Investment Views May/June 2016 2015 Contents Foreword Current market assessment 1. Focus Top issue of the month Economic outlook 4 5 6 7 9 2. Asset classes Money market and currencies Bonds Equities Alternative investments 10 10 14 18 22 3. Investment management 26 4. Appendix 30 31 32 34 Glossary Important legal information VP Bank Group Investment Views May/June 2016 Foreword Low interest rates here to stay Dear Reader Investors need strong nerves at present. Sentiment has been on a roller coaster in recent months, exposing the markets to extreme stresses and strains. An anxiety attack at the start of the year sent equities, the oil market and high yield bonds into headlong retreat. But this was followed, apparently out of the blue, by a vigorous rally. This time – for once – blame for the markets’ gyrations does not lie chiefly with the central banks. Even so, monetary actions are still causing headaches for investors. Central banks have resorted to increasingly unconventional measures since the financial market crisis, and more and more of them are now taking the highly unorthodox step of imposing negative interest rates. When creditors suddenly have to pay to lend money instead of receiving interest, this has far-reaching repercussions. The central banks’ actions do not merely affect short-term money market investments. The reverberations are felt throughout large parts of the real economy and financial system. Low and negative interest rates will not be a short-lived phenomenon. The main burden falls on investors, who have to decide how to respond. There is no sure and simple way of escaping the low interest trap, but various courses of action are possible. In “Top issue of the month” we offer a provisional assessment. Who are the winners and who are the losers? What are the challenges for investors, and what measures can they take? Hendrik Breitenstein Head of Group Active Advisory & Consulting Bernd Hartmann Head of Group Investment Research Current market assessment The tables below summarise VP Bank‘s trend assessments for all asset classes in our investment universe. The arrows reflect the forecasts of our investment strategists for the coming three to six months. Money market and currencies (pages 10–13) Currencies Rate as of 22/04/2016 EUR vs. USD 1.126 EUR vs. CHF March 2016 ¼ 1.099 ¼ USD vs. CHF 0.976 GBP vs. CHF 1.408 USD vs. JPY Bonds: total return (pages 14–17) May 2016  New À New ¼ À New À À High yield bonds High yield March 2016 May 2016 À À Emerging market bonds Hard currency bonds À À Local currency bonds ¼ ¼ 111.32 À À AUD vs. USD 0.775 À ¼ USD vs. SGD 1.350 À À Switzerland À ¼ New USD vs. RUB 65.775 ¼ ¼ Europe À ¼ New North America À ¼ New New Key interest rates Switzerland New Equities (pages 18–21) –0.75% ¼ ¼ Pacifi c À ¼ Europe (EMU) 0.00% ¼ ¼ Emerging markets À À USA 0.50% À À Commodities À À Crude oil À À Investment grade government bonds Switzerland À À Gold À À Europe À À Real estate shares À ¼ New USA À À Private equity À ¼ New Convertible bonds À ¼ New Hedge funds ¼ ¼ Investment grade corporate bonds Switzerland À À Europe À À USA À À Legal notes on page 32 5 | May/June 2016 | Current market assessment Alternative investments (pages 22–25) Bond yields (pages 14–17) 1. Focus Top issue of the month | Bernd Hartmann Life below zero: coping with low and negative yields Monetary policy has become increasingly unconventional in recent years, and more and more central banks are now resorting to the most unorthodox measure of all: negative interest rates. The negative interest rate club currently includes the eurozone and Japan as well as Switzerland, Denmark and Sweden. Sub-zero rates are by no means confined to central bank transactions. Lenders are being hit by negative yields in large segments of the money and bond markets. Around 80% of all government and quasigovernment bonds in the Swiss franc sector are now trading with a negative yield to maturity. In the euro sector the figure is just under 50%. Who are the losers? The most obvious losers are savers and conservative investors. Real interest rates on money market investments and in large parts of the bond markets are now in minus territory. Barring a deflation scenario, the purchasing power of money invested in these vehicles gradually diminishes. Who are the winners? Central banks have various reasons for imposing negative interest rates. In small countries the motivation is often the need to combat a runaway appreciation of the currency. In the eurozone, however, the primary aim is to rev up the economy. By charging banks for parking their surplus liquidity, the European Central Bank hopes to encourage them to grant more credit and thereby provide economic stimulus. It is too early to say whether this will be successful. In countries that already have lengthy experience of negative interest rates, lending has mostly contracted when rates were pushed below zero. Whether the economy will be on the winning side in a sub-zero interest rate environment is therefore questionable. The situation is clearer with regard to public finances. As long as inflation outpaces low or negative borrowing costs, public debt will gradually decline in real terms (other things being equal). In the past, various countries have been able to whittle down their public debt burden thanks to a protracted period of sub-zero real interest rates. The clearest winners, however, are holders of assets that confer direct ownership rights, e.g. equities and real estate. But not all such assets profit equally. Precious metals, for example, have shed a large part of their gains in recent years. 0% Legal notes on page 32 Investment world in an era of negative real yields Yield Emerging market equities Private equity Real estate Developed market equities High yield bonds Emerging market bonds Mid-grade corporate bonds High-grade corporate bonds Government bonds (risk-free) Money market Cash Certain loss in absence of deflation Risk As the low interest environment drags on, pension funds also become losers. Initially they benefit, because falling interest rates generate capital gains on their bond portfolios. Now, however, they are feeling the pinch. In Switzerland, where negative rates are highest, the direct charge on cash deposits amounts to only a few basis points. What causes the real damage is the fact that maturing bond holdings cannot be reinvested. This is reinforcing the pressure for a reform of investment-based pension systems. The losers club is a mixed bunch. Banks are hit directly by shrinking interest earnings. For employees the impact is indirect. Downward pressure on interest rates lowers the cost of capital, making machinery increasingly attractive compared with human resources. 7 | May/June 2016 | Focus | Top issue of the month Real yield > 0% Nominal yield < 0% 8 | May/June 2016 | Focus | Top issue of the month What action can be taken? One point needs to be emphasised: there is no patent remedy for avoiding the negative effects of low and subzero interest rates. But that does not mean that investors are helpless. Until a few years ago money market rates were enough to preserve purchasing power. Asset preservation and security went hand in hand. This comfortable situation is now a thing of the past. Investors have to decide whether to keep their money as secure and accessible as possible at the price of an insidious loss of value, or to expose themselves to greater risks in the hope of preserving or even enhancing the purchasing power of their assets over the long term. There are many possible measures that can be taken. The choice will depend primarily on individual circumstances. Basically there are three approaches: incur greater risk on a controlled basis, exploit flexibility or minimise losses. Controlled risk-taking Many investors will opt for increased risk. But greater risk does not automatically lead to success. Risks should not be incurred unless they offer a sound prospect of a corresponding return. Meagre interest payments are boosting the popularity of dividend-bearing equity investments, especially among income-oriented investors. But it is also possible to participate in the equity market without full exposure to the equity risk. Structured products known as “deep barrier reverse convertibles”, for example, pay a fixed regular coupon instead of providing participation in capital gains. They are de facto immune to small and medium corrections on the equity market and do not incur losses on the same scale as a straightforward equity investment except in the case of an extreme share price decline, e.g. over 40%. Exploiting flexibility Instead of reinvesting capital in Swiss bonds, investors can buy foreign currency bonds. This, of course, involves a currency risk, which can be hedged at a cost. For international investors who are equally happy in either of two currencies, “double currency units” are an interesting possibility. These “DOCUs”, as they are known, involve an option premium payable to the depositor, which generates a relatively attractive return. Minimising losses There are also strategies suitable for risk-shunning investors. In the cash market, for example, money market funds offer better interest rates than the negative rates imposed by central banks. A further advantage compared with a bank deposit is that the fund’s assets are spread over various borrowers and business sectors. Credit ratings are usually at least as good as those of a bank deposit. However, given the low interest rates being offered, investors should carefully familiarise themselves with the fund’s fee structure. Conclusion We are probably all affected by sub-zero yields in one way or another. Low and negative interest rates are not a temporary aberration. They will be with us for years to come and constitute a critical challenge for investors. There is no patent remedy for dealing with them, but various responses are possible. In all cases, investors must be careful to choose courses of action that match their personal risk tolerance. It is also important to achieve broad diversification. Not every risk offers the prospect of a higher yield. Economic outlook | Dr Thomas Gitzel Brexit: will Brits file for divorce? Brexit: UK interests on the line Brexit would hit Britain hard. High levels of foreign direct investment make the UK economy especially vulnerable to reduced capital inflows, which could well occur in the climate of uncertainty that Brexit would create. Moreover, untrammelled access to EU markets has been a major incentive for multinational companies to locate their European headquarters in London. Several prominent firms are already threatening to pull out of the UK if Brexit happens. A major worry on the macroeconomic front is Britain’s relatively high current account deficit, which stood at 5.2% of GDP in 2015. This creates dependence on foreign portfolio investment. If less portfolio investment comes in from Europe, the result would be a significant depreciation of the pound and consequently higher inflation. That, in turn, would eat into consumers’ purchasing power and reduce domestic demand. It should also be noted that the UK would initially be excluded from the free trade agreements that the EU has made with other countries and economic areas. New agreements would have to be hammered out in negotiations involving many countries, and that would be a time- and cost-intensive process. Not a complete break Brexit would expose the UK to new challenges. Close trade links with Europe (50% of British exports go to the EU) would force the UK to make bilateral arrangements Legal notes on page 32 with the European Union, as Switzerland and Norway have done. But Britain would be a supplicant in these negotiations, putting the EU in a position to dictate terms. David Cameron is painfully aware of this and has made the economic risks the central plank of his anti-Brexit campaign. Britain’s industrialists are also loudly proclaiming the need to stay in the EU. The “Project Fear” being mounted by Cameron and the business community could bear fruit in the coming weeks and engineer a swing in public opinion. Pound sterling: sink or swim? An urgent question is how the financial markets would react. The relationship between Britain and the rest of Europe has never been a love affair – more like a marriage of convenience. The UK’s net payments to the EU are reduced by the rebate negotiated by Margaret Thatcher and amount to just under EUR 5 billion a year, which is not particularly lavish. In normal circumstances, a UK withdrawal could therefore be coped with. But the refugee crisis has plunged the EU into one of the greatest convulsions since its foundation. Brexit would pour oil on the flames, probably resulting in a sharp depreciation of the euro against the US dollar. Given the macroeconomic dangers, the devaluation risk for the pound would be even greater. This is not our baseline scenario, however. On balance we expect Britain to stay in the EU, and that would argue for a substantial appreciation of the pound. 9 | May/June 2016 | Focus | Economic outlook On 23 June 2016 the people of Britain will vote on whether or not to stay in the European Union. Will it be “Brexit” or “Bremain”? A number of opinion polls indicate that support for Brexit has grown, despite the substantial concessions that Britain achieved in pre-referendum horse-trading with the EU. But poll results should be taken with a pinch of salt. Online surveys are regarded as less reliable than telephone polls, which show a clear lead for the Bremain camp. Even so, the result is up in the air. Uncertainty about the outcome will continue until polling day. Highlights • There are growing fears of a possible Brexit as the referendum on Britain’s membership of the EU draws closer. • Opinion polls should be treated with caution. • We expect Britain to remain in the EU, and that would signal a higher pound. 2. Asset classes Money market and currencies Money market and currencies Market overview EUR/CHF and EUR/USD: exchange rates since April 2014 USD/CHF: exchange rate since April 2014 1.30 1.40 1.25 1.35 1.30 1.20 1.05 1.00 1.25 1.15 1.20 1.10 0.95 1.15 1.05 1.10 1.00 0.90 1.05 1.00 0.95 0.85 A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A EUR/USD (r-h scale) USD/CHF GBP/CHF and GBP/USD: exchange rates since April 2014 USD/JPY and USD/AUD: exchange rates since April 2014 1.60 1.75 1.55 1.70 130 1.50 1.45 125 1.40 1.65 1.50 1.60 1.45 1.55 1.40 1.50 1.35 1.35 120 1.30 115 1.25 1.20 110 1.15 1.45 1.30 1.40 1.25 1.35 1.05 1.00 100 A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A GBP/CHF 1.10 105 GBP/USD (r-h scale) USD/JPY Key interest rates in Switzerland, eurozone, USA: since April 2006 Key interest rates in UK and Japan: since April 2006 6% 7% 5% 6% 4% USD/AUD (r-h scale) 5% 3% 4% 2% 3% 1% 2% 0% 1% –1% 0% –2% 06 07 08 USA Legal notes on page 32 09 10 11 Eurozone 12 13 14 15 Switzerland 16 06 07 UK 08 09 10 Japan 11 12 13 14 15 16 11 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Money market and currencies EUR/CHF Money market and currencies | Dr Thomas Gitzel 12 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Money market and currencies Market outlook China: in calmer waters The situation in China has become relatively calm after the turbulence on the financial markets in January and February. The markets have woken up to the fact that the Chinese economy is not heading for a major slowdown. In mid-March the National People’s Congress passed China’s 13th five-year plan, which foresees annual growth of 6.5% or more until 2020. The plan reiterates the aim of doubling per capita income and GDP by 2020 from a 2010 base. Emphasis is placed on research and innovation, which will provide important new drivers of growth. The services sector is slated to grow, while measures will be taken to tackle industrial overcapacity. The government is promising further large-scale infrastructure investments together with green initiatives designed to protect the environment. Growth will be supported by capital spending and tax breaks. Above all, the expansionary monetary policy being pursued by the People’s Bank of China will provide crucial support for the 6.5% growth target. In the past the expansion of M1 money supply has been a good leading indicator of future GDP growth. China: M1 money supply and GDP growth 16% 45% 15% 40% 14% 35% 13% 30% 12% 25% 11% 20% 10% 15% 9% 8% 10% 7% 5% 6% 0% GDP growth, % yoy M1 expansion, % yoy (r-h scale) Critical look at expanding money supply A word of caution is needed here. The theoretical justifi cation for regarding money supply as a leading indicator of economic growth is not unequivocal. M1 money supply consists of cash and sight deposits. If these assets increase, individuals and companies have more to spend, which can be seen as indicating higher personal consumption, increased investment and consequently faster economic growth. This interpretation supports the close link between M1 money supply and GDP growth. But other factors might also be in play. Higher cash holdings and sight deposits could be motivated by insecurity resulting in heightened aversion to risk. That would argue against stronger growth. Moreover, recent interest rate cuts by the Chinese central bank make long-term investments less attractive compared with short-term money, which could explain the increase in sight deposits. Theoretically, therefore, a substantial expansion of M1 money supply does not necessarily point to a correspondingly high economic growth rate. Nevertheless, there is a wealth of evidence from many economies that money supply does indeed provide a good indication of future growth trends. Empirically, the connection therefore seems to be confirmed. On this basis we believe that China’s growth rate will at least be stabilised. China’s exchange rate policy In its efforts to keep the economy on a healthy growth trajectory, the Chinese government could conceivably resort to a major devaluation of the yuan. In fact, though, it is doing just the opposite. The authorities are intervening energetically on the foreign exchange markets to buoy up the currency and prevent a steep depreciation. This is reflected in the country’s shrinking international reserves, which have diminished by almost USD 800 billion since mid-2014. Balance of payments data published by the State Administration of Foreign Exchange (“SAFE”) highlight the nature of the problem. Figures show that China has experienced a continuous net outflow of capital since mid-2014. Highlights • We do not expect a dramatic deceleration of Chinese economic growth. • Exchange rate policy presents China with a difficult balancing act, but the authorities will take measures to prevent a steep depreciation of the yuan. • A gradual weakening of the exchange rate is the likeliest scenario. China: balance of payments 250 200 150 100 50 0 –50 –100 –150 –200 2007 2011 2015 Conclusion The Chinese economy will remain on course. A dramatic slowdown is not on the cards. But exchange rate policy presents Beijing with a delicate balancing act. A major depreciation of the yuan will be avoided for fear of triggering a dangerous downward spiral. We expect a gradual depreciation over the coming quarters, with the USD/CNY rate possibly moving to around 6.80. Given the limitations on foreign transfers by private individuals, these capital exports must have been largely carried out by companies worried about the prospect of devaluation. Many Chinese firms are stashing their export revenues in US dollar accounts or using them to repay dollar liabilities instead of converting them into yuan via the Chinese central bank. The government, however, is vehemently resisting market pressures and doing all it can to keep the currency stable. A serious weakening of the yuan could prompt Chinese firms to take money out of the inflated real estate market and convert it into dollars. A resultant weakening of property prices could have a destabilising effect on the entire Chinese economy. A free-floating yuan is therefore not on the agenda for the time being. We expect a gradual depreciation interspersed with periods of exchange rate stability. Moreover, Beijing is quietly reversing some previous moves to liberalise the rules on capital movements. During the recent market turmoil, restrictions were imposed on some foreign banks’ ability to shift funds from the Chinese capital market to the largely liberalised Hong Kong market. Legal notes on page 32 Key interest rates Switzerland Europe (EMU) USA May 2016 ¼ ¼ À Upside/downside ranges indicated by our 3–6 month interest rate forecasts: ½> +50 basis points À+25 basis points ¼No change –25 basis points ¾< –50 basis points 13 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Money market and currencies Current account balance in USD bn Financial account in USD bn: capital exports (net) Change in currency reserves in USD bn 2. Asset classes Bonds Bonds Bond yields – overview Switzerland: yields since April 2014 Emerging markets (hard currency): yields since April 2014 1.5% 7.0% 6.5% 1.0% 6.0% 5.5% 0.5% 5.0% 4.5% 0.0% 4.0% –0.5% 3.5% A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J CHF government bonds A M J J A S O N D J F M A CHF corporate bonds (5 to 10 y.) J A S O N D J F M A M J EM government bonds (5 to 10 y.) J A S O N D J F MA EM corporate bonds (5 to 10 y.) Europe: yields since April 2014 Emerging markets (local currency): yields since April 2014 2.5% 6.0% 2.0% 5.5% 1.5% 5.0% 1.0% 4.5% 0.5% 4.0% A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J EUR government bonds (5 to 10 y.) A M J J A S O N D J F MA EUR corporate bonds (5 to 10 y.) USA: yields since April 2014 J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F MA EM government bonds (local currency) High yield: yields since April 2014 9.5% 4.5% 9.0% 8.5% 3.5% 8.0% 7.5% 2.5% 7.0% 6.5% 1.5% 6.0% 5.5% 5.0% 0.5% A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J USD government bonds (5 to 10 y.) Legal notes on page 32 J A S O N D J F MA USD corporate bonds (5 to 10 y.) A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J Global high yield (5 to 10 y.) J A S O N D J F MA 15 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Bonds 0.0% Bonds | Dr Thomas Gitzel, Bernhard Allgäuer Market outlook 16 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Bonds Recent US macro data have been encouraging, but the Fed is deliberately playing down the good news. This creates a confused picture. Last year, when the numbers were not as good, the Fed made optimistic noises and raised its key interest rate. Washington’s current cautious stance has boosted the bond markets. US Treasuries are now trading only slightly below their all-time high. Solid US economy… The US economy is performing well. Figures for new jobs show that US firms are still upbeat and are expanding their workforces. Nonfarm payrolls climbed by 215,000 in March, with most of the increase occurring in the services sector. US manufacturers are still reluctant to hire, but an improvement is in sight here. Manufacturing companies have been through an exceptionally rough patch in recent quarters, and this is reflected in a year-on-year decline in industrial output – the first such contraction since the financial market crisis of 2008 and 2009. The strong US dollar has put a brake on exports, while the low oil price has undermined capital spending in the energy sector. But major leading indicators now suggest that manufacturers have become more optimistic again. There is good reason to hope that ailing industrial production will recuperate in the months ahead, providing the economy with a second (albeit less dynamic) motor alongside the services sector. …but pessimistic Fed The Fed now seems to be consciously playing down the economy’s solid performance. Fed Chair Janet Yellen misses no opportunity to expatiate upon the economic risks. This is a reaction to the unhappy experience of last December’s rate hike. At that time monetary tightening was economically unnecessary, but Janet Yellen had talked so much about the improving economy and an imminent rate hike that policy had to be tightened to avoid a serious loss of face. Now the Fed is backpedalling verbally, but once again the timing is wrong. Economic conditions are better than at the time of the first rate hike, yet the Fed is sounding gloomier. This breeds confusion, to the detriment of the Fed’s credibility. We believe that the robust economy will make a rate hike in June virtually inescapable. Government bond markets in need of correction The pussyfooting posture adopted by Janet Yellen has led to a change of sentiment on the financial markets. The US money market now believes that Yellen will not pluck up courage to raise the fed funds rate until 2017. We, however, expect the next hike to come in June 2016. That means that the fixed income markets are heading for a correction. As the current yield on 10-year Treasuries (around 1.8%) anticipates a postponement of the next rate hike until 2017, any tightening this year would tend to push yields higher. Given that the US Treasuries market also sets the tone for European government bonds, we would expect to see a weaker trend in the Swiss bond market too. Another factor also has to be considered: The oil price (Brent crude) has climbed by 60% since January. This will have an impact on inflation. If inflation rates accelerate in the coming months, that too would create potential for higher bond yields. ECB takes historic step At its meeting in March the European Central Bank (ECB) not only lowered interest rates but also expanded its asset purchase programme from EUR 60 billion to EUR 80 billion a month. In doing so it added corporate bonds to the classes of securities eligible for purchase. The criteria for corporate bond eligibility were defined as follows: • Euro-denominated • Investment grade rating • Company domiciled in eurozone • Securities issued by banks are excluded. The first purchases are scheduled for June. Market structure Bonds with a total value of around EUR 821 billion meet the ECB’s initial criteria. The volume of top-quality corporate bonds is small. Most corporate bonds are classed by the Which corporate bonds will the ECB buy? In April, however, additional detailed requirements were published. The ECB’s purchase programme covers issuers based in the eurozone, but the ultimate parent company can be outside the eurozone. If the field is limited to large (and therefore more liquid) issues of over EUR 500 million, the eligible volume comes down to EUR 354 billion. The ECB permits itself to buy up to 70% of any one issue. The total asset purchase programme scheduled until next March amounts to EUR 960 billion. Current holdings are as follows: • Public sector purchase programme (PSPP): EUR 689 billion • Covered bond purchase programme (CBPP3): EUR 169 billion • Asset backed securities purchase programme (ABSPP): EUR 19 billion Conclusion Although the corporate bond market is large, the ECB might not be able to find enough securities on the market and would therefore soon have to relax its purchase criteria. As the secondary market is not liquid, more reliance Legal notes on page 32 will be placed on the primary market. In this environment, credit spreads will not widen and therefore remain attractive. Benchmark May 2016 Gov. bonds Switzerland2 À Gov. bonds Europe (EUR)2 À Gov. bonds USA 2 À Inv. grade corp. bonds Switzerland2 À Inv. grade corp. bonds Europe (EUR)2 À Inv. grade corp. bonds USA 2 À High yield bonds3 À Emerging market bonds (hard currency)3 À Emerging market bonds (local currency)3 ¼ 1 As of 22/04/2016 Yield 3 Total return 2 % YTD1 3.34% 2.59% 2.73% 1.23% 2.77% 4.95% 6.27% 7.11% 12.80% 17 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Bonds rating agencies as BBB or lower. A special feature of the corporate bond market concerns issuers’ country of origin. For tax reasons German companies frequently issue bonds through special-purpose companies established in the Netherlands, which have been set up for the sole purpose of handling the parent company’s financing. A country comparison therefore puts the Netherlands in second place (EUR 220 billion) after France (EUR 270 billion), with Germany down in third place (EUR 95 billion). But if borrowing volume is ranked on the basis of the parent company’s domicile, France is still in first place (EUR 260 billion), followed by Germany in second place (EUR 195 billion) and Italy third (EUR 95 billion). Moreover, some bonds are issued outside the eurozone, bringing the total volume down to EUR 745 billion. Highlights • Recent economic data from the USA have been upbeat, but Fed Chair Janet Yellen prefers to talk up the risks. • The Fed wants to dampen expectations of higher interest rates. Even so, there is still potential for yields to rise. • The ECB has expanded its asset purchase programme to include corporate bonds. But it is questionable whether enough eligible bonds will be available. 2. Asset classes Equities Equities Equity indices – overview Switzerland: market movement since April 2014 (indexed) Pacific: market movement since April 2014 (indexed) 120 120 115 115 110 110 105 105 100 100 95 95 90 90 85 A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F MA A M J MSCI Switzerland TR Index (net) rebased J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F MA MSCI Pacific TR Index (net) rebased Europe: market movement since April 2014 (indexed) 110 Emerging markets: market movement since April 2014 (indexed) 115 110 105 105 100 100 95 95 90 90 85 85 80 80 75 70 75 J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F MA A M J MSCI Europe TR Index (net) rebased J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F MA MSCI Emerging Markets TR Index (net) rebased North America: market movement since April 2014 (indexed) United Kingdom: market movement since April 2014 (indexed) 120 115 115 110 110 105 105 100 100 95 95 90 85 90 A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F MA MSCI North America TR Index (net) rebased Legal notes on page 32 A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J MSCI UK TR Index (net) rebased J A S O N D J F MA 19 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Equities A M J Equities | Rolf Kuster Market outlook 20 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Equities Equity markets still prey to uncertainty It has been an awkward year so far on the equity markets. The first quarter was characterised by a diffuse mood of foreboding among many investors. Whatever its underlying causes, the anxiety syndrome was able to feed on a succession of perceived problems. First it was fear of a looming slowdown in the Chinese economy. Then came worries about deflationary trends in the eurozone, followed by jitters about the alleged threat of a US recession. The current nail-biting factor is uncertainty about a possible British exit from the EU. As the multi-year bull market has resulted in increasingly lofty valuation levels, investors have become more sensitive to risk and are easily spooked. The upshot is heightened volatility. In the present environment a cautious investment stance seems appropriate. The increased volume of M&A (mergers and acquisitions) and initial public offerings, combined with ambitious valuation levels in many cases, highlights the fact that the equity market cycle is at an advanced stage. Amid all the talk of possible interest rate hikes, imminent ballots and other geopolitical risks, the biggest downside factor generally gets forgotten: corporate earnings performance is extremely weak and has been so for a long time. Earnings versus valuation Valuation and earnings are regarded as the two main drivers of long-term equity market performance. Valuation ratios are calculated by taking the current equity price and relating it to an accounting figure such as earnings (price/ earnings ratio). The resultant ratio, considered either in absolute terms or in comparison with historical levels, gives a guide as to whether the market is expensive or cheap. By also factoring in other variables such as interest rates, it is possible to draw conclusions about equities’ relative attractiveness, e.g. compared with bonds. Earnings trends are mostly steadier and easier to forecast in the short term than changes in valuation levels. While valuation levels generally fluctuate around a mean, corporate earnings often show a positive trend. Put simply, higher equity prices can be sustained in the long term only on the basis of higher earnings. This is the nub of the present problem. Chary analysts Corporate earnings were already sluggish last year. The key MSCI World index registered an earnings decline of around 2%. The contraction was sharpest in emerging markets, especially in Latin America. This year, too, analysts’ initial euphoria has largely evaporated. The consensus estimate at the start of the year foresaw earnings growth of around 7% per share. In the first three and a half months of 2016 this forecast has been ratcheted down to a paltry 2.3%. 2016 earnings growth expectations in the major regions 12% 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% MSCI World 6 months ago 1 month ago USA Europe Emerging markets 3 months ago Current forecast Analysts are now forecasting 2016 earnings growth of only 1.5% in the USA and 1.9% in Europe (including Switzerland and the UK). It is normal for estimates to be revised downwards after the start of the calendar year, but the revisions are rarely as dramatic as this. The feeble overall earnings performance is attributable primarily to the energy and commodities sector. Low commodity prices and the continuing weakness of the oil market have depressed margins Highlights • The recovering oil price has not yet given a boost to corporate earnings. • The current reporting season in the USA is the weakest since the financial crisis. • Positive earnings revisions on the basis of rising oil prices would be a buy signal for equities. and sent earnings in these sectors plummeting. Analysts expect earnings in the global energy sector to fall by a further 40% in 2016. A glance at first-quarter company reports highlights the scale of the problem. US quarterly earnings for 2016 Q1 are about 9% down on the year-ago figure. This is the steepest fall since the outbreak of the financial crisis. Although the chief blame for the decline in earnings expectations lies with the energy sector, other sectors are also in difficulty. Banks, for example, are having to set aside more money as provisions for future bad loans. move in this direction over the coming months. Equity holdings should be regionally diversified. The eurozone and emerging markets are still offering earnings growth rates in excess of 5%. The combination of comparatively attractive valuations and positive (and sustained) earnings growth is an argument for these regions. We currently view the USA, the UK and Switzerland with particular caution. Seeking an optimal positioning With earnings growth in decline and valuation ratios at heightened levels, it is appropriate to treat the equity markets with a degree of caution at present, at least in terms of the fundamentals. Geopolitical risks, for example the current discussion about a possible British exit from the EU, can easily lead to increased volatility in these circumstances. It the weeks ahead it will therefore be advisable to stay near the sidelines. But as soon as crude oil inventories decline and the oil price rises, the earnings outlook should improve. That would provide better fundamental support for the market. We expect to see a gradual Legal notes on page 32 Benchmark % YTD1 May 2016 Switzerland ¼ Europe ¼ North America ¼ Pacific (incl. Japan) ¼ Emerging markets À –5.05% 0.69% 3.18% 1.74% 7.96% Upside/downside ranges indicated by our 3–6 month absolute performance assessments ½> +5% À+2% to +5% ¼–2% to +2% –5% to –2% ¾< –5% 1 As of 22/04/2016 21 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Equities Crucial oil price Whether the vicious spiral of negative earnings revisions and falling earnings growth can be broken depends crucially on the price of crude oil. For many analysts, an oil price of around USD 40 is still too low to justify a sustained upward revision of earnings estimates. The price probably needs to reach USD 45–50 before estimates can start to rise again. Positive earnings revisions improve the fundamental picture and ease the strain on valuations. Investors are therefore advised to monitor movements in earnings estimates very carefully. Positive signals on the earnings side can be reasonably interpreted as signals for further market gains. 2. Asset classes Alternative investments Alternative investments Alternative investments – overview Commodities: performance since April 2014 Private equity: performance since April 2014 (indexed) 140 120 110 130 100 90 120 80 110 70 100 60 50 90 40 80 30 70 20 A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F MA Bloomberg Commodity Index (rebased on oil) A M J WTI crude oil (USD) Precious metals: performance since April 2014 J A S O N D J F M A M J LPX Major Market TR Index (EUR) J A S O N D J F MA LPX Major Market TR Index (USD) Convertible bonds: performance since April 2014 (indexed) 1,400 110 1,300 105 1,200 100 1,100 95 90 900 800 85 A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J Gold (USD) J A S O N D J F MA A M J Silver (rebased on gold) J A S O N D J F M A M J UBS Convertible Index (USD) Real estate: performance since April 2014 (indexed) J A S O N D J F MA UBS Convertible Index (CHF hedged) Hedge funds: performance since April 2014 (indexed) 135 125 130 120 125 115 120 115 110 110 105 105 100 100 95 95 90 90 85 A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J FTSE EPRA/NAREIT TR Index (USD) Legal notes on page 32 J A S O N D J F MA SXI Swiss Real Estate Index (CHF) A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J HFRX Global HF Index (USD) J A S O N D J F MA Newedge CTA Index 23 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Alternative investments 1,000 Alternative investments | Bernhard Allgäuer, Norman Quaderer 24 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Alternative investments Market outlook Adapting portfolios to negative interest rates The trend towards negative bond yields (see “Top issue of the month”) is increasingly driving investors to search for alternatives. The Swiss market is spearheading this development. Since the start of 2015 even 10-year Swiss government bonds have been yielding less than zero. Portfolios need to be adapted to the new situation, and what happens in Switzerland could become a blueprint for international portfolios in the future. A distinction has to be drawn between institutional and private portfolios. Swiss occupational pension schemes, for example, are obliged to ensure that the funds under their management generate income at or above a legally fixed minimum rate, which currently stands at 1.25% per annum. This can no longer be achieved by investing in government bonds, as used to be the case. Possible solutions to this dilemma are as follows: • Holding larger positions in riskier asset classes offering a higher return. • Switching to riskier segments within a given asset class, e.g. by including high yield or emerging market bonds in the fixed income allocation. • Making bigger and more frequent tactical portfolio adjustments. • Adding new asset classes (notably “alternative investments”) to achieve diversification. In practice investors often adopt a combination of solutions rather than plumping for just one approach. It should be remembered that institutional investors are subject to legal restrictions on their investment activities. Solutions adopted in the institutional sector are generally implemented by private investors with a time lag. Increased role for real estate investments A strong trend among Swiss institutional investors in recent years has been investment in real estate. This has been a factor behind the rise in Swiss property prices (with a resultant increase in risk). Even now, exchange traded real estate funds still deliver a handsome yield of 5.08%. Added to that, higher property prices have generated capital gains of 7.5% p.a. on real estate funds since the start of 2014, while shares in real estate companies have done even better, climbing by 15.2% p.a. But real estate price performance varies greatly from canton to canton and even from one municipality to another. There are also big differences depending on the type of property (apartments, single-family houses, office space, retail properties). A distinctive feature compared with other types on investment is the proportion of debt finance employed (leverage), which is particularly high in the case of real estate companies. In reaction to heightened risks, there is now a growing trend towards investing in the global real estate market via exchange traded real estate investment trusts (REITs). In contrast to Swiss real estate funds, where leverage is normally between 10% and 20%, REITs are mostly leveraged at 70% to 80%. In this context attention must be paid to the currency risk, which as far as possible should be hedged. Real estate is an example of an asset class with heightened risk that can generate a positive return over the long term. Other alternative investments that serve the same purpose include convertible bonds, CTAs (trend-following commodity trading advisors) and smart beta funds, all of which are increasingly being used in investment portfolios. Commodity investments, on the other hand, are included in portfolios principally for the sake of diversification. Commodities: platinum as a tactical diversifier Platinum is a widely used raw material employed in the manufacture of high-performance batteries, catalytic converters and jewellery. It is also increasingly being used in medicine and dentistry. 80% of European demand for platinum is for catalytic converters in the automobile industry, whereas sales for jewellery-making are especially strong in China. The price of platinum has recovered strongly since its January low and has now reached a plateau. The recovery Highlights • Negative interest rates are encouraging new approaches to asset allocation. • Real estate provides a strategic means of generating a positive yield on the basis of higher risk. • Platinum, by contrast, is an example of an asset offering a tactical investment opportunity. was driven by a stronger gold price and an appreciation of the South African rand. There has also been a rise in demand since the start of the year, driven chiefly by China. Total demand in March was 71% higher than a year before, boosted by a significant recovery in the jewellery sector. At the same time, low prices in January encouraged industrial users to build up their inventories. The important automobile market still boasts a positive outlook, with increased demand for catalytic converters in Europe and India. Jewellery demand likewise continues to climb (24% growth reported). Platinum: demand and supply at a glance Conclusion Unlike gold, platinum is an industrial metal and can therefore benefit from healthy economic activity. The fundamentals remain robust and indicate further upside potential. We expect a gentle rise in the platinum price over the weeks ahead. 300 2,000 250 1,500 1,750 1,250 1,000 200 750 500 150 2011 2012 2013 Platinum total demand (tons) Platinum price, USD/oz. (r-h scale) 2014 2015 Platinum total supply (tons) Total supply has also rebounded, with South African mines stepping up production. Output in 2015 amounted to over 125,000 kilos, compared with 94,000 kilos in 2014 – an increase of around 33%. We therefore expect the present imbalance between supply and demand to be whittled down. Even so, platinum producers still face enormous challenges. Major mines have seen their cash reserves evaporate, which rules out large-scale capital spending projects. South Africa is also facing a new round of wage negotiations, which are generally bad news for mine owners. But what is bad for the mines is generally good for the platinum price. The fundamentals have improved slightly since the start of the year. True, above-ground stocks have not really diminished and investor demand is in retreat, but there are positive signals regarding other components of demand. Legal notes on page 32 Benchmark Commodities Gold Crude oil Commercial real estate Private equity Convertible bonds Hedge funds May 2016 À À À ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ % YTD1 7.02% 8.62% 17.29% 4.11% –1.03% 0.96% –1.28% Upside/downside ranges indicated by our 3–6 month absolute performance assessments: ½> +5% À+2% to +5% ¼–2% to +2% –5% to –2% ¾< –5% 1 As of 22/04/2016 25 | May/June 2016 | Asset classes | Alternative investments 2010 3. Investment management Investment management | Aurelia Schmitt, Christoph Boner Investment management portfolios Strategic and tactical allocation – balanced portfolio based in CHF (% weightings) Hedge funds Money market 8 9 Convertibles 3 Commodities 8 14 2 Government bonds 10 Strategic 2 3 41 10 8 40 5 Europe 34 15 Corporate bonds 15 5 6 16 44 Money market Bonds Equities Alternative investments 15 3 3 North America 5 14 6 Pacific 5 9 8 3 Global bonds Tactical 7 6 Emerging markets 18 Switzerland VP Bank Strategy Funds Product name Curr. ISIN NAV date NAV Payout Currency hedged YTD perf. % VP Bank Strategy Fund Conservative (CHF) CHF LI0017957502 19/04/16 1,037.14 no yes VP Bank Strategy Fund Conservative (EUR) EUR LI0017957528 19/04/16 1,369.53 no yes 0.63% VP Bank Strategy Fund Conservative (USD) USD LI0100145379 19/04/16 1,301.45 no yes 1.00% VP Bank Strategy Fund Balanced (CHF) CHF LI0014803709 19/04/16 1,492.63 no yes –1.26% VP Bank Strategy Fund Balanced (EUR) EUR LI0014803972 19/04/16 936.68 no yes –0.52% VP Bank Strategy Fund Balanced (USD) USD LI0014804020 19/04/16 1,417.79 no yes 0.96% For detailed information on our investment management mandates, please contact your personal advisor. Legal notes on page 32 –0.19% 27 | May/June 2016 | Investment management | Investment management portfolios Emerging markets Investment management 28 | May/June 2016 | Investment management | Current investment tactics Current investment tactics Current investment tactics In February we raised our equity allocation from neutral to overweight. Equity markets and commodity prices have since recovered significantly, helped by expansionary monetary policies. The recovering oil price has fuelled a strong advance on equity markets in some emerging economies, while credit spreads in the bond sector have narrowed significantly. Our positioning produced handsome capital gains, notably in the emerging markets. The Fed’s waitand-see attitude and the resultant mild depreciation of the US dollar against the euro have exposed the eurozone to a stronger headwind, and this has been aggravated by other factors such as difficulties in Greece and the ongoing discussion about a possible “Brexit”. Thus the recovery in the eurozone has been more subdued than expected. However, the recent worldwide uptick in purchasing managers indices for the manufacturing sector makes a moderate recovery of economic activity more probable. In view of the risks that exist, we have taken measures to lock in profits as far as possible in the event of a correction. Bonds Government bonds have been boosted by anxiety about economic growth. We have taken profits on government bond holdings in EUR-based portfolios and are keeping duration below benchmark in our base currencies. Overall we are still underweight in investment grade bonds. Emerging market bonds, however, are weighted at neutral. This asset class features an attractive risk premium and is supported by increased risk-tolerance and rising commodity prices. We regard current inflation expectations as too low and therefore hold a position in inflation-linked bonds as an attractive alternative to standard government issues. Equities Manufacturing companies are now looking to the future rather more optimistically, as evidenced by leading indicators in the developed countries and also in the emerging economies. This is the main reason why we remain over- weight in equities. We favour the eurozone as well as the emerging markets. Eurozone equities benefit from attractive valuations and continuing support from the European Central Bank. As long as global growth rates stay positive, equities have upside potential. Additional support comes from dividend yields, which are high compared with yields in the fixed income market. Emerging markets are underpinned by the stabilisation of commodity prices and continued earnings growth. Alternative investments and currencies We hold positions in alternative investments, notably commodities, convertible bonds and hedge funds, as a useful portfolio component providing risk diversification. These categories are weighted at neutral. We have an open EUR position in our CHF-based portfolios. Otherwise currencies of the major developed countries remain hedged. Investment management Return Our solutions Money market Bonds Equities Risk Features Equity allocation Investment horizon Fixed income Conservative Balanced Growth Equities 0% 10–30% 20–50% 30–70% 80–100% 3 years 5 years 7 years 10 years 15 years Conservative Balanced Growth Equities Alternative investments Expected return Investment solutions Fixed income Strategy fund 1 unit Fund mandate from CHF 250,000 or equivalent Classic mandate from CHF 1 mn or equivalent Special mandate from CHF 2 mn or equivalent Portfolio management enhanced mandate from CHF 5 mn or equivalent Legal notes on page 32 29 | May/June 2016 | Investment management | Our solutions Liquidity requirement 4. Appendix Allocation Strategic Long-term division of an investment portfolio into various asset classes (money markets, bonds, equities, alternative investments) on the basis of a defined investment strategy. The strategic allocation is reviewed twice a year and adjusted if appropriate. Tactical Modification of the strategic allocation by short-term variations. The tactical allocation is the portfolio mix implemented at any given time with the aim of achieving an above-average return. Benchmark A standard, e.g. a market index or index-based portfolio, against which the performance of a portfolio is measured. Bond fund Investment fund investing chiefly in bonds of the currency stated in the fund‘s name. Commodity fund Investment fund investing chiefly in tradable commodities and commodity-linked financial instruments. Conversion premium Percentage difference between the price of a share acquired by converting a convertible bond and the price of the same share bought directly on the stock market. Conversion price The price at which a convertible bond can be converted into shares or participation certificates. The conversion price is fixed when the convertible bond is issued. Convertible bond fund Investment fund investing chiefly in convertible bonds. Currency hedging Technique whereby the value of an investment or debt denominated in a foreign currency is protected against exchange rate movements. Investors and borrowers achieve this by taking positions in the currency futures market. Hedging excludes the risk of exchange losses but also rules out the possibility of exchange gains. Dividend yield A measure of the profitability of an equity investment, calculated by comparing a company‘s dividend with its current share price. This figure can be used to make yield comparisons with other types of capital market investment. Duration A weighted average of the maturity of all income streams (principal repayment and interest payments) from a bond or bond portfolio. In the case of coupon payments the duration is shorter than the period to maturity. In the case of zero coupon bonds duration and maturity are identical. Equity fund Investment fund investing chiefly in equities of the country or region stated in the fund‘s name. Euribor (Euro Interbank Offered Rate) Interest rate at which first-class banks borrow from each other at short term on the euro interbank market. Exchange traded commodity (ETC) A secured debt instrument with an unlimited term whose value is coupled to the value of one or more commodities. Exchange traded fund (ETF) Investment fund whose composition mirrors that of an index and which can be traded at any time without an issue commission. Exchange traded notes (ETNs) are debt securities. Although distinct from investment funds, they have similar characteristics. Like an ETF, they are traded on an exchange and usually linked to the return on a benchmark index. Special types of ETN are exchange traded certificates and exchange traded commodities. Fiduciary deposit A money market transaction in which a bank places a deposit with a foreign bank on a client‘s behalf. The deposit has a fixed term, fixed amount and fixed interest rate, or it may take the form of call money with a 48-hour period of notice. Fiduciary deposits can be made in various currencies. The deposit is in the name of the client‘s bank but for the account and at the risk of the client. Fixed-term deposit Money deposited by a client with a bank for a fixed term and at a predetermined interest rate. Fixed-term deposits are subject to a minimum Legal notes on page 32 deposit amount (frequently CHF 100,000) with terms ranging from one to twelve months. Fund of funds Investment fund that invests exclusively in other investment funds. Hedge fund Investment fund in which the manager can employ various alternative investment techniques such as leverage, short-selling and derivatives. Investment grade Credit ratings of BBB to AAA, indicating that the securities are of satisfactory to very good quality. ISIN International Securities Identification Number. LIBOR (London Interbank Offered Rate) Interest rate at which first-class banks borrow from each other at short term on the interbank market in London. Lombard loan Loan granted against a collateral pledge of securities, bank balances, precious metals or claims under life insurance policies. Lombard loans can be granted for private or commercial use and can take the form of a fixed loan or overdraft. Medium-term note Debt security issued on tap by Swiss and Liechtenstein banks with a maturity of two to eight years. Money market fund Investment fund that invests only in assets with a very short remaining life to maturity or with a very short duration. NAV (net asset value) Value of a unit of an investment fund, calculated by taking the market value of the fund on a specified date, deducting the fund‘s liabilities and dividing the result by the number of units outstanding. Open end An open end certificate is a certificate that has an unlimited life. The holder can remain invested as long as he likes. Price information / indicative prices The prices stated in this publication are closing prices on the date indicated. They are net prices, i.e. excluding purchasing costs. The price of an asset when bought on the stock exchange or other market will usually differ from the price stated in this publication because of changes in supply and demand. Current prices are available from your advisor at VP Bank. Private equity fund Investment fund investing chiefly in equity securities that are not (yet) listed on an exchange. The liquidity of such funds can be very limited. Real estate fund Investment fund that invests on a diversified basis in land and buildings and sometimes also in equity or debt securities of real estate companies. Strategy funds A family of strategic investment funds distinguished by different risk categories. The portfolio mix of each fund is based on the corresponding asset allocation of VP Bank. Third party fund Investment fund issued on behalf of and managed by a third party. Volatility The range of fluctuation of an interest rate or asset price (stock, bond, commodity, investment fund unit, etc.) within a given period. It is a mathematical expression (annualised standard deviation) of the overall risk on an investment. For example, to find the standard deviation for changes in the price of an investment fund, one takes the average price of the fund over a given period and then calculates how far the price has deviated from that average during that period. The greater the range of fluctuation, the more volatile and therefore more risky the fund is. Risk can also be expressed as maximum loss. Yield The effective interest rate on a bond, as calculated by the ISMA (International Securities Market Association) method. This internationally recognised method is the most commonly used basis for yield calculations. It permits precise adjustments for fractional periods and multiple coupon payments within a year. YTD perf. % Year-to-date performance in per cent, i.e. performance from the start of the current year to the present date. 31 | May/June 2016 | Appendix | Glossary Glossary Important legal information (Disclaimer) 32 | May/June 2016 | Appendix | Disclaimer Principal sources of information / No warranty: This document was produced by VP Bank Ltd (hereinafter referred to as VP Bank) using sources that are believed to be reliable. The principal sources of information for this document were: • secondary research (financial analyses by specialist brokers/ analysts); • information published in domestic and foreign media and by wire services (e.g. Bloomberg, Thomson Financial Datastream, Reuters, etc.); • statistics in the public domain. Although the utmost care has been taken in producing this document, VP Bank does not warrant that its contents are complete, up-to-date or correct. In particular, the information in this document may not include all relevant information regarding financial instruments or their issuers. The opinions expressed in this document reflect the opinions of VP Bank on the date stated in the document. It is possible that VP Bank and/or its subsidiaries have published in the past or will publish in the future documents that contain information and opinions that do not accord with those in this document. VP Bank and/or its subsidiaries are not obliged to provide recipients of this document with such documents offering different information or opinions. Suitability / Not an offer: The information contained in this document does not constitute a recommendation to buy, hold or sell the financial instruments described herein, nor does it constitute advice on legal, financial, accountancy or taxation matters or any form of personal advice.In particular, the financial instruments discussed in this document may be unsuitable for an investor on the basis of his/her investment objective, time horizon, risk tolerance, risk capability, financial situation or other personal circumstances or because of sales restrictions applying to a particular financial instrument. The information provided in this document is therefore in no way a substitute for individual advice by a specialist qualified in the matters referred to or a substitute for perusal of the documents provided by the issuers and sellers of the financial instruments (e.g. issue prospectuses, term sheets, full and simplified investment fund prospectuses). In particular, this document does not constitute an offer, a solicitation to make an offer or a public advertisement inviting participation in transactions involving the financial instruments described herein or an invitation to enter into any transaction. VP Bank and its subsidiaries expressly refuse to accept any liability for any detriment or loss allegedly incurred as a result of the information contained in this document. Notes on risk: The price and value of the investments mentioned in this document and the returns achieved on these investments may rise or fall. Investments denominated in foreign currencies are also exposed to exchange rate fluctuations. No assurance can be given to investors that they will recover the amounts that they invest. The past performance of an investment is not a reliable indicator of future performance. The same remarks apply to performance forecasts. The performance shown does not take account of any commissions and costs charged when subscribing to and redeeming units in investment funds. Such commissions and costs have a detrimental effect on performance. Any investment mentioned in this document may involve the following risks (the list of these risks should not be regarded as exhaustive): issuer (creditworthiness) risk, market risk, credit risk, liquidity risk, interest rate risk, currency risk, economic risk and political risk. Investments in emerging markets are speculative and particularly strongly exposed to such risks. Proprietary business: To the extent permitted by law, VP Bank and/or its subsidiaries and/or their employees may participate in other financial transactions with the issuers of assets mentioned in this document. They may invest in these issuers or render services to them, acquire orders from them, hold positions in their assets or in options on those assets, carry out transactions in these positions, or have other substantial interests relating to the issuers of assets mentioned in this document. Such actions or situations may already have occurred in the past. Core methods used in financial analysis: VP Bank has adopted the following core methods in its financial analysis: • The stock selection list is based on a global, quantitative screening model. This classifies stocks according to factors that deliver the highest performance levels over the long term. • In each currency sector, bond selection considers only bonds without special clauses (bullet bonds). These tend to be Eurobonds with investment grade ratings and no special risk premiums. Attention is also paid to the marketability factor before allocations are divided into the sovereign and corporate segments. • ETF selection is based on quantitative scoring and a qualitative analysis. • Investment funds are selected according to the “best in class” method. Our multi-tiered analytical process includes both quantitative and qualitative elements. Investment horizon: Recommendations are based on welldiversified portfolios. The recommended investment horizons for balanced port folios are five to ten years, and for equity portfolios generally more than ten years. Explanatory notes on conflicts of interest: Potential conflicts of interest are to be clarified by means of the following numbers appended to the issuer‘s name. VP Bank and/or its Group companies 1. hold more than a 5% equity interest in the issuer; 2. have significant financial interests in relation to the issuer; 3. have within the past twelve months been involved in managing a consortium that issued the issuer‘s financial instruments by way of public offering; 4. are a market maker in the issuer‘s financial instruments; 5. have within the past twelve months concluded an agreement relating to the provision of investment banking services with issuers subjected to financial analysis (with regard to themselves or their financial instruments) or received a service or an undertaking to provide a service under such an agreement; 6. have concluded with issuers subjected to financial analysis (with regard to themselves or their financial instruments) an agreement relating to the conduct of that financial analysis. Notes on the distribution of this document: Access to the information contained or financial instruments (especially investment funds) described in this document may be restricted by national law. Accordingly, the information contained or financial instruments (especially investment funds) described in this document are not intended for persons or corporations subject to any jurisdiction in which access to the information contained or financial instruments (especially investment funds) described in this document is prohibited or made conditional on official authorisation (whether on account of the nationality of the persons concerned, their place of residence or any other reason). Persons who come into possession of this document or wish to acquire financial instruments (especially investment funds) described in this document must therefore acquaint themselves with local laws and restrictions and abide by them. The contents of this document are protected by copyright, and any utilisation other than private use requires the prior authorisation of VP Bank. British Virgin Islands: This information was distributed by VP Bank (BVI) Ltd, VP Bank House, 156 Main Street, Road Town, Tortola VG1110, British Virgin Islands. VP Bank (BVI) Ltd is subject to authorisation and regulation by the British Virgin Islands Financial Services Commission. Hong Kong: This information was distributed by VP Wealth Management (Hong Kong) Ltd, 33/F, Suite 3305, Two Exchange Square, 8 Connaught Place, Central, Hong Kong. Related financial products or services are only available to wholesale clients with liquid assets of over USD 1 million that meet the regulatory criteria and the Company’s policy to be a client, and who have sufficient financial experience and understanding to participate in financial markets in a wholesale jurisdiction. VP Wealth Management (Hong Kong) Ltd is a licensed corporation under the Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571) and is regulated by the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC). Singapore: This document is distributed by VP Bank (Singapore) Ltd, 9 Raffles Place, # 49-01 Republic Plaza, Singapore 048619, Singapore, which is licensed as a merchant bank by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. The new address as from June 2016 is as follows: VP Bank (Singapore) Ltd, 8 Marina View, #27-03 Asia Square Tower 1, Singapore 018960, Singapore. Liechtenstein: This document has been created and distributed by VP Bank Ltd, Aeulestrasse 6, 9490 Vaduz, Liechtenstein. VP Bank Ltd is authorized and regulated by the Financial Services Authority (FMA) Liechtenstein. Luxembourg: This information was distributed by VP Bank (Luxembourg) SA, 26, Avenue de la Liberté, L-1930 Luxembourg, Luxembourg. VP Bank (Luxembourg) SA is subject to authorisation and regulation by the Luxembourg Commission de Surveillance du Secteur Financier (CSSF). Switzerland: This information was distributed by VP Bank (Switzerland) Ltd, Bahnhofstrasse 3, 8001 Zurich, Switzerland. VP Bank (Switzerland) Ltd is subject to authorisation and regulation by the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA). USA/Canada: This document or copies thereof may not be delivered to persons who are resident in or citizens of the USA or Canada. 33 | May/June 2016 | Appendix | Disclaimer Internal regulations and organisational measures to prevent conflicts of interest: VP Bank and its Group companies have implemented a number of internal regulations and organisational measures to prevent potential conflicts of interest and to identify any such conflicts that arise. VP Bank Group VP Bank Ltd is a bank domiciled in Liechtenstein and is subject to the Financial Market Authority (FMA) Liechtenstein, Landstrasse 109, PO Box 279, 9490 Vaduz, Liechtenstein, www.fma-li.li VP Bank Ltd Aeulestrasse 6 9490 Vaduz · Liechtenstein T +423 235 66 55 · F +423 235 65 00 info@vpbank.com · www.vpbank.com VAT No. 51.263 · Reg. No. FL-0001.007.080-0 VP Bank (Switzerland) Ltd Bahnhofstrasse 3 8001 Zurich · Switzerland T +41 44 226 24 24 · F +41 44 226 25 24 · info.ch@vpbank.com VP Bank (Luxembourg) SA 26, Avenue de la Liberté L-1930 Luxembourg · Luxembourg T +352 404 770-1 · F +352 481 117 · info.lu@vpbank.com VP Bank (BVI) Ltd VP Bank House · 156 Main Street · PO Box 3463 Road Town · Tortola VG1110 · British Virgin Islands T +1 284 494 11 00 · F +1 284 494 11 44 · info.bvi@vpbank.com VP Bank (Singapore) Ltd 9 Raffles Place · #49-01 Republic Plaza Singapore 048619 · Singapore T +65 6305 0050 · F +65 6305 0051 · info.sg@vpbank.com VP Wealth Management (Hong Kong) Ltd 33/F · Suite 3305 · Two Exchange Square 8 Connaught Place · Central · Hong Kong T +852 3628 99 00 · F +852 3628 99 11 · info.hkwm@vpbank.com VP Bank Ltd Hong Kong Representative Office 33/F · Suite 3305 · Two Exchange Square 8 Connaught Place · Central · Hong Kong T +852 3628 99 99 · F +852 3628 99 11 · info.hk@vpbank.com VP Bank (Switzerland) Ltd Moscow Representative Office World Trade Center · Office building 2 · Entrance 7 · 5th Floor · Office 511 12 Krasnopresnenskaya Embankment · 123610 Moscow · Russian Federation T +7 495 967 00 95 · F +7 495 967 00 98 · info.ru@vpbank.com VP Fund Solutions (Luxembourg) SA 26, Avenue de la Liberté · L-1930 Luxembourg · Luxembourg T +352 404 770-260 · F +352 404 770-283 fundclients-lux@vpbank.com · www.vpfundsolutions.com VP Fund Solutions (Liechtenstein) AG Aeulestrasse 6 · 9490 Vaduz · Liechtenstein T +423 235 67 67 · F +423 235 67 77 fundsetup@vpbank.com · www.vpfundsolutions.com Published by Group Investment Research VP Bank Ltd Aeulestrasse 6 9490 Vaduz T +423 235 61 73 F +423 235 76 21 investmentviews@vpbank.com Editors and contributors Hendrik Breitenstein, Head of Group Active Advisory & Consulting Bernd Hartmann, Head of Group Investment Research Dr Thomas Gitzel, Senior Economist Rolf Kuster, Investment Strategist Jens Zimmermann, Senior Equity Analyst Bernhard Allgäuer, Senior Investment Strategist Christoph Boner, Head of Investment Management Aurelia Schmitt, Head of Investment Management Liechtenstein Norman Quaderer, Junior Investment Strategist Christina Strutz, Office & Publication Manager Periodicity Bimonthly Publication date 2 May 2016 This publication was finalised on 26 April 2016 Closing prices as at 22 April 2016, unless otherwise stated Sources for charts and statistics Bloomberg, Reuters, Thomson Financial Datastream, unless otherwise stated Photos Roland Korner, Triesen Printed by BVD Druck+Verlag AG, Schaan Swiss Climate climate neutral printing SC2016011404 • www.swissclimate.ch