Log of DEIS Comments and Location in FEIS

ECHO BAY CENTER WATERFRONT DEVELOPMENT

NEW ROCHELLE, NEW YORK

DEIS COMMENT LOG

Letter

No.

Author

PUBLIC HEARING NO. 1 - MARCH 12, 2013

PH1-1 James O'Toole

James O'Toole

James O'Toole

PH1-2 Robert Cox

Robert Cox

Robert Cox

Robert Cox

Robert Cox

PH1-3 Leslie Mignone

PH1-4 Marissa Brett, Westchester County Business Association

Marissa Brett, Westchester County Business Association

PH1-5 Alexi Brock, 57 Stonelea Place, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-6 Byron Gray, 219 Sickles Avenue, New Rochelle, NY - UFFA

Byron Gray, 219 Sickles Avenue, New Rochelle, NY - UFFA



PH1-7 Joanna Schaumburg, 25 Petersville Road, New Rochelle, NY

Joanna Schaumburg, 25 Petersville Road, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-8 Deidre Polow, 150 Woodlawn Avenue, New Rochelle, NY - New Rochelle Board of Education

Deidre Polow, 150 Woodlawn Avenue, New Rochelle, NY - New Rochelle Board of Education



PH1-9 Jeffrey Hastie, 254 Beechmont Drive, New Rochelle, NY - New Rochelle Board of Education

PH1-10 Mary Jo Jacobs, 33 Bon Air, New Rochelle, NY

Mary Jo Jacobs, 33 Bon Air, New Rochelle, NY

Mary Jo Jacobs, 33 Bon Air, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-11 Robert McCaffrey, 157 Mount Joy Place, New Rochelle, NY

674 DEIS Comment Log.xls

FEIS III.B-1 of 11

Comment

No.

Topic

FEIS

Section

PH101 School Children Generation

PH102 Purchase of City Yard Parcel

PH103 Armory Building

PH201 School Taxes - Based on Actual Number of

Children in Project

PH202 School Taxes - Based on Actual Number of

Children in Project

PH203 School Impacts - General

PH204 Per Pupil Expenditure


PH301 General Comments - In Favor

PH401 Residential Component

PH402 Benefits of the Project

PH501 School Impacts - General

PH601 Fire and Emergency Services




PH701 Parking

PH702 Parking During Construction



PH803 Per Pupil Expenditure

PH804 Educational Infrastructure

No Comments


PH1002 Public Improvements - Waterfront

PH1003 Residential Component

PH1101 Permits and Approvals

IV.I

IV.H

IV.J

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I

III

III

III

Divney Tung Schwalbe, LLP

III

IV.H

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I

IV.E

IV.L

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I




Letter

No.

Author

Comment

No.

Topic

FEIS

Section

Robert McCaffrey, 157 Mount Joy Place, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-12 Toryn Landrine, 361 Main Street, New Rochelle, NY - NYS Youth Works Program

PH1-13 John Ravitz, Business Council of Westchester

John Ravitz, Business Council of Westchester

PH1-14 Adam Eagleburg, 550 Forest Avenue, New Rochelle, NY

Adam Eagleburg, 550 Forest Avenue, New Rochelle, NY



PH1-15 Kyle Rhett, 590 Fifth Avenue, New Rochelle, NY - NYS Youth Works Program

PH1-16 Charles Morgan, New Rochelle Housing Authority

PH1-17 Rhonda Hamilton

PH1-18 Eileen Taus, 15 Leffingwell Place, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-19 Jason Klein, Federated Conservationists of Westchester County

Jason Klein, Federated Conservationists of Westchester County

PH1-20 John Delois, 41 Pratt Street, New Rochelle, NY

John Delois, 41 Pratt Street, New Rochelle, NY








PH1-21 Peter Parenti, 95 Brookside Place, New Rochelle, NY - United Veterans Memorial and Patriotic

Association of New Rochelle

PH1-22 James Warren

PH1-23 Shira Manning, 151 Central Avenue, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-24 Elizabeth Freh, 17 Eck Place, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-25 Frank Capasso, 48 Pratt Street, New Rochelle, NY

PH1102 Scale and Size of Project

No Comments

III



PH1401 General Comments - Opposed

PH1402 Benefits of the Project

PH1403 Real Property Assessment


No Comments




PH1901 Green Building Technology

PH1902

PH2001

PH2002

PH2003

Consistency with Planning Documents

Sunlight

Transportation Report Methodology

Transportation Report Methodology

MC

MC

MC

III

IV.A

IV.D

IV.E

IV.E

PH2004 Parking During Construction

PH2005 Parking

IV.L

IV.E

PH2006 School Children Generation IV.I

PH2007 Payment-In-Lieu-Of-Taxes (PILOT) Agreement III

PH2008 Armory Parcel III

PH2009 Air Quality Analysis

PH2101 Armory Parcel

IV.G

III

MC

MC

MC

IV.H

IV.H

IV.I



MC

MC

PH2401 General Comments - In Favor MC



FEIS III.B-2 of 11 Divney Tung Schwalbe, LLP




Letter

No.

Author

Frank Capasso, 48 Pratt Street, New Rochelle, NY





PH1-26 Derrick Williams, 10 Hemingway Avenue, New Rochelle, NY - National Builders Association

Derrick Williams, 10 Hemingway Avenue, New Rochelle, NY - National Builders Association

Derrick Williams, 10 Hemingway Avenue, New Rochelle, NY - National Builders Association

PH1-27 Peggy Godfried, 29 Bayview Avenue, New Rochelle, NY

Peggy Godfried, 29 Bayview Avenue, New Rochelle, NY





PH1-28 Susan Newman, 618 Forest Avenue, New Rochelle, NY

Susan Newman, 618 Forest Avenue, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-29 Olivia Kaplan

PH1-30 John Lots

PH1-31 Rosemary Spillane, 26 Woodbury Street, New Rochelle, NY

Rosemary Spillane, 26 Woodbury Street, New Rochelle, NY




PH1-32 Lawrence Talt, Lawrence Talt Realty

Lawrence Talt, Lawrence Talt Realty

PH1-33 Ron Tocci

Ron Tocci

Ron Tocci


FEIS III.B-3 of 11

Comment

No.

Topic

FEIS

Section


PH2503 Proposed Zoning Amendments IV.A

PH2504 Parking


IV.E

III


PH2601

PH2603

PH2701 New Rochelle Comprehensive Plan

PH2702

PH2704

PH2705 Environmental Assessment

PH2706

PH2802


PH3001

PH3102

Community Employment

PH2602 Community Employment

Open Space Resources

Proposed Zoning Amendments

PH2703 City Department of Public Works Yard Parcel

City Department of Public Works Yard Parcel

State Brownfield Clean-Up Program


City DPW Yard - Clean Up

Residential Component

PH3101 Public Improvements - Access to Waterfront

Scale and Size of Project

III

III

III

IV.I

IV.A

IV.A

III

III

IV.K

III

MC

IV.K

MC

III

III

III

PH3103 Dredging in Echo Bay IV.B


PH3105

PH3201


Parking

PH3202 City Department of Public Works Yard Parcel

PH3301 Armory Parcel

III

IV.E

III

III

V PH3302 Alternative B (Proposed Building with Removal of the Annex)

PH3303 Viewshed IV.D





Letter

No.

Author

Ron Tocci

PH1-34 Vince Napolitano, 9 Fairview Place, New Rochelle, NY

Vince Napolitano, 9 Fairview Place, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-35 Howard Stevens, 421 Grand Boulevard, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-36 Lorraine Carl, 43 Belmont Avenue, New Rochelle, NY

Lorraine Carl, 43 Belmont Avenue, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-37 Frank Morganthal, Hawthorne, NY - Marine Corps League - Westchester County Detachment

PH1-38 Julia Cost, 39 Emerson Avenue, New Rochelle, NY

Julia Cost, 39 Emerson Avenue, New Rochelle, NY

PH1-39 Matthew Rooney, 55 Decatur Road, New Rochelle, New York

Matthew Rooney, 55 Decatur Road, New Rochelle, New York

Matthew Rooney, 55 Decatur Road, New Rochelle, New York

PH1-40 James Kaplan, 191 Barnard Road, New Rochelle, NY

James Kaplan, 191 Barnard Road, New Rochelle, NY

1

2

3

4

5

PUBLIC COMMENT LETTERS

Natasha Court, Westchester County Department of Health - Bureau of Environmental Quality,

145 Huguenot Street, New Rochelle, NY

Natasha Court, Westchester County Department of Health - Bureau of Environmental Quality,

145 Huguenot Street, New Rochelle, NY

Candace Shafer, Westchester Land Trust, 403 Harris Road, Bedford Hills, NY

Business Council of Westchester, 108 Corporate Park Drive, White Plains, NY

Business Council of Westchester, 108 Corporate Park Drive, White Plains, NY

Deirdre Polow, City School District of New Rochelle - Board of Education, no address given




Peggy Godfrey, Echo Heights Neighborhood Association, no address given




FEIS III.B-4 of 11

Comment

No.

Topic




No Comments

PH3601 Public Infrastructure Improvements


No Comments



PH3901 Waterfront Shoreline

PH3902 General Comments - Opposed

PH3903 Dredging in Echo Bay



101

102

201

301

302

401

402

403

404

501

502

503

Permits and Approvals III

Permits and Approvals III

General Comments - In Favor



School Children Generation


Per Pupil Expenditure

Educational Infrastructure

New Rochelle Comprehensive Plan



MC

MC

MC

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I

IV.I

IV.A

IV.A

III


FEIS

Section

IV.I

IV.I

IV.B

IV.B

MC

MC

III

IV.I

IV.I

IV.E

IV.I




Letter

No.

Author

6

7

8

9

10

11








James Fleming, 11 Pratt Street, New Rochelle, NY

James Fleming, 11 Pratt Street, New Rochelle, NY

George Imburgia, 35 Maple Avenue, New Rochelle, NY





Gary and Ellen Freiberger, 51 Plymouth Drive, New Rochelle, NY







Stanley Bernstein, 300 Trenor Drive, New Rochelle, NY



Edward Lynch, AICP (Former City Planner), no address given



Susan Masi, Planning Board Member, no address given



FEIS III.B-5 of 11

Comment

No.

807

901

902

903

1001

1002

1003

1101

1102

705

801

802

803

804

805

806

509

510

601

602

701

702

703

704

504

505

506

507

508

Topic

FEIS

Section

Environmental Assessment

State Brownfield Clean-Up Program

Waste Water Treatment Plant

Alternatives with Good Profit Proposal

Community Service Providers

Permits and Approvals

Parking

General Comment - Opposed

Armory Parcel



Waterfront Shoreline

Payment-In-Lieu-Of-Taxes (PILOT) Agreement

Armory Parcel

Commercial Development - Taxes

Commercial Retail Component


City DPW Yard - Cost of Remediation

Payment-In-Lieu-Of-Taxes (PILOT)


Public Improvements - Waterfront



Per Pupil Expenditure



Building Construction - FEMA



III

MC

IV.I

IV.I

MC

IV.A

IV.B

III

III

III

IV.H

III

III

IV.K

IV.H

IV.H

IV.K

III

IV.F/G

V

IV.I

III

IV.E

MC

III

MC

III

IV.B

III





Letter

No.

Author

12










Doug Hocking, Planning Board Member, no address given




















FEIS III.B-6 of 11

1103

1104

1105

1106

1107

1108

1109

1110

1111

1201

1202

1203

1204

1205

1206

1207

1208

1209

1210

1211

1212

1213

1214

1215

1216

1217

1218

1219

Comment

No.

Topic

FEIS

Section



Parking



Proposed Building Height


Building and Site Design - KSQ




Demographics




Parking


Public Improvements - Access to Waterfront


Public Infrastructure Improvements

Alternative B (Proposed Building with Removal of the Annex)




Adjoining and Nearby Properties


Infrastructure

Green Building Technology

III

III

III

III

IV.B

IV.C

III

III

III

IV.E

III

IV.B

III

III

III

V

IV.I

IV.H

IV.H

IV.H

IV.K

III

IV.E

III

III

III

IV.E

V





Letter

No.

Author

13

14

15







Sarah Dodds-Brown, Planning Board Member, no address given













New Rochelle Department of Development, Planning Board Resolution










FEIS III.B-7 of 11

1402

1403

1404

1405

1501

1502

1503

1504

1304

1305

1306

1307

1308

1401

1505

1506

1507

1508

1509

1220

1221

1222

1223

1224

1225

1301

1302

1303

Comment

No.

Topic

FEIS

Section

Viewshed


Demographics



General Comment - In Favor

General Comment - In Favor


Alternative B (Proposed Building with Removal of the Annex)


Lighting

Payment-In-Lieu-Of-Taxes (PILOT) Agreement

Adjoining and Nearby Properties

Parking

Commercial Development - Taxes

Sunlight



General Comment - Opposed





Public Improvements - Access to Waterfront

Viewshed


Demographics


IV.D

IV.E

IV.H

V

III

MC

MC

III

V

III

III

III

III

IV.D

IV.H

III

MC

III

IV.D

III

III

IV.E

IV.H

III

IV.D

III

IV.H

IV.H





Letter

No.

Author

16









Edward Buroughs, Commissioner, Westchester County Planning Board, 148 Martine Avenue,

White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


FEIS III.B-8 of 11

Comment

No.

1607

1608

1609

1610

1611

1612

1603

1604

1605

1606

1510

1511

1512

1513

1514

1515

1516

1517

1601

1602

Topic



Parking






Project Purpose, Need and Benefits


Consistency with Westchester 2025

Residential Component


Sanitary Sewer

Sanitary Sewer

Westchester County Bee-Line Bus Service

Recycling





FEIS

Section

IV.C

IV.E

IV.C

IV.B

IV.K

IV.B

IV.A

III

III

IV.C

IV.K

III

IV.E

IV.A

IV.E

IV.B

IV.E

III

III

IV.A




Letter

No.

Author


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


FEIS III.B-9 of 11

Comment

No.

1621

1622

1623

1624

1625

1626

1627

1628

1617

1618

1619

1620

1613

1614

1615

1616

Topic

FEIS

Section


Project Purpose, Need and Benefits

Project Location


Armory Parcel







Sanitary Sewer

Sanitary Sewer

Westchester County Bee-Line Bus Service



IV.A

IV.A

III

IV.C

IV.C

IV.E

IV.B

IV.K

III

IV.A

IV.A

IV.A

III

III

III

III





17

18

19

19

19

19

19

19

19

19

19

Letter

No.

Author


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY


White Plains, NY

Grace Musumeci, Chief, Environmental Review Section, United States Environmental Protection

Agency, Region 2, 290 Broadway, New York, NY

Grace Musumeci, Chief, Environmental Review Section, United States Environmental Protection

Agency, Region 2, 290 Broadway, New York, NY

Chuck Sheifer, Chief, Bureau of Land Management, State of New York, Executive Department -

Office of General Services, Empire State Plaza, Albany, NY

Chuck Sheifer, Chief, Bureau of Land Management, State of New York, Executive Department -

Office of General Services, Empire State Plaza, Albany, NY

Rebecca Crist, Environmental Analyst, New York State Dept of Environmental Conservation,

Division of Environmental Permits - Region 3, 21 South Putt Corners Road, New Paltz, NY

















Comment

No.

1902

1903

1904

1905

1906

1907

1908

1909

1702

1801

1802

1901

1629

1630

1631

1701

Topic

Recycling







NYSDEC Regulation

NYSDEC Regulation

NYSDEC Regulation

NYSDEC Regulation

NYSDEC Regulation

NYSDEC Regulation

NYSDEC Regulation

NYSDEC Regulation

NYSDEC Regulation



FEIS

Section

IV.B

IV.B

IV.B

IV.B

IV.B

IV.B

IV.B

IV.B

III

III

III

IV.B

IV.C

IV.B

III

III




19

19

Letter

No.

Author





Comment

No.

1910

1911

NYSDEC Regulation

NYSDEC Regulation

Topic

FEIS

Section

IV.B

IV.B



Log of DEIS Comments and Location in FEIS

Related documents

Products

Support

Log of DEIS Comments and Location in FEIS

Related documents

Add this document to collection(s)

Add this document to saved

Suggest us how to improve StudyLib