Monitoring and Study of Marine Pollution: Activities at the IAEA - Marine Environmental Studies Laboratory Stephen de Mora Marine Environmental Studies Laboratory (MESL) International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Marine Environment Laboratory 4, Quai Antoine 1er MONACO Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Monitoring and Study of Marine Pollution • Introduction – MEL and MESL • Facilities and Capabilities – 11 laboratories in MESL • Supporting Regional Seas Programmes • Research • The Future Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency The only Marine Laboratory in the UN System 1961 1961 - Laboratory established in the Oceanographic Museum 1988 -Temporary facilities in the Louis II Football Stadium 1998 - Permanent facilities on the Port of Monaco 1998 1988 Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Marine Environment Laboratory Organizational Chart Hugh D. Livingston DIRECTOR-NAML Pavel P. Povinec Head RADIOMETRICS LABORATORY Scott W. Fowler Head RADIOECOLOGY LABORATORY Stephen J. de Mora Head MARINE ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES LABORATORY H1 Measurement and Assessment of Radionuclides in the Marine Environment H2 Transfer of Radionuclides in the Marine Environment H3 Monitoring and Study of Marine Pollution Marine Environment Marine Environment Laboratory Laboratory Department of Department of Nuclear Nuclear Sciences Sciences and and Applications Applications International Atomic International Atomic Energy Energy Agency Agency Mission of MESL Interactions between Environmental Quality and Marine Resources Environment Resources Effect of Non-nuclear Pollutants on the Marine Environment Safe and Sustainable use of Marine Resources People Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Marine Environmental Studies Laboratory • MESL has expertise in: – Marine analytical chemistry – Marine pollution monitoring and assessment – Chemical oceanography & marine biogeochemistry • Within the IAEA: – Laboratory responsible for the study of non-nuclear marine pollution – Manages the H.3 subprogramme entitled Monitoring and Study of Marine Pollution • Within the UN System: – MESL co-ordinates the Inter-agency Programme on Marine Pollution – Interacts with various Regional Seas Programmes: MED POL, ROPME, BSEP, CEP Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency IAEA H.3 Subprogramme: Projects • Environmental Analytical Chemistry in Support of Marine Pollution Monitoring Programmes • Marine Pollution Assessment in Coastal Regions and Bioresources, including support to UN Inter-Agency Activities • Nuclear Techniques in Studies of Marine Antifoulants in Coastal Environments • Isotopic Applications in Non-radioactive Marine Contaminant Studies Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Ongoing Support to UN Inter-agency Marine-Related Activities UNEP IAEA IOC Inter-agency Programme on Marine Pollution Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Analysis of Inorganic Contaminants • Inorganic pollutants includes heavy metals and organometallic species such as methylmercury and tributyltin • Instruments: – aas (flame, cold vapour, hydride generation, graphite furnace) – atomic fluorescence detectors for mercury analyses – ICP-MS Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Analysis of Mercury and Methylmercury • Determination of mercury and methylmercury – water, sediments and biota • Instruments: – aas (cold vapour) – atomic fluorescence – AMA 254 Mercury Analyzer Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Isotopic Analyses using ICP-MS Finnigan Element High Resolution ICP-MS • Multi-element technique • Isotopic analyses (uranium isotopes in tap water) • High sensitivity sub-fg detection limits (U-234 is ~30 fg/mL in domestic water) • High resolution for resolving problematic spectral interferences • Speed most analyses require a scan of <2 minutes intensity (cps) 1000000 100000 Uranium Isotopes in Tap Water 10000 1000 100 10 1 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 mass (amu) intensity (cps) 100000 Separation of Fe from ArO+ 80000 60000 40000 20000 0 55.88 55.9 55.92 55.94 55.96 mass (amu) 55.98 56 56.02 Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Analysis of Organic Contaminants Organic contaminants analysed: – petroleum hydrocarbons, including PAHs – pesticides (DDT, lindane, etc) – other chlorinated contaminants, such as PCBs Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Analysis of Organic Contaminants Gas chromatographs with various detectors: FID, ECD, NPD, FPD GC-MS Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Isotopic Analyses using GC-C-IRMS Variations of 13C in POC and biomarkers in particulate matter vs [CO2] in sea water 13C (‰) -20 -24 C37:2 -28 • Gas Chromatography-CombustionIsotope Ratio Mass Spectrometry is used to measure the 13C in individual organic components for: – – – source apportionment assessments investigate carbon cycling and behaviour reconstructing the atmospheric CO2 concentrations from the sedimentary record as an indicator of global change -32 -36 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 [CO2]aq (M) Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Supporting Regional Seas Programmes • Technique development in marine analytical chemistry • Formulation of reference methods and guidelines • Intercomparison exercises • Production of reference materials (RMs) • Education and training in analytical techniques • Capacity building • Monitoring programmes • Research activities Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Reference Methods for Marine Pollution Studies • Formulation of reference methods and guidelines – Sanitary quality of coastal waters – Analysis of chemical contaminants in organisms, sea water and sediments – Effects of pollutants on organisms and ecosystems • 56 reference methods and 2 technical bulletins • All are available in English, some have been translated into French and / or Spanish Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Large Scale Sample Preparation Large-Sale sample preparation for intercomparison exercises and the production of reference materials Homogeniser Grinder Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Intercomparison Exercises • Marine samples (sediment or biota) are periodically distributed free of charge • Results are reported to MESL and evaluated statistically • Intercomparison exercises offer analysts means to: – Test analytical methods – Control laboratory performance – Assess accuracy of results Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Global Participation in Intercomparison Exercises for Trace Metals Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Data Reporting in Intercomparison Exercises 245 laboratories world-wide participated in IAEA-142. 84 labs provided organochlorine data For these 84 labs: – 25% of the results were outliers – 50% fell outside the range of acceptable precision – only 11 identified the POPs shown on the right. Z-scores for pp' DDE Z-scores 2 1 0 -1 -2 19 28 16 47 18 17 45 4 21 1 38 46 29 33 20 12 27 2 31 25 14 24 41 7 30 15 36 39 26 34 9 40 43 22 Laboratory code numbers Z-scores for pp' DDD Graphical presentation of z-scores easily shows the relative performance of laboratories (IAEA-408). Z-scores 2 1 0 -1 21 47 19 34 18 46 28 25 45 31 36 29 20 44 4 17 14 1 9 39 22 27 24 16 15 26 43 7 41 30 Laboratory code numbers Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Reference Materials (RMs) • RMs are vital for training programmes, intercomparison studies and for laboratories to maintain their own Analytical Quality Control procedures • MESL is one of the few producers worldwide of marine RMs • MESL has produced >20 RMs • a range of environmental matrices (sediment & biota) • certified with respect to various organic and metallic pollutants • MESL provides RMs free to laboratories participating in Regional Seas Programmes Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Some available Reference Materials IAEA-140 Sea plant Trace metals, mercury and methylmercury, chlorinated pesticides, petroleum hydrocarbons IAEA-142 Mussel Mercury and methylmercury, chlorinated pesticides, petroleum hydrocarbons IAEA-383 Sediment Chlorinated pesticides, petroleum hydrocarbons and sterols IAEA-405 Estuarine Trace metals, mercury and methylmercury Sediment IAEA-408 Estuarine Chlorinated pesticides and petroleum Sediment hydrocarbons Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency REFERENCE MATERIAL IAEA-405 Trace Elements and Methylmercury in Estuarine Sediment: Recommended Values (dry weight basis) Element Arsenic Cadmium Cobalt Chromium Copper Iron Mercury Lithium Magnesium Manganese Nickel Lead Antimony Selenium Tin Vanadium Zinc 4 Me-Hg Concentration -1 (mg kg ) 23.6 0.73 13.7 84 47.7 37400 0.81 72 12300 495 32.5 74.8 1.81 0.44 7.6 95 279 0.00549 1 95 % Confidence Interval -1 (mg kg ) 22.9 – 24.3 0.68 – 0.78 13.0 – 14.4 80 – 88 46.5 – 48.9 36700 – 38100 0.77 – 0.85 65 – 79 11400 – 13200 484 – 506 31.1 – 33.9 72.6 – 77.0 1.62 – 2.00 0.32 – 0.56 6.3 – 8.9 90 – 100 272 – 286 0.00496 – 0.00602 2 N 3 47 63 50 63 80 64 60 25 13 52 61 74 21 12 17 29 87 12 Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Capacity Building Undertake quality assurance missions to regional laboratories – assessment of infrastructure and training needs – technical assistance to laboratories Provide advice to prioritise purchase and capacity building to suit the regional targets set Arrange purchase of laboratories supplies Purchase instruments Install and maintain equipment Remote monitoring of instruments via modem (troubleshooting, update method files) Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Education and Training in Analytical Techniques • Training courses: run regionally and in Monaco: – – – – MED POL Black Sea Caspian Sea ROPME • Course subjects: Visiting scientists and fellows work in Monaco with access to sophisticated instrumentation such as ICP-MS and GC-C-IRMS – sampling procedures – analysis of heavy metals – analysis of persistent organic polutants – use of nuclear and isotopic techniques in pesticide research Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Monitoring of Marine Contaminants • Active collaboration with laboratories in Member States assisting with: – Project design – Sample collection and handling – Analyses of contaminants (i.e. heavy metals and persistent organic pollutants) – Organization of Quality Assurance – Data interpretation – Assessment of pollution Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Research at MESL • Methodology development – Organotin analyses – Organophosphorus analyses • Biogeochemistry – 13C biomarkers – Mercury cycling – Marine antifoulants (Organotins) • Pollution Assessment Studies – ROPME Sea Area – Black Sea – Caspian Sea Rock oysters along the shore at Masirah Island, Oman Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Analysis of Organotin Species 1 • Organotin Speciation Analyses in Marine Biota using NaBEt4 Ethylation and GC-FPD • Optimised to overcome the most common matrix effect problems (especially colloidal interfaces) with biological samples • A strict quality control system using three internal standards was implemented – Tripropyltin to assess the derivatisation reaction – Tetraoctyltin to check the overall extraction efficiency – Tetrabutyltin was used to verify the GC-FPD performance • Successfully applied to different biological matrices – – – – Fish Mussels Oysters Barnacles Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Analysis of Organotin Species 2 Blank Oyster Sample Mussel RM BCR 477 Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Analysis of Organotin Species 3 Measured and certified butyltin concentrations (mg kg-1 as cation) in Certified Reference Materials BCR 477 (mussel tissue) MBT DBT TBT Sample N 1 1.0 1.5 2.3 2 1.4 1.3 2.6 3 1.4 1.4 2.7 4 1.3 1.3 2.4 5 1.3 1.7 2.0 Measured 1.27 ± 0.16 1.44 ± 0.18 2.39 ± 0.25 Certified 1.50 ± 0.28 1.54 ± 0.12 2.20 ± 0.19 Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Biogeochemical Cycling of Mercury Mercury and methylmercury are notable marine pollutants • Speciation analyses are necessary to understand environmental mobility and bioavailability MeHg (pmole/g) 0 0 Studies have been undertaken in the ROPME Sea Area, Black Sea, Laptev Sea, and Adriatic Sea 0.5 1 0 C32 2 C20 2 4 Depth (cm) • Total and Methylmercury Profiles in Sediment Cores of the Laptev Sea 4 Depth (cm) • 6 8 6 8 10 10 12 12 14 14 0 1 2 3 Total-Hg (nmole/g) 4 0 1 2 3 Total-Hg (nmole/g) Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency 4 IRGAROL-1051(ng L-1) Research in the MED POL Programme 800 1992 1995 700 600 Marine biocides in waters from marinas along the south of France 500 400 300 200 100 be ac Po h rt Va ub C an an ne s be ac h co An tib es re s N eg he m ar in a in a m ar nc fra Vi lle Be a ul ie u m ille vi e Fo nt M on a co po rt ar in a 0 Total Butyltins (ng L ) 1800 -1 1600 1400 1988 1995 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 Fo nt v ie ille Be m ar au in lie Vi a u lle m fra a r in nc a he m ar in a N ic e po An rt tib es C an po Sa ne rt in s tR C ap .p or ha t el m ar in a 0 Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Field Studies in the ROPME Sea Area • Countries within the ROPME Sea Area: Bahrain, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates • Contaminant Screening Project: surveys of contaminants in water, sediments and biota for a suite of inorganic and organic pollutants. • MESL undertakes a quality assurance programme with Member States in the region involving: – site visits – training courses – capacity building – split sample analyses – intercomparison exercises Tar washing ashore at Mina Al Fahal, Oman Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Persian Gulf ‘Hot-Spots’ for As in Shellfish 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Saudi Arabia Oyster Clam As (ppm) 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Bahrain Pearl Oyster Rock Scallops As (ppm) UAE 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Oman Pearl Oyster Rock Scallop As (ppm) 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Rock Oyster Mussel As (ppm) Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Black Sea Environment Programme Map showing the distribution of PAHs in marine Marine Environment Laboratory sediments from the Black Sea Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Caspian Environment Programme •At Sea Training Programme •Contaminant Screening Campaign •Transboundary Diagnostics Analysis Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Analyses of Sediment Samples • • • • • • Metals Hydrocarbons Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) Chlorinated Pesticides (lindane, DDT, etc.) Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs) Other parameters – – – – Grain size distribution Total Organic Carbon (TOC) carbonate content Extracted Organic Matter (EOM Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Tree Diagram: 25 elements @ 61 Stations T O C % _ F IN E S A L F E V Z N N I C O L I M G M N P B C R C U A S C D S B S N H G A G B A U C A R C A S R 0 .0 0 .1 0 .2 0 .3 0 .4 0 .5 0 .6 0 .7 L in k a g eD is ta n c e Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency 0 .8 Co & Pb versus Al in Sediments 35 Co µg/g Pb µg/g Linear (Pb µg/g) Linear (Co µg/g) 30 Co & Pb ( g/g) 25 20 15 y = 0.0003x 2 R = 0.889 10 y = 0.0002x R2 = 0.8671 5 0 0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000 80000 90000 Al ( g/g) Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Nickel • Ni displays very high levels in sediments throughout the central and southern Caspian Sea. • NOAA ERL (21 mg g-1) was always exceeded and the ERM (52 mg g-1) values at several sites. • The highest concentrations were found near the mouth of the Kura River, but the Ural River influence is also evident. • The elevated content reflects a high natural background, but could be augmented though mining activities. Similar behaviour was apparent for Cr and As. Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Mercury • The mercury content is low in the northern sector having sediments that are relatively coarse or composed mostly of carbonates. • Mercury concentrations are high at a number of sites in Azerbaijan, where Hg content exceeds the NOAA ERL value of 0.15 g g-1. • In particular, the sediments to the south of Baku Bay are polluted. Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons • The concentrations of total petroleum hydrocarbons range from 29 to 1820 µg g-1 in Azerbaijan, where generally the highest amounts were found. • Sediments from Turkmenistan were not available. • Compared to other global locations, the levels of petroleum hydrocarbons in the most contaminated of these sediments just south of Baku Bay are relatively high. Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency 160 UCM (µg/g) Azerbaijan 1400 1200 UCM (µg/g) 140 UCM/R 120 UCM/n-alkanes 1000 100 800 80 600 60 400 40 200 20 I-4 -1 I-5 I-3 -1 I-6 BP -3 IS -4 -1 d IS -4 -1 b BP -2 BP -1 H41 H51 H21 H23 G -3 -1 G -2 -1 G -2 -2 IS -3 -1 0 IS -3 -2 IS -3 -2 -1 0 Station 120 60 110 90 UCM (µg/g) Iran 50 UCM/R UCM/n-alkanes 40 70 60 30 50 40 20 30 20 10 10 D4 D5 Marine Environment Laboratory Station Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency D3 D1 D6 D2 D9 0 D7 0 D8 UCM (µg/g) 80 UCM/R & UCM/n-alkanes 100 IS 51 IS 52 IS 5IS 3 52A IS 53A DP -1 A C2 C5 C4 C6 C7 C8 C2A C3A IS 63 IS 62 DP -4 IS 73 IS 72 DP -2 A • Unresolved aliphatic hydrocarbons are also known as the unresolved complex mixture (UCM). • Concentrations of UCM <10 µg g-1 are common in coastal environments distant from hydrocarbon inputs. • The levels in Azerbaijan are generally quite high and indicative of pollution, especially near Baku Bay. 1600 UCM/R & UCM/n-alkanes Unresolved Complex Mixture Lindane in Sediments • Lowest values were found in the Iranian and Kazakhstan sectors. • Several stations in the Russian coastal zone had elevated levels. • The maximum concentration 609 pg g-1, exceeded the ISQG value of 320 pg g-1. • As lindane degrades rapidly in the environment, elevated levels reflect ongoing usage. Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Endrin in Sediments • Low levels were found in Kazakhstan and Russia. • Highest values were observed in the coastal zone of Azerbaijan (85 pg g-1) and Iran (81 pg g-1). • Maximum concentrations did not exceed the ISQG value of 267 pg g-1. Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Total DDTs in Caspian Sea Sediments • NOAA ERL is 1600 pg g-1. • Total DDT levels exceed this quality standard at a number of locations, especially in Azerbaijan and Iran. • The maximum value (13400 pg g-1) shows a strong signal from the Kura River. • The lowest concentrations were found in the North Caspian Sea, particularly in the north-eastern shallow area. Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Relative Contributions of DDT and Degradation Products DDD & DDE 0 DDT and Degradation Products 10 90 20 80 70 40 60 50 60 %) 50 D( DD E (% ) 30 DD Azerbaijan Iran Kazakhstan Russia Turkmenistan • Relatively high proportions of DDT indicate recent influxes and, by implication, ongoing DDT usage throughout the region. 100 40 70 30 80 20 90 10 100 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 DDT (%) Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency The Future: New Priorities • Strengthened co-ordination with national institutes and regional organisations • Broadening of activities in response to the changing needs of UN bodies: – Global Programme of Action for the protection of the marine environment from land based activities • Tracers to characterise sewage and ground water discharges – IMO regulations on the use of tributyltin (TBT) as a marine antifoulant • Environmental chemistry and ecotoxicology of alternative marine biocides Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency Thank You Marine Environment Laboratory Department of Nuclear Sciences and Applications International Atomic Energy Agency