90186 >. Editor’s Note: NCAC congratulates Bob for his recognition and contributions to acoustical consulting and education. [NTS] • Shipped completed and ready to install • Tested in Accordance with ASTM E-90 • Engineered for windloads to 60 PSF • Half the cost of concrete and steel • STC comparable to concrete • Gravel posts backfill • Preservative treated • Custom engineered Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 17 IEEE Honors Leo Beranek, Irwin Jacobs and Barry Schoop I nternational Electronic and Electrical Engineers (IEEE) has announced its 2013 IEEE Medal recipients, the highest awards bestowed by IEEE. The IEEE Foundation is proud to sponsor and present two of the medals and one service award. IEEE Life Fellow Leo Beranek, Founder (Retired), Bolt, Beranek, and Newman, Boston, MA, will receive the IEEE Founders Medal, for outstanding contributions in the leadership, planning, and administration of affairs of great value to the electrical and electronics engineering profession, sponsored by the IEEE Foundation, “For leadership as a co-founder of a premier consulting firm that shaped modern acoustical practice and laid the groundwork for the Internet, and for public service.” IEEE Life Fellow Irwin M. Jacobs, co-founder of Qualcomm, Inc., Inc., La Jolla, CA, will receive the 2013 IEEE Medal of Honor, IEEE’s highest award, which is sponsored by IEEE Foundation. Jacobs is being honored for leadership and fundamental contributions to digital communications and wireless technology. He oversaw Qualcomm’s revolutionary innovations in Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA), a technology fundamental to today’s 3G mobile wireless standards. IEEE Fellow Barry L. Shoop, Professor and Department Head, Electrical Engineering & Computer Science, United States Military Academy, West Point, NY, will receive the IEEE Haraden Pratt Award, for outstanding service to IEEE, sponsored by the IEEE Foundation, “For vision and leadership in improving IEEE operations and governance, and for building a Custom Designed Special Purpose DooRS AND WINDoWS STC-56 Music Hall Windows 14 ft x 4 ft STC-50 Room Divider Doors 22 ft x 14 ft Krieger’s radio frequency doors use a unique seal similar to robust weather stripping, eliminating the need of a knifed edge seal, resulting in less wear and increased door life. The doors meets the IEEE 229 standard and are ADA threshold compliant. See what’s possible. Request a free Door and Window Idea Catalog at: www.KriegerProducts.com/NCAC 18 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter stronger foundation for IEEE’s strategic future.” Since 1917, the IEEE Awards Program has paid tribute to technical professionals whose exceptional achievements and outstanding contributions have made a lasting impact on technology, society, the engineering profession, and humanity. Recipients of IEEE-level awards are recognized as the most influential members in their chosen field. They are revered for their resolve to discover, extend, or complement technological advancements in education, industry, research, and service. Each year, new recipients join the prestigious IEEE Award honoree list through a selective peer nomination and approval process. For additional information please see: < https://www.ieee.org/organizations/ foundation/2012news.html >. Your Source for all Your Sound and Vibration Instrumentation Sales/Calibration/Rental Brands you Know DELTA Tools you Need Calibrators Sound Sources Vibration Meters Impedance Tubes Tapping Machines Prediction Software Construction Noise Monitoring Intensity Systems Acoustic Camera Calibration Systems Sound Level Meters Multi-Channel Systems Reporting & Analysis Software Microphones & Accelerometers Calibrations you Trust Distributed by: Scantek, Inc. www.Scantekinc.com 410.290.7726 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 19 Save The Date For The 2013 NCAC Annual Meeting 23-25 August 2013 Denver, Colorado Preliminary Schedule Accommodations Brown Palace Hotel Rate: $189/night plus tax Deadline: July 24, 2013 Reservations: 800-321-2599 Friday, August 23 3:00 – 3:45 p.m. Registration 4:00 p.m. Courthouse Tour & Reception to Follow The Brown Palace Hotel has long stood as the pride of luxury hotels in Denver, CO – embraced by the city as its own and regarded as a national treasure. For more than a century the hotel has stood as an anchor to the bustling financial and cultural district, playing host to presidents, prime ministers, and celebrities. Saturday, August 24 9:30 a.m. – 12:30 p.m.Exhibits 12:30 – 1:30 p.m. Lunch 1:30 – 4:30 p.m. Seminar 5:30 – 9:00 p.m. Reception & Dinner Manufacturer Exhibits NCAC Exhibitor Registration is open – for more information visit Sunday, August 25 10:30 a.m. – 12:00 p.m. Seminar 12:00 – 2:00 p.m. Lunch & NCAC Annual Membership Meeting < http://www.ncac.com/ncaceventspage.php > or email info@ncac.com Registration will open in late Spring. TM AqFlex : Revolutionary on/off absorption system • Lowers RT (63 - 1000 Hz) by up to 45% at the push of a button • αon = app. 0.5 (63 - 1000 Hz) in entire ceiling area. α off = app. 0.0 • For use in music education institutions , performing arts centres, etc • Complies with the ASTM E 84, NFPA 701 and B,s1- d0 standards OFF ON • Detailed information: www. flexac. com • Strategic support: www. USA. UM. dk Any kind of acoustics at any time 20 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter • Patents: EP 1 779 375 B1, JP 2008 510408, US 7905323 etc. Gold Bond® BraND SoundBreak® XP® Gypsum Board How can he sleep so peacefully when the volume is cranked up next door? SoundBreak XP Gypsum Board. This innovative gypsum board allows for construction of high STC wall partitions that are thinner, lower cost and more reliable than traditional methods for constructing these types of assemblies. SoundBreak XP is the sound solution for high-rise condos, townhouses, home theaters, hotels and other places that are clamoring for quiet. THE SOUND SOLUTION Technical Info: 1-800-NATIONAL or visit soundbreakxp.info Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 21 New Staff at Cavanaugh Tocci Associates C avanaugh Tocci Associates (CTA) is pleased to announce two new staff members: Chris Bajdek and Liz Lamour. Chris will work primarily in environmental noise and Liz will spend most of her time on audio/visual systems design. (BSME), and has worked at ESS Group in Waltham, MA and Harris Miller Miller & Hanson in Burlington, MA. Outside the office, he enjoys playing soccer and serves on the Conservation Commission and the Community Preservation Committee in the Town of Holliston, where he resides with his wife and three children. CTA President, Greg Tocci, said ‘Chris will help us serve clients better with more efficient computer modeling of noise sources, and develop new business in the growing area of wind turbine construction. We have seen an increasing demand for environmental noise analysis due to the population density in the Northeast and increased public awareness of noise issues.’ Chris Bajdek Chris Bajdek brings 20 years of experience in environmental noise analysis to enhance CTA’s capabilities in this growing area. As a senior consultant, he will use his extensive experience with prediction and analysis of noise from wind turbines, traffic, rail, and aircraft to provide clients with accurate analysis and recommendations. Chris is currently working on noise studies for the permitting of transfer facilities for FedEx Ground and supporting CTA’s efforts on two proposed wind energy facilities in northern New England. Chris graduated magna cum laude from Northeastern University ate studies, Liz attended Berklee College of Music in Boston and graduated magna cum laude with a dual-major Bachelor of Music degree in Music Production & Engineering and Professional Music. Her studies encompassed a wide range of topics, including: architectural acoustics, mechanical noise, electro-acoustics, audio engineering, and signal processing. Liz was an intern at CTA in the summer of 2011 and now joins us full time in the Audiovisual Systems Group. She is currently working on designs for Middlebury College Fieldhouse and Amherst College Science Center. In her spare time Liz likes spending time outdoors hiking and exploring New England, and playing music with friends. Matt Moore, Principal of the Audio/ Visual Systems Group stated, ‘Liz will provide much-needed assistance with the demand for high-performance audio/ visual systems in all of our projects. This is true especially with our university and corporate projects that have shown strong growth in the past two years. She also provides valuable 3-D modeling experience to our group.’ Liz Lamour Liz Lamour is a recent graduate of the architectural acoustics program at the University of Kansas with a Master of Arts in Architecture. For her undergradu- NCAC Thanks Our Sponsors Platinum Level Sponsor Gold Level Sponsor Silver Level Sponsors Evonik Foams, Inc. Flexmaster USA, Inc. 22 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 2012 Index of Newsletter Articles Winter 2012 President’s Winter Message.............................................................................................................................................................................................................. Page 1 From the Editor..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 2 Acoustic Tidbits..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 3 Hospital Alarm Fatigue Statement of Interest........................................................................................................................................................................... Page 4 Clinical Alarms & Fatalities Resulting From ‘Alarm Fatigue’ In Hospitals........................................................................................................................... Page 8 Greater Boston Chapter ASA Meeting.......................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 12 Tributes to Colleagues: Kenneth Mckechnie Eldred 1929 – 2012, Robert A. Schmidt 1952 – 2012, Jason ‘Tic’ Weissenburger, D.Sc., P.E. 1932 – 2011......................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 14 Lucky Tsaih Rejoins Acoustical Design Collaborative, Ltd..................................................................................................................................................... Page 14 New OSHA Guide Available.............................................................................................................................................................................................................. Page 15 New Member Profile Soundscape Engineering........................................................................................................................................................................ Page 18 What Do You Get When You Say ‘Regupol’?................................................................................................................................................................................ Page 18 Manufacturer’s Corner Olive Tree Lab........................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 20 Safe Sounds Conference.................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 29 Spring 2012 President’s Summer Message.......................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 1 From the Editor..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 2 NCAC 50th Anniversary Meeting.................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 4 Book Review, Journey to Greatness – The Story of Brüel & Kjær......................................................................................................................................... Page 11 Lang and Maling Elected NCAC Honorary Members.............................................................................................................................................................. Page 13 Individual Members: What We Get for the Price of One Grande Latte a Month!........................................................................................................... Page 16 Manufacturer’s Corner Eggers Ecoustic Plywood Panels....................................................................................................................................................... Page 18 Lowest Sung Note................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ Page 18 New On/Off Broadband Absorption Product............................................................................................................................................................................ Page 19 NCAC New Website.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................. Page 21 U.S. GSA Issues Sound Matters Publication................................................................................................................................................................................ Page 21 Leo L. Beranek Receives Honorary Membership in the Acoustical Society of China................................................................................................... Page 22 Paoletti’s Back........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ Page 24 Acoustic Tidbits..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 26 Web Sitings............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. Page 27 Summer 2012 President’s Summer Message.......................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 1 From the Editor..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 2 The Kauffman Center for the Performing Arts........................................................................................................................................................................... Page 6 NCAC Announces 2012 – 2014 Officers And Directors........................................................................................................................................................... Page 8 Book Review Site and Sound Victoria Newhouse..................................................................................................................................................................... Page 8 Architectural Testing Acoustical Testing Expansion................................................................................................................................................................ Page 10 NCAC Board of Directors Profile Richard Riedel, Director-at-Large.................................................................................................................................... Page 11 Thanks and Congratulations to . . . . . GenRad, Leo Beranek, Arnold Peterson, Jack Mowry, S&V, B&K, Neil Shade, and NCAC............... Page 12 NCAC Board of Directors Profile Richard Schrag, Director-at-Large.................................................................................................................................. Page 13 Technical Feature Article Collaboration Composes Success: Music Practice Room Installations........................................................................... Page 16 Economic Downturn Cut Architecture Firm Revenue by 40 Percent, Employment by Almost a Third................................................................. Page 22 Manufacturer’s Corner Scantek, Inc............................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 24 Construction Economy Outlook: Recovery Has Begun and Will Extend into 2014...................................................................................................... Page 26 Web Sitings............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. Page 27 Fall 2012 President’s Fall Message..................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 1 From the Editor..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 2 Mentoring...Guidelines for a professional Life........................................................................................................................................................................... Page 4 Acoustic Tid-Bits.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 7 NCAC Firm Profile Sonic-Space....................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 8 Architecture and Acoustics Audio Document........................................................................................................................................................................... Page 8 Dick Campbell 1937-2012...Tribute to a Renaissance Man.................................................................................................................................................... Page 10 Warren Blazier Memorial................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 12 Linc Berry Consults on the Historic Old South Meeting House on Boston’s Freedom Trail....................................................................................... Page 13 Book Review, Acoustics and Audio................................................................................................................................................................................................ Page 16 Book Review, Acoustics: Sound Field............................................................................................................................................................................................ Page 16 Manufacturer’s Corner Scantek....................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 18 NCAC Student Travel Award Recipients....................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 20 Guest Editorial: Wonder Without Googling................................................................................................................................................................................ Page 22 Upcoming Meetings........................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Page 27 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 23 Now Available ANSI/ASA S12.55-2012 / ISO 3745:2012 AMERICAN NATIONAL STANDARD Acoustics – Determination of sound power levels and sound energy levels of noise sources using sound pressure – Precision methods for anechoic rooms and hemi-anechoic rooms (a nationally adopted international standard) This American National Standard specifies methods for measuring the sound pressure levels on a measurement surface enveloping a noise source (machinery or equipment) in an anechoic room or a hemi-anechoic room. The sound power level (or, in the case of impulsive or transient noise emission, the sound energy level) produced by the noise source, in frequency bands of width one-third octave or with frequency weighting A applied, is calculated using those measurements, including corrections to allow for any differences between the meteorological conditions at the time and place of the test and those corresponding to a reference characteristic acoustic impedance. To purchase an electronic copy of this ANSI Standard or other National or International Standards on Acoustics, Mechanical Vibration and Shock, Bioacoustics, or Noise please visit the Acoustical Society of America's Home Page at: http://acousticalsociety.org and click the "Store" button. You can purchase hard copies of Standards by contacting our office at: Acoustical Society of America Standards Secretariat 35 Pinelawn Road, Suite 114E Melville, NY 11747-3177 Phone (631) 390-0215 / Fax (631) 390-0217 ANSI/ASA S12.55-2012 / ISO 3745:2012 Price: $199.00 per copy 24 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter a Great Floor systeM by Maxxon & HiGH PerForMance ceilinG by Kinetics noise control IIC 61 • STC 60 1" (25 mm) approved Maxxon® Underlayment Floating Wood Floor WAVE HANgEr VS. rC CHANNEL – IIC rATINgS 80 1/4" (6.4 mm) Acousti-Mat II 70 60 40 30 20 Acoustical Products Floor Good Rating 7011040 Acousti-Mat II, WAVE Hanger Floating Engineered Wood IIC 61 7004048 Acousti-Mat II, RC Channel Floating Engineered Wood IIC 56 5k 4k 3.15k 2k Test Report 2.5k 1.6k 1k 1.25k Freq (Hz) 800 630 500 400 315 250 200 Kinetics WAVE Hanger 160 0 125 Parallel Chord Truss 80 2 layers Gypsum Board WAVE, Wood, Pad, gyp-Crete, Acousti-Mat — IIC 61 63 Batt Insulation rC, Wood, Pad, gyp-Crete, Acousti-Mat — IIC 56 10 50 Furring Channel 100 OSB or Plywood Subfloor ISPL (dB) 50 • Luxury performance at mid-level construction cost • Excellent low frequency noise control in wood frame construction For more info: 800-356-7887 • Email: info@maxxon.com www.MaxxonCorporation.com For more info: 877-457-2695 • Email: sales@kineticsnoise.com www.KineticsNoise.com Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 25 Critical attenuation requires... Water Treatment Oil & Gas Commercial and Big Box HVAC and Rooftop Enclosures Utilities Rail, Highways and Bridges Outstanding Performance! Sound Fighter Systems’ LSE Absorptive Noise Barriers STC: 33 NRC: 1.05 Custom-engineered and designed for any outdoor application and wind-load. Proven weatherproof, colorfast and incredibly durable. 40+ Years of Proven Success! Sound Fighter Systems, L.L.C. 1-866-348-0833 info@soundfighter.com www.soundfighter.com 26 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter Manufacturer’s Corner Sound Design Acoustics Program C M Y CM MY Keep track of assumptions made during the assessment, and keep all previous versions of your assessments and data objects. In addition to this, as acoustics assessments tend to form chains of noise sources to receivers, Sound Design allows you to draw your acoustic calculations on a ‘canvas’ in two dimensions, with each part of the assessment being a link in the chain. A huge amount of interoperability with spreadsheet programs is provided, with the ability to export and import data between Sound Design and spreadsheet programs. At its heart Sound Design is a program written by acoustics consultants for acoustics consultants. Plans are intend to continually improve and add new features to the program, and we welcome any feedback from the acoustics community. For additional information please visit: < www.acousticscentral.com/ software/sounddesign > where you can view instructional videos and developers’ blog among other items. You can install Sound Design from the website, which can be used for 30 days with full functionality with the exception of saving database files. SOLCOUSTIC is a registered trademark of Evonik Foams Sound Design is a new program from Acoustics Central intended to handle general acoustics assessments carried out by acoustic consultants. Sound Design allows you to: • Store your data (e.g., noise levels, transmission loss, absorption coefficients, lookup tables, et cetera) in one file to be available when creating new assessments. • Carry out your assessments within one file and assessment environment (e.g., room acoustics, noise transfer, noise break-in/out) to save on entering the same data in multiple locations. • Produce all schedules of data and calculation sheets with a couple of mouse clicks. • Have standard corrections available and usable at all times, along with the ability to create and save any corrections of your own. • SOLCOUSTIC is a registered trademark of Evonik Foams Editor’s Note: Information is provided to the Editor for review and editing prior to inclusion in the Newsletter. NCAC does not endorse products that are featured in this column. Information is provided to keep readers abreast of the latest products industry has to offer. [NTS] When has to be Whenthe youairwant them clean andevery fiber-free to hear note Count Counton on SOLCOUSTIC SOLCOUSTIC Duct Liner Advertisers in this issue: AcouStaCorp......................5 BASWA................................28 Dynasound.........................3 Eckel......................................6 Evonik Foams...................27 FlexAcoustics...................20 FlexMaster USA...............15 KINETICS Noise........ 9 & 25 Krieger ...............................18 National Gypsum............21 Northwest Wood.............12 Plywall................................17 Scantek...............................19 Sound Fighter Systems.26 Wenger...............................13 Zero International..........11 NCAC encourages advertising of acoustical products, services, and systems in the NCAC Newsletter as a means of improving communication with the acoustical consulting profession. Acceptance of advertising does not imply endorsement of products or services by the National Council of Acoustical Consultants or any of its individual members. Newsletter readers are invited to contact the advertisers directly for additional product technical and cost information or to advise of possible misleading information in their advertisements. CY CMY K SOLCOUSTIC® coated polyimide foam duct liner is a low VOC product that SOLCOUSTIC® polyimide duct liner offers superior acoustical resists microbialcoated growth. It exhibits excellent acoustical performance, performance, reducingnoise mechanical noisethrough from airair handling systems with reducing mechanical transmitted handling systems. Fora a low VOC, fiber-free duct liner solution. For a quieter, healthier environment, quieter, healthier work environment, specify GREENGUARD® certified specify GREENGUARD® Children and Schools certified SOLCOUSTIC Duct SOLCOUSTIC Duct Liner. For more information visit www.solcoustic.com Liner. For more information visit www.solcoustic.com Evonik Foams, Inc. Evonik Foams, Inc.Suite N. Watters Road, N.TX Watters Allen, Road, Suite Allen, TX + - + - + - + - Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter 27 Commerical Wall and Ceiling Acoustical Wood Solutions Available in a variety of materials, finishes, colors, and perforation patterns. www.ideatecusa.com 28 Winter 2013 NCAC Newsletter