This resource provides an overview of the Core Skills for Work Developmental Framework (CSfW) for employers, its application and benefits. This resource should be read in conjunction with the CSfW. CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS What are Core Skills for Work? It’s not just technical skills and knowledge that make someone good at their work. To be effective in any work situation, people need a combination of technical skills, language, literacy and numeracy (LLN) skills and a variety of non-technical skills - sometimes called ‘employability’ skills, but referred to here as Core Skills for Work. 1 Three types of skills needed for performance in any work environment Core Skills for Work Work Performance Technical or DisciplineSpecific Skills Language, Literacy & Numeracy Skills Work Environment A plumber laying pipes, for example, needs the technical skills necessary for this, as well as the appropriate language, literacy and numeracy skills to read plans, take measurements, make calculations, etc. In order to complete the task, he or she also needs non-technical skills such as planning and organising and identifying and solving problems, and skills for working effectively with others. The Core Skills for Work Developmental Framework (or CSfW) paints a detailed picture of performance in ten non-technical Skill Areas that Australian employers have identified as critical to work performance in the 21st Century. Core Skills for Work enable people to be more productive. They include the skills people need to understand their work environment, so that they can apply their technical skills more effectively. They include the skills needed to get on with people from a diverse range of backgrounds and to make use of digital technology, as well as planning, decision-making and problem-solving processes that help to get the work done. They also include skills for self-reflecting, self-regulating, making use of different perspectives, innovating and learning – all of which help people to adapt and respond flexibly and creatively to changes in the work environment. 1 The combination of LLN skills (described in the Australian Core Skills Framework) and Core Skills for Work is referred to as Foundation Skills in the Vocational Education and Training sector. In the School sector these two types of skills are described as General Capabilities and in the Higher Education sector they are referred to as Graduate Attributes. SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 1 HOW DOES THE CSFW BENEFIT EMPLOYERS? The CSfW has been developed to actively support the recognition and development of these non-technical skills. It provides a common language for talking about skills, a way of clarifying workplace expectations, identifying an individual’s strengths and areas for further development, and recognising ways in which organisations can support this. The CSfW has been developed primarily for use by: ■■ Teachers and trainers preparing learners for real work situations or facilitating learning at any stage of a person’s career ■■ Employment service providers and career counsellors helping job seekers ■■ Individuals at any stage of their working lives who want to identify their strengths and areas for further development. However, employers from a wide range of different industries who contributed to the development of the CSfW reported finding it very useful as a way of identifying – and sometimes challenging – their expectations and requirements about non-technical skills in their work environments. Employers have suggested that the CSfW could also be used as a basis for developing tailored resources to help them: ■■ Have conversations with teachers, trainers and employment services staff about what they are looking for in a prospective employee ■■ Have conversations with employees about their strengths and weaknesses ■■ Write position descriptions and undertake formal staff development processes. The CSfW differs from other approaches to ‘employability’ because it focuses on skills that can be learned, rather than focusing on desirable employee attributes. SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 2 WHICH SKILLS DOES IT COVER? The CSfW organises the ten Skill Areas into three clusters: Cluster Navigate the world of work Interact with others Get the work done SEPTEMBER 2013 Skill Area What does it cover? Manage career and work life These skills that help us to make decisions throughout life about how, when and where to work, and the skills (and willingness) to learn what a person needs to know to undertake work tasks. Work with roles, rights and protocols These skills that help us to understand our work roles and rights and the skills to undertake our work in a way that meets workplace expectations and ethical and legal responsibilities. Communicate for work The communication skills we need to get work done, including listening, understanding and getting our messages across to others. Connect and work with others The skills we need to cooperate and collaborate with others in order to get work done, including those skills we need to manage our own behaviour, to be sensitive to the needs of others and to work as a member of a team. Recognise and utilise diverse perspectives The skills that help us to recognise, respect and build on the different perspectives and behaviours that people bring to work situations, including skills to avoid or manage conflict. Plan and organise The skills we need to organise ourselves, our activities and our workloads. Make decisions The skills we need to help us choose between different options and reflect on the process and outcomes of decisions once they have been made. Identify and solve problems The skills we use to anticipate and avoid potential problems, take steps to solve them and reflect on, and learn from, each experience. Create and innovate The skills we need to identify new ideas ourselves (and to recognise the value of ideas developed by others), and apply them to improving or creating new processes, products or strategies. Work in a digital world The skills we need to use technology to get our work done, including our capacity to understand and use accepted conventions and appropriate safeguards in online environments. CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 3 WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THESE SKILLS? Individuals develop these skills over time We develop the knowledge, skills and understandings associated with each Skill Area throughout our lives. Research has identified recognisable stages that we move through as we develop our skills. To progress, we need practical hands-on experience, opportunities to try things out and time to reflect on, and learn from, what happens. Therefore, the CSfW describes performance across five Stages of Development - Novice, Advanced Beginner, Capable, Proficient and Expert.2 Different work environments require different skills or different Stages of Development There is no suggestion that every individual needs to aim to develop all of their skills to an Expert level. Every work role and environment has its own unique set of priority CSfW Skill Areas and Stages of Development. The CSfW provides generic descriptions of skills development that can be adapted and tailored to specific industries and occupations. (See pages 8-10 for an example of the generic problem solving descriptors) Performance at any time is influenced by a range of factors Our ability to use our skills or to develop them further depends on many factors. For example: ■■ Do we have opportunities to learn and practice in real work situations? ■■ Do we reflect on our performance to learn from successes and mistakes? ■■ Do we have the right kinds of supports (such as mentors, supervisors or professional networks) to help us learn from our experience? ■■ Are there cultural or attitudinal factors that are encouraging or undermining skills development and work performance? The CSfW describes a number of Influencing Factors that may affect an individual’s ability to develop and apply their skills in a specific work situation. These include: ■■ Individual factors, such as a person’s motivation, self-belief, resilience and familiarity with the work context, and the values and attitudes that affect their behaviour at work ■■ Work factors, such as the complexity of tasks, level of autonomy, the nature and degree of support available, and workplace values and culture ■■ External factors, such as an individual’s health, access to transport, housing arrangements, family responsibilities and other personal circumstances. 2 These stages are based on the Dreyfus and Dreyfus Novice to Expert Model of Skills Acquisition and other research on skill development and performance. SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 4 HOW DOES THE CSFW SUPPORT SKILL DEVELOPMENT? The CSfW takes the non-technical capabilities that employers have identified and breaks them into elements that can be more easily and explicitly taught and learned. For example, employers told us they valued punctuality. But how does someone learn to be punctual? Firstly, they need to understand that workplaces usually have expectations of when you need to be there and what to do if you can’t be there..... Then they need the skills to find out what the specific expectations of a particular workplace are.... They need planning and organising skills to make sure they can meet those expectations.... ...and they may need to address external factors, such as transport or care arrangements. While these things may seem obvious to us, a novice in navigating the world of work may benefit from explicit help in each of these areas. The knowledge, understandings and skills required for arriving on time are explicitly described by the CSfW under: ■■ Work with roles, rights and protocols ■■ Communicate for work ■■ Plan and organise, and ■■ Influencing Factors. The ability to work in a team is another commonly valued capability. Teamwork is however not a single skill, but the result of a combination of several skills, all of which are covered within the CSfW Skill Areas.3 Understanding your role and responsibilities and those of others Effective Teamwork Planning and implementing tasks and organising your workload in relation to others Managing your own behaviour, building rapport, cooperating and collaborating Communicating with others Recogising and responding to other perspectives and managing conflict 3 An explanation of how the CSfW relates to the Employability Skills and attributes developed by the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI) and the Business Council of Australia (BCA) in 2002 can be found at www.innovation.gov.au/csfw. SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 5 WHAT CAN EMPLOYERS DO TO SUPPORT SKILL DEVELOPMENT? Effective work performance is not just the result of the skills that individuals bring with them into the workplace. Employers also have a critical role to play in supporting employees to use and further develop their skills, knowledge and understandings. There are many ways in which individuals can be actively supported to perform at their best and to develop greater expertise in each of the Skill Areas. Individuals at every stage of development need opportunities to practice over time, and will benefit from some form of formal reflection on their experiences. (Even people at the Expert stage need to continue to reflect and learn if they are to maintain their expertise). However, there are also some specific types of support and opportunities that have been found to assist (or hinder) performance at each stage, and help in moving to the next stage. 4 Stage 1. A Novice performer: Is focused on trying to survive Benefits from: ■■ clearly articulated expectations, reviewed regularly to ensure they are reasonable and achievable ■■ unambiguous step by step instructions, with modelling by someone at the Capable stage or by someone with expertise in working with novices ■■ small amounts of new information at any one time ■■ a limited range of tasks with clearly stated priorities and sequences ■■ active encouragement to ask questions when something is not clear ■■ achievable challenges and opportunities to practice ■■ assistance to recognise important features of a situation ■■ acknowledgement that mistakes are an important part of learning ■■ encouragement and time to reflect May be confused or overwhelmed by: ■■ too many new ideas, information and/or new tasks at one time Stage 2. An Advanced Beginner: Is looking for certainty Benefits from: ■■ clearly articulated expectations, reviewed regularly to ensure they are reasonable and achievable ■■ assistance to identify priorities and support to reflect on why some things are more important than others ■■ a broadening range of tasks with increasing challenge ■■ formal and informal support from a Capable performer in the Skill Area concerned ■■ specific, focused feedback from a trusted mentor ■■ guided reflection and assistance to identify strategies that facilitate self reflection May be frustrated by: ■■ ambiguity and results that don’t fit established patterns 4 Based on work by Professor John Edwards of Edwards Explorations. SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 6 Stage 3. A Capable performer: Is looking for a sense of control over events/activities Benefits from: ■■ assistance to notice subtle variations, identify meaningful patterns and well articulated principles and concepts in different contexts ■■ practice in planning and coordinating increasingly complex workplace situations ■■ opportunities to learn and test new strategies (including training using games and simulations) ■■ mentoring by those who are experts in the Skill Area concerned ■■ formal feedback and reflection sessions May be frustrated by: ■■ deviations from the status quo Stage 4. A Proficient performer: Is starting to see the bigger picture Benefits from: ■■ learning inductively e.g. from complex case studies relating to real work situations that enable reflection on own experience ■■ responsibility for applying relevant skills in complex situations, supported by expert mentors ■■ coaching/guided reflection to identify principles and concepts and develop insights into the complex relationships between variables in different situations May be frustrated by: ■■ ‘context-free’ training, and inflexible rules and processes for doing things Stage 5. A Expert performer: Understands that ‘it all depends’… Benefits from: ■■ opportunities to think through complex situations, challenge accepted perceptions and ways of doing things and test new theories and strategies ■■ coaching/mentoring of individuals at the Capable and Proficient Stages ■■ reflective practice that encourages the articulation of tacit knowledge and understanding e.g. through skilled interviews conducted by fellow experts, thinking aloud using videotapes of the expert performing their work May be frustrated by: ■■ non-experts who cannot ‘see’ what is obvious to the expert or who seek the certainty of rules SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 7 SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 8 Identify problems Focus Area Recognises and responds to predictable routine problems related to role in the immediate work context Seeks assistance when problems are beyond immediate responsibilities or experience May need encouragement to seek assistance when problems are beyond immediate responsibilities or experience An Advanced Beginner in identifying and solving problems: May recognise and respond to highly obvious, routine problems in the immediate work context e.g. a disruption to a familiar procedure A Novice in identifying and solving problems: STAGES Generally accepts the obvious symptoms of a problem as ‘the problem’ and seeks to re-establish the status quo Understands when to take responsibility and when to notify others Recognises and takes responsibility for addressing predictable, and some less predictable problems in familiar work contexts A Capable performer in identifying and solving problems: Begins to look behind the obvious symptoms to redefine the problem and identify underlying causes Recognises and addresses some unfamiliar problems of increasing complexity within own scope, recognising when to seek the expertise of others Recognises and anticipates an increasing range of familiar problems, their symptoms and causes, actively looking for early warning signs and implementing contingency plans A Proficient performer in identifying and solving problems: An example of the detailed descriptors - Identify and solve problems Recognises that identified ’problems’ can be surface indicators of deeper issues, and routinely reframes problem definitions as part of the process of identifying a root cause Uses nuanced understanding of context to recognise anomalies and subtle deviations to normal expectations, focusing attention on critical issues and variables and filtering out peripheral issues Recognises and addresses complex problems involving multiple variables An Expert in identifying and solving problems: SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 9 Apply problemsolving processes Focus Area If no direction or advice is available, may attempt to solve a problem using a ‘trial and error’ approach, with a limited awareness of the potential impact of solutions Follows clear, step by step instructions or procedures to address a small set of identified, routine problems directly relevant to own role A Novice in identifying and solving problems: Where appropriate, seeks feedback or advice before implementing a solution Applies formal problem solving processes when tackling an unfamiliar problem, breaking complex issues into manageable parts and identifying and evaluating several options for action Where standardised procedures or assistance is not available, addresses unfamiliar problems by applying past solutions that may appear to have some relevance to the current situation A Capable performer in identifying and solving problems: Initiates standard procedures when responding to familiar problems within immediate context An Advanced Beginner in identifying and solving problems: Begins to identify and implement standard solutions for an increasing number of routine problems STAGES Uses analytical processes to decide on a course of action, establishing criteria for deciding between options, and seeking input and advice from others before taking action when necessary When dealing with complex issues, may use intuition to identify the general problem area, switching to analytical processes to clarify goals and key issues, and using lateral thinking processes to generate possible solutions In familiar contexts, responds intuitively to problems requiring immediate attention, quickly drawing on past experience to devise solutions A Proficient performer in identifying and solving problems: An Expert in identifying and solving problems: May identify a need for further information or seek advice from relevant experts May use formal analytical and lateral thinking techniques for identifying issues, generating and evaluating possible solutions May invest time in defining the real problem, using a variety of techniques to challenge initial perceptions of the situation, identify key contributing factors and critical issues May intuitively hone in on the problem area and identify a small set of possible appropriate solutions Approaches problem solving in diverse ways, recognising that there is no formula and that ‘it all depends’ An example of the detailed descriptors - Identify and solve problems (Continued) SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 10 Review outcomes Focus Area With guidance, may identify some ways in which a suggested solution worked or did not work, and suggest actions that could be taken in a similar situation A Novice in identifying and solving problems: An Advanced Beginner in identifying and solving problems: May reflect on outcomes and identify what worked, or develop an improved approach for future situations STAGES With guidance, begins to reflect on the effectiveness of a selected problem solving process Considers the effectiveness of a solution in terms of how well it met stated goals, and seeks to improve a future response when a solution does not achieve its intended outcome A Capable performer in identifying and solving problems: Reflects on the appropriateness and effectiveness of the problem solving process used and identifies some key principles that may be relevant in future situations Acknowledges where a solution did not achieve expected outcomes and seeks a range of perspectives to understand why, including a rethinking of original goals Uses formal and informal processes to monitor implementation of solutions and reflect on outcomes A Proficient performer in identifying and solving problems: An Expert in identifying and solving problems: Reflects on the application of key principles in a particular context, the appropriateness and effectiveness of different sources of information and problem solving processes for that context, and the potential implications for future situations Uses every situation as an opportunity for extending insights and understanding, recognising that any solution will have both intended and unintended consequences and that cause and effect may not be closely or obviously linked An example of the detailed descriptors - Identify and solve problems (Continued) WANT TO KNOW MORE? You can find a copy of the complete Core Skills for Work Developmental Framework, and examples of other tools and resources that have been developed based on the CSfW at www.innovation.gov.au/csfw How was the CSfW developed? The Australian Government funded the development of the CSfW across 2011 and 2012. More than 800 people had input into its development, including employers, unions, industry groups and a broad cross-section of organisations from the school, vocational education and training, university and employment services sectors – all of which have an interest in, and potential use for, the CSfW. The development also drew upon recent research about employability and generic skills and their development, as well as analysis of a range of current approaches to addressing employability and generic skills in Australia and overseas. The current version of the CSfW is intended to be reviewed after a number of years of use to check whether it would benefit from adjustment or further development. The CSfW follows on from the Mayer Key Competencies that were developed in the 1990s and the Employability Skills Framework developed in 2002 by the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI) and the Business Council of Australia (BCA) with funding from the Commonwealth Government. If you would like to find out more about how the CSfW relates to the 2002 Employability Skills, go to www.innovation.gov.au/csfw SEPTEMBER 2013 CORE SKILLS FOR WORK DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK: A GUIDE FOR EMPLOYERS 11