Dow wntow wn Easstside e LOCAL L AREA PROFIL P E 2013 3 Ch hinatown n Gastown n Industria al Oppe enheimer a Strathcona k Thorn nton Park e Victorry Square A joint publication between: City of Vancouver Community Services – Social Development, Social Policy City of Vancouver Planning and Development Services – Central Area Planning, Downtown Eastside Group Comments and inquiries concerning this publication may be directed to: City of Vancouver 453 West 12th Avenue Vancouver BC V5Y 1V4 Telephone: 3-1-1 Last Updated: November 7, 2013 T Table of Contents IIntroduction ........................................................... 2 F Framework: A Healthy City fo or All ............................... 4 1 1. Toward Healthy People ......................................... 5 Demographicss ....................................................... 5 Population Characteristicss ........................................ 5 2011).................................. 6 Population Growth (2001–2 G Profile ............................................ 6 Age and Gender Language Spoken at Home e ........................................ 8 Immigration .......................................................... 9 1 Aboriginal Identity ................................................. 10 1.1 Making En nds Meet.............................................11 Income ................................................................ 12 1 Social Asssistance ................................................... 13 1 Volunteerring ........................................................ 13 1 1.2 Working Well W ..................................................14 Employme ent Sectors ............................................... 14 1 Informal Economy E .................................................. 15 1 Social Entterprise ................................................... 16 1 1.3 Feeding Ourselves O Well ......................................17 Food Insec curity and Purcha asing Power ........................ 17 1 Free and Low Cost Meals .......................................... 19 1 ets.......................................................... 20 2 Food Asse Food Reta ail .......................................................... 21 2 1.4 A Home fo or Everyone ........................................23 2 Tenure ................................................................ 23 2 Housing Types T ...................................................... 24 2 Single Roo om Occupancy Bu uildings (SROs)...................... 25 2 Non-mark ket housing ............................................... 26 2 1.5 Health an nd Social Service es ..................................27 2 Health Ou utcomes ................................................... 27 2 Health and Social Servicess ....................................... 28 2 Communitty Centres ................................................ 30 3 Basic Needs ......................................................... 31 3 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Grants and Sociaal Purpose Real E Estate ........................ 32 1.6 A Good Start... ................................................ 34 Child Poverty ........................................................ 34 Early Developmeent Instrument .................................. 35 Childcare ............................................................. 36 Schools ............................................................... 37 1.7 Learning for Liffe .............................................. 38 Formal Educatioon .................................................. 38 Learning Resourrces ................................................ 39 Aboriginal Focussed Learning ..................................... 40 C Connecctions ......................................... 41 1.8 Critical Household Struccture .............................................. 41 Mobility ............................................................... 42 1.9 Being and Feeliing Safe ...................................... 43 Women’s Safetyy .................................................... 43 General Safety ...................................................... 44 Infrastructure a nd Facilities ..................................... 45 Reported Crime .................................................... 46 1.10 0 Expressing Ou rselves ....................................... 47 Artist Populationn ................................................... 47 Cultural Assets ...................................................... 49 Neighbourhood C Change and the A Arts .......................... 50 Public Art ............................................................ 51 1.11 Getting Outsid de ............................................. 52 Parks .................................................................. 53 1.12 2 Being Active.. ................................................ 54 Recreation and Gathering Space ............................... 54 1.13 3 Getting Arounnd .............................................. 55 Journey to Workk ................................................... 55 Walking ............................................................... 56 Cycling................................................................ 57 Local Transit......................................................... 58 Commercial Traansportation ...................................... 59 Areas of Concerrn................................................... 59 Page i Pedestrian and Cyclist Collisions ............................... 60 6 2 2. Toward Healthy Communitties ............................... 61 6 6 2.1 In the Neiighbourhood ........................................61 2.2 Out and About............ A .....................................62 6 Library an nd Community Ce entre Use ............................ 62 6 2.3 Across the e City ................................................63 6 3 3. Toward Healthy Environme ents............................... 64 6 Neighbourrhood Change ............................................ 64 6 3.1 A Thriving g Economic Environment .........................66 6 Key Econo omic Sectors ............................................. 66 6 Change in n Economic Sectors ..................................... 67 6 Economic Development ........................................... 68 6 Change in n Property Valuess ....................................... 70 7 Business Improvement Associations ............................ 71 7 3.2 A Sustaina able Natural Environment ........................72 7 3.3 A Well-Pla anned Built Env vironment .........................73 7 Land Use ..................... . ........................................ 73 7 Sub-Area Zoning and Allow wed Uses ............................. 75 7 H .................................................... 78 7 Building Heights Building Floor F Space ............................................... 79 7 Heritage and a Culture .............................................. 80 8 3.4 A Vibrant Social Environm ment...............................82 8 P Page ii ndix A: Vulneraable Population ns in the Downttown Appen Eastsid de ............... ............................................... 84 Women ............................................................... 84 Children and Yoouth ................................................ 85 Seniors ................................................................ 86 Aboriginal Peoplle .................................................. 87 New Immigrantss .................................................... 87 Lesbian, Gay, Biisexual, Transgen nder, Queer and Questioning (LGBTQ) Peoplee .................................................... 87 Low Income Singgles ................................................ 88 Low Income Fam milies .............................................. 88 Renters ............................................................... 89 Single Room Occcupancy (SRO) Te enants ....................... 89 Homeless Peoplee ................................................... 90 People with Disaabilities ........................................... 90 People affectedd by Mental Illnesss .............................. 90 Drug Users ........................................................... 91 Survival Sex Worrkers .............................................. 91 Glossa ary ............... ............................................... 92 Refere ences and Furtther Reading ............................... 95 M Maps, Figu ures and Ta ables Downtown Eastside E Local Pla anning Area .......................... 1 IIntroduction ........................................................... 2 F Framework: A Healthy City fo or All ............................... 4 Building Bloc cks of a Healthy City for All........................... 4 1 1. Toward Healthy People ......................................... 5 Demographicss ....................................................... 5 Population Growth, G 2001-201 11...................................... 6 Age and Gen nder Profile by Su ubarea, 2006 ........................ 7 Language Mo ost Commonly Sp poken at Home byy Subarea, 2006 . 8 Immigration Status by Subare ea, 2006 .............................. 9 dentity by Subare ea, 2006 ............................. 10 1 Aboriginal Id 1.1 Making En nds Meet.............................................11 Prevalence of o Low Income Sttatus by Subarea,, 2005 ........... 11 1 Median Houssehold Income by y Subarea, 2000 and a 2005 ........ 12 1 Total cases for f three welfare e offices serving V6A, V March 2013 ............................................................................ 13 1 1.2 Working Well W ..................................................14 Employmentt by Economic Se ector, 2012. ......................... 14 1 Employmentt Profile of Downtown Eastside Re esidents by Subarea, 200 06 ......................................................... 15 1 Employmentt Services and Selected Social Entterprises, 2012 . 16 1 1.3 Feeding Ourselves O Well ......................................17 Illustration of o Food Purchasin ng Power for a So ocial Assistance Recipient ................................................................ 17 1 Illustration of o Populations att Risk of Food Inse ecurity .......... 18 1 Free and Low w-Cost Meals, 20 011 .................................... 19 1 Food Educattion and Training Resources, 2012 2 .................. 20 2 Food Service e and Retail Busin ness Licenses, 20 013 ............... 21 2 Estimated Population 5-Minu ute Walking Distance from Produce e . ........................................ 22 2 Store, 2011 ..................... 1.4 A Home fo or Everyone ........................................23 2 Housing Ten nure by Subarea, 2006 ................................. 23 2 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Ho ousing Types, 20006 ................................................. 24 Ho ousing Mix, 2011 .................................................... 24 Single-Room Occuppancy Hotels, 2012 ............................ 25 on-Market Housinng, 2012 .......................................... 26 No 1.5 Health and Sociial Services .................................. 27 Se elected Health Ouutcomes and Acccess Indicators .............. 27 Se elected Health Seervices, 2013..................................... 28 Co ommunity and Soocial Services, 20 008 ............................ 29 Do owntown Eastsidee Community Cen ntres Services an nd Po opulations Servedd, 2012............................................ 30 Do owntown Eastsidee Toilets, Drinkin ng Fountains and Showers, 20 012...................................................................... 31 Drrinking Fountainss, 2012 ............................................ 31 Ciity of Vancouver Community Services Grants, 2011 1 .......... 32 So ocial Purpose Reaal Estate, 2012 .................................. 33 1.6 A Good Start... ................................................ 34 Affter-Tax Low Incoome Children Und der 6 by Subarea a, 2005 ... 34 Ea arly Developmentt Instrument Vuln nerability, 2011-2 2012 ..... 35 Ch hildcare Program ms and Schools, 20 012 ........................... 37 Scchool Demographhics, Enrollment a and Programs, 20 012 ....... 37 1.7 Learning for Liffe .............................................. 38 Hiighest Formal Ed ucational Certificcate by Subarea, 2006 .... 38 Pu ublic Post-Seconddary Institutions, 2012 ........................ 38 Ad dult Continuing EEducation Resourrces, 2012 ................... 39 Ab boriginal Educati on Resources, 20 012............................ 40 1.8 Critical C Connecctions ......................................... 41 Prrivate Household Size by Subarea, 2006........................ 41 Le ength of Time at Current Address by Subarea, 200 06 ......... 42 1.9 Being and Feeliing Safe ...................................... 43 Pu ublic Phones, 20112 .................................................. 44 Po olice, Emergencyy Response and Ju ustice System Faccility Lo ocations, 2012 ........................................................ 45 Re eported Crime Inncidences, 2006-2 2011 .......................... 46 1.10 0 Expressing Ou rselves ....................................... 47 Page iii Employmentt in Arts and Cultture, 2006 ........................... 47 4 Non-Profit Cultural C Assets, 2013................................... 49 4 Community-Identified Culturral Spaces Serving g the Low Income e 5 Community, 2012 ..................................................... 50 2 ....................................................... 51 5 Public Art, 2012 1.11 Getting Outside .............................................52 5 Parks and Green Space Provision and Proximity, 2011 ......... 53 5 1.12 Being Ac ctive..................................................54 5 Community Recreation and Gathering G Spaces, 2012 ........... 54 5 1.13 Getting Around A ..............................................55 5 Usual Mode of Travel to Work, 2006 .............................. 55 5 S and Crossw walks, 2013 ......................... 57 5 Pedestrian Signals Bikeway Nettwork, 2012 .............................................. 57 5 Frequent Lo ocal Transit Network, 2012 ........................... 58 5 Pedestrian and a Cyclist-Involv ved Collisions, 20 005-2010 ......... 60 6 2 2. Toward Healthy Communitties ............................... 61 6 6 2.1 In the Neiighbourhood ........................................61 2.2 Out and About............ A .....................................62 6 Libraries and d Community Cen ntres Select Usag ge Indicators, 2006-2010 ............................................................... 62 6 2.3 Across the e City ................................................63 6 Voter Turnout in Recent Elec ctions, 2009-2011 1 .................. 64 6 3 3. Toward Healthy Environme ents............................... 64 6 g Economic Environment .........................66 6 3.1 A Thriving Number of Business B Licenses by Type in the DTES, D 2011 ...... 67 6 Property Asssessment Change, 2001-2011 ........................ 70 7 Business Imp provement Areas, 2013 ............................... 71 7 3.2 A Sustaina able Natural Environment ........................72 7 3.3 A Well-Pla anned Built Env vironment .........................73 7 Land use by type in the Downtown Eastside, 2012 2 ............. 73 7 Generalized Land Use, 2011........................................ 74 7 uilding Heights and Floor Space Ratios, R by Zoning Allowable Bu District ................................................................... 75 7 Zoning Distrricts, 2012 ................................................ 77 7 Building Heights, 2012 ............................................... 78 7 ntial and Residential Floor Space, 2001 and 2011 79 7 Non-Residen Heritage Buiildings, 2013 ............................................. 81 8 P Page iv 3.4 A Vibrant Sociaal Environment .............................. 82 Im mportant Communnity Places and SSpaces Identified in Social Im mpact Assessmentt Public Input Pro ocess, 2012 ................. 83 Appen ndix A: Vulneraable Population ns in the Downttown Eastsid de ............... ............................................... 84 Glossa ary ............... ............................................... 92 Refere ences and Furtther Reading ............................... 95 Downtown Eastside Local Planning Area D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 1 Introduction T The Downtown Eastside, also called c “Q’umq’umal’ay,” is on ne of Vancouverr’s oldest neighb bourhoods and the historic hea art of the ccity. It has a div verse, mixed an nd predominanttly low income1 population livin ng in a neighboourhood rich in h history and stro ongly cconnected to its founding Aborriginal communities, including the Musqueam and Squamish FFirst Nations. Japanese, Chine ese and o other cultural groups g also have e early ties to the neighbourho ood. The unique eness of Downtoown Eastside ste ems from the e early ssettlements in the t areas of Gastown, Powell Street S (Japanto own), Oppenheimer, Chinatownn and Strathcon na. The neighbo ourhood h has many assetss, critical for lo ow income resid dents. Residentss value the sensse of belonging and feelings off acceptance exxperienced iin the Downtow wn Eastside; the e rich diversity of o Downtown Ea astside commun nities linked to their strong culltural heritage; and a access to health h and social serrvices. T The Downtown Eastside struggles with many complex c challen nges including homelessness, h p poverty, afforda able and qualityy housing, u unemployment,, mental health, drug use and crime. c There arre many vulnera able groups livi ng in the Downtown Eastside, and the rrapid changes occurring o in the area are placin ng increased pre essure on these e groups. Rising rental rates an nd displacementt as rrenovations of older o buildings take place are among the facttors contributing to perceptionns of pressure on vulnerable re esidents. M Many jobs are lo ocated in the Downtown D Eastsiide, but relatively few of them m are held by arrea residents. T The high level o of a accessibility to transit servicess and proximity to Downtown is attractive to new emerging b business venturres and developers sseeking to meett the demand fo or affordable co ommercial prem mises and middlle to upper incoome accommodation near the core of tthe city. These fundamental diifferences go to o the heart of the complicated d issues facing D Downtown Eastsside Local Area Planning. A As the Pivot Leg gal Society putss it, “Vancouverr—the most liva able city in the world, w in one oof the most peacceful and wealtthy ccountries in the e world—is a key y trendsetter. How H we addresss the social prob blems represen ted by the Dow wntown Eastside e—one of tthe most concentrated districtts of poverty, illness and addic ction in the world—could set thhe bar for globa al best practicess.”2 F From a City planning point of view, v the Downtown Eastside is a specially de efined boundaryy that straddless the boundariess of two of V Vancouver’s 22 local areas: Do owntown and Strathcona. The neighbourhood’ n ’s unique social , economic and d geographical ccontext a and the particular challenges it i faces have led d to the develo opment of this lo ocal planning aarea. The Downttown Eastside iss further b broken down into sub-areas, re eflecting differe ences in charac cter, population n, built form an d land use. The ese sub-areas arre not 1 The Downtown Eastside Local Arrea Planning Proc cess (LAPP) termss of reference de efines "low incom me" as follows: “L Low income” is brroadly d defined by the Ciity of Vancouver as those who are e living under the e low income cut off line (LICO). IIn the Downtown n Eastside, and fo or the p purpose of the LA APP, the definitio on of “low Income” will be for ressidents who depe end on Income Asssistance, Old Age Pension, part-ttime m minimum wage, informal i and unre egulated labour, and volunteer work w to survive. “Low Income” peoople in the DTES subsist well belo ow the ccity’s low income e cut-off line and d the Canadian po overty line. The exact e number of low income residdents is unknown n. According to th he 2006 C Census, 53 per ce ent of the residen nts in the Downto own Eastside (mo ore than 8,500 pe eople) have afterr tax incomes bellow the LICO. 2 John Richardson n, Pivot Legal Soc ciety, “Heart of the t City”. P Page 2 definitive or the only way to identify different spaces; they are simply a planning tool used to identify key characteristics of different parts of the Downtown Eastside neighbourhood. This profile provides baseline information for the Downtown Eastside, to help the community engage with current and upcoming plans and projects in the area. It builds on the 2012 Local Area Profile by adding maps, updated information and more research. Data have been gathered from a variety of sources including Statistics Canada’s Census of Population, the City of Vancouver, non-profit service providers and, in some cases, primary research shared by low income community members. Using census data in the Downtown Eastside poses particular challenges. First, only limited population information is available from the 2011 Census of Population and National Household Survey3, so 2006 data continue to be used throughout this document in most cases. It had been hoped that some updated data would be available, but this appears unlikely, particularly at the sub-area level. Second, notwithstanding the changes made to the 2011 Census, there are longstanding challenges with the reliability and completeness of census data in the Downtown Eastside, particularly for marginalized and transient populations that are often undercounted. As door-to-door enumeration and paper questionnaires have been diminished in favour of mailed notifications and online questionnaires, some people in the Downtown Eastside have likely not been included in census data. Finally, data at the sub-area level is not always reliable due to small sample sizes and suppression of data.4 However, despite these limitations, the census remains the most comprehensive and reliable information available. This profile is not a complete—or completely accurate—picture of the Downtown Eastside. The information needed to understand aspects of this community may not be available, and the quality of data that are available varies significantly. While all information presented in this document is believed to be as accurate as possible, there remains the possibility of errors, omissions and differences in interpretation or analysis. This should be considered a “living draft” document; it is intended to serve as a beginning, not end, of understanding the people, places and issues facing the complex communities that make up Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside. 3 The 2011 Census was conducted differently than previous censuses, with the former mandatory long-form questionnaire replaced with an optional survey. At the time of this writing, only partial information is available from the 2011 National Household Survey, and the impacts on data quality are not yet known. 4 Statistics Canada is mandated not to report any information which might identify individual respondents; as such, data are always rounded and may be suppressed in areas of small population or low response rates. Note also that census data dissemination boundaries for sub-areas may differ slightly from the planning boundaries. Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 3 Framework: A Healthy City C for Alll Building Blocks of a Healthy City for All The City of Vancouver V is deeveloping a Hea althy City Strate egy as the third compo onent of our oveerall plan for su ustainability. Th his long-term, comprehensive c strategy for soccial development will be based on the e understandingg that the cond ditions in which we are born, grow up, u play, learn,, love, work, an nd age largely d determine our health and a well-being aat different stages throughout our lives. The intercon nnected and intterdependent n nature of these broad determinantts of health and d well-being are e illustrated at left: the building blocks of a healthyy city for all. What does a healthy city foor all look like? We know that the healthiest cities pay attenttion to the heallth of their resid dents, to o their neighboourhoods, and to o the health of the planet the health of that we’re all a living on toggether. That me eans that at the e most basic level we w all need a goood start in life e, a place we ca an call home, enough money to geet by, access to nutritious food d, a strong ort network, a ssense of safety, and plenty of social suppo opportunitie es for working, playing, and liffelong learning.. So, we need to take e care of the baasics. But, healthyy cities also havve places and sp paces that cultiivate belonging, inclusion, conneectedness and e engagement, an nd they have a well--planned built eenvironment, a sustainable nattural environment, a thriving ecoonomic environ nment and a vib brant social ple can live, wo ork and play. environment in which peop B Building a healtthy city for all means m creating the conditions in which we can all thrive, nott merely survive e, in every n neighbourhood.. We know that some of the wo orst health ineq quities in our city—avoidable innequalities in health between groups of p people—are fou und in the Down ntown Eastside. We are using the 20 building blocks b as a wayy to present info ormation in thiss document tto help ensure that t planning an nd monitoring that t is holistic and a comprehenssive, with the ooverall goal of a achieving a healthy city ffor all, including the city’s most vulnerable re esidents. P Page 4 1. Toward d Healthy People P D Demographics W Who lives in the e Downtown Easstside (DTES)? This T section con ntains some basiic data on the p people making up this commun nity and e explores some of o the vulnerabiilities and challlenges they face e. The purpose of this section is to clarify and d dispel traditio onal sstereotypes com mmonly associatted with vulnerrable people, an nd to identify th hose for whom special care an nd attention mu ust be paid tto achieve a mo ore healthy and equitable neighbourhood for all a peoples. P Population Ch haracteristicss T The DTES is one e of Vancouver’s oldest neighbourhoods, with the historic he eart of the city llocated on land d considered by the ccommunities as unceded territtory of the Coasst Salish Nationss and the urban n home of First Nations Aborigiinal communitie es for m many generatio ons. The area is also home to th he immigrant communities of Chinese C and Jap panese Canadia ans and other cu ultural ggroups, includin ng those with Affrican, Asian, European, British, Scandinavian n and South Ameerican heritage e. While many o of the p population are largely considerred low income e, there are also o working poor, moderate incoome and middle e income familie es and ssingles living in a diverse mix of o accommodatiion in seven diffferent neighbourhoods. M Many groups in the DTES are co onsidered vulne erable because they experience greater risk tto health and we ellbeing than th he p population as a whole. These groups g include women, w childre en and youth, ho omeless, seniorrs, Lesbian, Gayy, Bisexual, Transgender a and Queer (LGB BTQ) residents, low income singles and familie es, sex workers, drug users and d people with d disabilities or m mental iillness. Some off the vulnerabilities and challe enges experienc ced by these gro oups include pooverty, safety, a adequate and afffordable a accommodation n, unemploymen nt, poor nutritio on, poor health h, a poor sense of o self-esteem, a lack of wellb being and conne ectedness a and dependency y on social serv vices and charityy. More detail about a specific vulnerabilities v faaced by these ggroups may be ffound in A Appendix A of this t document. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 5 P Population Grrowth (2001–2 2011) B Between 2001 and a 2011, the to otal population of the Downtow wn E Eastside (18,477 7) grew slightly y faster than the e population of the city a as a whole, though the rate of growth has slow wed since 2006 6. G Growth has bee en influenced by y the provision of new accomm modation, iincluding the re enovation and re eplacement of older housing and a hotel sstock with new apartments and d condominiums; and the deve elopment o of sites that had d been vacant, such as the Wo oodward’s proje ect. C Continued repla acement of olde er buildings cou uld maintain the e recent ggrowth rate (12 2.7 per cent from m 2001 to 2011); if so, the 201 11 p population of 18 8,500 could rea ach approximate ely 25,000 by 20 0415. Population Growth, 2001-2011 A Age and Gend der Profile T The concentratiion of males in the Downtown Eastside is strik kingly differentt from other areeas of Vancouve er, which has significant iimplications forr planning and facilities f provisiion in the future e. The gender split s in the Dow wntown Eastside e has remained stable ((approximately 60 per cent ma ale and 40 per cent c female6) siince 2001. Base ed on 2006 data shown on the m map below, Vicctory SSquare and Thornton Park have e the highest prroportional malle population, while w Strathconaa is closer to th he city as a who ole. IIn 2006, just ov ver half of Down ntown Eastside residents were over 45 years of o age. There iss a high percenttage of seniors ((65+) ccompared to the city as a whole. The Downto own Eastside has a relatively lo ow percentage oof children (2 p per cent) and yo outh ((8 per cent), ab bout half the cittywide percenta age. The relativvely small propo ortion of youngg people and the e high concentrration of sseniors need to be considered when planning for future need ds, services and d amenities in thhe Downtown E Eastside. 5 City of Vancouv ver. Research and d Data Services. 2012. 2 Growth ratte is dependent on o construction oof new homes and d replacement off aging SSingle Room Occu upancy (SRO) residences. 6 The census quesstionnaire does not n allow respond dents to indicate a full representa ation of their gennder identity. Peo ople are not provvided with o options to indicatte having transitiioned from male to female or fem male to male; add ditionally, there are no options to o identify outside e of d dichotomous “ma ale” and “female e” categories, or identify with botth “male” and “female”. The usee of gender statisttics from census data is not m meant to be exclusive or normativ ve, but more inclusive data are not available from m this source at tthis time. P Page 6 Age and Gender Profile by Subarea, 2006 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 7 L Language Spo oken at Home T The majority (6 64 per cent) of Downtown D Eastsside residents speak s English ass their main hom me language. Chinese (includin ng both M Mandarin and Cantonese) is the e next most spo oken home lang guage. Strathcon na has a large C Chinese-speakin ng population (4 45 per ccent), which is proportionally even e larger than that of Chinatown. Language Most Commonly Spoken at Home by Subarea, 2006 P Page 8 IImmigration T The Downtown Eastside has proportionately fe ewer immigrantts than the Cityy of Vancouver aas a whole. How wever, the distribution of iimmigrant and non-immigrant n populations witthin the Downto own Eastside is highly uneven. Strathcona and d Chinatown ha ave a large iimmigrant popu ulation while the population in the other sub-areas is much lo ower. Between 1996 and 2006 6, the absolute n number of p people born outtside Canada de ecreased by 6 per p cent, while across a the City of Vancouver t he number decreased by 3 perr cent. Immigration Status by Subarea, 2006 IIn 2006, the Dow wntown Eastsid de had a slightlyy lower proportiion of both tota al immigrants (339 per cent vs. 46 per cent) an nd recent iimmigrants (15 per cent of imm migrants arrived d from 2001 to 2006 vs. 17 perr cent) than thee City of Vancou uver as a whole. The llargest proportiion of recent im mmigrants, 16 per cent, is in Ch hinatown.7 New w immigrants in the Downtown Eastside overw whelmingly ccome from Chin na: 74 per cent of immigrants who w arrived fro om 2001 to 2006 6 came from Chhina.8 Newcome ers often strugglle to enter tthe job market and find afford dable housing. 7 8 Census, 2006. Census, 2006. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 9 A Aboriginal Ide entity T The Downtown Eastside has a much m higher pro oportion of Abo original people than t the city ass a whole. Aborriginal identity iincludes p people of First Nations, Métis or o Inuit identityy. Persons with Aboriginal iden ntity represent m many different First Nations frrom across C Canada. Aboriginal Identity by Subarea, 2006 P Page 10 1.1 Making g Ends Mee et M Measuring low income and pov verty is challeng ging. An imperfe ect measure, bu ut one that is cconsistently app plied and compa arable a across geograph hies, is the afte er-tax low incom me cut-off (LICO O).9 Using the LIICO shows that Metro Vancouvver consistently has a rrelatively high proportion p of its population be elow the LICO.100 In this contextt, the Downtow wn Eastside is an n extreme case;; the most rrecent available e census data sh hows that it hass one of the low west per capita incomes of anyy urban area in Canada. In 2005, 53 per ccent of its resid dents were conssidered low inco ome after tax.111 Prevalence of Low Income Status by Subarea, 2005 9 The LICO varies by community siize and family sizze, and is a relattive measure iden ntifying families oor individuals wh ho spend 20 perce entage p points more than average on a ba asket of basic hou usehold goods, ba ased on a survey conducted in 19992. 1 10 Statistics Canada, CANSIM table e 202-0802,Persons in Low Income e Families. In 201 11, 13.6 per centt of persons in Me etro Vancouver w were in low iincome families, the highest of major m census metrropolitan areas re eported. 1 11 Statistics Canada, 2006 Long-Fo orm Census. Prevvalence of low inc come shows the proportion p of peoople living below w the low income cut-off w within a given gro oup. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 11 IIncome A As of 2005, the median income e for private households in the Downtown Eastside was $13,6691, up from $12,083 in 2000. Median iincome change was the same in Vancouver an nd the Downtow wn Eastside betw ween 2000 and 2005 (13 per ce ent increase). H However, cchanges in median income variied considerablyy by sub-area. The T largest incrrease in incomee was experiencced in Chinatow wn ((44 per cent inc crease) and Victtory Square (31 per cent increa ase), while med dian incomes sliightly decrease ed in the Industrrial area ((10 per cent decrease) and Gasstown (2 per ce ent decrease). Median Household Income by Subarea, 2000 and 2005 P Page 12 Social Assistance Welfare office12 catchment areas are organized according to Canada Post mail forward sortation areas (FSAs), which are the first three digits in a client’s postal code. Most of the Downtown Eastside falls into V6A, which extends from Carrall Street to Clark Drive and from Burrard Inlet to Great Northern Way. However, some residents live in the V6B postal area, which also covers the downtown core, Downtown South and portions of Yaletown and False Creek. In March 2013, there were 6,339 cases of social assistance in V6A, seen in the table below. 13 Total cases for three welfare offices serving V6A, March 2013 Type Cases Expected to Work 1,461 Expected to Work – Medical Condition 115 Medical Services Only 772 Old Age Security 15 Persons with Persistent Multiple Barriers 676 Persons with Disabilities 3,193 Total14 6,339 The shelter component for a single, employable person on income assistance (temporary assistance) is $375 and $235 for all other expenses.15 Social assistance is further discussed in sections 1.3 and 1.4. Volunteering Many residents in the DTES volunteer at service agencies and community centres, such as the Carnegie Centre. In 2013, 2,075 volunteers contributed to 29 organizations funded by the City of Vancouver, giving 108,955 hours of their time.16 This volunteer work is an important part of the survival economy and helps residents make ends meet as well as contribute to their community. Some volunteer opportunities provide food and training in return for hours worked. Additionally, eligible volunteers may be provided with a community volunteer supplement through the Ministry of Social Development’s Community Volunteer Program. 12 Welfare offices are sorted by surname: Dockside office: V6B, V6A Alpha: A to G Kiwassa office: V6B, V6A Alpha: H to M Strathcona: V6B, V6A Alpha: N to Z 13 Ministry of Social Development, March 2013. 14 Includes: child in home of relative, expected to work, expected to work (medical condition), long term care, medical services only, no employment options, old age security, persons with persistent multiple barriers and persons with disabilities. 15 Income assistance effective June 1, 2007 16 Social Policy, City of Vancouver, 2012. Based on self-reporting by organizations that the City of Vancouver funds through Community Services grant programs. Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 13 1.2 Workin ng Well T The proportion of Downtown Eastside E residents who are emp ployed or lookin ng for work is geenerally low compared to the city as a w whole. A significant proportion n of Downtown Eastside residents are considered part of Vanncouver’s working poor, meaning llow-paid workers living in low income situatio ons. As a centra ally located area a with many job bs, the majorityy of people worrking in tthe Downtown Eastside E commu ute from elsewh here in the mettropolitan area. In 2002, an esttimated 13 per cent of people employed iin the Downtow wn Eastside were e residents, witth the remaining 87 per cent of o employees livving elsewhere.17 E Employment Sectors S T The number of people employe ed in the Downttown Eastside appears a to have e remained moree or less stable in the last 10 yyears. T There are appro oximately 19,50 00 employees in n the Downtown n Eastside, work king at total of 2,800 businesse es.18 Employment by Economic Sector, 2012. 1 17 1 18 Messrs Ference e Weicker, 2002. Vancouver Economic Commissio on, 2012. P Page 14 8 Agriculture, Forestry, Finishing and Hunting 29 105 Management of Companies and Enterprises Utilities 115 Mining, Quarrying, and Oil and Gas Extraction 331 Construction 558 Educational Services 406 593 Finance and Insurance Arts, Entertainment and Recreation 615 Transportation and Warehousing 868 Real Estate and Leasing 1189 Health Care and Social Assistance 1192 Wholesale Trade 1524 Public Administration 1401 1542 Administration and Support and Waste Management and… Retail Trade R t il T d 0 Professional Scientific and Technical 500 Other Services (except Public Administration) 1591 1759 Accommodation and Food Services Information and Cultural Industries 1770 1000 Manufacturing 1500 2006 2 2000 2346 2 2500 T The Census data a, presented on n the map below w, shows the em mployment occu upations for Dow wntown Eastsid de residents, wh hich are sslightly differen nt than the econ nomic sectors lo ocated in the Downtown D Eastsiide. According to the 2006 Cen nsus, key occup pation ccategories for Downtown D Eastsside residents in ncluded sales an nd service; trad des, transport aand equipment; business, finan nce and a administration; and arts, cultu ure, recreation and a sport. IInformal Econ nomy Employment Profile of Downtown Eastside Residents by Subarea, 2006 SSome Downtown n Eastside resid dents participate in the informal economy. Th his includes actiivities such as b binning, street vvending or b bartering. Altho ough this economy has little fo ormal recognitio on, it provides an a income for m many people tha at is essential to the a attainment of their basic need ds. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 15 SSocial Enterprise SSocial enterprisses are businessses operated by non-profit orga anizations to su upport social deevelopment. Som me social enterrprises that e employ Downtown Eastside ressidents are show wn below.19 Peo ople with barrie ers to employmeent require add ditional supports to find w work and naviga ate their job on nce employed. The T Downtown Eastside is hom me to employmeent services, wh hich provide add ditional ssupports to peo ople with barriers to employme ent for findings work and navig gating their job once employed d. Employment Services and Selected Social Enterprises, 2012 1 19 Vancouver Economic Commissio on, 2011. P Page 16 1.3 Feedin ng Ourselv ves Well M Many low incom me residents of the t Downtown Eastside lack su ufficient income e to access basiic needs, includ ding affordable,, n nutritional, safe e and culturally y-appropriate fo ood, discussed further f in sectio on 1.1. T The Downtown Eastside has the highest numb ber of SRO residences in the citty. 20 SROs typiccally contain on nly limited kitch hen ffacilities, limiting residents’ ab bility to prepare or store theirr own food. Lack of food prepaaration facilitiess presents a cha allenge for llow income resiidents. This con ntributes to a he eavy reliance on charitable foo od sources and on inexpensive e highly processe ed foods llacking in nutrittional quality. These T barriers further f exacerb bate difficulties faced by resideents in their ability to purchasse healthy a and affordable foods. T The Downtown Eastside has the highest conce entration of free e and charitable food in Vancoouver. Food inse ecurity is a majjor issue ffor many Downttown Eastside re esidents. F Food Insecurity and Purcha asing Power T The graphic at right r illustratess an example mo onthly b budget for a sin ngle male, aged 31-50, living in n a private SSRO and receiviing social assistance. As shown n, p purchasing a he ealthy basket off food21 is likelyy beyond tthe means of th his individual. Illustration of Food Purchasing Power for a Social Assistan nce Recipient T The graphic on the next page summarizes s som me key d demographic indicators of food d insecurity at the t p population leve el. This graphic is adapted from m a 2006 p paper prepared by Vancouver Coastal C Health, and is not iintended to illustrate all of the e factors that give rise to ffood insecurity.. 2 20 2 21 City of Vancouv ver Housing, 2013. There are 5,49 97 units of SRO housing. Healthy food basket costs adapted by Vancouver Coastal Health from Dieticians of o Canada. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 17 Illustration of Populations at Risk of Food Insecurity P Page 18 F Free and Low w Cost Meals T The map below illustrates agen ncies providing free or low-cosst meals in 2011 1, as compiled b by Vancouver C Coastal Health. Locations a are self-reporte ed by organizatiions; this map is not comprehe ensive, and defiinitions of low-ccost meals varyy. Free and Low-Cost Meals, 2011 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 19 F Food Assets F Food assets in the t Downtown Eastside E include e urban agricultture, such as community gardeens, urban farmss and a community o orchard; and ca apacity-building g resources such h as community kitchens and trraining program ms. These are im mportant neighb bourhood ggathering place es that increase local food prod duction; and pro omote urban he ealth, sustainab bility, livability,, community bu uilding, iinter-generation nal sharing and social interactiion. There are eight e food-prod ducing gardens w with approxima ately 650 plots o on City, p park, school and d private lands in the Downtow wn Eastside. SO OLEFood, a non-profit organizattion that emplo oys Downtown E Eastside rresidents in the e local food secttor, operates tw wo urban farm sites s in the Dow wntown Eastsidee. Food Education and Training Resources, 2012 P Page 20 F Food Retail T The map below illustrates food d-related busine esses located within w the Downtown Eastside p planning bounda aries. Note, how wever, tthat food busine esses serving Do owntown Eastside residents alsso exist outside e the planning aarea. Food Service and Retail Business Licenses, 2013 A result of genttrification in the e Downtown Easstside is that ne ew businesses are a locating in tthe neighbourho ood, many of w which are u unaffordable to o low income residents. Work iss ongoing to furrther research retail r affordabi lity for Downtown Eastside ressidents. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 21 A Access to fresh produce within n walking distan nce is fundamen ntal for a nutritiious diet. Approoximately 83 pe er cent of Down ntown E Eastside residen nts are believed d to be within a five-minute wa alk of a store se elling produce, but not all of tthese stores are e a affordable and accessible to alll members of the t community. Food access re emains a pressinng challenge in the Downtown Eastside. Estimated Population 5-Minute Walking Distance from Produce Store, 2011 P Page 22 1.4 A Hom me for Everryone A As of the 2006 census, c average e gross rent in the Downtown Eastside E was $47 77, compared tto $898 across tthe city. For ma any rresidents, the comparatively c lo ow rental rates are still expenssive; half of Downtown Eastsid de renters (51 p per cent) paid m more than 3 30 per cent or more m of their ho ousehold income on shelter costs compared to o 23 per cent inn Vancouver ove erall.23 T Tenure T The vast majoriity of Downtown n Eastside dwelllings are rented d. The lowest cost c rents in thee Downtown Easstside are found d in the SSRO stock; however, even thesse units are una affordable for many m low income residents on ssocial assistancce. Housing Tenure by Subarea, 2006 2 23 Census, 2006. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 23 H Housing Type es A According to 20 006 census data, the most common housing ttype in the Dow wntown Eastside e was apartmen nts (almost 90 per p ccent), with the majority of uniits were in build dings more than n ffive storeys talll. Variations in housing h types occur o across sub ba areas; for exam mple, nearly 90 per cent of detached homes in n tthe Downtown Eastside E are fou und in the Stratthcona sub-area a.24 Housing Types, 2006 IIn 2011, there were w 1,522 non--market SRO un nits, all renting at $ $375; and 3,975 5 privately owne ed SROs, of whiich 27 per cent ((1,073) rent at $375. In 2011, the t City of Vanc couver’s LowIIncome Housing g Survey found an a average rentt of $416 for a rroom in a privatte SRO residenc ce in the Downttown Eastside. T The number of units being rented at the sheltter component of w welfare has bee en declining.25 2 24 2 25 2 26 2 27 2 28 Housing Mix, 2011 Since De ecember 2010, 200 2 units of sup pportive housing g have bee en completed, and 286 are und der construction and are expected to be e completed by 2014. All units 2 will be rented r at $375.26 In 2012, there were 846 6 homeless people in the Downtow wn Eastside27—6 675 were shelte ered and 171 we ere 28 on the sttreet. In 2011, there were 905 5 community ca are facility bedss in the Do owntown Eastsiide for women, seniors, youth and men n. Many of these e beds are locatted within non-market housing h or transsitional housing g developments. 2006 Census. Note N that SROs arre not counted co onsistently in cen nsus data. City of Vancouv ver. Downtown Eastside E Key Houssing Facts, June 12, 1 2012. Ibid. City of Vancouv ver Homeless Cou unt, 2012. City of Vancouv ver. Downtown Eastside E Key Houssing Facts, June 12, 1 2012. P Page 24 SSingle Room Occupancy O Buildings (SROs)) SSRO hotels and rooming housess make up a large portion of th he market renta al stock in the D Downtown Eastsside, especiallyy for p people on incom me assistance and others living g on a fixed inco ome. Many SRO rooms do not hhave their own bathrooms or kkitchens. A As of 2011, 101 private markett SRO buildings were located within w the Down ntown Eastside, with an additio onal 31 SROs be eing rented a at non-market rates. r The gene eral location of these buildings is shown on the map below. Single-Room Occupancy Hotels, 2012 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 25 N Non-market housing h N Non-market hou using (social hou using) is self-co ontained (own bathroom b and kiitchen) housingg owned and ope erated by a non n-profit or ggovernment age ency. The majority of non-marrket housing uniits in the Downttown Eastside aare for singles. E Excluding the 31 non-market SROs mentioned on the previou us page, there are a 71 non-markket developmen nts in the Downtown E Eastside, shown n below. Non-Market Housing, 2012 P Page 26 1.5 Health h and Socia al Servicess H Health Outcom mes R Recent years ha ave seen improv vements to man ny health indica ators in the Dow wntown Eastsidee, including longer life expecta ancy, llower rates of infectious disease, fewer overd dose deaths and d greater service provision. Hoowever, Downto own Eastside ressidents ccontinue to exp perience worse health outcome es than the gene eral population n, with many coomplex health challenges and b barriers to a accessing care. Positive health h outcomes depe end on factors such as access to t quality food;; safe and secure housing; and d positive e early child deve elopment. Selected Health Outcomes and Access Indicators D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 27 H Health and So ocial Services T There is a high concentration of o health and so ocial services in n the Downtown n Eastside. The following mapss illustrate the d distribution of services s by type e; they do not analyze a or addre ess service leve els or services p provided. Selected Health Services, 2013 P Page 28 Community and Social Services, 2008 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 29 C Community Ce entres T The Downtown Eastside’s four City-funded community and re esource centress serve as servicce hubs, gatherring spaces and o opportunities fo or recreation. Some facilities, such as the Eve elyne Saller Cen ntre, also provid de access to basic needs includ ding sshowers and lau undry. Downtown Eastside Community Centres Services and Populations Served, 2012 P Page 30 B Basic Needs A Access to basic needs, includin ng access to batthrooms, showe ers, water founttains, clothing aand laundry, are a particular cconcern for rresidents in the e Downtown Easstside because of o the rate of ho omelessness and the SRO stockk with inadequa ate bathroom and laundry ffacilities. IIn addition to City C facilities suc ch as libraries and a community centres, many agencies provid de access to toiilet and showerr facilities; a an illustration of o some of these e facilities appe ears on the map p below. Downtown Eastside Toilets, Drinking Fountains and Showers, 2012 Drinking Fountains, 2012 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 31 G Grants and So ocial Purpose Real Estate E Each year, the City C of Vancouv ver provides mo ore than $1 million in grants to o Downtown Easstside organizattions for important sservices for chilldren, youth, fa amilies, Aboriginals, immigrantts, refugees, pe eople with disab bilities, seniors and women. M Many of tthese grants go towards betterring neighbourh hood services fo or vulnerable po opulations and iissues concernin ng social justice e, mental h health and addiictions. In addittion to organiza ations located in n the Downtown n Eastside, 44 oorganizations located outside tthe D Downtown Eastsside that receiv ved grants from Social Policy also reported serving the comm munity in 2011.332 City of Vancouver Community Services Grants, 2011 3 32 City of Vancouv ver Social Policy Division, Survey of 2011 Grant Re ecipients, 2011. P Page 32 A An additional way w the City sup pports organizattions is by providing subsidized d rent, known ass social purpose e real estate, on City o owned or leased d property. Social Purpose Real Estate, 2012 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 33 1.6 A Good d Start A As dicussed in the introductory y section, the Downtown D Eastside has a relativvely small child d population compared to the ccity o overall. Howeve er, a number off children live in n the residentia al areas of Stratthcona and Opp penheimer. C Child Poverty y B British Columbia a has consistenttly had higher rates r of children n in low income e families than Canada overall. Within the Citty of V Vancouver, the proportion of children c under six s living in low w income familie es is approximattely 2.5 times h higher in the Do owntown E Eastside than ac cross the city as a whole. The effects of child d poverty are prrofound; living iin poverty limitts access to food and h healthy nutritio on, daycare optiions, choices re egarding schooliing, and social and a recreationaal opportunitiess. Furthermore,, poverty lleads to stigmattization, discrim mination and alienation.33 After-Tax Low Income Children Under 6 by Subarea, 2005 3 33 SPARC. The Cost of Poverty in BC, B 2011. P Page 34 Early Development Instrument A frequently used measure of child vulnerability is the Early Development Instrument (EDI). The EDI measures school-readiness for six-year-olds on five scales of potential vulnerability: physical, social, emotional, language and communication. As discussed on the previous page, most Downtown Eastside children live in the Strathcona area, which has the highest percentage of children vulnerable on one or more scales in Vancouver. In 2011/2012, 51 per cent of children in Strathcona were considered "not ready for school,” compared to 36 per cent for the entire Vancouver School Board.34 Early Development Instrument Vulnerability, 2011-2012 34 UBC Human Early Learning Partnership (HELP), 2011/12. Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 35 C Childcare A Availability and affordability of quality early learning l and ca are opportunitie es are key issuess, especially for vulnerable fam milies in tthe Downtown Eastside. E Qualitty care and learrning opportunities for children n in their early years have bee en linked to many positive ssocial, economiic and health ou utcomes, for ind dividuals and co ommunities. Wiithout additionaal support and ccare, children in highly vvulnerable environments in the eir early years may m be at greatter risk for diffiiculty in the schhool years and b beyond.35 3 35 Early Learning Advisory Group. Ministry of Healtth and the Ministrry of Children and Family Developpment. British Co olumbia early lea arning fframework, 2008. P Page 36 Schools Childcare Programs and Schools, 2012 The catchment areas for the Downtown Eastside feed into two elementary schools and neighbouring Britannia Secondary School. Reflecting the demographics of the community, there is a larger proportion of Aboriginal students compared to other Vancouver schools. There is also a larger proportion of students with special needs, especially at Britannia Secondary where a Learning Support Program is offered. The proportion of English language learners in the Downtown Eastside is similar to that of Vancouver. School Demographics, Enrollment and Programs, 2012 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 37 1.7 Learniing for Life e O Opportunities fo or learning and development, especially for those t who are marginalized, m caan contribute to o improved indiividual and ccommunity health and well-be eing in countlesss ways. Education is strongly connected to othher determinan nts of health succh as a adequate incom me and decent employment e con nditions, and th here is a clear correlation c betw ween health outtcomes and edu ucation. 36 P People with hig gher education tend t to be healthier than those e without. F Formal Educa ation D Downtown Eastsside residents have h much lowe er rates of formal education th han the city as a whole; more tthan one-third o of rresidents over 15 1 have not com mpleted high school, and less than t 40 per cent have completted a post-secon ndary certificatte, diploma o or degree. Pove erty, addiction and a marginaliza ation are seriou us barriers to acccessing formal education, and d many residentts pursue o other learning opportunities. o Highest Formal Educational Certificate by Subarea, 2006 Public Post-Secondary Institutions, 2012 3 36 Raphael, D. Soc cial Determinantts of Health, 2010 0. P Page 38 Learning Resources Many unique learning resources have sprung up in the Downtown Eastside over the years. Neighbouring post-secondary institutions, including UBC, Capilano University, Vancouver Community College, have started programs or support existing programs for Downtown Eastside residents. For example, UBC runs the Learning Exchange which offers internet access, English conversation circles and, opportunities to learn about the humanities 101 or science 101 courses offered at UBC. The Hastings Education School at Britannia Secondary School runs an adult general educational development (GED) program. Adult Continuing Education Resources, 2012 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 39 A Aboriginal Focused Learnin ng A Aboriginal focussed learning hass been identifie ed as an importa ant contributorr to feelings of cconnection and inclusion. In th he D Downtown Eastsside, there are schools with Ab boriginal focuse ed programs; so ome communityy kitchens have classes tailored d to A Aboriginal participants; there is i an Aboriginall focused daycare; and there are a services thatt focus on programming for Ab boriginal p people. Aboriginal Education Resources, 2012 P Page 40 1.8 Critica al Connections T The presence off friendships, fa amily and strong social supportts are essential for personal heealth and well-b being. H Household Strructure In the Do owntown Eastside, only 44 perr cent of residen nts live in famillies with a part ner and/or chilldren, compared d to 73 per cent of residentss across the Citty of Vancouver. 45 per cent of o Downtown Eaastside residentts live alone, co ompared to 17 per cent of Vancouver residents. 37 owntown Eastside, 70 per cen nt of householdss are occupied by b a single persson, compared tto 39 per cent iin the City In the Do of Vanco ouver. The averrage size of privvate householdss is 1.5 persons per household, compared to a an average of 2..2 for 38 Vancouv ver. Private Household Size by Subarea, 2006 3 37 3 38 Census, 2006. Census, 2006. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 41 M Mobility M Mobility measurres the length of o time a person n has lived at hiis or her current residence. Moobility can be an indicator of ccommunity o ownership and engagement, e bu ut in different ways. w Low mobiility may indica ate secure housiing, or it may in ndicate that pe eople are u unable to move e. Compared to the City overall, the Downtow wn Eastside has a higher percenntage of people e who have lived d in their ccurrent residence for over five e years, and a higher percentag ge of people wh ho have lived inn their residence for less than one year. H However, this masks m the distin nction between sub-areas: Stra athcona is the only o sub-area wiith a larger proportion of resid dents not m moving in the past p five years than the city overall. Length of Time at Current Address by Subarea, 2006 P Page 42 1.9 Being and a Feelin ng Safe W Women’s Safe ety T The safety of women w in Vancou uver’s Downtow wn Eastside is a priority for botth the communiity and the Cityy. Poverty, hom melessness, rracism, sexism and unsafe housing make manyy women more vulnerable to sexual, s emotionnal, mental and physical violen nce. The ccase of the Dow wntown Eastside e’s missing and murdered wom men is a tragic example e of how marginalized w women, includin ng many A Aboriginal women and survival sex workers, can become victtims of homicide. As the Missinng Women Comm mission of Inquiiry has n noted, “Eradica ating the proble em of violence against a women involves addresssing the root caauses of margin nalization, nota ably ssexism, racism and the ongoing g pervasive effe ects of the colo onization of Abo original peoples – all of which ccontribute to th he poverty a and insecurity in which many women w live.39” IIn 2012, 16 per cent of reporte ed sexual assaullts in Vancouver occurred in th he Downtown Eaastside, an area a with only 3 pe er cent of V Vancouver’s pop pulation40. As many m sexual assa aults are unreported, and marrginalized group ps are particularly unlikely to rreport ccrime, this may y be an underestimate. E Estimating the number n of surviival sex workerss in Vancouver is challenging: the overall streeet sex work po opulation is estimated to b be between 1,5 500 and 2,000 in ndividuals, but studies s suggest that at least 80 0 per cent of seex work in Cana ada’s urban centres takes p place indoors an nd is less visible e than street se ex work. Eighty per cent of peo ople engaged inn sex work identify as women, while a about 20 per ce ent identify as males m or transge ender. Transgen nder people ma ay identify as feemale, male, bo oth or neither. A An estimated 40 0 per cent of street sex workers are immigran nt or visible min nority women.411 T The urban Aborriginal populatio on is vastly overr-represented in n street sex work. While comp prising two per ccent of Vancouvver’s p population, abo out 40 per cent of street sex workers w are Aborriginal.42 Severa al authors draw w a direct link to o the negative e effects of ccolonization, including the residential school experience, as contributing fa actors. Despite making up onlyy four per cent o of the ffemale populatiion, Aboriginal women make up a much larger proportion of women who arre missing and m murdered in Can nada. T The first Women’s Memorial March was held on o Valentine’s Day D in 1991 in response to the murder of a Co oast Salish woman on P Powell Street in n Vancouver. Ou ut of a sense off hopelessness and a anger came e this annual eveent which proviides an outlet tto express ccompassion, com mmunity, and caring c for all wo omen in the Dow wntown Eastsid de. Over 20 yearrs later, the Wo omen’s Memoria al March ccontinues to honour the lives of o missing and murdered m wome en. 3 39 W. T. Oppal. Forsaken, The Rep port of the Missin ng Women Commission of Inquiry Volume V 1, 2012. Vancouver Police Department, 2013. 4 41 MAKA Projectt; Farley, M., Lyn nne, J. and Cotto on, A.J. (2005). Prostitution P in Van ncouver: Violencce and the Colonization of First Na ation’s W Women. Transculltural Psychiatry,, 42:2:242-271. 4 42 Farley, M., Lyn nne, J. and Cotton, A.J. (2005). Prostitution in Van ncouver: Violence e and the Colonizzation of First Na ation’s Women. T Transcultural Psy ychiatry, 42:2:242 2-271. 4 40 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 43 G General Safetty A Accessibility of public phones is i a large conce ern in the Downtown Eastside because b many rresidents do nott have a cell ph hone. Only a few public phones remain, with w many of the em operating on nly for 911 callss. As a result, m many non-profitts offer free pho ones to ttheir patrons. An A innovative orrganization, Firsst Funds Societyy, provides a co ommunity voiceemail service to o low income co ommunity m members. Public Phones, 2012 P Page 44 Infrastructure and Facilities Police, Emergency Response and Justice System Facility Locations, 2012 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 45 R Reported Crim me T The Downtown Eastside experiiences higher ra ates of reported d crime than see en citywide. Frrom 2006 to 201 11, reported pro operty ccrime has decre eased, and othe er criminal code e43 and violent reported r crime has increased. N Note that interp preting reported crime statistics can be a frau ught exercise, particularly p in vvulnerable communities. An increase in rreported crime may be due to an improved re elationship betw ween police and d residents. Chaanges to police deployment an nd p priorities can allso affect how crime c is reporte ed. T These figures must m also be und derstood in the context that crrime is expected d to be higher iin central areass in close proxim mity to rregional destina ations. The grap ph below is onlyy a partial pictu ure and a first step s toward a m more complete u understanding o of the ssafety of the Do owntown Eastsid de and its resid dents. Reported Crime Incidences, 2006-2011 4 43 Other criminal code offences in nclude mischief, bail violations, disturbing the pea ace, arson, prostiitution and offen nsive weapons. P Page 46 1.10 Expre essing Ourrselves T The arts play an n important role e in the qualityy of life as w well as the social and economiic vitality of cities. For an iindividual, the arts a can stimula ate, inspire and d e entertain. At th he neighbourhoo od level, strong g creative ccommunities ma ay contribute to o positive chang ge in local e economies, sociial environmentts, neighbourho ood ccharacter and demographics. d A Artist Population Employment in Arts and Culture, 2006 A 2010 report profiled p artists and a cultural workers in C Canada’s five la argest cities.44 The T report foun nd V Vancouver has the t highest concentration of artists a among the five cities, with alm most one-third of o all BC a artists residing in the City of Vancouver. V The cconcentration of o artists in Vancouver is doublle the p provincial avera age and nearly triple t the national a average. Vancouver also has a high number an nd 45 cconcentration of o cultural work kers. T The map at righ ht summarizes the t proportion of o the p population emp ployed in all artss and culture in ndustries in llocal areas. Dow wntown and Strrathcona have higher h cconcentrations of artists and cultural workerss than the ccity as a whole.. 4 44 Calgary, Montreal, Ottawa, Torronto and Vancou uver were studied d. Using data from m Statistic Canadda’s 2006 Census, five variables w were e examined: concentration of artistts and cultural wo orkers within neighbourhoods and d labour force; m median earnings; income gap; education; and ggender balance. 4 45 Hills Strategiess Research. Mapp ping Artists and Cultural Workers in Canada’s Large e Cities, Februaryy 2010. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 47 T The report refe erenced above also a studies posttal FSAs in deptth. The V6A posstal region, whi ch contains mo ost of the Downttown E Eastside, has th he following fea atures: 4 46 Concenttration of artistss: The V6A posttal region had th he second highe est concentratioon of artists in the city at 4.4 per cent of the la abour force and is almost doub ble the concentrration of artistss in the city as a whole (2.3 pe er cent). Income and a earnings ga ap: Artists’ med dian earnings for the V6A posta al area were $144,300 as compa ared to $17,400 median earned by b artists living in city overall, and is 25 per cent c less than all Vancouver woorkers. Educatio on: At least 48 per p cent of artists living in the e V6A region havve a bachelor’s degree or higher, which is com mparable to the sttatistic for city artists. Gender distribution: d Th he V6A postal re egion contains a smaller proportion of femalee artists (36 per cent) than in V Vancouver as a who ole (47 per centt).46 Hills Strategiess Research. Mapp ping Artists and Cultural Workers in Canada’s Large e Cities, Februaryy 2010. P Page 48 Cultural Assets The map below plots the locations of non-profit cultural assets in the Downtown Eastside planning area. Non-Profit Cultural Assets, 2013. Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 49 N Neighbourhoo od Change and d the Arts A Artists tend to be b found in neig ghbourhoods wiith inexpensive housing and acccess to resourcces (studio space, galleries, reh hearsal a and performanc ce spaces, artistt-run centres, associations). a However, neighb bourhoods consiidered “artsy” o or trendy often then b become unafforrdable for the artists a community as gentrifica ation occurs. In the Downtown Eastside, there e is a perception n that a artists are being g displaced due e to rising rent, and migrating east e toward Gra andview-Woodlland. T The map below plots the locattions of assets id dentified by a member m of the LAPP committeee as serving the e Downtown Ea astside’s llow income artiist community; recognizing and d protecting the ese assets throu ugh neighbourhoood change will be a challenge e. Community-Identified Cultural Spaces Serving the Low Income Community, 2012 P Page 50 Public Art Public art has a profound effect on the built environment, and helps to make spaces welcoming and beautiful. Public art is often used as a form of political expression and to highlight the cultural history of the Downtown Eastside. Many public art programs operate in the Downtown Eastside.47 Great Beginnings, a City initiative to improve streets and public spaces and to support cultural activities, funded a mural project that produced more than 30 murals in the Downtown Eastside. These murals are illustrated on the map below along with works of public art catalogued by the City of Vancouver. Public Art, 2012 47 Princess Street Interactive Walk; Creative Pathways project (Community Arts Council of Vancouver). Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 51 1.11 Getting Outside e E Except for Stratthcona, the Dow wntown Eastside e has many mulltifamily b buildings and litttle yard space.. Parks and gree en spaces in the e D Downtown Eastsside are shared—and sometime es contested—sp paces for m many different community gro oups. CRAB Park k, created throu ugh ccommunity orga anizing, exempllifies the importance of accesssible n natural spaces to t this commun nity. O Opportunities to o spend time in n natural areas are a often constrained by a lack of resourrces and time lo ow income peop ple experience. Some p programs have developed d to prrovide Downtow wn Eastside resiidents w with the opporttunity to spend time in nature.. Organizations such as tthe Carnegie Ce entre offer prog grams for seniorrs and low incom me rresidents to go on camping trip ps and day tripss. P Page 52 P Parks T There are five major m parks witthin Downtown Eastside boundaries, consisting g of 14.09 ha; aanother 16.45 h ha are in parks a adjacent tto it.48 This amo ounts to 1.65 ha a of park space per 1,000 resid dents, less than citywide and ssignificantly lesss than City stan ndards. M Most residents live l near a park k or green space e, but access may be constrain ned by barriers ssuch as railwayy tracks and hea avily ttrafficked majo or roads in partss of the neighbo ourhood. Parks and Green Space Provision and Proximity, 2011 4 48 Adjacent parkss include CRAB Pa ark, Trillium Park k, Thornton Park,, Creekside Park,, Andy Livingstonne Park and Cathe edral Square. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 53 1.12 Being g Active T The central core of the Downto own Eastside in n the Oppenheim mer District (DE EOD) has little sspace for relaxa ation and active e rrecreation, apart from Oppenh heimer Park. Co ommunity centrres and social ag gencies providee vital gatheringg and recreation n space for rresidents of the e Downtown Easstside to socialize and play. R Recreation an nd Gathering Space T The map below presents a sele ection of community-identified d recreation and d gathering spaaces, as compile ed for the Carne egie C Centre’s Downtown Eastside re esource guide. Community Recreation and Gathering Spaces, 2012 P Page 54 1.13 Getting Around d R Residents in the e Downtown Easstside commute e more frequenttly by walking, biking or transiit, compared to o citywide avera ages. W While work trips offer only a liimited picture of o mobility,49 given the low lab bour force partiicipation in the Downtown Eastside, high u use of walking, cycling and tra ansit is supporte ed by other indiicators: Adanac is among the ccity’s busiest bikeways; transitt service llevels and riderrship are high, particularly p on Hastings H Street; and many dayy-to-day trips arre made by walking. T The Downtown Eastside’s central location allo ows for conveniient walking, cyycling and transsit trips to workk. However, forr low iincome people, transportation options may be e constrained by b income. JJourney to Work W Usual Mode of Travel to Work, 2006 4 49 Census informattion on modes off travel is only asked for commute e to work trips. While W Translink coollects informatio on on all trips through rregular trip diary y surveys, neighbo ourhood-level da ata are not availa able. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 55 W Walking 5 SStudies in 200950 and 201251 ha ave found that a disproportiona ate number of pedestrian p injurries take place in the Downtow wn E Eastside. The Downtown Eastsiide is home to a large number of particularly vulnerable road d users with spe ecial safety nee eds. A Actions taken to o improve safetty include estab blishing a 30 kilo ometres per hour zone along H Hastings Street from Jackson to o Abbott; iincreasing pede estrian walk tim mes at intersectiions; adding midblock signals; and installing ccountdown crossswalk signals. 5 50 5 51 Schuurman, N., et al. Pedestria an injury and the built environment: an environme ental scan of hotsspots. 2009. BMC C Public Health, 9 9:233. City of Vancouv ver, Pedestrian Safety S Study, 2012. P Page 56 C Cycling Pedestrian Signals and Crosswalks, 2013 W While bike riderrship is relative ely high in the DTES, D there are major gaps in the t bike networrk. In particularr, the area has limited e east-west conne ections. Furthermore, many off the existing ro outes only feel safe s for riders w who are confide ent riding in tra affic. The m map below illusstrates current bikeways and greenways in the e Downtown Eastside. Future aadditions may in nclude: Upgrade es to bike infrastructure on Exp po Boulevard an nd Union Street between Gore Avenue and Ca arrall Street is b being considerred by City Coun ncil in summer 2013, pending further f consulta ation with neig hbouring reside ents and businessses. In conjunction with the e Powell Street overpass projec ct, a new bike connection c will be developed a along Alexander and S addresssing a gap in easst-west bike rou utes through the northern porttion of the Dow wntown Eastside e. Powell Streets, Bikeway Network, 2012 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 57 L Local Transit T The map below illustrates freq quent local (all-stop) transit lin nes operating in n the Downtownn Eastside. Thesse services provvide a all-day access to destinations along a major Dow wntown Eastsid de corridors such as Hastings Sttreet and Main Street, and con nnections tto regional serv vices. Hastings Street S is identiffied as a future rapid transit co orridor. A Additional transsit lines operatiing in the Down ntown Eastside include i the 135 limited stop seervice along Hasstings Street, a and ssuburban express services to th he North Shore,, Port Moody, Coquitlam C and Port P Coquitlam. The West Coasst Express comm muter train o operates on the e railway tracks at the north ed dge of the Down ntown Eastside next to Burrard d Inlet. Frequent Local Transit Network, 2012 P Page 58 Commercial Transportation A significant transport asset and opportunity for Downtown Eastside is the adjacent port, which is linked by rail to the waterfront and through the Downtown Eastside by a north/south rail corridor route through Strathcona. The False Creek flats rail yards, industrial area and station provide additional transport advantages to businesses and industry in this area of the city. Road access to the port is achieved through Downtown Eastside along Heatley Avenue. As a result the Downtown Eastside has a relatively high connectivity to global markets and other regional economic opportunities. Areas of Concern The Downtown Eastside has a significant proportion of wheelchair users and residents dependent on walkers and different forms of mobility assistance. Uneven sidewalks, high curbs lacking ramps, and wide streets with limited crossing times make a challenging environment for people relying on mobility aids. The relative lack of on-street bike facilities can sometimes result in more people cycling or skateboarding on the sidewalk, leading to increased conflicts with pedestrians. Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 59 P Pedestrian an nd Cyclist Collisions T The Downtown Eastside has inttersections thatt are areas of concern for pede estrians and cycclists. The map below illustrattes llocations with five f or more ped destrian- or cyc clist-involved co ollisions from 20 005 to 2010. Pedestrian and Cyclist-Involved Collisions, 2005-2010 P Page 60 2. Toward He ealthy Com mmunities T The Downtown Eastside is a ne eighbourhood off diverse communities that tells a story of com mpassion, tolerrance, activism and hope ffor the future. Residents value e its rich cultura al and communiity heritage, strrong social netw works, acceptan nce of diversityy and sstrong sense of community. Bu uilding, maintaining and supporrting inclusion, belonging and connectedness is critical for w well-being. P Preserving the uniqueness u of the Downtown Eastside, E while addressing a majo or social issues,, is a central ch hallenge for planning in tthis community. 2 2.1 In the Neighbourrhood A 2012 Vancouv ver Foundation report r found th hat social conne ectedness and engagement e is loow in Vancouve er. Their findinggs showed h high levels of lo oneliness; one in n four people in ndicated they are a alone more often o than theyy would like and d a third of peo ople found iit hard to make e friends. 52 The Downtown Easttside provides a slight contrastt; many people reported durin ng the Social Impact A Assessment, desscribed in section 3.4, that the ey had a strong sense of comm munity in their nneighbourhood. A As discussed in section 1.8, ma any people live alone, and man ny of those resid dents live in sm mall SROs. Bars, restaurants, co ommunity ccentres and parrks are often seen as major asssets for gatherin ng and social in nteraction. Pigeeon and Oppenh heimer Parks in particular a are highly value ed by residents,, and are often described as th he living rooms of the Downtow wn Eastside. Soccial service age encies also o offer gathering spaces for vuln nerable residentts. W With the influx of new residents, many low in ncome people are feeling theirr sense of comm munity eroding. There is particular cconcern about discrimination d towards t low inc come people and decreased afffordability.53 Foor others, the neighbourhood cchanges a are welcomed, and bring with them increased d sense of safetty and improvem ments to the buuilt environment. 5 52 5 53 Vancouver Foundation. Connecttions and Engage ement. A survey of o metro Vancouvver. June 2012. Result of Social Impact Assessm ment. See section 3.4. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 61 2 2.2 Out an nd About SSchools, workpllaces and comm munity organizattions play important roles in so ocial interactio n and increasin ng sense of belo onging. T These places alsso support heallth and well-beiing, volunteerin ng, community building, local oorganizations, cclubs and sportss. L Library and Community C Ce entre Use T The use of Downtown Eastside libraries and co ommunity centres has increase ed, even as cityy-wide use has ffallen. These fa acilities a are important gathering g spacess for Downtown n Eastside reside ents, in addition to offering reecreation and le earning program mming. Libraries and Community Centres Select Usage Indicators, 2006-2010 P Page 62 2 2.3 Acrosss the City C Civic engageme ent and participation take many forms, b but a basic indicator of engage ed citizenship iss voter tturnout. Electio ons at all three levels of govern nment— m municipal, prov vincial and fede eral—have taken n place in tthe last four years54. In all elec ctions, voter turnout has b been significanttly lower in the Downtown Eastside than V Vancouver as a whole. IIn an attempt to o increase vote er turnout in the e D Downtown Eastsside, many prog grams seek to register vvoters who face e barriers to votting. The Carne egie centre rruns voter enga agement program mming to registter and ssupport people in advance pollls or on Election n Day. O Often this involves coordinatin ng witnesses, either sservice providerrs or friends, in n lieu of providing proof of a address. 5 54 At the time of this writing, polll-by-poll voter turnout data for th he 2013 provincia al election is not yet available. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 63 Voter Turnout in Recent Elections, 2009-2011 3. Toward T He ealthy Enviironmentss T The health of people, place an nd the planet arre inextricably linked. l To achie eve a healthy ccity requires a b built environment that is vvibrant and wellcoming, and fa acilitates easy access a to service es and retail. A sustainable nattural environme ent ensures clean air and w water, but also access to naturre. A thriving ec conomic enviro onment develops local employm ment opportunities. A vibrant ssocial e environment provides accessib ble and shared spaces s where we w can meet, lea arn, collaboratee, access servicces, relax and e enjoy. N Neighbourhoo od Change T The Downtown Eastside is chan nging, and these e changes affec ct the social, ecconomic and buuilt environmentt of the Downto own E Eastside. This iss of particular concern c for the many vulnerab ble people living g in the Downtoown Eastside wh ho are socially a and e economically marginalized. m An ny large and rap pid changes occu urring in the ne eighbourhood pllace pressure on vulnerable re esidents tthrough rising re ental rates, displacement as re enovations of older o buildings take t place, the closure of the ffew remaining affordable b businesses, and the accompany ying feelings an nd perceptions of o exclusion fro om a gentrifyingg landscape. The City of Vanco ouver’s p philosophy in th he Downtown Ea astside has been “revitalization without displacement”—meaaning that the e existing low inccome rresidents will be e a stable part of a future com mmunity that wiill also include people with divverse social and d economic backgrounds. “ “Revitalization without displac cement” is provving to be a cha allenging philoso ophy to achievee amidst the current land use cchanges ttaking place. Se everal factors se erve as evidenc ce that the Dow wntown Eastside e is experiencingg growth and ch hange and will probably ccontinue to do so s in the future e: 1. Populatiion growth in the t Downtown Eastside E as a wh hole (12 per cen nt) between 20001 and 2011 wa as slightly fasterr compare ed to the city att large (10 per cent). c The Deve elopment Capaccity model of thhe Downtown Eastside estimattes a growth of o approximatelly 7,000 people e by 2041 based on current rate es of developmeent and land usse constraints, ssuch as the availabillity of suitable redevelopment properties, the e Rate of Chang ge Policy for Reental Housing, e etc.55 2. The high h level of accessibility to transsit services and d proximity to the t Downtown ccore is attractivve to new emerrging businesss ventures and developers d seek king to meet the e demand for afffordable comm mercial premise es and middle to o upper income accommodation a n near the core of the city. 3. The neig ghbouring down ntown peninsulla has been the focus of majorr residential devvelopment overr the last decad de. Some of this has occurred within n the Downtown n Eastside throu ugh renovation of older buildinngs and some in n new neighbourhoods nearby. There has been n a mix of mark ket and non-marrket housing, with most being market units. 4. Analysis of the distributtion of vacant and a underdeve eloped propertiies reveals therre is capacity in n the Downtown n Eastside for addittional developm ment at even moderate m levells without affec cting heritage b buildings or ex xisting tall struc ctures. 5 55 City of Vancouv ver. Research and Data Services. 2012. P Page 64 There is estimated to be potential to accommodate from 6,000 to 10,000 additional units on vacant or I to 2 storey developed sites.56 5. The number of vacant storefronts is currently lower than in 2007, the last time data was available. There has been a noticeable trend of new retail and restaurant outlets in certain parts of Downtown Eastside including Pender, Hastings, Powell, Abbott and Carrall Streets. New commercial activities and retail outlets are being seen in the western sector resulting in less vacant storefronts along Hastings, Pender and Keefer streets.57 6. In spite of the slight decrease in the number of vacant storefronts, rising rents and expenses are seen to be threats to business occupancy.58 56 57 58 City of Vancouver. Research and Data Services. 2012. City of Vancouver. Research and Data Services. 2012. Social Impact Assessment, 2012. City of Vancouver. No quantitative data on business displacement is available. Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 65 3 3.1 A Thriv ving Econo omic Envirronment T The Downtown Eastside has seen a significantt transformation n in its economyy over 125 yearrs since the dayys of early settle ement by iimmigrants. Fro om the trading summer s camps of the Coast Sa alish Nation to a harbour, railw way line, sawmill, steelworks, hotels, b boarding housess, retail, commercial and industrial developm ment. Following the pattern of many major ce entral business d districts a and the adjacen nt precincts, Do owntown Eastsid de is undergoing change with older o buildings becoming unecconomic for their current u uses, leading to o renovation or demolition and replacement with w new structu ures to accomm modate new use es and residentss. T The Downtown Eastside is conssidered geograp phically well positioned to acce ess other markeets in the Lower Mainland beca ause of the H Hastings Street corridor, Skytra ain lines, rail, port p and bus fac cilities. Added to t high accessib bility, the heritage character p provides tthe opportunity y to promote tourism, retail prroducts and servvices. Lastly the ere is a diversitty of land uses a and building typ pes which p provides a mixture of business and employme ent opportunitie es. There is the industrial zonee, tourist areas of Chinatown a and G Gastown, and mixed m commerciial and office sp pace along the Hastings corrido or. K Key Economic c Sectors T The Downtown Eastside has a long l history of manufacturing m and a wholesaling g, and there haas been recent ggrowth in the diigital ccreative industrry and in green jobs. There are e approximatelyy 2,800 businessses and an estim mated 19,500 e employees workking in the D Downtown Eastsside; the most prevalent p Down ntown Eastside businesses are professional, p sccientific and tecchnical servicess; a administrative support, s waste management and remediation n and retail.59 Additionally, theere is a large clu uster of non-pro ofit service a agencies,60 some of which supp port social ente erprises linked to t low threshold d jobs. The cha rt on the next p page provides a b breakdown of th he types of businesses licensed d by the City off Vancouver in the t Downtown EEastside as of 2011.61 5 59 Vancouver Economic Commissio on compared the statistics genera ated by a 2002 stu udy by Messrs Feerence Weicker to o the Dun and Bra adstreet H Hoover’s databasse in 2012. 6 60 The 2008 BC211 Redbook directtory listed an estimated 174 socia al services in the Downtown Eastsside. More recentt BC211 data are not a available. 6 61 It should be no oted that a total of o 1,254 businessses were licensed d compared to the estimated 2,8000 businesses fou und to be operating in the a area in 2012 acco ording to the Dun n and Bradstreet data. The differe ences in data cou uld relate to diffeerent classificatio ons or definitionss of b businesses which may be clustere ed in the same ad ddress and license ed under single names, n rather thaan individually. In n addition, it is b believed tthere are businessses trading witho out licenses in ce ertain areas, eith her in homes and warehouse/factoory style buildinggs. P Page 66 250 200 150 100 50 0 5 5 Miscellaneous Accommodation 6 11 Education Scientific Establishment 12 Finance 6 17 Computer Services Waste Management 20 40 Health and Beauty Transportation & Warehousing 57 62 Community Associations Eating and Drinking Places 65 Construction and Trades 57 74 Arts and Entertainment Personal Services 84 PDR 191 Retail 153 194 Manufacturing Office 206 Wholesale Number of Business Licenses by Type in the DTES, 2011 Number of Business Licenses by Type in the DTES, 2011 On a more granular level, the top five lines of businesses in the Downtown Eastside in 2012 are: business services, eating places, legal services, business consulting and grocery stores.62 Change in Economic Sectors Between 2012 and 2002, there has been little change in the number of employees in Downtown Eastside, and an increase in number of businesses. Details of the implications drawn from the comparison between 2002 and 2012 included:63 62 63 The The The The biggest biggest biggest biggest decreases in business type were retail and wholesale. decreases in employees were wholesale, retail and manufacturing. increases in business type were business services and professional services. increases in employees were professional services, finance and insurance services. Dun and Bradstreet, 2012. Vancouver Economic Commission (2012) and Messrs Ference Weicker (2002). Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 67 E Economic Dev velopment A 2002 study reviewed the opp portunities for economic e develo opment in the Downtown D Eastsside.64 The stud dy identified some viable o opportunities fo or growth in a wide w variety of sectors, s includiing: Retail Tourism Educatio on Apparel Food pro ocessing and wholesale Film, artts, and culture High tech hnology Light man nufacturing, wh holesale, and logisttics Business services Social enterprise IIn 2002, the lev vel of business investment in th he DTES was low w and was proje ected to remainn low over the sshort term. The e iindications thatt led to that con nclusion include ed few development projects in i the previous five years, high h vacancy rates, low llevels of busine ess investment, and businesses shutting down or moving out of o the area. A Attracting new investment to the t area was a critical factor for f economic re evitalization. Foor the DTES, som me of the strengths to a attract new investment include e: The DTE ES is well-positio oned geographic cally to access other markets in i the Lower Maainland. The stro ong heritage of the t region provvides the opporttunity to promo ote tourism and retail productss and services in n an authentiic heritage enviironment. The area a has a long histtory as a centre e for apparel an nd food manufacturing. Property y costs are gene erally lower tha an elsewhere in Vancouver. There is a strong base of o residents, org ganizations, and d business imprrovement assoc iations committted to improvin ng the area. M More recently, there t are signs of growing inte erest in the DTE ES by investors and a developers . New commerccial activities an nd retail o outlets are bein ng seen in the western w sector resulting r in less vacant storefro onts along Hasttings, Pender an nd Keefer Stree ets. E Enquiries are be eing made abou ut the possibilityy of new or renovated premise es being created d in older buildings. 6 64 Study was commissioned throug gh the Vancouverr Agreement and conducted by Me essrs Ference Weeicker, commissio oned by Vancouve er Economic C Commission. P Page 68 Obstacles to Economic Development65 Safety and Security Concerns Business, visitors and residents say safety and security concerns are major obstacles to economic development. High Cost of Upgrading Buildings The cost of renovating older buildings to modern standards and the low market rents received in return, has reduced investment in Downtown Eastside properties. High Vacancy Rates High commercial vacancies contribute to economic decline. Many vacant buildings do not meet occupancy standards and are not actively marketed. Small Local Market Unemployment, low incomes and a small residential base limits the local market. Physical Separation Deteriorating links between Downtown Eastside neighbourhoods as well as with adjacent parts of the city means less business and little strategic cooperation. Rent and Property Costs Increasing assessment values contribute to rising rents and property costs for business owners. The Vancouver Economic Commission is conducting a more in-depth analysis of some of the key growth sectors for the neighbourhood and the potential for a vibrant employment climate emerging in key sectors, including: high technology and creative industries, the digital economy, tourism, hospitality and retail; finance, insurance and real estate; social enterprise sector; and green business. Some of the factors that contribute to growth in these sectors are lower-cost real estate (relative to elsewhere in Vancouver) that facilitates incubation of new enterprises; proximity to the Central Business District; historic character and open spaces in units; and many urban lifestyle amenities such as cafés and bars. 65 Adapted from Vancouver Agreement, Economic Revitalization Plan, 2004, with information on rent and property costs added by Downtown Eastside Planning Team, 2013. Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 69 C Change in Pro operty Valuess T The map below estimates chan nge in property and building va alues from 2001 to 2013, based d on assessment data. While la and in the D Downtown Eastsside has increassed in value at a similar rate to o the city as a whole, w buildingg values have no ot increased at the same rrate. Property Assessment Change, 2001-2011 P Page 70 B Business Imprrovement Asso ociations T There are four Business B Improv vement Associattions (BIAs) in the t Downtown Eastside. E Business Improvement Areas, 2013 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 71 3 3.2 A Susta ainable Na atural Enviironment T The Greenest City Action plan is the guiding strategy s for Van ncouver’s sustaiinability initiatiives, some of w which may influe ence the ffuture sustainab bility and econo omic growth of the Downtown Eastside. The Downtown D Eastsside is a possiblle location for a green e enterprise zone e, which would include i the Dow wntown Eastside e and False Cre eek Flats with a possible partne ership with the Vancouver P Port Authority. A green enterp prise zone is a designated area with innovative e sustainable laand use planning and a concentration of ggreen businesse es. At a lo ocal level, manyy organizations in the Downtow wn Eastside worrk to furtherr municipal and d regional sustaiinability goals: P Page 72 The Strathcona a Business Imprrovement Association has a zerro waste challenge. an farms in the Downtown SOLEFoods, of United We Cann, runs two urba Eastside. o Downtown Easstside Cycleback provvides bicycle reepair training to residents. n, the Recyclingg Centre, provid des informal job b United We Can opportunities to t Downtown Eaastside residentts. Residents ca an collect recyclable matterials (binning ) and exchange e them for mone ey. 3 3.3 A Welll-Planned Built B Envirronment L Land Use IIn 2012, total la and area of Dow wntown Eastside e totalled over 13 million square feet.66 The m majority of land d is used for ressidential p purposes, follow wed by industria al and commerc cial. This broad d mix of land use es is indicative of the unique ccharacter of Do owntown E Eastside and itss diversity, whic ch is not typicall of most neighb bourhoods in th he city. Land use by type in the Downtown Eastside, 2012 Land Classs Group Residentiall Industrial Commercia al Open Space e Institutiona al Vacant + under construction n Total 6 66 Land Percen ntage (sq ft) of T Total 5,2 235,424 2,4 402,374 2,5 507,462 9 940,247 2,161,612 5 519,786 38% 18% 17% 16% 7% 4% 13,76 66,905 100% City of Vancouv ver. Research and Data Services. 2012. D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 73 Generalized Land Use, 2011. P Page 74 Sub-Area Zoning and Allowed Uses Each of the seven sub-areas in the Downtown Eastside has a distinct character. District schedules outline allowable heights, densities and use. Floor space ratio (FSR) is used for measuring density—land area to square foot floor area in a building. The DEOD zoning is particularly important to note due to the social housing requirement for residential buildings above 1.0 FSR. Allowable Building Heights and Floor Space Ratios, by Zoning District Chinatown HA-1 HEIGHT FSR HA-1A 50’ maximum Relaxable to 75’ Sites with heritage buildings Existing height, possible additions Not specified in Zoning. Maximum achievable affected by Design Guidelines Allowable Discretionary Discretionary 90’ maximum 120’ maximum Main St. Sub-Area 150’ maximum Sites with heritage buildings Existing height, possible additions Not specified in Zoning. Maximum achievable affected by Design Guidelines Allowable Discretionary – Rezoning Policy Discretionary – Rezoning Policy Discretionary All sites 75’ maximum Sites with heritage buildings Existing height, possible additions Not specified in Zoning. Maximum achievable affected by Design Guidelines Allowable Discretionary All sites All sites HEIGHT FSR Gastown HA-2 HEIGHT FSR Industrial Area M-1 and M-2 HEIGHT All sites FSR All uses Manufacturing, Wholesale, Transport. & Storage Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Maximum 100’ Greater than 100’ Maximum 1.0 FSR Allowable Discretionary Allowable Maximum 5.0 FSR Allowable Page 75 O Oppenheimer Downtown n Eastside Oppenh heimer District (DE EOD) - Sub-area 1,, Main+ Hastings ( DEOD ODP) 98’ Max ximum HEIGHT All Sites Greaterr than 98’ All uses Maximum 1.0 FSR Maximum 5.0 FSR with 20% % social Above 1.0 FSR R housing; residential and/o or live-work FSR not to exceed e 3.0 FSR Maximum 2.5 FSR with 20% % social Above 1.0 FSR R housing Downtown n Eastside Oppenh heimer District (DE EOD) - All other Su ub-areas HEIGHT All Sites 50’ Max ximum All uses Maximum 1.0 FSR FSR Maximum 2.5 FSR with 20% % social Above 1.0 FSR R housing Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary S Strathcona RT-3 HEIGHT FSR All Sites Height averag ging or below grade e All uses Dwellings Infill Maximum 35’ Greaterr than 35’ Maximum 0.6 FSR Maximum 0.75 FSR Maximum 0.95 FSR Alllowable Diiscretionary Alllowable Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Maximum m 50’ Maximum m 275’ Up to 5.0 FSR Alllowable Diiscretionary Alllowable T Thornton Park FC-1 HEIGHT All Sites FSR All uses – a varriety of combinatio ons V Victory Square Downtown n District (DD) - Su ub-area C2 (Downttown District Offic cial Development Plan) All sites 70’ max ximum Social housing g development 100’ ma aximum HEIGHT Market housin ng development witth 100’ ma aximum social housing g on site Sites with herritage buildings Existing g height, possible additions a 5.0 FSR R overall (3.0 FSR for f residential All sites and/or live/work) FSR 5.0 resid dential (except wh here retail Development with 2/3 social housing continuiity is required at grade) g P Page 76 Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Diiscretionary Zoning Districts, 2012 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 77 B Building Heigh hts Building Heights, 2012 P Page 78 Building Floor Space The building floor space in the Downtown Eastside amounted to approximately 20 million square feet in 2012, with the major floor space allocated to commercial floor space (11 million square feet) followed by residential floor space (9 million square feet).67 Commercial floor space has increased in Chinatown and Gastown, and it has decreased in all other sub-areas. Residential floor space has increased in all sub-areas, expect for Industrial. 5000000 0 Non-Residential Space, 2001 and 2011 Chinatown Gastown Industrial 2001 4000000 Oppenheimer Strathcona Thornton Park 2011 Victory Square Residential Space, 2001 and 2011 2000000 0 Chinatown Gastown Industrial 2001 Oppenheimer Strathcona Thornton Park Victory Square 2011 Non-Residential and Residential Floor Space, 2001 and 2011 67 City of Vancouver. Research and Data Services. 2012. Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 79 H Heritage and Culture B Beyond land use e, a built enviro onment that is beautiful b and welcoming w contrributes to our seense of well-be eing. The Downttown E Eastside has a rich r cultural herritage, which is reflected in th he art (see sectiion 1.10) througghout the neigh hbourhood, such h as the C Chinatown Gate e and the many murals. D Downtown Eastsside is unique being b the origina al summer trading settlement for the Coast SSalish Nation on the Burrard Inllet and m more recently, the site of early settlement off new immigran nt residents which established Gastown, Japan ntown, Chinato own and SStrathcona. Acc cordingly the he eritage assets off Downtown Easstside are belie eved to be signifficant, both in terms of the sp piritual m memories and intangible value es to the commu unities and, the e tangible built form of variouss structures in tthe area. There e are a approximately 500 5 buildings in n the area curre ently listed on the City’s Herita age Register, acccounting for ne early 20 per cen nt of all tthe buildings on n the register. The T heritage pro operties are de epicted on the following f map. T The high proportion of heritagge stock in tthe area is an enormous e asset but could also be b regarded as a challenge due e to the age an d condition of m many buildings,, which are d deteriorating ov ver time. A Associated with h this aging build ding stock is the increased vulnerability of th he Downtown Eaastside from earthquake eventts due to tthe potential fo or structural failure and possible building colla apse. In additio on, the low leveel topography of the Downtown n Eastside ((particularly in the north south h linkage along Carrall Street between b Burrard d Inlet and Falsse Creek suggessts the area is vvulnerable tto rising water levels due to po otential sea levvel rise, impactiing infrastructure and basemennts over the nexxt thirty years. P Page 80 Heritage Buildings, 2013 D Downtown Eastside e Profile 2013 Page 81 3 3.4 A Vibra ant Social Environme ent A As explored in the t Healthy Peo ople and Health hy Communitie es chapters, ma any factors conttribute to a thriiving social environment. F For all residentss to thrive, they y need to have their basic nee eds meet and more. Without im mproving the livves of the comm munity’s m most vulnerable e residents, it iss impossible to have a healthy community forr all. How our ccommunities con nnect and comm municate iis also fundame ental. The Down ntown Eastside is i experiencing major changes in its social fab bric as new peo ople move into the new d developments and a renovated buildings, b and as a more businessses open in the neighbourhood d. This is causin ng changes in th he ccommunity, esp pecially felt by vulnerable resid dents who are most m affected by b the sense of displacement a and discriminatiion. A Social Impact Assessment (SIA) is being cond ducted and its outcomes o will be b integrated innto the Local Arrea Plan. The SIIA will iinform the actio ons and policiess of the Local Area A Plan to assiist with mitigatting developmennt impacts on the Downtown E Eastside’s llow income pop pulation. In the summer of 2012, workshops were w held to exp plore how the D Downtown Eastsside low income e ccommunity is be eing affected by changes in the neighbourhoo od. Assets, gapss, hopes and feaars were discusssed in seven ke ey areas, w which align with h the local area a planning proce ess themes: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Our Hom mes Our Live elihoods Our Plac ces Our Wellbeing: Generall ccess and Security Our Wellbeing: Food Ac y and Social Servvices Our Wellbeing: Healthy nd Safety Our Wellbeing: Inclusion, Belonging an SSome of the mo ost frequently mentioned m key assets a identified d by the commu unity include: Carnegie e Centre Oppenhe eimer Park Home Union Go ospel Mission First Uniited Church Strathco ona Community Centre CRAB Pa ark Downtow wn Eastside Women’s Centre Ray-Cam m Co-operative Centre C MacLean n Park T The map on the e next page illusstrates these asssets and otherss identified by workshop w particcipants through h the public inpu ut process. P Page 82 Important Community Places and Spaces Identified in Social Impact Assessment Public Input Process, 2012 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 83 Appendiix A: Vulne erable Pop pulations in n the Down ntown Eastside A As noted in the introduction to o this documentt, achieving a healthy and equitable city for aall peoples in th he Downtown Ea astside rrequires dispelling stereotypess about vulnerab ble populationss while at the sa ame time identiifying those to w whom special a attention m must be paid. This T section outlines some partticular areas of concern for me embers of thesee communities. W Women W Women aged 15 5 and over in the Downtown Ea astside have a significantly low wer labour forcee participation rrate (42 per cen nt) than b both women citty-wide (62 per cent) and male es in the Downto own Eastside (4 49 per cent). Deespite this, the median annuall income of ffemale residentts ($18,601) is slightly s higher than male reside ents ($17,949), but it is much lower than fem male median inccome ccitywide ($30,053). IIn 2006, there were w 460 female e-headed lone-parent familiess in the Downtow wn Eastside, prrimarily concenttrated in the O Oppenheimer and Strathcona sub-areas. s Seventeen per cent of all Downtow wn Eastside censsus families fall into this categgory, ccompared to 13 3 per cent of fam milies citywide..68 W Women in the Downtown D Eastsside face significant health and d shelter-relate ed challenges. T Though female rresidents of the e D Downtown Eastsside have a high her life expecta ancy than male residents (85 vs. v 74 years),69 a number of disstinct health isssues have b been identified: Female injection i drug users u have a 40 per cent higher incidence of HIV H than that off male injection n drug users70 Women report higher usage of many health services, such as pharma acies, nursing ccare, physician ccare, ambulancces, and h and outrreach services;711 mental health Women are more likely y to report poor treatment by health h care stafff and greater d difficulty keepin ng health-relate ed ;72 ments appointm Maternal health is a significant concerrn as the Downtown Eastside ha as higher rates of stillbirth, infant death, low w birth y of age, an nd births to motthers 35 years o of age or older tthan the weight, pre-term birthss, births to motthers under 20 years provincia al averages.73 6 68 Census, 2006. BC Ministry of Health, H Downtow wn Eastside Core Health Services Profile, P July 2011 1. 7 70 City of Vancouv ver Social Plannin ng Department. A Social Profile and a Assessment of the Social and H Health Needs of Low Income Resiidents in V Vancouver’s Dow wntown Eastside, 2004. 7 71 Ibid. 7 72 Ibid. 7 73 BC Ministry of Health, H Downtow wn Eastside Core Health Services Profile, P July 2011 1. 6 69 P Page 84 In a 2008 demographic study of Downtown Eastside SRO and social housing tenants, women were a minority in both types of housing, but were considerably more likely to reside in social housing (44 per cent of respondents) than in SROs (20 per cent of respondents). Female SRO residents are among the most vulnerable populations in the neighbourhood. In the 2008 study, they were much more likely to suffer from a variety of health conditions, declining health and addictions, and to report higher usage of several health services, supervised injection sites, and community centers than male SRO residents and both male and female social housing residents. The top ranked identified needs reported by female SRO residents were housing, health and income, while the top needs reported by female social housing residents were income, health and emotional support. 75 Though not confined to the Downtown Eastside, the estimated number of women who are homeless has slightly increased in recent years from 333 (22 per cent of City of Vancouver homeless population) in 2010 to 347 (26 per cent) in 2012.77 Abuse and family breakdown has been identified as the largest cause of homelessness among women.78 Women in the Downtown Eastside may face multiple barriers such as precarious housing, addiction and/or involvement in the sex trade, and are particularly vulnerable to violence and exploitation. Women who are members of other marginalized or vulnerable groups, such as Aboriginal women, may experience intersecting vulnerabilities and multiple forms of marginalization. Women experience physical, mental, emotional and sexual violence. The missing and murdered women taken from the neighbourhood since the 1980s number more than 60,79 and women continue to be particularly vulnerable. The Vancouver Police Department’s SisterWatch Project is intended to combat violence against women through coordination, public outreach, a tip line and town hall meetings.80 Children and Youth As a result of the prevalence of low income persons (see section 1.1), child poverty is a significant issue. The proportion of children under six years of age living in low income families in the Downtown Eastside is more than twice that of the City of Vancouver, also discussed in section 1.6. It is well known that children who experience persistent poverty in their early years face higher risks of health problems, developmental delays and behavioural disorders and are also more likely to have low incomes in adulthood.81 75 Downtown Eastside Demographic Study of SRO and Social Housing Tenants, April 2008; VANDU. Me, I’m Living it, 2009. City of Vancouver. Vancouver 2012 Homeless Count Results: Presentation to Council, May 29, 2012. 78 City of Vancouver Social Planning Department. A Social Profile and Assessment of the Social and Health Needs of Low Income Residents in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, 2004. 79 W. T. Oppal. Forsaken, The Report of the Missing Women Commission of Inquiry Volume 1, 2012. 80 Vancouver Police Department Project Sister Watch website. 81 An indicator of the challenges children face in the Downtown Eastside is the high proportion of vulnerabilities (measured using the Early Development Instrument) in kindergarten children affecting school readiness seen in section 1.6. SPARC. The Cost of Poverty in BC, 2011. 77 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 85 IIn addition to yo oung people liv ving with their families f or guardians in the Dow wntown Eastsid de, there are also youth and yo oung adults lliving on their own o in SROs, supportive housin ng units and on the streets of the t Downtown EEastside. In the 2012 Homelesss Count, tthere were 164 homeless youth h under the age e of 25 in Vanco ouver—12 per ce ent of the totall number of peo ople counted. SSeniors SSeniors are a ra apidly growing population p throu ughout Vancouvver and across Canada. C The Doowntown Eastsid de has long bee en home to a higher than av verage proportiion of adults over the age of 65 5. In 2006, therre were 3,740 seeniors in the Do owntown Eastside, iincluding nearly y 700 aged 85 and over. Altoge ether, seniors make m up about 21 2 per cent of t he population, compared with h 13 per 82 8 ccent city-wide. SSeniors living in n the Downtown n Eastside face greater g levels of o poverty than other areas of Vancouver. Wh hile seniors’ inco omes have b been increasing g on a national level l and the pe ercentage of se eniors with low incomes has deeclined sharply,83 well over hallf of D Downtown Eastsside seniors rem main low income e.84 A Around 1,800 se eniors live alone e in the Downto own Eastside, and they are more likely to be llow income tha an are seniors livving in 85 ffamilies. Senio ors aged 65 and d over in the Downtown Eastsid de are more tha an twice as like ly to live alone than seniors livving in o other parts of the city (55 per cent in the Dow wntown Eastside e vs. 29 per cen nt city-wide).86 These seniors a are also more liikely to be 87 iisolated from th heir communitie es and prone to o accidents and falls. T Though only a small s number off seniors are fullly homeless, se eniors are especcially vulnerablee to the risk of homelessness. A high p percentage of the t seniors who are homeless and seniors who o live in SROs re eport poor heallth status, inclu uding medical conditions, m mental illness, physical disabillities and addicttions.88 SSeniors who spe eak limited or no n English face additional a challlenges to their health h and indeependence, inclluding difficultyy accessing ttranslation and culturally-apprropriate service es.89 Within the Downtown Easttside, a large nuumber of Chine ese-speaking sen niors live iin or near China atown and rely heavily on its sh hops, services and a social netw works to meet thheir everyday needs. A Aboriginal Elderrs are highly impacted by pove erty, health issu ues and the effe ects of residenttial schools.90 A number of Abo original ggroups that prov vide support for Elders are con ncentrated in th he Downtown Eastside. 8 82 Census, 2006. City of Vancouv ver Social Policy Group. Seniors in n Vancouver, Octtober 2010. 8 84 Census, 2006. 8 85 City of Vancouv ver Social Policy Group. Seniors in n Vancouver, Octtober 2010. 8 86 Census, 2006. 8 87 City of Vancouv ver Social Plannin ng Department. A Social Profile and a Assessment of the Social and H Health Needs of Low Income Resiidents in V Vancouver’s Dow wntown Eastside, 2004. 8 88 Ibid. 8 89 City of Vancouv ver Social Policy Group. Seniors in n Vancouver, Octtober 2010. 8 83 P Page 86 Aboriginal People Even given a higher population in the Downtown Eastside, Aboriginal people are routinely overrepresented in vulnerable groups: Aboriginal people comprise 15 per cent of SRO residents in the Downtown Eastside.91 In 2012, 32 per cent of the sheltered and unsheltered homeless were Aboriginal.92 A quarter of the Downtown Eastside’s injection drug users are estimated to identify as Aboriginal.93 Aboriginal People in the Downtown Eastside are also disproportionately affected by health challenges, including: greater risk of HIV infection, particularly among drug users; higher rates of diabetes, particularly among Aboriginal women; higher rates of alcoholism.94 Aboriginal women are among the most marginalized in the Downtown Eastside and are particularly vulnerable to violence. One third of the missing and murdered women taken from the Downtown Eastside were Aboriginal.95 Aboriginal women disproportionately experience violence and marginalization, and are overrepresented in the survival sex trade. New Immigrants While the Downtown Eastside has relatively fewer new immigrants than the City of Vancouver as a whole, new immigrants face particular challenges. These newcomers often struggle to enter the job market and find affordable housing, and a disproportionate number of recent immigrant households are considered to be at high risk of homelessness as they spend more than 50% of their income on housing. 96 Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer and Questioning (LGBTQ) People While it is not known how many LGBTQ identifying people live in the Downtown Eastside, it is clear that there is a disproportionate number of LGBTQ homeless or street-involved youth. A 2002 survey of homeless or at risk of homeless youth in 90 Ibid. Downtown Eastside Demographic Study of SRO and Social Housing Tenants, April 2008. 92 City of Vancouver Homeless Count, 2012. 93 Canadian Community Epidemiology Network on Drug Use. Vancouver Drug Use Epidemiology, June 2005. 94 City of Vancouver Social Planning Department. A Social Profile and Assessment of the Social and Health Needs of Low Income Residents in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, 2004. 95 W. T. Oppal. Forsaken, The Report of the Missing Women Commission of Inquiry Volume 1, 2012. 96 Hiebert et al, ‘The Housing Situation and Needs of Recent Immigrants in the Vancouver Metropolitan Area,’ Metropolis British Columbia Working Paper Series. 91 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 87 V Vancouver found that 33 per cent of youth 19 9 and younger and 24 per cent of youth 19 to 25 years old ide entified as LGBT TQ97, 98 m much higher tha an the number of LGBTQ-identtifying youth in the entire popu ulation. LGBT TQ street youth are more likelyy to be ssexually exploitted than their heterosexual h peers.99 L Low Income Singles M Many Downtown n Eastside residents live alone (46 per cent vss. 17 per cent citywide). The p proportion of pe eople living alon ne ranges ffrom a low of 21 per cent in Sttrathcona, wherre much of the housing stock iss in the form off detached housses and self-con ntained a apartments, to a high of 78 pe er cent in Victorry Square, wherre many residen nts live in Singlee Room Occupancy buildings. T The median income for people e living alone in the Downtown Eastside is lesss than half that of people living alone across tthe city.100 L Low income peo ople living alone e are particularrly vulnerable as a they must relly on a single inncome and cann not pool resourcces with o other household d members. Obttaining affordab ble and adequate housing can be a serious ch allenge, especiially for those w who are on iincome assistan nce. L Low Income Families F T Though the Dow wntown Eastside e is characterize ed by a large po opulation of old der adults livingg alone, there a are many families with a and without chiildren that call the area home.. Most families live in the Stratthcona neighboourhood where h housing units arre larger. F Families living in i the Downtow wn Eastside have e lower median incomes than families f living inn other areas of Vancouver and more tthan a quarter fall f below the low income thre eshold after tax x.101 Over 45 perr cent of femalee headed lone-parent familiess in the D Downtown Eastsside are low inc come. Although there are far fewer f of them, male headed loone-parent families fare slightly worse, w with half falling g under the low w income threshold.102 O Obtaining afford dable housing that is large eno ough for severall people is challenging for low income familie es, especially in n the D Downtown Eastsside, where mu uch of the afford dable and non-m market housing stock is geared d toward single adults and seniors. In 2 2011, there werre 886 units of non-market hou using for familie es in the Downttown Eastside, aamounting to ju ust 13 per cent of total 103 n non-market stoc ck in the neighb bourhood. 9 97 McCreary Centre Society, No Place to Call Home e: A Profile of Strreet Youth in Brittish Columbia andd Between the Cracks: Homeless Youth in V Vancouver. 2002.. In 2009, 66 per cent of street involved youth rep ported the Downttown Eastside as their place of residence . B. S Ra achels. High R Rates of Homelesssness Among a Cohort C of Street-Involved Youth, 2009. 2 9 98 A 2008 McCreary Centre Society y Adolescent Hea alth Survey found that less than 3 per cent of BC yyouth in grades 7 to 12 identify ass gay, llesbian or bisexua al. An estimate of o youth identifyiing as transgende er is unavailable from f this survey.. 9 99 Jenna Owsianik k. Out of the closset and onto the streets: Young, gay g and homelesss in Vancouver, 22011. 1 100 2006 Census 1 101 Census, 2006. 1 102 Census, 2006. 1 103 City of Vancou uver. Downtown Eastside E Key Hou using Facts, 2012,, P Page 88 Renters The Downtown Eastside is overwhelmingly a neighbourhood of renters. Almost 90 per cent of households are rented, compared to slightly over half city-wide.105 Renters are a socio-economically varied group and the above numbers include higher-income renters in the neighbourhood’s newer condo buildings and converted loft apartments. Overall, renters in the Downtown Eastside are more likely than both owners in the neighbourhood and renters throughout the city to spend more than 30 per cent of their household income on housing. 106 In contrast to other neighbourhoods in the city with high renter populations, the Downtown Eastside has a significant number of renters living in Single-Room Occupancy buildings (SROs). These renters are typically very low income and face a unique set of barriers with regard to housing affordability and security. For low income renters experiencing affordability challenges in the Downtown Eastside, there are few places to turn for lower cost housing. Single Room Occupancy (SRO) Tenants SRO units in rooming houses and residential hotels are a very basic and low cost form of housing provided by the private and public market. Rooms are usually about ten by ten feet in size and do not have private bathrooms or cooking facilities beyond hotplates. While SROs used to exist in several Vancouver neighbourhoods, the remaining units are overwhelmingly concentrated in the Downtown Eastside. As of 2011, there were 3,975 market SRO units and 1,522 non-market units in 155 buildings in the Downtown Eastside, illustrated in section 1.4.107 Many SROs are run-down and suffer from pest and rodent infestations, and inspections routinely reveal unsafe living conditions.108 Residents of SROs are typically very low income and are unable to afford self-contained units in the conventional rental market. In a 2008 survey, 77 per cent reported annual incomes of $15,000 or less.109 Unless they can obtain non-market housing, SROs are often the last option before homelessness.110 Private SRO residents are vulnerable to rent increases that can exceed the shelter component of social assistance income or otherwise impact their ability to afford the unit. The proportion of SRO units renting at 105 Census, 2006. Census, 2006. The 30% mark is a commonly accepted definition of housing affordability. Households spending at above this threshold are considered to be at risk. 107 City of Vancouver Housing Policy. 2009 Survey of Low-Income Housing in the Downtown Core, April 2010. 108 Downtown Eastside Demographic Study of SRO and Social Housing Tenants, April 2008. 109 Downtown Eastside Demographic Study of SRO and Social Housing Tenants, April 2008. 110 City of Vancouver. Downtown Eastside Community Monitoring Report, 2005/06. 106 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 89 o or below the social assistance shelter rate hass been decreasiing—in 2011, 27 7 per cent of prrivate SROs were e renting at thiis rate. All p public SRO unitss rent at $375.111 1 L Living in substandard housing impacts i health and wellbeing.112 In a 2008 surrvey, a third of SRO residents ssurveyed had a mental h health illness an nd a third had a drug addiction n. H Homeless Peo ople W While homelessness is a serious issue across Metro M Vancouver, a significant number of hom meless people re eside in the Dow wntown E Eastside, with many m more trav veling to the neiighbourhood on n a regular basiss to access supp port services that may not be a available iin their own com mmunities.113 IIn 2012, the Dow wntown Eastsid de homeless pop pulation was esttimated to be around a 846 peop ple.114 Most hom meless people sstruggle w with mental and d physical healtth issues. Many people not currently homelesss are at risk of homelessness. P People with Disabilities D P People with phy ysical disabilitie es face significa ant barriers to employment e and d to obtaining hhousing that is both affordable e and a accessible. A sin ngle person on disability assisttance receives $531.42 $ supportt and $375 for sshelter per mon nth. There are 3 3,193 rresidents receiv ving disability assistance in the e V6A postal cod de; 115 cases incclude people deeemed unable tto work as a ressult of m mental and phy ysical barriers. P People affectted by Mental Illness M Mental health isssues are prevalent in the Dow wntown Eastside e, but it is difficcult to determinne how many re esidents are afffected. M Mental illness may m go undiagno osed and are often inextricablyy linked with po overty and subsstance abuse. Itt is estimated th hat one in ffive residents su uffer from mental illness.116 1 111 Total SRO unitts include public and private. All public units rent at the social assistance shelter ra rate ($375) and 27 7% of private SRO O units rent a at this rate—toge ether 47 per centt of Downtown Ea astside units rent at the shelter ra ate. The averagee rent of a private e SRO is $416. Citty of V Vancouver. Down ntown Eastside Ke ey Housing Facts,, 2012. 1 112 Hwang SW, Wiilkins R, Tjepkem ma M, O’Campo PJ, Dunn JR. Morttality among resid dents of shelters,, rooming housess, and hotels in C Canada: 11 yyear follow-up study. BMJ 2009;33 39:b4036. 1 113 City of Vancou uver Social Planning Department. A Social Profile and a Assessment of o the Social and Health Needs off Low Income Ressidents in V Vancouver’s Dow wntown Eastside, 2004. 1 114 The homeless count representss an undercount of o the total popu ulation. Homelesss people in shelteers and on the street are counted d. Some p people may be missed m in the coun nt. Those who are e staying with friiends, family or in a car are unlike kely to be capture ed in this count. 1 115 V6A does not include i Victory Square and parts of o Gastown. Its boundaries b are Cllark, Carrall and Great Northern W Way. Ministry of Social D Development, 2013. 1 116 City of Vancou uver. Housing Pla an for the Downto own Eastside, October 2005. P Page 90 As compared to people living in other parts of Vancouver and throughout the province, residents of the Downtown Eastside have a higher rate of depression and anxiety.117 In 2009-10, 7,588 Downtown Eastside residents received mental health and/or substance use services from a general practitioner and mental health issues were the most common reason for hospitalization.118 Drug Users An estimated 4,700 injection drug users resided in the Downtown Eastside in 2003.119 These individuals are among the most vulnerable in the Downtown Eastside as they often face multiple barriers to health and life stability. As seen in section 1.5, there are proportionally more alcohol and drug-related deaths in the Downtown Eastside Local Health Area than across the City.120 Many drug users are homeless or at risk of homelessness. Among participants in a large, ongoing study of Vancouver drug users, almost 70 per cent lived in unstable housing (including shelter/hostel, treatment/recovery house, jail, SRO, and street) in 2007, including 25 per cent who were outright homeless.121 Survival Sex Workers Survival sex workers—those whose urgent need for food, money or other basic needs prevent them from exercising their right to refuse to perform sexual acts—are among the most marginalized populations in our society. Sex workers identify as male, female and/or transgender, and come from a variety of backgrounds. It is difficult to determine exact numbers, but there may be 1,500 to 2,000 street level sex workers in Vancouver, with many working in the Downtown Eastside.122 The stigma of sex work makes these individuals more vulnerable to violence and marginalization, and prevents these individuals from accessing health care services.123 117 BC Ministry of Health. Downtown Eastside Core Health Services Profile, July 2011. Ibid. 119 Capture recapture analysis performed by Vancouver Costal Health (VCH), 2003. 120 Vancouver Coastal Health, 2012. 121 City of Vancouver Social Planning Department. A Social Profile and Assessment of the Social and Health Needs of Low Income Residents in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, 2004. 122 Sarah Stenabaugh, ‘Silent Cries: Vancouver sex workers continue to fight for services and support’, Megaphone Magazine, 2009; MAKA Project. 123 Lisa Lazarus et al, “Occupational Stigma as Primary Barrier to Health Care for Street-Based Sex Workers in Canada”, Cult Health Sex 2012. 118 Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 91 Glossary G A Aboriginal Iden ntity: Refers to people who rep ported identifying with at leastt one Aboriginaal group, that iss, North America an Indian, M Métis or Inuit, and/or a those wh ho reported being a Treaty Ind dian or a Registe ered Indian, as defined by the Indian Act of C Canada, a and/or those who reported the ey were membe ers of an Indian band or First Nation. N C Cultural Worke ers: Includes cre eative, production, technical and a managemen nt occupations iin the areas of broadcasting, ffilm and vvideo, sound recording, perforrming arts, publlishing, printing g, libraries, arch hives, heritage,, architecture a and design. E Extreme Weath her Response Shelter: S A temp porary space tha at is made availlable to people who are homelless during situa ations w where sleeping outside might threaten t their health h and safety. These temp porary shelters aare made availa able from appro oximately N November 1 to March 31. H Home Language e: Refers to the e language spok ken most often or o on a regular basis at home b by the individua al at the time o of the ccensus. H Homeless perso on: A person wh ho does not payy rent for a hom me. A homeless person may sleeep in a shelter,, the street, a ccar, a ffriend’s house or o other location. H Household: Reffers to a person n or a group of persons p (other than t foreign ressidents) who occcupy the same dwelling and do not have a usual place off residence else ewhere in Canad da. It may consiist of a family group g (census faamily) with or w without other p persons, ttwo or more fam milies sharing a dwelling, a gro oup of unrelated d persons, or on ne person livingg alone. IImmigrant: Reffers to people who w are, or have e been, landed immigrants in Canada. C A landeed immigrant iss a person who has been ggranted the righ ht to live in Can nada permanenttly by immigrattion authorities.. IInformal Econo omy: Economic sectors that are e not taxed or monitor m and at times discouragged. It includess work such as b binning and vvending. L Live/Work: Also o known as “arttist live/work sttudios”. Combin nes “living” and d “working” in tthe same premiises. The type o of work a activity varies from f commercia al (e.g. childcarre, music teach her, software de eveloper), indusstrial (e.g. jewe eller, recordingg studio, w woodwork), or artist a (e.g. pain nter or photogra aphy) work. L Local Area Plan nning Process (LAPP): ( A comm munity plan for a thirty year pe eriod, defining tthe desired futu ure for the com mmunities, tthe priorities, the actions and projects requirred to achieve improved qualitty of life for thee people of the Downtown Easttside. L Low Income: There are multip ple measures of low income use ed in this reporrt. They includee: P Page 92 Low Inco ome Cut Off (LICO): Relative measure m of low income i status. Describes a houusehold that spends over 20 pe ercentage points on a median goods basket. LIM varies v by familyy size, community size and taxx. Low Income Measure (LIM): Relative measure of low income status. Describes a household that learns less than half of median income. Market Basket Measure (MBM): Absolute measure of low income status. The disposable income needed for a basket of goods. Low Income Household: Determined by Statistics Canada as those households that qualify for Low Income Cut-off (LICO). LICO is the income level below which a family spends 20 per cent more of its income on necessities (food, shelter and clothing) than the average family does. Mode of Transportation: Main means a person uses to travel between home and place of work (by car, on foot, on public transit, or by some other means). The Census of Population tracks mode of transportation according to commute to work. Neighbourhood House (Association of Neighbourhood Houses of British Columbia): A non-profit organization that provides programs and services that are locally-based but also supportive of Metro Vancouver and provincial initiatives. Private Household: Person or group of persons occupying the same dwelling. Single Occupancy Room (SRO): SRO units are small rooms, usually in privately owned and managed buildings, with shared bathrooms. Most of the buildings containing SROs were built before the First World War.124 Single-Detached House: A building that does not share an inside wall with any other house or dwelling that is usually occupied by just one household or family and consists of just one dwelling unit or suite. Social Assistance: Also known as welfare. A government transfer managed by the Ministry of Human and Social Development. Types of social assistance include: child in home of relative, expected to work, expected to work (medical condition), long term care, medical services only, no employment options, old age security, persons with persistent multiple barriers and persons with disabilities. Social Enterprise: A business that operates with the intention of improving social, economic and/or environmental wellbeing. Social Housing: Social housing is housing owned or operated by a non-profit or government with a range of rents up to low end of market. Social Impact Assessment (SIA): A study to review the impact of future development on the existing low income residents of the Downtown Eastside. Involved community input, literature reviews and data analysis. Supportive Housing: Housing linked to support services and often, but not always funded by government. Supportive housing may be market or non-market housing. Services can include meals, housekeeping, personal care, lifeskills training and support, and other services. Supportive housing can be provided to individuals living in their own apartments/rooms in social housing projects 124 Housing Plan for the Downtown Eastside. City of Vancouver. 2005. Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 93 o or SROs and who receive suppo orts on an individual basis, or to t groups of peo ople who have ssimilar needs and who live in a building w which has been designed to provide the comm mon facilities an nd staff offices need by the paarticular popula ation.125 T Tenure: Refers to whether som me member of the t household owns o or rents th he dwelling or w whether the dw welling is band h housing (on a an Indian reserv ve or settlemen nt). V Vulnerable: A population p at grreat risk of poor health conditiions and wellbe eing. Risk may b be due to socio--economic cond ditions, ggender, ethnicitty and a host off other facts. Chapter 1 (Healtthy People) desccribes vulnerab ble groups in the e Downtown Ea astside. W Welfare: See So ocial Assistance e. 1 125 Housing Plan for f the Downtown n Eastside. City of o Vancouver. 200 05. P Page 94 References and Further Reading BC Ministry of Health, Downtown Eastside Core Health Services Profile, July 2011. City of Vancouver Social Planning Department. A Social Profile and Assessment of the Social and Health Needs of Low Income Residents in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, 2004. City of Vancouver Metropolitan Core Business Survey—Phase One. City of Vancouver. IPSOS Reid. 2005. Downtown Eastside Housing Plan. City of Vancouver, 2005 Downtown Eastside Local Area Profile. City of Vancouver, 2012. Downtown Eastside Vancouver Retail Capacity Study. City of Vancouver. Hudema Consulting, 2005. Powell Street/Port Lands and Powell Street/Clark Drive Industrial Areas Study. City of Vancouver. Harris Consulting and CitySpaces Consulting Ltd. 2007. The Gastown Heritage Management Plan. City of Vancouver. The Spaxman Consulting Group. 2001. Victory Square Policy Plan. City of Vancouver. 2005. Downtown Eastside Demographic Study of SRO and Social Housing Tenants. City of Vancouver, April 2008. VANDU. Me, I’m Living it, 2009. We’re All Pedestrians. Downtown Eastside Pedestrian Safety Project—Final Report. VANDU, 2010. For updates on the Local Area Planning process, please visit the City of Vancouver Downtown Eastside Local Area Plan webpage: vancouver.ca/dteslapp Downtown Eastside Profile 2013 Page 95