1. Introduction
considering comments from:
 21-05-0413-00-0000-General_MIH_ref_model.doc (ref 1)
 21-05-0423-00-0000-GeneralModel5_5_v1.doc (ref 2)
 21-05-0425-00-0000-InterDigital3GPPAmendments.doc (ref 3)
2. Figure 3: General MIH Reference Model
Direction of the
arrows to be
discussed
CS
Higher Layer
(eg. mobility management apps.)
ES
CS
IS
MIH
Function
CS
CS
ES
IS
IS
MIH Function
E
S
C
S
I
S
Lower layer
Transport
ES
IS
Higher Layer Transport
ES
Upper
Layers
E
S
C
S
I
S
MIH Function
E
S
C
S
I
S
E
S
C
S
I
S
CS
3 GPP
3 GPP2
802.x
( 11,16)
ES
Lower
Layers
IS
Network Side
Terminal Side
Legend
Layer 3 Transport
ES: Event Service
Layer 2 Transport
CS: Command Service
Local Interactions
IS: Information Service
Our Comments :



compared to orignial figure, the management plane is substituted with “Media
Independent L2 Transport”. Management plane is technology specific and is
already covered by the respective boxes
The direction of ES, CS, IS locally between MIHF and L2-Transport box is
bidirectional. It is because, just like higher layer, this transport is used to carry
the information between the peers. Since the L2-Transport box is situated in
the terminal, it is local communication between MIHF and itself
The intention of remaining ES, CS and IS pointing to lower layers is to extract
the information from the respective technology locally. It is also valid for IS as
some information is already available and can be acquired directly instead of
contacting the server (eg. QoS support in .11, is being discussed in .11e and
can be extracted directly if it is integrated)

Comments from e-mail:
1) Ref (1) shows the transport of MIH services between Lower Layer at the
network side and 802.21 MIH function as a local interface. However there are
other cases to consider. For example, in ref (3) we show this scenario as the
collocated case. However we also show that these services can transported
over higher layer transport (L3) or layer 2 as well. Furthermore in ref (3) we
stress that at the network side there is no direct communication between
3GPP/3GPP2 lower layers and the MIH function.
2) In ref (3) 3GPP and 3GPP2 communicate toward a MIH Network Entity
using higher layer transport. This is not described in ref (1)
3) Ref (1) shows communication from MIH function in the client station to its
peer at the Network through a higher layer transport. This is consistent with ref
(3). Then the interface goes through what it is referred to as 'Higher Layer'
before it communicates with the MIH peer. This is very similar to ref (3) for
case where the interface goes through the MIH Network Entity (e.g., the
Upper Layer being part of the MIH Network Entity). However the scenario
where just a L3 interface is used to communicate between two MIH peers is
not described. This is depicted in ref (3) as double-headed arrow that goes
from MIH to MIH simply using a Higher Layer Transport.
4) You also indicate that the management plane has been replaced by what it is
referred to as L2 transport and that the Management Plane is technology
specific and therefore it is already covered in the corresponding box. Here I
have a comment and a question: If it is already included in the box, why would
we need to specify a L2 transport? Also from ref (1) the common layer 2
transport (or lower layer) depicted in the figure indicates that both
3GPP/3GPP2 and 802 components used the same L2 transport, this is not
accurate. Furthermore, we have discussed two different mechanisms to send
MIH information both peer to peer and localy: 1) Over the management plane
(e.g.,through the introduction of a new action frame format), and 2) Over the
Data Plane using LSAP (e.g.,through the introduction of a new ethertype). It is
not obvious how the "Lower layer Transport" handles these two mechanism, in
particular considering that they interface between the LLT and the MIH
function is depicted as a local interface. This might be accurate for locally
generated events but not for peer to peer remote events
Leyend:
ES/CS/IS: Event Service/Command
Service/Information Service
CS: Convergence Sublayer
LLC: Logical Link Control
MAC: Medium Access Control
MIH: Media Independent Handover
PHY: Physical Layer
MIH Network En
(E.g., MIH Server Con
IS/CS/ES over Higher Layer Transport
Layer 3 Transport
Layer 2 Transport
Local Interactions
Media
Media
Independent
Independent
Handover
HandoverUser
User
Higher Layer
Transport
(E.g.,IP)
ES/
CS/
IS
Client
Station
Media Independent Handover
Function
ES/
CS/
IS
Media Independent Handover
Function
Higher Layer Transport/L2/Colocated with MIH
Higher
Tran
ES/
CS/
IS
ES
ES
LLC/CS
CS
3GPP/
3GPP2
Interface
LLC/CS
CS
IS
IS
MAC
PHY
MAC
PHY
MGMT
802 Interface
MGMT
IS/ES/CS over L2 Transport
802 Network
3GPP/
3GPP2
Networ