440 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 21, NO. 1, JANUARY 2006 Frequency-Domain Analysis of the Static Synchronous Series Compensator Anil C. Pradhan and P. W. Lehn, Member, IEEE Abstract—This paper presents an analytical formulation of the frequency-domain characteristics of the static synchronous series compensator (SSSC). This paper investigates the characteristics of using two different types of SSSC controllers–one with quadrature voltage regulation ( -controlled SSSC) and another with impedance regulation ( -controlled SSSC). The influence of the controller parameters on the characteristics is investigated and it is demonstrated that an SSSC-compensated transmission line displays an impedance minimum at a subsynchronous frequency similar to a capacitively compensated transmission line. The analytical results are validated with the results obtained by time-domain simulations. Fig. 1. Simplified diagram of the SSSC. Index Terms—Frequency-domain characteristics, static synchronous series compensator (SSSC), -controlled SSSC, -controlled SSSC. Fig. 2. Equivalent representations of the SSSC. (a) AC side. (b) DC side. I. INTRODUCTION T HE STATIC synchronous series compensator (SSSC) has been developed as an alternative to the conventional capacitor-based series compensators [1]–[3]. Apart from having other advantages, the SSSC was thought to be immune to subsynchronous resonance (SSR), which is inherent in capacitor-based compensators [4]. Through simulation, [5] has shown that the SSSC, contrary to initial expectations is, in fact, susceptible to SSR. Though frequency-domain characteristics of the SSSC and the capacitor-based series compensator are different and resonance occurs at different frequencies for the same amount of series compensation, both types of compensators can potentially excite SSR and have influence on neighboring turbine generators. Reference [5] also shows that the controller strategy has a significant effect on the frequency-domain characteristics of the SSSC. Furthermore, the control parameters also affect the impedance characteristic of the SSSC. While this study is sufficient for the observation of the frequency-domain characteristics of the SSSC, it offers little insight into the resonance phenomenon. The frequency response of the unified power-flow controller (UPFC) is investigated in [6]. It develops an analytical model of the UPFC containing other frequencies in addition to the fundamental. However, the analytical model developed in [6] ignores the influence of the controller which, for the SSSC, has Manuscript received October 6, 2004; revised January 11, 2005. Paper no. TPWRD-00471-2004. A. C. Pradhan is with Teshmont Consultants LP, Winnipeg, MB R3T 0P4, Canada (e-mail: apradhan@teshmont.com). P. W. Lehn is with the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON M5S 3G4, Canada (e-mail: lehn@ecf.utoronto.ca). Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPWRD.2005.852311 a significant impact on the impedance characteristic. Therefore, consideration of the controller’s effect must be included in the analytical model to understand the frequency-response behavior of the SSSC in totality. This paper develops a frequency-domain model of the SSSC including the influence of the controls. The impedance characteristic of the SSSC in the subsynchronous frequency range is derived for both the - and -controlled SSSC. The developed model is employed to demonstrate the influence of the control strategy and controller gains on the impedance characteristics. Finally, the model is validated by comparison with time-domain simulation results obtained from PSCAD/EMTDC–electromagnetic (EM) transient simulation software. II. MODELING OF THE SSSC A. Fundamental Frequency Model The fundamental frequency SSSC model is based on the simplified circuit diagram given in Fig. 1. In the figure, the SSSC is represented by a synchronous sinusoidal voltage source with a variable amplitude and phase angle on the ac side. The ac side of the SSSC also consists of a boost and leakage inductransformer represented with resistance tance . The dc side of the SSSC is represented by a current source connected to the dc capacitor. The equivalent representation of the ac and dc sides of the SSSC is given in Fig. 2, where represents losses in the converter. For simplification of the system equations, the following has been considered: 0885-8977/$20.00 © 2006 IEEE (1) (2) (3) PRADHAN AND LEHN: FREQUENCY-DOMAIN ANALYSIS OF THE SSSC 441 The mathematical model of the SSSC given in Fig. 1 in the reference frame can be written as follows: TABLE I RESULTS OF STEADY-STATE CALCULATIONS (4) The dynamics of the dc side of the voltage-source converter (VSC) are obtained from Fig. 2 to be where (5) and (6) where is the capacitance of the capacitor and is the side current. reference frame are transformed into a Equations in the rotating reference frame time-invariant form, namely the (7) The converter terminal voltage and dc voltage are given by (8) Equation (11) is the final form of the SSSC equation in a reference frame when operated in capacitive mode. Similarly, the equation can be derived for the inductive mode by changing the angle between the injected voltage and the line current from to in (10). Since the main objective is to study behavior of the SSSC and its interaction with the network while working in a capacitive mode, (11) has been derived to reflect the capacitive mode of the SSSC. III. STEADY-STATE MODEL OF THE SSSC For a fixed value of , the steady-state solution of (11) may be found by solving a linear system of the form (12) (9) where inverter constant, which gives the relation between dc side voltage and ac side peak, phase-to-neutral voltage; angle of relative to ; modulation index of the inverter; transformation ratio of the boost transformer. In order to make the SSSC work in the capacitive mode, the . line current must lead the injected compensating voltage by of the Therefore, the controller must determine the angle injected voltage as follows: where the subscript denotes that excitation is at the synand is the state of the chronous angular frequency of in the steady-state system in steady state. The state variables regime can be calculated using (13) (13) Five steady-state operating points of interest are calculated and the results are presented in Table I. The operating points of interest correspond to 0%, 25%, 35%, 45%, and 55% compensation of transmission-line impedance. The parameters of transmission line, boosting transformer, and VSC are given in the Appendix. IV. SSSC CONTROLLER (10) is the angle between line voltage and the line current where and is a small perturbation added to the inverter voltage angle needed to charge or discharge the capacitor voltage (Fig. 4). Finally, combining (7)–(10) gives (11) A. General The primary function of the SSSC is to control the power flow in the transmission line. This objective can be achieved either by direct control of the line current or, alternatively, by the indirect or the compocontrol of either the compensating reactance nent of that is quadrature to the line current [2], [4]. Indirect power-flow control through either reactance regulation ( control) or quadrature voltage regulation ( control) is exclusively used in the literature. and This section gives only a brief description of the controllers; more details may be found in [4]. 442 Fig. 3. IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 21, NO. 1, JANUARY 2006 TABLE II CONTROLLER DESIGN FOR V -CONTROLLED SSSC (K = 1:11 E -5 AND K = 0:001) SUMMARY OF THE SUMMARY OF THE Control block diagram of SSSC (X control). TABLE III CONTROLLER DESIGN FOR X -CONTROLLED SSSC (K = 1:11 E -5 AND K = 0:001) Fig. 5. Simplified diagram of the SSSC with subsynchronous voltage excitation. C. Fig. 4. Phasor diagram of the controller. B. Control of the SSSC The control circuit used in [4] is described. The control block diagram is given in Fig. 3. A phasor diagram is given in Fig. 4, which helps to understand the function of the SSSC controller. A phase-locked loop (PLL) is used to determine the instanin Fig. 1. The taneous angle of the three phase voltage and of the three-phase line currents are calcomponents culated in a synchronously rotating reference frame using . and are then used to determine the amplitude of the current and its angle relative to , called . The required ampliis determined by tude of the SSSC’s compensating voltage multiplying the current amplitude by the desired compensating . reactance The required angle of the ac compensating voltage space vector is determined by first calculating the instantaneous phase , and then eiof the line current space vector ther adding (inductive) or subtracting (capacitive) accordingly. The SSSC controller, in this case, assumes a fixed across the inverter, so the reference value dc to ac gain , in turn, determines the reference inverter of ac voltage dc voltage . A proportional-integral (PI) controller reguto by adding a small phase offset to angle lates forming the instantaneous phase of the injected compensating voltage space vector. The phase offset results in a power exchange with the dc link, as required for dc voltage regulation. Control of the SSSC control. In this A similar control strategy can be used for with case, instead of multiplying the current magnitude to obtain , is directly given as a reference. All of the remaining control functions given in Fig. 3 remain the same. D. Controller Design A simple PI controller has been designed for both the -con-controlled SSSC. Tables II and III trolled SSSC and the summarize the system’s small-signal performance about the operating points calculated in Table I. Comparing Tables II and III, there are differences in values of overshoots, settling times, and closed-loop poles between the two types of controllers. Nonetheless, in both cases, the system is stable and well damped. All subsequent analysis is done based on the steady-state solutions and controller designs described in Sections III and IV. V. FREQUENCY-DOMAIN CHARACTERISTICS OF THE SSSC A. General This section investigates the response of the SSSC when the ac source contains an additional excitation voltage source at subsynchronous frequency. Fig. 5 shows the SSSC connected to a transmission system operating at a fundamental frequency . A positive-sequence subsynchronous excitation voltage is applied to the system. PRADHAN AND LEHN: FREQUENCY-DOMAIN ANALYSIS OF THE SSSC 443 Reference [7] shows that the interaction of the VSC at fundawith an additional positive-sequence excimental frequency tation voltage at angular frequency causes ac-side currents at angular frequency and and dc side voltage ripple at . Reference [8] also shows similar angular frequency expressions for ac-side currents and the dc-side voltage of the inverter when the line voltage is unbalanced or distorted. frame equations are used to develop the frequencyThe domain characteristics of the SSSC. The VSC equations in the frame can be written as follows: ac side (14) dc side (15) Terminal voltage of the VSC is (16) Positive-sequence excitation voltages at the fundamental frequency and subsynchronous frequency can be expressed as follows: (17) (18) In steady state, ac-side current, including the fundamental component, can be written as follows: ; and are current amplitudes and . Simiphases at angular frequencies of , , and is the amplitude of the dc voltage at steady state and larly, are amplitude and phase angle of the dc-side voltage . at angular frequency B. Equations of the SSSC With Control Substituting (17)–(20) into (14)–(16) and applying harmonic balance, the following equations in phasor form are obtained as shown in (21)–(23) at the bottom of the page, where and the underlined parameters are peak phasors. Refer to the Appendix for detailed derivations of (22) and (23). Phasors are defined as at angular frequency ; at angular frequency ; at angular frequency ; at angular frequency ; at angular frequency ; phasor of at frequency ; phasor of at frequency . Since solutions for the fundamental frequency current and voltage components are already obtained, they are neglected in (21)–(23). Similarly, higher-order components of the equations, and components at other angular frequencies are neglected because of their very small magnitudes.1 Only the ac-side currents at angular frequencies and and dc-side voltage are considered. ripple at angular frequency control mode of the SSSC, dc voltage controller In the is given by output, (24) (19) (20) Combining (21)–(24), the -controlled SSSC equation can be written as (25), shown at the bottom of the next page. Due to the conjugate terms in (25), an expansion in terms of the real and imaginary parts of the phasors is necessary to yield Note that , and are amplitudes and phases and and of excitation voltages at angular frequencies 1It has been assumed that harmonic components resulting from the subsynchronous excitation are much smaller than the fundamental frequency components. Finally, the dc voltage may be expressed as follows: (21) (22) (23) 444 the final form of the -controlled SSSC equation as shown in (26) at the bottom of the page, where IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 21, NO. 1, JANUARY 2006 In (26), subscripts and are real and imaginary parts of the currents and voltages. Equation (26) is a linear system of equations that can be expressed in the generalized matrix form as Assuming is invertible, this system may be solved as (27) , , , , , , , and may Using (27), be calculated for different subsynchronous excitation voltages. C. Equations of the SSSC With Control The derivation of equations for the SSSC with control will control mode except for the be valid for the SSSC in the (25) (26) PRADHAN AND LEHN: FREQUENCY-DOMAIN ANALYSIS OF THE SSSC control portion. The equation for can be written as follows: in the 445 -controlled SSSC (28) represents ripple in the dc reference command where controller. It may be found from voltage, resulting from the the linearization of (29) (29) Neglecting higher order terms and the fundamental solution, can be approximated as (30) , therefore only contains terms at frequency and may be expressed by a phasor at that frequency according to where (31) Fig. 6. Theoretical results of frequency-response characteristics of the V -controlled SSSC. from (27) and then the impedance is calculated using (33). (The magnitude of the excitation voltage at subsynchronous is known.) frequency (33) Substituting (31) in (28), a new matrix may be found, shown in (32) at the bottom of the page, where VI. RESULTS OF FREQUENCY-DOMAIN ANALYSIS A. General and all other elements are as defined in (26). This will form control, including the complete equation of the SSSC with influence of the control parameters. D. Subsynchronous Impedance of the -Controlled SSSC A single-line diagram of a simplified power system with an SSSC is given in Fig. 5 and its parameters are given in the Appendix. The SSSC is located halfway between sending and receiving ends. The transmission-line voltage is 138 kV and the phase-angle difference between sending and receiving ends is 30 . The fundamental frequency of the power system is 60 Hz. In addition to the supply voltage at the fundamental frequency, a 2-kV excitation voltage at the subsynchronous frequency is inserted at the sending end. The frequency of the excitation voltage is varied between 60 to 60 Hz. - and In order to calculate the impedance at different subsynand are calculated chronous frequencies, first currents B. Currents and and Voltage Figs. 6 and 7 show the frequency response of the ac currents at and the dc voltage ripple angular frequencies and (32) 446 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 21, NO. 1, JANUARY 2006 Fig. 9. Comparison of impedance characteristics of the and (operating point 4). SSSC with different K K V - and X -controlled C. Impedance Fig. 7. Theoretical results of frequency-response characteristics of the -controlled SSSC. X The impedance characteristics of the - and -controlled SSSC are given in Fig. 8. Four curves represent the impedance associated with each of the four operating points (from Op. pt. 1 to Op. pt. 4 in Table I). These figures demonstrate that the SSSC has a frequency-domain impedance characteristic somewhat similar to that of a conventional series compensator. This analytically obtained result is consistent with the simulation results observed in [5]. The SSSC has resonant minima at subsynchronous frequencies for both types of controllers, which means it can potentially excite SSR and have influence on nearby turbine generators. Second, the controller type can be seen to strongly influence the frequency-response behavior of the SSSC. D. Effects of Controller Parameters ( Fig. 8. Theoretical impedance characteristics of the SSSC. V - and X -controlled at angular frequency for the - and -controlled SSSC, respectively. The top plot of the figures shows the subsynchronous ac current at angular frequency . This plot may be used to determine the impedance of the SSSC as a function of the frequency. The second plot shows the ac current that will flow at frequency due to the applied subsynchronous voltage of frequency . The last plot shows the additional dc voltage compo. nent at angular frequency From the figures, it can be noticed that the frequency-reand controls are sponse characteristics of the SSSC with quite different. Consider the current at angular frequency . In control, the current peaks at all operating points are of the same magnitude and peaks are spread between 7 and 20 Hz. control, magnitudes of the current However, in the case of peaks differ with an operating point and they are spread between also 7 and 45 Hz. The dc voltages at angular frequency differ for the two types of SSSC controls. In the -controlled is zero at all frequencies for SSSC, the magnitude of all operating points. However, in the case of the -controlled differ with frequency and operSSSC, magnitudes of ating point. Similarly, there are significant differences between . currents at angular frequency and ) Fig. 9 shows the impedance characteristics of the - and -controlled SSSC with different controller parameters. It can be noticed from the figure that impedance of the -controlled SSSC is insensitive to the control parameters and the resonant frequency is solely a function of the oper-controlled SSSC, ating point. However, in the case of the impedance and the resonant frequencies vary significantly with control parameters. Therefore, the impedance characteristic -controlled SSSC is a function of both the operating of the point and the control parameters. VII. VALIDATION OF RESULTS The proposed model is validated against PSCAD/EMTDC simulation results. The simulation includes a complete representation of the SSSC controller, the gating logic, and the power semiconductors. For simplicity, the SSSC simulated consisted of a single three-phase VSC that employed sinusoidal pulsewidth modulation to eliminate low-order harmonics.2 A. Steady-State Operation of the SSSC The steady-state results of simulation and the analysis are compared in Table IV. As expected, a close agreement is found between the simulation and the analytical steady-state operating 2Comparable results are expected for SSSCs using multipulse converter systems as the time averaged behavior of a system is independent of the specific switching scheme. In contrast, SSSCs using converter structures that employ multiple separate dc-side capacitors may display additional resonant modes due to the increased order of the state model. PRADHAN AND LEHN: FREQUENCY-DOMAIN ANALYSIS OF THE SSSC 447 TABLE IV STEADY-STATE SOLUTIONS TABLE V COMPARISON OF ANALYTICAL AND SIMULATION RESULTS (V -CONTROLLED SSSC), OP. PT. 2–V = 2 kV, f = 15 Hz Fig. 10. Comparison of impedance with V and X controls. VIII. CONCLUSION TABLE VI COMPARISON OF ANALYTICAL AND SIMULATION RESULTS (X -CONTROLLED SSSC), OP. PT. 2–V = 2 kV, f = 15 Hz point calculations. According to the table, the maximum error is about 1.4%, which is negligible. B. Frequency-Domain Characteristics and and voltage are comCurrents pared numerically with simulation results in Tables V and VI. Operating point 2 is considered for the comparison. A posi15 Hz is tive-sequence voltage of 2 kV with a frequency of injected. As indicated in the previous section, the current will have components at 15 and 105 Hz and the dc voltage will have a component at 45 Hz. Extraction of frequency components of currents and voltage is obtained using a discrete Fourier transform (DFT). Tables V and VI show the comparison of the analytical and simulation results of the ac currents and the dc voltage -controlled SSSC, respectively. According to the for - and tables, errors are small. This paper presents an exhaustive mathematical formulation of the frequency-domain characteristics of the SSSC. It includes all of the parameters that have an influence on characteristics including operating point and control parameters. The accuracy of the analytical formulation has then been established through comparison with simulation. Analytical and simulation results have been found to closely match. A small discrepancy has been found in the neighborhood of 60 Hz (negative sequence, fundamental frequency); however, it is small and not in the frequency range of interest for SSR studies. The following conclusions can be made from this study. -con• Both the -controlled (voltage reference) and trolled (impedance reference) SSSCs are found to have frequency-domain characteristics somewhat similar to that of a conventional series capacitor with a resonant minimum at subsynchronous frequency. -con• For the same amount of compensation, - and trolled SSSCs display different frequency-domain impedance characteristics. The resonant minima occur at different frequencies and impedance minima are of differing amplitudes. -controlled • Frequency-domain characteristics of the SSSC are a function of the operating point as well as the and . PI controller parameters -controlled • Frequency-domain characteristics of the SSSC are only a function of the operating point and are invariant to changes in the controller parameters. -controlled SSSC has more natural damping than • The the -controlled SSSC. C. Impedance Characteristic The time-domain simulation is used to validate the frequencydomain impedance characteristic of the SSSC. The frequency of the subsynchronous voltage is varied from 60 to 60 Hz. Sim-controlled SSSC. ulation is completed for both the - and Operating points 1 and 3 are chosen for validation of the frequency domain impedance of the SSSC. The analytical and simulated impedance characteristics of -controlled SSSC are plotted in Fig. 10. As can the - and be seen, analytical and simulation results closely match. In the neighborhood of 60 Hz, there are minor mismatches, however, they are not significant. The impedance characteristic of the SSSC found through analysis is substantiated by the simulation. Therefore, validity of the analytical model is proven. APPENDIX A DERIVATIONS OF ANGLES A. Angle Since the dc side of the VSC contains voltages at angular fre, , the output of the dc voltage quencies zero and controller also contains components at these frequencies. Therefore, can be expressed as (34) where angle is the amplitude of at steady state and angle is the amplitude at angular frequency . is the phase of the oscillatory component. 448 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 21, NO. 1, JANUARY 2006 B. Angle According to Fig. 4, angle is the angle between voltage space vector and the current space vector . Due to the presence of subsynchronous voltage, there is a small perturbation around its steady-state operating point that can be of angle represented as (35) is the angle at steady-state operation and related to where the operating point. is a small angle perturbation around due to the presence of subsynchronous voltage. the angle Since steady-state operating points have already been calcuis known. The next step is to define lated (refer to Table I), the angle . The ac-side current can be expressed as a space vector as where and so on. The above equation in the reference frame is The expression of angle in terms of currents is The results of this Appendix are used to derive equations for the ac terminal voltage and the dc-side equation of the VSC presented in Appendix B. APPENDIX B AND dc VOLTAGE TERMINAL VOLTAGE Substituting (39) and (20) into (16), and neglecting higher may be order terms, the following expression for obtained (36) where and . The last two terms of the denominator are small compared and are neglected. Similarly, the numerator is very small to compared to the denominator. Therefore, can be approximated as In the phasor form, this can be expressed as three equations–one at angular frequency , another at , and the other at . Since the solution for the fundamental currents and voltages have already been obtained and accounted for by the operating points, they are not considered. At frequency (40) (37) At frequency Equation (37) shows that apart from a dc component, angle contains a component at angular frequency . (41) C. Angle By definition (38) Substituting (34) and (37) in (38), the expression for be obtained can (39) These expressions for and are represented by (22) in matrix form. Similarly, substituting (39) and (19) into (15), the dc side of the VSC equation is obtained PRADHAN AND LEHN: FREQUENCY-DOMAIN ANALYSIS OF THE SSSC 449 MVA; 2) Boosting transformer: ; ; MVA; kV; 3) VSC: F; switching frequency kV; H kV; Hz REFERENCES [1] N. G. Hingorani and L. Gyugyi, Understanding FACTS Concept and Technology of Flexible AC Transmission Systems. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE Press, 2000. [2] L. Gyugyi, C. D. Schauder, and K. K. Sen, “Static synchronous series compensator: A solid-state approach to the series compensation of transmission lines,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 406–417, Jan. 1997. [3] L. Gyugyi, “Dynamic compensation of AC transmission lines by solidstate synchronous voltage sources,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 904–911, Apr. 1994. [4] K. K. Sen, “Static synchronous series compensator: Theory modeling and applications,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 241–246, Jan. 1998. [5] B. S. Rigby and R. G. Harley, “Resonant characteristics of inverter based transmission line series compensators,” in Proc. 30th Annu. IEEE Power Electronics Specialist Conf., vol. 1, Aug. 1999, pp. 412–417. [6] I. Papic and A. M. Gole, “Frequency response characteristics of the unified power flow controller,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 18, no. 4, pp. 1394–1402, Oct. 2003. [7] M. Mohaddes, A. M. Gole, and E. Sladjana, “Steady state frequency response of STATCOM,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 18–23, Jan. 2001. [8] C. Schauder and H. Mehta, “Vector analysis and control of advanced static VAR compensators,” Proc. Inst. Elect. Eng. C, vol. 140, no. 4, pp. 299–306, Jul. 1993. (42) Neglecting fundamental and second-order terms and simplifying (42), the following expression for the dc side of the VSC equation is obtained: (43) Substituting (20) into (43) and writing it in a phasor form gives (44) APPENDIX C PARAMETERS OF POWER SYSTEM 1) Parameters of transmission line: kV; ; ; H. kV; ; H; Anil C. Pradhan received the Diploma in electrical engineering from Belorussian Polytechnic Institute, Minsk, Belarus, in 1987 and the M.A.Sc. degree in electrical engineering from the University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, in 2004. From 1987 to 2001, he was a Transmission and Distribution Engineer with the Nepal Electricity Authority, Kathmandu. His research interests include power system planning and studies. Mr. Pradhan is a Chartered Electrical Engineer in the U.K. since 1996. P. W. Lehn (M’99) received the B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees in electrical engineering from the University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB, Canada, in 1990 and 1992, respectively, and the Ph.D. degree from the University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada, in 1999. Currently, he is an Associate Professor at the University of Toronto. From 1992 to 1994, he was with the Network Planning Group of Siemens AG, Erlangen, Germany.