Discourse in social change Ideology is the prime means of manufacturing

advertisement
Discourse in social change
Ideology is the prime
means of manufacturing
consent (Fairclough 2001)
Text is ideologically creative and
it appears as:
• Individual
• Commonsensical
Texts should be thought in terms
of:
• one’s position in society
• how society positions
individuals over time
Foucault’s notion of technologies of
themselves
• Academic discourse
types are
instrumentals in
framing our identity
and our subjectivity
Discourse and social struggle
• Physical struggle (revolution, war,
demonstrations, protests, elections)
• Ideological struggle in language
• Ideological power (having power to
legitimize and to naturalize)
Discourse types
• Ideologically particular or ideologically
variable (one position or another)
• Determined by different economic and
political realities (elite and dominant block)
• Naturalization and universality of
discourses (sustaining power in social
institutions)
Alternative discourses
• Conscious (against dominant
discourse)
• Oppositional (resistance)
• Marginal to political and
economic dominance
Presentation of experiential
values through words
• Coded in vocabulary
• Significance of ideology
in words (subversive,
democratic forces, etc)
The Contra war in Nicaragua
• Depending on the discourse they are freedom
fighters or murderers
Relations between words in
discourse
• Ideologically contested
• Meaning depending on the discourse
• Depending on the relation of some words
with others (communism and evil Empire
versus communism and solidarity)
Contemporary capitalism is
characterized by a degree of
colonization of peoples’ lives by
systems such as the economy and
state institutions in which
discourse is the most important
tool.
Two ways of colonization of
people’s lives
• Consumerism(economy
and commodity markets)
• Institutional control
(bureaucracy, social order)
Social tendencies
• Imposed by the dominant block
• They change according to the change of
these tendencies
• Discourse of consumerism: re-structuring of
other discourse types
Strategic discourse versus
communicative discourse
• Strategic discourse: discourse oriented to
instrumental goals, to getting results
(advertising)
• Communicative discourse: oriented to
reaching understanding between
participants
The dimensions of ideological
work in advertising
• The relationship advertising discourse construct
between the producer/advertiser and the consumer
• The way advertising discourse builds an imagine
for the product (predicated on the ideology
(freedom, richness, efficiency, etc)
• The way it constructs subject positions for
consumers
Cultural capitalism
The process of industrialization
and urbanization that has
destroyed traditional cultural
ties: Traditional ties (extended
families, religion or ethnic
community) are replaced (ties
of class)
How does advertising construct
consumption communities?
It does it indirectly
• Through ideology
• Superficial view of the relationship between
truth and fiction
• Commons sense assumptions
How does advertisement work
ideologically?
Works ideologically through
• Building relations
• Building images
• Building the consumer
Give an example of a common
sense assumption in a power
relationship. How can this
common sense assumption
contribute to sustaining unequal
power relations?
Download